Preclinical Data on Efficacy of 10 Drug-Radiation Combinations: Evaluations,Concerns, and Recommendations

BACKGROUND: Clinical testing of new therapeutic interventions requires comprehensive, high-quality preclinical data. Concerns regarding quality of preclinical data have been raised in recent reports. This report examines the data on the interaction of 10 drugs with radiation and provides recommendations for improving the quality, reproducibility, and utility of future studies. The drugs were AZD6244, bortezomib, 17-DMAG, erlotinib, gefitinib, lapatinib, oxaliplatin/Lipoxal, sunitinib (Pfizer, Corporate headquarters, New York, NY), thalidomide, and vorinostat. METHODS: In vitro and in vivo data were tabulated from 125 published papers, including methods, radiation and drug doses, schedules of administration, assays, measures of interaction, presentation and interpretation of data, dosimetry, and conclusions. RESULTS: In many instances, the studies contained inadequate or unclear information that would hamper efforts to replicate or intercompare the studies, and that weakened the evidence for designing and conducting clinical trials. The published reports on these drugs showed mixed results on enhancement of radiation response, except for sunitinib, which was ineffective. CONCLUSIONS: There is a need for improved experimental design, execution, and reporting of preclinical testing of agents that are candidates for clinical use in combination with radiation. A checklist is provided for authors and reviewers to ensure that preclinical studies of drug-radiation combinations meet standards of design, execution, and interpretation, and report necessary information to ensure high quality and reproducibility of studies. Improved design, execution, common measures of enhancement, and consistent interpretation of preclinical studies of drug-radiation interactions will provide rational guidance for prioritizing drugs for clinical radiotherapy trials and for the design of such trials.     

Cell therapy in the heart

Cell therapy is emerging as a new strategy to circumvent the adverse effects of heart disease. Many experimental and clinical studies investigating the transplantation of cells into the injured myocardium have yielded promising results. Moreover, data from these reports show that transplanted stem cells can engraft within the myocardium, differentiate into major cardiac cell types, and improve cardiac function. However, results from clinical trials show conflicting results. These trials demonstrate significant improvements in cardiac function for up to 6 months. However, these improved functions were diminished when examined at 18 months. In this review, we will discuss the current literature available on cell transplantation, covering studies ranging from animal models to clinical trials.     

Pooling, meta-analysis, and the evaluation of drug safety

Background  

The "integrated safety report" of the drug registration files submitted to health authorities usually summarizes the rates of adverse events observed for a new drug, placebo or active control drugs by pooling the safety data across the trials. Pooling consists of adding the numbers of events observed in a given treatment group across the trials and dividing the results by the total number of patients included in this group. Because it considers treatment groups rather than studies, pooling ignores validity of the comparisons and is subject to a particular kind of bias, termed "Simpson's paradox." In contrast, meta-analysis and other stratified analyses are less susceptible to bias.     

Design,Analysis, and Reporting of Crossover Trials for Inclusion in a Meta-Analysis

Randomized crossover trials are clinical experiments in which participants are assigned randomly to a sequence of treatments and each participant serves as his/her own control in estimating treatment effect. We need a better understanding of the validity of their results to enable recommendations as to which crossover trials can be included in meta-analysis and for development of reporting guidelines.

Objective

To evaluate the characteristics of the design, analysis, and reporting of crossover trials for inclusion in a meta-analysis of treatment for primary open-angle glaucoma and to provide empirical evidence to inform the development of tools to assess the validity of the results from crossover trials and reporting guidelines.

Methods

We searched MEDLINE, EMBASE, and Cochrane’s CENTRAL register for randomized crossover trials for a systematic review and network meta-analysis we are conducting. Two individuals independently screened the search results for eligibility and abstracted data from each included report.

Results

We identified 83 crossover trials eligible for inclusion. Issues affecting the risk of bias in crossover trials, such as carryover, period effects and missing data, were often ignored. Some trials failed to accommodate the within-individual differences in the analysis. For a large proportion of the trials, the authors tabulated the results as if they arose from a parallel design. Precision estimates properly accounting for the paired nature of the design were often unavailable from the study reports; consequently, to include trial findings in a meta-analysis would require further manipulation and assumptions.

Conclusions

The high proportion of poorly reported analyses and results has the potential to affect whether crossover data should or can be included in a meta-analysis. There is pressing need for reporting guidelines for crossover trials.     

Modeling the response of the Mediterranean fruit fly (Diptera:Tephritidae) to cold treatment

Recent interceptions of live Mediterranean fruit fly, Ceratitis capitata (Wiedemann), larvae in fruit that had been cold-treated during transit from abroad led to a reevaluation of the scientific basis for the relevant regulatory treatment schedules. A time-temperature response surface model based on the original experimental data from 1916 was developed and evaluated based on subsequent experimental trials and recent surveillance data collected from shipping operations. The resultant model is reasonably robust and supports the conclusion that the previous treatment schedule falls short of the intended probit nine level of security. Given the vintage of the data, methodological inconsistencies among studies, and the potential consequences of new introductions, additional research is warranted. Quantitative analysis of the currently available data suggests that future studies regarding the efficacy of cold storage should focus on low-temperature, short-duration treatments, where uncertainty about performance appears greatest. The analysis of subsequent experiments also demonstrates that for cold treatment trials most often resulting in zero survivors, Bayesian statistical methods applied to a series of replicated trials of more manageable size offers a feasible alternative to conducting impracticably large trials.     

Beta-carotene supplementation: a good thing, a bad thing, or nothing?

Available data from several completed large-scale randomized trials indicate that beta-carotene supplementation for durations up to 12 years has no overall benefit in well-nourished populations on the incidence of cardiovascular disease or the middle-to-late stages of carcinogenesis. Several important questions, however, remain unanswered. The post-trial follow-up of completed trials, together with the results of several ongoing trials of beta-carotene supplementation, will contribute reliable information to the totality of evidence from basic research, animal studies, observational epidemiologic studies, and completed trials, thus allowing more rational clinical decisions for individual patients and policy decisions for the health of the general public.     

Estrogens, lipoproteins, and cardiovascular risk factors: an update following the randomized placebo-controlled trials of hormone-replacement therapy

PURPOSE OF REVIEW: The effects of hormone-replacement therapy on cardiovascular risk factors are examined. In an attempt to explain the results of recent randomized controlled trials in which no benefit of hormone-replacement therapy for postmenopausal women has been observed, RECENT FINDINGS: Changes in lipoproteins in response to hormone-replacement therapy have now been analysed for both primary and secondary prevention studies. In none of the large randomized controlled trials was there any effect of hormone-induced changes in low-density lipoprotein, high-density lipoprotein, or triglyceride on clinical outcome. Further detailed studies of lipoprotein metabolism have not revealed any adverse effect of hormone-replacement therapy. Recent analysis of the Heart Estrogen/Progestin-Replacement Study data suggests hormone-replacement therapy reduces the risk of developing diabetes. The effect of hormone-replacement therapy on inflammatory markers and on flow-mediated dilatation is largely beneficial, although the effect on flow-mediated dilatation is modulated according to endothelial function, which is adversely affected by known risk factors, including age and presence of atherosclerosis. In this respect the work on polymorphisms of estrogen receptor-alpha may in due course help to define those women who would benefit most from use of estrogen. Crucially, oral but not transdermal hormone-replacement therapy increases activated protein C resistance independently of the presence of factor V Leiden. This effect increases the risk of venous thromboembolic events, which is reflected in the results of a hospital case control study of thromboembolism. SUMMARY: Despite the outcome of the hormone-replacement therapy trials, recent work has confirmed the putative antiatherogenic effects of hormone-replacement therapy on lipoprotein metabolism. Metabolic differences of route of administration of estrogen, particularly on haemostatic variables, may explain this clinical paradox, which continues to be an important research area.     

The efficiency of pot trials,or trials on undisturbed soil cores,as predictors of crop behaviour in the field

This study compares the efficiency of pot trials in the glasshouse or outdoors, and trials on undisturbed soil cores (100 cm deep; 15 cm wide), at simulating field trials. Yields of spring barley (Hordeum vulgare, cv Julia) were measured at sites on seven soil series on 11 farms, and also on undisturbed soil cores from the same sites, and in pot trials using disturbed soil from the same sites, to ascertain how far data from the core and pot trials (simulation procedures) could be used to generate the models, regressions or generalisations that were produced by more laborious and time-consuming field trials. There was no evidence of interactions between the soil series and simulation procedures. Correlations between field yields and yields from simulation procedures showed that the undisturbed cores gave the highest correlation (r=0.59^**) with field yields. This was followed by yields measured in outdoor pot trials (r=0.36^** and 0.67^** in two years), and by pot trials in the glasshouse (r=0.11 and 0.25, neither significant). In regressions of field yield on yields from simulation trials, the intercept on the field yield axis was lowest for cores and highest for pot trials in the glasshouse. Anovar studies on the partitioning of the total variability in trial yields showed that undisturbed cores gave a partitioning of yields more similar to that of field trials than did the pot trials. In some respects, but not all, core trials also gave the most similar regressions of yield on soil properties to those obtained from field trials. The use of undisturbed cores, collected at sites of interest and carried to a central site, combines the advantages of field trials (natural soil structure and environment) with those of pot trials (standard environment, easier management).     

Compromised ethical principles in randomised clinical trials of distant, intercessory prayer

The effects of distant, intercessory prayer on health outcomes have been studied in a range of randomised, blinded clinical trials. However, while seeking the evidentiary status accorded this 'gold standard' methodology, many prayer studies fall short of the requirements of the World Medical Association's Declaration of Helsinki for the ethical conduct of trials involving human subjects. Within a sample of 15 such studies published in the medical literature, many were found to have ignored or waived key ethical precepts, including adequate standards of care, patient confidentiality and informed consent. Prayer was considered in most studies to pose negligible or no risk to subjects, despite the fact that no clear mechanism of action nor any safety monitoring procedures were described. As a result, many studies did not meet basic ethical standards required of clinical trials of biophysical interventions, making application of their results ethically problematic. If investigators wish their data to adequately inform the use or rejection of intercessory prayer to improve health, these shortcomings should be addressed in future studies.     

Conjectures on some curious connections among social status, calorie restriction, hunger, fatness, and longevity

Since the original publication of the article "Development of the IL-12/23 antagonist ustekinumab in psoriasis: Past, present and future perspectives" in March 2011 (see Appendix),(1) there have been several new publications and developments of note. A number of new reports from the ustekinumab psoriasis clinical development program have been published. The analysis of efficacy and safety in the PHOENIX 1 long-term extension demonstrated that continuous stable maintenance dosing of ustekinumab was generally well tolerated and sustained durable efficacy through up to three years of treatment.(2) Pooled safety data from the phase 2 and phase 3 global trials showed that the safety profile of long-term continuous ustekinumab treatment through up to three years(3,4) and four years(5) of follow-up was favorable and comparable to what has been reported previously in the shorter-term ustekinumab psoriasis studies.(6-8) This represents the greatest exposure and longest follow-up of psoriasis patients treated with a biologic published to date. Additional phase 3 trials in Asian populations demonstrated similar high levels of efficacy and favorable safety profiles in Japanese,(9,10) Korean,(11,12) and Taiwanese(11,12) patients as those observed in trials conducted in mostly White populations in North America and Europe.(6-8) These data support the positive benefit:risk profile and consistency of response to ustekinumab over years of usage, and in multiple ethnic groups. Results from up to five years of treatment with ustekinumab in the long-term extensions of the phase 3 trials, and the efficacy, safety, and effect on quality of life in Chinese patients will be available in 2012. In addition to clinical trials of ustekinumab for the treatment of psoriasis, 24-week data from one phase 3 study of ustekinumab for the treatment of psoriatic arthritis has recently been presented(13) and another study is ongoing. A Phase 2b trial in Crohn's disease has also been presented,(14) and three phase 3 studies in Crohn's disease are currently in progress.     

Progress in clinical trials for coronary arterial restenosis using beta radiation sources

Vascular brachytherapy has yet taken the leap into progression from emerging technology to standard of care dependent on the outcome of clinical trials. Data collected from early pilot trials and on-going clinical trials indicate that such a progression is achievable. Three-year follow-up data from patients treated with intracoronary radiation for the prevention of restenosis are now available. Data from larger trials are being assessed using angiographic and intravascular ultrasound analysis. The beta radiation studies are demonstrating different levels of efficacy, raising new issues regarding dosimetry and potential complications. Past trials have examined the use of vascular brachytherapy for recurrence prevention of restenosis in patients with in-stent restenosis. New data related to the use of liquid-filled balloon systems and radioactive stent are also being collected. This article updates the current status of clinical trials in vascular brachytherapy utilizing beta emitters, highlighting preliminary results and assessing their implications for the development of this field.     

Efficient and robust methods for causally interpretable meta-analysis: Transporting inferences from multiple randomized trials to a target population

We present methods for causally interpretable meta-analyses that combine information from multiple randomized trials to draw causal inferences for a target population of substantive interest. We consider identifiability conditions, derive implications of the conditions for the law of the observed data, and obtain identification results for transporting causal inferences from a collection of independent randomized trials to a new target population in which experimental data may not be available. We propose an estimator for the potential outcome mean in the target population under each treatment studied in the trials. The estimator uses covariate, treatment, and outcome data from the collection of trials, but only covariate data from the target population sample. We show that it is doubly robust in the sense that it is consistent and asymptotically normal when at least one of the models it relies on is correctly specified. We study the finite sample properties of the estimator in simulation studies and demonstrate its implementation using data from a multicenter randomized trial.     

Effectiveness of different accelerated partial breast irradiation techniques for the treatment of breast cancer patients: Systematic review using indirect comparisons of randomized clinical trials

AimThis systematic review was conducted to compare the effectiveness of different accelerated partial breast irradiation (APBI) techniques for the treatment of breast cancer patients.BackgroundNumerous (APBI) techniques are available for clinical practice.Methods and materialsSystematic review of randomized controlled trials of APBI versus whole breast irradiation (WBI). The data from APBI studies were extracted for the analyses. Indirect comparisons were used to compare different APBI techniques.ResultsTen studies fulfilled the inclusion criteria. A total of 4343 patients were included, most of them with tumor stage T1-T2 and N0. Regarding APBI techniques, six trials used external beam radiation therapy; one intraoperative electrons; one intraoperative low-energy photons; one brachytherapy; and one external beam radiation therapy or brachytherapy. The indirect comparisons related to 5-years local control and 5-years overall survival were not significantly different between APBI techniques.ConclusionsBased on indirect comparisons, no differences in clinical outcomes were observed among diverse APBI techniques in published clinical trials that formally compared WBI to APBI. However wide confidence intervals and high risk of inconsistency precluded a sound conclusion. Further head-to-head clinical trials comparing different APBI techniques are required to confirm our findings. Studies comparing different techniques using individual participant data and/or real-life data from population-based studies/registries could also provide more robust results.     

Impact of Including Korean Randomized Controlled Trials in Cochrane Reviews of Acupuncture

Objective

Acupuncture is commonly practiced in Korea and is regularly evaluated in clinical trials. Although many Cochrane reviews of acupuncture include searches of both English and Chinese databases, there is no information on the value of searching Korean databases. This study aimed to investigate the impact of searching Korean databasesand journals for trials eligible for inclusion in existing Cochrane acupuncture reviews.

Methods

We searched 12 Korean databases and seven Korean journals to identify randomised trials meeting the inclusion criteria for acupuncture reviews in the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. We compared risk of bias assessments of the Korean trials with the trials included in the Cochrane acupuncture reviews. Where possible, we added data from the Korean trials to the existing meta-analyses in the relevant Cochrane review and conducted sensitivity analyses to test the robustness of the results.

Results

Sixteen Korean trials (742 participants) met the inclusion criteria for eight Cochrane acupuncture reviews (125 trials; 13,041 participants). Inclusion of the Korean trials provided data for 20% of existing meta-analyses (24 out of 120). Inclusion of the Korean trials did not change the direction of effect in any of the existing meta-analyses. The effect size and heterogeneity remained mostly unchanged. In only one meta-analysis did the significance change. Compared to the studies included in the Cochrane acupuncture reviews, the risk of bias in the Korean trials was higher in terms of outcome assessor blinding and allocation concealment.

Conclusions

Many Korean studies contributed additional data to the existing meta-analyses in Cochrane acupuncture reviews. Although inclusion of these studies did not alter the results of the meta-analyses, comprehensive searches of the literature are important to avoid potential language bias. The identification and inclusion of eligible Korean trials should be considered for reviews of acupuncture.     

The role of pirfenidone in the treatment of idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis

Idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis (IPF) is a progressive disease, with a median survival time of 2–5 years. The search for effective treatment has involved numerous clinical trials of investigational agents without significant success. However, in 2011, pirfenidone was the first drug to be approved for the treatment of IPF in Europe. Four key clinical trials supported the efficacy and tolerability of pirfenidone.In the two recently published Phase III CAPACITY trials evaluating pirfenidone (studies 004 and 006), patients with mild-to-moderate IPF were treated with pirfenidone or placebo. Study 004 and pooled analysis of primary endpoint data from both studies showed that pirfenidone significantly reduced decline in percent-predicted forced vital capacity (FVC) compared with placebo (p<0.005). Evidence of beneficial effects of pirfenidone treatment was also observed with regard to several secondary endpoints. Pirfenidone was generally well tolerated, with the most common side effects being gastrointestinal and photosensitivity. Data from the RECAP extension phase of the CAPACITY studies, where patients were treated with pirfenidone for up to three years, further support the manageable tolerability profile of pirfenidone. The efficacy data, coupled with long-term safety data, provide further evidence of a clinically-meaningful treatment effect with pirfenidone in patients with IPF.     

Effect of electrical stimulation on musculoskeletal systems; a meta-analysis of controlled clinical trials

This study was a meta-analysis to examine whether electrical stimulation has specific effects in the healing of musculoskeletal repair process and in the diminution of symptoms with bone and joint disorders. Using MEDLINE (1966-1999) and EMBASE (1985-1999) a search for articles was carried out with four medical subject headings. Data were extracted from all the accessed articles and additionally collected from appropriate journal lists. A total of 20 randomized controlled trials on bones was identified which assessed healing of fractures, bone graft, and other conditions; and 29 randomized controlled trials on soft tissues and joints were also found, dealing with healing of skin wounds or dermal ulcers, soft tissue injury, and other conditions. Using criteria through which the quality of studies was assessed, the content of the articles was reorganized into a tabular form. The majority of the identified articles reported positive findings, but all the trials showed methodological flaws to some extent. Because of heterogeneity of the studies and the various outcome measurements, pooling of only part of the data was performed. The combined results of 12 trials on bones and 16 trials on soft tissues, the cases in which major endpoints were mainly union or healing rate, revealed statistically significant effects. The studies in this review had some methodological limitations, and the selected pooled trials do not constitute acceptable proof that electrical stimulation has specific effects on health. However, one cannot ignore the statistically significant positive findings reported in the trials, from which extracted data were able to be combined.     

A framework for prospective,adaptive meta-analysis (FAME) of aggregate data from randomised trials

BackgroundThe vast majority of systematic reviews are planned retrospectively, once most eligible trials have completed and reported, and are based on aggregate data that can be extracted from publications. Prior knowledge of trial results can introduce bias into both review and meta-analysis methods, and the omission of unpublished data can lead to reporting biases. We present a collaborative framework for prospective, adaptive meta-analysis (FAME) of aggregate data to provide results that are less prone to bias. Also, with FAME, we monitor how evidence from trials is accumulating, to anticipate the earliest opportunity for a potentially definitive meta-analysis.MethodologyWe developed and piloted FAME alongside 4 systematic reviews in prostate cancer, which allowed us to refine the key principles. These are to: (1) start the systematic review process early, while trials are ongoing or yet to report; (2) liaise with trial investigators to develop a detailed picture of all eligible trials; (3) prospectively assess the earliest possible timing for reliable meta-analysis based on the accumulating aggregate data; (4) develop and register (or publish) the systematic review protocol before trials produce results and seek appropriate aggregate data; (5) interpret meta-analysis results taking account of both available and unavailable data; and (6) assess the value of updating the systematic review and meta-analysis. These principles are illustrated via a hypothetical review and their application to 3 published systematic reviews.ConclusionsFAME can reduce the potential for bias, and produce more timely, thorough and reliable systematic reviews of aggregate data.

Jayne Tierney and coauthors discuss FAME, an approach for adaptive meta-analysis of data from randomised trials.     

Genes, environment, and interactions in prevention of type 2 diabetes: a focus on physical activity and lifestyle changes

Type 2 diabetes is one of the fastest growing public health problems worldwide. Both environmental (e.g. physical activity, obesity, and diet) and genetic factors are involved in the development of type 2 diabetes. The associations between physical activity and diabetes risk have been assessed by a number of prospective studies and clinical trials. The results from these studies consistently indicate that the regular physical activity during occupation, commuting, leisure time or daily life reduces the risk of type 2 diabetes by 15-60%; and lifestyle intervention, including counselling for physical activity, nutrition, and body weight, can reduce the risk of type 2 diabetes by 40-60% among adults with impaired glucose tolerance and by about 20% among general individuals. In the past decade, studies using traditional linkage analysis and candidate-gene association approach have found dozens of genes harboring common variants that were related to the common-form type 2 diabetes. However, most reported associations are lack of reproducibility, except TCF7L2, PPARG, CAPN10, and KCNJ11. Since 2007, seven genome-wide association (GWA) studies emerged to generate a list of new diabetes genes. The genetic effects are largely of moderate size. These findings provide novel insight into the diabetes etiology and pave new avenue for predicting the disease risk using genetic information. In addition, data especially those from intervention trials display preliminary but promising evidence that the genetic variants might interact with physical activity in predisposing to type 2 diabetes. The gene-environment interactions merit extensive exploration in large, prospective studies.     

Spinal Cord Injury: A Review of Current Therapy, Future Treatments, and Basic Science Frontiers

The incidence of acute and chronic spinal cord injury (SCI) in the United States is more than 10,000 per year, resulting in 720 cases per million persons enduring permanent disability each year. The economic impact of SCI is estimated to be more than 4 billion dollars annually. Preclinical studies, case reports, and small clinical trials suggest that early treatment may improve neurological recovery. To date, no proven therapeutic modality exists that has demonstrated a positive effect on neurological outcome. Emerging data from recent preclinical and clinical studies offer hope for this devastating condition. This review gives an overview of current basic research and clinical studies for the treatment of SCI.