Mapping on the calf estrogen receptor of the binding domain for an antibody interfering with receptor activation

The localization on the calf estrogen receptor of the binding domain for B36 (an IgM antibody which prevents and reverses the effects of receptor activation) has been studied by means of controlled proteolysis of the receptor-estradiol complex using trypsin, chymotrypsin, and papain. We successively determined for intact and proteolyzed receptor-estradiol complex (i) the abilities of estradiol-binding species to aggregate in low salt medium, to bind to nonspecific DNA absorbed onto cellulose, and to interact with B36 antibody in sucrose gradients; (ii) the hydrodynamic properties of estradiol-binding species, by gel permeation chromatography and sucrose gradient centrifugation in high salt media and (iii) the molecular weights of B36-reactive species, by immunoblot analysis. Three tryptic receptor fragments of Mr 36,000, 34,000, and 33,000 and two chymotryptic fragments of Mr 36,000 and 33,000 included both the hormone- and B36-binding domains but did not interact with DNA, whereas at least two receptor fragments resulting from the action of chymotrypsin and papain bound estradiol with high affinity but interacted neither with DNA nor with B36. Taking into account these results and assuming that structure of the calf estrogen receptor is similar to those of sequenced estrogen receptors (which show a highly conserved organization with considerable homologies in the functional domains), we propose that the B36-binding domain is located either between the DNA- and hormone-binding domains (model I) or at the C-terminal end of the estrogen receptor (model II). The regions that include the main proteolytic cleavage sites of the receptor are also specified, and the abilities of the two models of the calf estrogen receptor to account for the effect of B36 on receptor activation are discussed.     

The binding of estrogen and estrogen antagonists to the estrogen receptor.

The model of the estrogen receptor as a dimer of identical, interacting subunits and data obtained by Sasson and Notides (1988, Mol. Endocrinol. 2, 307-312) were used to find the standard free energy changes that describe the binding of estradiol and 4-hydroxytamoxifen to the estrogen receptor. For the binding of estradiol or 4-hydroxytamoxifen to the estrogen receptor the data do not deviate systematically from the best fit to the model. The standard free energy change for binding of one molecule of estradiol at one site and one molecule of 4-hydroxytamoxifen at the second site of estrogen receptor indicates that 4-hydroxytamoxifen antagonizes the binding of estradiol to the estrogen receptor.     

Human estrogen receptor forms multiple protein-DNA complexes

A baculovirus expression system was used to overproduce the human estrogen receptor in insect cells. The estrogen receptor made in this system is full-length, binds estrogen specifically, and is recognized by a monoclonal antibody to the human estrogen receptor. The recombinant estrogen receptor binds the estrogen response element (ERE) in both the absence and presence of estrogen if the binding is carried out in the absence of Mg2+. In the presence of Mg2+, the estrogen receptor binds the ERE in a hormone-dependent fashion. This effect is more pronounced at higher temperatures. Tamoxifen, a nonsteroidal anti-estrogen, is able to stimulate ERE binding to the same extent and under the same conditions as estradiol. Estradiol stimulates formation of an estrogen receptor-ERE complex with an increased mobility in native gels as compared with the complex formed without hormone or with tamoxifen. These results demonstrate that specific DNA binding of the estrogen receptor is not absolutely dependent on the presence of hormone and that estradiol but not tamoxifen is able to induce a change in the estrogen receptor. This differential effect of estradiol and tamoxifen may be important in understanding the role of the receptor to activate target genes differentially.     

Immunological differences between the estradiol-, tamoxifen- and 4-hydroxy-tamoxifen-estrogen receptor complexes detected by two monoclonal antibodies

Two monoclonal antibodies (D547 and H222), obtained against the estrogen receptor from MCF-7 breast cancer cells, were used to study the estrogen receptor from fetal guinea-pig uterus bound to estradiol or to the antiestrogens tamoxifen and 4-hydroxytamoxifen. The estradiol-receptor complex binds partially to the monoclonal antibody D547, shifting its sedimentation coefficient in high salt sucrose density gradients from 4.5S to 7.5S. Recently, we demonstrated that the form selectively recognized by this monoclonal antibody is the activated form of the receptor. The estrogen receptor complexed with tamoxifen or 4-hydroxytamoxifen is also partially recognized by this monoclonal antibody but the fraction of total receptor bound to the antibody is significantly less than for the receptor complexed with estradiol. Another series of experiments showed that the monoclonal antibody H222, which recognizes a different antigenic site on the receptor molecule, binds all the estradiol-receptor complex (independently of the degree of activation), shifting its sedimentation coefficient to 7.5S. However, even if all the 4-hydroxytamoxifen-receptor complex is bound by this antibody, only a fraction of the receptor is recognized when it is complexed with tamoxifen. These data show different interactions between the estradiol-, tamoxifen- and 4-hydroxytamoxifen-receptor complexes and the two monoclonal antibodies tested and suggest that these compounds induce different conformational modifications of the estrogen receptor molecule.     

Similarities and differences of the binding of estradiol and 4-hydroxytamoxifen (an antiestrogen) in the chick oviduct cytosol

The binding characteristics of [³H]estradiol and 4-[³H]hydroxytamoxifen (a powerful estradiol antagonist) in the chick oviduct cytosol was analyzed by sucrose gradient centrifugation and dissociation kinetics experiments at 28°C. Heating the cytoplasmic estradiol-estrogen receptor complexes led to the ‘transformation’ of the receptor; as with the estrogen receptor in other target tissues and species, the transformed receptor sedimented in the 5 S region of sucrose gradients containing 0.4 M KCI and had a slower rate of dissociation of bound estradiol. Upon heating, the cytoplasmic 4-hydroxytamoxifen complexes also appeared to undergo similar changes in their physical states as analyzed by sedimentation rates and dissociation kinetics, and we conclude that antiestrogen can transform the receptor. Sodium molybdate inhibited the temperature mediated changes with both estrogen and antiestrogen complexes. Slight but consistent differences in the sedimentation coefficient and rate of ligand dissociation were observed between the complexes formed by estradiol and 4-hydroxytamoxifen but the relevance to opposite biological activities remains unknown.     

Hydrodynamic characterizations of estrogen receptors complexed with [3H]-4-hydroxytamoxifen: evidence in support of contrasting receptor transitions mediated by different ligands

Size-exclusion high-performance liquid chromatography was used to characterize the hydrodynamic molecular properties of estrogen receptors complexed with estradiol and the antiestrogen 4-hydroxytamoxifen. Cytoplasmic estrogen receptors complexed with [3H]-4-hydroxytamoxifen did not undergo reductions in hydrodynamic size after exposure to KCl or urea. Nuclear receptors complexed with 4-hydroxytamoxifen eluted as hydrodynamically larger molecules than nuclear receptors complexed with estradiol. Because identical hydrodynamic characterizations were obtained with the covalent ligand [3H]tamoxifen aziridine, these differences in chromatographic behavior are due to differences in ligand-mediated receptor properties and are not the result of ligand dissociation. When estrogen receptors, complexed with either [3H]estradiol or [3H]-4-hydroxytamoxifen, were exposed to trypsin, the receptors complexed with 4-hydroxytamoxifen eluted as larger hydrodynamic forms than receptors complexed with estradiol. These observations are interpreted to indicate that estradiol and 4-hydroxytamoxifen mediate contrasting transitions in the molecular orientation of estrogen receptors. The consequences of the transitions mediated by 4-hydroxytamoxifen appear to be that intermolecular associations become difficult to disrupt with KCl or urea and that the accessibility of trypsin-sensitive proteolytic sites becomes altered. Chromatin fractionation using DNase I and hypotonic Mg2+ solubilization identified a chromatin region that was less readily penetrated by receptors complexed with 4-hydroxytamoxifen than receptors complexed with estradiol.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Ligand-selective interdomain conformations of estrogen receptor-alpha

Selective estrogen receptor modulators (SERMs) inhibit estrogen activation of the estrogen receptor (ER) in some tissues but activate ER in other tissues. These tissue-selective actions suggest that SERMs may be identified with tissue specificities that would improve the safety of breast cancer and hormone replacement therapies. The identification of an improved SERM would be aided by understanding the effects of each SERM on the structure and interactions of ER. To date, the inability to obtain structures of the full-length ER has limited our structural characterization of SERM action to their antiestrogenic effects on the isolated ER ligand binding domain. We studied the effects of estradiol and the clinically useful SERMs 4-hydroxytamoxifen and fulvestrant on the conformation of the full-length ERalpha dimer complex by comparing, in living human breast cancer cells, the amounts of energy transfer between fluorophores attached to different domains of ERalpha. Estradiol, 4-hydroxytamoxifen, and fulvestrant all promoted the rapid formation of ERalpha dimers with equivalent interaction kinetics. The amino- and carboxyl-terminal ERalpha domains both contain activation functions differentially affected by these ligands, but the positions of only the carboxyl termini differed upon binding with estradiol, 4-hydroxytamoxifen, or fulvestrant. The association of a specific ERalpha dimer conformation with the binding of ligands of different clinical effect will assist the identification of a SERM with optimal tissue-selective estrogenic and antiestrogenic activities. These studies also provide a roadmap for dissecting important structural and kinetic details for any protein complex from the quantitative analysis of energy transfer.     

Melatonin blocks the activation of estrogen receptor for DNA binding.

The present study shows that melatonin prevents, within the first cell cycle, the estradiol-induced growth of synchronized MCF7 breast cancer cells. By using nuclear extracts of these cells, we first examined the binding of estradiol-estrogen receptor complexes to estrogen-responsive elements and found that the addition of estradiol to whole cells activates the binding of the estrogen receptor to DNA whereas melatonin blocks this interaction. By contrast, melatonin neither affects the binding of estradiol to its receptor nor the receptor nuclear localization. Moreover, we also show that addition of estradiol to nuclear extracts stimulates the binding of estrogen receptor to DNA, but this activation is also prevented by melatonin. The inhibitory effect caused by melatonin is saturable at nanomolar concentrations and does not appear to be mediated by RZR nuclear receptors. The effect is also specific, since indol derivatives do not cause significant inhibition. Furthermore, we provide evidence that melatonin does not interact with the estrogen receptor in the absence of estradiol. Together, these results demonstrate that melatonin interferes with the activation of estrogen receptor by estradiol. The effect of melatonin suggests the presence of a receptor that, upon melatonin addition, destabilizes the binding of the estradiol-estrogen receptor complex to the estrogen responsive element.     

hsp70 is not required for high affinity binding of purified calf uterine estrogen receptor to estrogen response element DNA in Vitro

Bovine estrogen receptor (ER) was purified to near homogeneity by estrogen response element (ERE) affinity chromatography, and its ERE binding ability was measured in vitro. Highly purified ER bound EREs with reduced affinity compared to partially purified ER. Partially purified ER contained hsp70, but highly purified ER did not. We examined whether addition of purified recombinant human hsp70 or purified bovine hsp70 would restore the higher ERE binding affinity, stoichiometry, and ligand retention detected with partially purified receptor and how hsp70 affected the rate of ER-ERE association and dissociation. ER-ERE binding was not affected by antibodies to either constitutive or induced forms of hsp70, regardless of ER purity. Addition of purified hsp70, with or without ATP and Mg²⁺, did not affect the association or dissociation rates of highly purified liganded ER binding to ERE. hsp70 Did not alter the total amount of ER-ERE complex formed. Similarly, hsp70 did not affect the rate of [³H]estradiol (E₂) or [³H]4-hydroxytamoxifen (4-OHT) ligand dissociation from ER in the presence or absence of EREs. These data contrast with a report showing that maximal ERE binding by highly purified recombinant human ER required hsp70. We conclude that ER, purified from a physiological source, i.e., calf uterus, does not require hsp70 for maximal ER-ERE binding in vitro. Additionally, once ER is activated and bound by ligand, the receptor assumes its proper tertiary structure, and hsp70 does not impact ER ligand binding domain conformation.     

Properties of the estrogen receptors contained in the MtTF4 tumor whose growth is inhibited by estradiol: 17 beta-estradiol, 17 alpha-estradiol and DNA bindings

The steroid and the DNA bindings of the estrogen receptor of the MtTF4 tumor whose growth is inhibited by estradiol where characterized and compared to those of uterine estrogen receptors. In the tumor cytosol: E protects its binding sites against thermal denaturation, depending on the effects of sodium molybdate upon the dissociation rate of [3H]E at 20 degrees C and the ability of receptor to bind to DNA, the activation (or transformation) process, supposed to be necessary for the full action of estrogen ligand, occurs on estrogen receptor complexes and the calf thymus DNA interacts with estrogen receptor with an affinity similar to that of uterine estrogen receptor. Kinetic and equilibrium studies with 17 alpha-[3H]E both in uterus and tumor indicate that this ligand is fast-associating, fast-dissociating and that its affinity for ER is 2- to 4-fold lower than that of 17 beta-[3H]estradiol one. Competition experiments between 17 beta-[3H]estradiol and the unlabelled 17 alpha epimer reveal, in both uterus and tumor, a time-dependent decrease of the apparent potency of 17 alpha-E to inhibit the binding of [3H]E. It is concluded that the estrogen receptors are very similar in MtTF4 tumor and uterus and the diversity of the response of cell growth to E is due rather to differences at the post-receptor level.     

Differences in the form of the salt-transformed estrogen receptor when bound by estrogen versus antiestrogen

Our laboratory has previously reported that antiestrogen binding to molybdate-stabilized non-transformed estrogen receptor results in a larger form of the receptor in 0.3 M KCl when compared with estrogen bound receptor. Estradiol promoted the formation of monomers in the presence of 0.3 M KCl whereas antiestrogen appeared to promote dimer formation. We have extended these studies examining the rabbit uterine salt-transformed estrogen receptor partially purified by DEAE-cellulose chromatography. We previously demonstrated that estrogen receptor prepared in this way bound to different sites on partially deproteinized chromatin subfractions or reconstituted chromosomal protein/DNA fractions when the receptor was complexed with estrogen vs antiestrogen. Analysis of these receptor preparations indicated that DEAE-cellulose step-elution resulted in a peak fraction which sedimented as a single 5.9S peak in 5-20% sucrose density gradients containing 0.3 M KCl for receptor bound by the antiestrogens H1285 and trans-hydroxytamoxifen. However, receptor bound by estradiol sedimented as 4.5S. These receptor complexes bound DNA-cellulose indicating that these partially purified receptors were transformed. DEAE rechromatography or agarose gel filtration of the partially purified antiestrogen-receptor complexes resulted in significant dissociation of the larger complex into monomers. Incubations of 5.9S antiestrogen-receptor complexes with antibodies against nontransformed steroid receptor-associated proteins (the 59 and 90 kDa proteins) did not result in the interaction of this larger antiestrogen-receptor complex with these antibodies (obtained from L. E. Faber and D. O. Toft, respectively). Our results support the concept that antiestrogen binding induces a different receptor conformation which could affect monomer-dimer equilibrium, thus rendering the antiestrogen-receptor complex incapable of inducing complete estrogenic responses in target tissues.     

Catecholestrogens are MCF-7 cell estrogen receptor agonists

Catecholestrogens are important metabolites of estradiol and estrone in the human. Considerable interest has focused on the catecholestrogens 2-hydroxy- and 4-hydroxyestradiol since they bind to the estrogen receptor with an affinity in the range of estradiol. Using the MCF-7 cell line, we analysed the capacity of purified catecholestrogens to transform the estrogen receptor into its high affinity nuclear binding form and to effect receptor-dependent processes such as proliferation and expression of the progesterone receptor (PR). Incubations with 2-hydroxy- and 4-hydroxyestradiol at 10⁻⁸ M for 1 h resulted in tight nuclear binding of the estrogen receptor. During treatment of the cells with catecholestrogens we obtained a marked increase in proliferation rate of 36 and 76% for 2-hydroxy- and 4-hydroxyestradiol, respectively, relative to the inductive effect of estradiol (100%). The PR level, was slightly increased by treatment with 2-hydroxyestradiol (10%), whereas treatment with 4-hydroxyestradiol increased the PR level at 28%, compared to estradiol (100%). Form these results we conclude that the 2- and 4-hydroxylated derivatives of estradiol are active hormones and are able to initiate estrogen receptor mediated processes in MCF-7 cells.     

Synergistic activation of the serotonin-1A receptor by nuclear factor-kappa B and estrogen

Estrogen exerts profound effects on mood and mental state. The ability of estrogen to modulate serotonergic function raises the possibility that it may play a role in the mechanism associated with depression and its treatment. A cellular mechanism for estrogen to influence mood might be through the regulation of genes involved at various levels of the serotonin system. Here we report that estrogen can up-regulate the expression of the serotonin-1A receptor via a new mechanism involving synergistic activation by nuclear factor-kappa B (NF-kappa B) with estrogen receptor alpha. Interestingly, we observed that only estrogen receptor-alpha, and not -beta, was able to mediate this effect of estrogens. The partial antiestrogen, 4-hydroxytamoxifen, had the same effect as estrogen. In addition, mutation analysis showed that both the transactivation function of p65 and activation function 1 of estrogen receptor-alpha were essential for this synergistic regulation. Therefore, we propose that NF-kappa B complexes cooperate with estrogen receptor-alpha to recruit cofactors into the complex and thereby synergistically activate the serotonin-1A receptor promoter through nonclassical estrogen response elements by a mechanism that does not involve direct receptor binding to DNA.     

Activation and immunorecognition by a monoclonal antibody of the tamoxifen-estrogen receptor complex

The interaction of tamoxifen with the estrogen receptor of fetal guinea pig uterus, the activation of the tamoxife-estrogen receptor complex and its immunorecognition by a monoclonal antibody raised against the human estrogen receptor is described in the present paper. The results show that: (1) the tamoxifen-receptor complex sediments at 8 S in low-salt and at 4.5 S in high-salt sucrose gradients, (2) this complex is partially recognized by the monoclonal antibody allowing the differentiation of two forms: the α form, which binds to the monoclonal antibody, and the β form, which does not react with it; (3) several factors such as time, temperature and high salt concentrations were capable of activating the tamoxifen-receptor complex, as determined by the increase of its binding to DNA-cellulose; (4) these factors also induced a partial transformation of the β form to the α form; (5) sodium molybdate inhibited both activation and transformation of the β into the α form. The correlation between activation and induction of the α form suggests that the monoclonal antibody recognizes selectively the activated form of the tamoxifen-receptor complex. These results indicate similar properties of the estrogen receptor when bound to either tamoxifen or estradiol; however, the differences observed in the behavior of the tamoxifen-receptor complex as compared with the estradiol-receptor complex. though quantitative rather than qualitative, suggest that the estrogen receptor is affected differently by tamoxifen and estradiol.