Comparative effects of retinoic acid and jervine on chondrocyte differentiation

Jervine and retinoic acid are both teratogenic to structures which are initially modelled in cartilage. Differences in periods of maximal sensitivity, as well as in certain aspects of the morphological manifestations of exposure, indicate that these two teratogens act via different molecular mechanisms. Here we compare the effects of jervine and retinoic acid in three culture systems which represent sequential stages of the chondrocyte lineage. Proliferation of pluripotent C3H 10T 1/2 cells was decreased by exposure to jervine but was not affected by retinoic acid. Differentiation of high-density "spot" cultures of embryonic limb bud mesenchyme were sensitive to both compounds. Mature chondrocytes were resistant to jervine but "dedifferentiated" after 48-hour exposure to retinoic acid. We conclude that jervine compromises rapidly dividing chondrogenic precursors, whereas retinoic acid has little effect prior to the expression of cartilage-specific proteins.     

Chondrogenesis from single limb mesenchyme cells

It is believed that cell-cell interaction between mesenchyme cells is involved in the initiation of chondrogenesis, based largely on the inability of limb mesenchyme cells to differentiate into cartilage unless cultures are inoculated at densities greater than confluency. The present study describes a culture situation in which single limb mesenchyme cells either in or on type I collagen gels are shown to differentiate into cartilage, as defined by the appearance of a pericellular alcian blue staining matrix, intracellular type II collagen (demonstrated by indirect immunofluorescence with monoclonal antibody), and clonable cartilage cells. Because the differentiation of cartilage cells from single mesenchyme cells occurs only when the cells are in a round configuration, it is proposed that cell shape changes are one factor that can mediate effects of cell-cell interaction on differentiation.     

Ethanol Exposure Stimulates Cartilage Differentiation by Embryonic Limb Mesenchyme Cells

Studies of neural, hepatic, and other cells have demonstrated thatin vitroethanol exposure can influence a variety of membrane-associated signaling mechanisms. These include processes such as receptor-kinase phosphorylation, adenylate cyclase and protein kinase C activation, and prostaglandin production that have been implicated as critical regulators of chondrocyte differentiation during embryonic limb development. The potential for ethanol to affect signaling mechanisms controlling chondrogenesis in the developing limb, together with its known ability to promote congenital skeletal deformitiesin vivo,prompted us to examine whether chronic alcohol exposure could influence cartilage differentiation in cultures of prechondrogenic mesenchyme cells isolated from limb buds of stage 23–25 chick embryos. We have made the novel and surprising finding that ethanol is a potent stimulant ofin vitrochondrogenesis at both pre- and posttranslational levels. In high-density cultures of embryonic limb mesenchyme cells, which spontaneously undergo extensive cartilage differentiation, the presence of ethanol in the culture medium promoted increased Alcian-blue-positive cartilage matrix production, a quantitative rise in³⁵SO₄incorporation into matrix glycosaminoglycans (GAG), and the precocious accumulation of mRNAs for cartilage-characteristic type II collagen and aggrecan (cartilage proteoglycan). Stimulation of matrix GAG accumulation was maximal at a concentration of 2% ethanol (v/v), although a significant increase was elicited by as little as 0.5% ethanol (approximately 85 mM). The alcohol appears to directly influence differentiation of the chondrogenic progenitor cells of the limb, since ethanol elevated cartilage formation even in cultures prepared from distal subridge mesenchyme of stage 24/25 chick embryo wing buds, which is free of myogenic precursor cells. When limb mesenchyme cells were cultured at low density, which suppresses spontaneous chondrogenesis, ethanol exposure induced the expression of high levels of type II collagen and aggrecan mRNAs and promoted abundant cartilage matrix formation. These stimulatory effects were not specific to ethanol, since methanol, propanol, and tertiary butanol treatments also enhanced cartilage differentiation in embryonic limb mesenchyme cultures. Further investigations of the stimulatory effects of ethanol onin vitrochondrogenesis may provide insights into the mechanisms regulating chondrocyte differentiation during embryogenesis and the molecular basis of alcohol's teratogenic effects on skeletal morphogenesis.     

Proliferation of cells undergoing chondrogenesis in vitro

Continuous exposure of chicken embryo limb bud mesenchyme cells undergoing chondrogenesis in vitro to [3H] thymidine thymidine [(3H]TdR) revealed that more than 90% of the cells synthesized DNA at least once during 120 h of culture. When cells were exposed to [3H]TdR for 24 h beginning at various times throughout the culture period, the percentage of cells which incorporated [3H]TdR during each period was approximately 92%. However, when the period for incorporation of radioisotope was limited to two hours, the number of cells which incorporated [3H]TdR was found to decline during chondrogenesis in vitro. This decline was coincident with the appearance of extracellular matrix material and occurred in those cells which had, and had not, expressed the cartilage phenotype. We conclude from these studies that (1) practically all of the cells continue to proliferate while chondrogenesis is occurring in vitro, (2) there is an increase in the length of the cell cycle during chondrogenesis in vitro, and (3) withdrawal from the cell cycle is not required for differentiation of mesenchyme into cartilage.     

Cell sorting and chondrogenic aggregate formation in micromass culture

A fundamental feature of cartilage differentiation in the developing limb is the formation of a prechondrogenic cell condensation. An apparently similar process of prechondrogenic cell aggregation occurs in micromass cultures of limb bud mesenchyme with the formation of cellular aggregates which often differentiate into cartilage nodules. We have investigated the process of aggregate formation in micromass culture using chimaeric mixtures of potentially chondrogenic and nonchondrogenic cell types. Two systems were studied: mixtures of distal and proximal limb mesenchyme cells and mixtures of distal limb cells with avian tendon fibroblasts. In both cases cultures of varying proportions of each cell type have been prepared. The results demonstrate that aggregate formation in vitro is the consequence of a cell sorting process which can involve prechondrogenic cells of widely different spatial origins within the developing limb. This contrasts with in vivo prechondrogenic condensation in which there is no evidence of cell sorting (Searls, R.L. (1967), J. Exp. Zool. 166, 39-50). However, our findings do indicate that cell surface differences occur in apparently undifferentiated limb mesenchyme. The results also suggest that mesenchymal cell aggregates must achieve a threshold size before chondrogenesis can proceed. In addition, the results show that under some culture conditions nonchondrogenic cells will form aggregates.     

Deletion of Tgfbr2 in Prx1-cre expressing mesenchyme results in defects in development of the long bones and joints

In this study, we address the function of Transforming Growth Factor beta (TGF-beta) and its type II receptor (Tgfbr2) in limb development in vivo. Mouse embryos were generated in which the Tgfbr2 gene was deleted in early limb mesenchyme using Prx1Cre-mediated LoxP recombination. A high level of Tgfbr2 gene deletion was verified in limb mesenchyme by PCR between E9.5 and E10.5 days in Cre expressing mice. RT-PCR assays indicated a significant depletion of Tgfbr2 mRNA by E10.5 days as a result of Cre mediated gene deletion. Furthermore, limb mesenchyme from Cre(+);Tgfbr2(f/f) mice placed in micromass culture did not respond to exogenously added TGF-beta1 confirming the functional deletion of the receptor. However, there was an unexpected increase in the number and intensity of Alcian blue stained chondrogenic nodules in micromass cultures derived from Tgfbr2-deleted limbs relative to cultures from control limbs suggesting that Tgfbr2 normally limits chondrogenesis in vitro. In vivo, early limb development and chondrocyte differentiation occurred normally in Tgfbr2-depleted mice. Later in development, depletion of Tgfbr2 in limb mesenchyme resulted in short limbs and fusion of the joints in the phalanges. Alteration in the length of the long bones was primarily due to a decrease in chondrocyte proliferation after E13.5 days. In addition, the transition from prehypertrophic to hypertrophic cells was accelerated while there was a delay in late hypertrophic differentiation leading to a reduction in the length of the marrow cavity. In the joint, cartilage cells replaced interzone cells during development. Analysis of markers for joint development indicated that the joint was specified properly and that the interzone cells were initially formed but not maintained. The results suggest that Tgfbr2 is required for normal development of the skeleton and that Tgfbr2 can act to limit chondrogenesis in mesenchymal cells like the interzone.     

Characterization of bone-derived chondrogenesis-stimulating activity on embryonic limb mesenchymal cells in vitro

Demineralized bone matrix contains factors which stimulate chondrogenesis and osteogenesis in vivo. A water-soluble extract of bone has been shown to stimulate chondrogenesis in vitro in embryonic limb mesenchymal cells (Syftestad, Lucas & Caplan, 1985). The aim of this study was to analyse the cellular mechanism of the bone-derived chondrogenesis-stimulating activity, with particular attention on how normal requirements for chondrogenesis may be altered. The effects of bovine bone extract (BBE) on chondrogenesis in vitro were studied using micromass cultures of chick limb bud mesenchyme isolated from embryos at Hamburger-Hamilton (HH) stage 23/24, an experimental system which is capable of undergoing chondrogenic differentiation. Bovine diaphyseal long bones were demineralized and extracted with guanidine-HCl to prepare BBE (Syftestad & Caplan, 1984). High-density mesenchyme cultures (30 x 10(6) cells/ml) were exposed to different doses of BBE (0.01-1.0 mg ml-1) and chondrogenesis was quantified based on cartilage nodule number and [35S]sulphate incorporation. BBE was tested on micromass cultures of varying plating densities (2-30 x 10(6) cells/ml), on cultures of 'young' limb bud cells (HH stage 17/18), and on cultures enriched with chondroprogenitor cells obtained from subridge mesoderm. Since poly-L-lysine (PL) has recently been shown (San Antonio & Tuan, 1986) to promote chondrogensis, PL and BBE were introduced together in different doses, in the culture medium, to determine if their actions were synergistic. Our results show that BBE stimulates chondrogenesis in a dose-dependent manner and by a specific, direct action on the chondroprogenitor cells but not in normally non-chondrogenic, low density or 'young' limb bud cell cultures. The effects of PL and BBE are additive and these agents appear to act by separate mechanisms to stimulate chondrogenesis; PL primarily enhances nodule formation, and BBE appears to promote nodule growth.     

Polyionic regulation of cartilage development: promotion of chondrogenesis in vitro by polylysine is associated with altered glycosaminoglycan biosynthesis and distribution.

The development of cartilage nodules in cultures of chick limb bud mesenchyme (Hamburger-Hamilton stages 23/24) is significantly promoted when the culture medium is supplemented with (poly-L-lysine (PL) (M(r) greater than or equal to 14K) (San Antonio and Tuan, 1986. Dev. Biol. 115: 313). Here we present findings consistent with the hypothesis that PL may promote chondrogenesis by interacting electrostatically with sulfated glycosaminoglycans (GAGs): (1) poly-L-ornithine, poly-L-histidine, poly-D,L-lysine, and lysine-containing heteropolypeptides stimulate chondrogenesis in proportion to their contents of cationic residues; (2) the effects of PL are diminished when limb mesenchyme cultures are supplemented with exogenous GAGs, including heparin, dermatan sulfate, and chondroitin sulfate; (3) in high density cultures of limb bud mesenchyme, the release of sulfated macromolecules, but not of proteins in general, into the culture medium was significantly inhibited by PL (398K M(r)) treatment, and a net increase in total GAG content of the PL-treated cultures was observed; and (4) in monolayer cultures of cells derived from other chick embryonic tissues, including liver, skeletal muscle, and calvaria, PL treatment promoted the cell layer-associated retention of sulfated GAG. These effects were not observed using the nonstimulatory, low M(r) PL (4K). Based on the above findings and those from previous studies, it is proposed that PL may promote chondrogenesis by interacting electrostatically with cartilage GAGs, thus trapping the extracellular matrix around the newly emerging cartilage nodules and thereby stabilizing their growth and differentiation.     

Proliferation of cells undergoing chondrogenesis in vitro

Abstract. Continuous exposure of chicken embryo limb bud mesenchyme cells undergoing chondrogenesis in vitro to [³H] thymidine ([³H]TdR) revealed that more than 90% of the cells synthesized DNA at least once during 120 h of culture. When cells were exposed to [³H]TdR for 24 h beginning at various times throughout the culture period, the percentage of cells which incorporated [³H]TdR during each period was approximately 92%. However, when the period for incorporation of radioisotope was limited to two hours, the number of cells which incorporated [³H]TdR was found to decline during chondrogenesis in vitro. This decline was coincident with the appearance of extracellular matrix material and occurred in those cells which had, and had not, expressed the cartilage phenotype.
We conclude from these studies that (1) practically all of the cells continue to proliferate while chondrogenesis is occurring in vitro, (2) there is an increase in the length of the cell cycle during chondrogenesis in vitro, and (3) withdrawal from the cell cycle is not required for differentiation of mesenchyme into cartilage.     

Cyclic nucleotides during chondrogenesis: concentration and distribution in vivo and in vitro

This study correlates endogenous levels of cAMP and cGMP with their immunohistochemical localization during chondrogenic differentiation of C57B1/6J mouse limb mesenchyme in vivo and in vitro. A transient decrease in cGMP but not cAMP was found from days 12 to 13 in vivo correlating with early stages of chondrogenesis in the developing limb. Intracellular levels of both cAMP and cGMP in high density limb mesenchyme cultures increased 25% after 24 hr in culture when aggregate and nodule formation was detectable. When cells were seeded at different initial plating densities to delay the onset of aggregate and nodule formation, increased levels of intracellular cAMP correlated temporally with the appearance of nodules. Both cyclic AMP and cGMP were immunohistochemically localized in perichondrial cells and chondrocytes in vivo and in vitro. Therefore, (1) cAMP levels correlated temporally with the appearance of chondrogenic cells and (2) cAMP and cGMP were immunohistochemically localized to chondrogenic cells. These data indicate that fluctuations of both cAMP and cGMP levels may be involved in limb cartilage differentiation. Although increases in both nucleotides were found to correlate with the onset of chondrogenesis in vitro, in vivo data suggest that the amount of cAMP relative to cGMP rather than the absolute amount of an individual cyclic nucleotide may be more significant in modulating differentiation.     

Platelet-derived growth factor A modulates limb chondrogenesis both in vivo and in vitro

Cartilage formation in the chick limb follows rapid proliferation, condensation and differentiation of limb mesenchyme. The control of these early events is poorly understood. Platelet-derived growth factor receptor alpha (PDGFR-alpha) is present throughout the mesenchyme of early chick limb buds, while its ligand, PDGF-A, is expressed in the surrounding epithelium. PDGFR-alpha is down-regulated in areas that will not give rise to cartilage and is then lost from cartilage forming areas after they begin to differentiate. PDGF-A increases chondrogenesis in micromass cultures of stage-20-24 limb buds, but not stage 25, where it inhibits chondrogenesis. Ectopic PDGF-A in the chick wing can lead to either a localized increase in cartilage formation, or an inhibition. Inhibition of PDGF signalling in the chick limb results in the loss of cartilage. These data demonstrate that PDGF-A functions to promote chondrogenesis at early stages of limb development and suggest that it inhibits chondrogenesis at later stages.     

Evidence for histogenic interactions during in vitro limb chondrogenesis

The requirement for homotypic cell interaction was studied by making chimeric micromass cultures containing various proportions of chick and quail limb mesenchyme. Cultures made from limb mesenchyme from embryos of Hamburger and Hamilton stages 23–24 produce large clumps of cartilage cells, identified by the accumulation of an extracellular matrix which stains with alcian blue at pH 1 and by the ability of cells to take up ³⁵SO₄ rapidly, as demonstrated autoradiographically. Dissociated mesenchyme from stage 19 embryos did not produce cartilage in micromass cultures, but only precartilage cell aggregates. Micromass cultures prepared from mixtures of mesenchyme cells obtained from stage 19 and stages 23–24 embryos contained decreasing numbers of cartilage nodules as the proportion of stage 19-derived mesenchyme increased. At the same time the number of aggregates was not affected. When the ratio of stage 19- to stage 24-derived cells was 3:1 or greater, no nodules were detected. The actual number of cells from each stage was verified by using mixtures of quail and chick cells, which are microscopically distinguishable. Additional evidence suggests that the stage 19-derived mesenchyme inhibits chondrogenesis by passively preventing stage 24-derived cells from interacting. The results presented are consistent with the suggestions that (1) homotypic cell interaction plays a role in limb chondrogenesis and (2) the capacity to interact in the required manner is acquired after the embryos have reached stage 19. These phenomena might be involved in the normal histogenesis of cartilage tissue.     

Comparative effects of cytosine arabinoside and a prostaglandin E2 antagonist, AH6809, on chondrogenesis in serum-free cultures of chick limb mesenchyme

The present study was designed to compare effects of an established inhibitor of cell proliferation and growth, cytosine arabinoside (Ara C), with that of a prostaglandin E2 (PGE2) antagonist, AH6809, on chondrogenesis in cultured mesenchyme derived from stage 25 chick limb buds. Continuous treatment of cell cultures with 10(-4) M AH6809 prevented completely the twofold increases in DNA content of control cultures which occurred between Day 1 and Day 5 of culture and also produced 90% inhibition of chondrogenesis occurring in control cultures during this same period. Treatment of cells with Ara C (0.1-0.5 microgram/ml) produced equivalent inhibition of DNA content during the same time period; however, chondrogenesis, as evaluated on Day 5 of cell culture, remained at approximately 90% of control cultures. These results indicate that the inhibitory effect of PGE2 receptor blockade on cell growth in these cultures cannot account for the potent inhibitory effects observed on differentiation of cartilage and provide further evidence in support of the notion that PGE2 plays an important initiating role in the process of chondrocyte differentiation within limb mesenchyme.     

Inhibitory and stimulatory effects of limb ectoderm on in vitro chondrogenesis

Previous studies have indicated possible dual effects of the limb ectoderm in cartilage differentiation. On one hand, explants from early (stage 15) wing buds are dependent on contact with the limb ectoderm for cartilage differentiation (Gumpel-Pinot, J. Embryol. Exp. Morph. 59:157-173, 1980). On the other hand, limb ectoderm from stage 23/24 wing buds inhibits cartilage differentiation by cultured limb mesenchyme cells even without direct contact (Solursh et al., Dev. Biol. 86:471-482, 1981). In the present study, ectoderms from both stage 15/16 and stage 23/24 wings are cultured under the same conditions, and ectoderms from each source are shown to have two effects. Each stimulates chondrogenesis in stage 15 wing bud mesenchyme, and each inhibits chondrogenesis in older wing mesenchyme. The results suggest that the limb ectoderm has at least dual effects on cartilage differentiation, depending on the stage of the mesenchyme. One effect involves an early mesenchymal dependence on the ectoderm. This effect requires contact between the ectoderm and mesoderm (Gumpel-Pinot, J. Embryol. Exp. Morphol. 59:157-173, 1980) but also can be observed at a distance from the ectoderm. Later, the ectoderm can act without direct contact between the ectoderm and mesoderm to inhibit chondrogenesis over some distance.     

Distinct functions of BMP4 and GDF5 in the regulation of chondrogenesis

Bone morphogenetic protein 4 (BMP4) and growth/differentiation factor 5 (GDF5) are closely related protein family members and regulate early cartilage patterning and differentiation. In this study, we compared the functional outcome of their actions systematically at various stages of chondrogenesis in mouse embryonic limb bud mesenchyme grown in micromass cultures. Overall, both growth factors enhanced cartilage growth and differentiation in these cultures. Uniquely, BMP4 not only accelerated the formation and maturation of cartilaginous nodules, but also induced internodular mesenchymal cells to express cartilage differentiation markers. On the other hand, GDF5 increased the number of prechondrogenic mesenchymal cell condensation and cartilaginous nodules, without altering the overall pattern of differentiation. In addition, GDF5 caused a more sustained elevated expression level of Sox9 relative to that associated with BMP4. BMP4 accelerated chondrocyte maturation throughout the cultures and sustained an elevated level of Col10 expression, whereas GDF5 caused a transient increase in Col10 expression. Taken together, we conclude that BMP4 is instructive to chondrogenesis and induces mesenchymal cells toward the chondrogenic lineage. Furthermore, BMP4 accelerates the progression of cartilage differentiation to maturation. GDF5 enhances cartilage formation by promoting chondroprogenitor cell aggregation, and amplifying the responses of cartilage differentiation markers. These differences may serve to fine-tune the normal cartilage differentiation program, and can be exploited for the molecular manipulation in biomimetics.