Human papillomavirus DNA detection in Papanicolaou-stained cervical smears with a nonradioactive, in situ hybridization assay.

Archived Papanicolaou-stained cervical smears from women with different cervical pathologies were processed for human papillomavirus (HPV) DNA detection and typing with an in situ hybridization (ISH) assay that employed commercial biotinylated HPV DNA probes. Two HPV DNA probes were utilized: one included HPV genotypes 6/11 and the other, 16/18. The method yielded positive results for HPV DNA 6/11 in 5 cases with condylomata acuminata (100%) and in 2 of 47 with flat warty lesions (4.2%), whereas HPV DNA 16/18 was detected in 29/47 of the latter group (61.7%). In cases with cervical intraepithelial III or invasive squamous cell carcinoma the yield was lower: positive results for HPV DNA 16/18 were obtained in only one of the five cases with one or the other cervical pathology (20%). An analysis of the results showed that the sensitivity of the assay correlated with evidence in the Papanicolaou specimens of pathognomonic cell injury from HPV infection. In the presence of such cytologic features, HPV DNA typing was possible in 37/52 cases (65.4%). In view of the modest difficulty and relatively quick execution of the nonradioactive ISH assay, the authors believe that Papanicolaou cervical smears with cytologic changes of HPV infection could be processed by this method in order to acquire information on the HPV type or types involved in the cervical infection.     

Association of human papillomavirus and Chlamydia infections with incidence cervical neoplasia

Incidence cervical neoplasia is defined as disease that becomes manifest during a given period of observation. Association with preceding genital infections having characteristic cytologic findings would seem to be more likely for incidence than for prevalence cases since the usual long latency period of carcinoma in situ (CIS) could allow resolution of infectious processes. For this reason, it was elected to examine the preceding Papanicolaou smears from patients with tissue-confirmed incidence CIS or invasive epidermoid carcinoma. There were 67 women with biopsy-proven CIS or invasive carcinoma of the uterine cervix identified in the files of the University of New Mexico Cytopathology Laboratory from 1966 to 1982 who had two initial negative smears as well as smears at intervals of three years or less. All cytologic smears prior to tissue diagnosis were rescreened for confirmation of cytologic atypia or its absence as well as for morphologic evidence of human papillomavirus (HPV) or chlamydial infections. Control cases matched for age, gravidity, ethnicity and number of smears were reviewed in an identical manner. Koilocytes indicative of HPV infection were found in 17 index cases (25%) and 5 controls (7%) (p = 0.005). Chlamydial infections were identified in 18 index cases (27%) and in 4 controls (6%) (p = 0.001). The times required for conversion from smear negativity to malignancy were determined for each incidence case. The results showed great variability but suggest that the progression to malignancy is not hastened in women with antecedent HPV or chlamydial infections. Our results indicate that the presence of koilocytes and/or chlamydial inclusions in cervical smears serves to identify a group of women with a significantly increased risk of developing cervical carcinoma, even in the absence of concurrent dysplasia.     

Detection of human papillomavirus in cervical smears. A comparison of in situ hybridization, immunocytochemistry and cytopathology

A comparison of different methods for the detection of cervical human papillomavirus (HPV) infection was made on patients attending the cervical dysplasia clinic. Cytomorphology, immunocytochemistry and in situ hybridization were compared for their ability to detect HPV. Separate cervicovaginal smears from 50 patients were tested for HPV types 6/11, 16 and 18 by in situ hybridization using 35S-labeled DNA probes. Duplicate smears from the same patients were Papanicolaou stained and evaluated for evidence of condylomatous and dysplastic changes. Twenty-five matching cervical biopsies were immunostained for HPV capsid antigen and tested by in situ hybridization for HPV DNA. The cytologic smears of 20 patients (40%) were positive for HPV DNA. Six patients had HPV 6/11, ten had HPV 16, three had HPV 18, and one had both HPV 6/11 and HPV 16. There was a high correlation between condylomatous cytopathology and antigen and DNA detection. One-third of the specimens with condylomatous changes were DNA negative by the tested probes, suggesting the presence of other HPV types in the genital tract.     

Cytomorphological analysis of uterine cervical pap smears in relation to human papillomavirus infection in Indonesian women

Objective: Cervical cancer is the number one cause of cancer-associated death in Indonesian women (30/100,000 annually), where no screening program is present. The Papanicolaou test is widely accepted as an effective screening method for cervical neoplasia detection and often shows certain cytological features associated with human papillomavirus (HPV) infection. Especially in developing countries, cytological investigation is still the method of choice as compared to the frequent use of HPV DNA testing in western countries. Study Design: In the present study, we investigated the validity of the use of cytomorphological changes as a marker for HPV infection. A total of 140 smears collected in three different areas in Indonesia (Jakarta, Tasikmalaya and Bali) were analyzed. HPV DNA testing was performed using INNO-LiPA assays. Results and Conclusions: We found a highly significant association of classical koilocytosis, multinucleated cells, dyskeratosis-parakeratosis, nuclear membrane, enlarged nuclei, moderate/strong hyperchromasia and chromatin pattern with HPV positivity. Using classical and nonclassical cytomorphological parameters we found an overall sensitivity of 42% and a specificity of 90%. The combination of classical and nonclassical parameters led to a higher sensitivity of HPV positivity prediction. These results are of importance for cytologists in developing countries as molecular HPV testing still poses a major financial, logistic and expertise problem.     

Detection of sexually transmitted diseases by urethral cytology, the ignored male counterpart of cervical cytology

The detection of sexually transmitted diseases by urethral cytology was investigated in 270 men examined by urethral swabbing smears. Each sample was used to prepare a wet mount smear and smears for staining by the Papanicolaou, Gram and methylene blue techniques. A fifth smear was used for direct staining with fluorescein-conjugated monoclonal antibodies for the detection of Chlamydia trachomatis. The smears were examined for cytoplasmic and nuclear changes as well as for pathogenic organisms and inflammatory changes. Infections with Chlamydia trachomatis, Neisseria gonorrhoeae and human papillomavirus (HPV) produced distinctive cytologic patterns similar to those seen in cervicovaginal smears from women. The patterns in candidiasis, trichomoniasis and herpes simplex virus infection were not as diagnostic. Particularly noteworthy were the nuclear alterations, which appeared to be proplastic in HPV infection but retroplastic in Chlamydia infection. The results of this study indicate that urethral cytology would be an invaluable addition in diagnosing sexually transmitted diseases in men, particularly in the case of Chlamydia and HPV infections. The monomorphic structure of urethral columnar epithelium, as compared to the cervical epithelium, seems to result in a clearer and more constant response to pathogenic infections, as seen in the resulting smears.     

Can we detect cervical human papillomavirus (HPV) infection by cytomorphology alone? Diagnostic value of non‐classic cytological signs of HPV effect in minimally abnormal Pap tests

OBJECTIVE: Our aim was to assess the validity of non-classical cytological signs in minimally abnormal cervical smears for the prediction of HPV infection. METHODS: 164 ThinPrep monolayers were re-screened for mild nuclear changes, disorders of keratinisation, abortive koilocytes and 'measles cells', as well as degenerative changes. HPV DNA was detected by GP5+/6+ and MY09/MY11 consensus primer PCR assays. RESULTS: Seventy six of 164 cases (46.3%) had HPV positivity by PCR. All cytomorphological features studied were significantly associated with the presence of HPV. Mild nuclear changes had 100% sensitivity and 100% negative predictive value for HPV infection. CONCLUSIONS: Our results indicate that non-classic cytomorphological signs can improve the sensitivity of cytology for detecting HPV. Minimally abnormal Pap smears lacking mild nuclear changes (16%) in the present study--do not require further molecular HPV testing.     

Value of cytology in papillary condylomatous lesions of the cervix

OBJECTIVE: To determine the value of cytology in detecting mature and immature papillary condylomas of the uterine cervix. STUDY DESIGN: We evaluated 240 cases of plane cervical intraepithelial neoplasia, grade 1 (CIN 1), and 23 papillary condylomas by Pap smear and biopsy and classified histologic sections according to maturity and keratinization. We reevaluated corresponding cytologic smears and identified criteria of low grade squamous lesion (LSIL) and human papillomavirus (HPV) infection. RESULTS: Thirteen (56.5%) papillary lesions were histologically classified as mature, 6 (26%) as immature and 4 (17.3%) as mixed. Fifteen lesions (65.2%) were nonkeratinized, 2 (8.6%) keratinized and 6 (26%) partially keratinized. Corresponding smears were cytologically diagnosed as LSIL (6, 26%), atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance (ASCUS) (7, 30.4%) and negative (10, 43.4%). Careful cytologic review diagnosed only two of the 13 mature lesions; few cytological criteria of LSIL and HPV infection were observed. Koilocytes were seen in just 1 case. Sample limiting factors occurred in 4 cases: 2 cytologically diagnosed as LSIL, 1 asASCUS and 1 as negative for lesion. CONCLUSION: Cytology was not effective in the detection of cervical condyloma acuminatum, independent of limitations in sample adequacy and of the degree of maturity or keratinization of the lesions.     

Human papillomavirus infection and neoplasia of the cervix and anogenital region in women with Hodgkin's disease

Immunosuppression has been associated with an increased incidence of condyloma and neoplasia of the cervix and anogenital region, lesions associated with human papillomavirus (HPV) infection. The role of immunosuppression as a risk factor for the development of these lesions in patients with Hodgkin's disease was studied in a series of 666 consecutive women seen at the University of Texas M. D. Anderson Hospital between 1963 and 1982. Thirty-nine patients (5.9%) of the entire series and 45.9% of the 85 women with Hodgkin's disease who had a gynecologic examination showed evidence of condyloma, dysplasia or carcinoma of the cervix or anogenital region. This is a significantly greater percentage of affected women than would be expected based on published results from Papanicolaou screening services. The evidence is compatible with immunosuppression from Hodgkin's disease or its treatment rendering a woman susceptible to persistent HPV infection and its consequences.     

Koilocytosis; an indication for conservative management

The management of women with mild dyskaryosis continues to be the subject of debate. The management of cases with such smears could be improved if additional morphological features were found to be indicative of low/high grade cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN). Our own experience in the routine audit of the diagnostic accuracy of cervical smears had suggested that cases of dyskaryosis with koilocytosis were associated with a low risk of CINIII. Two hundred and forty-four cervical smears reported as showing evidence of wart virus infection were reviewed and their subsequent histories noted. Of these smears, 173 demonstrated clear evidence of koilocytosis. Irrespective of the initial grade of dyskaryosis, only 28 cases (16.2%) had underlying CIN or had progressed to CIN over a minimum follow-up period of 21 months. Only two cases (1.2%) showed evidence of CINIII. Koilocytosis is associated with a low risk of CIN and an especially low risk of CINIII. The management of women with koilocytic smears should be modified accordingly.     

Koilocytosis; an indication for conservative management

The management of women with mild dyskaryosis continues to be the subject of debate. The management of cases with such smears could be improved if additional morphological features were found to be indicative of low/high grade cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN). Our own experience in the routine audit of the diagnostic accuracy of cervical smears had suggested that cases of dyskaryosis with koilocytosis were associated with a low risk of CINIII. Two hundred and forty-four cervical smears reported as showing evidence of wart virus infection were reviewed and their subsequent histories noted. Of these smears, 173 demonstrated clear evidence of koilocytosis. Irrespective of the initial grade of dyskaryosis, only 28 cases (16.2%) had underlying CIN or had progressed to CIN over a minimum follow-up period of 21 months. Only two cases (1.2%) showed evidence of CINIII. Koilocytosis is associated with a low risk of CIN and an especially low risk of CINIII. The management of women with koilocytic smears should be modified accordingly.     

The "suspicious" gynecologic smear

"Suspicious" gynecologic smears from 842 patients over a seven-year period were analyzed for their causes and outcomes. The frequency of the cytologic diagnosis of "suspicious" ranged between 0.5% in 1979 and 1.44% in 1975 of all smears examined. Review of the smears showed that this classification was used to report a variety of conditions, including equivocal possible precancerous changes as well as the presence of severe inflammation, degenerative or atrophic changes, abnormal glandular cells and metaplasia. The cytologic follow-up, following anti-inflammatory or hormonal therapy, showed a conversion to negative findings in 65.1% of all cases, usually within 12 months. In 294 cases, histologic analysis became necessary, revealing precancerous changes or cancer in 147 patients (17.5% of the study group). Smears of postmenopausal women with suspicious glandular or endometrial cells received special analysis. Significant numbers of such cases had histologic findings positive for malignancy (20% of smears with glandular cells and 21.3% with endometrial cells), as did also smears showing post-irradiative changes (34.6%) or atrophic and degenerative changes (17.1%). Therefore, "suspicious" smears in these groups were considered to indicate an increased risk of malignancy. A regimen for the proper management of cases with "suspicious" smears has been established.     

False-negative Papanicolaou smears from women with cancerous and precancerous lesions of the uterine cervix

The occurrence from 1980 to 1989 of false-negative Papanicolaou smears in women with cancerous and precancerous lesions of the uterine cervix was studied. The 4,781 cases of cancer (2,814 invasive carcinomas and 593 carcinomas in situ) and precancerous lesions (418 severe dysplasias, 748 moderate dysplasias and 208 mild dysplasias) included 70 cases (1.5%) with false-negative smears. These 70 cases included 43 invasive carcinomas (61.4%), 17 carcinomas in situ and adenocarcinomas in situ (24.2%), and 10 dysplasias (14.4%); all were diagnosed histologically. The mean age of women with false-negative smears was 44.1 +/- 13.7 years. Review of the original cytologic samples showed a screening error in 41 cases (58.5%), an interpretation error in 2 cases (2.9%) and a sampling error in 27 cases (38.6%). Methods for eliminating false-negative smears are discussed.     

The effect of delivery on regression of abnormal cervical cytologic findings

The purpose of this study was to determine whether abnormal antepartum cervical cytologic findings result in differing postpartum regression rates. Between 1993 and 2000, 107 pregnant women with antepartum abnormal cervical cytologic findings were identified. Papanicolaou smear data were separated into three groups by use of the CIN classification system. Postpartum regression rates of antepartum Papanicolaou smears were analyzed six months after delivery. Normalization of Papanicolaou smears in the postpartum period were observed in 50 of 107 women (46.7%). Regression of cervical cytologic findings was noted in 61 of 107 women (57%). Respectively, persistence of Papanicolaou smear was noted in 43 of 107 patients (40%). Only 3 of 107 (3%) antepartum findings progressed after delivery. Desquamation of the cervical epithelium or enhancement of a localized reparative immunologic response after vaginal delivery could play an important role in the spontaneous regression of cervical dysplasia in the postpartum period.     

Five-year follow-up of women with borderline and mildly dyskaryotic cervical smears

This study investigated the 5-year follow-up status of women with cervical smears showing borderline nuclear changes (BNC) or mild dyskaryosis and the effect of koilocytosis on the outcome. Thirteen per cent of women with cervical smears showing BNC had high-grade cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN). In contrast, 28% of women with cervical smears showing mild dyskaryosis had high-grade CIN. The presence of koilocytosis (24% for borderline smears and 34% for mild dyskaryotic smears) did not appear to influence the risk of developing high-grade CIN. Our results suggest that the simultaneous implementation of the British Society for Clinical Cytology proposed terminology and the colposcopy guidelines from the British Society for Colposcopy and Cervical Pathology could have an impact on colposcopy services.     

Human papillomavirus infection. Frequency and association with cervical neoplasia in a young population

One million, six hundred thirty-two thousand, eight hundred forty-seven women from two independent populations in the United States received cytologic screening during a two-year period. Condylomatous lesions (human papillomavirus [HPV] infections) were the most frequent cytologic abnormality in women in both the Planned Parenthood and private sector groups (prevalence rates of 18.6 to 19.0 in women between ages 15 to 19). The prevalence rates of mild-to-moderate dysplasia were also similar in both populations, with the highest frequencies being between ages 25 to 29. Severe dysplasia and carcinoma in situ were most frequent between ages 35 to 39. In both populations, women with condylomatous changes coexisting with dysplastic changes were about ten years younger, grade-for-grade of severity of the lesion, than women without evidence of HPV infection. Since HPV infection is believed to represent the soil from which neoplasm develops, both the frequency of condyloma and the occurrence of dysplasia and cancer in young women suggest that women should begin regular screening programs while in their teens or after they become sexually active.     

Thin-layer cytology findings of small cell carcinoma of the lower female genital tract. Review of three cases with molecular analysis

OBJECTIVE: To describe the thin-layer cytology findings of small cell carcinoma of the low female genital tract, with histologic correlation and human papillomavirus (HPV) genotyping. STUDY DESIGN: The authors reviewed the clinical findings, thin-layer cytology and histologic features of small cell carcinoma of the lower female genital tract (cervix or vagina) occurring in three postmenopausal Chinese women at Pamela Youde Nethersole Eastern Hospital, Hong Kong, over a four-year period, from January 1998 to December 2001. Molecular techniques for HPV screening and genotyping using the polymerase chain reaction and restriction fragment length polymorphism were employed on the cytologic specimens. RESULTS: The thin-layer preparations were of moderate to high cellularity. There were loose aggregates of or isolated small round cells with a high nuclear/cytoplasmic ratio, thin but irregular nuclear membrane, hyperchromatic nuclei, inconspicuous nucleoli and scanty cytoplasm. Tumor cell cannibalism was commonly found. Small groups of tumor cells with nuclear molding were noted. There was also obvious tumor diathesis in the background. The necrotic debris was admixed with isolated small round cells, apoptotic bodies and nuclear dust. Associated koilocytosis or squamous intraepithelial lesions were not seen. Histologic examination of the tumor biopsies showed classic features of small cell carcinoma associated with squashing artifacts and vascularized stroma. Molecular analysis revealed the presence of HPV DNA (either type 18 or 16) in all the three liquid-based cytology samples. CONCLUSION: While the cytomorphologic features of small cell carcinoma of the cervix or vagina in thin-layer preparations are slightly different from those in conventional smears, due mainly to the absence of smearing effect, recognition of the subtle but characteristic appearance can enhance the accuracy of the cytologic diagnosis. The association between HPV and primary small cell carcinoma of the lower female genital tract was confirmed by this study.     

Proffered Papers 10.30–11.15 Monday 15 September 2003 3 5 year outcome of women with borderline and mild dyskaryosis smears 3 5 year outcome of women with borderline and mild dyskaryosis smears

Aims

• 1 To identify the outcome status of women with borderline and mild dyskaryosis smears.
• 2 To determine whether the presence or absence of koilocytosis influences the outcome status.
• 3 To identify the proportion of women with borderline smears showing koilocytosis.

Materials and methods Borderline and mild dyskaryosis cervical smears diagnosed during January to March 1997 were identified from the laboratory database. Each slide was reviewed by two researchers independently, who then agreed a final consensus diagnosis. All slides were classified according to the presence or absence of koilocytosis. Slides were excluded from the study if the review diagnosis was negative, inadequate or high‐grade dyskaryosis. The outcome status was classified according to the worst lesion identified histologically and/or cytologically during the 5‐year follow‐up period. Results 1974 women were identified with borderline or mild dyskaryosis cervical smears of which 1597 were included in the study. Table 1 shows the outcome status of these women.

Table 1. . The outcome status of these women

P‐26CONVENTIONAL V THIN LAYER TECHNIQUES: A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF BRONCHIAL SPECIMENS USING CONVENTIONAL AND TWO LBC METHODS,THINPREP AND SUREPATH

Introduction: There is ongoing debate about the terminology used in the classification of dyskaryosis, including whether BNA smears should be classified according to whether koilocytes are present or not. We explored the effect of koilocytosis in the management experiences and clinical outcomes of women with a single BNA smear. Methods: This study includes 410 women aged 20–59 years, resident in Tayside who had an ‘baseline’ BNA smear between 31/10/1999 and 31/10/2002 who were eligible for the TOMBOLA trial but who did not participate. Recommended follow‐up for these women was a repeat smear in six months. Up to three‐years follow‐up data was collected on subsequent cytological smears, colposcopy examinations and any related histology. The baseline smear was re‐read for the presence or absence of koilocytes. Women were classified according to their clinical outcomes during their three years. Results: 47% (192/410) of women were classified as having koilocytosis at baseline. The mean age was lower among these women (25 years) compared to those without koilocytosis (35 years). 55% (105/192) of women with koilocytosis at baseline had one or more negative smears and no further abnormal smears, compared to 63% (137/218) of those without koilocytosis, the difference was not statistically significant. 28% (53/192) of women with koilocytosis at baseline were referred to colposcopy after subsequent low‐grade or high‐grade smears compared to 19% (42/218) of those without koilocytosis; the difference was statistically significant. 14% (27/192) of women with koilocytosis at baseline were diagnosed with CIN2/3 or worse during follow‐up compared to 10% (21/218) of women without koilocytosis; the difference was not statistically significant. Discussion: Our results suggest that the presence or absence of koilocytosis has little impact on the clinical outcomes of women with a BNA smear.     

Investigation of 208 consecutive cases of cervical cone biopsies with regard to indication, negative samples and quality control

OBJECTIVE: To analyze factors in preoperative management and cytologic screening leading to a conization specimen free of neoplasia. STUDY DESIGN: From January 2001 through December 2003, cervical conization was performed on 208 consecutive cases at the Gynecologic Department, Krankenhaus Lainz, Vienna. Indications for cone biopsy were based on suspicious internal and/or external conventional cytologic screening results followed by punch biopsies in selected cases. RESULTS: Benign cervical lesions were diagnosed in 22 women (10.6%). Histologic results in negative cone biopsies were cervicitis (n = 12), infection with HPV without cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (n = 1), tubal metaplasia (n = 4) and combined diagnoses indicating no neoplasia (n = 5). Regarding cytologic screening results prior to conization, long-lasting infections with HPV can cause repeated findings of cells of unknown origin or reversible mild to moderate dysplasia eventually leading to conization specimens free of neoplasia. Furthermore, tubal metaplasia is a frequent pitfall in misinterpretation of cytologic smears. CONCLUSION: Reevaluation of cytologic screening results after the final histologic diagnosis becomes available following cone biopsy is a key issue in continuous quality assurance for the diagnostic procedure. In this article we also present a method of stratifying screening results according to the correctness of the results. Along with other established measures of diagnostic performance, this may support benchmarking and interpretation of the overall cytologic screening quality.     

Sensitivity of HPV tests on stained vs. unstained cervical smears

OBJECTIVE: To examine the effect of Pspanicolaou staining of cervical smears on the sensitivity of molecular biologic HPV tests. STUDY DESIGN: Two sensitive HPV tests were used, HPV DNA sequence analysis after polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification and the Hybrid Capture II method (HC II) (Digene Diagnostics Inc., Silver Spring, Maryland, USA). Papanicolaou-stained and unstained smears taken simultaneously were examined from 265 women readmitted for examination due to an atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance diagnosis. RESULTS: After an HPV test with the PCR method on unstained slides, 66% of the women were HPV positive, whereas the same women were HPVpositive in 54% when Papanicolaou-stained slides were analyzed. However, this difference was not statistically significant (p > 0.1). With the HC II method, 55% of unstained smears were HPV positive whereas 29% were HPV positive, when Papanicolaou-stained slides were examined. This difference was significant (p < 0.001). The same strong differences in sensitivity were observed when both the PCR and HC II methods were studied on the same Papanicolaou stained glass slides, whereas on unstained slides no significant difference was found. CONCLUSION: The results demonstrate that Papanicolaou staining of a cervical smear significantly decreases the sensitivity of an HPV test performed with the HC II method, whereas the PCR method is less affected. With the Papanicolaou method, the hematoxylin bath is followed by HCl treatment, and strong acid treatment destroys DNA.