Effects of transgenic rootstocks on growth and development of non-transgenic scion cultivars in apple

Although cultivation of genetic modified (GM) annual crops has been steadily increasing in the recent 10 years, the commercial cultivation of GM fruit tree is still very limited and reports of field trials on GM fruit trees are rare. This is probably because development and evaluation of GM fruit trees require a long period of time due to long life cycles of trees. In this study, we report results from a field trial on three rolB transgenic dwarfing apple rootstocks of M26 and M9 together with non-transgenic controls grafted with five non-transgenic scion cultivars. We intended to investigate the effects of transgenic rootstock on non-transgenic scion cultivars under natural conditions as well as to evaluate the potential value of using the rolB gene to modify difficult-to-root rootstocks of fruit trees. The results showed that all rolB transgenic rootstocks significantly reduced vegetative growth including tree height regardless of scion cultivar, compared with the non-transgenic rootstocks. Flowering and fruiting were also decreased for cultivars grown on the transgenic rootstocks in most cases, but the fruit quality was not clearly affected by the transgenic rootstocks. Cutting experiment and RT-PCR analysis showed that the rolB gene was stably expressed under field conditions. PCR and RT-PCR analyses displayed that the rolB gene or its mRNA were not detectable in the scion cultivars, indicating no translocation of the transgene or its mRNA from rootstock to scion. Our results suggest that rolB modified rootstocks should be used in combination with vigorous scion cultivars in order to obtain sufficient vegetative growth and good yield. Alternatively, the rolB gene could be used to dwarf vigorous rootstocks of fruit trees or produce bonzai plants as it can significantly reduce the vegetative growth of plants.     

Effect of rootstock on apple (Malus domestica) tree water relations

The effects of rootstock on mid-season water relations, under orchard conditions of non-limiting soil moisture, were determined for bearing 'Empire' apple trees ( Malus domestica Borkh.) on the clonal rootstocks M9, M26, M7, MM106, and MM104 (most to least dwarfing) in their sixth and seventh growing seasons. Stem water potentials (ψ^stem) of trees on M9 and M26 were more negative at midday, under warm, sunny conditions, than were the trees on the other three rootstocks. However, change in ψ^stem per change in stem distance through the canopy (water potential gradient) did not vary among rootstocks at midday. There was no rootstock effect on diurnal variation in transpiration or stomatal conductance. Differences in water storage capacitance, relative to tree size, were determined in a separate study but did not account for the differences observed in ψ^stem. Calculated hydraulic conductivities of xylem water transport suggest that rootstocks differ in their ability to conduct water to the scion, but hydraulic conductivity of the scion was not affected by rootstock. Root-stock differences in hydraulic conductivity were not accounted for by differences in tree size.     

Modification of gibberellin biosynthesis in the grafted apple scion allows control of tree height independent of the rootstock

The availability of short stature apple scions that required minimal applications of chemical growth retardants and could be used with a range of rootstocks would be of considerable benefit to fruit growers. We have suppressed the expression of a gene encoding the gibberellin (GA) biosynthetic enzyme GA 20-oxidase to reduce the levels of bioactive GAs in a scion variety, resulting in significant reductions in stem height. Application of GA3 reversed the effect. The scion remained dwarfed after grafting on to normally invigorating rootstocks, whilst control plants of the same cultivar displayed the expected vigour when grafted on to these rootstocks. This approach could be applicable to any perennial crop variety, allowing dwarf trees to be obtained on any available rootstock or on their own roots without the need for chemical growth retardant application. In effect, seedlings that are well suited to local conditions (drought, salinity) could be employed as tree rootstocks, as could existing rootstocks valued for characters other than vigour control, such as pest and disease resistance.     

Key flowering genes including FT-like genes are upregulated in the vasculature of apple dwarfing rootstocks

The Malling 9 (M.9) dwarfing rootstock is widely used in apple breeding and commercial cultivation to shorten the juvenile period, reduce vegetative growth and increase flowering of the scion. A segment of M.9 stem (interstock) or M.9 bark grafted into a compound tree can cause significant dwarfing of the scion, suggesting that the dwarfing signal may be vascular derived. To better understand how the M.9 rootstock alters the growth and development of the scion, we compared gene expression in vascular-enriched tissue from dwarfing and vigorous rootstocks. RNA sequencing indicated that key flowering genes were upregulated in M.9 relative to a vigorous rootstock, Malling 793 (M.793). An in-depth analysis of the apple FT/TFL1 gene family identified four new members: MdMFTa, MdMFTb, MdBFTa and MdBFTb. Quantitative RT-PCR analysis confirmed the higher expression of MdFT1/2, MdBFTa/b, MdCO, MdGI, and MdSOC1 in two different dwarfing rootstocks (M.9 and Malling 27 (M.27)) relative to M.793. Both MdFT1/2, and MdBFTa/b were expressed at higher levels in multiple dwarfing rootstock accessions relative to more vigorous genotypes. In perennial species, FT promotes flowering, and has additional roles in accelerating the transition from juvenility to maturity, and regulating cycles of seasonal growth and termination. Apple dwarfing rootstocks reduce the juvenile phase and promote both flowering and early shoot termination. Our work supports a role for MdFT in promoting flowering and earlier shoot termination. We suggest that upregulation of a suite of flowering genes including MdFT, and possibly MdBFT, in the vasculature is part of the underlying mechanism of apple dwarfing rootstocks. Genes involved with response to biotic and abiotic stress and disease were also upregulated in the M.9 rootstock, suggesting that stress, possibly mediated by JA and ABA signalling, also plays a role in the M.9-induced phenotype.     

The role of horticulture in plant invasions: how grafting in cultivars of Callery pear (Pyrus calleryana) can facilitate spread into natural areas

Although few plant species escape from cultivation, some horticultural practices used with woody ornamentals may enhance their invasion potential into natural areas. One such procedure is grafting, in which individuals are propagated for commercial sale by joining a clone of a desired cultivar (the scion) with rootstock obtained from a different individual. If the rootstock can sprout and flower, it can potentially cross-pollinate the scion, leading to fruit production in a self-incompatible species. The effect of grafting on invasion success was examined in the Callery pear, Pyrus calleryana, one of the most popular landscaping trees in the United States. Using nine microsatellite markers, scion and rootstock were genotyped for 57 cultivated trees to characterize rootstock genotypes and the rootstock gene pool. Invasive populations were then sampled to determine if rootstock genotypes have contributed to their formation. In no case were scion and rootstock genotypes identical for any given cultivated tree and rootstock genotypes were genetically variable, although some cloned rootstock genotypes were detected. Rootstock genotypes were also observed in invasive populations, with up to 17% of wild individuals having at least one rootstock parent. These results indicate that rootstock can contribute to the formation of invasive populations of the Callery pear through cross-pollination with other available genotypes. Future investigations of woody ornamentals propagated by grafting should consider this horticultural practice as a potential contributor to invasiveness. Furthermore, plant breeders are encouraged to assess the ability of rootstock to sprout as well as its cross-compatibility with the scion or other cultivar genotypes growing nearby.     

Root and stem hydraulic conductivity as determinants of growth potential in grafted trees of apple (Malus pumila Mill.)

The anatomy of the graft tissue between a rootstock and its shoot (scion) can provide a mechanistic explanation of the way dwarfing Malus rootstocks reduce shoot growth. Considerable xylem tissue disorganization may result in graft tissue having a low hydraulic conductivity (k(h)), relative to the scion stem. The graft may influence the movement of substances in the xylem such as ions, water and plant-growth-regulating hormones. Measurements were made on 3-year-old apple trees with a low-pressure flow system to determine k(h) of root and scion stem sections incorporating the graft tissue. A range of rootstocks was examined, with different abilities of dwarfing; both ungrafted and grafted with the same scion shoot cultivar. The results showed that the hydraulic conductivity (k(hroot)) of roots from dwarfing rootstocks was lower compared with semi-vigorous rootstocks, at least for the size class of root measured (1.5 mm diameter). Scion hydraulic conductivity (k(hs)) was linked to leaf area and also to the rootstock on to which it was grafted, i.e. hydraulic conductivity was greater for the scion stem on the semi-vigorous rootstock. Expressing conductivities relative to xylem cross-sectional areas (k(s)) did not remove these differences suggesting that there were anatomical changes induced by the rootstock. The calculated hydraulic conductivity of the graft tissue was found to be lower for grafted trees on dwarfing rootstocks compared to invigorating rootstocks. These observations are discussed in relation to the mechanism(s) by which rootstock influences shoot growth in grafted trees.     

Association of Tobacco Ringspot Virus with a Union Incompatibility of Apple

A virus-like disease of apple was observed for the first time in Canada in 1974 in a three year old planting. The disease was characterised by stem pitting, necrosis and breaking or separation of scion/rootstock at the graft union. Foliage was sparse and leaves were chlorotic and diffusely mottled. Using both frozen and freshly harvested leaves of infected apple trees from rootstock suckers as inoculum, a virus was transmitted to herbaceous indicator hosts. Based on host range symptoms, serology and electron microscopy, this virus was identified as tobacco ringspot virus. Initial counts of nematodes in the rhizophere of apple trees affected with union necrosis showed high densities of Xiphinema americanum Cobb., a known vector of nepoviruses. Reports of similar symptoms have indicated that the disease, apple union necrosis and decline was associated with the recovery of tobacco ringspot virus from infected rootstocks. This is the first report associating a union incompatibility condition of apple and tobacco ringspot virus.     

<Emphasis Type="Italic">MdPIN1b</Emphasis> encodes a putative auxin efflux carrier and has different expression patterns in BC and M9 apple rootstocks

Key message

Lower promoter activity is closely associated with lower MdPIN1b expression in the M9 interstem, which might contribute to the dwarfing effect in apple trees.

Abstract

Apple trees grafted onto dwarfing rootstock Malling 9 (M9) produce dwarfing tree architecture with high yield and widely applying in production. Previously, we have reported that in Malus ‘Red Fuji’ (RF) trees growing on M9 interstem and Baleng Crab (BC) rootstock, IAA content was relatively higher in bark tissue of M9 interstem than that in scion or rootstock. As IAA polar transportation largely depends on the PIN-FORMED (PIN) auxin efflux carrier. Herein, we identify two putative auxin efflux carrier genes in Malus genus, MdPIN1a and MdPIN1b, which were closely related to the AtPIN1. We found that MdPIN1b was expressed preferentially in BC and M9, and the expression of MdPIN1b was significantly lower in the phloem of M9 interstem than that in the scion and rootstock. The distinct expression of MdPIN1b and IAA content were concentrated in the cambium and adjacent xylem or phloem, and MdPIN1b protein was localized on cell plasma membrane in onion epidermal cells transiently expressing 35S:MdPIN1b-GFP fusion protein. Interestingly, an MdPIN1b mutant allele in the promoter region upstream of M9 exhibited decreased MdPIN1b expression compared to BC. MdPIN1b over-expressing interstem in tobacco exhibited increased polar auxin transport. It is proposed that natural allelic differences decreased promoter activity is closely associated with lower MdPIN1b expression in the M9 interstem, which might limit the basipetal transport of auxin, and in turn might contribute to the dwarfing effect. Taken together, these results reveal allelic variation underlying an important apple rootstock trait, and specifically a novel molecular genetic mechanism underlying dwarfing mechanism.

     

Interrelation of Scion and Rootstock in Fruit-trees: I. Weights and Relative Weights of Young Trees formed by the Reciprocal Unions, as Scion and Rootstock, of Three Apple Rootstock Varieties: M.IX, M.IV, and M.XII

Three apple rootstock varieties, M. IX, M. IV, and M. XII, werecombined as scion and rootstock in all nine ways and sampleswere harvested at intervals over 3 years. Their relative sizeson each occasion and their relative rates of growth betweenoccasions were determined by calculating the ratios betweenthe geometric mean weights. The ratio of the products of thesefor trees with reciprocal Unlike unions, e.g. IX/XIIx XII/IX,to that for trees with Like unions of the component varieties,e.g. IX/IX x XII/XII, was slightly but not significantly lessthan unity. Composite trees, e.g. IX/XII, resembled in sizethose of the rootstock type, e.g. XII, more than the scion variety,IX, though this had some influence.     

Evaluation of monoammonium phosphate and bacterial strains to increase tree growth and fruit yield in apple replant problem soil

The long-term effects of biological agents alone and in combination with monoammonium phosphate on tree growth and fruit production of apple trees planted on apple replant soil was studied for five years. Application of monoammonium phosphate (MAP) in the year of planting increased shoot growth, cross-sectional trunk area and fruit yield of McIntosh on M.26 rootstock for the first two years. The application of bacterial agents alone were not effective in increasing young tree growth except BACT-1 in 1987. None of the bacterial agents increased fruit yield when applied alone. The addition of certain bacterial agents to MAP application increased young tree growth in various years. The combination of bacterial agent B-10 and MAP reduced young tree growth and yield compared with the MAP treatment alone. These results suggest that the application of MAP alone may be sufficient to alleviate the replant problem and the addition of BACT-1, EBW-4 or B8 bacterial agents to this treatment may be beneficial to increase tree growth in some years. Contribution number 822. Contribution number 822.     

Phytophthora collar rot of apple: influence of the rootstock on scion variety resistance

In field experiments with young trees great differences were found in the resistance to Phytophthora cactorum of Cox's Orange Pippin apple scions grafted on different clonal rootstocks. The rootstock effect on scion resistance was inversely related to the effect on tree vigour: the rootstocks inducing high resistance were dwarfing (M. 9) or semi-dwarfing (M. 7, M. 26, MM. 106), and those inducing low resistance were vigorous or very vigorous (M. 25, MM. 104, MM. 109). Mean lesion lengths in Cox on MM. 104 were five to eight times greater than those in Cox on M. 9. The rootstock influence on scion resistance was associated primarily with effects on the rate of lesion extension: during the early stages only of host colonization there appeared to be threshold extension rates below which host resistance factors effectively suppressed a large proportion of infections. The influence of the root-stock on scion resistance was apparently unrelated to inherent rootstock resistance. On all rootstocks Cox showed diminished resistance to infection during the period from the swelling of buds to the early stages of shoot growth. Although most susceptible during the ‘mouse-ear’ and ‘pink bud’ stages of development, suscpetibility was not associated with flowering per se. Rootstock type did not affect the resistance of Cox scions to P. syringae, for which the period of susceptibility to infection occurred in the dormant season.     

Reverse-cleft in vitro micrografting of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Ziziphus jujuba</Emphasis> Mill. Infected with jujube witches’ broom (JWB)

Jujube witches’ broom (JWB) is a destructive disease, caused by a phytoplasma, of Chinese jujube (Ziziphus jujuba Mill.), an important traditional fruit in China and South Korea. Micrografting of plantlets to detect those affected with JWB is difficult due to differences in stem diameter between the scion and rootstock. In this study, an in vitro micrografting technique, reverse-cleft graft, suitable for rootstock thinner than scion was developed and optimized. The JWB phytoplasma was successfully transmitted into the scion from diseased rootstock using this technique as determined by polymerase chain reaction. Micrografted plantlets of Chinese jujube were incubated on Murashige and Skoog medium without plant growth regulators. The survival frequencies of 78–91%, depending on grafting combinations, were obtained.     

GC-MS-SIM analysis of abscisic acid and indole-3-acetic acid in shoot bark of apple rootstocks

Concentrations of abscisic acid and indole-3-acetic acid were measured by GC-MS-SIM in the shoot bark of clonal apple rootstocks (M.27, M.9, MM.106 and MM.111) when the rootstocks were growing actively in the UK. These rootstocks are known to exhibit a wide range of control of tree size when grafted to a common scion. Shoot bark of the dwarfing rootstocks (M.27 and M.9) contained higher concentrations than the more vigorous rootstocks (MM.106 and MM.111) of ABA. Concentrations of ABA increased from May to July, followed by a decline in August. Only the month of sampling showed any significant influence on the concentration of IAA in shoot bark; however, there was a general increase, although not significant statistically, in IAA concentration with the increasing invigoration-capacity of the rootstock. At each sampling date the dwarfing rootstocks showed greater ratios of ABA:IAA than the invigorating rootstocks and generally the ratio for each rootstock increased from May to July, except for M.27 which showed the smallest ratio in June and the largest ratio in August. The results are discussed in relation to the generally accepted control exerted by the rootstocks on tree size and the possible influence of ABA on polar auxin transport.     

Hydraulic resistance components of mature apple trees on rootstocks of different vigours

Dwarfing of fruit trees is often achieved through the use of dwarfing rootstocks. Dwarf trees are characterized by sustained reductions in vegetative growth during the lifetime of the tree. The dwarfing mechanism is not well understood, but it has been hypothesized that hydraulic properties of the rootstock and the graft union are involved. It is hypothesized here that leaf- or stem-specific resistance of at least one hydraulic component of the water transport system would be negatively correlated with rootstock 'vigour', and this could be useful for selection of rootstocks. Hydraulic resistance (R) of fully grown apple trees on a variety of rootstocks of different 'vigours' was measured. Most measurements were with the evaporative flux (EF) method, where water uptake measured with sap flow sensors was related to the pressure gradient from soil (taken as pre-dawn leaf) and midday root (taken as covered root-sucker), stem (from covered leaf), and exposed and shaded leaf water potentials (Psi(l)). R of trees on dwarfing M9 rootstock was compared with that of more vigorous MM106 and MM111 rootstocks in Israel and Vermont, USA. In Israel, M9 consistently had higher leaf-specific hydraulic resistance (R(l)) in the soil to scion stem pathway, but this difference was only significant for one summer. R was larger in M9 between the root and stem, implicating the graft union as the site of increased resistance. In Vermont, R(l) of 9- and 10-year-old trees on six rootstocks of various vigours was not consistently related to vigour, and stem-specific resistance (R(s)) increased with increasing vigour. High pressure flow meter (HPFM) measurements gave a lower R than the EF method in all but one case, perhaps indicating a significant amount of xylem dysfunction in these trees, and demonstrated the increased resistivity of stem sections that included dwarf graft unions as compared with non-graft stem sections. It is concluded that stem- and leaf-specific R are not consistently positively correlated with dwarfing, although the increased resistivity of the graft union in dwarfing rootstocks may influence the transport of water and other elements across the graft union, and therefore be involved in the dwarfing mechanism.     

Construction of a high-density genetic linkage map and QTL analysis of morphological traits in an F1 Malusdomestica × Malus baccata hybrid

Apple is considered the most commonly grown fruit crop in temperate regions that brings great economic profits to fruit growers. Dwarfing rootstocks have been extensively used in apple breeding as well as commercial orchards, but the molecular and genetic basis of scion dwarfing and other morphological traits induced by them is still unclear. At present, we report a genetic map of Malusdomestica × Malus baccata with high density. The F₁ population was sequenced by a specific length amplified fragment (SLAF). In the genetic map, 5064 SLAF markers spanning 17 linkage groups (LG) were included. Dwarf-related and other phenotypic traits of the scion were evaluated over a 3-year growth period. Based on quantitative trait loci (QTL) evaluation of plant height and trunk diameter, two QTL clusters were found on LG 11, which exhibited remarkable influences on dwarfing of the scion. In this analysis, QTL DW2, which was previously reported as a locus that controls dwarfing, was confirmed. Moreover, three novel QTLs for total flower number and branching flower number were detected on LG2 and LG4, exhibited the phenotypic variation that has been explained by QTL ranging from 8.80% to 34.80%. The findings of the present study are helpful to find scion dwarfing and other phenotypes induced by rootstock in the apple.Supplementary InformationThe online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s12298-021-01069-0.     

蔷薇科果树类受体激酶的研究进展

类受体激酶(receptor like kinase,RLK)参与调控植物几乎所有的生命活动,是植物生长发育和环境适应的“中央处理器”。该文对近年来国内外有关蔷薇科果树RLK基因鉴定、进化特征及其在各器官生长发育、非生物和生物逆境中的作用及调控机制等方面的研究进展进行了综述。蔷薇科果树基因组中存在数目庞大的RLKs,不同树种间的RLK数目和各亚家族成员数目都存在较大差异,而且蔷薇科果树RLK存在极为普遍的部分重复和串联重复现象,是导致家族成员迅速变化的重要原因。有研究发现,一些RLKs调控蔷薇科果树器官发育和对环境的适应性。在器官发育方面,LRR RLK亚家族成员调控根系发育,CrRLK1L、LysM RLK和LRR RLK亚家族部分成员参与调控果实发育,CrRLK1L亚家族成员参与调控花粉管发育,LRR RLK、LysM RLK、L LEC RLK和B Lectin RLK亚家族部分成员调控蔷薇科果树对生物逆境的适应。今后RLK功能研究可侧重于蔷薇科果树特色性状,通过提高目标基因的筛选和验证的效率,加速主效RLKs的筛选进程,并通过筛选主效RLKs诱导方式和加速分子育种进程等途径,将研究成果应用于实际生产。     

Identification and quantitation by GC-MS of zeatin and zeatin riboside in xylem sap from rootstock and scion of grafted apple trees

Zeatin and zeatin riboside were identified by full-scan gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS) in xylem sap of clonal apple rootstocks (M.27, M.9 and MM.106). These rootstocks exhibit a wide range of control over tree size when grafted to a common scion. The concentrations of zeatin and zeatin riboside were measured by GC-MS selected ion monitoring (SIM) in shoot xylem sap and root pressure exudate obtained from these rootstocks and from trees of Fiesta scion grafted onto the rootstocks. Zeatin was the predominant cytokinin in xylem sap from the dwarfing rootstocks, M.27 and M.9, while zeatin riboside was the predominant cytokinin in xylem sap from the more invigorating rootstock MM.106. Cytokinin concentrations (ng ml^–1) in root pressure exudate and shoot xylem sap, (i.e. from above the graft union in composite trees), increased with increasing vigour of the rootstock, irrespective of whether the plants were non-grafted rootstocks, or were composite plants of Fiesta scion grafted onto the rootstocks. Cytokinin content (ng shoot^–1) of shoot sap differed with rootstock; the more invigorating (MM.106) had greater amounts of cytokinins than the more dwarfing (M.9 and M.27) rootstocks. These results are discussed in relation to possible influences of roots on the growth of shoots via cytokinin supplies in the xylem sap.