Assessing detection methods for gel-based proteomic analyses

Proteomic analyses using two-dimensional gel electrophoresis (2DE) depend heavily upon the quality of protein stains for sensitive detection. Indeed, detection rather than protein resolution is likely a current limiting factor in 2DE. The recent development of fluorescent protein stains has dramatically improved the sensitivity of in-gel protein detection and has enabled more accurate protein quantification. Here, we have evaluated the overall quality and relative cost of five commercially available fluorescent stains, Krypton, Deep Purple, Rubeo, Flamingo, and the most commonly used stain, Sypro Ruby (SR). All stains were found to be statistically comparable with regard to number of protein spots detected, but SR was superior with regard to fluorophore stability (e.g., capacity for repeated use of the stain solution). Notably, colloidal Coomassie Blue was also found to be comparable to SR when detected using an infrared fluorescence imaging system rather than standard densitometry. Thus, depending on available equipment and operating budgets, there are at least two high-sensitivity alternatives to achieve the best currently available in-gel protein detection: Sypro Ruby or Coomassie Blue.     

Comparison of MS/MS methods for protein identification from 2D-PAGE

We have compared the use of a low resolution MALDI-Ion Trap MS/MS and a high-resolution ESI-TOF-MS/MS for the analysis of spots from 2D gels. The main criteria were speed and accuracy of protein identification. The results obtained using the MALDI-MS/MS system are comparable to those from the LC-MS/MS system in terms of accuracy, but less low-level proteins are identified while the time required for the analysis is dramatically reduced.     

Optimization of 2D-PAGE protocols for proteomic analysis of two nonaxenic toxin-producing freshwater cyanobacteria: Cylindrospermopsis raciborskii and Raphidiopsis sp.

Aims:  To optimize a protocol for the extraction and an in-depth analysis of the soluble protein fraction of two nonaxenic toxin-producing cyanobacteria Cylindrospermopsis raciborskii (hepatotoxin-producing), and Raphidiopsis sp. (neurotoxin-producing), using two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (2D-PAGE).
Methods and Results:  The soluble protein fractions from strains of C. raciborskii and Raphidiosis sp. with different toxicity phenotypes were analysed by 2D-PAGE. Specific protocols were optimized specifically for each strain. Between 500 and 700 sharp protein spots were distinguished in a single 4–7 pH range 2D-PAGE for each cyanobacterium. Comparison of the protein maps of C. raciborskii CS-505 (a cylindrospermopsin-producing strain) and Raphidiopsis sp. D9 (saxitoxin-producing strain) against the nontoxic C. raciborskii strain CS-509 revealed many unique proteins in each protein map. We confirmed that the resolved proteins were cyanobacterial by identifying three randomly chosen protein spots from a Raphidiopsis sp. strain D9 2D-PAGE, using high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) tandem mass spectrometry (MS).
Conclusions:  The 2D-PAGE conditions presented here provide a robust protocol for proteomic studies in two CYN- and STX-producing model organisms, C. raciborskii and Raphidiopsis sp.
Significance and Impact of the Study:  We present the first protocols for proteomic analyses of Cylindrospermopsis raciborskii and Raphidiopsis sp.     

DBParser: web-based software for shotgun proteomic data analyses

We describe a web-based program called 'DBParser' for rapidly culling, merging, and comparing sequence search engine results from multiple LC-MS/MS peptide analyses. DBParser employs the principle of parsimony to consolidate redundant protein assignments and derive the most concise set of proteins consistent with all of the assigned peptide sequences observed in an experiment or series of experiments. The resulting reports summarize peptide and protein identifications from multidimensional experiments that may contain a single data set or combine data from a group of data sets, all related to a single analytical sample. Additionally, the results of multiple experiments, each of which may contain several data sets, can be compared in reports that identify features that are common or different. DBParser actively links to the primary mass spectral data and to public online databases such as NCBI, GO, and Swiss-Prot in order to structure contextually specific reports for biologists and biochemists.     

Optimal isolation of mitochondria for proteomic analyses

Considering the key role of mitochondria in cellular (dys)functions, we compared a standard isolation protocol, followed by lysis in urea/detergent buffer, with a commercially available isolation buffer that rapidly yields a mitochondrial protein fraction. The standard protocol yielded significantly better overall resolution and coverage of both the soluble and membrane mitochondrial proteomes; although the kit was faster, it resulted in recovery of only approximately 56% of the detectable proteome. The quality of “omic” analysis depends on sample handling; for large-scale protein studies, well-resolved proteomes are highly dependent on the purity of starting material and the rigor of the extraction protocol.     

STEM: a software tool for large-scale proteomic data analyses

We describe the software, STEM (STrategic Extractor for Mascot's results), which efficiently processes large-scale mass spectrometry-based proteomics data. V (View)-mode evaluates the Mascot peptide identification dataset, removes unreliable candidates and redundant assignments, and integrates the results with key information in the experiment. C (Comparison)-mode compares peptide coverage among multiple datasets and displays proteins commonly/specifically found therein, and processes data for quantitative studies that utilize conventional isotope tags or tags having a smaller mass difference. STEM significantly improves throughput of proteomics study.     

Saturation fluorescence labeling of proteins for proteomic analyses

We present here an optimized and cost-effective approach to saturation fluorescence labeling of protein thiols for proteomic analysis. We investigated a number of conditions and reagent concentrations, including the disulfide reducing agent tris(2-carboxyethyl)phosphine (TCEP), pH, incubation time, linearity of labeling, and saturating dye/protein thiol ratio with protein standards to gauge specific and nonspecific labeling. Efficacy of labeling under these conditions was quantified using specific fluorescence estimation, defined as the ratio of fluorescence pixel intensities and Coomassie-stained pixel intensities of bands after digital imaging. Factors leading to specific versus nonspecific labeling in the presence of thiourea are also discussed. We found that reproducible saturation of available Cys residues of the proteins used as labeling standards (human carbonic anhydrase I, enolase, and α-lactalbumin) is achieved at 50- to 100-fold excess of the uncharged maleimide-functionalized BODIPY dyes over Cys. We confirmed our previous findings, and those of others, that the maleimide dyes are not affected by the presence of 2 M thiourea. Moreover, we established that 2 mM TCEP used as reductant is optimal. We also established that labeling is optimal at pH 7.5 and complete after 30 min. Low nonspecific labeling was gauged by the inclusion of non-Cys-containing proteins (horse myoglobin and bovine carbonic anhydrase) to the labeling mixture. We also showed that the dye exhibits little to no effect on the two-dimensional mobilities of labeled proteins derived from cells.     

2D-difference gel electrophoretic proteomic analysis of a cell culture model of alveolar rhabdomyosarcoma

To evaluate the consequences of expression of the protein encoded by PAX3-FOXO1 (P3F) in the pediatric malignancy alveolar rhabdomyosarcoma (A-RMS), we developed and evaluated a genetically defined in vitro model of A-RMS tumorigenesis. The expression of P3F in cooperation with simian virus 40 (SV40) Large-T (LT) antigen in murine C3H10T1/2 fibroblasts led to robust malignant transformation. Using 2-dimensional-difference gel electrophoresis (2D-DIGE), we compared proteomes from lysates from cells that express P3F + LT versus from cells that express LT alone. Analysis of 2D gel spot patterns by DeCyder image analysis software indicated 93 spots that were different in abundance. Peptide mass fingerprint analysis of the 93 spots by matrix assisted laser desorption ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry (MALDI-TOF MS) analysis identified 37 nonredundant proteins. 2D-DIGE analysis of cell culture media conditioned by cells transduced by P3F + LT versus by LT alone found 29 spots in the P3F + LT cells leading to the identification of 11 nonredundant proteins. A substantial number of proteins with potential roles in tumorigenesis and myogenesis were detected, most of which have not been identified in previous wide-scale expression studies of RMS experimental models or tumors. We validated the 2D gel image analysis findings by Western blot analysis and immunohistochemistry (IHC). Thus, the 2D-DIGE proteomics methodology described here provided an important discovery approach to the study of RMS biology and complements the findings of previous mRNA expression studies.     

Production of polyacrylamide gradient gels for the electrophoretic resolution of lipoproteins.

We describe a protocol to cast nondenaturing polyacrylamide gradient gels (SFBR3/31) for the size resolution of lipoproteins. The protocol yields gels with minimal lot-to-lot variation in length and electrophoretic properties. Absorbance profiles of cholesterol-stained lipoproteins in baboon sera were used to estimate the relative amounts of stain in four lipoprotein size classes (VLDL+LDL, HDL1, HDL2, and HDL3). When compared with gels from a commercial source, the SFBR3/31 gels gave very similar results in terms of precision (coefficients of variation) and of estimated amounts of lipoproteins in the four size classes. In other studies, we estimated peak diameters of protein-stained human lipoproteins after calibrating the gels with size standards. Peak diameters estimated using SFBR3/31 gels were highly correlated (r2 = 0.99, n = 33) with those estimated using gels from a commercial source. We conclude that the protocol reliably produces gradient gels that are suitable for the analysis of lipoprotein phenotypes.     

A review of quantitative methods for proteomic studies

An overview is provided of six strategies for relative or absolute quantitation of protein abundances that are widely used in proteomic studies. Strengths and limitations are discussed. Four of these involve stable isotope labeling and isotope ratio measurements by mass spectrometry. In another, mass spectra are used to deconvolute overlapping peptide HPLC peaks to provide relative quantitation based on peak areas. The sixth provides relative abundances of proteins based on 2-D gel arrays. It should be noted that these strategies measure peptide and protein abundances, and cannot directly assess changes in regulation or expression.     

Genomic and proteomic analyses of the agarolytic system expressed by Saccharophagus degradans 2-40

Saccharophagus degradans 2-40 (formerly Microbulbifer degradans 2-40) is a marine gamma-subgroup proteobacterium capable of degrading many complex polysaccharides, such as agar. While several agarolytic systems have been characterized biochemically, the genetics of agarolytic systems have been only partially determined. By use of genomic, proteomic, and genetic approaches, the components of the S. degradans 2-40 agarolytic system were identified. Five agarases were identified in the S. degradans 2-40 genome. Aga50A and Aga50D include GH50 domains. Aga86C and Aga86E contain GH86 domains, whereas Aga16B carries a GH16 domain. Novel family 6 carbohydrate binding modules (CBM6) were identified in Aga16B and Aga86E. Aga86C has an amino-terminal acylation site, suggesting that it is surface associated. Aga16B, Aga86C, and Aga86E were detected by mass spectrometry in agarolytic fractions obtained from culture filtrates of agar-grown cells. Deletion analysis revealed that aga50A and aga86E were essential for the metabolism of agarose. Aga16B was shown to endolytically degrade agarose to release neoagarotetraose, similarly to a beta-agarase I, whereas Aga86E was demonstrated to exolytically degrade agarose to form neoagarobiose. The agarolytic system of S. degradans 2-40 is thus predicted to be composed of a secreted endo-acting GH16-dependent depolymerase, a surface-associated GH50-dependent depolymerase, an exo-acting GH86-dependent agarase, and an alpha-neoagarobiose hydrolase to release galactose from agarose.     

Plasmid vectors for proteomic analyses in Giardia: purification of virulence factors and analysis of the proteasome

In recent years, proteomics has come of age with the development of efficient tools for purification, identification, and characterization of gene products predicted by genome projects. The intestinal protozoan Giardia intestinalis can be transfected, but there is only a limited set of vectors available, and most of them are not user friendly. This work delineates the construction of a suite of cassette-based expression vectors for use in Giardia. Expression is provided by the strong constitutive ornithine carbamoyltransferase (OCT) promoter, and tagging is possible in both N- and C-terminal configurations. Taken together, the vectors are capable of providing protein localization and production of recombinant proteins, followed by efficient purification by a novel affinity tag combination, streptavidin binding peptide-glutathione S-transferase (SBP-GST). The option of removing the tags from purified proteins was provided by the inclusion of a PreScission protease site. The efficiency and feasibility of producing and purifying endogenous recombinant Giardia proteins with the developed vectors was demonstrated by the purification of active recombinant arginine deiminase (ADI) and OCT from stably transfected trophozoites. Moreover, we describe the tagging, purification by StrepTactin affinity chromatography, and compositional analysis by mass spectrometry of the G. intestinalis 26S proteasome by employing the Strep II-FLAG-tandem affinity purification (SF-TAP) tag. This is the first report of efficient production and purification of recombinant proteins in and from Giardia, which will allow the study of specific parasite proteins and protein complexes.     

Lessons from Kitty Hawk: from feasibility to routine clinical use for the field of proteomic pattern diagnostics

Proteomic pattern diagnostics is a rapidly evolving field of science. Despite the increasingly large number of laboratories reporting exciting success with this concept, recent speculation concerning reproducibility and the nature and identities of the information content of the pattern constituents have served to defocus and polarize the community. These controversies will be rendered obsolete as the field accelerates into a new realm of clinical diagnostics. This new era will see the currently dry biomarker pipeline flooded with new candidate molecules, and the mass spectrometer will continue its maturation into a dominant clinical platform. We reflect on the important lessons gleaned from the Wright brothers' attempts at controlled heavier-than-air flight as a model for perseverance and a view to the very near future for proteomic pattern diagnostics.     

Application of electrophoretic methods for detection of protein-porphyrin complexes

Simple methods for detection and isolation of protein-porphyrin complexes were elaborated in our laboratory. They are based on the separation of protein-porphyrin complexes in native polyacrylamide gel and measurement of their fluorescence, with the use of two detection systems: the commercially available Gel Doc(TM) 2000 system, and a system specially designed for the purpose of these investigations, concerning protein-porphyrin interactions. The fluorescent complexes can be electro-transferred from the gel onto PVDF membrane, eluted and analyzed in order to identify the protein interacting with porphyrins.     

Chromatographic and electrophoretic methods for analysis of superoxide dismutases

A brief overview of the family of superoxide dismutase (SOD) enzymes and their biomedical significance is presented. Methodology for the purification and electrophoretic analysis of superoxide dismutases is reviewed and discussed, with emphasis on the specific problems raised by the separation of individual superoxide dismutase isoenzymes. Purification methods and their performance, as reported in the literature, are summarised in table form. Generally used methods for measuring SOD activity in vitro and SOD visualisation after electrophoresis are outlined, particularly those relevant to the monitoring of progress of SOD purification.     

Simplified enrichment of plasma membrane proteins for proteomic analyses in Arabidopsis thaliana

The plasma membrane (PM) serves as the point of contact between cells and the outside environment. As such, changes in the PM proteome are an important component of understanding cellular responses to a diverse array of stimuli. However, intricate sample handling to enrich PM proteomes by traditional methods is both technically challenging and time consuming. Here, we describe a simplified method for decreasing the representation of other membrane-containing organelles such as the endoplasmic reticulum, plastids and mitochondria from crude microsomal membrane isolations. The decrease in other organellar proteomes results in an increase in both the total number of PM proteins and the number of spectra identified from these proteins representing the PM proteome. Therefore, this strategy represents a simple and rapid method for enriching PM proteins from Arabidopsis cell cultures for proteomic analyses.     

Peptidomic and proteomic analyses of the systemic immune response of Drosophila

Insects have developed an efficient host defense against microorganisms, which involves humoral and cellular mechanisms. Numerous data highlight similarities between defense responses of insects and innate immunity of mammals. The fruit fly, Drosophila melanogaster, is a favorable model system for the analysis of the first line defense against microorganisms. Taking advantages of improvements in mass spectrometry (MS), two-dimensional (2D) gel electrophoresis and bioinformatics, differential analyses of blood content (hemolymph) from immune-challenged versus control Drosophila were performed. Two strategies were developed: (i) peptidomic analyses through matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight (MALDI-TOF) MS and high performance liquid chromatography for molecules below 15 kDa, and (ii) proteomic studies based on 2D gel electrophoresis, MALDI-TOF fingerprinting and database searches, for compounds of greater molecular masses. The peptidomic strategy led to the detection of a large number of peptides induced in the hemolymph of challenged flies as compared to controls. Of these, 28 were characterized, amongst which were antimicrobial peptides. The 2D gel electrophoresis strategy led to the detection of 70 spots differentially regulated by at least fivefold after microbial infection. This approach yielded the identity of a series of proteins that were related to the Drosophila immune response, such as proteases, protease inhibitors, prophenoloxydase-activating enzymes, serpins and a Gram-negative binding protein-like protein. This strategy also brought to light new candidates with a potential function in the immune response (odorant-binding protein, peptidylglycine alpha-hydroxylating monooxygenase and transferrin). Interestingly, several molecules resulting from the cleavage of proteins were detected after a fungal infection. Together, peptidomic and proteomic analyses represent new tools to characterize molecules involved in the innate immune reactions of Drosophila.     

Specificity of Kirkman-Robbins hepatoma non-histone chromatin proteins: electrophoretic and immunological analyses

The specificity of Kirkman-Robbins hepatoma and hamster liver non-histone chromatin proteins has been studied by comparing polypeptide patterns in polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and by their immunological activity in the complement fixation test. Non-histone proteins were separated from DNA with a polyethylene glycol-dextran mixture and fractionated by hydroxylapatite chromatography into three classes named NHCP1, NHCP2, and NHCP3. Electrophoretic analysis indicated that among the non-histone proteins of Kirkman-Robbins hepatoma and hamster liver differences mainly of a quantitative nature can be observed. However, the polypeptides with molecular weight 25 000, 31 000, 36 000, 73 000 in NHCP1; 20 000, 40 000 in NHCP2 and 20 000, 23 000, 32 000, 38 000, 44 000, 75 000, 80 000 in NHCP3 were found to be specific for hepatoma chromatin. Application of antibodies against NHCP1, NHCP2 and dehistonized chromatin of Kirkman-Robbins hepatoma revealed that the highest specificity of NHCP2 eluted from hydroxylapatite with 100 mM phosphate buffer at pH 6.8. The NHCP1 of hepatoma shares some common antigenic determinants with analogous proteins of liver. On the other hand non-histone proteins specific for hepatoma dehistonized chromatin can be localized in the NHCP3 and partially in the NHCP1 fractions.     

Simple standard procedure for the routine determination of organic matter in marine sediment

For the routine determination of organic matter inmarine sediment, a rough estimate is often obtained bymeasuring the loss of weight on ignition(Difference-On-Ignition method: D.O.I.). This D.O.I. is to beused in ecological studies where organic material insediment is used as an environmental variable amongothers. A review of papers using this method showed agreat variability within conditions used. Theseconditions are generally used without accuratejustification. We propose a simple standard procedurebased on grain-size fraction of sediment to determineoptimal temperature and time of ignition, and theinfluence of the sample weight. The method proposed, using the loss of weight on ignition, will give thesame accuracy in measurements of organic matter inmarine sediments.