The in vivo elimination of CD4+ T cells prevents the induction but not the expression of carrier-induced epitopic suppression.

Injection of mice with an immunogenic dose of carrier (keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH)) followed by immunization with hapten-carrier conjugate (TNP-KLH) selectively suppresses anti-hapten antibody response. In this study, the cellular basis of this epitopic suppression and also of the suppression induced by a high dose of carrier were analyzed by in vivo depletion of CD4+ or CD8+ T cell subsets by using mAb. The mAb treatments were performed either at the time of carrier priming or at the time of hapten-carrier immunization. The elimination of CD8+ T cells has not modified the anti-carrier antibody response, whether this treatment was performed at the time of KLH-priming or during TNP-KLH immunization. Moreover, the in vivo treatment with the anti-CD8 mAb did not modify the carrier-induced epitopic suppression induced either by a low immunogenic dose of KLH or by a high dose of this Ag. The elimination of CD4+ T cells at the time of KLH immunization has prevented the induction of a memory response to KLH, clearly establishing that CD4+ T cells are essential in memory B cell development to T-dependent Ag. Moreover, this treatment has totally abrogated the epitopic suppression induced either by low or high dosages of KLH. In contrast, the in vivo elimination of CD4+ T cells after carrier immunization did not abolish the secondary anti-carrier antibody response and did not prevent the expression of epitopic suppression. These data indicate that primed CD4+ T cells are required neither for memory B cell expression nor for the expression of suppression. Finally, once induced, the suppression can be evidenced after in vivo depletion of both primed CD4+ and CD8+ T cells. These data support the view that epitopic suppression is induced through the expansion of carrier-specific B cells and resulted from intramolecular antigenic competition between hapten and carrier epitopes.     

Mast cell migration from the skin to the draining lymph nodes upon ultraviolet irradiation represents a key step in the induction of immune suppression

The UV radiation in sunlight is the primary cause of skin cancer. UV is also immunosuppressive and numerous studies have shown that UV-induced immune suppression is a major risk factor for skin cancer induction. Previous studies demonstrated that dermal mast cells play a critical role in the induction of immune suppression. Mast cell-deficient mice are resistant to the immunosuppressive effects of UV radiation, and UV-induced immune suppression can be restored by injecting bone marrow-derived mast cells into the skin of mast cell- deficient mice. The exact process however, by which mast cells contribute to immune suppression, is not known. In this study, we show that one of the first steps in the induction of immune suppression is mast cell migration from the skin to the draining lymph nodes. UV exposure, in a dose-dependent manner, causes a significant increase in lymph node mast cell numbers. When GFP(+) skin was grafted onto mast cell-deficient mice, we found that GFP(+) mast cells preferentially migrated into the lymph nodes draining the skin. The mast cells migrated primarily to the B cell areas of the draining nodes. Mast cells express CXCR4(+) and UV exposure up-regulated the expression of its ligand CXCL12 by lymph node B cells. Treating UV-irradiated mice with a CXCR4 antagonist blocked mast cell migration and abrogated UV-induced immune suppression. Our findings indicate that UV-induced mast cell migration to draining lymph nodes, mediated by CXCR4 interacting with CXCL12, represents a key early step in UV-induced immune suppression.     

The role of lymphoid cells in antibody-induced suppression of the fourth component of guinea pig complement

Many laboratories have demonstrated that immunoglobulin production by B cells is controlled by networks of interacting lymphocytes and their products. Our laboratory has demonstrated that complement components produced by macrophages are also regulated by networks of interacting cells and humoral factors. Treatment of mice in vivo or guinea pig cells in vitro with anticomponent antibody specifically inhibits synthesis and secretion of the component by macrophages. We have further characterized the cellular basis for in vitro suppression of the fourth component of guinea pig complement. C4 suppression has been accomplished with dispersed spleen cells as well as intact splenic fragments. This facilitated examination of the cells responsible for long-term C4 suppression. The data suggested that C4 suppression required either cell contact or sufficient concentrations of soluble factors. Long-term suppression of C4 depends upon a lymphoid cell contained in the spleen and in lymph nodes but absent or in insufficient concentration in the peritoneum. The lymphocyte that actively maintains suppression was negative for the guinea pig T-cell marker detected by the monoclonal antibody mc8BE6. Therefore, the critical cell is either another T-cell subset or non-T lymphocyte. These data demonstrate that a network of interacting cells analogous to that proposed to regulate antibody synthesis is also involved in regulating some nonlymphoid cell products.     

Mechanism of neonatal idiotype suppression. II. Alterations in the T cell compartment suppress the maturation of B cell precursors

The cellular mechanism in neonatally suppressed BALB/c mice, which maintains the chronic suppressed state of the TEPC-15 idiotype in the antibody response to phosphorylcholine (PC), was investigated. Cells taken from these suppressed mice cannot transfer suppression to adult BALB/c or affect the in vitro response to PC of adult BALB/c spleen cells. However, spleen cells or T cells from neonatally suppressed mice given to neonatal animals induce chronic suppression of the TEPC-15 idiotype in the anti-PC response. Co-transfer of T cells from neonatally suppressed cells with normal T cells prevented the induction of suppression in neonates. Transfer of T cells from normal or keyhole limpet hemocyanin-primed BALB/c increased the expression of TEPC-15 idiotype in chronically suppressed mice, whereas T cells from neonatally suppressed were ineffective. These findings show that T cells in neonatally suppressed mice can affect the development of immature but not mature cells. The restoration of TEPC-15 expression in neonatally suppressed animals by normal T cells and the failure to induce suppression in neonates by co-transfers of T cells from normal and chronically suppressed mice demonstrate the profound role of an altered T cell compartment in sustaining chronic idiotype suppression.     

Role of self carriers in the immune response and tolerance. VIII. Suppression of the MOPC-104E idiotypic response by idiotype-modified self, but not by dextran-modified self

We have investigated the suppression of the anti-dextran B1355S immune response using our model of modified self. The anti-dextran response is idiotypically well defined in BALB/c mice. This system enables us to examine the contribution of various predominant idiotypes to the antibody response under conditions of suppression by antigen or by idiotype-specific suppressor cells. Our results demonstrate that the total anti-dextran response can be inhibited by pretreatment of animals with dextran-coupled syngeneic spleen cells; however, the representation of major idiotypes constituting this response are not reduced in percentage. In contrast, pretreatment of mice with MOPC-104E-coupled spleen cells leads to a specific suppression of the private IdI-104E idiotype. The total anti-dextran response remains unchanged, as well as proportions of other major idiotypes known (IdI-588 and IdX). This suppression is mediated by Thy-1.2+, Lyt-2.2+ T cells, as demonstrated by adoptive transfer assays. This system will allow the molecular dissection of the regulation of an idiotypically well-defined system for the suppression by either antigen- or idiotype-specific suppressor T cells.     

The role of the thymus in the establishment of suppressor cells in liver chimeras.

The role of the thymus in the establishment of specific suppression was studied in an experimental model in which lethally irradiated F1 mice were reconstituted with parental C57BL neonatal liver cells and then challenged with immunocompetent spleen cells syngeneic to the donor. In this model, inhibition of a graft-versus-host response by these spleen cells served as an indication of the establishment of a suppressive state towards syngeneic antigens in the liver chimeras. It was demonstrated that since thymectomy of the chimeras could not prevent the elicitation of a graft-versus-host response by spleen cells, the thymus is essential for the establishment of this specific suppression. Reconstitution of such chimeras with intact thymus grafts of either donor (C57BL) or host (F1) origin led to the inhibition of the graft-versus-host response and to the reappearance of the suppressive state. Removal of the thymus in intact liver chimeras after establishment of a suppressive state did not affect suppression. Thus, it was concluded that the thymus is needed in the chimeras during a critical period in the development of suppression. Once suppression is established, the presence of the thymus is no longer required.     

Activation of human B lymphocytes. III. Concanavalin A-induced generation of suppressor cells of the plaque-forming cell response of normal human B lymphocytes.

Con A-induced suppression of the direct PFC response to polyclonal stimulation in human B cells has been described. Two types of experiments are presented. First, Con A was added directly to PWM-stimulated PB or tonsil cells resulting in a dose-dependent suppression of the PFC response, with maximal suppression occurring at a Con A concentration of 10 mug/ml. This suppression is completely removed by the simultaneous addition of alphaMM to the cultures. Secondly, Con A stimulation of tonsil or PB lymphocytes generated a population of cells which when added to autologous lymphocyte cultures induced a marked and reproducible suppression of the PFC response. The generation of suppressor cells is dependent on cell division and is blocked by alpha MM. Once generated the process of suppression is indpendent of the presence of Con A itself and is mediated by an activated lymphocyte population. These studies demonstrate a simple and reproducible model for the generation of a population of suppressor cells capable of inhibiting the direct PFC response to PWM-induced polyclonal activation of normal human B lymphocytes.     

The action of tuftsin on the reaction of macrophage-suppressor formation in vitro and in vivo

A cell suspension consisting of nonadhering and adhering spleen cells in the ratio 30:1 was incubated in a 10(-4) M tuftsin's solution during 15-30 min. The addition of 10(7) cells incubated in tuftsin syngeneic recipients resulted in the suppression of the immune response of the latter to sheep red blood cells. It was noted that this effect may be induced by using adhering cells only of intact donors and only when incubated together with nonadhering cells. The addition of tuftsin one hour after transplantation of the nonadhering spleen cells resulted in the suppression of the immune response. It was proposed, that suppression effect released through generation of the macrophage-suppressors.     

The nature of the interaction between suppressor and helper T cells in the response to LDHB

Purified Lyt-1+2+ T cells were depleted of alloreactive cells by BUdR and light treatment, and then were primed in vitro against LDHB presented on allogeneic APC. Such cells could be restimulated by LDHB on the same allogeneic APC, but not by LDHB on APC syngeneic with the T cells. The restimulated T cells suppressed the proliferative response of Lyt-1+2- T cells primed and restimulated by the same antigen. The suppression, which was antigen specific, occurred after a 6-hr co-culture of the suppressor (Tse) and proliferating helper (Th) cells. The successful interaction (as measured by suppression) between allogeneic Th and Tse cells was found to be determined by the restriction specificity but not the MHC haplotype of Th cells, and the MHC haplotype but not the restriction specificity of Tse cells. Thus, suppression occurred only when the Tse cells carried genes controlling the MHC molecules that served as restriction elements for antigen recognition by the Th cells. No evidence could be obtained for the participation of APC in the Tse-Th interaction. The data suggest the interaction is based on the recognition by the Th cell of the antigen presented in the context of MHC molecules controlled by the Tse cell.     

Mechanism for the suppression of gamma-interferon responsiveness in mice after thermal injury

As reported previously, gamma-interferon production was decreased after the administration of inducers to thermally injured mice as compared with noninjured controls. Similarly, spleen cells from injured mice had decreased ability to produce interferon in vitro after stimulation with inducers. The present study demonstrated that the decrease in interferon production was associated with the presence of suppressor cells in the spleen of burned mice that were capable of inhibiting interferon production by normal splenic lymphocytes in vitro. Passive transfer of spleen cells containing suppressor cell activity derived from injured mice induced suppression in normal mice, and the time of the appearance of suppressor cell activity in injured mouse spleens closely approximated the time of the appearance of the suppression of interferon production observed in mice after thermal injury. The suppressor cells were characterized as a population of macrophages by the following: they adhered to plastic surface and could be removed from spleen cells by carbonyl-iron treatment; treatment of plastic-adherent cells with anti-Thy-1.2 and anti-mouse immunoglobulin antisera followed by complement failed to abrogate the suppression produced by these cells.     

Regulation of human natural killing. II. Protective effect of interferon on NK cells from suppression by PGE2

Activation of human natural killer (NK) cells in vitro with interferon (IFN) and poly I:C results in a partial loss of sensitivity of these cells to suppression by PGE2. The acquired resistance to suppression can be induced with the large granular lymphocytes (LGL) in the absence of monocytes. With K562, HSB, and CEM used as NK target cells, the IFN-induced resistance to suppression by PGE2 is observed with all three target cells. Furthermore, ADCC activity of IFN-activated cells against tumor (SB-TNP) and erythroid (CRC-TNP) target cells is also less susceptible to suppression by PGE2. The dual effect of IFN on NK cells is prompt; the augmentation of NK activity and the acquired resistance to suppression by PGE2 can be seen after 3 hr of treatment with IFN. Both of these characteristics seem to be quite stable for at least 24 hr. Spleen cells from mice (CBA, C3H, and BALB/c nude) treated in vivo with poly I:C also acquire partial resistance to suppression by PGE2. Our data therefore suggest that IFN-stimulated NK cells are protected from suppression by PGE2. Biologically, the IFN-induced protective effect may be beneficial to host resistance to neoplasia.     

Comparative study of the influence of renal endogenic factors on the proliferation activity of epithelial cells

The proliferation activity of monolayer culture of Madin Darby Canine Kidney (MDSK) cells is suppressed by a thermostable protein factor of renal tissue of white rats and of humans. Under the influence of renal factors (RF), a decrease in cell number, and suppression of DNA synthesis and mitotic activity in MDCK cells occur. The inhibition of proliferative activity of cultured cells under the influence of RF was substantiated also by MTT assay. It was established that the inhibitory influence of RF is stipulated by suppression of RNA synthesis. It follows that RF may inhibit division of MDCK cells via suppression of gene expression in G1-phase. Similar factors were obtained from renal cells of different systematic groups of organisms (snail, frog, fish, pigeon, guinea pig, swine).     

Analysis of the cellular interactions involved in the regulation of induced erythrocyte autoantibodies

When normal mice are immunised with rat red blood cells (RBC) they produce autoantibodies against their own red blood cells as well as antibodies against determinants on rat RBC non-cross-reacting with self-RBC. Spleen cells from mice primed with rat RBC specifically suppress the subsequent induction of autoantibody in normal mice. The response to non-cross-reacting determinants on rat RBC is not affected. The results presented here indicate that either T cells or a thymus have to be present in the recipient for suppression to be manifest. It may therefore be the case that suppression is in fact induced in the recipient by the primed T cells.     

Chromosome balance and the control of malignancy.

The Giemsa banding pattern of the chromosomes has been analyzed in a line of transformed golden hamster cells, revertant and re-revertant cells and their tumors. The transformed and re-revertant cells were malignant in vivo and had gained an additional chromosome 5(7). Revertants with a suppression of malignancy lost this additional chromosome 5(7) and gained an additional chromosome 7(2). The tumors produced by segregants from the revertant cells were malignant, although to a lower degree than transformed and re-revertant cells. These tumors had lost the additional chromosome 7(2) found in revertants and gained one or two 5(12) chromosomes. The results support the hypothesis that the balance between genes for expression and suppression controls malignancy. The data indicate that chromosome 7(2) carries genes for suppression and that chromosomes 5(7) and 5(12) carry genes for expression of malignancy. The genes on chromosome 5(7) seem to result in a greater degree of expression than the genes on chromosome 5(12). The chromosome balance that controlled malignancy in these cells, also controlled the expression and suppression of transformed properties in vitro.     

Transfer of agammaglobulinemia in the chicken. II. Characterization of the target of suppression

The T-independent adoptive primary and secondary responses of FP chicken spleen cells to B. abortus (BA) were suppressed by simultaneously transferred histocompatible spleen cells from agammaglobulinemic (Aγ) chickens previously injected with bursa cells. The response of spleen cells transferred with BA 2 days prior to suppressor cells was partially inhibited. Highly significant suppression of both 19 S and 7 S antibody formation was seen during the second week after memory cell transfer. When suppressor cells and primed spleen cells were transferred together and challenged with BA 2 weeks later the secondary responses were more inhibited in recipients that showed persistently decreased serum IgM than in those showing recovery toward normal IgM levels. Transfer of histocompatible suppressor cells into surgically bursectomized (SBX). irradiated, 4-week-old SC and FP strain recipients caused reduction or complete disappearance of serum IgM and lowered IgG levels, which correlated well with a decrease in plasma cell numbers in spleen and trident. Many recipients of both strains, examined 1 to 2 weeks after transfer, completely lacked plasma cells from gut-associated lymphoid tissues and from spleen. When such animals had been sensitized to BA prior to transfer and were challenged after recovery from suppression, they showed good secondary responses. Experiments with serially transferred memory cells using suppressed intermediate hosts also indicated survival of such cells in the face of marked suppression of antibody synthesis. Bursa follicles that were not destroyed by irradiation did not show any effect of the suppressor cells, although plasma cells often disappeared from the interfollicular areas. Intact irradiated recipients showed a greater tendency toward recovery from suppression than did SBX recipients. Although Ig-bearing cells in spleen and peripheral blood of suppressed animals were significantly lower than in irradiated SBX controls, they never disappeared as completely as did plasma cells and serum IgM. The results suggest a direct effect of suppressor cells on antibody-forming cells with a less marked effect on their precursors.     

Specific, transient suppression of the immune response by HGG tolerant spleen cells. II. Effector cells and target cells.

In a previous report, it was shown that spleen cells from mice made tolerant to human gamma-globulin (HGG)5 could specifically inhibit the immune response of normal spleen cells after adoptive transfer to lethally irradiated recipients. However, that report also showed that the suppressive activity was only transiently associated with tolerant spleen cell populations. It was concluded from those experiments that while suppressive activity could be demonstrated in tolerant spleen cells under certain conditions, such activity was not obligatory for the maintainance of the tolerant state. The experiments presented here were performed to determine the nature of the effector cell(s) and the target cell(s) involved in this system of suppression of the immune response. Treatment of cells from tolerant animals with anti-thymocyte serum and complement to remove thymus-derived (T) cells completely abrogated suppresive activity. Removal of adherent cells from tolerant spleen cells by passage over glass wool columns resulted in partial loss of the suppression. The inhibitory activity of the suppressor cells was resistant to 900 R irradiation regardless of whether the tolerant spleen cells were irradiated before or after adoptive transfer. The cellular target(s) for the supprssor cells was examined by using lipopolysaccharide (LPS) as an alternative source of helper activity for the response to HGG. LPS, injected at the time of the initial antigenic challenge of mice that had been reconstituted with tolerant and normal spleen cells, prevented the expression of suppression against bone marrow-derived (B) cells. However, when LPS was presented only at the time of secondary antigenic challenge, it was unable to overcome suppression of the immune response of reconstituted recipients. Thus, LPS could produce a state where the B cells were resistant to suppression, but LPS could not rescue the responsiveness of B cells once the cells in the reconstituted recipient had been suppressed. In addition, the immune response to both the hapten dinitrophenol (DNP) and the carrier (HGG) were suppressed when recipients of tolerant and normal spleen cells were challenged with DNP6HGG. This indicates that T helper cells are also a target for suppression. The results presented in this paper are discussed in relation to a possible mechanism of suppression which proposes that suppressive activity represents the induction of tolerance in immunologically competent cells by HCG which is closely associated with the tolerant spleen cells.     

Disabled-2 mediates c-Fos suppression and the cell growth regulatory activity of retinoic acid in embryonic carcinoma cells

F9 embryonic stem cell-like teratocarcinoma cells are widely used to study early embryonic development and cell differentiation. The cells can be induced by retinoic acid to undergo endodermal differentiation. The retinoic acid-induced differentiation accompanies cell growth suppression, and thus, F9 cells are also often used as a model for analysis of retinoic acid biological activity. We have recently shown that MAPK activation and c-Fos expression are uncoupled in F9 cells upon retinoic acid-induced endodermal differentiation. The expression of the candidate tumor suppressor Disabled-2 is induced and correlates with cell growth suppression in F9 cells. We were not able to establish stable Disabled-2 expression by cDNA transfection in F9 cells without induction of spontaneous cell differentiation. Transient transfection of Dab2 by adenoviral vector nevertheless suppresses Elk-1 phosphorylation, c-Fos expression, and cell growth. In PA-1, another teratocarcinoma cell line of human origin that has no or very low levels of Disabled-2, retinoic acid fails to induce Disabled-2, correlating with a lack of growth suppression, although PA-1 is responsive to retinoic acid in morphological change. Transfection and expression of Disabled-2 in PA-1 cells mimic the effects of retinoic acid on growth suppression; the Disabled-2-expressing cells reach a much lower saturation density, and serum-stimulated c-Fos expression is greatly suppressed and disassociated from MAPK activation. Thus, Dab2 is one of the principal genes induced by retinoic acid involved in cell growth suppression, and expression of Dab2 alone is sufficient for uncoupling of MAPK activation and c-Fos expression. Resistance to retinoic acid regulation in PA-1 cells likely results from defects in retinoic acid up-regulation of Dab2 expression.     

Mechanism controlling the genetic restrictions of an NP-specific suppressor factor that inhibits B cell responses

The mechanism of B cell suppression by a T cell hybridoma-derived monoclonal effector suppressor factor (TsF3) was studied in the 4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl acetyl (NP) system. The NP-specific effector suppressor cells that produce TsF3 are Lyt-1-, 2+, I-J+, NP-binding T cells and are induced by immunization with NP conjugates. Monoclonal TsF3 inhibits both T cell activity as measured by suppression of contact sensitivity responses and B cell function as measured by suppression of antibody production to both T-independent and T-dependent antigens. The present studies were designed to specifically investigate the mechanisms and genetic restrictions that govern the interactions between TsF3 and its target cells in the plaque-forming cell (PFC) response. The results show that the target of TsF3 is a splenic adherent cell. Suppression will occur only if the restriction specificity of the TsF3 matches the H-2 genotype of the adherent population. Once this TsF3-adherent cell interaction has occurred, suppression of NP-specific B cells can occur across an H-2 barrier. The data also demonstrate that Igh-linked gene products do not appear to play a part in the TsF3-mediated suppression of in vitro PFC responses, which contrasts with the requirements for regulation of T cell-mediated contact sensitivity responses.     

Dendritic cell type determines the mechanism of bystander suppression by adaptive T regulatory cells specific for the minor antigen HA-1

One hallmark of acquired tolerance is bystander suppression, a process whereby Ag-specific (adaptive) T regulatory cells (TR) inhibit the T effector cell response both to specific Ag and to a colocalized third-party Ag. Using peripheral blood T cells from recipients of HLA-identical kidney transplants as responders in the trans vivo-delayed type hypersensitivity assay, we found that dendritic cells (DC), but not monocyte APCs, could mediate bystander suppression of EBV-specific recall response. When HA-1(H) peptide was added to mixtures of plasmacytoid DC (pDC) and T cells, bystander suppression of the response to a colocalized recall Ag occurred primarily via indolamine-2,3-dioxygenase (IDO) production. Similarly, addition of HA-1(H) peptide to cocultures of T cells and pDC, but not myeloid DC (mDC), induced IDO activity in vitro. When mDC presented HA-1(H) peptide to Ag-specific CD8+ TR, cytokine release (TGF-beta, IL-10, or both) was the primary mode of bystander suppression. Bystander suppression via mDC was reversed not only by Ab to TGF-beta and its receptor on T cells, but also by Ab to thrombospondin-1. EBV addition did not induce IDO or thrombospondin-1 in T-DC cocultures, suggesting that these DC products are not induced by T effector cells, but only by TR cells. These results shed light upon the mechanism of bystander suppression by donor Ag-specific TR in patients with organ transplant tolerance and underscores the distinct and critical roles of mDC and pDCs in this phenomenon.     

The suppression of mitogen responses associated with resistance to experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis requires adherent and T cells

Resistance to experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE) in Hartley guinea pigs has previously been reported to be associated with disease-specific antigen-induced suppression of mitogen responses in vitro. The present studies were initiated to investigate the requirement for different cell populations in this suppression. Intact and adherent-cell-depleted cultures of spleen cells from experimental and control animals were incubated with myelin basic protein (MBP), the major antigen of EAE, with the T-cell mitogen concanavalin A (Con A) alone or with Con A in the presence of MBP. In agreement with previous studies, MBP-induced suppression of the Con A response was observed only in cultures derived from resistant animals. In addition, it was observed that this suppression was abrogated by depletion of adherent cells. When cells from resistant and susceptible animals were mixed, suppression occurred only in the presence of nonadherent cells from resistant guinea pigs. Adherent cells from either resistant or susceptible animals functioned equally well. Cultures of purified E-rosette-forming cells (E+) from resistant animals (i.e., T cells) showed no suppression. Similarly, cells from these same animals which were depleted of E+ cells (i.e., non-T cells) did not demonstrate suppression in vitro. Upon reconstitution of spleen cell populations from resistant guinea pigs by mixing E+ and E- cells, suppression was restored. These experiments show that this model of suppression in vitro requires adherent cells as well as T cells and suggests that antigen-induced suppression of mitogen responses is dependent upon a cell-mediated immunologic mechanism.