Selective ablation of virion host shutoff protein RNase activity attenuates herpes simplex virus 2 in mice

The virion host shutoff (vhs) protein of herpes simplex virus (HSV) has endoribonuclease activity and rapidly reduces protein synthesis in infected cells through mRNA degradation. Herpes simplex virus 1 (HSV-1) and HSV-2 vhs mutants are highly attenuated in vivo, but replication and virulence are largely restored to HSV-2 vhs mutants in the absence of a type I interferon (IFN) response. The role of vhs in pathogenesis and the hindrance of the type I IFN response have classically been examined with viruses that completely lack vhs or express a truncated vhs protein. To determine whether RNase activity is the principal mechanism of vhs-mediated type I IFN resistance and virulence, we constructed a HSV-2 point mutant that synthesizes full-length vhs protein lacking RNase activity (RNase(-) virus). Wild-type and mutant HSV-2 vhs proteins coimmunoprecipitated with VP16 and VP22. vhs protein bearing the point mutation was packaged into the virion as efficiently as the wild-type vhs protein. Like a mutant encoding truncated vhs, the RNase(-) virus showed IFN-dependent replication that was restricted compared with that of the wild-type virus. The RNase(-) virus was highly attenuated in wild-type mice infected intravaginally, with reduced mucosal replication, disease severity, and spread to the nervous system comparable to those of the vhs truncation mutant. Surprisingly, in alpha/beta interferon (IFN-alpha/beta) receptor knockout mice, the vhs RNase mutant was more attenuated than the vhs truncation mutant in terms of disease severity and virus titer in vaginal swabs and central nervous system samples, suggesting that non-enzymatically active vhs protein interferes with efficient virus replication. Our results indicate that vhs enzymatic activity plays a complex role in vhs-mediated type I IFN resistance during HSV-2 infection.     

Control of mRNA stability by the virion host shutoff function of herpes simplex virus

vhs1 is a mutant of herpes simplex virus type 1 that is defective in the virion host shutoff function responsible for the degradation of cellular mRNAs and the concomitant shutoff of host protein synthesis. In this study, the effect of the vhs1 mutation on the metabolism of viral mRNAs was examined by measuring the half-lives and patterns of accumulation of 10 different viral mRNAs representing all kinetic classes. The vhs1 mutation had the effect of dramatically lengthening the cytoplasmic half-lives of all 10 mRNAs. In wild-type virus infections, the 10 mRNAs had similar half-lives, suggesting that little, if any, target mRNA selectivity was exhibited by the vhs function. The vhs1 mutation caused overaccumulation of a number of mRNAs. The effect was most dramatic for the alpha (immediate-early) mRNA for ICP27 and the beta (early) mRNAs encoding thymidine kinase, ICP8, and DNA polymerase. Whereas in wild-type infections these mRNAs increased to peak levels and subsequently declined in abundance, in vhs1 infections they continued to accumulate until late times. A significant but less dramatic overaccumulation was observed for several beta-gamma (delayed-early) and gamma (late) mRNAs. The results suggest that the vhs protein plays an important role in determining the half-lives of viral mRNAs belonging to all kinetic classes and in so doing is important in the normal downregulation at late times of alpha and beta gene expression.     

The vhs1 mutant form of herpes simplex virus virion host shutoff protein retains significant internal ribosome entry site-directed RNA cleavage activity

The virion host shutoff (vhs) protein of herpes simplex virus (HSV) triggers global shutoff of host protein synthesis and accelerated turnover of host and viral mRNAs during HSV infection. As well, it induces endoribonucleolytic cleavage of RNA substrates when produced in a rabbit reticulocyte lysate (RRL) in vitro translation system. The vhs1 point mutation (Thr 214-->Ile) eliminates vhs function during virus infection and in transiently transfected mammalian cells and was therefore previously considered to abolish vhs activity. Here we demonstrate that the vhs1 mutant protein induces readily detectable endoribonuclease activity on RNA substrates bearing the internal ribosome entry site of encephalomyocarditis virus in the RRL assay system. These data document that the vhs1 mutation does not eliminate catalytic activity and raise the possibility that the vhs-dependent endoribonuclease employs more than one mode of substrate recognition.     

In vitro mRNA degradation system to study the virion host shutoff function of herpes simplex virus.

The virion host shutoff (vhs) gene of herpes simplex virus encodes a virion polypeptide that induces degradation of host mRNAs at early times and rapid turnover of viral mRNAs throughout infection. To better investigate the vhs function, an in vitro mRNA degradation system was developed, consisting of cytoplasmic extracts from HeLa cells infected with wild-type herpes simplex virus type 1 or a mutant encoding a defective vhs polypeptide. Host and viral mRNAs were degraded rapidly in extracts from cells productively infected with wild-type herpes simplex virus type 1 but not in extracts from mock-infected cells or cells infected with the mutant vhs1. In contrast, 28S rRNA was stable in all three kinds of extract. Accelerated turnover of host mRNAs was also observed in extracts from cells infected with wild-type virus in the presence of dactinomycin, indicating that the activity was induced by a structural component of the infecting virions. The in vitro vhs activity was inactivated by heat or proteinase K digestion but was insensitive to brief treatment of the extracts with micrococcal nuclease. It was not inhibited by placental RNase inhibitor, it exhibited a strong dependence upon added Mg2+, it was active at concentrations of K+ up to 200 mM, and it did not require the components of an energy-generating system. In summary, the in vitro mRNA degradation system appears to accurately reproduce the vhs-mediated decay of host and viral mRNAs and should be useful for studies of the mechanism of vhs action.     

Inhibition of human immunodeficiency virus replication by the herpes simplex virus virion host shutoff protein.

The herpes simplex virus (HSV) virion host shutoff gene (vhs) encodes a protein which nonspecifically accelerates the degradation of mRNA molecules, leading to inhibition of protein synthesis. This ability to inhibit a critical cellular function suggested that vhs could be used as a suicide gene in certain gene therapy applications. To investigate whether vhs might be useful for treatment of AIDS, we tested the ability of both HSV type 1 (HSV-1) and HSV-2 vhs to inhibit replication of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). Replication of HIV was substantially inhibited when an infectious HIV proviral clone was cotransfected into HeLa cells together with vhs under the control of the cytomegalovirus (CMV) immediate-early promoter. HSV-2 vhs was more active than HSV-1 vhs in these experiments, consistent with previously published studies on these genes. Since expression of vhs from the CMV promoter is essentially unregulated, we also tested the ability of vhs expressed from the HIV long terminal repeat (LTR) promoter to inhibit HIV replication. Wild-type HSV-1 vhs inhibited HIV replication more than 44,000-fold in comparison to a mutant vhs gene encoding a nonfunctional form of the Vhs protein. Production of Vhs in transfected cells was verified by Western blot assays. A larger amount of Vhs was observed in cells transfected with plasmids expressing vhs from the HIV LTR than from the CMV promoter, consistent with the greater inhibition of HIV replication observed with these constructs. Mutant forms of Vhs were expressed at higher levels than wild-type Vhs, most likely due to the ability of wild-type Vhs to degrade its own mRNA. The strong inhibitory activity of the vhs gene and its unique biological properties make vhs an interesting candidate for use as a suicide gene for HIV gene therapy.     

The herpes simplex virus virion host shutoff function.

The virion host shutoff (vhs) function of herpes simplex virus (HSV) limits the expression of genes in the infected cells by destabilizing both host and viral mRNAs. vhs function mutants have been isolated which are defective in their ability to degrade host mRNA. Furthermore, the half-life of viral mRNAs is significantly longer in cells infected with the vhs-1 mutant virus than in cells infected with the wild-type (wt) virus. Recent data have shown that the vhs-1 mutation resides within the open reading frame UL41. We have analyzed the shutoff of host protein synthesis in cells infected with a mixture of the wt HSV-1 (KOS) and the vhs-1 mutant virus. The results of these experiments revealed that (i) the wt virus shutoff activity requires a threshold level of input virions per cell and (ii) the mutant vhs-1 virus protein can irreversibly block the wt virus shutoff activity. These results are consistent with a stoichiometric model in which the wt vhs protein interacts with a cellular factor which controls the half-life of cell mRNA. This wt virus interaction results in the destabilization of both host and viral mRNAs. In contrast, the mutant vhs function interacts with the cellular factor irreversibly, resulting in the increased half-life of both host and viral mRNAs.     

Role of the VP16-binding domain of vhs in viral growth, host shutoff activity, and pathogenesis

The virion host shutoff (vhs) protein of herpes simplex virus type 1 causes the degradation of host and viral mRNA immediately upon infection of permissive cells. vhs can interact with VP16 through a 20-amino-acid binding domain, and viruses containing a deletion of this VP16-binding domain of vhs (Delta20) and a corresponding marker rescue (Delta20R) were constructed and characterized. Transient-transfection assays showed that this domain was dispensable for vhs activity. The Delta20 recombinant virus, however, was unable to induce mRNA degradation in the presence of actinomycin D, while degradation induced by Delta20R was equivalent to that for wild-type virus. Delta20, Delta20R, and KOS caused comparable RNA degradation in the absence of actinomycin D. Western blot analysis of infected cells indicated that comparable levels of vhs were expressed by Delta20, Delta20R, and KOS, and there was only a modest reduction of vhs packaging in Delta20. Immunoprecipitation of protein from cells infected with Delta20 and Delta20R showed equivalent coprecipitation of vhs and VP16. Pathogenesis studies with Delta20 showed a significant decrease in replication in the corneas, trigeminal ganglia, and brains, as well as a significant reduction in clinical disease and lethality, but no significant difference in the establishment of, or reactivation from, latency compared to results with KOS and Delta20R. These results suggest that the previously described VP16-binding domain is not required for vhs packaging or for binding to VP16. It is required, however, for RNA degradation activity of tegument-derived vhs and wild-type replication and virulence in mice.     

Expression and function of the equine herpesvirus 1 virion-associated host shutoff homolog.

The ability of herpes simplex virus types 1 and 2 (HSV-1 and HSV-2, respectively) to repress host cell protein synthesis early in infection has been studied extensively and found to involve the activities of the UL41 gene product, the virion-associated host shutoff (vhs) protein. To date, UL41 homologs have been identified in the genomes of three other alphaherpesviruses: equine herpesvirus 1 (EHV-1), varicella-zoster virus, and pseudorabies virus, but very little is known about the putative products of these homologous genes. Our earlier observations that no rapid early host protein shutoff occurred in EHV-1-infected cells led us to test EHV-1 vhs activity more thoroughly and to examine the expression and function of the EHV-1 UL41 homolog, ORF19. In the present study, the effects of EHV-1 and HSV-1 infections on cellular protein synthesis and mRNA degradation were compared at various multiplicities of infection in several cell types under an actinomycin D block. No virion-associated inhibition of cellular protein synthesis or vhs-induced cellular mRNA degradation was detected in cells infected with any of three EHV-1 strains (Ab4, KyA, and KyD) at multiplicities of infection at which HSV-1 strain F exhibited maximal vhs activity. However, further analyses revealed that (i) the EHV-1 vhs homolog gene, ORF19, was transcribed and translated into a 58-kDa protein in infected cells; (ii) the ORF19 protein was packaged into viral particles in amounts detectable in Western blots (immunoblots) with monoclonal antibodies; (iii) in cotransfection vhs activity assays, transiently-expressed ORF19 protein had intrinsic vhs activity comparable to that of wild-type HSV-1 vhs; and (iv) this intrinsic vhs activity was ablated by in vitro site-directed mutations in which either the functionally inactive HSV-1 vhs1 UL41 mutation (Thr at position 214 replaced by Ile [Thr-214-->Ile]) was recreated within ORF19 or two conserved residues within the putative poly(A) binding region of the ORF19 sequence were altered (Tyr-190, 192-->Phe). From these results we conclude that EHV-1's low vhs activity in infected cells is not a reflection of the ORF19 protein's intrinsic vhs activity but may be due instead to the amount of ORF19 protein associated with viral particles or to modulation of ORF19 protein's intrinsic activity by another viral component(s).     

Disruption of virion host shutoff activity improves the immunogenicity and protective capacity of a replication-incompetent herpes simplex virus type 1 vaccine strain

The virion host shutoff (vhs) protein encoded by herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) destabilizes both viral and host mRNAs. An HSV-1 strain with a mutation in vhs is attenuated in virulence and induces immune responses in mice that are protective against corneal infection with virulent HSV-1, but it has the capacity to establish latency. Similarly, a replication-incompetent HSV-1 strain with a mutation in ICP8 elicits an immune response protective against corneal challenge, but it may be limited in viral antigen production. We hypothesized therefore that inactivation of vhs in an ICP8(-) virus would yield a replication-incompetent mutant with enhanced immunogenicity and protective capacity. In this study, a vhs(-)/ICP8(-) HSV-1 mutant was engineered. BALB/c mice were immunized with incremental doses of the vhs(-)/ICP8(-) double mutant or vhs(-) or ICP8(-) single mutants, or the mice were mock immunized, and protective immunity against corneal challenge with virulent HSV-1 was assessed. Mice immunized with the vhs(-)/ICP8(-) mutant showed prechallenge serum immunoglobulin G titers comparable to those immunized with replication-competent vhs(-) virus and exceed those of mice immunized with the ICP8(-) single mutant. Following corneal challenge, the degrees of protection against ocular disease, weight loss, encephalitis, and establishment of latency were similar for vhs(-)/ICP8(-) and vhs(-) virus-vaccinated mice. Moreover, the double deleted vhs(-)/ICP8(-) virus protected mice better in all respects than the single deleted ICP8(-) mutant virus. The data indicate that inactivation of vhs in a replication-incompetent virus significantly enhances its protective efficacy while retaining its safety for potential human vaccination. Possible mechanisms of enhanced immunogenicity are discussed.     

Replication-competent herpes simplex virus 1 isolates selected from cells transfected with a bacterial artificial chromosome DNA lacking only the UL49 gene vary with respect to the defect in the UL41 gene encoding host shutoff RNase

To generate a null U(L)49 gene mutant of herpes simplex virus 1 (HSV-1), we deleted from the viral DNA, encoded as a bacterial artificial chromosome (BAC), the U(L)49 open reading frame and, in a second step, restored it. Upon transfection into Vero cells, the BAC-DeltaU(L)49 DNA yielded foci of degenerated cells that could not be expanded and a few replication-competent clones. The replication-competent viral clones derived from independent transfections yielded viruses that expressed genes with some delay, produced smaller plaques, and gave lower yields than wild-type virus. A key finding is that the independently derived replication-competent viruses lacked the virion host shutoff (vhs) activity expressed by the RNase encoded by the U(L)41 gene. One mutant virus expressed no vhs protein, whereas two others, derived from independent transfections, produced truncated vhs proteins consistent with the spontaneous in-frame deletion. In contrast, cells infected with the virus recovered upon transfection of the BAC-U(L)49R DNA (R-U(L)49) accumulated a full-length vhs protein, indicating that in the parental BAC-DeltaU(L)49 DNA, the U(L)41 gene was intact. We conclude that expression of the vhs protein in the absence of U(L)49 protein is lethal, a conclusion bolstered by the evidence reported elsewhere that in transfected cells vhs requires both VP16 and VP22, the product of U(L)49, to be neutralized.     

The virion host shutoff protein of herpes simplex virus type 1: messenger ribonucleolytic activity in vitro.

Shortly after tissue culture cells are infected with herpes simplex virus (HSV) type 1 or 2, the rate of host protein synthesis decreases 5- to 10-fold and most host mRNAs are degraded. mRNA destabilization is triggered by the virion host shutoff (vhs) protein, a virus encoded, 58-kDa protein located in the virion tegument. To determine whether it can function as a messenger RNase (mRNase), the capacity of vhs protein to degrade RNA in vitro in absence of host cell components was assessed. Two sources of vhs protein were used in these assays: crude extract from virions or protein translated in a reticulocyte-free system. In each case, wild-type but not mutant vhs protein degraded various RNA substrates. Preincubation with anti-vhs antibody blocked RNase activity. These studies do not prove that vhs protein on its own is an mRNase but do demonstrate that the protein, either on its own or in conjunction with another factor(s), has the biochemical property of an mRNase, consistent with its role in infected cells.     

Herpes simplex virus type 2 virion host shutoff protein regulates alpha/beta interferon but not adaptive immune responses during primary infection in vivo

The herpes simplex virus (HSV) virion host shutoff (vhs) protein, the product of the UL41 (vhs) gene, is an important determinant of HSV virulence. vhs has been implicated in HSV interference with host antiviral immune responses, down-regulating expression of major histocompatibility complex molecules to help HSV evade host adaptive immunity. The severe attenuation of vhs-deficient viruses in vivo could reflect their inability to escape immune detection. To test this hypothesis, BALB/c or congenic SCID mice were infected intravaginally (i.vag.) with the HSV type 2 (HSV-2) vhs null mutant 333d41 or the vhs rescue virus 333d41(R). vhs-deficient virus remained severely attenuated in SCID mice compared with rescue virus, indicating that vhs regulation of adaptive immune responses does not influence HSV pathogenesis during acute infection. Innate antiviral effectors remain intact in SCID mice; prominent among these is alpha/beta interferon (IFN-alpha/beta). The attenuation of HSV-2 vhs mutants could reflect their failure to suppress IFN-alpha/beta-mediated antiviral activity. To test this hypothesis, 129 and congenic IFN-alpha/beta receptor-deficient (IFN-alpha/betaR(-/-)) mice were infected i.vag. with wild-type virus, vhs null mutants 333-vhsB or 333d41, or the vhs rescue virus 333d41(R). Whereas vhs-deficient viruses showed greatly reduced replication in the genital mucosa of 129 mice compared with wild-type or vhs rescue viruses, they were restored to nearly wild-type levels of replication in IFN-alpha/betaR(-/-) mice over the first 2 days postinfection. Only wild-type and vhs rescue viruses caused severe genital disease and hind limb paralysis in 129 mice, but infection of IFN-alpha/betaR(-/-) mice restored the virulence of vhs-deficient viruses. vhs-deficient viruses replicated as vigorously as wild-type and rescue viruses in the nervous systems of IFN-alpha/betaR(-/-) mice. Restoration was specific for the vhs mutation, because thymidine kinase-deficient HSV-2 did not regain virulence or the capacity to replicate in the nervous systems of IFN-alpha/betaR(-/-) mice. Furthermore, the defect in the IFN-alpha/beta response was required for restoration of vhs-deficient virus replication and virulence, but the IFN-alpha/beta-stimulated protein kinase R pathway was not involved. Finally, vhs of HSV-2 has a unique capacity to interfere with the IFN-alpha/beta response in vivo, because an HSV-1 vhs null mutant did not recover replication and virulence after i.vag. inoculation into IFN-alpha/betaR(-/-) mice. These results indicate that vhs plays an important role early in HSV-2 pathogenesis in vivo by interfering with the IFN-alpha/beta-mediated antiviral response.     

Varicella-zoster virus (VZV) ORF17 protein induces RNA cleavage and is critical for replication of VZV at 37 degrees C but not 33 degrees C

Varicella-zoster virus (VZV) open reading frame 17 (ORF17) is homologous to herpes simplex virus (HSV) UL41, which encodes the viral host shutoff protein (vhs). HSV vhs induces degradation of mRNA and rapid shutoff of host protein synthesis. An antibody to ORF17 protein detected a 46-kDa protein in VZV-infected cells. While HSV vhs is located in virions, VZV ORF17 protein was not detectable in virions. ORF17 protein induced RNA cleavage, but to a substantially lesser extent than HSV-1 vhs. Expression of ORF17 protein did not inhibit expression from a beta-galactosidase reporter plasmid, while HSV type 1 vhs abolished reporter expression. Two VZV ORF17 deletion mutants were constructed to examine the role of ORF17 in virus replication. While the ORF17 VZV mutants grew to peak titers that were similar to those of the parental virus at 33 degrees C, the ORF17 mutants grew to 20- to 35-fold-lower titers than parental virus at 37 degrees C. ORF62 protein was distributed in a different pattern in the nuclei and cytoplasm of cells infected with an ORF17 deletion mutant at 37 degrees C compared to 33 degrees C. Inoculation of cotton rats with the ORF17 deletion mutant resulted in a level of latent infection similar to that produced by inoculation with the parental virus. The importance of ORF17 protein for viral replication at 37 degrees C but not at 33 degrees C suggests that this protein may facilitate the growth of virus in certain tissues in vivo.     

The Virion Host Shut-Off (vhs) Protein Blocks a TLR-Independent Pathway of Herpes Simplex Virus Type 1 Recognition in Human and Mouse Dendritic Cells

Molecular pathways underlying the activation of dendritic cells (DCs) in response to Herpes Simplex Virus type 1 (HSV-1) are poorly understood. Removal of the HSV virion host shut-off (vhs) protein relieves a block to DC activation observed during wild-type infection. In this study, we utilized a potent DC stimulatory HSV-1 recombinant virus lacking vhs as a tool to investigate the mechanisms involved in the activation of DCs by HSV-1. We report that the release of pro-inflammatory cytokines by conventional DC (cDC) during HSV-1 infection is triggered by both virus replication-dependent and replication-independent pathways. Interestingly, while vhs is capable of inhibiting the release of cytokines during infection of human and mouse cDCs, the secretion of cytokines by plasmacytoid DC (pDC) is not affected by vhs. These data prompted us to postulate that infection of cDCs by HSV triggers a TLR independent pathway for cDC activation that is susceptible to blockage by the vhs protein. Using cDCs isolated from mice deficient in both the TLR adaptor protein MyD88 and TLR3, we show that HSV-1 and the vhs-deleted virus can activate cDCs independently of TLR signaling. In addition, virion-associated vhs fails to block cDC activation in response to treatment with TLR agonists, but it efficiently blocked cDC activation triggered by the paramyxoviruses Sendai Virus (SeV) and Newcastle Disease Virus (NDV). This block to SeV- and NDV-induced activation of cDC resulted in elevated SeV and NDV viral gene expression indicating that infection with HSV-1 enhances the cell''s susceptibility to other pathogens through the action of vhs. Our results demonstrate for the first time that a viral protein contained in the tegument of HSV-1 can block the induction of DC activation by TLR-independent pathways of viral recognition.