Programmed cell death-involved aluminum toxicity in yeast alleviated by antiapoptotic members with decreased calcium signals

The molecular mechanisms of aluminum (Al) toxicity and tolerance in plants have been the focus of ongoing research in the area of stress phytophysiology. Recent studies have described Al-induced apoptosis-like cell death in plant and animal cells. In this study, we show that yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) exposed to low effective concentrations of Al for short times undergoes enhanced cell division in a manner that is dose and cell density dependent. At higher concentrations of Al or longer exposure times, Al induces cell death and growth inhibition. Several apoptotic features appear during Al treatment, including cell shrinkage, vacuolation, chromatin marginalization, nuclear fragmentation, DNA degradation, and DNA strand breaks, as well as concomitant cell aggregation. Yeast strains expressing Ced-9, Bcl-2, and PpBI-1 (a plant Bax inhibitor-1 isolated from Phyllostachys praecox), respectively, display more resistance to Al toxicity compared with control cells. Data from flow cytometric studies show these three antiapoptotic members do not affect reactive oxygen species levels, but decrease calcium ion (Ca(2+)) signals in response to Al stress, although both intracellular reactive oxygen species and Ca(2+) levels were increased. The data presented suggest that manipulation of the negative regulation process of programmed cell death may provide a novel mechanism for conferring Al tolerance.     

Caspase-like proteases regulate aluminum-induced programmed cell death in peanut

Recent evidence has proved that caspase protease activities are detected in both mammals and plants during programmed cell death (PCD). The characteristics and functions of caspase-like proteases play important roles in understanding the mechanisms of PCD in plants. In this work, we report firstly the involvement of caspase-like protease activities and effects in aluminum (Al) stress in two contrasting peanut genotypes. Caspase-like activities in the root tip cells of ‘Zhonghua 2’ (Al-sensitive) and ‘99-1507’ (Al-tolerant) were detected using synthetic caspase substrates during Al-triggered PCD. Caspase-1-, -2-, -3-, -4-, -5-, -6-, -8- and -9-like proteases were found in peanut root tip cells. VDQQDase (caspase-2-like) and WEHD (caspase-5-like) were the first detected in the plants, and almost all of the caspase-like proteases were activated during Al-induced PCD, especially caspase-3-like and caspase-1-like, which was higher in ‘Zhonghua 2’ than in ‘99-1507’. The highest activity levels of caspase-3- and caspase-1-like proteases occurred 8 and 4 h after 100 µM Al treatment, respectively. Compared with 100 µM AlCl₃ treatment alone, specific caspase-3 protease inhibitor Ac-DEVD-CHO inhibited the increase of caspase-3-like protease activity, Al content, Hsr203j expression, cell death and DNA fragmentation, and the decrease in root growth induced by 100 µM AlCl₃ treatment, but it was more obvious in ‘Zhonghua 2’ than in ‘99-1507’. In conclusion, there were different caspase-like proteases in root tips of peanut, and caspase-3-like protease was a crucial executioner in Al-induced PCD. Its effects in the ‘Zhonghua 2’ genotype were higher than in ‘99-1507’. An improved model of the mechanism of Al-induced PCD and Al tolerance differences in different genotypes is proposed.     

Aluminum-induced cell death in root-tip cells of barley

Aluminum-induced cell death was investigated in root-tip cells of barley (Hordeum vulgare). The growth of roots in 0.1-50 mM Al treatments was inhibited after 8 h treatments, and could not be recovered after 24 h recovery culture without Al. Viable detection with fluorescein diacetate-propidium iodide (FDA-PI) staining shows that most of the root-tip cells have lost viability. These results suggest that the irreversible inhibition of root growth after 8 h Al treatments or 24 h recovery culture is mainly caused by cell death. DNA ladders occurred in root tips only after 8 h Al treatments (0.1-1.0 mM), but no apoptotic bodies in root tips were observed. Thus, the cell death caused by Al stress is likely to be Al-induced programmed cell death (PCD). The reactive oxygen species (ROS) in root-tip cells measured by ultraweak luminescence indicated that the oxidation status in root-tip cells basically ceased after exposure to 10-50 mM Al for 24 h, but was very violent in the root-tip cells treated with 0.1-1.0 mM for 24 h. Exposure to 0.1-1.0 mM Al for 3-12 h led to ROS burst. Therefore, our results suggest that 0.1-1.0 mM Al treatments for 8 h induce cell death (Al-induced PCD) possibly via a ROS-activated signal transduction pathway, whereas 10-50 mM Al treatments may cause necrosis in the root-tip cells. These results have an important role for further studies on the mechanism of Al toxicity in plants.     

Aluminum-induced 1-->3-beta-D-glucan inhibits cell-to-cell trafficking of molecules through plasmodesmata. A new mechanism of aluminum toxicity in plants

Symplastic intercellular transport in plants is achieved by plasmodesmata (PD). These cytoplasmic channels are well known to interconnect plant cells to facilitate intercellular movement of water, nutrients, and signaling molecules including hormones. However, it is not known whether Al may affect this cell-to-cell transport process, which is a critical feature for roots as organs of nutrient/water uptake. We have microinjected the dye lucifer yellow carbohydrazide into peripheral root cells of an Al-sensitive wheat (Triticum aestivum cv Scout 66) either before or after Al treatment and followed the cell-to-cell dye-coupling through PD. Here we show that the Al-induced root growth inhibition is closely associated with the Al-induced blockage of cell-to-cell dye coupling. Immunofluorescence combined with immuno-electron microscopic techniques using monoclonal antibodies against 1-->3-beta-D-glucan (callose) revealed circumstantial evidence that Al-induced callose deposition at PD may responsible for this blockage of symplastic transport. Use of 2-deoxy-D-glucose, a callose synthesis inhibitor, allowed us to demonstrate that a reduction in callose particles correlated well with the improved dye-coupling and reduced root growth inhibition. While assessing the tissue specificity of this Al effect, comparable responses were obtained from the dye-coupling pattern in tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum) mesophyll cells. Analyses of the Al-induced expression of PD-associated proteins, such as calreticulin and unconventional myosin VIII, showed enhanced fluorescence and co-localizations with callose deposits. These results suggest that Al-signal mediated localized alterations to calcium homeostasis may drive callose formation and PD closure. Our data demonstrate that extracellular Al-induced callose deposition at PD could effectively block symplastic transport and communication in higher plants.     

Inhibition of nitric oxide synthase (NOS) underlies aluminum-induced inhibition of root elongation in Hibiscus moscheutos

Aluminum (Al) is toxic to plants when solubilized into Al(3+) in acidic soils, and becomes a major factor limiting plant growth. However, the primary cause for Al toxicity remains unknown. Nitric oxide (NO) is an important signaling molecule modulating numerous physiological processes in plants. Here, we investigated the role of NO in Al toxicity to Hibiscus moscheutos. Exposure of H. moscheutos to Al(3+) led to a rapid inhibition of root elongation, and the inhibitory effect was alleviated by NO donor sodium nitroprusside (SNP). NO scavenger and inhibitors of NO synthase (NOS) and nitrate reductase had a similar inhibitory effect on root elongation. The inhibition of root elongation by these treatments was ameliorated by SNP. Aluminum inhibited activity of NOS and reduced endogenous NO concentrations. The alleviation of inhibition of root elongation induced by Al, NO scavenger and NOS inhibitor was correlated with endogenous NO concentrations in root apical cells, suggesting that reduction of endogenous NO concentrations resulting from inhibition of NOS activity could underpin Al-induced arrest of root elongation in H. moscheutos.     

Nitric oxide exacerbates Al-induced inhibition of root elongation in rice bean by affecting cell wall and plasma membrane properties

Aluminum (Al) toxicity is one of the most widespread problems for crop production on acid soils, and nitric oxide (NO) is a key signaling molecule involved in the mediation of various biotic and abiotic stresses in plants. Here we found that exogenous application of the NO donor sodium nitroprusside (SNP) exacerbated the inhibition of Al-induced root growth in rice bean [Vigna umbellata (Thunb.) Ohwi & Ohashi ‘Jiangnan’, Fabaceae]. This was accompanied by an increased accumulation of Al in the root apex. However, Al treatments had no effect on endogenous NO concentrations in root apices. These results indicate that a change in NO concentration is not the cause of Al-induced root growth inhibition and the adverse effect of SNP on Al-induced root growth inhibition should result from increased Al accumulation. Al could significantly induce citrate efflux but SNP had no effects on citrate efflux either in the absence or presence of Al. On the other hand, SNP pretreatment significantly increased Al-induced malondialdehyde accumulation and Evans Blue staining, indicating an intensification of the disruption of plasma membrane integrity. Furthermore, SNP pretreatment also caused greater induction of pectin methylesterase activity by Al, which could be the cause of the increased Al accumulation. Taken together, it is concluded that NO exacerbates Al-induced root growth inhibition by affecting cell wall and plasma membrane properties.     

Expression of Animal Anti-Apoptotic Gene Ced-9 Enhances Tolerance during Glycine max L.–Bradyrhizobium japonicum Interaction under Saline Stress but Reduces Nodule Formation

The mechanisms by which the expression of animal cell death suppressors in economically important plants conferred enhanced stress tolerance are not fully understood. In the present work, the effect of expression of animal antiapoptotic gene Ced-9 in soybean hairy roots was evaluated under root hairs and hairy roots death-inducing stress conditions given by i) Bradyrhizobium japonicum inoculation in presence of 50 mM NaCl, and ii) severe salt stress (150 mM NaCl), for 30 min and 3 h, respectively. We have determined that root hairs death induced by inoculation in presence of 50 mM NaCl showed characteristics of ordered process, with increased ROS generation, MDA and ATP levels, whereas the cell death induced by 150 mM NaCl treatment showed non-ordered or necrotic-like characteristics. The expression of Ced-9 inhibited or at least delayed root hairs death under these treatments. Hairy roots expressing Ced-9 had better homeostasis maintenance, preventing potassium release; increasing the ATP levels and controlling the oxidative damage avoiding the increase of reactive oxygen species production. Even when our results demonstrate a positive effect of animal cell death suppressors in plant cell ionic and redox homeostasis under cell death-inducing conditions, its expression, contrary to expectations, drastically inhibited nodule formation even under control conditions.     

Involvement of putrescine and nitric oxide in aluminum tolerance by modulating citrate secretion from roots of red kidney bean

Background and Aims

Polyamines and nitric oxide (NO) are two important molecules modulating numerous environment stresses in plants. This study was to investigate the roles of polyamines and NO in aluminum (Al) tolerance in red kidney bean.

Methods

The interaction between putrescine (Put) and NO under Al stress was examined. NO donor and scavenger were used to further examine the role of NO in Al-induced citrate secretion from roots by high performance liquid chromatography.

Results

Al stress caused increase of endogenous free Put, and exogenous Put alleviated Al-induced inhibition of root elongation and Al accumulation. In addition, Put induced NO production and nitrate reductase (NR) activity under Al stress. Al- and Put-induced NO production could be reversed by NR inhibitor. Furthermore, Al stress stimulated citrate secretion from roots, and this response was stimulated by NO donor, whereas NO scavenger inhibited Al-induced citrate secretion from roots. Concomitantly, NO donor reduced Al accumulation in root apexes, while NO scavenger further enhanced Al accumulation. Al-induced inhibition of root growth was significantly improved by exogenous citrate treatment.

Conclusions

Put and NO enhanced Al tolerance by modulating citrate secretion from roots, and NO may act downstream of Put in red kidney bean under Al stress.     

A combination of five mechanisms confers a high tolerance for aluminum to a wild species of Poaceae,Andropogon virginicus L.

How can high tolerance against aluminum (Al) toxicity be obtained in plants? To address this question, tolerant mechanisms were characterized in a highly Al tolerant wild species of Poaceae, Andropogon virginicus L. A. virginicus showed an Al-stress-induced synthesis and secretion of citrate and malate in roots. This mechanism may help to suppress an increase of toxic Al ions in the root region. Microscopic observation of the morin-stained leaves indicated that the Al transferred to shoots was specifically accumulated in the trichomes and spikes of the leaves and that some portion of the accumulated Al was furthermore secreted as sap from the tips of trichomes. Al-induced synthesis of poly-phenolic compounds including anthocyanin also occurred in roots as a long term response to Al toxicity and anthocyanin production did not co-localize with either Al accumulation, nitric oxide (NO) production or lipid peroxides production in the roots. It was suggested that oxidative damage caused by Al stress was suppressed in these areas where anthocyanin was localized. Moreover, induction of NO production occurred in roots within 24 h of Al treatment. Our results suggested that NO could not efficiently ameliorate the Al-dependent nuclei deformation and DNA fragmentation, but could function as a trigger to stimulate anti-peroxidation enzymes under Al stress. Collectively the results suggested that A. virginicus manifests its high Al tolerance by a unique combination of effective mechanisms.     

Physiological basis of reduced Al tolerance in ditelosomic lines of Chinese Spring wheat

Aluminum tolerance was assessed in the moderately Al-tolerant wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) cultivar Chinese Spring and a set of ditelosomic lines derived from Chinese Spring. Three ditelosomic lines lacking chromosome arms 4DL, 5AS and 7AS, respectively, exhibited decreased Al tolerance relative to the euploid parent Chinese Spring based on reduced root growth in Al-containing solutions. The physiological basis of the reduced Al tolerance was investigated. Measurements by inductively coupled argon plasma mass spectroscopy of root apical Al accumulation demonstrated that two of these three lines had a decreased ability to exclude Al from the root apex, the site of Al phytotoxicity. As Al-induced malate exudation has been suggested to be an important physiological mechanism of Al tolerance in wheat, this parameter was quantified and malate exudation was shown to be smaller in all three deletion lines compared with Chinese Spring. These results suggest that the decreased Al tolerance in at least two of the three ditelosomic lines is due to the loss of different genes independently influencing a single Al-tolerance mechanism, rather than to the loss of genes encoding alternative Al-tolerance mechanisms. Received: 3 July 2000 / Accepted: 9 August 2000     

Aluminium-induced drought and oxidative stress in barley roots

The aim of the present study was to examine the relation between Al accumulation in root tissues, root growth inhibition, root water content, cell viability and expression of oxidative and drought stress-related genes in barley roots growing on the filter paper. Al-induced root growth inhibition correlated with Al uptake and cell death. Water content of Al-treated root represented only half of the control one. The expression of the dehydrin gene dhn4, which is a marker for drought stress in plant tissues, was strongly induced during Al stress. Al treatment also induced expression of oxidative stress-related genes such as glutathione peroxidase (gpx), pathogen-related peroxidase (prx8), glutathione reductase (gr) and dehydroascorbate reductase (dhar). The present results suggest correlation between Al uptake, Al-induced drought stress, oxidative stress, cell death and root growth inhibition.     

Roles of rootstocks and scions in aluminum-tolerance of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Citrus</Emphasis>

Four scion-rootstock combination [i.e., X/X and X/SP, ‘Xuegan’ (Citrus sinensis) grafted on ‘Xugan’ and ‘Sour pummelo’ (Citrus grandis), respectively, and SP/X and SP/SP, ‘Sour pummelo’ grafted on ‘Xuegan’ and ‘Sour pummelo’, respectively] plants were treated for 18 weeks with 0 (?Al) or 1.2 mM AlCl₃·6H₂O (+Al). Thereafter, leaf, stem and root concentrations of phosphorus and aluminum (Al), leaf and root levels of organic acids (OAs), Al-induced release of OA anions (i.e., malate and citrate), photosynthesis and chlorophyll a fluorescence (OJIP) transients were measured. Al-induced decrease of photosynthesis and damage of photosynthetic electron transport chain were less pronounced in X/X and X/SP leaves than in SP/SP and SP/X leaves, which might be related with the higher Al-induced root efflux of OA anions and leaf P concentration. C. sinensis rootstock alleviated the influences of Al-toxicity on leaf photosynthetic electron transport chain by enhancing Al-induced release of root OA anions, hence lessening Al-induced photosynthesis inhibition in SP/X plants, while the reverse was the case for C. grandis rootstock in X/SP plants. In conclusion, the tolerance of grafted Citrus plants to Al depends on the scion as well as rootstock genotype, and the scion-rootstock interaction.     

Mechanistic study of mitochondria-dependent programmed cell death induced by aluminium phytotoxicity using fluorescence techniques

Recent studies have suggested that aluminium (Al) induces programmed cell death (PCD) in plants. To investigate possible mechanisms, fluorescence techniques were used to monitor the behaviour of mitochondria in vivo, as well as the activation of caspase-3-like activity during protoplast PCD induced by Al. A quick burst of mitochondrial reactive oxygen species (ROS) was detected in Al-treated protoplasts. The mitochondrial swelling and mitochondrial transmembrane potential (MTP) loss occurred prior to cell death. Pre-incubation with ascorbic acid (AsA, antioxidant molecule) retarded mitochondrial swelling and MTP loss. The real-time detection of caspase-3-like activation was achieved by measuring the degree of fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET). At 30 min after exposure to Al, caspase-3-like protease activation, indicated by the decrease in the FRET ratio, occurred, taking about 1 h to reach completion in single living protoplasts. The mitochondrial permeability transition pore (MPTP) inhibitor, cyclosporine (CsA) gave significant protection against MTP loss and subsequent caspase-3-like activation. Our data also showed that Al-induced mitochondrial ROS possibly originated from complex I and III damage in the respiratory chain through the interaction between Al and iron-sulphur (Fe-S) protein. Alternative oxidase (AOX), the unique respiratory terminal oxidase in plants, was demonstrated to play protective roles in Al-induced protoplast death. Our results showed that mitochondrial swelling and MTP loss, as well as the generation of mitochondrial ROS play important roles in Al-induced caspase-3-like activation and PCD, which provided new insight into the signalling cascades that modulate Al phytotoxicity mechanism.     

Boron-induced amelioration of aluminium toxicity in a monocot and a dicot species

Previous research has reported inconsistent results from experiments on the influence of boron (B) on plant sensitivity to potentially toxic aluminium (Al) concentrations. Differences in B requirement and cell wall properties among species, especially between Poaceae and dicots, may account for this. This investigation reports amelioration by B of Al-induced inhibition of root elongation in Al-sensitive cucumber (Cucumis sativus), but not in Al-sensitive maize (Zea mays). Vital staining, however, also revealed a positive influence of B supply on Al tolerance in maize. In both species, adequate B supply decreased Al-induced damage of cell integrity. In cucumber, increasing B supply enhanced Al concentrations and haematoxylin staining in root tips. In maize, no differences for root Al among B treatments were observed. These results indicate that the positive effect of B on Al resistance was not due to less Al accumulation in root tips. Enhanced concentrations of reduced glutathione were found in roots of Al-stressed maize plants growing with adequate B. It is concluded that adequate B supply is essential for prevention of Al toxicity in both the dicot and the monocot species. In dicot cucumber, the B-induced amelioration of root elongation, despite higher Al accumulation in root tips, indicates B-induced change in either or both Al speciation and compartmentation in the tips. The protection by an adequate B supply of roots against Al-induced cell death suggests a role for B in the defence against oxidative stress. This is supported by the observation that Al induced enhanced levels of GSH in roots of maize plants growing with adequate B supply but not in those growing with either deficient or excess B concentrations.     

Effect of mitochondria-targeted antioxidant SkQ1 on programmed cell death induced by viral proteins in tobacco plants

Programmed cell death (PCD) is the main defense mechanism in plants to fight various pathogens including viruses. The best-studied example of virus-induced PCD in plants is Tobacco mosaic virus (TMV)-elicited hypersensitive response in tobacco plants containing the N resistance gene. It was previously reported that the animal mitochondrial protein Bcl-xL, which lacks a homolog in plants, effectively suppresses plant PCD induced by TMV p50 — the elicitor of hyper-sensitive response in Nicotiana tabacum carrying the N gene. Our studies show that the mitochondria-targeted antioxidant SkQ1 effectively suppresses p50-induced PCD in tobacco plants. On the other hand, SkQ1 did not affect Poa semilatent virus TGB3-induced endoplasmic reticulum stress, which is followed by PCD, in Nicotiana benthamiana epidermal cells. These data suggest that mitochondria-targeted antioxidant SkQ1 can be used to study molecular mechanisms of PCD suppression in plants.     

Metacaspase MC1 enhances aluminum-induced programmed cell death of root tip cells in Peanut

Aims

Metacaspases are cysteine-dependent proteases, which play essential roles in programmed cell death (PCD), and caspase-3-like protease is the crucial executioner. However, its response mechanism to aluminum (Al)-induced PCD is still elusive.

Methods

Here, the type I metacaspase gene in peanut (Arachis hypoganea L.), AhMC1, was cloned from the Al-sensitive cultivar ZH2. Physiological and biochemical methods, as well as gene expression analyses, were employed to explore its function in Al-induced PCD in peanut root tips.

Results

AhMC1 had a 1068-bp open reading frame, encoding a peptide of 355 amino acids, and the purified protein exhibited a high caspase-3-like protease activity. Its expression levels in different tissues of peanut varieties ZH2 and 99–1507 (Al-tolerant) varied under Al-stress conditions. The subcellular localization indicated that AhMC1 was transferred from mitochondria into the cytoplasm. Furthermore, overexpressing AhMC1 reduced the resistance to Al stress. Sense transgenic plants showed a low relative root growth rate, and reduced superoxide dismutase, peroxidase, and catalase activities, compared with wild-type and antisense transgenic plants under Al-stress conditions, but had a high root-cell death rate, and increased Al and maleic dialdehyde contents.

Conclusions

The data suggest that metacaspase AhMC1 is a positive factor in Al-induced PCD in peanut root tips.

     

Boron supply alleviates Al-induced inhibition of root elongation and physiological characteristics in rapeseed (Brassica napus L.)

Aluminum (Al) toxicity is one of the major problems affecting crop production. Boron (B) is an essential micronutrient for higher plants. In the present study, we investigated the alleviation of Al-induced inhibition of root growth and physiological characteristics by B in rapeseed. The rapeseeds were grown in different Al concentrations (0 and 300?μM), and for every concentration, two B treatments (2.5 and 25?µM as H₃BO₃) were applied. The results showed that Al toxicity under low B drastically inhibited root growth. The supply of B improved root length, photosynthesis, root activity, total chlorophyll by 60.15%, 104.7%, 102%, and 106.3%, respectively under Al toxicity. This further resulted in improvement of peroxidase, catalase, and ascorbate peroxidase activities while decreasing malondialdehyde, H₂O_2, and Al contents in roots and leaves. It might be supposed that B alleviates Al toxicity by less mobilization of Al in plant parts and through improving antioxidant enzyme activities.     

Morphological changes in the apex of pea roots during and after recovery from aluminium treatment

We investigated how the pea (Pisum sativum cv. Harunoka) root, upon return to an Al-free condition, recovers from injury caused by exposure to Al. The growing region of the root during and after treatment with Al was examined by marking the root at intervals with India ink. Al-induced cell death was detected by staining with Evans blue. Root growth in 40 μM Al solution relative to that in Al-free solution (RRG) was approximately 45% from 6 h to12 h after the start of the treatment. However, values of RRG from 12 h to 24 h in Al-free solution for recovery or in the same Al solution were about 75% and 35%, respectively, indicating recovery from Al-induced growth inhibition. Images of the root characterized by zonal staining with Evans blue were observed in the sub-apical region (more than 1 mm from the tip) in Al-stressed roots. However, the interval of the stained zone was widened in the root after recovery from Al-induced growth inhibition, though it was narrower and more densely stained with time in the Al-stressed roots. During the recovery, the root apex may resume elongation in a specified region without Al-induced death or injury in cells detected by Evans blue.