A comprehensive set of DnaA-box mutations in the replication origin, oriC, of Escherichia coli

We probed the complex between the replication origin, oriC , and the initiator protein DnaA using different types of mutations in the five binding sites for DnaA, DnaA boxes R1–R4 and M: (i) point mutations in individual DnaA boxes and combinations of them; (ii) replacement of the DnaA boxes by a scrambled 9 bp non-box motif; (iii) positional exchange; and (iv) inversion of the DnaA boxes. For each of the five DnaA boxes we found at least one type of mutation that resulted in a phenotype. This demonstrates that all DnaA boxes in oriC have a function in the initiation process. Most mutants with point mutations retained some origin activity, and the in vitro DnaA-binding capacity of these origins correlated well with their replication proficiency. Inversion or scrambling of DnaA boxes R1 or M inactivated oriC -dependent replication of joint replicons or minichromosomes under all conditions, demonstrating the importance of these sites. In contrast, mutants with inverted or scrambled DnaA boxes R2 or R4 could not replicate in wild-type hosts but gave transformants in host strains with deleted or compromised chromosomal oriC at elevated DnaA concentrations. We conclude that these origins require more DnaA per origin for initiation than does wild-type oriC . Mutants in DnaA box R3 behaved essentially like wild-type oriC , except for those in which the low-affinity box R3 was replaced by the high-affinity box R1. Apparently, initiation is possible without DnaA binding to box R3, but high-affinity DnaA binding to DnaA box R3 upsets the regulation. Taken together, these results demonstrate that there are finely tuned DnaA binding requirements for each of the individual DnaA boxes for optimal build-up of the initiation complex and replication initiation in vivo     

DnaA Protein of Escherichia coli: oligomerization at the E. coli chromosomal origin is required for initiation and involves specific N-terminal amino acids

Iterated DnaA box sequences within the replication origins of bacteria and prokaryotic plasmids are recognized by the replication initiator, DnaA protein. At the E. coli chromosomal origin, oriC, DnaA is speculated to oligomerize to initiate DNA replication. We developed an assay of oligomer formation at oriC that relies on complementation between two dnaA alleles that are inactive by themselves. One allele is dnaA46; its inactivity at the non-permissive temperature is due to a specific defect in ATP binding. The second allele, T435K, does not support DNA replication because of its inability to bind to DnaA box sequences within oriC. We show that the T435K allele can complement the dnaA46(Ts) allele. The results support a model of oligomer formation in which DnaA box sequences of oriC are bound by DnaA46 to which T435K then binds to form an active complex. Relying on this assay, leucine 5, tryptophan 6 and cysteine 9 in a predicted alpha helix were identified that, when altered, interfere with oligomer formation. Glutamine 8 is additionally needed for oligomer formation on an oriC-containing plasmid, suggesting that the structure of the DnaA-oriC complex at the chromosomal oriC locus is similar but not identical to that assembled on a plasmid. Other evidence suggests that proline 28 of DnaA is involved in the recruitment of DnaB to oriC. These results provide direct evidence that DnaA oligomerization at oriC is required for initiation to occur.     

Regulation of the initiation of chromosomal replication in bacteria

The initiation of chromosomal replication occurs only once during the cell cycle in both prokaryotes and eukaryotes. Initiation of chromosome replication is the first and tightly controlled step of a DNA synthesis. Bacterial chromosome replication is initiated at a single origin, oriC, by the initiator protein DnaA, which specifically interacts with 9-bp non-palindromic sequences (DnaA boxes) at oriC. In Escherichia coli, a model organism used to study the mechanism of DNA replication and its regulation, the control of initiation relies on a reduction of the availability and/or activity of the two key elements, DnaA and the oriC region. This review summarizes recent research into the regulatory mechanisms of the initiation of chromosomal replication in bacteria, with emphasis on organisms other than E. coli.     

Two oppositely oriented arrays of low-affinity recognition sites in oriC guide progressive binding of DnaA during Escherichia coli pre-RC assembly

The onset of chromosomal DNA replication requires highly precise and reproducible interactions between initiator proteins and replication origins to assemble a pre-replicative complex (pre-RC) that unwinds the DNA duplex. In bacteria, initiator protein DnaA, bound to specific high- and low-affinity recognition sites within the unique oriC locus, comprises the pre-RC, but how complex assembly is choreographed to ensure precise initiation timing during the cell cycle is not well understood. In this study, we present evidence that higher-order DnaA structures are formed at oriC when DnaA monomers are closely positioned on the same face of the DNA helix by interaction with two oppositely oriented essential arrays of closely spaced low-affinity DnaA binding sites. As DnaA levels increase, peripheral high-affinity anchor sites begin cooperative loading of the arrays, which is extended by sequential binding of additional DnaA monomers resulting in growth of the complexes towards the centre of oriC. We suggest that this polarized assembly of unique DnaA oligomers within oriC plays an important role in mediating pre-RC activity and may be a feature found in all bacterial replication origins.     

Coupling the initiation of chromosome replication to cell size in Escherichia coli

Bacterial cells change size dramatically with change in growth rate, but the ratio between cell volume and the number of copies of the origin of chromosome replication (oriC) is roughly constant at the time of initiation of DNA replication at almost all growth rates. Recent research on the inactivation of initiator protein (DnaA) and depletion of DnaA pools by the high-affinity DnaA-binding locus datA allows us to propose a simple model to explain the long-standing question of how Escherichia coli couples DNA replication to cell size.     

Localized DNA melting and structural pertubations in the origin of replication, oriC, of Escherichia coli in vitro and in vivo.

The leftmost region of the Escherichia coli origin of DNA replication (oriC) contains three tandemly repeated AT-rich 13mers which have been shown to become single-stranded during the early stages of initiation in vitro. Melting is induced by the ATP form of DnaA, the initiator protein of DNA replication. KMnO4 was used to probe for single-stranded regions and altered DNA conformation during the initiation of DNA replication at oriC in vitro and in vivo. Unpairing in the AT-rich 13mer region is thermodynamically stable even in the absence of DnaA protein, but only when divalent cations are omitted from the reaction. In the presence of Mg2+, oriC melting is strictly DnaA dependent. The sensitive region is distinct from that detected in the absence of DnaA as it is located further to the left within the minimal origin. In addition, the DNA is severely distorted between the three 13mers and the IHF binding site in oriC. A change of conformation can also be observed during the initiation of DNA replication in vivo. This is the first in vivo evidence for a structural change at the 13mers during initiation complex formation.     

The initiation mess?

This review concerns the mechanisms which control initiation of chromosome replication in enterobacteria with respect to cell growth. Initiation control is commonly separated into positive and negative regulatory mechanisms. Four main points are advanced concerning these different aspects of initiation control. (i) The average concentration of the initiator protein DnaA is proportional to the origin concentration, i.e. the origin per cell mass ratio and, thus, inversely proportional to the very often used term of the 'initiation mass'. (ii) The time of initiation of chromosome replication in the cell cycle is set by DnaA protein accumulating to a threshold level, which in concert with a number of other factors allows for a co-operative formation of the initiation complex. (iii) The time of initiation is not determined by the interaction with these other factors or by the transient interaction between newly replicated origins ( oriC  ) and the cell surface. (iv) The aberrant initiation phenotype observed in various mutants, including dnaA (ts) mutants, might be due to a defective pre-initiation DnaA– oriC interaction or it might be due to a defect in the protection of newly initiated origins from reinitiation. Many of these points are discussed and evaluated in view of recent developments concerning the regulation of chromosome replication in Escherichia coli     

The right half of the Escherichia coli replication origin is not essential for viability, but facilitates multi-forked replication

Replication initiation is a key event in the cell cycle of all organisms and oriC , the replication origin in Escherichia coli , serves as the prototypical model for this process. The minimal sequence required for oriC function was originally determined entirely from plasmid studies using cloned origin fragments, which have previously been shown to differ dramatically in sequence requirement from the chromosome. Using an in vivo recombineering strategy to exchange wt oriC s for mutated ones regardless of whether they are functional origins or not, we have determined the minimal origin sequence that will support chromosome replication. Nearly the entire right half of oriC could be deleted without loss of origin function, demanding a reassessment of existing models for initiation. Cells carrying the new DnaA box-depleted 163 bp minimal oriC exhibited little or no loss of fitness under slow-growth conditions, but were sensitive to rich medium, suggesting that the dense packing of initiator binding sites that is a hallmark of prokaryotic origins, has likely evolved to support the increased demands of multi-forked replication.     

The structure of the initiation complex at the replication origin, oriC, of Escherichia coli.

Two distinct regions in the replication origin, oriC, of Escherichia coli are separately distorted upon initiation complex formation by the initiator protein DnaA. The AT-rich region in the left part of oriC and the start site region in the right part of oriC. Chemical modification of single-stranded DNA was observed at both regions whereas endonuclease recognition of DNA mini-bulges specifically occurred in the start site region. We show that the helical phasing of binding sites for DnaA protein in oriC is important for origin function. An insertion or deletion of one helical turn between the two rightmost binding sites does not alter the efficiency of replication initiation, whereas all modifications of distance by less or more than one helical turn result in inactivation of oriC. DnaA binding and helical distortions in the AT-rich region as well as in the start site region are not affected in the distance mutants irrespective of their functionality in vivo. We propose a specific compact nucleoprotein structure for the initiation complex.     

Stoichiometry of DnaA and DnaB protein in initiation at the Escherichia coli chromosomal origin

Initiation of DNA replication at the Escherichia coli chromosomal origin, oriC, occurs through an ordered series of events that depend first on the binding of DnaA protein, the replication initiator, to DnaA box sequences within oriC followed by unwinding of an AT-rich region near the left border. The prepriming complex then forms, involving the binding of DnaB helicase at oriC so that it is properly positioned at each replication fork. We assembled and isolated the prepriming complexes on an oriC plasmid, then determined the stoichiometries of proteins in these complexes by quantitative immunoblot analysis. DnaA protein alone binds to oriC with a stoichiometry of 4-5 monomers per oriC DNA. In the prepriming complex, the stoichiometries are 10 DnaA monomers and 2 DnaB hexamers per oriC plasmid. That only two DnaB hexamers are bound, one for each replication fork, suggests that the binding of additional molecules of DnaA in forming the prepriming complex restricts the loading of additional DnaB hexamers that can bind at oriC.     

The E. coli cell surface specifically prevents the initiation of DNA replication at oriC on hemimethylated DNA templates

A particular outer membrane fraction previously defined as possessing specific affinity for the hemimethylated form of the origin of replication of the E. coli chromosome (oriC) is shown to inhibit the initiation of DNA synthesis at this site on hemimethylated DNA templates in vitro. The replication of fully methylated or unmethylated DNA templates is not affected. Also, no inhibition is observed if initiation takes place at random sites on the hemimethylated template. The key inactivation step appears to be membrane inhibition of DnaA initiator protein binding to oriC. Remethylation of the membrane-bound hemimethylated DNA results in reactivation. Our results demonstrate direct involvement of the membrane in the control of DNA replication. We propose that association/dissociation of the origin from the cell membrane is one of the control elements governing interinitiation times in E. coli.     

Drunken-cell footprints: nuclease treatment of ethanol-permeabilized bacteria reveals an initiation-like nucleoprotein complex in stationary phase replication origins.

The nucleoprotein complex formed on oriC, the Escherichia coli replication origin, is dynamic. During the cell cycle, high levels of the initiator DnaA and a bending protein, IHF, bind to oriC at the time of initiation of DNA replication, while binding of Fis, another bending protein, is reduced. In order to probe the structure of nucleoprotein complexes at oriC in more detail, we have developed an in situ footprinting method, termed drunken-cell footprinting, that allows enzymatic DNA modifying reagents access to intracellular nucleoprotein complexes in E.coli, after a brief exposure to ethanol. With this method, we observed in situ binding of Fis to oriC in exponentially growing cells, and binding of IHF to oriC in stationary cells, using DNase I and Bst NI endonuclease, respectively. Increased binding of DnaA to oriC in stationary phase was also noted. Because binding of DnaA and IHF results in unwinding of oriC in vitro, P1 endonuclease was used to probe for intracellular unwinding of oriC. P1 cleavage sites, localized within the 13mer unwinding region of oriC ', were dramatically enhanced in stationary phase on wild-type origins, but not on mutant versions of oriC unable to unwind. These observations suggest that most oriC copies become unwound during stationary phase, forming an initiation-like nucleoprotein complex.     

Inactivation of Escherichia coli DnaA protein by DNA polymerase III and negative regulations for initiation of chromosomal replication

Genetic and biochemical evidence indicates that initiation of chromosomal replication in Escherichia coli occurs in a nucleoprotein complex at the replication origin (oriC) formed with DnaA protein. The frequency of initiation at oriC is tightly regulated to only once per chromosome per cell cycle. To prevent untimely, extra initiations, negative control for initiation is indispensable. Recently, we found that the function of the initiator protein, DnaA, is controlled by DNA polymerase III holoenzyme, the replicase of the chromosome. The ATP-bound form of DnaA protein, an active form for initiation, is efficiently converted to the ADP bound form, an inactive form, since a subunit of the polymerase loaded on DNA (beta subunit sliding clamp) stimulates hydrolysis of ATP bound to DnaA protein. Comparison of this system, RIDA (regulatory inactivation of DnaA), with other systems for negative regulation of initiation is included in this review, and the roles of these systems for concerted control for initiation during the cell cycle are discussed.     

The intrinsic ATPase activity of Mycobacterium tuberculosis DnaA promotes rapid oligomerization of DnaA on oriC

Oligomerization of the initiator protein, DnaA, on the origin of replication (oriC) is crucial for initiation of DNA replication. Studies in Escherichia coli (Gram-negative) have revealed that binding of DnaA to ATP, but not hydrolysis of ATP, is sufficient to promote DnaA binding, oligomerization and DNA strand separation. To begin understanding the initial events involved in the initiation of DNA replication in Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Gram-positive), we investigated interactions of M. tuberculosis DnaA (DnaA(TB)) with oriC using surface plasmon resonance in the presence of ATP and ADP. We provide evidence that, in contrast to what is observed in E. coli, ATPase activity of DnaA(TB) promoted rapid oligomerization on oriC. In support, we found that a recombinant mutant DnaA(TB) proficient in binding to ATP, but deficient in ATPase activity, did not oligomerize as rapidly. The corresponding mutation in the dnaA gene of M. tuberculosis resulted in non-viability, presumably due to a defect in oriC-DnaA interactions. Dimethy sulphate (DMS) footprinting experiments revealed that DnaA(TB) bound to DnaA boxes similarly with ATP or ADP. DnaA(TB) binding to individual DnaA boxes revealed that rapid oligomerization on oriC is triggered only after the initial interaction of DnaA with individual DnaA boxes. We propose that ATPase activity enables the DnaA protomers on oriC to rapidly form oligomeric complexes competent for replication initiation.     

Control of the replication initiator DnaA by an anti-cooperativity factor

Proper coordination of DNA replication with cell growth and division is critical for production of viable progeny. In bacteria, coordination of DNA replication with cell growth is generally achieved by controlling activity of the replication initiator DnaA and its access to the chromosomal origin of replication, oriC. Here we describe a previously unknown mechanism for regulation of DnaA. YabA, a negative regulator of replication initiation in Bacillus subtilis, interacts with DnaA and DnaN, the sliding (processivity) clamp of DNA polymerase. We found that in vivo, YabA associated with the oriC region in a DnaA-dependent manner and limited the amount of DnaA at oriC. In vitro, purified YabA altered binding of DnaA to DNA by inhibiting cooperativity. Although previously undescribed, proteins that directly inhibit cooperativity may be a common mechanism for regulating replication initiation. Conditions that cause release of DnaN from the replisome, or overproduction of DnaN, caused decreased association of YabA and increased association of DnaA with oriC. This effect of DnaN, either directly or indirectly, is likely responsible, in part, for enabling initiation of a new round of replication following completion of a previous round.     

The chromosome origin of Escherichia coli stabilizes DnaA protein during rejuvenation by phospholipids.

DnaA protein (the initiator protein) binds and clusters at the four DnaA boxes of the Escherichia coli chromosomal origin (oriC) to promote the strand opening for DNA replication. DnaA protein activity depends on the tight binding of ATP; the ADP form of DnaA protein, generated by hydrolysis of the bound ATP, is inactive. Rejuvenation of ADP-DnaA protein, by replacement with ATP, is catalyzed by acidic phospholipids in a highly fluid bilayer. We find that interaction of DnaA protein with oriC DNA is needed to stabilize DnaA protein during this rejuvenation process. Whereas DnaA protein bound to oriC DNA responds to phospholipids, free DnaA protein is inactivated by phospholipids and then fails to bind oriC. Furthermore, oriC DNA facilitates the high affinity binding of ATP to DnaA protein during treatment with phospholipids. A significant portion of the DnaA protein associated with oriC DNA can be replaced by the ADP form of the protein, suggesting that all of the DnaA protein bound to oriC DNA need not be rejuvenated between rounds of replication.