GTP analogues interact with the tubulin exchangeable site during assembly and upon binding

The question of whether nonhydrolyzable nucleotide analogues and other nucleoside triphosphates support tubulin assembly was addressed. Tubulin which contained residual GTP at the exchangeable site polymerized in the absence of added GTP in the presence of DMSO or glycerol. After maximum absorbance was reached, disassembly occurred at a slow rate. When 0.5 mM GMPPCP, GMPPNP, or ATP was included in the assembly reaction, disassembly did not occur, and about 0.1 mol of these nucleotides per mole of tubulin was incorporated into the protein. When 5 mM nucleotide was used or alkaline phosphatase was included in the case of the nonhydrolyzable analogues, a greater amount of assembly occurred and about 0.7-0.8 mol of analogue was incorporated. The products of the assembly reaction were cold-labile microtubules and protofilament ribbons. After cold-depolymerization of the microtubules and ribbons, a second cycle of assembly produced some microtubules, but cold-stable amorphous polymers were the major product. In addition, when GTP at the exchangeable site was first removed by a cycle of assembly, followed by depolymerization, assembly in the presence of GMPPCP, GMPPNP, or ATP produced a mixture of microtubules and cold-stable polymers, both of which contained bound analogue. Incorporation of GMPPCP, GMPPNP, or ATP into polymerized tubulin always occurred at the expense of GDP at the exchangeable site, the content of which decreased correspondingly. Incubation of tubulin with 5 mM GMPPCP, GMPPNP, or ATP under nonassembly conditions also displaced GDP.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Effects of pH on tubulin-nucleotide interactions

Significant GTP-independent, temperature-dependent turbidity development occurs with purified tubulin stored in the absence of unbound nucleotide, and this can be minimized with a higher reaction pH. Since microtubule assembly is optimal at lower pH values, we examined pH effects on tubulin-nucleotide interactions. While the lowest concentration of GTP required for assembly changed little, GDP was more inhibitory at higher pH values. The amounts of exogenous GTP bound to tubulin at all pH values were similar, but the amounts of exogenous GDP bound and endogenous GDP (i.e., GDP originally bound in the exchangeable site) retained by tubulin rose as reaction pH increased. Endogenous GDP was more efficiently displaced by exogenous GTP than GDP at all pH values, but displacement by GTP was 10-15% greater at pH 6 than at pH 7. Dissociation constants for GDP and GTP were about 1.0 microM at pH 6 and 0.02 microM at pH 7. A small increase in the affinity of GDP relative to that of GTP occurs at pH 7 as compared to pH 6, together with a 50-fold absolute increase in the affinity of both nucleotides for tubulin at pH 7. The time courses of microtubule assembly and GTP hydrolysis were compared at pH 6 and pH 7. At pH 6, the two reactions were simultaneous in onset and initially stoichiometric. At pH 7, although the reactions began simultaneously, hydrolysis seemed to lag substantially behind assembly. Unhydrolyzed radiolabeled GTP was not incorporated into microtubules, however, indicating that GTP hydrolysis is actually closely coupled to assembly. The apparent lag in hydrolysis probably results from a methodological artifact rather than incorporation of GTP into the microtubule with delayed hydrolysis.     

Tubulin-nucleotide interactions. Effects of removal of exchangeable guanine nucleotide on protein conformation and microtubule assembly.

The removal of tightly bound GDP from the exchangeable nucleotide-binding site of tubulin has been performed with alkaline phosphatase under conditions which essentially retain the assembly properties of the protein. When microtubule protein is treated with alkaline phosphatase, nucleotide is selectively removed from tubulin dimer rather than from MAP (microtubule-associated protein)-containing oligomeric species. Tubulin devoid of E-site (the exchangeable nucleotide-binding site of the tubulin dimer) nucleotide shows enhanced proteolytic susceptibility of the beta-subunit to thermolysin and decreased protein stability, consistent with nucleotide removal causing changes in protein tertiary structure. Pyrophosphate ion (3 mM) is able to promote formation of normal microtubules in the complete absence of GTP by incubation at 37 degrees C either with nucleotide-depleted microtubule protein or with nucleotide-depleted tubulin dimer to which MAPs have been added. The resulting microtubules contain up to 80% of tubulin lacking E-site nucleotide. In addition to its effects on nucleation, pyrophosphate competes weakly with GDP bound at the E-site. It is deduced that binding of pyrophosphate at a vacant E-site can promote microtubule assembly. The minimum structural requirement for ligands to induce tubulin assembly apparently involves charge neutralization at the E-site by bidentate ligation, which stabilizes protein domains in a favourable orientation for promoting the supramolecular protein-protein interactions involved in microtubule formation.     

Nucleotide binding and phosphorylation in microtubule assembly in vitro.

Two non-hydrolyzable analogs of GTP, guanylyl-β,γ-methylene diphosphonate and guanylyl imidodiphosphate, have been found to induce rapid and efficient microtubule assembly in vitro by binding at the exchangeable site (E-site) on tubulin. Characterization of microtubule polymerization by several criteria, including polymerization kinetics, nucleotide binding to depolymerized and polymerized microtubules, and microtubule stability, reveals strong similarities between microtubule assembly induced by GTP and non-hydrolyzable GTP analogs. Nucleoside triphosphates which bind weakly or not at all to tubulin, such as ATP, UTP and CTP, are shown to induce microtubule assembly by means of a nucleoside diphosphate kinase (NDP-kinase, EC 2.7.4.6.) activity which is not intrinsic to tubulin. The NDP-kinase mediates microtubule polymerization by phosphorylating tubulin-bound GDP in situ at the E-site. Although hydrolysis of exchangeably bound GTP occurs, it is found to be uncoupled from the polymerization reaction. The non-exchangeable nucleotide binding site on tubulin (N-site) is not directly involved in microtubule assembly in vitro. The N-site is shown to contain almost exclusively GTP which is not hydrolyzed during microtubule assembly. A scheme is presented in which GTP acts as an allosteric effector at the E-site during microtubule assembly in vitro.     

Stoichiometry and role of GTP hydrolysis in bovine neurotubule assembly

A method is given for preparing tubulin with 1 mol of exchangeably bound [gamma-32P]GTP/mol of 6 S dimer. Bovine tubulin is shown to hydrolyze 1 mol of GTP/mol of 6 S dimer added to assembling microtubules at 37 degrees. Hydrolysis and assembly occur at the same rate and to the same extent. When microtubule-associated proteins (MAPs) are removed, both hydrolysis and assembly fail to occur. Readdition of the MAPs restores both activities. Tubulin with exchangeable GDP will co-assemble with GTP.tubulin even at equimolar levels. Exchangeability is demonstrated by pulse-chase experiments with GDP or GTP. GDP is also a potent inhibitor of assembly under these conditions, and the rate of assembly is reduced by 50% at 10 micron GDP. One mole of inorganic phosphate is released to the solvent per mole of exchangeable GTP hydrolyzed. An assembly mechanism is proposed in which exchangeable GTP is hydrolyzed without intermediate transphosphorylation of nonexchangeable GDP.     

Turnover of tubulin and the N site GTP in Chinese hamster ovary cells

Radioactively labeled tubulin from Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells can be isolated by co-polymerization with nonradioactive porcine brain microtubule protein. 75% of the soluble tubulin in CHO extracts co-polymerizes with the porcine protein through several cycles, without preferential loss of either CHO or porcine subunits. After phosphocellulose chromatography of the co-polymerized microtubules, the CHO tubulin is radiochemically homogeneous, as judged by SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. CHO tubulin purified in this way has 1 mole of nucleotide per mole of protein noncovalently bound at the non-exchangeable or N site. This-layer chromatography indicates that the N site nucleotide is entirely ribo-GTP. Label and chase experiments show that the N site GTP exchanges intracellularly with a half-time of 33 hr in growing cells which have a generation time of 17 hr, while the tubulin polypeptides are degraded with a half-time of 48 hr. Intracellular hydrolysis of the gamma-phosphate of the N site nucleotide can be detected but occurs very slowly, with a half-time of 24 hr. These results suggest that the N site nucleotide may function in vivo as a stable structural co-factor of the tubulin molecule and render improbable the possibility that it has a regulatory role in microtubule assembly.     

Nucleotide specificity in microtubule assembly in vitro

A procedure is described for removing most of the GDP bound at the exchangeable GTP binding site (E site) of tubulin. Microtubule protein containing substoichiometric amounts of GDP at the E site is found to polymerize in response to: (a) two nonhydrolyzable ATP analogues, adenylyl imidodiphosphate (AMP-PNP) and adenylyl beta, gamma-methylenediphosphonate (AMP-PCP); and (b) substoichiometric levels of GTP or dGTP. The results are interpreted as suggesting that: (1) when GDP is removed from tubulin, the E site shows broad specificity for nucleoside triphosphates: (2) microtubule assembly can be induced by the binding of substoichiometric amounts of nucleoside triphosphate to the E site.     

Neurotubule assembly at substoichiometric nucleotide levels using a GTP regenerating system

Tubulin derived from cold depolymerized bovine microtubules has been gel filtered to obtain a tubulin preparation with only 3% of the tubulin dimers containing exchangeable [³H]-guanine nucleotide. In the presence of acetyl-P and bacterial acetate kinase, this preparation polymerizes to form microtubules which are morphologically indistinguishable from microtubules formed in the presence of excess GTP. The extent of microtubule formation at substoichiometric nucleotide levels using the GTP regenerating system exceeds the extent of assembly obtained with excess GTP. It is concluded that the exchangeable guanine nucleotide site can be virtually unoccupied in intact neurotubules and this finding indicates that GDP can “catalyze” tubule assembly in the presence of a GTP regenerating system.     

Tublin: nucleotide binding and enzymic activity

The existence of two distinguishable guanine nucleotide binding sites per molecule of tubulin has been confirmed. One site rapidly exchanges GTP with the medium (E site), the other site binds GDP or GTP very strongly (N site). The GDP bound to the N site can be converted to GTP by transphosphorylase activity using GTP or ATP as the phosphate donor. ATP binds only weakly to the E site, yet it is a better substrate than GTP in the transphosphorylation reaction. The nucleotide used in this reaction therefore comes from the medium and binds to a third site on tubulin itself or to another protein associated with it. Tubulin preparations also show a low ATPase or GTPase activity, which in part is accounted for by turnover of GTP on the N site, the remainder may be associated with the transphosphorylase, tubulin aggregation or contaminating enzyme activity. In addition, during microtubule formation the bound γ-³²P of GTP is lost from both the E and the N sites, leaving bound GDP on the former and probably on the latter site.     

Nucleoside diphosphate kinase from brain. Purification and effect on microtubule assembly in vitro

Tubulin strictly requires GTP for its polymerization. Nevertheless, microtubule assembly can be observed in the presence of ATP as the only nucleotide triphosphate, due to the nucleoside diphosphate kinase (NDP kinase) present in microtubule preparations, and which phosphorylates the GDP into GTP. We have purified this enzyme from pig brain to homogeneity, and shown that its relative mass is close to 100 000 in its native state, and 17 000 under denaturing conditions. Therefore it is probably a hexamer, as previously shown for the enzyme from other sources, and also presents a microheterogeneity, with the major isoforms between pI 5.0 and 6.0. The enzyme is transiently phosphorylated during catalysis, as expected within a ping-pong bi-bi mechanism. The effect of the NDP kinase on pure tubulin polymerization was studied: in the presence of NDP kinase, the lag time observed in the kinetics of microtubule assembly was shorter and the final extent of assembly was unchanged. The effect of the enzyme was observed at enzyme concentrations 900-fold lower than tubulin concentration, which shows that the NDP kinase acts catalytically. Kinetic data show that the catalytic effect of the NDP kinase is faster than the rate of nucleotide exchange on tubulin under the same conditions. This result demonstrates that the tubulin-GDP complex itself is a substrate for the enzyme, which may indicate that the GDP bound to tubulin at the E site is exposed on the surface of dimeric tubulin.     

Guanosine 5'-O-(3-thiotriphosphate), a potent nucleotide inhibitor of microtubule assembly

Guanosine 5'-O-(3-thiotriphosphate) (GTP gamma S) and the two diastereoisomers of guanosine 5'-O-(2-thiotriphosphate) (GTP beta S) were prepared enzymatically, and their interactions with tubulin and microtubule-associated proteins (MAPs) in 0.1 M 2-(N-morpholino)ethanesulfonate, 0.5 mM MgCl2 were examined. GTP gamma S did not support microtubule assembly but instead inhibited the reaction. This analog was 1.5-2 times more potent than GDP in inhibiting both tubulin polymerization and GTP hydrolysis under conditions in which these reactions were dependent on MAPs. In contrast to the analog's inhibitory effects on polymerization and hydrolysis, however, radiolabeled GTP gamma S was only feebly bound by purified tubulin at 0 degrees C relative to the binding of GDP and GTP. There was a marked increase in the amount of GTP gamma S bound when the reaction temperature was raised to 37 degrees C or when MAPs were included in the reaction mixture. Only when both MAPs were present and the higher reaction temperature was used did the binding of GTP gamma S exceed that of GDP. Since substitution of sulfur for oxygen in a molecule should decrease its hydrophilic properties, these findings suggest that the exchangeable nucleotide binding site of tubulin becomes more hydrophobic at higher temperatures and in the presence of MAPs. The two isomers of GTP beta S were able to support MAP-dependent polymerization, although a 50-100-fold higher concentration of the analogs as compared to GTP was required. Neither isomer of GTP beta S had a significant inhibitory effect on GTP hydrolysis dependent on tubulin + MAPs.     

Tubulin-associated nucleoside diphosphokinase.

Microtubule protein, prepared by cycles of polymerisation and dissociation, contained a nucleoside diphosphokinase (NDP kinase) activity (EC 2.7.4.6). This activity was not intrinsic to the tubulin dimer or the so-called microtubule-associated proteins. The NDP kinase had the following properties. (1) The enzyme existed in a low-molecular-weight form and in association with the complex of microtubule-associated proteins and tubulin (i.e. multimeric tubulin). (2) The low-molecular-weight species was also formed by dissociation of multimeric tubulin by salt or by removal of microtubule-associated proteins on phosphocellulose. (3) GDP bound to the exchangeable site of multimeric tubulin and also GDP derived from the E site of the tubulin dimer was a substrate for the NDP kinase. (4) The NDP kinase showed a 7-fold increase in activity during ATP-dependent microtubule assembly. On the basis of these properties, it is proposed that microtubule protein contains an NDP kinase specifically associated with tubulin and its functions.     

Use of a GTP photoaffinity probe to resolve aspects of the mechanism of tubulin polymerization.

8-Azidoguanosine 5'-triphosphate (8-N3GTP) was used in a photoactivatable probe to examine the role of GTP in microtubule assembly. 8-N3GTP was able to substitute for GTP in the promotion of tubulin polymerization and was hydrolyzed at 37 degrees C in the presence or absence of colchicine or calcium. Photolysis of the analog in the presence of microtubular protein resulted in its covalent incorporation onto a GTP-specific site of the beta monomer. The efficiency of this incorporation was different when 8-N3GDP (which does not affect polymerization) was used in place of 8-N3GTP, implying a different orientation of the nucleoside diphosphate within the receptor site. During microtubule assembly, 8-N3GTP was hydrolyzed in situ at the tubulin-GTP exchangeable site in a process that was dependent upon polymerization. The use of [beta, gamma-32P]8-N3GTP and [gamma-32P]8-N3GTP indicated that this hydrolysis occurred concurrently with polymerization and that only nucleoside diphosphate remained bound to the polymerized tubulin.     

Direct incorporation of guanosine 5'-diphosphate into microtubules without guanosine 5'-triphosphate hydrolysis

Using highly purified calf brain tubulin bearing [8-14C]guanosine 5'-diphosphate (GDP) in the exchangeable nucleotide site and heat-treated microtubule-associated proteins (both components containing negligible amounts of nucleoside diphosphate kinase and nonspecific phosphatase activities), we have found that a significant proportion of exchangeable-site GDP in microtubules can be incorporated directly during guanosine 5'-triphosphate (GTP) dependent polymerization of tubulin, without an initial exchange of GDP for GTP and subsequent GTP hydrolysis during assembly. The precise amount of GDP incorporated directly into microtubules is highly dependent on specific reaction conditions, being favored by high tubulin concentrations, low GTP and Mg2+ concentrations, and exogenous GDP in the reaction mixture. Minimum effects were observed with changes in reaction pH or temperature, changes in concentration of microtubule-associated proteins, alteration of the sulfonate buffer, or the presence of a calcium chelator in the reaction mixture. Under conditions most favorable for direct GDP incorporation, about one-third of the GDP in microtubules is incorporated directly (without GTP hydrolysis) and two-thirds is incorporated hydrolytically (as a consequence of GTP hydrolysis). Direct incorporation of GDP occurs in a constant proportion throughout elongation, and the amount of direct incorporation probably reflects the rapid equilibration of GDP and GTP at the exchangeable site that occurs before the onset of assembly.     

Evidence for a distinct ligand binding site on tubulin discovered through inhibition by GDP of paclitaxel-induced tubulin assembly in the absence of exogenous GTP

GDP inhibits paclitaxel-induced tubulin assembly without GTP when the tubulin bears GDP in the exchangeable site (E-site). Initially, we thought inhibition was mediated through the E-site, since small amounts of GTP or Mg²⁺, which favors GTP binding to the E-site, reduced inhibition by GDP. We thought trace GTP released from the nonexchangeable site (N-site) by tubulin denaturation was required for polymer nucleation, but microtubule length was unaffected by GDP. Further, enhancing polymer nucleation reduced inhibition by GDP. Other mechanisms involving the E-site were eliminated experimentally. Upon finding that ATP weakly inhibited paclitaxel-induced assembly, we concluded that another ligand binding site was responsible for these inhibitory effects, and we found that GDP was not binding at the taxoid, colchicine, or vinca sites. There may therefore be a lower affinity site on tubulin to which GDP can bind distinct from the E- and N-sites, possibly on α-tubulin, based on molecular modeling studies.     

Stoichiometry for guanine nucleotide binding to tubulin under polymerizing and nonpolymerizing conditions

The maximal stoichiometry for [³H]GTP binding to depolymerized tubulin with saturating amounts of added [³H]GTP is 0.4 mol/110,000 g protein. In contrast, 1 mol of radioactive nucleotide is incorporated into microtubules as a result of polymerization with [³H]GTP. The different stoichiometries result from a difference in the nucleotide binding properties of ring protein under polymerizing and nonpolymerizing conditions: ring protein at 0 °C is devoid of binding activity but binds added radioactive guanine nucleotide during microtubule assembly. The radioactive nucleotide which is incorporated into rings during microtubule assembly is not displaced by excess GDP, although it is at a site which is distinct from the N site.     

On the role of the tubulin nonexchangeable GTP site in bovine neurotubule assembly.

A procedure for radiolabeling the terminal phosphoryl group of the tubulin nonexchangeable GTP site using bacterial acetate kinase and acetyl-32P is described. Warming such samples to 37 degrees results in microtubule assembly and hydrolysis of the nonexchangeable site GTP in a parallel fashion. Removal of the microtubule-associated protein fraction from lebeled tubulin prevents hydrolysis and assembly, and recombination of these components restores both processes again in a parallel fashion. These and other experiments indicate that the nonexchangeable site GTP hydrolysis and assembly are intimately linked. The experiments also demonstrate that GRP is not required at the exchangeable nucleotide site for assembly to occur.     

Reexamination of the role of nonhydrolyzable guanosine 5'-triphosphate analogues in tubulin polymerization: reaction conditions are a critical factor for effective interactions at the exchangeable nucleotide site

Recently it was proposed [O'Brien, E. T., & Erickson, H. P. (1989) Biochemistry 28, 1413-1422] that tubulin polymerization supported by guanosine 5'-(beta,gamma-imidotriphosphate) [p(NH)ppG], guanosine 5'-(beta,gamma-methylenetriphosphate) [p(CH2)ppG], and ATP might be due to residual GTP in reaction mixtures and that these nucleotides would probably support only one cycle of assembly. Since we had observed polymerization with these three compounds, we decided to study these reactions in greater detail in two systems. The first contained purified tubulin and a high concentration of glycerol, the second tubulin and microtubule-associated proteins (MAPs). In both systems, reactions supported by nucleotides other than GTP were most vigorous at lower pH values. In the glycerol system, repeated cycles of polymerization were observed with ATP and p(CH2)ppG, but not with p(NH)ppG. With p(NH)ppG, a single cycle of polymerization was observed, and this was caused by contaminating GTP. In the MAPs system, repeated cycles of polymerization were observed with both nonhydrolyzable GTP analogues, even without contaminating GTP, but ATP was not active at all in this system. Binding to tubulin of p(NH)ppG, p(CH2)ppG, and, to a lesser extent, ATP was demonstrated indirectly, since high concentrations of the three nucleotides displaced radiolabeled GDP originally bound in the exchangeable site, with p(NH)ppG the most active of the three compounds in this displacement assay. The failure of GTP-free p(NH)ppG to support tubulin polymerization in our glycerol system even though it displaced GDP from the exchangeable site was further investigated by examining the effects of p(NH)ppG on polymerization and polymer-bound nucleotide with low concentrations of GTP. The two nucleotides appeared to act synergistically in supporting polymerization, so that a reaction occurred with a subthreshold GTP concentration if p(NH)ppG was also in the reaction mixture. Analysis of radiolabeled exchangeable-site nucleotide in polymers formed in reaction mixtures containing both GTP and p(NH)ppG demonstrated that p(NH)ppG which entered polymer did so primarily at the expense of GDP originally bound in the exchangeable site rather than at the expense of GTP. It appears that in the glycerol reaction condition, tubulin-p(NH)ppG cannot initiate tubulin polymerization but that it can participate in polymer elongation. ATP and p(CH2)ppG also entered the exchangeable site during polymerization without GTP in glycerol, as demonstrated by displacement of radiolabeled GDP from polymer when these alternate nucleotides were used.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Effect of tubulin self-association on GTP hydrolysis and nucleotide exchange reactions

We investigated how the self-association of isolated tubulin dimers affects the rate of GTP hydrolysis and the equilibrium of nucleotide exchange. Both reactions are relevant for microtubule (MT) dynamics. We used HPLC to determine the concentrations of GDP and GTP and thereby the GTPase activity of SEC-eluted tubulin dimers in assembly buffer solution, free of glycerol and tubulin aggregates. When GTP hydrolysis was negligible, the nucleotide exchange mechanism was studied by determining the concentrations of tubulin-free and tubulin-bound GTP and GDP. We observed no GTP hydrolysis below the critical conditions for MT assembly (either below the critical tubulin concentration and/or at low temperature), despite the assembly of tubulin 1D curved oligomers and single-rings, showing that their assembly did not involve GTP hydrolysis. Under conditions enabling spontaneous slow MT assembly, a slow pseudo-first-order GTP hydrolysis kinetics was detected, limited by the rate of MT assembly. Cryo-TEM images showed that GTP-tubulin 1D oligomers were curved also at 36 °C. Nucleotide exchange depended on the total tubulin concentration and the molar ratio between tubulin-free GDP and GTP. We used a thermodynamic model of isodesmic tubulin self-association, terminated by the formation of tubulin single-rings to determine the molar fractions of dimers with exposed and buried nucleotide exchangeable sites (E-sites). Our analysis shows that the GDP to GTP exchange reaction equilibrium constant was an order-of-magnitude larger for tubulin dimers with exposed E-sites than for assembled dimers with buried E-sites. This conclusion may have implications on the dynamics at the tip of the MT plus end.     

Microtubules and nucleoside diphosphate kinase. Comparison of kinetics of GTP- and CTP-induced assembly.

The kinetics of assembly of MAP2-tubulin microtubule protein were examined as a function of the GTP concentration in order to test the hypothesis that CTP-induced assembly results from the generation of GTP by nucleoside diphosphate kinase. These studies show that (a) there is no assembly below a minimum GTP concentration and that this represents a nucleation requirement, (b) the rate of elongation is inconsistent with a single assembly-species, and (c) the elongation rate increases markedly as the GTP concentration is raised, although GTP is not absolutely required for elongation. These assembly kinetics have been compared with those with increasing CTP concentrations, by using microtubule protein containing a very low nucleoside diphosphate kinase activity of known substrate specificity. Neither nucleation nor the observed rates of elongation can be attributed to the formation of GTP, either (a) in terms of the generation of free GTP and subsequent binding to tubulin or (b) by the direct charging of GDP bound to the tubulin exchangeable site. The results show that nucleoside diphosphate kinase is not required for CTP-induced microtubule assembly, and suggest that CTP directly effects microtubule assembly.