Molecular organisation of the plant genome: Its relation to structure,recombination and evolution of chromosomes

Large scale changes in nuclear DNA amount accompany the evolution of species of higher plants. Much of the nuclear DNA accrued during the evolution of species does not encode genetic information and is selectively neutral. Nonetheless, the pattern of distribution of the excess DNA within and between chromosome complements suggests that there are rigid constraints underlying evolutionary changes in genome organisation. A five-fold increase in the amount of nuclear DNA has occurred in the evolution ofLathyrus species. Not withstanding this massive DNA variation, species show consistently similar patterns in base sequence proliferation, divergence and DNA distribution within and between chromosome complements. Within chromosome complements, the excess DNA is distributed evenly in all chromosomes irrespective of the large differences in chromosome size and, between complements, DNA distribution is discontinuous; species cluster into DNA groups with remarkably regular intervals. Similar constraints govern the frequency and distribution of chiasmata in the chromosome complements. Between species chiasma frequency and nuclear DNA amounts are not correlated but within complements it is positively correlated with the amount of DNA contained in each chromosome.     

Changes in DNA composition in the evolution of Vicia species

Summary The composition of nuclear DNA in 3 Vicia species are compared. The species V. eriocarpa, V. johannis and V. melanops are from three separate subgeneric sections of Vicia and show a fourfold variation in their amounts of nuclear DNA. DNA melting experiments, buoyant density gradient analysis and Cot reassociation experiments show that the quantitiative change in nuclear DNA between the three species is achieved by changes in the amounts of both repetitive and nonrepetitive DNA sequences. It is suggested that while the increase in the repetitive fraction is achieved by the proliferation of repetitive base sequences the increase in the nonrepetitive fraction is due to the steady accretion of highly diverged base sequences resulting from mutations, deletions, insertions and base sequence rearrangements among families of repetitive sequences.     

Nuclear DNA divergence among Lathyrus species

Among diploid Lathyrus species a threefold variation in nuclear DNA amount is attributable to differences in the amount of repetitive DNA. Cross reassociation among repetitive and among non-repetitive DNA fractions from different species shows substantial divergence in DNA composition. The divergence in base composition is correlated with nuclear DNA amount. The degree of divergence is of the same order of magnitude in both the repetitive and nonrepetitive fractions.     

Studies on DNA sequences in the Osmundaceae

Summary Phylogenetic relationships ofOsmunda cinnamomea, O. claytoniana, andO. regalis were explored by means of DNA sequence comparisons. Hydroxyapatite thermal elution profiles of self-reassociated repetitive DNA fragments were very similar, indicating the absence of gross differences in the amount of recent amplification or addition of repetitive DNA in any of these three genomes. Interspecific DNA sequence comparisons showed, in contrast to our earlier interpretation, that repeated DNA sequences ofO. claytoniana are nearly equally diverged from those ofO. cinnamomea andO. regalis. Differences between repetitive sequences of the three species can be interpreted as reflecting amplification events which occurred subsequent to speciation. The data obtained suggest that the threeOsmunda species most likely arose more or less simultaneously from a common ancestor. These findings were verified in experiments with tracer DNA preparations enriched for single copy sequences. On the basis of the hybridization data presented here and of the fossil record, the rate of single copy sequence divergence in the ferns is comparable to that in the primates, although slower than that observed in other animal taxa. From this first evaluation of rates of DNA evolution in plants it would seem that the rates for plants and animals are roughly comparable. The evidence suggests that species divergence is accompanied by further reiteration of preexisting repeat sequences. The rate of addition of repetitive sequences probably is slower in ferns than in angiosperms. This difference might be attributable to the much larger effective generation time in ferns.     

Constraints upon the organisation and evolution of chromosomes in Allium

Summary In terms of chromosome morphology, karyotype organisation, taxonomy and genetic relationship as judged from chromosome pairing in the Fl hybrid, A. cepa and A.fistulosum are two closely related species. But large variation in nuclear DNA amounts has occurred during the evolution of the two species. A comparison of the molecular composition of DNA in the two species has confirmed that the excess DNA acquired during evolution was predominantly repetitive sequences (sequences which do not encode genetic information). However, its distribution within the chromosome complements was equal in all chromosomes irrespective of the differences in chromosome size. The even distribution of the excess DNA within complements suggests strong constraints underlying evolutionary changes in genome organisation. The nature of the constraints is discussed, and it is shown that such constraints can influence the direction of karyotype evolution during speciation.     

Rapid evolution of a heteroplasmic repetitive sequence in the mitochondrial DNA control region of carnivores

We describe a repetitive DNA region at the 3 end of the mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) control region and compare it in 21 carnivore species representing eight carnivore families. The sequence and organization of the repetitive motifs can differ extensively between arrays; however, all motifs appear to be derived from the core motif ACGT. Sequence data and Southern blot analysis demonstrate extensive heteroplasmy. The general form of the array is similar between heteroplasmic variants within an individual and between individuals within a species (varying primarily in the length of the array, though two clones from the northern elephant seal are exceptional). Within certain families, notably ursids, the array structure is also similar between species. Similarity between species was not apparent in other carnivore families, such as the mustelids, suggesting rapid changes in the organization and sequence of some arrays. The pattern of change seen within and between species suggests that a dominant mechanism involved in the evolution of these arrays is DNA slippage. A comparative analysis shows that the motifs that are being reiterated or deleted vary within and between arrays, suggesting a varying rate of DNA turnover. We discuss the evolutionary implications of the observed patterns of variation and extreme levels of heteroplasmy.By acceptance of this article, the publisher acknowledges the right of the US Government to retain non-exclusive, royalty-free license in and to any copyright covering the article. Correspondence to: A.R. Hoetzel     

Chromosomal DNA variation,genomic constraints and recombination in Lathyrus

There is approximately a doubling of the total nuclear DNA between the 8 Lathyrus species and there are significant differences in the amounts of DNA in euchromatin and heterochromatin. Between the 8 species chiasma frequency and total nuclear DNA are not correlated but within complements it is positively correlated with the amount of DNA in the chromosomes. There is no significant correlation between chiasma frequency and euchromatin DNA nor between chiasma frequency and heterochromatin DNA among species, but among chromosomes, as with total DNA, it is positively correlated with euchromatin DNA and heterochromatin DNA. Results show that despite the large differences in DNA amounts between species there are genomic constraints underlying the frequency and distribution of chiasmata in the chromosome complements.     

The genome of Zea mays,its organization and homology to related grasses

The pattern of genome organization of Zea mays has been analyzed, and the relationship of maize to possible progenitor species assessed by DNADNA hybridization. Reassociation of 470 and 1,350 bp fragments of maize DNA to various C₀t values demonstrates that the genome is composed of 3 major kinetic classes: highly repetitive, mid-repetitive, and unique. Mini-C₀t curves of the repetitive sequences at short fragment length indicate that the highly repetitive sequence class is 20% of the genome and is present at an average reiteration frequency of 800,000 copies; the mid-repetitive sequence class is 40% of the genome and is present at an average reiteration frequency of 1,000 copies. Thermal denaturation studies show that the highly repetitive sequences are 12% divergent and mid-repetitive sequences are 6% divergent. Most of the genome is organized in two interspersion patterns. One, approximately one-third of the genome, is composed of unique sequences of average length 2,100 bp interspersed with mid-repetitive sequences; the other, also one-third of the genome, is mid-repetitive sequences interspersed with highly repetitive sequences. The repetitive sequences are 500 to 1,000 bp by electron microscopic measurement. The remaining third of the genome is unique sequences farther than 5,000 bp from a palindromic or repetitive sequence. Hybridization of maize DNA from Midwestern Dent to popcorn and related grasses indicates that both the unique and repetitive sequence elements have diverged. Teosinte and popcorn are approximately equally divergent from Midwestern Dent whereas Tripsacum is much more divergent. The divergence times calculated from the depression of T_m in heterologous duplexes indicate that the divergence within Zea mays and between maize and near relatives is at least an order of magnitude greater than expected. This high degree of divergence may reflect the pressures of domestication of maize.     

Nuclear DNA variation in Lathyrus

In the genus Lathyrus the divergence and evolution of species was accompanied by large scale changes in nuclear DNA amount. All the species are diploids with 14 chromosomes so that the DNA changes were the result of amplification or deletion of segments within chromosomes. Our evidence indicates that the quantitative changes involve mainly the repetitive, as distinct from the non-repetitive fraction of the chromosomal DNA and, on a cytological basis, mainly heterochromatin in contrast to euchromatin. There is an element of discontinuity in the distribution of DNA amounts among species which suggests that the DNA variation results from a series of separate, spasmodic events. The discontinuities may be viewed, also, as steady states from the standpoint of genetic balance and biological fitness.     

Nuclear DNA changes within Helianthus annuus L.: variations in the amount and methylation of repetitive DNA within homozygous progenies

Complex alterations in the redundancy and methylation of repeated DNA sequences were shown to differentiate the nuclear genome of individuals belonging to single progenies of homozygous plants of the sunflower. DNA was extracted from seedlings obtained from seeds collected at the periphery of flowering heads (P DNA) or from seedlings obtained from seeds collected in their middle (M DNA). Three fractions of repeated sequences were isolated from genomic DNA: a highly repetitive fraction (HR), which reassociates within an equivalent Cot of about 2 × 10^-1, and two medium repetitive fractions (MR1 and MR2) having Cot ranges of about 2 × 10^-1-2 and 2-10², respectively. Denaturation kinetics allowed different sequence families to be recognized within each fraction of repetitive DNA, and showed significant differences in sequence redundancy to occur between P and M DNA, particularly as far as the MR2 fraction is concerned. Most DNA sequence families are more represented in P DNA than in M DNA. However, the redundancy of certain sequences is greater in the latter than in the former. Each repetitive DNA fraction was hybridized to Southern blots of genomic P or M DNA which was digested to completion by three pairs of isoschizomeric restriction endonucleases which are either insensitive or sensitive to the methylation of a cytosine in the recognition site. The results obtained showed that the repetitive DNA of H. annuus is highly methylated. Clear-cut differences in the degree of methylation of P and M DNA were found, and these differences were particularly apparent in the MR2 fraction. It is suggested that alterations in the redundancy of given DNA sequences and changes in their methylation patterns are complementary ways to produce continuous genotypic variability within the species which can be exploited in environmental adaptation.Research supported by National Research Council of Italy, Special Project RAISA, Sub-project No. 2     

Sequence analysis of Vicia faba highly repeated DNA: the BamHI repeated sequence families

Cleavage of Vicia faba nuclear DNA with the restriction endonuclease BamHI yielded discrete size classes of 250, 850, 900, 990, 1 150, 1 500 and 1 750 bp of highly repetitive DNA. Each of these sequence families comprised about 3% of the total genomic DNA. Some sequence members from each sequence family were cloned in pBR322 and their primary structures determined. Computer analyses of nucleotide sequences suggested the existence of about 60 bp sequence periodicity within the repeating unit of the 990 bp sequence family, though the extent of homology among the surmised shorter subrepeat units was very low. With other BamHI sequence families, however, the data did not show any clear internal sequence periodicity. The repeat units of the 850 bp and 1 750 bp sequence families contained nucleotide sequences homologous to the 250 bp family sequence. No sequence relationship between or among other sequence families was observed. There was 13–25% sequence variation among 6 cloned members of the 250 bp family and probably also among those of other BamHI repeat families. DNA sequences homologous to these V. faba BamHI repeat families were detected in Pisum sativum DNA by Southern blot hybridization. Furthermore, very weak cross-hybridization was observed with plant DNAs from Phaseolus vulgaris, Triticum aestivum, Cucumis sativus and Trillium kamtschaticum.     

Reduced Rates of Sequence Evolution of Y-Linked Satellite DNA in Rumex (Polygonaceae)

One characteristic of sex chromosomes is the accumulation of a set of different types of repetitive DNA sequences in the Y chromosomes. However, little is known about how this occurs or about how the absence of recombination affects the subsequent evolutionary fate of the repetitive sequences in the Y chromosome. Here we compare the evolutionary pathways leading to the appearance of three different families of satellite-DNA sequences within the genomes of Rumex acetosa and R. papillaris, two dioecious plant species with a complex XX/XY₁Y₂ sex-chromosome system. We have found that two of these families, one autosomic (the RAE730 family) and one Y-linked (the RAYSI family), arose independently from the ancestral duplication of the same 120-bp repeat unit. Conversely, a comparative analysis of the three satellite-DNA families reveals no evolutionary relationships between these two and the third, RAE180, also located in the Y chromosomes. However, we have demonstrated that, regardless of the mechanisms that gave rise to these families, satellite-DNA sequences have different evolutionary fates according to their location in different types of chromosomes. Specifically, those in the Y chromosomes have evolved at half the rate of those in the autosomes, our results supporting the hypothesis that satellite DNAs in nonrecombining Y chromosomes undergo lower rates of sequence evolution and homogenization than do satellite DNAs in autosomes.[Reviewing Editor: DR. Jerzy Jurka]     

DNA characterization in host-specificViscum album subspecies (Viscaceae)

The nuclear DNA content and composition with respect to base composition and the proportion of repetitive DNA was studied in the host-specific mistletoe subspecies,Viscum album subsp.album, V. a. subsp.abietis andV. a. subsp.laxum, using DNA ofLoranthus europaeus as a standard. Small but not significant differences were found between the 2C DNA contents and the base composition but significant differences were detected in the patterns of sequence organization. This infraspecific variation is briefly discussed in the light of differences known to occur in the patterns of lectins and viscotoxins, immunostimulating and cancerostatic effects.     

DNA analysis methods for recognizing species invasion: the example of Codium,and generally applicable methods for algae

Analysis of DNA can help to distinguish those morphological characters indicative of species difference from those representing retained traits or parallel evolution. This can be of great value in detecting recent invaders. The choice of which DNA characters to examine not only dictates the methodology to be used but must also be appropriate for the detection level sought. Restriction endonuclease fragment comparisons of plastid DNA have been used to assess Codium species; the results show C. fragile subsp. tomentosoides from east and west coast North America to be identical while sympatric endemic Codium species each display their own unique set of fragments. For species of other algae, plastid DNA fragment patterns are not necessarily identical across a morphological species, e.g. Pandorina morum. Such repetitive element probes as M13 and the use of RAPDs are more appropriate for analysis of populations within species. DNA base sequence comparisons of nuclear rDNA genes often yield too few variant bases between closely related species for reliable identifications. Analysis of the more variable Internal Transcribed Spacer (ITS) region, lying between the small and large ribosomal subunit genes in nuclear DNA, yields more extensive base pair variation between species and relatively little within species; it may be an alternative choice for endonuclease restriction fragment analysis or for sequencing.     

DNA Sequence Comparison among Closely Related Drosophila Species in the MULLERI Complex

DNA hybridization was used to establish DNA sequence relationships among seven Drosophila species. Single-copy DNA was isolated from four species within the Drosophila mulleri complex, D. mojavensis, D. arizonensis, D. ritae and D. starmeri. These single-copy DNAs were used as tracers to be hybridized with each other and one additional member of the mulleri complex, D. aldrichi, a member of a closely related complex, D. hydei, and a distantly related species, D. melanogaster. Two methods have been used to determine the relatedness between these species: (1) the extent of duplex formed as measured by binding to hydroxyapatite and (2) the thermal stability of the duplexed DNA. Moderately repetitive DNA was purified from these species and used similarly to determine the divergence of this family of sequences. The rate of nucleotide substitution was estimated to be 0.2 +/-, 0.1% base pair change per million years for both single-copy and middle-repetitive DNAs. The size of the D. arizonensis genome, a representative of the mulleri complex, was calculated to be 2.2 X 10(8) base pairs from its kinetic complexity similar to that of D. hydei. The relative amounts (18%) and average reiteration frequency (100 copies) of the middle-repetitive DNA are similar for all Drosophila species studied. Finally, the data are presented in a phylogenetic tree.     

Characteristics of nuclear DNA in the genus Oryza

Summary DNAs have been isolated from various Oryza species and studied using physical techniques. The percent of guanine plus cytosine has been determined by thermal denaturation. While the base composition varied between the species, no heterogeneity in the base pair distribution was observed. Renaturation kinetics data of DNAs from different species show that the proportion of repeated DNA sequences vary considerably depending on the DNA content per cell, whereas the nonrepetitive DNA component remains relatively constant. These results suggest that in addition to a small range of DNA variation between the species, changes in the base composition and proportion of repeated sequences have accompanied divergence of the species within the genus.     

In vitro and in vivo analysis of transcription within the replication region of plasmid pIP501

Summary The tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum) nuclear genome contains long tracts of DNA (i.e. in excess of 18 kb) with high sequence homology to the tobacco plastid genome. Five lambda clones containing these nuclear DNA sequences encompass more than one-third of the tobacco plastid genome. The absolute size of these five integrants is unknown but potentially includes uninterrupted sequences that are as large as the plastid genome itself. An additional sequence was cloned consisting of both nuclear and plastid-derived DNA sequences. The nuclear component of the clone is part of a family of repeats, which are present in about 400 locations in the nuclear genome. The homologous sequences present in chromosomal DNA were very similar to those of the corresponding sequences in the plastid genome. However significant sequence divergence, including base substitutions, insertions and deletions of up to 41 bp, was observed between these nuclear sequences and the plastid genome. Associated with the larger deletions were sequence motifs suggesting that processes such as DNA replication slippage and excision of hairpin loops may have been involved in deletion formation.     

Generation of VNTRs and heteroplasmy by sequence turnover in the mitochondrial control region of two elephant seal species

We describe an unusual repetitive DNA region located in the 3′ end of the light (L)-strand in the mitochondrial control region of two elephant seal species. The array of tandem repeats shows both VNTR (variable-number tandem repeat) and sequence variation and is absent from 12 compared mammalian species, except for the occurrence in the same location of a distinct repetitive region in rabbit mtDNA and a similar repeat in the harbor seal. The sequence composition and arrangement of the repeats differ considerably between the northern elephant seal (Mirounga angustirostris) and the southern species (M. leonina) despite an estimated divergence time of 1 MY (based on an mtDNA-RNA gene and the nonrepetitive control region). Analysis of repeat sequence relationships within and between species indicate that divergence in sequence and structure of repeats has involved both slippagelike and unequal crossingover processes of turnover, generating very high levels of divergence and heteroplasmy. Presented at the NATO Advanced Research Workshop onGenome Organization and Evolution, Spetsai, Greece, 16–22 September 1992     

DNA sequences repaired at pachytene exhibit strong homology among distantly related higher plants

Moderately repetitive DNA sequences in Lilium (cv Enchantment) which undergo a meiotic-specific repair synthesis during pachytene (P-DNA) were previously shown to exist as families of very low internal sequence divergence. The present study concerns P-DNA sequence preservation among higher plants. The relative abundance of these sequences in a variety of plant species and their divergence relative to Enchantment P-DNA was determined through C₀t analysis and thermal denaturation of hybrid duplexes. Nearly all of the P-DNA sequence families of Enchantment were found to be present in the genomes of a number of monocot species and the dicot Vicia faba. Sequence content is highly conserved, with less than 6% divergence between Lilium and distantly related species such as Zea mays and Secale cereale. However, the number of repeats per P-DNA family varies considerably in different species, being particularly low among the Poales. P-DNA differs from most high thermal stability (HTS) sequence families of Enchantment which, although exhibiting a high degree of internal homology, are not present as repetitive DNA in the genomes of the other species examined. For most HTS families, the lack of internal divergence probably reflects their fairly recent introduction into the moderately repetitive DNA class, while P-DNA sequences represent evolutionarily ancient families which are the products of strong selective pressure for an indispensable meiotic function.     

High mitochondrial diversity in geographically widespread butterflies of Madagascar: A test of the DNA barcoding approach

The standardized use of mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase subunit I (COI) gene sequences as DNA barcodes has been widely promoted as a high-throughput method for species identification and discovery. Species delimitation has been based on the following criteria: (1) monophyletic association and less frequently (2) a minimum 10× greater divergence between than within species. Divergence estimates, however, can be inflated if sister species pairs are not included and the geographic extent of variation within any given taxon is not sampled comprehensively. This paper addresses both potential biases in DNA divergence estimation by sampling range-wide variation in several morphologically distinct, endemic butterfly species in the genus Heteropsis, some of which are sister taxa. We also explored the extent to which mitochondrial DNA from the barcode region can be used to assess the effects of historical rainforest fragmentation by comparing genetic variation across Heteropsis populations with an unrelated forest-associated taxon Saribia tepahi. Unexpectedly, generalized primers led to the inadvertent amplification of the endosymbiont Wolbachia, undermining the use of universal primers and necessitating the design of genus-specific COI primers alongside a Wolbachia-specific PCR assay. Regardless of the high intra-specific genetic variation observed, most species satisfy DNA barcoding criteria and can be differentiated in the nuclear phylogeny. Nevertheless, two morphologically distinguishable candidate species fail to satisfy the barcoding 10× genetic distance criterion, underlining the difficulties of applying a standard distance threshold to species delimitation. Phylogeographic analysis of COI data suggests that forest fragmentation may have played an important role in the recent evolutionary diversification of these butterflies. Further work on other Malagasy taxa using both mitochondrial and nuclear data will provide better insight into the role of historical habitat fragmentation in species diversification and may potentially contribute to the identification of priority areas for conservation.