Cell competition and its implications for development and cancer

Cell competition is a struggle for existence between cells in heterogeneous tissues of multicellular organisms.Loser cells,which die during cell competition,are normally viable when grown only with other loser cells,but when mixed with winner cells,they are at a growth disadvantage and undergo apoptosis.Intriguingly,several recent studies have revealed that cells bearing mutant tumor-suppressor genes,which show overgrowth and tumorigenesis in a homotypic situation,are frequently eliminated,through cell competition,from tissues in which they are surrounded by wild-type cells.Here,we focus on the regulation of cellular competitiveness and the mechanism of cell competition as inferred from two different categories of mutant cells:(1) slower-growing cells and (2) structurally defective cells.We also discuss the possible role of cell competition as an intrinsic homeostasis system through which normal cells sense and remove aberrant cells,such as precancerous cells,to maintain the integrity and normal development of tissues and organs.     

Basolateral Junction Proteins Regulate Competition for the Follicle Stem Cell Niche in the Drosophila Ovary

Epithelial stem cells are routinely lost or damaged during adult life and must therefore be replaced to maintain homeostasis. Recent studies indicate that stem cell replacement occurs through neutral competition in many types of epithelial tissues, but little is known about the factors that determine competitive outcome. The epithelial follicle stem cells (FSCs) in the Drosophila ovary are regularly lost and replaced during normal homeostasis, and we show that FSC replacement conforms to a model of neutral competition. In addition, we found that FSCs mutant for the basolateral junction genes, lethal giant larvae (lgl) or discs large (dlg), undergo a biased competition for niche occupancy characterized by increased invasion of neighboring FSCs and reduced loss. Interestingly, FSCs mutant for a third basolateral junction gene, scribble (scrib), do not exhibit biased competition, suggesting that Lgl and Dlg regulate niche competition through a Scrib-independent process. Lastly, we found that FSCs have a unique cell polarity characterized by broadly distributed adherens junctions and the lack of a mature apical domain. Collectively, these observations indicate that Lgl and Dlg promote the differentiation of FSC progeny to a state in which they are less prone to invade the neighboring niche. In addition, we demonstrate that the neutral drift model can be adapted to quantify non-neutral behavior of mutant clones.     

The Genes Raw and Ribbon Are Required for Proper Shape of Tubular Epithelial Tissues in Drosophila

The products of two genes, raw and ribbon (rib), are required for the proper morphogenesis of a variety of tissues. Malpighian tubules mutant for raw or rib are wider and shorter than normal tubules, which are only two cells in circumference when they are fully formed. The mutations alter the shape of the tubules beginning early in their formation and block cell rearrangement late in development, which normally lengthens and narrows the tubes. Mutations of both genes affect a number of other tissues as well. Both genes are required for dorsal closure and retraction of the CNS during embryonic development. In addition, rib mutations block head involution, and broaden and shorten other tubular epithelia (salivary glands, tracheae, and hindgut) in much same manner as they alter the shape of the Malpighian tubules. In tissues in which the shape of cells can be observed readily, rib mutations alter cell shape, which probably causes the change in shape of the organs that are affected. In double mutants raw enhances the phenotypes of all the tissues that are affected by rib but unaffected by raw alone, indicating that raw is also active in these tissues.     

Elimination of oncogenic cells that regulate epithelial homeostasis in Drosophila

Normal epithelial tissues often put anti-tumorigenic pressure on newly emerged oncogenic cells through cell–cell communications. In Drosophila epithelium, clones of oncogenic cells mutant for evolutionarily conserved apico-basal polarity genes such as scribble (scrib) and discs large (dlg) are actively eliminated when surrounded by normal cells. It has been reported that c-Jun N-terminal kinase (JNK) signaling in polarity-deficient cells is crucial for their cell death. However, the mechanism by which normal epithelial tissues exert anti-tumorigenic effects on polarity-deficient cells had been elusive. Here, I describe our genetic studies in Drosophila epithelium especially focused on the role of surrounding normal epithelial cells in response to the emergence of polarity-deficient cells. Furthermore, I also describe recent studies regarding the mechanism by which polarity-deficient cells are extruded from the tissue, and discuss future perspectives on the study of cell–cell communications in epithelial homeostasis.     

Morphology of developing heart in cardiac lethal mutant Mexican axolotls, Ambystoma mexicanum

In Ambystoma mexicanum, recessive mutant gene c results in an absence of embryonic heart function because of altered influences from surrounding tissues (Humphrey, 1972). The present light and electron microscope study compares heart development in normal and mutant embryos from Harrison stage 34 or 6 days (at which normal heart beat initiates) through stage 41 or 25 days (at which mutant embryos die). The hearts display increasing differences as development progresses, and by stage 41 mutant abnormalities are striking. The normal myocardium shows organized sarcomeres at stage 34 and numerous intercalated discs subsequently appear. By stage 41, the normal myocardium is composed of highly differentiated muscle cells and shows extensive trabeculation. The mutant myocardium throughout development remains only one cell layer thick with no indication of developing trabeculae. Mutant cells at stage 34 have a few 140 Å and 60 Å filaments along with what appear to be Z bodies. A partial organization of myofibrillar components is occasionally noted at stages 38–41; however, distinct sarcomeres are not apparent and intercalated discs are rarely seen. In general the mutant cells appear less differentiated than usual and in many respects are reminiscent of pre-heart-beat normal cells. Although most mutant cells show images characteristic of pathological conditions (e.g., pleomorphic mitochondria, membranous whorls, and numerous autophagic vacuoles), selective myocardial cell death, a phenomenon associated with normal trabeculation, is not evident. It is clear that gene c, in homozygous condition, results in an altered pattern of heart cell differentiation. The mutation, by way of abnormal inductive processes, appears to affect the synthesis and organization of heart contractile proteins.     

Dose-Dependent Dual Role of PIT-1 (POU1F1) in Somatolactotroph Cell Proliferation and Apoptosis

To test the role of wtPIT-1 (PITWT) or PIT-1 (R271W) (PIT271) in somatolactotroph cells, we established, using inducible lentiviral vectors, sublines of GH4C1 somatotroph cells that allow the blockade of the expression of endogenous PIT-1 and/or the expression of PITWT or PIT271, a dominant negative mutant of PIT-1 responsible for Combined Pituitary Hormone Deficiency in patients. Blocking expression of endogenous PIT-1 induced a marked decrease of cell proliferation. Overexpressing PITWT twofold led also to a dose-dependent decrease of cell proliferation that was accompanied by cell death. Expression of PIT271 induced a strong dose-dependent decrease of cell proliferation accompanied by a very pronounced cell death. These actions of PIT271 are independent of its interaction/competition with endogenous PIT-1, as they were unchanged when expression of endogenous PIT-1 was blocked. All these actions are specific for somatolactotroph cells, and could not be observed in heterologous cells. Cell death induced by PITWT or by PIT271 was accompanied by DNA fragmentation, but was not inhibited by inhibitors of caspases, autophagy or necrosis, suggesting that this cell death is a caspase-independent apoptosis. Altogether, our results indicate that under normal conditions PIT-1 is important for the maintenance of cell proliferation, while when expressed at supra-normal levels it induces cell death. Through this dual action, PIT-1 may play a role in the expansion/regression cycles of pituitary lactotroph population during and after lactation. Our results also demonstrate that the so-called “dominant-negative” action of PIT271 is independent of its competition with PIT-1 or a blockade of the actions of the latter, and are actions specific to this mutant variant of PIT-1.     

Altered cell-surface targeting of stem cell factor causes loss of melanocyte precursors in Steel17H mutant mice.

The normal products of the murine Steel (Sl) and Dominant white spotting (W) genes are essential for the development of melanocyte precursors, germ cells, and hematopoietic cells. The Sl locus encodes stem cell factor (SCF), which is the ligand of c-kit, a receptor tyrosine kinase encoded by the W locus. One allele of the Sl mutation, Sl17H, exhibits minor hematopoietic defects, sterility only in males, and a complete absence of coat pigmentation. The Sl17H gene encodes SCF protein which exhibits an altered cytoplasmic domain due to a splicing defect. In this paper we analyzed the mechanism by which the pigmentation phenotype in Sl17H mutant mice occurs. We show that in embryos homozygous for Sl17H the number of melanocyte precursors is severely reduced on the lateral neural crest migration pathway by e11.5 and can no longer be detected by e13.5 when they would enter the epidermis in wildtype embryos. The reduced number of dispersing melanocyte precursors correlates with a reduction of SCF immunoreactivity in mutant embryos in all tissues examined. Regardless of the reduced amount, functional SCF is present at the cell surface of fibroblasts transfected with Sl17H mutant SCF cDNA. Since SCF immunoreactivity normally accumulates in basolateral compartments of SCF-expressing embryonic epithelial tissues, we analyzed the localization of wildtype and Sl17H mutant SCF protein in transfected epithelial (MDCK) cells in vitro. As expected, wildtype forms of SCF localize to and are secreted from the basolateral compartment. In contrast, mutant forms of SCF, which either lack a membrane anchor or exhibit the Sl17H altered cytoplasmic tail, localize to and are secreted from the apical compartment of the cultured epithelium. We suggest, therefore, that the loss of melanocyte precursors prior to epidermal invasion, and the loss of germ cells from mature testis, can be explained by the inability of Sl17H mutant SCF to be targeted to the basolateral compartment of polarized epithelial keratinocytes and Sertoli cells, respectively.     

Socs36E Controls Niche Competition by Repressing MAPK Signaling in the Drosophila Testis

The Drosophila testis is a well-established system for studying stem cell self-renewal and competition. In this tissue, the niche supports two stem cell populations, germ line stem cells (GSCs), which give rise to sperm, and somatic stem cells called cyst stem cells (CySCs), which support GSCs and their descendants. It has been established that CySCs compete with each other and with GSCs for niche access, and mutations have been identified that confer increased competitiveness to CySCs, resulting in the mutant stem cell and its descendants outcompeting wild type resident stem cells. Socs36E, which encodes a negative feedback inhibitor of the JAK/STAT pathway, was the first identified regulator of niche competition. The competitive behavior of Socs36E mutant CySCs was attributed to increased JAK/STAT signaling. Here we show that competitive behavior of Socs36E mutant CySCs is due in large part to unbridled Mitogen-Activated Protein Kinase (MAPK) signaling. In Socs36E mutant clones, MAPK activity is elevated. Furthermore, we find that clonal upregulation of MAPK in CySCs leads to their outcompetition of wild type CySCs and of GSCs, recapitulating the Socs36E mutant phenotype. Indeed, when MAPK activity is removed from Socs36E mutant clones, they lose their competitiveness but maintain self-renewal, presumably due to increased JAK/STAT signaling in these cells. Consistently, loss of JAK/STAT activity in Socs36E mutant clones severely impairs their self-renewal. Thus, our results enable the genetic separation of two essential processes that occur in stem cells. While some niche signals specify the intrinsic property of self-renewal, which is absolutely required in all stem cells for niche residence, additional signals control the ability of stem cells to compete with their neighbors. Socs36E is node through which these processes are linked, demonstrating that negative feedback inhibition integrates multiple aspects of stem cell behavior.     

Expression of Cell Competition Markers at the Interface between p53 Signature and Normal Epithelium in the Human Fallopian Tube

There is a growing body of evidence regarding cell competition between normal and mutant mammalian cells, which suggest that it may play a defensive role in the early phase of carcinogenesis. In vitro study in the past has shown that overexpression of vimentin in normal epithelial cells at the contact surface with transformed cells is essential for the cell competition involved in epithelial defense against cancer. In this study, we attempted to examine cell competition in human tissue in vivo by investigating surgically resected human fallopian tubes that contain p53 signatures and serous tubal intraepithelial lesions (STILs), a linear expansion of p53-immunopositive/TP53 mutant tubal epithelial cells that are considered as precursors of pelvic high grade serous carcinoma. Immunofluorescence double staining for p53 and the cell competition marker vimentin was performed in 21 sections of human fallopian tube tissue containing 17 p53 signatures and 4 STILs. The intensities of vimentin expression at the interface between p53-positive cells at the end of the p53 signature/STIL and adjacent p53-negative normal tubal epithelial cells were compared with the background tubal epithelium. As a result, the average vimentin intensity at the interfaces relative to the background intensity was 1.076 (95% CI, 0.9412 – 1.211 for p53 signature and 0.9790 (95% CI, 0.7206 – 1.237) for STIL. Thus, it can be concluded that overexpression of the cell competition marker vimentin are not observed in human tissue with TP53 alterations.     

Reversion in expression of hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyl transferase following cell hybridization.

Hybridization of mutant cell lines deficient in hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyl transferase (HGPRT; E.C.: 2.4.2.8) from a variety of established rodent sources with HGPRT plus human cells yielded progeny cells which grew in selective medium containing hypoxanthine, aminopterin and thymidine (HAT). The same result was obtained when the human cell used was an HGPRT minus transformed line derived from a patient with the Lesch-Nyhan syndrome. Electrophoretic analysis indicated that all HAT-resistant progeny clones contained an active HGPRT enzyme which was indistinguishable from the wild type enzyme of the corresponding normal rodent cells. In contrast, no HAT-resistant cells have been obtained when the same HGPRT minus rodent cells were subjected to fusion processes in the absence of human cells or when they fused with similarly derived HGPRT minus mutant cells of other rodents. Reversion in expression of the rodent gene for HGPRT was detected in clones which retained one or more human chromosomes and in clones which contained no detectable human chromosomal material. The observed re-expression of rodent HGPRT in HAT-resistant clones suggests that HGPRT plus as well as HGPRT minus human cells contributed a factor which determined the expression of respective rodent structural genes for HGPRT. In contrast, HGPRT minus rodent cells were unable to induce the synthesis or normal HGPRT in the cells derived from the patient with the Lesch-Nyhan syndrome.     

MORPHOGENETIC ASPECTS OF A LEAFLESS MUTANT IN TOMATO II. INDUCTION OF A VASCULAR CAMBIUM

The vascular tissues of the leafless form of the “lanceolate” mutant in tomato resemble those of the normal hypocotyl in the lower portions. A divergence in development occurs in the middle region of the mutant hypocotyl: two xylary strands split acropetally into five to seven units, while in the normal hypocotyl four main vascular bundles are established. The three to four week old mutant hypocotyl shows a marked proliferation of cells in its central cylinder when it is grown on a simple nutrient medium; proliferation also occurs in older specimens grown in soil. This condition is averted if the mutant is grafted beneath an actively growing normal shoot tip. Instead of having numerous, random cell divisions in the central cylinder, the grafted mutant shows large pith parenchyma cells and an active vascular cambium. These features characterize the normal hypocotyl and they have not been observed in the intact leafless mutant. The observed behavior of intact and grafted mutant hypocotyls can be interpreted in terms of the normal shoot tip acting both as physiological sink, with respect to cell-division stimuli produced mainly in the root system, and physiological source, with respect to cambial activating hormones.     

Normal skin cells in vitro

Major cells in skin are epidermal cells in epidermis and fibroblasts in dermis. These cells can be isolated as a relatively pure population from the tissues using proteases and chelating agents. In this review we describe the way of culture where these two kinds of cells express normal function as they do in vivo. 1) It is important to consider the polarity of epidermal cell membranes in the transport of nutrients and metabolites when the cells are to be cultured in a healthy state in a long period. Epidermals cells expressed their normal polarities when cultured on a porous thin film of collagen and bathed on both sides (apical and basal) in culture media. 2) It is important to consider the interactions of fibroblasts with collagen when normal morphology and physiology are expected to be expressed in the cell in culture. Collagen affected the morphology of the cell and profoundly decreased the rate of DNA synthesis. We present a hypothesis which explains the fibronectin-independent interaction of fibroblasts with collagen. 3) It is important to consider the interactions between fibroblasts and epidermal cells when normal physiology of the skin as a whole is expected to be expressed in vitro, because exchange of information between them control their metabolic activities and functions. In this review, two examples for this exchange are presented: cell growth and collagenolysis.     

Stem cells and genetic disease

Abstract.  Stem cell research is now a very broad field encompassing cells derived from all stages of life from the embryonic stem cells of the early blastocyst through to the adult stem cells of many tissues of the body. Adult stem cells from a variety of tissues are proving to be pluripotent and can differentiate into cell types different from the tissues from which they derive. Pre-clinical animal models indicate that adult stem cells do not cause tumours, not even, teratomas when transplanted. These properties, combined with the possibility of autologous transplantation, indicate significant advantages over embryonic stem cells in many proposed clinical applications.     

Ablation of TrkA function in the immune system causes B cell abnormalities

The nerve growth factor (NGF) receptor TrkA is widely expressed in non-neural tissues suggesting pleiotropic functions outside the nervous system. Based on pharmacological and immuno-depletion experiments, it has been hypothesized that NGF plays an important role in the normal development and function of the immune system. However, attempts to unravel these functions by conventional gene targeting in mice have been hampered by the early postnatal lethality caused by null mutations. We have developed a novel 'reverse conditional' gene targeting strategy by which TrkA function is restored specifically in the nervous system. Mice lacking TrkA in non-neuronal tissues are viable and appear grossly normal. All major immune system cell populations are present in normal numbers and distributions. However, mutant mice have elevated serum levels of certain immunoglobulin classes and accumulate B1 cells with aging. These data, confirmed in a classical reconstitution model using embryonic fetal liver from TrkA-null mice, demonstrate that endogenous NGF modulates B cell development through TrkA in vivo. Furthermore, they demonstrate that many of the dramatic effects previously reported by pharmacological or immuno-depletion approaches do not reflect physiological developmental roles of TrkA in the immune system.     

Restoration of mutant TP53 to normal TP53 function by glycerol as a chemical chaperone

We have previously reported that heat stress induces expression of wild-type TP53 (formerly known as p53) activated factor 1 (CDKN1A, formerly known as WAF1) only when TP53 protein is wild-type using cells of a human glioblastoma cell line (A-172) and cells of its transformant (A-172/mp53/ 143) with a mutant TP53 (point mutation at codon 143 from Val to Ala) vector. Transfection of A-172 cells with the mutant TP53 vector abolished the heat-induced expression of CDKN1A, demonstrating the dominant negative nature of this TP53 mutant over the endogenous wild-type TP53. This kind of dominant negative TP53 mutant occurs frequently in various types of cancer. Overcoming this dominance or restoring the normal functions to these TP53 mutants is a new strategy for TP53-targeted cancer therapies. We examined whether glycerol can act as a chemical chaperone to correct the mutant TP53 conformation. No CDKN1A expression was induced after heating or treatment with glycerol at concentrations of 0.6 and 1.2 M in these transformants. In contrast, A-172/mp53/ 143 cells showed CDKN1A expression when they were heated in the presence of glycerol at 0.6 or 1.2 M, which was similar to the response of the parental and neo vector-transfected control cells. To test the generality of the effects of glycerol on mutant TP53, we used human osteosarcoma Saos-2 cells (lacking TP53) transfected with mutant TP53 and cells of two other human glioblastoma cell lines carrying mutant TP53. These cells showed similar CDKN1A expression when heated in the presence of glycerol at 0.6 or 1.2 M. These results suggest that glycerol is effective in restoring several TP53 mutants to normal TP53 function, leading to normal CDKN1A expression after heat stress. This observation provides a novel tool for correction of mutant TP53 conformation and may be applicable for TP53-targeted cancer therapy.     

Communication between normal and enzyme deficient cells in tissue culture

Correction of certain mutant phenotypes by intimate contact with normal cells, i.e. ‘metabolic cooperation’, is an easily studied form of cell communication. Metabolic cooperation between normal cells and mutant cells deficient in hypoxanthine-guanine or adenine phosphoribosyl transferase (HGPRTase and APRTase respectively) appears to be the result of transfer of the enzyme product, nucleotide or nucleotide derivative, from normal to mutant cells. This process shows selectivity in that mutant derivatives of mouse L cells are unable to function as recipients of HGPRTase or APRTase products, while hamster and human fibroblasts with these enzyme deficiencies, exhibit correction of the mutant phenotype, when in contact with normal donor cells. There is also selectivity with respect to substances transferred, since other mutant phenotypes, i.e. G-6 PD deficiency, are not corrected by contact with normal cells. Species specificities do not appear to influence metabolic cooperation, therefore heterospecific cell mixtures provide an opportunity to cytologically distinguish cells and study individual cell interactions.     

Intrinsic growth control in the imaginal primordia of Drosophila, and the autonomous action of a lethal mutation causing overgrowth

Cell proliferation in Drosophila imaginal discs appears to be regulated by a disc-intrinsic mechanism involving local cell interactions that also control the formation of patterns of differentiation. This growth-control mechanism breaks down in animals homozygous for the mutation lethal (2) giant discs (l(2)gd) which remain as larvae for up to 9 days longer than normal. During this time cell proliferation continues in the imaginal discs as well as in the imaginal rings for the salivary glands, foregut, and hindgut, so that these tissues become greatly overgrown. When wild-type wing discs from mid-third instar larvae were removed and cultured for up to 28 days in wild-type female adult hosts, they grew and terminated growth at a cell number close to that which would be attained in situ by the time of pupariation. On the other hand, wing discs from l(2)gd homozygotes grew rapidly and continuously when cultivated in wild-type hosts, reached an enormous size, and acquired abnormal folding patterns. Overgrowth of mutant imaginal rings also continued during culture of these tissues in wild-type hosts. We conclude that overgrowth in this mutant is due to an autonomous defect in the imaginal primordia, which requires an extended larval period for its expression in situ.     

Intercellular communication and tissue growth

Summary Epithelial cells of normal rat (adult) liver and hamster embryo in tissue culture communicate through membrane junctions: the membrane regions of cell contact are highly ion-permeable. Cancerous counterparts of these cells, cells from Morris' and Reuber's liver tumors and from x-ray-transformed embryo cultures, do not communicate under the same experimental conditions. These cells also fail to communicate with contiguous normal cells. Cancerous fibroblastic cells from a variety of tissues, including cells transformed by virus, x-radiation and chemicals, communicate as well as their normal counterparts; this is so for long- and short-term cell cultures. Communication in some fibroblastic cells is sensitive to components of blood serum: normal and transformed hamster embryo fibroblasts, which communicate when cultured in medium containing fetal calf serum, appear to lose communication in medium containing calf serum; the converse holds for hamster (adult) fibroblasts and 3T3 cells.The preceding papers of this series appeared in the Journal of Cell Biology.Trainee of the National Institutes of Health, National Cancer Institute, Grant CA 05011.     

Revisiting p53 for cancer-specific chemo- and radiotherapy

Despite intense studies, highly effective therapeutic strategies against cancer have not yet been fully exploited, because few true cancer-specific targets have been identified. Most modalities, perhaps with the exception of radiation therapy, target proliferating cells, which are also abundant in normal tissues. Thus, most current cancer treatments have significant side effects. More than 10 years ago, the tumor suppressor p53 was first explored as a cancer-specific target. At the time, the approach was to introduce a normal p53 gene into mutant p53 (mp53) tumor cells to induce cell cycle arrest and apoptosis. However, this strategy did not hold up and mostly failed in subsequent clinical studies. Recent research developments have now returned p53 to the limelight. Several studies have reported that mutant or null p53 tumor cells undergo apoptosis more easily than genetically matched, normal p53 counterparts when inhibiting a specific stress kinase in combination with standard chemotherapy or when exposed to an ataxia-telangiectasia mutated (ATM) kinase inhibitor and radiation, thus achieving true cancer specificity in animal tumor models. This short review highlights several of these recent studies, discusses possible mechanism(s) for mp53-mediated “synthetic lethality,” and the implications for cancer therapy.