Novel monoclonal antibodies identify antigenic determinants unique to cellular senescence.

Normal human diploid fibroblasts exhibit a limited lifespan in vitro and are used as a model to study in vivo aging. Monoclonal antibodies were generated against partially purified surface membranes from human diploid fibroblasts at the end of their lifespan (senescent). Three hybridomas were isolated that secreted antibodies reacting to cellular determinants expressed specifically on senescent human fibroblasts of different origin, including neonatal foreskin, embryonic lung, and adult skin punch biopsy, but not expressed on matched young cells. The antibodies did not bind to immortal human cells and normal young cells made reversibly nondividing, indicating the antigens are not expressed in cells that are not senescent. The antibodies identified senescent cells in a mixed cell population and expression of the senescent cell antigens correlated strongly with the cells inability to synthesize DNA at the onset of senescence. The antigens appeared to be cell surface or extracellular matrix associated, and the epitopes were destroyed by mild trypsin treatment. Western analysis indicated all three antibodies reacted with fibronectin. Though the antigenic determinants on the fibronectin molecule were not accessible in the intact young cell, the epitopes were present in fibronectin extracted from both senescent and young cells, as well as purified human plasma fibronectin. These antibodies and the senescent specific expression of the antigens provide powerful tools to investigate the mechanisms leading to in vitro senescence. This may enable us to investigate directly the relationship between cellular aging and aging of the individual.     

Evidence contrary to the protein error hypothesis for in vitro senescence.

A strain of diploid fibroblasts, obtained from the skin of a male infant, was cultured in vitro and cells were tested throughout their lifespan for the appearance of altered glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G-6-PD) detected either by thermostability studies or by immunotitration. No significant difference was found in the proportion of thermolabile enzyme in 31 young cultures (4.8 +/- 1%, S.E.), in comparison with that in 19 old cultures (4.9 +/- 1%, S.E.). Old cultures had ceased active cell division (49-60 doublings); DNA replication, measured by [3H]thymidine uptake over a period of 24 hours, was limited to less than 5% of these cells. Young cells (5-22 doublings) had a [3H]thymidine labeling index of 75-85%. Titration of G-6-PD activity in extracts of young and old cells with neutralizing antibody directes specifically against G-6-PD failed to detect an increment of enzymatically defective G-6-PD in old cells. The thermostability studies were capable of detecting altered G-6-PD in skin fibroblasts from a female heterozygous for a thermolabile mutant of G-6-PD, and in fibroblasts treated with a proline analogue, azetidine carboxylic acid. The immunotitration technique was also capable of detecting catalytically altered G-6-PD from the thermolabile mutant and G-6-PD inactivated with N-ethylameimide. These findings argue against a protein error catastrophe as the cause of in vitro clonal senescence.     

Enzyme activity during the growth and aging of human cells in vitro

Acid phosphatase, alkaline phosphatase, and lactic dehydrogenase activities have been compared in normal human diploid cell strains and in SV₄₀-transformed heteroploid cell lines derived from them. A higher level of acid phosphatase activity was observed in diploid cultures derived from adult lung than in cultures derived from fetal lung of similar passage levels. The alkaline phosphatase activity of normal diploid fibroblasts was significantly higher than that of SV₄₀-transformed cell lines derived from them. Generally, the lactic dehydrogenase activities of all these cell cultures were similar. Human diploid cells in culture “age,” in the sense that their ability to proliferate decreases with time during serial subcultivation. Evaluation of the activities of these three enzymes during the “aging” process showed that, although alkaline phosphatase and lactic dehydrogenase activities were similar in “young” and “senescent” cells, acid phosphatase showed a small but significant increase in the senescent cells.     

Effect of in vitro aging on 6-ketoprostaglandin F1 alpha-producing activity in cultured human diploid lung fibroblasts.

Prostaglandin synthesis in human diploid fibroblasts was studied by incubating [14C]-arachidonic acid with cell homogenates. The majority of prostaglandins produced in young cells was 6-ketoprostaglandin F1 alpha. The 6-ketoprostaglandin F1 alpha-producing activity of cultures declined with in vitro aging, and was almost undetectable at the senescent stage, while total production of thromboxane B2, prostaglandin F2 alpha and prostaglandin E2-like metabolites increased with in vitro aging.     

The effect of serum batch on the in vitro lifespans of cell cultures derived from old and young human donors

In a senescence study, skin fibroblast cultures grown in the presence of a second batch of fetal calf serum (FCS) revealed delayed onsets of cell culture senescence and prolonged in vitro lifespans when compared to cell cultures grown on the initial batch of serum. These statistically significant differences occurred despite the fact that both sera displayed equal growth promoting abilities as measured by cell culture growth curves performed on parallel cultures with the two sera. When cultures grown in either sera were analyzed separately, the onset of cell culture senescence was earlier and in vitro lifespan was shorter in those cultures derived from the old donor group (ages 63–92) when compared to cultures derived from young donors (ages 21–36).     

TGF-β1 induces the expression of type I collagen and SPARC,and enhances contraction of collagen gels,by fibroblasts from young and aged donors

Fibroblasts have a major role in the synthesis and reorganization of extracellular matrix that occur during wound repair. An impaired biosynthetic or functional response of these cells to stimulation by growth factors might contribute to the delayed wound healing noted in aging. We, therefore, compared the responses of dermal fibroblasts from young and elderly individuals (26, 29, 65, 89, 90, and 92 years of age) to transforming growth factor-β1 (TGF-β1) with respect to: (1) the synthesis of type I collagen and SPARC (two extracellular matrix proteins that are highly expressed by dermal fibroblasts during the remodeling phase of wound repair) and (2) the contraction of collagen gels, an in vitro assay of wound contraction. With the exception of one young donor, all cultures exposed for 44 hours to 10 ng/ml TGF-β1 exhibited a 1.6- to 5.5-fold increase in the levels of secreted type 1 collagen and SPARC, relative to untreated cultures, and exhibited a 2.0- to 6.2-fold increase in the amounts of the corresponding mRNAs. Moreover, the dose-response to TGF-β1 (0.1–10 ng/ml), as determined by synthesis of type I collagen and SPARC mRNA, was as vigorous in cells from aged donors as in cells from a young donor. In assays of collagen gel contraction, fibroblasts from all donors were stimulated to a similar degree by 10 ng/ml TGF-β1. In conclusion, cells from both young and aged donors exhibited similar biosynthetic and contractile properties with exposure to TGF-β1. It therefore appears that the impaired wound healing noted in the aged does not result from a failure of their dermal fibroblasts to respond to this cytokine. © 1994 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Inhibition of DNA synthesis in proliferating human diploid fibroblasts by fusion with senescent cytoplasts

Cytoplasts were prepared from senescent human diploid fibroblasts. The cytoplasts were fused to young human diploid fibroblasts and DNA synthesis was analyzed in the fusion products. DNA synthesis was inhibited (greater than or equal to 40%) in the senescent cytoplast fusion products when compared to unfused young cells or young cytoplasts fused with young cells. These results are consistent with previous experiments that have shown the blockage of DNA synthesis in both nuclei of heterokaryons from fusions of senescent and young human diploid fibroblast cells. Furthermore, these results support the postulate that senescent cells synthesize a specific substance(s), which is present in the cytoplasm of the senescent cell that inhibits DNA synthesis.     

Retardation of the Senescence of Cultured Human Diploid Fibroblasts by Carnosine

We have examined the effects of the naturally occurring dipeptide carnosine (β-alanyl-L-histidine) on the growth, morphology, and lifespan of cultured human diploid fibroblasts. With human foreskin cells, HFF-1, and fetal lung cells, MRC-5, we have shown that carnosine at high concentrations (20-50 mM) in standard medium retards senescence and rejuvenates senescent cultures. These late-passage cultures preserve a nonsenescent morphology in the presence of carnosine, in comparison to the senescent morphology first described by Hayflick and Moorhead. Transfer of these late-passage cells in medium containing carnosine to unsupplemented normal medium results in the appearance of the senescent phenotype. The serial subculture of cells in the presence of carnosine does not prevent the Hayflick limit to growth, although the lifespan in population doublings as well as chronological age is often increased. This effect is obscured by the normal variability of human fibroblast lifespans, which we have confirmed. Transfer of cells approaching senescence in normal medium to medium supplemented with carnosine rejuvenates the cells but the extension in lifespan is variable. Neither D -carnosine, (β-alanyl-D-histidine), homocarnosine, anserine, nor β-alanine had the same effects as carnosine on human fibroblasts. Carnosine is an antioxidant, but it is more likely that it preserves cellular integrity by its effects on protein metabolism.     

Patients with myotonic dystrophy,a possible segmental progeroid syndrome,and duchenne muscular dystrophy have fibroblasts with normal limits for in vitro lifespan and growth characteristics

Myotonic dystrophy (MyD) has been suggested to be a segmental progeroid syndrome in man, as this syndrome has some clinical manifestations of premature aging. Fibroblasts from patients with other progeroid syndromes have been shown to have diminished in vitro lifespans or growth characteristics; therefore, it was of interest to study cellular senescence in fibroblasts from patients with MyD. Fibroblast cultures from patients with Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) were used as additional controls, as premature aging is not associated with this genetic disorder. Primary skin fibroblast cultures obtained from patients with MyD or DMD and from age-sex matched controls were grown in DMEM plus 10% FBS. The in vitro lifespan was determined by either a 1:4 split ratio or with a constant initial inoculum of 1 × 10⁴ cells/cm², followed by determination of the final density at weekly intervals. Our results demonstrate that there is no difference in the limits of the in vitro lifespan for either the MyD or DMD fibroblast strains compared to the controls. Likewise, no difference could be detected in the growth characteristics of these cells. The only observable difference was that the pooled age-matched controls and MyD cultures had a shorter in vitro lifespan than the DMD group and their pooled controls, a finding expected because of the age of the patients in each group. Unlike the other progeroid syndromes, MyD fibroblasts have normal limits for in vitro lifespan. MyD is probably not closely related to the other premature aging syndromes, although there is an increasing phenotypic expression as a function of age.     

Heterogeneity of dimer excision in young and senescent human dermal fibroblasts

We have examined the relationship between nucleotide excision of the main UV-induced photoproduct, the cyclobutane pyrimidine dimer and in vitro cellular senescence. An in situ semiquantitative immunocytochemical assay has demonstrated that, following a UV-C dose of 15 J m-2, young human dermal fibroblasts maintained in a high level of serum are more efficient than senescent fibroblasts in the removal of dimers. However, in G0-arrested cultures (serum-starved), young fibroblasts are compromised in their ability to remove dimers and are significantly less efficient than senescent cells in this process. Supplementation of the culture medium with 0.1 mm deoxyribonucleosides enhances the removal of dimers in both young and senescent fibroblasts in proliferating or serum-starved cells. These data indicate that overall there is a modest but significant reduction in nucleotide excision of dimer photoproducts in cells as they age in vitro. In addition, G0-arrested young cells exhibit reduced removal of dimers, although this can be complemented by deoxyribonucleoside addition. In addition, this in situ assay has revealed heterogeneity in both susceptibility to UV-C-induced damage and excision. Overall, we provide evidence of reduced UV-induced damage excision in senescent compared with young fibroblasts, and demonstrate modulation of these processes in young and senescent cells under specific growth conditions.     

A new cell surface marker of aging in human diploid fibroblasts

The relationship of cell surface changes to proliferative decline of human diploid fibroblasts was investigated using the concanavalin A-mediated red blood cell adsorption assay. The amount of the red blood cells adsorbed to human diploid fibroblasts via concanavalin A increased continuously from the early phases of cell passage up through cell senescence, while the amount of 3H-concanavalin A binding did not change to a significant extent. The red blood cell adsorption is not a function of cell cycle phase and time spent in culture. Cocultivation of young cells with old cells also did not affect the adsorption capacity of respective cells. Thus, the concanavalin A-mediated red blood cell adsorption can be expected to serve as a new cell surface marker for aging in vitro. Using this marker, it was revealed that transient cell size or 3H-thymidine incorporating capacity di not have a direct relationship with the division age of a cell. Small rapidly dividing cells in old populations resemble large slowly dividing or nondividing cells of the same populations and differ from small rapidly dividing cells in young populations, in terms of cell surface properties.     

Bovine endothelial cells transformed in vitro by benzo(a)pyrene

A cloned strain of bovine vascular endothelial cells with a finite in vitro lifespan was treated with benzo(a)pyrene (BP) after approximately 75% of its lifespan was completed. Untreated cultures of this strain senesced upon serial subcultivation and contained large, nondividing cells. In three out of seven trials, BP treatment produced transformed cells appeared in the cultures concomitant with the senescence of the parent cells. All transformed cell lines examined exhibited indefinite lifespans and altered karyotypes. Two of the lines retained most of the characteristics of normal endothelial cells, except that one became aneuploid and the other polyploid, Neither of these lines formed tumors when inoculated into nude mice. The remaining two lines retained mostly diploid kayotypes, but a high percentage of cells contained Robertsonian translocations. In one line cell volume was markedly reduced. In addition, these lines grew in multilayers, were anchorage independent, and proliferated in medium containing 0.5% serum. When 10⁷ cells of these lines were injected into nude mice, tumors appeared within 1 week and were identified as malignant hemangioendotheliomas of bovine origin.     

Fluorescence-polarization measurements on normal and mutant human skin fibroblasts

Measurements of fluorescence polarization in intact diploid skin fibroblasts after exposure to 1,6-diphenyl-1,3,5-hexatriene were used to estimate the fluidity of the lipid phase(s) of cellular membranes. The membrane lipids of cells derived from four patients with homozygous familial hypercholesterolemia were in a more fluid state than those of cells obtained from 13 other individuals of normal and nonrelated mutant genotypes when all cultures were grown on medium with native serum. The only other cell type having membrane lipids of increased fluidity under these conditions was one fibroblast line derived from a patient with the Lesch-Nyhan syndrome. Examination of two additional nonconsanguinous lines of Lesch-Nyhan fibroblasts, however, revealed that an abnormally high level of lipid fluidity was not a common property of the membranes of cells of this genotype. Incubation of cultures in medium containing lipid-depleted serum (virtually devoid of lipoprotein-bound sterol) caused a reversible increase in the fluidity of the membranes of normal cells to values similar to those of the hypercholesterolemic cells, but had no effect on the membranelipid fluidity of the latter. By contrast, exposure of cultures to cholesterol not bound to lipoprotein in serum-free medium resulted in a decrease in the lipid fluidity of the membranes of both normo- and hypercholesterolemic fibroblasts.     

Donor-age-related changes in the morphology, growth potential, and collagen biosynthesis in rat fibroblast subpopulations in vitro

Primary explant, mass and clonal fibroblast cultures established from BN rat skin and lungs were used to examine changes in cell behaviour associated with aging. Three distinct fibroblast cell types, i.e. FI, FII and FIII, could be identified on the basis of their morphological and proliferative properties. They could also be distinguished from each other by the amount and type of collagen they synthesized in clonal cultures. FI cells are diploid, spindle shaped and highly proliferative, and they synthesize low levels of type-I and -III collagen. Epithelioid FII cells are also diploid, proliferate slowly, and exhibited elevated collagen synthesis as compared to FI cells. FIII fibroblasts are large, stellate, tetraploid cells that proliferate more slowly than the other types but synthesize large amounts of collagen. In comparison to FI cells, the level of type-III-collagen synthesis is slightly elevated in FIII fibroblasts. In primary explant, mass and clonal cultures, the relative proportions of FI, FII and FIII cells were found to change as a function of the age of the donor animal. The increasing predominance of FIII cells in mass cultures of fibroblasts obtained from donors of increasing ages was consistent with the increased level of collagen synthesis in these cultures. Our observations indicate that the differentiation of normal BN rat fibroblasts occurs via a three-phase process. We discuss the age-related changes in the relative abundance of FI, FII and FIII cells in vivo in the context of alterations in fibroblast replacement and changes in connective tissue that occur during aging.     

Normal level of unscheduled DNA synthesis in Werner''s syndrome fibroblasts in culture

We investigated UV-induced unscheduled DNA synthesis (UDS) in skin fibroblasts from seven unrelated patients with clinically apparent Werner's syndrome (WS). WS cells exhibited greatly abbreviated in vitro lifespans, the extents of which ranged from about 20 to 50% of the normal. However, WS cells in early and senescent phases of growth showed the same quantity of DNA repair following UV exposure as did normal fibroblasts.     

THE OUTWARD TRANSPORT OF CORTISOL BY MAMMALIAN CELLS IN VITRO

It has been determined that cortisol and a few other steroids are transported outward from certain mammalian cells growing in vitro. The extrusion process is temperature dependent, glucose dependent, saturable, and operates for only a few selected steroids. Many, but not all, steroids are able to block the extrusion process but are not themselves transported. The outward transport process for steroids has been found in mouse fibroblasts, mouse lymphoma cells, and functional mouse adrenal gland tumor cells growing in vitro. The transport process is not present in two varieties of cells cultured from human sources—HeLa or diploid fibroblasts, WI-38.     

Thermosensitivity of Nuclear RNA Polymerase during the in vitro Senescence of Mouse Fibroblasts

Embryonic mouse fibroblasts divide approximately twelve times in vitro prior to cessation of mitotic activity. During this period of cellular senescence the thermosensitivity of the RNA polymerase activity of isolated nuclei has been examined as a means of detecting the possible accumulation of defective enzyme molecules, as has been found by other workers for several cytoplasmic enzymes during the ageing of human fibroblasts in vitro.
The total RNA polymerase activity of nuclei isolated from old (10th generation) cells is more thermoresistant than that of young (2nd generation) cells. However, the net RNA polymerase activity of nuclei from non-dividing (confluent) cells is more thermoresistant than that of exponentially growing cells of the same age. When allowance is made for the state of growth of the cultures, little difference is seens in the thermosensitivity of the activities of nuclei from old and young cells. Neither is there any difference between the thermosensitivity of the net activity of an established line of murine fibroblasts (L-cells) and cells in primary culture.
Preheating nuclei increases the inhibition of their total RNA polymerase activity by or-α-amanitin, indicating that RNA polymerase II is the most heat resistance species present. There appears to be no difference between the thermosensitivity of the α-amanitin sensitive and resistance species of the enzyme in the nuclei of old and young cells.
It is concluded that old cells resemble non-dividing young cells in containing a higher proportion of RNA polymerase II in their nuclei, resulting in greater thermoresistance of the total RNA polymerase activity over that of exponentially growing cells. However, there appears to be no increase in thermosensitivity of the enzymes with age.