Identification of affinity ligands for protein purification from synthetic chemical combinatorial libraries

A method to screen combinatorial libraries for the development of selective ligands for protein affinity chromatographic purification is described. The method is based on the application of parallel combinatorial libraries, and it has several potential advantages. The screening procedure is simple and straightforward, and it does not require the chemical derivatization of the target proteins or even that the target protein be pure. The experiment can also be designed to select binders that are less likely to cause protein denaturation. Feasibility of this approach is demonstrated with a model study of the chromatographic purification of bovine albumin serum (BSA) and Avidin.     

New inhibitors of Helicobacter pylori urease holoenzyme selected from phage-displayed peptide libraries.

Urease is an important virulence factor for Helicobacter pylori and is critical for bacterial colonization of the human gastric mucosa. Specific inhibition of urease activity has been proposed as a possible strategy to fight this bacteria which infects billions of individual throughout the world and can lead to severe pathological conditions in a limited number of cases. We have selected peptides which specifically bind and inhibit H. pylori urease from libraries of random peptides displayed on filamentous phage in the context of pIII coat protein. Screening of a highly diverse 25-mer combinatorial library and two newly constructed random 6-mer peptide libraries on solid phase H. pylori urease holoenzyme allowed the identification of two peptides, 24-mer TFLPQPRCSALLRYLSEDGVIVPS and 6-mer YDFYWW that can bind and inhibit the activity of urease purified from H. pylori. These two peptides were chemically synthesized and their inhibition constants (Ki) were found to be 47 microM for the 24-mer and 30 microM for the 6-mer peptide. Both peptides specifically inhibited the activity of H. pylori urease but not that of Bacillus pasteurii.     

Ligands selected from combinatorial libraries of protein A for use in affinity capture of apolipoprotein A-1M and taq DNA polymerase

Here we show that robust and small protein ligands can be used for affinity capture of recombinant proteins from crude cell lysates. Two ligands selectively binding to bacterial Taq DNA polymerase and human apolipoprotein A-1(M), respectively, were used in the study. The ligands were selected from libraries of a randomized alpha-helical bacterial receptor domain derived from staphylococcal protein A and have dissociation constants in the micromolar range, which is typical after primary selection from these libraries consisting of approximately 40 million different members each. Using these ligands in affinity chromatography, both target proteins were efficiently recovered from crude cell lysates with high selectivities. No loss of column capacity or selectivity was observed for repeated cycles of sample loading, washing and low pH elution. Interestingly, column sanitation could be performed using 0. 5 M sodium hydroxide without significant loss of ligand performance. The results suggest that combinatorial approaches using robust protein domains as scaffolds can be a general tool in the process of designing purification strategies for biomolecules.     

DNA binding affinity of pentapeptides selected from combinatorial library.

The combinatorial method has been applied to determine peptide ligands to the duplex DNA by using the solid-state pentapeptide library and the target-DNA conjugated magnetic beads. Seventy-one sequences were determined as ligands for AT duplex. Interestingly, hydrophobic amino acids such as Phe, Ile and Gly were most frequently determined. Relative binding affinity of the selected pentapeptides with the various DNA sequences was estimated by ethidium displacement assay in 10 mM SHE buffer. FQGII constituted of amino acids that were most frequently determined in the random screening showed highest binding affinity to the duplex DNA.     

Rapid identification of high affinity peptide ligands using positional scanning synthetic peptide combinatorial libraries.

We describe here a conceptually unique set of individual synthetic peptide combinatorial libraries (SPCLs), termed a positional scanning SPCL (PS-SPCL), that can be used for the rapid (i.e., a single day) identification of peptide sequences that bind with high affinity to antibodies, receptors or other acceptor molecules. The PS-SPCL described here is made up of six individual positional peptide libraries, each one consisting of hexamers with a single position defined and five positions as mixtures. As an example of the utility of such PS-SPCLs, the antigenic determinants recognized by two different monoclonal antibodies were correctly identified upon a single screening.     

High-throughput method for ranking the affinity of peptide ligands selected from phage display libraries

The use of phage display peptide libraries allows rapid isolation of peptide ligands for any target selector molecule. However, due to differences in peptide expression and the heterogeneity of the phage preparations, there is no easy way to compare the binding properties of the selected clones, which operates as a major "bottleneck" of the technology. Here, we present the development of a new type of library that allows rapid comparison of the relative affinity of the selected peptides in a high-throughput screening format. As a model system, a phage display peptide library constructed on a phagemid vector that contains the bacterial alkaline phosphatase gene (BAP) was selected with an antiherbicide antibody. Due to the intrinsic switching capacity of the library, the selected peptides were transferred "en masse" from the phage coat protein to BAP. This was coupled to an optimized affinity ELISA where normalized amounts of the peptide-BAP fusion allow direct comparison of the binding properties of hundreds of peptide ligands. The system was validated by plasmon surface resonance experiments using synthetic peptides, showing that the method discriminates among the affinities of the peptides within 3 orders of magnitude. In addition, the peptide-BAP protein can find direct application as a tracer reagent.     

Non-Shine-Dalgarno initiators of translation selected from combinatorial DNA libraries

In a search for non-Shine-Dalgarno (non-SD) translational initiators, two combinatorial expression libraries (denoted R(1) and R(2)) were constructed containing randomized decanucleotide regions placed at either 6 (R(1)) or 11 (R(2)) nucleotides upstream of a modified chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (CAT) gene. To prevent sporadic formation of SD-like sequences the content of G in the randomized region was restricted to 3% only. The two libraries were transformed in Escherichia coli cells and screened for chloramphenicol (Cm) resistance. More than 50 clones capable of tolerating Cm concentrations from 50 micro g/ml to more than 800 micro g/ml were selected. With few exceptions only, the non-SD sequences found in the Cm-resistant clones did not show any significant homology with other known non-SD initiators or enhancers of translation. Statistical (chi(2)) analysis of the distribution of nucleotides in the new non-SD translational initiators showed a different pattern from that of the conventional SD sequences. In few of the clones the yield of CAT exceeded that of the referent (SD-containing) construct. The most productive clones carried the decanucleotides ATTTACCTCC, CCAATCTAC, TTCAATATTT, and TATTCCCCCA, and the corresponding yield of CAT obtained with them was 2.70, 2.06, 2.12 and 1.32 times, respectively, higher than that of the SD-bearing construct.     

Designing gene libraries from protein profiles for combinatorial protein experiments

Protein combinatorial libraries provide new ways to probe the determinants of folding and to discover novel proteins. Such libraries are often constructed by expressing an ensemble of partially random gene sequences. Given the intractably large number of possible sequences, some limitation on diversity must be imposed. A non-uniform distribution of nucleotides can be used to reduce the number of possible sequences and encode peptide sequences having a predetermined set of amino acid probabilities at each residue position, i.e., the amino acid sequence profile. Such profiles can be determined by inspection, multiple sequence alignment or physically-based computational methods. Here we present a computational method that takes as input a desired sequence profile and calculates the individual nucleotide probabilities among partially random genes. The calculated gene library can be readily used in the context of standard DNA synthesis to generate a protein library with essentially the desired profile. The fidelity between the desired profile and the calculated one coded by these partially random genes is quantitatively evaluated using the linear correlation coefficient and a relative entropy, each of which provides a measure of profile agreement at each position of the sequence. On average, this method of identifying such codon frequencies performs as well or better than other methods with regard to fidelity to the original profile. Importantly, the method presented here provides much better yields of complete sequences that do not contain stop codons, a feature that is particularly important when all or large fractions of a gene are subject to combinatorial mutation.     

Intracellular kinase inhibitors selected from combinatorial libraries of designed ankyrin repeat proteins

The specific intracellular inhibition of protein activity at the protein level allows the determination of protein function in the cellular context. We demonstrate here the use of designed ankyrin repeat proteins as tailor-made intracellular kinase inhibitors. The target was aminoglycoside phosphotransferase (3')-IIIa (APH), which mediates resistance to aminoglycoside antibiotics in pathogenic bacteria and shares structural homology with eukaryotic protein kinases. Combining a selection and screening approach, we isolated 198 potential APH inhibitors from highly diverse combinatorial libraries of designed ankyrin repeat proteins. A detailed analysis of several inhibitors revealed that they bind APH with high specificity and with affinities down to the subnanomolar range. In vitro, the most potent inhibitors showed complete enzyme inhibition, and in vivo, a phenotype comparable with the gene knockout was observed, fully restoring antibiotic sensitivity in resistant bacteria. These results underline the great potential of designed ankyrin repeat proteins for modulation of intracellular protein function.     

Human immunoglobulin A (IgA)-specific ligands from combinatorial engineering of protein A.

Affinity reagents capable of selective recognition of the different human immunoglobulin isotypes are important detection and purification tools in biotechnology. Here we describe the development and characterization of affinity proteins (affibodies) showing selective binding to human IgA. From protein libraries constructed by combinatorial mutagenesis of a 58-amino-acid, three-helix bundle domain derived from the IgG-binding staphylococcal protein A, variants showing IgA binding were selected by using phage display technology and IgA monoclonal antibodies (myeloma) as target molecules. Characterization of selected clones by biosensor technology showed that five out of eight investigated affibody variants were capable of IgA binding, with dissociation constants (K(d)) in the range between 0.5 and 3 microm. One variant (Z(IgA1)) showing the strongest binding affinity was further analyzed, and showed that human IgA subclasses (IgA(1) and IgA(2)) as well as secretory IgA were recognized with similar efficiencies. No detectable cross-reactivity towards human IgG, IgM, IgD or IgE was observed. The potential use of the Z(IgA1) affibody as a ligand in affinity chromatography applications was first demonstrated by selective recovery of IgA protein from a spiked Escherichia coli total cell lysate, using an affinity column containing a divalent head-to-tail Z(IgA1) affibody dimer construct as a ligand. In addition, efficient affinity recovery of IgA from unconditioned human plasma was also demonstrated.     

Anti-idiotypic protein domains selected from protein A-based affibody libraries

Three pairs of small protein domains showing binding behavior in analogy with anti-idiotypic antibodies have been selected using phage display technology. From an affibody protein library constructed by combinatorial variegation of the Fc binding surface of the 58 residue staphylococcal protein A (SPA)-derived domain Z, affibody variants have been selected to the parental SPA scaffold and to two earlier identified SPA-derived affibodies. One selected affibody (Z(SPA-1)) was shown to recognize each of the five domains of wild-type SPA with dissociation constants (K(D)) in the micromolar range. The binding of the Z(SPA-1) affibody to its parental structure was shown to involve the Fc binding site of SPA, while the Fab-binding site was not involved. Similarly, affibodies showing anti-idiotypic binding characteristics were also obtained when affibodies previously selected for binding to Taq DNA polymerase and human IgA, respectively, were used as targets for selections. The potential applications for these types of affinity pairs were exemplified by one-step protein recovery using affinity chromatography employing the specific interactions between the respective protein pair members. These experiments included the purification of the Z(SPA-1) affibody from a total Escherichia coli cell lysate using protein A-Sepharose, suggesting that this protein A/antiprotein A affinity pair could provide a basis for novel affinity gene fusion systems. The use of this type of small, robust, and easily expressed anti-idiotypic affibody pair for affinity technology applications, including self-assembled protein networks, is discussed.     

A new method for the screening of solid-phase combinatorial libraries for affinity chromatography

A new methodology for the rapid assessment of affinity ligands synthesized by combinatorial solid-phase chemistry is reported. This screening strategy utilizes the target protein conjugated to FITC, and represents an almost universal technique for the preliminary screening of solid-phase combinatorial libraries. The assessment of a triazine-scaffolded solid-phase combinatorial library of ligands, designed to bind to human IgG, was performed with FITC-human IgG, and the results compared with those obtained by conventional affinity chromatographic screening assays. The effect of different molar conjugation ratios of FITC-IgG (F/P) was evaluated. Independently of the F/P ratio, no false negative results were observed, although lower F/P ratios diminished non-specific interactions and the number of false positives. The nature of the substituents on the triazine scaffold was not related to the number of false positive IgG-binding ligands. The reproducibility of the FITC technique, using FITC-human IgG conjugates with low F/P ratio (F/P=2), was also evaluated. The FITC-based technique proved to be efficient and accurate in the identification of strongly binding ligands (binding >50% of loaded protein, by standard affinity chromatographic assays), and is envisaged as a versatile and cost-effective method to screen other systems, and evaluate several binding/elution conditions at small-scale, prior to scale-up to standard affinity chromatography.     

Synthesis and screening of a rationally designed combinatorial library of affinity ligands mimicking protein L from Peptostreptococcus magnus

Rational design and combinatorial chemistry were utilized to search for lead protein L (PpL) mimetics for application as affinity ligands for the purification of antibodies and small fragments, such as Fab and scFv, and as potential diagnostic or therapeutic agents. Inspection of the key structural features of the complex between PpL and human Fab prompted the de novo design and combinatorial synthesis of a 169-membered solid-phase ligand library, which was assessed for binding to human IgG and subsequent selectivity for the Fab fragment. Eight ligands were selected, chemically characterized and compared with a commercial PpL-adsorbent for binding pure immunoglobulin fractions. The most promising lead, ligand 8/7, when immobilized on an agarose support, behaved in a similar fashion to PpL in isolating Fab fragments from papain digests of human IgG to a final purity of 97%.     

High-affinity human antibodies from phage-displayed synthetic Fab libraries with a single framework scaffold

Phage-displayed synthetic antibody libraries were built on a single human framework by introducing synthetic diversity at solvent-exposed positions within the heavy chain complementarity-determining regions (CDRs). The design strategy of mimicking natural diversity using tailored codons had been validated previously with scFv libraries, which produced antibodies that bound to antigen, murine vascular endothelial growth factor (mVEGF), with affinities in the 100nM range. To improve library performance, we constructed monovalent and bivalent antigen-binding fragment (Fab) libraries, and explored different CDR-H3 diversities by varying the amino acid composition and CDR length. A Fab with sub-nanomolar affinity for mVEGF was obtained from a library with CDR-H3 diversity designed to contain all 20 naturally occurring amino acids. We then expanded the library by increasing the variability of CDR-H3 length and using tailored codons that mimicked the amino acid composition of natural CDR-H3 sequences. The library was tested against a panel of 13 protein antigens and high-affinity Fabs were obtained for most antigens. Furthermore, the heavy chain of an anti-mVEGF clone was recombined with a library of light chain CDRs, and the affinity was improved from low nanomolar to low picomolar. The results demonstrated that high-affinity human antibodies can be generated from libraries with completely synthetic CDRs displayed on a single scaffold.     

High-affinity binders selected from designed ankyrin repeat protein libraries

We report here the evolution of ankyrin repeat (AR) proteins in vitro for specific, high-affinity target binding. Using a consensus design strategy, we generated combinatorial libraries of AR proteins of varying repeat numbers with diversified binding surfaces. Libraries of two and three repeats, flanked by 'capping repeats,' were used in ribosome-display selections against maltose binding protein (MBP) and two eukaryotic kinases. We rapidly enriched target-specific binders with affinities in the low nanomolar range and determined the crystal structure of one of the selected AR proteins in complex with MBP at 2.3 A resolution. The interaction relies on the randomized positions of the designed AR protein and is comparable to natural, heterodimeric protein-protein interactions. Thus, our AR protein libraries are valuable sources for binding molecules and, because of the very favorable biophysical properties of the designed AR proteins, an attractive alternative to antibody libraries.     

Design of combinatorial protein libraries of optimal size

In this article we introduce a computational procedure, OPTCOMB (Optimal Pattern of Tiling for COMBinatorial library design), for designing protein hybrid libraries that optimally balance library size with quality. The proposed procedure is directly applicable to oligonucleotide ligation-based protocols such as GeneReassembly, DHR, SISDC, and many more. Given a set of parental sequences and the size ranges of the parental sequence fragments, OPTCOMB determines the optimal junction points (i.e., crossover positions) and the fragment contributing parental sequences at each one of the junction points. By rationally selecting the junction points and the contributing parental sequences, the number of clashes (i.e., unfavorable interactions) in the library is systematically minimized with the aim of improving the overall library quality. Using OPTCOMB, hybrid libraries containing fragments from three different dihydrofolate reductase sequences (Escherichia coli, Bacillus subtilis, and Lactobacillus casei) are computationally designed. Notably, we find that there exists an optimal library size when both the number of clashes between the fragments composing the library and the average number of clashes per hybrid in the library are minimized. Results reveal that the best library designs typically involve complex tiling patterns of parental segments of unequal size hard to infer without relying on computational means.     

Inhibition of Aβ42 aggregation using peptides selected from combinatorial libraries

Increasing evidence suggests that the aggregation of the small peptide Aβ42 plays an important role in the development of Alzheimer's disease. Inhibiting the initial aggregation of Aβ42 may be an effective treatment for preventing, or slowing, the onset of the disease. Using an in vivo screen based on the enzyme EGFP, we have searched through two combinatorially diverse peptide libraries to identify peptides capable of inhibiting Aβ42 aggregation. From this initial screen, three candidate peptides were selected and characterized. ThT studies indicated that the selected peptides were capable of inhibiting amyloid aggregation. Additional ThT studies showed that one of the selected peptides was capable of disaggregating preformed Aβ42 fibers. Copyright © 2009 European Peptide Society and John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

De novo heme proteins from designed combinatorial libraries.

We previously reported the design of a library of de novo amino acid sequences targeted to fold into four-helix bundles. The design of these sequences was based on a "binary code" strategy, in which the patterning of polar and nonpolar amino acids is specified explicitly, but the exact identities of the side chains is varied extensively (Kamtekar S, Schiffer JM, Xiong H, Babik JM, Hecht MH, 1993, Science 262:1680-1685). Because of this variability, the resulting collection of amino acid sequences may include de novo proteins capable of binding biologically important cofactors. To probe for such binding, the de novo sequences were screened for their ability to bind the heme cofactor. Among an initial collection of 30 binary code sequences, 15 are shown to bind heme and form bright red complexes. Characterization of several of these de novo heme proteins demonstrated that their absorption spectra and resonance Raman spectra resemble those of natural cytochromes. Because the design of these sequences is based on global features of polar/ nonpolar patterning, the finding that half of them bind heme highlights the power of the binary code strategy, and demonstrates that isolating de novo heme proteins does not require explicit design of the cofactor binding site. Because bound heme plays a key role in the functions of many natural proteins, these results suggest that binary code sequences may serve as initial prototypes for the development of large collections of functionally active de novo proteins.     

Core-directed protein design. I. An experimental method for selecting stable proteins from combinatorial libraries.

The design of proteins represents a significant challenge to modern-day structural biology. A major obstacle here is the specification of well-packed hydrophobic cores to drive the folding and stabilization of the target. Computational approaches have been used to alleviate this by testing alternate sequences prior to the production and characterization of a few proteins. Here we present the experimental counterpart of this approach. We selected stable variants from a library of ubiquitin hydrophobic-core mutants as follows. Hexahistidine-tagged proteins were displayed on the surface of phage. These protein-phage were immobilized onto Ni-coated surfaces. The bound fusion-phage were treated with protease to remove unstable or poorly folded proteins. Stable phage fusions were eluted and infected into Escherichia coli, which allowed amplification for further selection, sequencing, or protein expression. Two Ni-derivatized supports were tested: Ni-NTA chips for surface plasmon resonance (SPR) and Ni-NTA agarose beads. SPR had an advantage in that the selection process could be monitored directly. This allowed individual clones and experimental conditions to be tested rapidly prior to preparative panning of the library, which was carried out using Ni-NTA agarose beads. We demonstrate the method by selecting stable core mutants of ubiquitin, the characterization of which is described in the following paper [Finucane, M. D., and Woolfson, D. N. (1999) Biochemistry 38, XXXXX-XXXXX]. As our method selects only on the basis of structure and stability, it will be of use in improving the stabilities and structural specificities of proteins of de novo design, and in establishing rules that link sequence and structure.