The impact of elevated CO2 on plant-herbivore interactions: experimental evidence of moderating effects at the community level

Surprisingly little research has been published on the responses to elevated [CO₂] at the community level, where herbivores can select their preferred food. We investigated the combined effects of atmospheric [CO₂] and herbivory on synthesised plant communities growing on soils of different fertility. Factorial combinations of two [CO₂] (350 or 700 l l⁻¹), two fertility (fertilised or non-fertilised), and two herbivory (herbivores present or absent) treatments were applied to a standard mixture of seven fast- and eight slow-growing plants in outdoor microcosms. The herbivores used were the grain aphid (Sitobion avenae) and the garden snail (Helix aspersa). We measured plant biomass, foliar nitrogen and soluble tannin concentration, aphid fecundity, and snail growth, fecundity, and feeding preferences over one growing season. Elevated [CO₂] did not have a significant impact on (1) the combined biomass of fast-growing or slow-growing plants, (2) herbivore feeding preferences, or (3) herbivore fitness. There was, however, a significant biomass increase of Carex flacca (which represented in all cases less than 5% of total live biomass), and some chemical changes in unpalatable plants under elevated [CO₂]. The herbivory treatment significantly increased the biomass of slow-growing plants over fast-growing plants, whereas fertilisation significantly increased the abundance of fast-growing plants over slow-growing plants. Predictions on the effects of elevated [CO₂] based on published single-species experiments were not supported by the results of this microcosm study. Received: 30 November 1997 / Accepted: 24 July 1998     

Interactive effects of pre-industrial, current and future [CO2] and temperature on an insect herbivore of Eucalyptus

Both atmospheric [CO₂] and average surface temperatures are predicted to increase with potentially different, additive or opposing, effects on leaf quality and insect herbivore activity. Few studies have directly measured the interactive effects of concurrent changes in [CO₂] and temperature on insect herbivores. None have done so over the entire developmental period of a tree-feeding insect, and none have compared responses to low pre-industrial [CO₂] and present day [CO₂] to estimate responses to future increases. Eucalypt herbivores may be particularly sensitive to climate-driven shifts in plant chemistry, as eucalypt foliage is naturally low in [N]. In this study, we assessed the development of the eucalypt herbivore Doratifera quadriguttata exposed concurrently to variable [CO₂] (290, 400, 650 μmol mol^?1) and temperature (ambient, ambient +4 °C) on glasshouse-grown Eucalyptus tereticornis. Overall, insects performed best on foliage grown at pre-industrial [CO₂], indicating that modern insect herbivores have already experienced nutritional shifts since industrialisation. Rising [CO₂] increased specific leaf mass and leaf carbohydrate concentration, subsequently reducing leaf [N]. Lower leaf [N] induced compensatory feeding and impeded insect performance, particularly by prolonging larval development. Importantly, elevated temperature dampened the negative effects of rising [CO₂] on larval performance. Therefore, rising [CO₂] over the past 200 years may have reduced forage quality for eucalypt insects, but concurrent temperature increases may have partially compensated for this, and may continue to do so in the future. These results highlight the importance of assessing plant–insect interactions within the context of multiple climate-change factors because of the interactive and potentially opposing effects of different factors within and between trophic levels.     

The impact of recent increases in atmospheric CO2 on biomass production and vegetative retention of Cheatgrass (Bromus tectorum): implications for fire disturbance

Cheatgrass (Bromus tectorum) is a recognized, invasive annual weed of the western United States that reduces fire return times from decades to less than 5 years. To determine the interaction between rising carbon dioxide concentration ([CO₂]) and fuel load, we characterized potential changes in biomass accumulation, C : N ratio and digestibility of three cheatgrass populations from different elevations to recent and near‐term projections in atmospheric [CO₂]. The experimental CO₂ values (270, 320, 370, 420 μmol mol^?1) corresponded roughly to the CO₂ concentrations that existed at the beginning of the 19th century, that during the 1960s, the current [CO₂], and the near‐term [CO₂] projection for 2020, respectively. From 25 until 87 days after sowing (DAS), aboveground biomass for these different populations increased 1.5–2.7 g per plant for every 10 μmol mol^?1 increase above the 270 μmol mol^?1 preindustrial baseline. CO₂ sensitivity among populations varied with elevational origin with populations from the lowest elevation showing the greatest productivity. Among all populations, the undigestible portion of aboveground plant material (acid detergent fiber ADF, mostly cellulose and lignin) increased with increasing [CO₂]. In addition, the ratio of C : N increased with leaf age, with [CO₂] and was highest for the lower elevational population. These CO₂‐induced qualitative changes could, in turn, result in potential decreases in herbivory and decomposition with subsequent effects on the aboveground retention of cheatgrass biomass. Overall, these data suggest that increasing atmospheric [CO₂] above preambient levels may have contributed significantly to cheatgrass productivity and fuel load with subsequent effects on fire frequency and intensity.     

The impact of elevated carbon dioxide on the growth and gas exchange of three C4 species differing in CO2 leak rates

Recent work has suggested that the photosynthetic rate of certain C₄ species can be stimulated by increasing CO₂ concentration, [CO₂], even under optimal water and nutrients. To determine the basis for the observed photosynthetic stimulation, we tested the hypothesis that the CO₂ leak rate from the bundle sheath would be directly related to any observed stimulation in single leaf photosynthesis at double the current [CO₂]. Three C₄ species that differed in the reported degree of bundle sheath leakiness to CO₂, Flaveria trinervia, Panicum miliaceum, and Panicum maximum, were grown for 31–48 days after sowing at a [CO₂] of 350 μl l^?1 (ambient) or 700 μl l^?1 (elevated). Assimilation as a function of increasing [CO₂] at high photosynthetic photon flux density (PPFD, 1 600 μmol m^?2 s^?1) indicated that leaf photosynthesis was not saturated under current ambient [CO₂] for any of the three C₄ species. Assimilation as a function of increasing PPFD also indicated that the response of leaf photosynthesis to elevated [CO₂] was light dependent for all three C₄ species. The stimulation of leaf photosynthesis at elevated [CO₂] was not associated with previously published values of CO₂ leak rates from the bundle sheath, changes in the ratio of activities of PEP-carboxylase to RuBP carboxylase/oxgenase, or any improvement in daytime leaf water potential for the species tested in this experiment. In spite of the simulation of leaf photosynthesis, a significant increase in growth at elevated [CO₂] was only observed for one species, F. trinervia. Results from this study indicate that leaf photosynthetic rates of certain C₄ species can respond directly to increased [CO₂] under optimal growth conditions, but that the stimulation of whole plant growth at elevated carbon dioxide cannot be predicted solely on the response of individual leaves.     

The impact of elevated CO2 on yield loss from a C3 and C4 weed in field-grown soybean

Soybean (Glycine max) was grown at ambient and enhanced carbon dioxide (CO₂, + 250 μL L^?1 above ambient) with and without the presence of a C3 weed (lambsquarters, Chenopodium album L.) and a C4 weed (redroot pigweed, Amaranthus retroflexus L.), in order to evaluate the impact of rising atmospheric carbon dioxide concentration [CO₂] on crop production losses due to weeds. Weeds of a given species were sown at a density of two per metre of row. A significant reduction in soybean seed yield was observed with either weed species relative to the weed‐free control at either [CO₂]. However, for lambsquarters the reduction in soybean seed yield relative to the weed‐free condition increased from 28 to 39% as CO₂ increased, with a 65% increase in the average dry weight of lambsquarters at enhanced [CO₂]. Conversely, for pigweed, soybean seed yield losses diminished with increasing [CO₂] from 45 to 30%, with no change in the average dry weight of pigweed. In a weed‐free environment, elevated [CO₂] resulted in a significant increase in vegetative dry weight and seed yield at maturity for soybean (33 and 24%, respectively) compared to the ambient CO₂ condition. Interestingly, the presence of either weed negated the ability of soybean to respond either vegetatively or reproductively to enhanced [CO₂]. Results from this experiment suggest: (i) that rising [CO₂] could alter current yield losses associated with competition from weeds; and (ii) that weed control will be crucial in realizing any potential increase in economic yield of agronomic crops such as soybean as atmospheric [CO₂] increases.     

Interactive direct and plant‐mediated effects of elevated atmospheric [CO2] and temperature on a eucalypt‐feeding insect herbivore

Understanding the direct and indirect effects of elevated [CO₂] and temperature on insect herbivores and how these factors interact are essential to predict ecosystem‐level responses to climate change scenarios. In three concurrent glasshouse experiments, we measured both the individual and interactive effects of elevated [CO₂] and temperature on foliar quality. We also assessed the interactions between their direct and plant‐mediated effects on the development of an insect herbivore of eucalypts. Eucalyptus tereticornis saplings were grown at ambient or elevated [CO₂] (400 and 650 μmol mol^?1 respectively) and ambient or elevated ( + 4 °C) temperature for 10 months. Doratifera quadriguttata (Lepidoptera: Limacodidae) larvae were feeding directly on these trees, on their excised leaves in a separate glasshouse, or on excised field‐grown leaves within the temperature and [CO₂] controlled glasshouse. To allow insect gender to be determined and to ensure that any sex‐specific developmental differences could be distinguished from treatment effects, insect development time and consumption were measured from egg hatch to pupation. No direct [CO₂] effects on insects were observed. Elevated temperature accelerated larval development, but did not affect leaf consumption. Elevated [CO₂] and temperature independently reduced foliar quality, slowing larval development and increasing consumption. Simultaneously increasing both [CO₂] and temperature reduced these shifts in foliar quality, and negative effects on larval performance were subsequently ameliorated. Negative nutritional effects of elevated [CO₂] and temperature were also independently outweighed by the direct positive effect of elevated temperature on larvae. Rising [CO₂] and temperature are thus predicted to have interactive effects on foliar quality that affect eucalypt‐feeding insects. However, the ecological consequences of these interactions will depend on the magnitude of concurrent temperature rise and its direct effects on insect physiology and feeding behaviour.     

New insights into the cellular mechanisms of plant growth at elevated atmospheric carbon dioxide concentrations

Rising atmospheric carbon dioxide concentration ([CO₂]) significantly influences plant growth, development, and biomass. Increased photosynthesis rate, together with lower stomatal conductance, has been identified as the key factors that stimulate plant growth at elevated [CO₂] (e[CO₂]). However, variations in photosynthesis and stomatal conductance alone cannot fully explain the dynamic changes in plant growth. Stimulation of photosynthesis at e[CO₂] is always associated with post‐photosynthetic secondary metabolic processes that include carbon and nitrogen metabolism, cell cycle functions, and hormonal regulation. Most studies have focused on photosynthesis and stomatal conductance in response to e[CO₂], despite the emerging evidence of e[CO₂]'s role in moderating secondary metabolism in plants. In this review, we briefly discuss the effects of e[CO₂] on photosynthesis and stomatal conductance and then focus on the changes in other cellular mechanisms and growth processes at e[CO₂] in relation to plant growth and development. Finally, knowledge gaps in understanding plant growth responses to e[CO₂] have been identified with the aim of improving crop productivity under a CO₂ rich atmosphere.     

Canopy warming caused photosynthetic acclimation and reduced seed yield in maize grown at ambient and elevated [CO2]

Rising atmospheric CO₂ concentration ([CO₂]) and attendant increases in growing season temperature are expected to be the most important global change factors impacting production agriculture. Although maize is the most highly produced crop worldwide, few studies have evaluated the interactive effects of elevated [CO₂] and temperature on its photosynthetic physiology, agronomic traits or biomass, and seed yield under open field conditions. This study investigates the effects of rising [CO₂] and warmer temperature, independently and in combination, on maize grown in the field throughout a full growing season. Free‐air CO₂ enrichment (FACE) technology was used to target atmospheric [CO₂] to 200 μmol mol^?1 above ambient [CO₂] and infrared heaters to target a plant canopy increase of 3.5 °C, with actual season mean heating of ~2.7 °C, mimicking conditions predicted by the second half of this century. Photosynthetic gas‐exchange parameters, leaf nitrogen and carbon content, leaf water potential components, and developmental measurements were collected throughout the season, and biomass and yield were measured at the end of the growing season. As predicted for a C₄ plant, elevated [CO₂] did not stimulate photosynthesis, biomass, or yield. Canopy warming caused a large shift in aboveground allocation by stimulating season‐long vegetative biomass and decreasing reproductive biomass accumulation at both CO₂ concentrations, resulting in decreased harvest index. Warming caused a reduction in photosynthesis due to down‐regulation of photosynthetic biochemical parameters and the decrease in the electron transport rate. The reduction in seed yield with warming was driven by reduced photosynthetic capacity and by a shift in aboveground carbon allocation away from reproduction. This field study portends that future warming will reduce yield in maize, and this will not be mitigated by higher atmospheric [CO₂] unless appropriate adaptation traits can be introduced into future cultivars.     

Stomatal density and aperture length in four plant species grown across a subambient CO2 gradient

Stomatal density, stomatal aperture length, area/leaf, and number of stomata/leaf were measured after the annual C₃ agronomic grasses oats (Avena sativa) and wheat (Triticum aestivum), the C, woody legume honey mesquite (Prosopis glandulosa), and the perennial C₄ grass little bluestem (Schizachyrium scoparium) were grown across a subambient carbon dioxide concentration ([CO₂]) gradient from near 200 to 350 μmol/mol in a growth chamber. The purpose was to determine if the size and density of stomata vary in response to atmospheric [CO₂] during growth, across a subambient [CO₂] range representative of the doubling that has occurred since the last ice age. Changes in stomatal density and aperture length with increasing [CO₂] were small when detected. Stomatal density decreased on adaxial flag leaf surfaces of wheat, and aperture length increased slightly with [CO₂], Leaf area and number of stomata/flag leaf increased by similar proportions with [CO₂] in two wheat cultivars. No consistent relationship between [CO₂] and stomatal density or size was detected in mesquite, oats, or little bluestem. We conclude that individual plants of these species lack the plasticity to significantly alter stomatal density and aperture length in response to increasing atmospheric [CO₂] in a single generation (annuals) or growing season (perennials).     

Low soil temperature inhibits the stimulatory effect of elevated [CO2] on height and biomass accumulation of white birch seedlings grown under three non‐limiting phosphorus conditions

White birch (Betula papyrifera Marsh.) seedlings were exposed to ambient or doubled ambient carbon dioxide concentration ([CO₂]), three soil temperatures (T_soil) (low, intermediate, high), and three phosphorus (P) regimes (low, medium, high) in environment‐controlled greenhouses. Height (H), root‐collar diameter (RCD), biomass, and leaf phosphorus concentration (leaf P) were determined four months after initiation of treatments. The low T_soil reduced H, RCD, shoot biomass, root biomass and total seedling biomass whereas the high‐P level and the [CO₂] elevation increased all the growth and biomass parameters. Elevated [CO₂] significantly reduced leaf P. There were significant two‐factor interactions suggesting that the effect of elevated [CO₂] on (1) H, total biomass, biomass of plant components, and leaf P was dependent on T_soil, (2) total biomass was contingent on P regime. For instance, the positive response of H and total biomass to elevated [CO₂] was limited to seedlings raised under the intermediate and high T_soil, respectively. In addition, [CO₂] elevation increased total biomass only at the high‐P regime but not at the low‐ or medium‐P level where the effect of [CO₂] was statistically insignificant. No significant main effect of treatment or interaction was observed for root to shoot biomass ratio.     

Regulation of hormonal responses of sweet pepper as affected by salinity and elevated CO2 concentration

This study examines the extent to which the predicted CO₂‐protective effects on the inhibition of growth, impairment of photosynthesis and nutrient imbalance caused by saline stress are mediated by an effective adaptation of the endogenous plant hormonal balance. Therefore, sweet pepper plants (Capsicum annuum, cv. Ciclón) were grown at ambient or elevated [CO₂] (400 or 800 µmol mol^–1) with a nutrient solution containing 0 or 80 mM NaCl. The results show that, under saline conditions, elevated [CO₂] increased plant dry weight, leaf area, leaf relative water content and net photosynthesis compared with ambient [CO₂], whilst the maximum potential quantum efficiency of photosystem II was not modified. In salt‐stressed plants, elevated [CO₂] increased leaf NO₃^– concentration and reduced Cl^– concentration. Salinity stress induced ABA accumulation in the leaves but it was reduced in the roots at high [CO₂], being correlated with the stomatal response. Under non‐stressed conditions, IAA was dramatically reduced in the roots when high [CO₂] was applied, which resulted in greater root DW and root respiration. Additionally, the observed high CK concentration in the roots (especially tZR) could prevent downregulation of photosynthesis at high [CO₂], as the N level in the leaves was increased compared with the ambient [CO₂], under salt‐stress conditions. These results demonstrate that the hormonal balance was altered by the [CO₂], which resulted in significant changes at the growth, gas exchange and nutritional levels.     

Influence of carbon dioxide enrichment, ozone and nitrogen fertilization on cotton (Gossypium hirsutum L.) leaf and root composition

The objective of this study was to test whether elevated [CO₂], [O₃] and nitrogen (N) fertility altered leaf mass per area (LMPA), non‐structural carbohydrate (TNC), N, lignin (LTGA) and proanthocyanidin (PA) concentrations in cotton (Gossypium hirsutum L.) leaves and roots. Cotton was grown in 14 dm³ pots with either sufficient (0·8 g N dm ^{? 3}) or deficient (0·4 and 0·2 g N dm ^{? 3}) N fertilization, and treated in open‐top chambers with either ambient or elevated ( + 175 and + 350 μ mol mol ^{? 1}) [CO₂] in combination with either charcoal‐filtered air (CF) or non‐filtered air plus 1·5 times ambient [O₃]. At about 50 d after planting, LMPA, starch and PA concentrations in canopy leaves were as much as 51–72% higher in plants treated with elevated [CO₂] compared with plants treated with ambient [CO₂], whereas leaf N concentration was 29% lower in elevated [CO₂]‐treated plants compared with controls. None of the treatments had a major effect on LTGA concentrations on a TNC‐free mass basis. LMPA and starch levels were up to 48% lower in plants treated with elevated [O₃] and ambient [CO₂] compared with CF controls, although the elevated [O₃] effect was diminished when plants were treated concurrently with elevated [CO₂]. On a total mass basis, leaf N and PA concentrations were higher in samples treated with elevated [O₃] in ambient [CO₂], but the difference was much reduced by elevated [CO₂]. On a TNC‐free basis, however, elevated [O₃] had little effect on tissue N and PA concentrations. Fertilization treatments resulted in higher PA and lower N concentrations in tissues from the deficient N fertility treatments. The experiment showed that suppression by elevated [O₃] of LMPA and starch was largely prevented by elevated [CO₂], and that interpretation of [CO₂] and [O₃] effects should include comparisons on a TNC‐free basis. Overall, the experiment indicated that allocation to starch and PA may be related to how environmental factors affect source–sink relationships in plants, although the effects of elevated [O₃] on secondary metabolites differed in this respect.     

Temporal dynamics and spatial variability in the enhancement of canopy leaf area under elevated atmospheric CO2

Increased canopy leaf area (L) may lead to higher forest productivity and alter processes such as species dynamics and ecosystem mass and energy fluxes. Few CO₂ enrichment studies have been conducted in closed canopy forests and none have shown a sustained enhancement of L. We reconstructed 8 years (1996–2003) of L at Duke's Free Air CO₂ Enrichment experiment to determine the effects of elevated atmospheric CO₂ concentration ([CO₂]) on L before and after canopy closure in a pine forest with a hardwood component, focusing on interactions with temporal variation in water availability and spatial variation in nitrogen (N) supply. The dynamics of L were reconstructed using data on leaf litterfall mass and specific leaf area for hardwoods, and needle litterfall mass and specific leaf area combined with needle elongation rates, and fascicle and shoot counts for pines. The dynamics of pine L production and senescence were unaffected by elevated [CO₂], although L senescence for hardwoods was slowed. Elevated [CO₂] enhanced pine L and the total canopy L (combined pine and hardwood species; P<0.050); on average, enhancement following canopy closure was ～16% and 14% respectively. However, variation in pine L and its response to elevated [CO₂] was not random. Each year pine L under ambient and elevated [CO₂] was spatially correlated to the variability in site nitrogen availability (e.g. r²=0.94 and 0.87 in 2001, when L was highest before declining due to droughts and storms), with the [CO₂]‐induced enhancement increasing with N (P=0.061). Incorporating data on N beyond the range of native fertility, achieved through N fertilization, indicated that pine L had reached the site maximum under elevated [CO₂] where native N was highest. Thus closed canopy pine forests may be able to increase leaf area under elevated [CO₂] in moderate fertility sites, but are unable to respond to [CO₂] in both infertile sites (insufficient resources) and sites having high levels of fertility (maximum utilization of resources). The total canopy L, representing the combined L of pine and hardwood species, was constant across the N gradient under both ambient and elevated [CO₂], generating a constant enhancement of canopy L. Thus, in mixed species stands, L of canopy hardwoods which developed on lower fertility sites (～3 g N inputs m^?2 yr^?1) may be sufficiently enhanced under elevated [CO₂] to compensate for the lack of response in pine L, and generate an appreciable response of total canopy L (～14%).     

Effects of daytime carbon dioxide concentration on dark respiration in rice

Rising atmospheric carbon dioxide concentration ([CO₂]) has generated considerable interest in the response of agricultural crops to [CO₂]. The objectives of this study were to determine the effects of a wide range of daytime [CO₂] on dark respiration of rice (Oryza sativa L. cv. IR-30). Rice plants were grown season-long in naturally sunlit plant growth chambers in subambient (160 and 250), ambient (330), or super-ambient (500, 660 and 900 μmol CO₂ mol^?1 air) [CO₂] treatments. Canopy dark respiration, expressed on a ground area basis (R_d) increased with increasing [CO₂] treatment from 160 to 500 μmol mol^?1 treatments and was very similar among the superambient treatments. The trends in R_d over time and in response to increasing daytime [CO₂] treatment were associated with and similar to trends previously described for photosynthesis. Specific respiration rate (R_dw) decreased with time during the growing season and was higher in the subambient than the ambient and superambient [CO₂] treatments. This greater R_dw in the subambient [CO₂] treatments was attributed to a higher specific maintenance respiration rate and was associated with higher plant tissue nitrogen concentration.     

HIGH CARBON DIOXIDE CONCENTRATIONS IN AERENCHYMA OF TYPHA LATIFOLIA

Diurnal and seasonal patterns of CO₂ concentration ([CO₂]) in leaf gas spaces were measured to better understand the relationship of sediment-derived CO₂ to photosynthesis in the emergent wetland species, Typha latifolia L. (cattail). Leaf [CO₂] was above 2,000 μl/liter at dawn on all but the first sampling date. At all sampling dates, leaf [CO₂] declined to near atmospheric [CO₂] at midday and rose to well above atmospheric [CO₂] in the late afternoon. The maximum leaf [CO₂] varied with sampling date and was over 18 times atmospheric levels (over 6,300 μl/liter) in August. Based on measurement of photon flux density and temperature, the diurnal pattern in leaf [CO₂] may be generally controlled by expected photosynthetic rates. It is hypothesized that seasonal variation in leaf [CO₂] may be a function of variation in microbial (soil) respiration. Using dye and slight pressurization, it was confirmed that gas spaces in rhizomes were interconnected with the gas spaces in leaves through the rhizome-shoot transition. From anatomical measurements, it was also estimated that over 50% of total leaf volume was occupied by gas spaces and that most of the total gas-space volume in plants was in the shoot. Photosynthetic rate in C3 plants, like cattail, can increase with increasing [CO₂] under natural conditions. For this reason, cattail and other emergent wetland plants possessing continuous gas-space pathways appear to have a significant carbon supplement as compared to other C3 plants growing in well-aerated soils.     

Constitutive and herbivore-inducible glucosinolate concentrations in oilseed rape (Brassica napus) leaves are not affected by Bt Cry1Ac insertion but change under elevated atmospheric CO2 and O3

Glucosinolates are plant secondary compounds involved in direct chemical defence by cruciferous plants against herbivores. The glucosinolate profile can be affected by abiotic and biotic environmental stimuli. We studied changes in glucosinolate patterns in leaves of non-transgenic oilseed rape (Brassica napus ssp. oleifera) under elevated atmospheric CO₂ or ozone (O₃) concentrations and compared them with those from transgenic for herbivore-resistance (Bacillus thuringiensis Cry1Ac endotoxin), to assess herbivory dynamics. Both elevated CO₂ and O₃ levels decreased indolic glucosinolate concentrations in transgenic and non-transgenic lines, whereas O₃ specifically increased the concentration of an aromatic glucosinolate, 2-phenylethylglucosinolate. The herbivore-inducible indolic glucosinolate response was reduced in elevated O₃ whereas elevated CO₂ altered the induction dynamics of indolic and aliphatic glucosinolates. Herbivore-resistant Bt plants experienced minimal leaf damage after target herbivore Plutella xylostella feeding, but exhibited comparatively similar increase in glucosinolate concentrations after herbivory as non-transgenic plants, indicating that the endogenous glucosinolate defence was not severely compromised by transgenic modifications. The observed differences in constitutive and inducible glucosinolate concentrations of oilseed rape under elevated atmospheric CO₂ and O₃ might have implications for plant–herbivore interactions in Brassica crop-ecosystems in future climate scenarios.     

Acclimation of photosynthesis to elevated CO2 and temperature in five British native species of contrasting functional type

Acclimation of photosynthesis to growth at elevated CO₂ concentration varies markedly between species. Species functionally classified as stress-tolerators (S) and ruderals (R), are thought to be incapable, or the least capable, of responding positively in terms of growth to elevated [CO₂]. Is this pattern of response also apparent in leaf photosynthesis of wild S- and R-strategists? Acclimatory loss of a photosynthetic and growth response to elevated [CO₂] is assumed to reflect limitation on capacity to utilize additional photosynthate. The doubling of pre-industrial global [CO₂] is expected to coincide with a 3 °C increase in mean temperature which could stimulate growth; will photosynthetic capacity at elevated [CO₂] be greater when the concurrent temperature increase is simulated? Five species from natural grassland of NW Europe and of contrasting ecological strategy were grown in hemispherical greenhouses, environmentally controlled to track the external microclimate. Within a replicated design, plants were grown at (i) current ambient [CO₂] and temperature, (ii) elevated [CO₂] (ambient + 340 μmol mol^–1) and ambient temperature, (iii) ambient [CO₂] and elevated temperature (ambient + 3 °C), or (iv) elevated [CO₂] and elevated temperature. After 75–104 days, the CO₂ response of light-saturated rates of photosynthesis (A_sat) was analysed in controlled-environment cuvettes in a field laboratory. There was no acclimatory loss of photosynthetic capacity with growth in elevated [CO₂] or elevated temperature over this period in Poa alpina (S), Bellis perennis (R) or Plantago lanceolata (mixed C-S-R strategist), and a significant (P ? ? bl 0.05) increase in capacity in Helianthemum nummularium (S) and Poa annua (R). Photosynthetic rates of leaves grown and measured in elevated [CO₂] were therefore significantly higher than rates for leaves grown and measured in ambient [CO₂], for all species. With the exception of Poa alpina, stomatal conductance and stomatal limitation on A_sat showed no acclimatory response to growth in elevated [CO₂]. Carboxylation efficiency, determined from the initial slope of the response of A_sat to intercellular CO₂ concentration was significantly increased by elevated [CO₂] and elevated temperature in H.nummularium, implying a possible increase in in vivo RubisCO activity. Increased carboxylation efficiency of this species was also reflected by an increase in the CO₂- and light-saturated rates of photosynthesis, indicating an increased capacity for regeneration of the primary CO₂ acceptor in photosynthesis. The results show that R-strategists and slow-growing S-strategists, are inherently capable of large increases in leaf photosynthetic capacity with growth in elevated [CO₂] in contrast to expectations from growth studies. With the exception of P.annua, where there was a significant negative interaction between CO₂ and temperature, concurrent increase in growth temperature had little effect on this pattern of response.     

Responses of leaf nitrogen concentration and specific leaf area to atmospheric CO2 enrichment: a retrospective synthesis across 62 species

Knowledge of leaf responses to elevated atmospheric [CO₂] (CO₂ concentration) is integral to understanding interactions between vegetation and global change. This work deals with responses of leaf mass‐based nitrogen concentration (N_m) and specific leaf area (SLA). It assesses the statistical significance of factors perceived as influential on the responses, and quantifies how the responses vary with the significant factors identified, based on 170 data cases of 62 species compiled from the literature. Resultant equations capture about 41% of the variance in the data for percent responses of N_m and SLA, or about 95% of the variance for N_m and SLA at 57–320% normal [CO₂]; these performance statistics also hold for leaf area‐based N concentration and specific leaf weight. The equations generalize that: (i) both N_m and SLA decline as [CO₂] increases; (ii) proportional decline of N_m is greater with deciduous woody species and with plants of normally low N_m, increases with pot size in growth chamber and greenhouse settings and with temperature and photosynthetic photon flux density (PPFD), and is mitigated by N fertilization; and (iii) proportional decline of SLA depends on pot size and PPFD similarly to N_m, increases with leaf life span and water vapour pressure deficit in enclosed experiments, and decreases with prolonged exposure to elevated [CO₂] among broadleaf woody species in field conditions. The results highlight great uncertainty in the percent‐response data and reveal the potential feasibility to estimate N_m and SLA at various magnitudes of elevated [CO₂] from a few key plant and environmental factors of broad data bases.