Thermodynamic and kinetic characterization of ligand binding to the purine riboswitch aptamer domain

Riboswitches are cis-acting genetic regulatory elements found commonly in bacterial mRNAs that consist of a metabolite-responsive aptamer domain coupled to a regulatory switch. Purine riboswitches respond to intracellular concentrations of either adenine or guanine/hypoxanthine to control gene expression. The aptamer domain of the purine riboswitch contains a pyrimidine residue (Y74) that forms a Watson-Crick base-pairing interaction with the bound purine nucleobase ligand that discriminates between adenine and guanine. We sought to understand the structural basis of this specificity and the mechanism of ligand recognition by the purine riboswitch. Here, we present the 2,6-diaminopurine-bound structure of a C74U mutant of the xpt-pbuX guanine riboswitch, along with a detailed thermodynamic and kinetic analysis of nucleobase recognition by both the native and mutant riboswitches. These studies demonstrate clearly that the pyrimidine at position 74 is the sole determinant of purine riboswitch specificity. In addition, the mutant riboswitch binds adenine and adenine derivatives well compared with the guanine-responsive riboswitch. Under our experimental conditions, 2,6-diaminopurine binds the RNA with DeltaH=-40.3 kcal mol(-1), DeltaS=-97.6 cal mol(-1)K(-1), and DeltaG=-10.73 kcal mol(-1). A kinetic determination of the slow rate (0.15 x 10(5)M(-1)s(-1) and 2.1 x 10(5)mM(-1)s(-1) for 2-aminopurine binding the adenine-responsive mutant riboswitch and 7-deazaguanine-binding guanine riboswitch, respectively) of association under varying experimental conditions allowed us to propose a mechanism for ligand recognition by the purine riboswitch. A conformationally dynamic unliganded state for the binding pocket is stabilized first by the Watson-Crick base pairing between the ligand and Y74, and by the subsequent ordering of the J2/3 loop, enclosing the ligand within the three-way junction.     

Molecular dynamics simulation study of the binding of purine bases to the aptamer domain of the guanine sensing riboswitch

Riboswitches are a novel class of genetic control elements that function through the direct interaction of small metabolite molecules with structured RNA elements. The ligand is bound with high specificity and affinity to its RNA target and induces conformational changes of the RNA''s secondary and tertiary structure upon binding. To elucidate the molecular basis of the remarkable ligand selectivity and affinity of one of these riboswitches, extensive all-atom molecular dynamics simulations in explicit solvent (≈1 μs total simulation length) of the aptamer domain of the guanine sensing riboswitch are performed. The conformational dynamics is studied when the system is bound to its cognate ligand guanine as well as bound to the non-cognate ligand adenine and in its free form. The simulations indicate that residue U51 in the aptamer domain functions as a general docking platform for purine bases, whereas the interactions between C74 and the ligand are crucial for ligand selectivity. These findings either suggest a two-step ligand recognition process, including a general purine binding step and a subsequent selection of the cognate ligand, or hint at different initial interactions of cognate and noncognate ligands with residues of the ligand binding pocket. To explore possible pathways of complex dissociation, various nonequilibrium simulations are performed which account for the first steps of ligand unbinding. The results delineate the minimal set of conformational changes needed for ligand release, suggest two possible pathways for the dissociation reaction, and underline the importance of long-range tertiary contacts for locking the ligand in the complex.     

Mutational analysis of the purine riboswitch aptamer domain

The purine riboswitch is one of a number of mRNA elements commonly found in the 5'-untranslated region capable of controlling expression in a cis-fashion via its ability to directly bind small-molecule metabolites. Extensive biochemical and structural analysis of the nucleobase-binding domain of the riboswitch, referred to as the aptamer domain, has revealed that the mRNA recognizes its cognate ligand using an intricately folded three-way junction motif that completely encapsulates the ligand. High-affinity binding of the purine nucleobase is facilitated by a distal loop-loop interaction that is conserved between both the adenine and guanine riboswitches. To understand the contribution of conserved nucleotides in both the three-way junction and the loop-loop interaction of this RNA, we performed a detailed mutagenic survey of these elements in the context of an adenine-responsive variant of the xpt-pbuX guanine riboswitch from Bacillus subtilis. The varying ability of these mutants to bind ligand as measured by isothermal titration calorimetry uncovered the conserved nucleotides whose identity is required for purine binding. Crystallographic analysis of the bound form of five mutants and chemical probing of their free state demonstrate that the identity of several universally conserved nucleotides is not essential for formation of the RNA-ligand complex but rather for maintaining a binding-competent form of the free RNA. These data show that conservation patterns in riboswitches arise from a combination of formation of the ligand-bound complex, promoting an open form of the free RNA, and participating in the secondary structural switch with the expression platform.     

Structural insights into the interactions of xpt riboswitch with novel guanine analogues: a molecular dynamics simulation study

Ligand recognition in purine riboswitches is a complex process requiring different levels of conformational changes. Recent efforts in the area of purine riboswitch research have focused on ligand analogue binding studies. In the case of the guanine xanthine phosphoribosyl transferase (xpt) riboswitch, synthetic analogues that resemble guanine have the potential to tightly bind and subsequently influence the genetic expression of xpt mRNA in prokaryotes. We have carried out 25 ns Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulation studies of the aptamer domain of the xpt G-riboswitch in four different states: guanine riboswitch in free form, riboswitch bound with its cognate ligand guanine, and with two guanine analogues SJ1 and SJ2. Our work reveals novel interactions of SJ1 and SJ2 ligands with the binding core residues of the riboswitch. The ligands proposed in this work bind to the riboswitch with greater overall stability and lower root mean square deviations and fluctuations compared to guanine ligand. Reporter gene assay data demonstrate that the ligand analogues, upon binding to the RNA, lower the genetic expression of the guanine riboswitch. Our work has important implications for future ligand design and binding studies in the exciting field of riboswitches.     

Riboswitch structure: an internal residue mimicking the purine ligand

The adenine and guanine riboswitches regulate gene expression in response to their purine ligand. X-ray structures of the aptamer moiety of these riboswitches are characterized by a compact fold in which the ligand forms a Watson–Crick base pair with residue 65. Phylogenetic analyses revealed a strict restriction at position 39 of the aptamer that prevents the G39–C65 and A39–U65 combinations, and mutational studies indicate that aptamers with these sequence combinations are impaired for ligand binding. In order to investigate the rationale for sequence conservation at residue 39, structural characterization of the U65C mutant from Bacillus subtilis pbuE adenine riboswitch aptamer was undertaken. NMR spectroscopy and X-ray crystallography studies demonstrate that the U65C mutant adopts a compact ligand-free structure, in which G39 occupies the ligand-binding site of purine riboswitch aptamers. These studies present a remarkable example of a mutant RNA aptamer that adopts a native-like fold by means of ligand mimicking and explain why this mutant is impaired for ligand binding. Furthermore, this work provides a specific insight into how the natural sequence has evolved through selection of nucleotide identities that contribute to formation of the ligand-bound state, but ensures that the ligand-free state remains in an active conformation.     

Purine sensing by riboswitches.

Structured mRNA elements called riboswitches control gene expression by binding to small metabolites. Over a dozen riboswitch classes have been characterized that target a broad range of molecules and vary widely in size and secondary structure. Four of the known riboswitch classes recognize purines or modified purines. Three of these classes are closely related in conserved sequence and secondary structure, but members of these classes selectively recognize guanine, adenine or 2'-deoxyguanosine. Members of the fourth riboswitch class adopt a distinct structure to form a selective binding pocket for the guanine analogue preQ(1) (7-aminomethyl-7-deazaguanine). All four classes of purine-sensing riboswitches are most likely to recognize their respective metabolites by utilizing a riboswitch residue to make a canonical Watson-Crick base-pair with the ligand. This review will provide a summary of the purine-sensing riboswitches, as well as discuss the complex functions and applications of these RNAs.     

Purine sensing by riboswitches

Structured mRNA elements called riboswitches control gene expression by binding to small metabolites. Over a dozen riboswitch classes have been characterized that target a broad range of molecules and vary widely in size and secondary structure. Four of the known riboswitch classes recognize purines or modified purines. Three of these classes are closely related in conserved sequence and secondary structure, but members of these classes selectively recognize guanine, adenine or 2'-deoxyguanosine. Members of the fourth riboswitch class adopt a distinct structure to form a selective binding pocket for the guanine analogue preQ(1) (7-aminomethyl-7-deazaguanine). All four classes of purine-sensing riboswitches are most likely to recognize their respective metabolites by utilizing a riboswitch residue to make a canonical Watson-Crick base-pair with the ligand. This review will provide a summary of the purine-sensing riboswitches, as well as discuss the complex functions and applications of these RNAs.     

A Structural Basis for the Recognition of 2′-Deoxyguanosine by the Purine Riboswitch

Riboswitches are noncoding RNA elements that are commonly found in the 5′-untranslated region of bacterial mRNA. Binding of a small-molecule metabolite to the riboswitch aptamer domain guides the folding of the downstream sequence into one of two mutually exclusive secondary structures that directs gene expression. The purine riboswitch family, which regulates aspects of purine biosynthesis and transport, contains three distinct classes that specifically recognize guanine/hypoxanthine, adenine, or 2′-deoxyguanosine (dG). Structural analysis of the guanine and adenine classes revealed a binding pocket that almost completely buries the nucleobase within the core of the folded RNA. Thus, it is somewhat surprising that this family of RNA elements also recognizes dG. We have used a combination of structural and biochemical techniques to understand how the guanine riboswitch could be converted into a dG binder and the structural basis for dG recognition. These studies reveal that a limited number of sequence changes to a guanine-sensing RNA are required to cause a specificity switch from guanine to 2′-deoxyguanosine, and to impart an altered structure for accommodating the additional deoxyribose sugar moiety.     

Riboswitch regulation mechanisms: RNA,metabolites and regulatory proteins

Riboswitches are RNA sensors that have been shown to modulate the expression of downstream genes by altering their structure upon metabolite binding. Riboswitches are unique among cellular regulators in that metabolite detection is strictly performed using RNA interactions with the sensed metabolite and in which no regulatory protein is needed to mediate the interaction. However, recent studies have shed light on riboswitch control mechanisms relying on protein regulators to harness metabolite binding for the mediation of gene expression, thereby increasing the range of cellular factors involved in riboswitch regulation. The interaction between riboswitches and proteins adds another level of evolutionary pressure as riboswitches must maintain key residues for metabolite detection, structural switching and protein binding sites. Here, we review regulatory mechanisms involving Escherichia coli riboswitches that have recently been shown to rely on regulatory proteins. We also discuss the implication of such protein-based riboswitch regulatory mechanisms for genetic regulation.     

Structure and mechanism of purine-binding riboswitches

A riboswitch is a non-protein coding sequence capable of directly binding a small molecule effector without the assistance of accessory proteins to regulate expression of the mRNA in which it is embedded. Currently, over 20 different classes of riboswitches have been validated in bacteria with the promise of many more to come, making them an important means of regulating the genome in the bacterial kingdom. Strikingly, half of the known riboswitches recognize effector compounds that contain a purine or related moiety. In the last decade, significant progress has been made to determine how riboswitches specifically recognize these compounds against the background of many other similar cellular metabolites and transduce this signal into a regulatory response. Of the known riboswitches, the purine family containing guanine, adenine and 2'-deoxyguanosine-binding classes are the most extensively studied, serving as a simple and useful paradigm for understanding how these regulatory RNAs function. This review provides a comprehensive summary of the current state of knowledge regarding the structure and mechanism of these riboswitches, as well as insights into how they might be exploited as therapeutic targets and novel biosensors.     

A structural intermediate pre-organizes the add adenine riboswitch for ligand recognition

Riboswitches are RNA sequences that regulate gene expression by undergoing structural changes upon the specific binding of cellular metabolites. Crystal structures of purine-sensing riboswitches have revealed an intricate network of interactions surrounding the ligand in the bound complex. The mechanistic details about how the aptamer folding pathway is involved in the formation of the metabolite binding site have been previously shown to be highly important for the riboswitch regulatory activity. Here, a combination of single-molecule FRET and SHAPE assays have been used to characterize the folding pathway of the adenine riboswitch from Vibrio vulnificus. Experimental evidences suggest a folding process characterized by the presence of a structural intermediate involved in ligand recognition. This intermediate state acts as an open conformation to ensure ligand accessibility to the aptamer and folds into a structure nearly identical to the ligand-bound complex through a series of structural changes. This study demonstrates that the add riboswitch relies on the folding of a structural intermediate that pre-organizes the aptamer global structure and the ligand binding site to allow efficient metabolite sensing and riboswitch genetic regulation.     

Theoretical studies on the interaction of guanine riboswitch with guanine and its closest analogues

Experimental studies (M. Mandal, B. Boese, J.E. Barrick, W.C. Winkler and R.R. Breaker, Riboswitches control fundamental biochemical pathways in bacillus subtilis and other bacteria, Cell 113 (2003), pp. 577–586) demonstrated that, besides recognising guanine with high specificity, guanine riboswitch could also bind guanine analogues, but the alteration of every functionalised position on the guanine heterocycle could cause a substantial loss of binding affinity. To investigate the nature of guanine riboswitch recognising metabolites, molecular docking and molecular dynamics simulation were carried out on diverse guanine analogues. The calculation results reveal that (1) most guanine analogues could bind to guanine riboswitch at the same binding pocket, with identical orientations and dissimilar binding energies, which is related to the positions of the functional groups; (2) the two tautomers of xanthine adopt different binding modes, and the enol-tautomer shows similar binding mode and affinity of hypoxanthine, which agrees well with the experimental results and (3) the riboswitch could form stable complexes with guanine analogues by hydrogen bonding contacts with U51 and C74. Particularly, U51 plays an important role in stabilising the complexes.     

Atomistic basis for the on–off signaling mechanism in SAM-II riboswitch

Many bacterial genes are controlled by metabolite sensing motifs known as riboswitches, normally located in the 5′ un-translated region of their mRNAs. Small molecular metabolites bind to the aptamer domain of riboswitches with amazing specificity, modulating gene regulation in a feedback loop as a result of induced conformational changes in the expression platform. Here, we report the results of molecular dynamics simulation studies of the S-adenosylmethionine (SAM)-II riboswitch that is involved in regulating translation in sulfur metabolic pathways in bacteria. We show that the ensemble of conformations of the unbound form of the SAM-II riboswitch is a loose pseudoknot structure that periodically visits conformations similar to the bound form, and the pseudoknot structure is only fully formed upon binding the metabolite, SAM. The rate of forming contacts in the unbound form that are similar to that in the bound form is fast. Ligand binding to SAM-II alters the curvature and base-pairing of the expression platform that could affect the interaction of the latter with the ribosome.     

Role of ligand binding in structural organization of add A-riboswitch aptamer: a molecular dynamics simulation

The specific binding of ligands is the first step of gene expression or translation regulation by riboswitches. However, understanding the mechanism of the specific binding is still difficult because the tertiary structures of the riboswitch aptamers are available almost only for ligand-bound state at present. In this paper we hope to give some insights into this problem through the studies of the role of ligand-aptamer interaction in the structural organization of add A-riboswitch aptamer, based on the crystal structure of the ligand-bound aptamer. We use all-atom molecular dynamics to simulate the behaviors of the aptamer in ligand-bound, free and mutated states by Amber force field. The results show that the correct paring of the ligand adenine with the nucleotide U74 in the binding pocket is crucial to stabilizing the conformations of the ligand-bound aptamer, especially the helix P1 connecting the expression platform. Our results also suggest that both the nucleotide U74 and U51 may be the key sites of the ligand recognition but the former has much higher probability as the initial docking site. This is in agreement with previous experimental results.