The antimetastatic function of concomitant antitumor immunity. I. Host Ly-1+2+ effector T cells prevent the enumeration of metastatic tumor cells in a biological assay

A mouse survival assay was evaluated for its suitability to enumerate metastatic P815 tumor cells in the draining lymph node and spleen of a B6D2 F1 (H-2b X H-2d) host bearing a primary intradermal P815 tumor. The mouse survival assay is based on the linear relationship between the log10 number of P815 tumor cells (H-2d) injected i.p. into mice and their mean survival time. It was found that the assay is capable of quantifying as few as 10 tumor cells in lymph node and spleen, but only if cell suspensions of these organs are treated with anti-H-2b serum and complement, in order to selectively destroy H-2bd host cells. This was necessary because host cells from the lymph node and spleen of a tumor-bearing host possessed antitumor functions, in that they were capable of destroying the H-2d P815 tumor cells when admixed with the tumor cells and injected i.p. into 800-rad irradiated test recipients. The kinetics of acquisition and loss of host cells with antitumor function and the Ly phenotype of these host cells suggest that they are the same cells that give the tumor-bearing host the capacity to express concomitant immunity against a tumor implant.     

Tumor bearer T cells suppress BCG-potentiated antitumor responses. I. Requirements for their effect

Mice bearing established syngeneic tumors fail to reject them when immunized according to protocols based on optimal conditions for BCG potentiation of specific delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) and antitumor immunity. Serum factors from mice bearing either the poorly immunogenic mastocytoma, P815 (MA), or the more antigenic sarcoma, Meth A, have been shown to depress both DTH and antitumor immunity. This report demonstrates that lymphoid cells adoptively transferred from these tumor-bearing hosts also can suppress the efferent and afferent phases of DTH to tumor-specific antigens in both BCG-primed and unprimed syngeneic hosts. Suppressor cells (SC) were detected in spleen, thymus, and lymph nodes draining the tumor site, but not in distant superficial lymph nodes. Maximal suppressor activity apeared 6 days after tumor implantation and waned by 18 days. Suppression of the afferent phase of both the BCG-primed and unprimed responses was antigen specific; suppression of the efferent phase of the BCG-primed response was also specific but SC could partially suppress the unprimed responses to sheep red blood cells (SRBC). Amputation of 6-day-old tumors resulted in the disappearance of splenic SC within 2 days but did not affect SC in draining lymph nodes. SC suppressed DTH in a dose-dependent manner but even the highest doses tested did not totally eliminate the response. Depression of the peak DTH reaction was not accompanied by significant abrogation of antitumor activity. If, however, SC were transferred during the ongoing antitumor response, immunity was partially suppressed. Efferentphase SC were sensitive to treatment with anti-Thy 1 sera and complement but were unaffected by B-cell depletion.     

T and B lymphocyte migration into syngeneic tumors.

The migration of splenic T and B lymphocytes into syngeneic tumors undergoing immunologic rejection was investigates. Spleen cells were obtained from normal BALC/c mice or BALB/c mice bearing tumors induced by murine sarcoma virus (MSV). Either whole spleen cells or immunoabsorbent purified T and B cells were radiolabeled with sodium chromate-51 and injected i.v. into normal or MSV inducted-tumor bearing syngeneic recipients. Twenty-four hours later the recipient mice were sacrificed and radioactivity was assessed for tumor, contralateral normal muscle, the lymph nodes draining the tumor and contralateral draining lymph nodes, peripheral lymph nodes, spleen, and liver. Both T and B lymphocytes from either normal or MSV tumor-bearing animals show greatly increased migration into the tumor when compared with normal muscle. Migration of T cells from both normal and MSV tumor bearers was 30 times that of migration to normal muscle. B cells from tumor-bearing mice, on the other hand, localized in the tumor itself only 50% as frequently as did B cells from normal animals. In addition, T cells from MSV tumor bearers were found in the highest proportion in the lymph node draining the tumor site. We conclude that T and B lymphocytes from either normal or tumor-bearing mice migrate to a syngeneic tumor undergoing immunologic rejection. In contrast, the migration of both T and B cells from tumor-bearing animals was decreased to the peripheral lymph nodes at the time of maximum tumor growth.     

Characterization of suppressor cells in mice bearing syngeneic mastocytoma.

Suppressor cells from syngeneic P815 mastocytoma-bearing DBA/2 mice that inhibit in vitro generation of specific anti-tumor cytotoxicity were characterized. Suppressive activity was almost completely eliminated by treating suppressive spleen cells with anti-theta serum and complement. Treatment with anti-mouse lg serum and complement or with carbonyl iron did not affect their suppressive activity. When suppressive thymocytes from P815 tumor-bearing DBA/2 mice were tested for their capacity to inhibit the generation of cytotoxicity against L1210 cells, a leukemia line in DBa/2 mice, they did not affect the activity, indicating that the supressor cells in the thymocytes of P815 tumor-bearing mice are specific to the tumor. When Ficoll-Hypaque density cell separation was carried out with cytotoxic spleen cells and suppressive spleen cells from 815 tumor-bearing mice, the dense fraction was enriched for kiler cells whereas the suppressive activitty was mainly recovered in the light fraction. Therefore, killer cells and suppressor cells in P815 tumor-bearing mice are thought to be distinct populations.     

The generation of tumor-specific in vivo protective immunity in the tumor mass from mice rendered tolerant to tumor antigens

Summary C3H/He mice were inoculated i.v. with 10⁶ heavily X-irradiated syngeneic X5563 plasmacytoma cells 3 times at 4 day intervals. When these mice received an appropriate immunization procedure consisting of i. d. inoculation of viable tumor cells plus the surgical resection of the tumor which enables i.v. nonpresensitized mice to produce anti-X5563 immunity, they failed to develop tumor-specific immunity. This was demonstrated by the abrogation in potential of spleen and lymph node cells to generate in vivo protective immunity. In contrast, the tumor mass from X5563 tumor-bearing mice which had received the i.v. presensitization contained comparable anti-X5563 tumor neutralizing activity to that obtained from the tumor mass from nonpresensitized, X5563 tumor-bearing mice. Such an in vivo protective immunity was revealed to be mediated by tumor-specific T cells. These results demonstrate the differential generation and antitumor capability of tumor infiltrating T cells and T cells in lymphoid organs from mice which are in the tumor-specific tolerant state. The results are discussed in the context of potential utilization of tumor infiltrating in vivo protective T cells to enhance the local tumor-specific immunity in tumor-specific tolerant mice.This work was supported by Special Project Research-Cancer Bioscience from the Ministry of Education, Science and Culture     

Altered lymphocyte functions in rats bearing syngeneic Moloney sarcoma tumors. I. Mitogen responses, mixed lymphocyte reactions (MLR) and mixed lymphocyte-tumor reactions (MLTR).

Impairment of mitogen responses to Con A and LPS and of MLR and MLTR was detected in the spleens of rats bearing syngeneic Moloney sarcoma tumors. Depressed responses of both T cell and Ig+ cell populations were observed. During the observation period of 6 to 10 days post-tumor inoculation when maximal T cell-mediated cytotoxicity was observed in spleen and draining lymph node cells, spleen cells showed marked impairment in response to stimuli mentioned above. By contrast, draining lymph node cell activity was either unaltered or somewhat elevated above the level of activity measured in normal control populations. Data presented in this and an accompanying paper strongly indicate that macrophages are activated as immunosuppressor cells in tumor-bearing rats.     

In situ lymphoid cells of mouse mammary tumors. IV. Comparison of functional activity of lymphoid cells separated from mammary tumors to that of spleen and lymph node cells of tumor-sensitized mice.

Lymphoid cells isolated form several types of mouse mammary tumors are capable of stimulating tumor cell growth or survival in MCT assays. Lymph node and spleen cells of mice bearing such a tumor are specifically cytotoxic to the tumor cells. Surgical removal of the tumor is followed in 4 to 7 days by the appearance of stimulatory capacity in spleens and lymph nodes. By day 10, cytotoxic cells specific for the sensitizing tumor are again detected. These reach a peak on day 13. By day 17 no reactivity is detectable. The functional distribution of tumor-reactive lymphoid cells is different between tumor masses and peripheral lymphoid organs.     

Intracamerally induced concomitant immunity: mice harboring progressively growing intraocular tumors are immune to spontaneous metastases and secondary tumor challenge

Intracameral inoculation of allogeneic P815 mastocytoma cells (DBA/2) into BALB/c mice resulted in progressively growing intraocular tumors. Intraocular tumor cells disseminated rapidly to the spleen and cervical lymph nodes, yet extraocular nests of tumor cells never developed into fulminant tumors. Further experiments showed that tumor cells were continuously seeded from the primary intraocular tumor and were rapidly cleared from extraocular sites. Hosts harboring intraocular P815 mastocytomas rejected tumorigenic doses of P815 cells inoculated subcutaneously or even into the contralateral anterior chamber. This systemic tumor immunity was found to be radiosensitive and T cell dependent. Spleen cells from animals with progressively growing intraocular tumors protected recipient mice challenged with intracamerally inoculated tumor cells and thus suggests that a cell-mediated mechanism is the underlying basis for this form of tumor immunity. The data indicate that mice harboring progressively growing intraocular tumors develop a potent state of "concomitant immunity," that prevents the development of metastases, yet is ineffective in controlling the primary tumor.     

Local injections of OK432 can help the infiltration of adoptively transferred CD8+ T cells into the tumor sites and synergistically induce the local production of Th1-type cytokines and CXC3 chemokines

The effect of local injections with streptococcal preparation OK432 on the antitumor effect induced by adoptive immunotherapy (AIT) was investigated. Draining lymph node cells on day 14 after B7-P815 inoculation were used for AIT after in vitro stimulation. AIT on days 7 and 10 showed no effect on the growth of s.c. established P815 mastocytoma, but local injections with OK432 into the tumor sites on days 3, 6 and 9 resulted in a moderate antitumor effect. On the other hand, the combination therapy significantly suppressed tumor growth, and the tumor-bearing mice survived longer than those receiving only one of the treatment modalities. The significant infiltration of CD4⁺ or CD8⁺ T cells and multiple necrosis in the tumor sites were observed only when the tumor-bearing mice were treated with the combination therapy. In addition, a transfer experiment using labeled effector cells revealed these infiltrated CD8⁺ T cells and CD4⁺ T cells to be derived from the donor and the host respectively. More importantly, the combination therapy clearly led to higher expression of the mRNA for Th1-type cytokines and CXC3 chemokines in the tumor sites than resulted from each of the treatment modalities alone. Collectively, these results indicate that local injections with OK432 can help the infiltration of adoptively transferred CD8⁺ T cells into the tumor sites and synergistically induce the local production of the Th1-type cytokines and CXC3 chemokines. Received: 3 April 2000 / Accepted: 5 May 2000     

Contact sensitivity to picryl chloride: the occurrence of B suppressor cells in the lymph nodes and spleen of immunized mice.

Mice were immunized for contact sensitivity and antibody production by painting the skin with picryl chloride. Lymph node and spleen cells taken 4 days later transferred contact sensitivity. However, cells taken at 7–8 days failed to transfer but were able to block the transfer by 4 day immune cells. These suppressor cells occurred in the regional lymph nodes, spleen and thymus. The suppressor activity of lymph node and spleen cells was due to B cells as shown by the effect of anti-θ serum and complement, nylon wool filtration and separation of EAC positive and negative cells by centrifugation on a discontinuous gradient. The transfer of fractions rich or poor in macrophages showed that the suppressor cell in the transferred population was not a macrophage. Separation using EAC rosettes suggested that B cells were responsible for the suppressor activity in the thymus.T cells isolated from the lymph nodes and spleen 7–8 days after immunization transferred contact sensitivity although the initial population was inactive. This indicates that passive transfer cells are present in the regional lymph nodes and spleen at later times after immunization but cannot be demonstrated because of the presence of suppressor B cells. However, no passive transfer cells were found in the thymus. The production of B suppressor cells required little or no T cell help and following immunization the spleens of reconstituted (B) mice were at least as active as control cells in causing suppression. There are several different suppressor cells which act in the picryl system and the B suppressor cells in immunized mice described here are distinct from the T suppressor cells in mice injected with picryl sulphonic acid.     

Studies of thymopoietin pentapeptide (TP5) on experimental tumors: I. TP5 relieves immunosuppression in tumor-bearing mice

The allogeneic and syngeneic immune responses of tumor-bearing mice (C57BL/6 mice bearing 3LL and DBA mice bearing P815) were evaluated by the cytotoxic lymphocyte precursor unit (CLP-U) and MLC. In general, tumor-bearing mice showed slightly enhanced immune responses 4 days after tumor inoculation. This enhanced immune response rapidly declined and about 7–10 days after tumor inoculation, both allogeneic and syngeneic responses were markedly lower than normal. Mice treated with TP5, starting 2 weeks before tumor inoculation, retained normal or enhanced allogeneic and syngeneic responses up to 3 weeks after tumor inoculation. When this tumor-induced suppressive effect was studied in cell transfer experiments, spleen cells from tumor-bearing mice enhanced the growth of tumors in syngeneic recipients whereas spleen cells from TP5-treated mice inhibited the growth of tumors in syngeneic recipients. Moreover, the spleen cells from TP5-treated mice also showed enhanced cytotoxic activity against tumor cells in vitro. These findings suggest that the tumors, after a transient stimulatory phase, induced immune suppressive mechanisms in the hosts' immune defenses. Treatment with TP5 prevented the development of these immune suppressive effects and spleen cells from TP5-treated tumor-bearing mice inhibited tumor growth in freshly tumor-inoculated recipients.     

Generation of cytotoxic lymphocytes to syngeneic tumor by using co-stimulator (Interleukin 2)

Cytotoxic lymphocytes (CL) highly active against the syngeneic mastocytoma, P815, were generated from spleen cells of DBA mice cultured with co-stimulator (Interleukin 2) and P815. More CL activity was generated from spleen cells of P815 tumor-bearing mice than from spleen cells of normal mice. Thymus cells from tumor-bearing mice, however, did not produce increased CL activity. Most of the CL were Thy 1 and Ly 1 positive. The optimal culture conditions and kinetics were similar to those for the generation of allogeneic cytotoxic T lymphocytes. The cytotoxic activity against syngeneic P815 was similar in magnitude to the response of DBA spleen cells to allogeneic tumor lines and to the response of allogeneic CBA spleen cells to P815. Although CL generated from tumor-bearing mice did not lyse normal DBA cells, they did lyse, to a much lesser degree, a number of tumor cell lines other than the sensitizing P815. This nonspecific lysis was not H2 restricted nor was it restricted to tumors of lymphoid origin. Generation of nonspecific cytolytic activity was antigen independent, occurring in the presence of co-stimulator alone.     

Recovery of activated cytotoxic T cells from minor H incompatible tumor graft rejection sites

In this study we determined whether minor H-specific cytotoxic T cells and their precursors (pTc) are present at the site of rejection of minor H disparate tumor allografts. Lymphocytes were retrieved from eyes of BALB/c mice that received subconjunctival injections of minor H-incompatible P815 tumor cells. The lymphocytes were then assayed for direct cytotoxic activity as well as precursor frequency by limiting dilution. Similar assays were conducted on cells obtained from the draining lymph nodes and from the spleen. As expected, tumor rejection was accompanied by significant clonal expansion of minor H-specific pTc within the draining lymph node and the spleen. A correspondingly high frequency of pTc was also detected at the graft site. More importantly, fully functional cytotoxic T cells were recovered from the tumor graft site during rejection, but no similarly active cells were found in either the draining nodes or spleen. We conclude that, after Ag stimulation, pTc are generated in draining central lymphoid compartments. From this generative site, the precursor cells then disseminate systemically, gradually reaching and infiltrating the tumor graft site. A further activation step, dependent upon Ag and T cell help, permits these cells to mature into fully active cytotoxic cells which can then effect tumor rejection. We propose that the terminal stage(s) of pTc activation is promoted by lymphokines released locally from TDH cells that are also generated during the alloimmune response and simultaneously infiltrate the site.     

Kinetics of lymphoid cells in tumor-bearing mice

The distribution patterns of ⁵¹Cr-labeled lymphoid cells from normal C3H and tumor-bearing 6C3HED mice were studied by the method of Bainbridge and Gowland (1). An increased localization of normal recirculating lymphocytes was observed in draining lymph nodes of tumor bearing animals which reached a maximum of 8.4% by the 8th–10th day following transplantation. The proportion of recirculating cells from draining nodes of tumor-bearing animals decreased with the progression of the tumor although their actual numbers increased. This decrease is thought to be related to the invasion of draining nodes by tumor cells.     

Activation and expansion of cytotoxic T lymphocytes from tumor-draining lymph nodes

Summary Large numbers of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) could be generated from tumor-draining lymph nodes (DLN) from mice bearing PHS-5 tumor by culturing at low density with autologous tumor cell stimulators and 20 U/ml recombinant interleukin-2 (IL-2). Outgrowth of metastatic tumor cells in culture was prevented by use of this hypoxanthine/aminopterin/thymidine-sensitive mutant of P815, PHS-5. After 9 days in culture, lymphoid cells demonstrated specific cytotoxicity against autologous tumor target cells. Lymph node cells could be expanded continuously in culture with repeated tumor stimulation with up to 7500-fold increase in cell number by 6 weeks; although CTL could be activated from tumor-bearing host spleen cells in short-term culture, they showed no significant growth in long-term cultures. Phenotypically, DLN cells were a mixture of CD8⁺ and CD4⁺ cells immediately after harvest but after 2 weeks in culture they were predominantly CD8⁺ CD4^–. CTL could be generated from tumor-bearing mice 10–14 days after i.d. tumor inoculation into the abdominal wall, but the immune response declined both in spleen and DLN by 21 days. Much greater CTL activity could be generated from axillary DLN that contained metastases than from non-draining popliteal nodes that were free of metastatic tumor cells. Some CTL activity could be generated from DLN with the addition of IL-2 alone but was further increased by the addition of more tumor cells as stimulators. When adoptively transferred to a host with 3-day P815 liver metastases, lymphocytes from DLN activated in vitro were able to reduce or eliminate metastases with very little or no IL-2 administered concomitantly. As few as 10⁶ cells were therapeutically effective, and in vivo efficacy was tumor-specific, since L5178Y liver metastases were not affected.This work was supported in part by grants CA42443, CA48075 and T32-CA09210 from the National Cancer Institute, Department of Health and Human ServicesRecipient of the Canadian Cancer Society McEachern Fellowship.     

Release of immature cells from the thymus during solid tumor growth: identification by assay of TdT activity.

In vivo anti-tumor activity of spleen cells from C3H/eb mice bearing a syngeneic fibrosarcoma was shown previously to decline to an undetectable level and be replaced by tumor-enhancing activity as tumor growth proceeds. In the light of our findings that thymocytes in the early stages of thymic processing can bring about tumor enhancement, we postulated that premature release of thymocytes and their accumulation in the spleen might account for the loss of the anti-tumor response. In the present experiments an injection of thymocytes did in fact cancel the anti-tumor response of reactive splenocytes from tumor-bearing mice. In order to determine whether premature thymocyte release occurs naturally in the tumor-bearing animals, we assayed activity of the enzyme TdT (as a marker for thymus cells) in the spleens of these mice during progressive tumor growth. Cells with TdT activity were clearly evident in the spleens of the tumor-bearing animals, were derived from the thymus, and accumulated in parallel to the loss of anti-tumour reactivity.     

Studies of the T-lymphocytes resident in the spleens of thymectomized, irradiated, bone marrow-reconstituted (TXB) mice.

The T-lymphocytes resident in the spleens of thymectomized, lethally irradiated mice that had been reconstituted with syngeneic bone marrow (TXB) were characterized. Both recently reconstituted N-TXB, (approximately 3 weeks after bone marrow injection) and aged (>6 months after reconstitution) A-TXB animals were studied. The T-lymphocytes from spleens of recently reconstituted N-TXB donors did not respond to PHA but did react significantly to Concanavalin A (Con A). The lack of PHA sensitivity was not due to dilution of reactive cells by other cell types. Removal of adherent cells, likewise, did not restore N-TXB spleen cell PHA responsiveness. N-TXB splenic T-cells were cortisone resistant. N-TXB spleen cells by themselves did not cause a graft vs host response. However, N-TXB spleen cells amplified the graft vs host response of normal lymph node cells but not N-TXB lymph node cells. Addition of cyclic GMP enhanced [³H]thymidine uptake of N-TXB spleen cells caused by Con A. N-TXB spleen cells were exclusively spleen seeking. The Con A reactive cell within N-TXB spleens was demonstrated to be of donor origin. Fetal liver as well as syngeneic bone marrow contained cells capable of reconstituting the Con A response. Spleen cells from aged. (>6 months) A-TXB were found to be PHA sensitive. Competitive inhibition assays measuring θ expression in A-TXB spleen cells indicate a significant increase in the θ positive lymphocyte population occurred with time. The data indicate that considerable reconstitution of θ positive cells had occurred in A-TXB donors. The results also suggest that the T-lymphocyte population of the TXB spleen may be a unique subpopulation of T-lymphocytes that resides exclusively in spleen and bone marrow.     

Effects of isolated tumor lymphocytes alone and with adherent cells

Summary The effect on the growth of gradient-isolated mouse mammary tumor cells of different populations of lymphoid cells were evaluated in micrototoxicity assays. Variable effects were obtained with tumor-bearer lymph node and spleen cells: in some experiments growth stimulation occurred, whereas in others inhibition was observed. Mixed effector populations gave more regular results: adherent spleen cells added to lymph node or spleen lymphocytes inhibited tumor cell growth in six of nine experiments; inhibition occurred when either of the effector populations in the mixture was derived from the tumor-bearing mouse. Tumor-associated lymphoid cells (TAL) stimulated growth of the tumor cells in five of seven experiments. However, TAL inhibited tumor growth when combined with adherent spleen cells from tumor-bearing animals. In contrast with the peripheral lymphoid cells, admixture of control adherent cells from normal animals with TAL did not inhibit growth. No natural killer effect was seen in these growth inhibition assays. These data indicate that lymphoid populations capable of inhibiting tumor cell growth can be found in tumor-bearing animals, but such combination of active cells are not present at the tumor site.     

Activation of dendritic cells that cross-present tumor-derived antigen licenses CD8+ CTL to cause tumor eradication

The fate of naive CD8(+) T cells is determined by the environment in which they encounter MHC class I presented peptide Ags. The manner in which tumor Ags are presented is a longstanding matter of debate. Ag presentation might be mediated by tumor cells in tumor draining lymph nodes or via cross-presentation by professional APC. Either pathway is insufficient to elicit protective antitumor immunity. We now demonstrate using a syngeneic mouse tumor model, expressing an Ag derived from the early region 1A of human adenovirus type 5, that the inadequate nature of the antitumor CTL response is not due to direct Ag presentation by the tumor cells, but results from presentation of tumor-derived Ag by nonactivated CD11c(+) APC. Although this event results in division of naive CTL in tumor draining lymph nodes, it does not establish a productive immune response. Treatment of tumor-bearing mice with dendritic cell-stimulating agonistic anti-CD40 mAb resulted in systemic efflux of CTL with robust effector function capable to eradicate established tumors. For efficacy of anti-CD40 treatment, CD40 ligation of host APC is required because adoptive transfer of CD40-proficient tumor-specific TCR transgenic CTL into CD40-deficient tumor-bearing mice did not lead to productive antitumor immunity after CD40 triggering in vivo. CpG and detoxified LPS (MPL) acted similarly as agonistic anti-CD40 mAb with respect to CD8(+) CTL efflux and tumor eradication. Together these results indicate that dendritic cells, depending on their activation state, orchestrate the outcome of CTL-mediated immunity against tumors, leading either to an ineffective immune response or potent antitumor immunity.     

The influence of cyclophosphamide on antitumor immunity in mice bearing late-stage tumors

Spleen cells from mice bearing late-stage methylcholanthrene-induced tumor did not show any tumor activity when mixed with tumor cells in Winn's assay. Treatment of these mice with cyclophosphamide (CY) induced a tumor-inhibitory activity in spleen, occurring on day 7 after treatment, reaching its maximum on day 11 and disappearing by day 21. This antitumor activity could not be induced in control, tumor-free or T-deficient tumor-bearing mice. CY-induced tumor-inhibitory activity was immunologically specific, and mediated by Thy-1⁺, L3T4^–, Ly-2⁺ cells. Contrary to spleen cells from untreated tumor-bearing mice, spleen cells from CY-treated tumor-bearing mice did not suppress the antitumor activity of immune spleen cells in Winn's assay. However, in contrast to immune spleen cells, CY-induced tumor-inhibitory cells did not manifest antitumor activity when transferred systemically (i. v.) into T-cell-deficient tumor-bearing mice. Even more, spleen cells from CY-pretreated mice, harvested 7–15 days after the drug administration, partially suppressed the antitumor activity of concomitantly transferred spleen cells from specifically immune mice. Nevertheless, CY-pretreated mice manifested concomitant immunity, i.e. these mice exhibited higher resistance to a second inoculum of the same tumor than did nontreated mice or even mice with excised primary tumor.