A molecular analysis of the isolated rat posterior frontal and sagittal sutures: differences in gene expression

Although it is one of the most commonly occurring craniofacial congenital disabilities, craniosynostosis (the premature fusion of cranial sutures) is nearly impossible to prevent because the molecular mechanisms that regulate the process of cranial suture fusion remain largely unknown. Recent studies have implicated the dura mater in determining the fate of the overlying cranial suture; however, the molecular biology within the suture itself has not been sufficiently investigated. In the murine model of cranial suture fusion, the posterior frontal suture is programmed to begin fusing by postnatal day 12 in rats (day 25 in mice), reliably completing bony union by postnatal day 22 (day 45 in mice). In contrast, the sagittal suture remains patent throughout the life of the animal. Using this model, this study sought to examine for the first time what differences in gene expression--if any--exist between the two sutures with opposite fates. For each series of experiments, 35 to 40 posterior frontal and sagittal suture complexes were isolated from 6-day-old Sprague-Dawley rat pups. Suture-derived cell cultures were established, and ribonuicleic acid was derived from snap-frozen, isolated suture tissue. Results demonstrated that molecular differences between the posterior frontal and sagittal suture complexes were readily identified in vivo, although these distinctions were lost once the cells comprising the suture complex were cultured in vitro. Hypothetically, this change in gene expression resulted from the loss of the influence of the underlying dura mater. Significant differences in the expression of genes encoding extracellular matrix proteins existed in vivo between the posterior frontal and sagittal sutures. However, the production of the critical, regulatory cytokine transforming growth factor beta-1 was equal between the two suture complexes, lending further support to the hypothesis that dura mater regulates the fate of the overlying cranial suture.     

Cranial suture obliteration is induced by removal of transforming growth factor (TGF)-beta 3 activity and prevented by removal of TGF-beta 2 activity from fetal rat calvaria in vitro

Cranial suture morphogenesis requires soluble, heparin-binding factors secreted by the dura mater to resist premature osseous obliteration. Elevated levels of transforming growth factor (TGF)-beta 1, TGF-beta 2, and TGF-beta 3 have previously been noted in cranial sutures undergoing normal and premature sutural obliteration. To examine the role of TGF-beta s in regulating cranial suture morphogenesis, an established in vitro, serum-free, calvarial culture system was used. In this system, fetal rat coronal sutures undergo apparently normal suture morphogenesis in the presence of dura mater, but undergo osseous obliteration in the absence of dura mater. Neutralizing polyclonal antibodies to TGF-beta 1, TGF-beta 2, or TGF-beta 3 were added to cultures of fetal day 19 rat calvaria, which were harvested at 3, 4, or 5 days, processed for histology, sectioned, and examined. Coronal sutures from calvaria cultured in the presence of dura mater resisted obliteration, either alone or in the presence of TGF-beta 1 or TGF-beta 2 neutralizing antibodies. However, sutures from calvaria cultured in the presence of TGF-beta 3 neutralizing antibodies became obliterated. Conversely, sutures from calvaria cultured in the absence of dura mater became obliterated by bone, either alone or in the presence of neutralizing antibodies to TGF-beta 1 or TGF-beta 3. However, those sutures cultured in the presence of neutralizing antibodies to TGF-beta 2 were rescued from osseous obliteration.     

Regional differentiation of rat cranial suture-derived dural cells is dependent on association with fusing and patent cranial sutures

A significant body of literature supports a role for the dura mater underlying cranial sutures in the regulation of sutural fate. These studies have implicated regional differentiation of the dura mater based on association with fusing and patent rat cranial sutures. The purpose of these experiments was to isolate and characterize dural cells associated with fusing (posterior frontal) and patent (sagittal) rat cranial sutures. Six-day-old rats were killed, and the dura mater underlying the posterior frontal and sagittal sutures was harvested. Dural cells were briefly trypsinized and allowed to reach confluence. Two litters (10 animals per litter) were used for each set of experiments. Cells were harvested after the first and fifth passages for analysis of vimentin and desmoplakin expression (characteristic of human meningeal cells), cellular proliferation, density at confluence (a measure of cellular contact inhibition), and alkaline phosphatase production. In addition, bone nodule formation and collagen I production were analyzed in first passage cells. The results indicate that suture-derived dural cells can be established and that these cells coexpress vimentin and desmoplakin. In addition, it is demonstrated that first-passage sagittal suture-derived dural cells proliferate significantly faster and have decreased cellular contact inhibition than posterior frontal suture-derived cells (p < 0.01). Finally, it is shown that suture-derived dural cells have osteoblast-like properties, including alkaline phosphatase production, collagen I expression, and bone nodule formation in vitro. The possible mechanisms by which regional differentiation of suture-derived dural cells occur are discussed.     

Mechanisms of murine cranial suture patency mediated by a dominant negative transforming growth factor-beta receptor adenovirus

Using a physiologic model of mouse cranial suture fusion, the authors' laboratory has previously demonstrated that transforming growth factor (TGF)-betas appear to be more abundantly expressed in the suture complex of the fusing posterior frontal compared with the patent sagittal suture. Furthermore, the authors have shown that by blocking TGF-beta signaling with a replication-deficient adenovirus encoding a defective, dominant negative type II TGF-beta receptor (AdDN-TbetaRII), posterior frontal suture fusion was inhibited. In this study, the authors attempt to further elucidate the role of TGF-beta in cranial suture fusion by investigating possible mechanisms of AdDN-TbetaRII-mediated cranial suture patency using both an established organ culture model and a novel in vitro co-culture system that recapitulates the in vivo anatomic dura mater/cranial suture relationship. In this article, the authors demonstrate that blocking TGF-beta signaling with the AdDN-TbetaRII construct led to inhibition of cellular proliferation in the suture mesenchyme and subjacent dura mater during the early period of predicted posterior frontal suture fusion. Interestingly, co-culture experiments revealed that transfecting osteoblasts with AdDN-TbetaRII led to alterations in the gene expression levels of two important bone-related molecules (Msx2 and osteopontin). Inhibiting TGF-beta signaling prevented time-dependent suppression of Msx2 and prevented induction of osteopontin, thereby retarding osteoblast differentiation. Furthermore, the authors demonstrated that the AdDN-TbetaRII construct was capable of blocking TGF-beta -mediated up-regulation of collagen IalphaI, an extracellular matrix molecule important for bone formation. Collectively, these data strongly suggest that AdDN-TbetaRII maintains posterior frontal patency, in part by altering early events in de novo bone formation, including cellular proliferation and early extracellular matrix production.     

Craniosynostosis and altered patterns of fetal TGF-beta expression induced by intrauterine constraint

Recent work has demonstrated that fusion of the calvarial sutures is mediated by locally elaborated soluble growth factors, including the transforming growth factor-betas (TGF-betas), leading some to speculate that external biomechanical forces play little role in suture development. Clinical evidence has long suggested, however, that fetal head constraint may play a critical role in the pathogenesis of many cases of nonsyndromic craniosynostosis. The purpose of these experiments was to test the hypothesis that intrauterine constraint leads to an alteration in normal patterns of TGF-beta expression and that these alterations are associated with craniosynostosis. Fetal constraint was induced by allowing C57Bl/6 murine fetuses to grow for 2.5 days beyond the normal 20-day gestation by performing uterine cerclage on the eighteenth day. Cranial suture morphology was examined in hematoxylin and eosin-stained sections and in cleared whole-mount specimens, double stained with alizarin red S and Alcian blue. Expression patterns of TGF-beta1 and TGF-beta3 were examined by immunohistochemical techniques. Gross and microscopic examination of the cranial sutures of 17 constrained fetuses revealed changes that ranged from narrowing to complete osseous obliteration of the coronal and squamosal sutures. All sutures of 14 nonconstrained control pups remained patent. Fetal head constraint was associated with increased TGF-beta1 immunoreactivity within the new bone and the underlying dura when compared with nonconstrained age-matched controls. TGF-beta3 immunoreactivity was associated with the dura underlying patent, nonconstrained sutures, whereas constraint-induced synostosis was characterized by down-regulation of dural TGF-beta3 expression. These experiments confirm the ability of intrauterine constraint to induce premature fusion of the cranial sutures and provide evidence that intrauterine head constraint induces the expression of osteogenic growth factors in fetal calvarial bone and the underlying dura.     

Basic fibroblast growth factor and transforming growth factor beta-1 expression in the developing dura mater correlates with calvarial bone formation

Numerous studies have found dura mater-calvarial mesenchyme interactions during calvarial bone induction; however, the exact molecular mechanisms governing these inductive events remain unknown. Recent studies have implicated basic fibroblast growth factor (FGF-2) and transforming growth factor-beta1 (TGF-beta1) in regulating bone formation. The purpose of this study was, therefore, to investigate the expression of FGF-2 and TGF-beta1 during calvarial bone formation in rats. Eight rats were killed on embryonic days 14, 18, and 20 and neonatal day 1 (n = 32). Four animals at each time point were analyzed by in situ hybridization, and the remainder were analyzed by immunohistochemistry. The results indicated that the dura mater underlying the developing calvarial bone strongly expressed FGF-2 and TGF-beta1 mRNA at all time points examined. In contrast, minimal growth factor expression was noted in the overlying calvarial mesenchyme until embryonic day 18, but it increased significantly with increasing age. Importantly, FGF-2 and TGF-beta1 mRNA expression in the dura mater underlying the developing calvarium preceded and was significantly greater than expression in the calvarium mesenchyme (p < 0.05). Interestingly, minimal expression of FGF-2 and TGF-beta1 mRNA was noted for all time points in the dura mater underlying the posterior frontal suture and within the posterior frontal suture connective tissue (p < 0.01 when compared with the dura mater underlying the developing calvarium). Immunohistochemical findings closely paralleled mRNA expression, with intense staining for FGF-2 and TGF-beta1 in the dura mater underlying the developing calvarial mesenchyme. Increasing FGF-2 and TGF-beta1 staining was noted within calvarial osteoblasts with increasing age, particularly in cells located near the endocranial surface (i.e., in contact with the developing dura mater). These findings, together with the known biologic functions of FGF-2 and TGF-beta1, implicate these growth factors in the regulation of calvarial bone growth by the developing dura mater. The possible mechanisms of this interaction are discussed.     

Nasal capsular cartilage is required for rat transpalatal suture morphogenesis

In the cranial vault, suture morphogenesis occurs when the growing cranial bones approximate and overlap or abut one another. Patency of developing sutures is regulated by the underlying dura mater. Once cranial sutures form, bone growth proceeds from the sutures in response to growth signals from the rapidly expanding neurocranium. Facial sutures do not develop in contact with the dura mater. It was therefore hypothesized that facial suture morphogenesis and bone growth from facial sutures are regulated by tissues with an equivalent role to the dura mater. The present study was designed to test this hypothesis by characterizing the morphology and growth factor expression in developing transpalatal (TP) sutures and their surrounding tissues, and then assessing the role of the overlying nasal capsular (NC) cartilages in maintaining suture patency. TP sutures develop as overlapping sutures, similar to cranial coronal sutures, and expression of Tgf-betas in TP sutures was similar to their distribution in cranial coronal sutures. To establish whether NC cartilages play a role in regulating TP suture morphogenesis, fetal rat TP sutures were cultured with associated attached NC cartilages or with NC cartilages removed. Sutures cultured for upward of 5 days with intact NC cartilages remained patent and maintained their cellular and fibrous components. However, in the absence of NC cartilages, the cellular nature of the sutures was not maintained and they became progressively acellular, with bony bridging across the suture. This finding is similar to that for cranial vault sutures cultured in the absence of dura mater, indicating that NC cartilages play an equivalent role to dura mater in maintaining the patency of developing sutures. These studies indicate that tissue interactions likely regulate morphogenesis of all cranial and facial sutures.     

TGF-beta2 stimulates cranial suture closure through activation of the Erk-MAPK pathway

Cranial sutures are important growth sites of the skull. During suture closure, the dura mater is one of the most important sources of various positive and negative regulatory signals. Previous results indicate that TGF-beta2 from dura mater strongly accelerates suture closure, however, its exact regulatory mechanism is still unclear. In this study, we confirmed that removal of dura mater in calvarial organ culture strongly accelerates sagittal suture closure and that this effect is further enhanced by TGF-beta2 treatment. TGF-beta2 stimulated cell proliferation in the MC3T3-E1 cell line. Similarly, it stimulated the proliferation of cells in the sutural space in calvarial organ culture. Furthermore, TGF-beta2-mediated enhanced cell proliferation and suture closure were almost completely inhibited by an Erk-MAPK blocker, PD98059. These results indicate that TGF-beta2-induced activation of Erk-MAPK is an important signaling component that stimulates cell proliferation to enrich osteoprogenitor cells, thereby promoting their differentiation into osteoblasts to achieve a rapid calvarial bone expansion.     

Increased IGF-I and IGF-II mRNA and IGF-I peptide in fusing rat cranial sutures suggest evidence for a paracrine role of insulin-like growth factors in suture fusion

Premature cranial suture fusion, or craniosynostosis, can result in gross aberrations of craniofacial growth. The biology underlying cranial suture fusion remains poorly understood. Previous studies of the Sprague-Dawley rat posterior frontal suture, which fuses at between 12 and 20 days, have suggested that the regional dura mater beneath the cranial suture directs the overlying suture's fusion. To address the dura-suture paracrine signaling that results in osteogenic differentiation and suture fusion, the authors investigated the possible role of insulin-like growth factors (IGF) I and II. The authors studied the temporal and spatial patterns of the expression of IGF-I and IGF-II mRNA and IGF-I peptide and osteocalcin (bone morphogenetic protein-4) protein in fusing posterior frontal rat sutures, and they compared them with patent coronal (control) sutures. Ten Sprague-Dawley rats were studied at the following time points: 16, 18, and 20 days of gestation and 2, 5, 10, 15, 20, 30, 50, and 80 days after birth (n = 110). Posterior frontal and coronal (patent, control) sutures were analyzed for IGF-I and IGF-II mRNA expression by in situ hybridization by using 35S-labeled IGF-I and IGF-II antisense riboprobes. Levels of IGF-I and IGF-II mRNA were quantified by counting the number of autoradiograph signals per cell. IGF-I and osteocalcin immunoreactivity were identified by avidin-biotin peroxidase immunohistochemistry. IGF-I and IGF-II mRNA were expressed in dural cells beneath fusing sutures, and the relative mRNA abundance increased between 2 and 10 days before initiation of fusion. Subsequently, IGF-I and IGF-II mRNA were detected in the suture connective tissue cells at 15 and 20 days during the time of active fusion. In contrast, within large osteoblasts of the osteogenic front, the expression of IGF-I and IGF-II mRNA was minimal. However, IGF-I peptide and osteocalcin protein were intensely immunoreactive within these osteoblasts at 15 days (during the period of suture fusion). These data suggest that the dura-suture interaction may be signaled in a paracrine fashion by dura-derived growth factors, such as IGF-I and IGF-II. These peptides, in turn, stimulate nearby osteoblasts to produce bone-promoting growth factors, such as osteocalcin.     

Cellular dynamics and tissue interactions of the dura mater during head development

During development and growth of the neurocranium, the dura mater regulates events in the underlying brain and overlying skull by the release of soluble factors and cellular activity. Morphogenesis of the cranial bones and sutures is dependent on tissue interactions with the dura mater, which control the size and shape of bones as well as sutural patency. Development of the brain also involves interactions with dura mater: secretion of stromal derived factor 1 (SDF-1) is a critical event in directing migration of the external granular layer precursors of the cerebellar cortex and the Cajal-Retzius (CR) cells of the cerebral cortex. The dura mater is also required for growth of the hippocampal dentate gyrus. Wnt1Cre/R26R transgenic reporter mice were used to study the origin and fates of the cells of dura mater during head development. The dura mater of mammals is derived entirely from the cranial neural crest. Beginning around neonatal day 10 (N 10), the dura mater is infiltrated by cells derived from paraxial mesoderm, which later come to predominate. Over the course of infancy, the neural crest-derived cells of the dura mater become sequestered in niche-like distribution characteristic of stem cells. Simultaneously, dura mater cells underlying the sagittal suture migrate upward into the mesodermally-derived mesenchyme separating the parietal bones. Although initially the parietal bones are formed entirely from paraxial mesoderm, the cellular composition gradually becomes chimeric and is populated mainly by neural crest-derived cells by N 30. This occurs as a consequence of osteoblastic differentiation at the dura mater interface and intravasation of neural crest-derived osteoclastic and other hematopoietic precursors. The isolated cells of the dura mater are multipotent in vitro, giving rise to osteoblasts, neuronal cells and other derivatives characteristic of cranial neural crest, possibly reflecting the multipotent nature of dura mater cells in vivo.     

Enzymatic activation associated with programmed fusion of the posterior interfrontal sutures in rats

Fetal rat coronal sutures in culture undergo fusion in the absence of their dura mater. Coinciding with the period of fusion are marked cellular enzymatic changes. Alkaline phosphatase, a marker of osteoblastic activity, and tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase (TRAP), a marker of osteoclastic activity, both increase significantly within fusing sutures and indicate changes in the control of bone synthesis and breakdown. Other enzymes not specifically related to bone formation or degradation also show activation within these fusing sutures. These enzymes include tartrate-sensitive acid phosphatase (TSAP), a marker of lysosomal activity; hexokinase, a glycolytic enzyme; glucose 6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PD), an enzyme of the pentose monophosphate shunt; and glutathione reductase, an enzyme of the antioxidant pathway.In the present study, we compared the enzymatic changes previously seen ex vivo with those occurring in vivo during the programmed closure of the posterior interfrontal suture of the rat. This suture fuses between postnatal days 10 and 30 in the rat. The sagittal suture, which remains patent during this period, was used to establish baseline enzymatic activities in a comparable midline suture. Neonatal rats were killed at postnatal days 2, 4, 5, 8, 10, 12, 15, 20, and 30, and posterior interfrontal and sagittal sutures with bone plates on either side were removed. The suture regions of the samples were isolated, dura mater was removed, and suture regions were assayed by microanalytical techniques. Activities of alkaline phosphatase, TRAP, TSAP, hexokinase, G6PD, and glutathione reductase were measured. DNA content was also assayed, and enzyme activities were expressed per amount of DNA. Three pups were killed at each time point, and three to five assays were performed per suture (posterior interfrontal or sagittal) for each time point assayed.Alkaline phosphatase and TRAP activities showed marked increases in fusing sutures compared with nonfusing controls, similar to the increases demonstrated ex vivo. TSAP and hexokinase also showed elevations in the fusing posterior interfrontal sutures, with the greatest differences predominantly during the period of fusion, comparable to the changes seen ex vivo. However, G6PD and glutathione reductase, enzymes of the antioxidant pathway, did not demonstrate the same degree of activation seen ex vivo in fusing sutures. In fact, the levels were actually higher in the patent sagittal samples for the majority of time points examined.Alkaline phosphatase and TRAP activity elevations indicated both osteoblastic and osteoclastic activation during fusion, as seen in the ex vivo phenomenon. TSAP and hexokinase increases also reflected activation in lysosomes and in cellular metabolism during fusion, paralleling the ex vivo situation. However, a less clear pattern of activation in the antioxidant pathway, in contrast to the pattern seen ex vivo, was present. These differences may reflect the different environments of sutures in vivo and ex vivo. Alternatively, oxidative stress may play a more central role in the pathologic process of induced suture fusion ex vivo than in programmed suture fusion in vivo.     

In vitro murine posterior frontal suture fate is age-dependent: implications for cranial suture biology

In CD-1 mice, the posterior frontal suture (analogous to the human metopic suture) fuses while all other cranial sutures remain patent. In an in vitro organ culture model, the authors previously demonstrated that posterior frontal sutures explanted immediately before the onset of suture fusion (at 25 days old) mimic in vivo physiologic fusion. In the first portion of this study, the authors defined how early in development the posterior frontal suture fuses in their tension-free, serum-free organ culture system by serially analyzing posterior frontal suture fusion from calvariae explanted at different stages of postnatal development. Their results revealed a divergence of suture fate leading to abnormal patency or physiologic fusion between the first and second weeks of life, respectively, despite viability and continued growth of the calvarial explants in vitro. From these data, the authors postulated that the gene expression patterns present in the suture complex at the time of explant may determine whether the posterior frontal suture fuses or remains patent in organ culture. Therefore, to elucidate potentially important differences in gene expression within this "window of opportunity," they performed a cDNA microarray analysis on 5-day-old and 15-day-old posterior frontal and sagittal whole suture complexes corresponding to the age ranges for unsuccessful (1 to 7 days old) and successful (14 to 21 days old) in vitro posterior frontal suture fusion. Overall, their microarray results reveal interesting differential expression patterns of candidate genes in different categories, including angiogenic cytokines and mechanosensitive genes potentially important in cranial suture biology.     

Development of cartilage in transplanted future coronal sutures

From fetal rat skulls, tissue containing the 19-day-old presumptive coronal suture was excised and transplanted onto the exposed dura mater of adult rats. Host animals were sacrificed after 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6 days. From the results of these experiments, the following conclusions can be drawn: (1) in all transplants chondrogenic activity occurred, resulting in the production of ectopic cartilage, and (2) cartilage development only starts on the cerebral side of the transplanted embryonic dura mater just beneath the area of the presumptive suture. Transplanted presumptive sutures of 21-day-old rats do not produce cartilage. The findings suggest that the suture undergoes a process of maturation. The existence of an osteogenesis-inhibiting mechanism, located in embryonic sutural tissue and being transmitted to the developing dura, is discussed.     

Dura mater secretes soluble heparin-binding factors required for cranial suture morphogenesis

Summary Cranial sutures play a critical role in calvarial morphogenesis, serving as bone growth centers during skull enlargement. Defective suture morphogenesis, resulting in premature osseous obliteration of sutures and their failure to function appropriately, causes severe craniofacial anomalies. Previously published data demonstrated osseous obliteration of coronal suturesin vitro in the absence of dura mater and the rescue of sutures from osseous obliteration in rudiments cocultured with dura mater on the opposite sides of 0.45-μm polycarbonate filters. With thisin vitro culture system, experiments were designed to examine the nature of the soluble signal secreted by dura mater, required for maintaining intact sutures. The signal remained active in conditioned medium produced from dura mater, which was capable of rescuing coronal sutures from osseous obliteration in calvaria cultured without dura mater. When conditioned medium was segregated into heparin-binding and non-heparin-binding fractions, the signal capable of maintaining intact coronal sutures cosegregated with the heparin-binding component and remained functional in the absence of the non-heparin-binding component of conditioned medium. Evidence indicates that soluble, heparin-binding factors secreted by the dura mater act as osteoinhibitory signals at the suture site.