Understanding and modeling alternating tangential flow filtration for perfusion cell culture

Alternating tangential flow (ATF) filtration has been used with success in the Biopharmaceutical industry as a lower shear technology for cell retention with perfusion cultures. The ATF system is different than tangential flow filtration; however, in that reverse flow is used once per cycle as a means to minimize fouling. Few studies have been reported in the literature that evaluates ATF and how key system variables affect the rate at which ATF filters foul. In this study, an experimental setup was devised that allowed for determination of the time it took for fouling to occur for given mammalian (PER.C6) cell culture cell densities and viabilities as permeate flow rate and antifoam concentration was varied. The experimental results indicate, in accordance with D'Arcy's law, that the average resistance to permeate flow (across a cycle of operation) increases as biological material deposits on the membrane. Scanning electron microscope images of the post‐run filtration surface indicated that both cells and antifoam micelles deposit on the membrane. A unique mathematical model, based on the assumption that fouling was due to pore blockage from the cells and micelles in combination, was devised that allowed for estimation of sticking factors for the cells and the micelles on the membrane. This model was then used to accurately predict the increase in transmembane pressure during constant flux operation for an ATF cartridge used for perfusion cell culture. © 2014 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 30:1291–1300, 2014     

Industrial scale harvest of proteins from mammalian cell culture by tangential flow filtration

An industrial-scale methods for harvest of biologically active proteins form mammalian cell culture has been developed using tangential flow filtration. A robust and economical process capable of processing approximately 5000 L conditioned media/h with protein yields in excess of 99% has been achieved. A completely contained system has been designed in which total cell number and viability are maintained throughout the process. The process has successfully been implemented at 1.25 x 10(4) L scale for the recovery of kilogram quantities of pharmaceutical proteins such as recombinant tissue type plasminogen activator (rt-PA).     

Large-scale preparation of bacterial cell membranes by tangential flow filtration

The preparation of cell membranes by ultracentrifugation of bacterial cell lysates, a pre-requisite for the purification of over-expressed membrane proteins, is both time-consuming and difficult to perform on a large scale. To overcome this bottleneck in the structural investigation of such proteins in the UK Membrane Protein Structure Initiative, we have investigated the alternative use of tangential flow filtration for preparation of membranes from Escherichia coli. This method proved to be superior to the conventional use of ultracentrifuges both in speed and in yield of membrane protein. Moreover, it could more readily be scaled up to process larger quantities of bacterial cells. Comparison of the purity and monodispersity of an over-expressed membrane protein purified from conventionally-prepared membranes and from membranes prepared by filtration revealed no substantial differences. The approach described should therefore be of general use for membrane protein preparation for a wide range of applications, including both structural and functional studies.     

Intramodule pressure profiles and protein accumulation during tangential flow filtration

Tangential flow filtration (TFF) through a 30 kDa nominal molecular weight cut-off (MWCO) ultrafiltration membrane is widely employed to concentrate purified monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) to levels required for their formulation into injectable biologics. While TFF has been used to remove casein from milk for cheese production for over 35 years, and in pharmaceutical manufacture of biotherapeutic proteins for 20 years, the rapid decline in filtration rate (i.e., flux) at high protein concentrations is a limitation that still needs to be addressed. This is particularly important for mAbs, many of which are 140–160 kDa immunoglobulin G (IgG) type proteins recovered at concentrations of 200 mg/mL or higher. This work reports the direct measurement of local transmembrane pressure drops and off-line confocal imaging of protein accumulation in stagnant regions on the surface of a 30 kDa regenerated cellulose membrane in a flat-sheet configuration widely used in manufacture of biotherapeutic proteins. These first-of-a-kind measurements using 150 kDa bovine IgG show that while axial pressure decreases by 58 psi across a process membrane cassette, the decrease in transmembrane pressure drop is constant at about 1.2 psi/cm along the 20.7 cm length of the membrane. Confocal laser scanning microscopy of the membrane surface at the completion of runs where retentate protein concentration exceeds 200 mg/mL, shows a 50 μm thick protein layer is uniformly deposited. The localized measurements made possible by the modified membrane system confirm the role of protein deposition on limiting ultrafiltration rate and indicate possible targets for improving membrane performance.     

The effects of alternating tangential flow (ATF) residence time,hydrodynamic stress,and filtration flux on high-density perfusion cell culture

In this study, we investigated the effects of alternating tangential flow (ATF) cell separation on high-density perfusion cultures. We have developed methods to estimate theoretical residence times of cells in the ATF system and discovered that long residence times (above 75 s) correlate with decreased growth, metabolism, and productivity. We have calculated energy dissipation rates in the ATF transfer line and filter and empirically studied the impacts of increased exchange rates on cell culture, determining that increased hydrodynamic stress can lead to decreased cell size, lactate production, and specific productivity. Finally, we have conducted experiments to understand the relationship between filtration fluxes and ATF membrane fouling, finding that at fluxes above 60 L·m^–2·day ^–1, protein sieving coefficients see significant rates of decrease (greater than 1% per day). While most of these studies have been conducted with one cell line at one target viable cell density (40 million cells/ml), the general, directional knowledge arising from this study should be applicable to other conditions and programs, ultimately leading to more robust and well-designed perfusion processes.     

Use of scanning electron microscopy and energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy to identify key fouling species during alternating tangential filtration

Alternating tangential flow filtration (ATF) has become one of the primary methods for cell retention and clarification in perfusion bioreactors. However, membrane fouling can cause product sieving losses that limit the performance of these systems. This study used scanning electron microscopy and energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy to identify the nature and location of foulants on 0.2 μm polyethersulfone hollow fiber membranes after use in industrial Chinese hamster ovary cell perfusion bioreactors for monoclonal antibody production. Membrane fouling was dominated by proteinaceous material, primarily host cell proteins along with some monoclonal antibody. Fouling occurred primarily on the lumen surface with much less protein trapped within the depth of the fiber. Protein deposition was also most pronounced near the inlet/exit of the hollow fibers, which are the regions with the greatest flux (and transmembrane pressure) during the cyclical operation of the ATF. These results provide important insights into the underlying phenomena governing the fouling behavior of ATF systems for continuous bioprocessing.     

Wide-surface pore microfiltration membrane drastically improves sieving decay in TFF-based perfusion cell culture and streamline chromatography integration for continuous bioprocessing

Although several compelling benefits for bioprocess intensification have been reported, the need for a streamlined integration of perfusion cultures with capture chromatography still remains unmet. Here, a robust solution is established by conducting tangential flow filtration-based perfusion with a wide-surface pore microfiltration membrane. The resulting integrated continuous bioprocess demonstrated negligible retention of antibody, DNA, and host cell proteins in the bioreactor with average sieving coefficients of 98 ± 1%, 124 ± 28%, and 109 ± 27%, respectively. Further discussion regarding the potential membrane fouling mechanisms is also provided by comparing two membranes with different surface pore structures and the same hollow fiber length, total membrane area, and chemistry. A cake-growth profile is reported for the narrower surface pore, 0.65-µm nominal retention perfusion membrane with final antibody sieving coefficients ≤70%. Whereas the sieving coefficient remained ≥85% during 40 culture days for the wide-surface pore, 0.2-µm nominal retention rating membrane. The wide-surface pore structure, confirmed by scanning electron microscopy imaging, minimizes the formation of biomass deposits on the membrane surface and drastically improves product sieving. This study not only offers a robust alternative for integrated continuous bioprocess by eliminating additional filtration steps while overcoming sieving decay, but also provides insight into membranes' fouling mechanism.     

Purification of plasmid DNA by an integrated operation comprising tangential flow filtration and nitrocellulose adsorption

There is an increasing interest in the development of scaleable and reproducible plasmid DNA purification protocols for vaccine and gene therapy. The use of an integrated unit operation, comprising tangential flow microfiltration coupled with the adsorption of contaminants onto nitrocellulose membranes as a single processing step was examined in this work. Experiments were performed using a custom-built tangential flow microfiltration rig (membrane area=12.5 cm(2)). Tangential flow filtration-adsorption of E. coli lysates containing a plasmid product removed most solids (>75%) and decreased chromosomal DNA contamination by 75% w/w. Total plasmid DNA concentration and supercoiled content of the permeate were virtually identical to those of the feed, indicating a recovery yield of 100% (transmission equal to 1). Results were similar for E. coli lysates containing either a 6.9 kb or a 20 kb plasmid. Significant reductions in RNA, endotoxin, and protein levels were also observed. The reproducibility and potential for scale up of this integrated filtration-adsorption operation makes it at attractive option for intermediate- to large-scale pharmaceutical-grade plasmid processing.     

Upscaling of lentiviral vector production by tangential flow filtration

BACKGROUND: HIV-1-derived vectors are promising tools for gene transfer into the brain. Application of these vectors for gene therapy or for the creation of animal models for neurodegenerative diseases requires standardization and upscaling of lentiviral vector production methods. METHODS: In this study, serum-free HIV-1 vector production was efficiently upscaled by use of cell factories and the introduction of tangential flow filtration (TFF) prior to centrifugation. RESULTS: Vector titers (TU/ml) and p24 values (pg p24/ml) for a serum-free HIV-1 vector produced in cell factories and using TFF prior to centrifugation were comparable to those of small-scale productions. TFF allowed a 66-fold concentration of the vectors with complete vector recovery. Further concentration of the vector (30-fold) was achieved either by low-speed centrifugation or by ultracentrifugation. Combination of TFF and ultracentrifugation resulted in a vector recovery of 90-100% and titers that increased 1800-fold and 900-fold for transducing units and p24 concentration, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: With this new standardized method for lentiviral vector production and concentration, 1 ml of concentrated vector is routinely produced with titers of 10(9)-10(10) TU/ml starting from 2 l of cell-culture medium. Moreover, stereotactic injection of this vector in mouse striatum resulted in a large transduced brain volume in the absence of any immune response.     

Purification of hemoglobin by tangential flow filtration with diafiltration

A recent study by Palmer, Sun, and Harris (Biotechnol. Prog., 25:189–199, 2009) demonstrated that tangential flow filtration (TFF) can be used to produce HPLC‐grade bovine and human hemoglobin (Hb). In this current study, we assessed the quality of bovine Hb (bHb) purified by introducing a 10 L batch‐mode diafiltration step to the previously mentioned TFF Hb purification process. The bHb was purified from bovine red blood cells (RBCs) by filtering clarified RBC lysate through 50 nm (stage I) and 500 kDa (stage II) hollow fiber (HF) membranes. The filtrate was then passed through a 100 kDa (stage III) HF membrane with or without an additional 10 L diafiltration step to potentially remove additional small molecular weight impurities. Protein assays, SDS‐PAGE, and LC‐MS of the purified bHb (stage III retentate) reveal that addition of a diafiltration step has no effect on bHb purity or yield; however, it does increase the methemoglobin level and oxygen affinity of purified bHb. Therefore, we conclude that no additional benefit is gained from diafiltration at stage III and a three stage TFF process is sufficient to produce HPLC‐grade bHb. © 2009 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 2009     

Very high density of CHO cells in perfusion by ATF or TFF in WAVE bioreactor™. Part I. Effect of the cell density on the process

High cell density perfusion process of antibody producing CHO cells was developed in disposable WAVE Bioreactor? using external hollow fiber filter as cell separation device. Both “classical” tangential flow filtration (TFF) and alternating tangential flow system (ATF) equipment were used and compared. Consistency of both TFF‐ and ATF‐based cultures was shown at 20–35 × 10⁶ cells/mL density stabilized by cell bleeds. To minimize the nutrients deprivation and by‐product accumulation, a perfusion rate correlated to the cell density was applied. The cells were maintained by cell bleeds at density 0.9–1.3 × 10⁸ cells/mL in growing state and at high viability for more than 2 weeks. Finally, with the present settings, maximal cell densities of 2.14 × 10⁸ cells/mL, achieved for the first time in a wave‐induced bioreactor, and 1.32 × 10⁸ cells/mL were reached using TFF and ATF systems, respectively. Using TFF, the cell density was limited by the membrane capacity for the encountered high viscosity and by the pCO₂ level. Using ATF, the cell density was limited by the vacuum capacity failing to pull the highly viscous fluid. Thus, the TFF system allowed reaching higher cell densities. The TFF inlet pressure was highly correlated to the viscosity leading to the development of a model of this pressure, which is a useful tool for hollow fiber design of TFF and ATF. At very high cell density, the viscosity introduced physical limitations. This led us to recommend cell densities under 1.46 × 10⁸ cell/mL based on the analysis of the theoretical distance between the cells for the present cell line. © 2013 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 29:754–767, 2013     

Development of a novel purification method for AAV vectors using tangential flow filtration

Adeno-associated virus (AAV) vector can efficiently transduce therapeutic genes in various tissue types with less side effects; however, owing to complex multistep processes during manufacture, there have been surges in the pricing of recently approved AAV vector-based gene therapy products. This study aimed to develop a simple and efficient method for high-quality purification of AAV vector via tangential flow filtration (TFF), which is commonly used for concentration and diafiltration of solutions during AAV vector purification. We established a novel purification method using TFF and surfactants. Treatment with two classes of surfactants (anionic and zwitterionic) successfully inhibited the aggregation of residual proteins separated from the AAV vector in the crude product by TFF, obtaining a clearance of 99.5% residual proteins. Infectivity of the AAV vector purified using the new method was confirmed both in vitro and in vivo, and no remarkable inflammation or tissue damage was observed in mouse skeletal muscle after local administration. Overall, our proposed method could be used to establish a platform for the purification of AAV vector.     

Production of high-titer transmission-defective RNA virus-based episomal vector using tangential flow filtration

In recent years, viral vector based in vivo gene delivery strategies have achieved a significant success in the treatment of genetic diseases. RNA virus-based episomal vector lacking viral glycoprotein gene (ΔG-REVec) is a nontransmissive gene delivery system that enables long-term gene expression in a variety of cell types in vitro, yet in vivo gene delivery has not been successful due to the difficulty in producing high titer vector. The present study showed that tangential flow filtration (TFF) can be effectively employed to increase the titer of ΔG-REVec. Concentration and diafiltration of ΔG-REVec using TFF significantly increased its titer without loss of infectious activity. Importantly, intracranial administration of high titer vector enabled persistent transgene expression in rodent brain.     

Investigating the combination of single-pass tangential flow filtration and anion exchange chromatography for intensified mAb polishing

There is growing interest within the biopharmaceutical industry to improve manufacturing efficiency through process intensification, with the goal of generating more product in less time with smaller equipment. In monoclonal antibody (mAb) purification, a unit operation that can benefit from intensification is anion exchange (AEX) polishing chromatography. Single-pass tangential flow filtration (SPTFF) technology offers an opportunity for process intensification by reducing intermediate pool volumes and increasing product concentration without recirculation. This study evaluated the performance of an AEX resin, both in terms of host cell protein (HCP) purification and viral clearance, following concentration of a mAb feed using SPTFF. Results show that preconcentration of AEX feed material improved isotherm conditions for HCP binding, resulting in a fourfold increase in resin mAb loading at the target HCP clearance level. Excellent clearance of minute virus of mouse and xenotropic murine virus was maintained at this higher load level. The increased mAb loading enabled by SPTFF preconcentration effectively reduced AEX column volume and buffer requirements, shrinking the overall size of the polishing step. In addition, the suitability of SPTFF for extended processing time operation was demonstrated, indicating that this approach can be implemented for continuous biomanufacturing. The combination of SPTFF concentration and AEX chromatography for an intensified mAb polishing step which improves both manufacturing flexibility and process productivity is supported.     

Investigation of the parameters affecting the separation of bacterial enzymes from cell debris by tangential flow filtration

The effect of organism, enzyme, method of cell breakage and membrane characteristics on the separation of bacterial enzymes from cell debris by tangential flow filtration has been studied. The effectiveness of separation was assessed by process time, enzyme yield and specific activity, and turbidity of the filtrate. For a particular organism and enzyme, method of cell breakage and membrane characteristics significantly influenced separation performance, though results indicate that it is not yet possible to optimize all aspects of performance simultaneously.     

Virus harvesting in perfusion culture: Choosing the right type of hollow fiber membrane

The use of bioreactors coupled to membrane-based perfusion systems enables very high cell and product concentrations in vaccine and viral vector manufacturing. Many virus particles, however, are not stable and either lose their infectivity or physically degrade resulting in significant product losses if not harvested continuously. Even hollow fiber membranes with a nominal pore size of 0.2 µm can retain much smaller virions within a bioreactor. Here, we report on a systematic study to characterize structural and physicochemical membrane properties with respect to filter fouling and harvesting of yellow fever virus (YFV; ~50 nm). In tangential flow filtration perfusion experiments, we observed that YFV retention was only marginally determined by nominal but by effective pore sizes depending on filter fouling. Evaluation of scanning electron microscope images indicated that filter fouling can be reduced significantly by choosing membranes with (i) a flat inner surface (low boundary layer thickness), (ii) a smooth material structure (reduced deposition), (iii) a high porosity (high transmembrane flux), (iv) a distinct pore size distribution (well-defined pore selectivity), and (v) an increased fiber wall thickness (larger effective surface area). Lowest filter fouling was observed with polysulfone (PS) membranes. While the use of a small-pore PS membrane (0.08 µm) allowed to fully retain YFV within the bioreactor, continuous product harvesting was achieved with the large-pore PS membrane (0.34 µm). Due to the low protein rejection of the latter, this membrane type could also be of interest for other applications, that is, recombinant protein production in perfusion cultures.     

Application of high-performance tangential flow filtration (HPTFF) to the purification of a human pharmaceutical antibody fragment expressed in Escherichia coli

High-performance tangential flow filtration (HPTFF) is shown to successfully enable concentration, purification and formulation in a single unit operation. This is illustrated with feedstreams comprising recombinant proteins expressed in Escherichia coli (E. coli). Using positively charged cellulosic membranes of 100 kDa molecular weight cut-off and operating under a selected range of buffer pH and ionic strength at a filtrate flux of 100 L m(-2) h(-1), a 10-fold removal of E. coli host cell proteins (HCP) was obtained with an overall process yield of 98%. The HPTFF performance was shown to be robust and reproducible. In addition, the novel charged membrane was regenerated and re-used seven times without loss of selectivity or throughput. When compared with a conventional purification scheme, the proposed process results in the elimination of one chromatographic step, a 12% yield improvement and a significant reduction in purification cost of goods.     

Development of a small-scale rotary lobe-pump cell culture model for examining cell damage in large-scale N-1 seed perfusion process

Perfusion technology has been identified as a process improvement capable of eliminating some of the constraints in cell culture and allows for high cell densities and viabilities. However, when implementing this N-1 seed perfusion platform in large-scale manufacturing, unexpected cell damage was observed as early as Day 1. Given that the shear rate within recirculation hollow fibers was normalized and aligned correctly across bench, pilot, and manufacture scale, the primary mitigation was placed on the rotary lobe pump. Lowering the pump rate in manufacture scale successfully alleviated the cell damage. To understand the source of cell damage within the pump, a small-scale rotary lobe-pump robustness model was developed. Testing different pump flow rates and back pressures, it was concluded that high back pressure can cause cell damage. The back pressure within the system can cause back flow and high shear within small clearances inside the pump, which lead to the primary cell damage observed at a large scale. This shear level can be significantly higher than the shear in the hollow fiber. This pump robustness model can be utilized to aid the perfusion skid design, including pump operation efficiency and cell shear sensitivity. Methods to reduce the back pressure and cell shearing were determined to better predict manufacturing performance in the future.     

High density culture of HeLa cells in a CelliGen perfusion system

A hollow fiber cartridge may be used in an extraneous recycle loop to facilitate perfusion operation of a stirred tank bioreactor. Retention of cells while removing waste products and replenishment with fresh nutrients allows higher than normal cell densities obtained in batch or continuous culture systems. This system successfully propagated HeLa cells to over 11 million viable cells per milliliter. Much higher perfusion rates (up to 4 vessel volumes per day) were necessary for high density culture of HeLa cells compared to BHK or a hybridoma cell line because of a much higher specific cellular metabolic rate. Cell specific glucose consumption rate, lactate production and ammonia production rates are several times higher for HeLa cells. Reproducible high cell densities and viabilities can be repeatedly obtained after harvest and dilution of a HeLa cell culture by partial drainage and reconstitution in the bioreactor.     

Purification of infectious adenovirus in two hours by ultracentrifugation and tangential flow filtration

Adenoviruses are excellent vectors for gene transfer and are used extensively for high-level expression of the products of transgenes in living cells. The development of simple and rapid methods for the purification of stable infectious recombinant adenoviruses (rAds) remains a challenge. We report here a method for the purification of infectious adenovirus type 5 (Ad5) that involves ultracentrifugation on a cesium chloride gradient at 604,000g for 15 min at 4 degrees C and tangential flow filtration. The entire procedure requires less than two hours and infectious Ad5 can be recovered at levels higher than 64% of the number of plaque-forming units (pfu) in the initial crude preparation of viruses. We have obtained titers of infectious purified Ad5 of 1.35x10(10) pfu/ml and a ratio of particle titer to infectious titer of seven. The method described here allows the rapid purification of rAds for studies of gene function in vivo and in vitro, as well as the rapid purification of Ad5.