Tissue specific DNA methylation of CpG islands in normal human adult somatic tissues distinguishes neural from non-neural tissues

Although most CpG islands are generally thought to remain unmethylated in all adult somatic tissues, recent genome-wide approaches have found that some CpG islands have distinct methylation patterns in various tissues, with most differences being seen between germ cells and somatic tissues. Few studies have addressed this among human somatic tissues and fewer still have studied the same sets of tissues from multiple individuals. In the current study, we used Restriction Landmark Genomic Scanning to study tissue specific methylation patterns in a set of 12 human tissues collected from multiple individuals. We identified 34 differentially methylated CpG islands among these tissues, many of which showed consistent patterns in multiple individuals. Of particular interest were striking differences in CpG island methylation, not only among brain regions, but also between white and grey matter of the same region. These findings were confirmed for selected loci by quantitative bisulfite sequencing. Cluster analysis of the RLGS data indicated that several tissues clustered together, but the strongest clustering was in brain. Tissues from different brain regions clustered together, and, as a group, brain tissues were distinct from either mesoderm or endoderm derived tissues which demonstrated limited clustering. These data demonstrate consistent tissue specific methylation for certain CpG islands, with clear differences between white and grey matter of the brain. Furthermore, there was an overall pattern of tissue specifically methylated CpG islands that distinguished neural tissues from non-neural.Key words: Tissue specific methylation, CpG island methylation, neural, brain tissue, grey matter, white matter     

Tissue specific DNA methylation of CpG islands in normal human adult somatic tissues distinguishes neural from non-neural tissues

Although most CpG islands are generally thought to remain unmethylated in all adult somatic tissues, recent genome-wide approaches have found that some CpG islands have distinct methylation patterns in various tissues, with most differences being seen between germ cells and somatic tissues. Few studies have addressed this among human somatic tissues and fewer still have studied the same sets of tissues from multiple individuals. In the current study, we used Restriction Landmark Genomic Scanning to study tissue specific methylation patterns in a set of twelve human tissues collected from multiple individuals. We identified 34 differentially methylated CpG islands among these tissues, many of which showed consistent patterns in multiple individuals. Of particular interest were striking differences in CpG island methylation, not only among brain regions, but also between white and grey matter of the same region. These findings were confirmed for selected loci by quantitative bisulfite sequencing. Cluster analysis of the RLGS data indicated that several tissues clustered together, but the strongest clustering was in brain. Tissues from different brain regions clustered together, and, as a group, brain tissues were distinct from either mesoderm or endoderm derived tissues which demonstrated limited clustering. These data demonstrate consistent tissue specific methylation for certain CpG islands, with clear differences between white and grey matter of the brain. Furthermore, there was an overall pattern of tissue specifically methylated CpG islands that distinguished neural tissues from non-neural.     

Genome-wide profiling of DNA methylation reveals a class of normally methylated CpG island promoters

The role of CpG island methylation in normal development and cell differentiation is of keen interest, but remains poorly understood. We performed comprehensive DNA methylation profiling of promoter regions in normal peripheral blood by methylated CpG island amplification in combination with microarrays. This technique allowed us to simultaneously determine the methylation status of 6,177 genes, 92% of which include dense CpG islands. Among these 5,549 autosomal genes with dense CpG island promoters, we have identified 4.0% genes that are nearly completely methylated in normal blood, providing another exception to the general rule that CpG island methylation in normal tissue is limited to X inactivation and imprinted genes. We examined seven genes in detail, including ANKRD30A, FLJ40201, INSL6, SOHLH2, FTMT, C12orf12, and DPPA5. Dense promoter CpG island methylation and gene silencing were found in normal tissues studied except testis and sperm. In both tissues, bisulfite cloning and sequencing identified cells carrying unmethylated alleles. Interestingly, hypomethylation of several genes was associated with gene activation in cancer. Furthermore, reactivation of silenced genes could be induced after treatment with a DNA demethylating agent or in a cell line lacking DNMT1 and/or DNMT3b. Sequence analysis identified five motifs significantly enriched in this class of genes, suggesting that cis-regulatory elements may facilitate preferential methylation at these promoter CpG islands. We have identified a group of non-X-linked bona fide promoter CpG islands that are densely methylated in normal somatic tissues, escape methylation in germline cells, and for which DNA methylation is a primary mechanism of tissue-specific gene silencing.     

Tissue-specific methylation of a CpG island in transgenic mice.

Clustering of CpG dinucleotides in CpG-rich islands is a characteristic feature of mammalian genomes. Such CpG islands are frequently associated with genes and usually hypomethylated, regardless of the gene activity. This is the case for the CpG island of the murine Thy-1 gene. A transgenic line containing multiple copies of a truncated, concatemeric CpG island from the Thy-1.1 allele (Thy-1.2 background) showed that a stable fraction (approx. 0.20) became fully methylated in somatic tissues of homozygous mice with respect to testable restriction sites, while the remaining copies were methylation-free, i.e., this methylation appears to be an 'all-or-none' phenomenon. DNA from extraembryonic tissues (placenta and yolk sac) and epididymal sperm showed, however, an even higher degree of methylation in two distinct patterns. In the extraembryonic tissue, partial methylation of each copy was seen, whereas in sperm a high degree of 'all-or-none' methylation (greater than 0.35) was observed.     

Dynamic CpG and non-CpG methylation of the Peg1/Mest gene in the mouse oocyte and preimplantation embryo

In somatic tissues, the CpG island of the imprinted Peg1/Mest gene is methylated on the maternal allele. We have examined the methylation of CpG and non-CpG sites of this differentially methylated CpG island in freshly ovulated oocytes, in vitro aged oocytes, and preimplantation embryos. The CpG methylation pattern was heterogeneous in freshly ovulated oocytes, despite the fact that they all were arrested in metaphase II. After short in vitro culture, Peg1/Mest became hypermethylated, whereas prolonged in vitro culture resulted in demethylation in a fraction of oocytes. Non-CpG methylation also occurred in a stage-specific manner. On alleles that were fully methylated at CpG sites, this modification was found, and it became reduced in two-cell stage embryos and blastocysts. These observations suggest that the process of establishment of the methylation imprint at this locus is more dynamic than previously thought.     

A DNA signal from the Thy-1 gene defines de novo methylation patterns in embryonic stem cells.

Although DNA can be extensively methylated de novo when introduced into pluripotent cells, the CpG island in the Thy-1 gene does not become methylated either in the mouse embryo or in embryonic stem cells. A 214-base-pair region near the promoter of the Thy-1 gene protects itself as well as heterologous DNA sequences from de novo methylation. We propose that this nucleotide sequence is representative of a class of important signals that limits de novo methylation in the embryo and establishes the pattern of hypomethylated CpG dinucleotides found in somatic tissues.     

Genomic analysis of the mouse protamine 1, protamine 2, and transition protein 2 gene cluster reveals hypermethylation in expressing cells

To understand the role of chromatin structure in the expression of the mouse protamine 1, protamine 2, and transition protein 2 genes during spermatogenesis, we have examined the genomic organization of this cluster of ``haploid-specific' genes. As seen in the human genome, protamine 2, transition protein 2, and approximately 2.8 kb of a CpG island, hereafter called CpG island-dTP2, were clustered in a small region. Methylation analyses of this region have demonstrated that i) unlike most other tissue-specific genes, the protamine 1, protamine 2, and transition protein 2 genes were located in a large methylated domain in round spermatids, the cell type where they are transcribed, ii) the protamine 1 gene was only partially methylated in somatic cells and in testes from 7-day-old mice, and iii) the approximately 2 kb upstream and downstream of the CpG island-dTP2 were only partially methylated in somatic tissues. DNase I analysis revealed the presence of at least five strong DNase I hypersensitive sites over the CpG island-dTP2 in somatic tissues, but not in germ cells, and sequence analysis indicated that the CpG island-dTP2 is homologous to a CpG island located approximately 10.6 kb downstream of the human transition protein 2 gene. Although the nature of a CpG island-dTP2 and the function of a CpG island-dTP2-containing somatic tissue-specific DNase I hypersensitive sites in close proximity to the germ cell-specific gene cluster are unclear, the ``open' chromatin structure of the CpG island-dTP2 may be responsible for the partial methylation pattern of the flanking sequences including the transition protein 2 gene in somatic tissues. Received: 6 September 1996 / Accepted: 14 January 1997     

Tissue specificity and organisation of CpG methylation in calf satellite DNA I.

Examination of bovine satellite DNA I methylation within CpG dinucleotides has been made by restriction analysis. It is shown that variations in the methylation patterns occur between different tissues (brain, liver, thymus and sperm) . Some of the 8 Hpa II sites present per repeat are clearly undermethylated in sperm as compared to other tissues. Methylation is considered therefore, as a highly specific event. It is also shown that there is a spatial specificity in the methylation pattern of the 3 Hha I sites in all tissues. These results are discussed in the light of methylation and satellite DNA functions.     

Heterologous CpG island becomes extensively methylated in the genome of transgenic mice

It is demonstrated that a heterologous (chicken) CpG island containing five Sp1 canonical recognition sequences becomes highly methylated in the genome of transgenic mice bearing one or several copies of the transgene. Similar levels of methylation of the chicken CpG island were observed in different tissues of transgenic mice except the brain where the level of methylation of this chicken CpG-rich fragment was significantly lower than in other tissues. Analysis of susceptibility of the "transgenic" CpG island to Hpa II and Msp I restriction nucleases revealed an unusual methylation pattern interfering with the action of both of these enzymes. A conclusion has been drawn that heterologous CpG island per se does not contain all necessary signals permitting to maintain its own non-methylated status in the genome of transgenic animals.     

Alu repeated DNAs are differentially methylated in primate germ cells.

A significant fraction of Alu repeats in human sperm DNA, previously found to be unmethylated, is nearly completely methylated in DNA from many somatic tissues. A similar fraction of unmethylated Alus is observed here in sperm DNA from rhesus monkey. However, Alus are almost completely methylated at the restriction sites tested in monkey follicular oocyte DNA. The Alu methylation patterns in mature male and female monkey germ cells are consistent with Alu methylation in human germ cell tumors. Alu sequences are hypomethylated in seminoma DNAs and more methylated in a human ovarian dysgerminoma. These results contrast with methylation patterns reported for germ cell single-copy, CpG island, satellite, and L1 sequences. The function of Alu repeats is not known, but differential methylation of Alu repeats in the male and female germ lines suggests that they may serve as markers for genomic imprinting or in maintaining differences in male and female meiosis.     

Aberrant DNA Methylation in ES Cells

Both mouse and human embryonic stem cells can be differentiated in vitro to produce a variety of somatic cell types. Using a new developmental tracing approach, we show that these cells are subject to massive aberrant CpG island de novo methylation that is exacerbated by differentiation in vitro. Bioinformatics analysis indicates that there are two distinct forms of abnormal de novo methylation, global as opposed to targeted, and in each case the resulting pattern is determined by molecular rules correlated with local pre-existing histone modification profiles. Since much of the abnormal methylation generated in vitro appears to be stably maintained, this modification may inhibit normal differentiation and could predispose to cancer if cells are used for replacement therapy. Excess CpG island methylation is also observed in normal placenta, suggesting that this process may be governed by an inherent program.     

Developmental differences in methylation of human Alu repeats.

Alu repeats are especially rich in CpG dinucleotides, the principal target sites for DNA methylation in eukaryotes. The methylation state of Alus in different human tissues is investigated by simple, direct genomic blot analysis exploiting recent theoretical and practical advances concerning Alu sequence evolution. Whereas Alus are almost completely methylated in somatic tissues such as spleen, they are hypomethylated in the male germ line and tissues which depend on the differential expression of the paternal genome complement for development. In particular, we have identified a subset enriched in young Alus whose CpGs appear to be almost completely unmethylated in sperm DNA. The existence of this subset potentially explains the conservation of CpG dinucleotides in active Alu source genes. These profound, sequence-specific developmental changes in the methylation state of Alu repeats suggest a function for Alu sequences at the DNA level, such as a role in genomic imprinting.     

Variations in DNA Methylation Patterns During the Cell Cycle of HeLa Cells

DNA methylation has been viewed as a stable component of the epigenome, which is established during development and fixed thereafter. We show here using nearest neighbor analysis, immunocytochemistry, and high performance capillary electrophoresis that the DNA methylation pattern varies in HeLa cells during a single cell cycle. Immunocytochemical analysis in primary human fibroblasts shows similar variations. The global levels of DNA methylation decreased in G1 and increase during the S phase of the cell cycle. Since there was little change in the DNA methylation levels in repetitive sequences throughout the cell cycle, we examined the DNA methylation pattern of unique sequences using a human CpG island microarray. Hybridization with methylated DNA from G1 and S phase of the cell cycle revealed that 174 CG-containing sequences were differentially methylated between G1 and S. 75% of all the variations in DNA methylation detected in unique sequences represented hypomethylation at G0, with changes occurring in both CpG islands and non-CpG islands. Bisulfite mapping confirmed these changes in methylation in the regions identified by the microarray. This is the first demonstration of a dynamic DNA methylation pattern within a single cell cycle of a mature somatic cell. These data are important for our understanding of the stability of DNA methylation patterns in somatic cells.     

A distinct sequence (ATAAA)n separates methylated and unmethylated domains at the 5'-end of the GSTP1 CpG island

What defines the boundaries between methylated and unmethylated domains in the genome is unclear. In this study we used bisulfite genomic sequencing to map the boundaries of methylation that flank the 5'- and 3'-ends of the CpG island spanning the promoter region of the glutathione S-transferase (GSTP1) gene. We show that GSTP1 is expressed in a wide range of tissues including brain, lung, skeletal muscle, spleen, pancreas, bone marrow, prostate, heart, and blood and that this expression is associated with the CpG island being unmethylated. In these normal tissues a marked boundary was found to separate the methylated and unmethylated regions of the gene at the 5'-flank of the CpG island, and this boundary correlated with an (ATAAA)(19-24) repeated sequence. In contrast, the 3'-end of the CpG island was not marked by a sharp transition in methylation but by a gradual change in methylation density over about 500 base pairs. In normal tissue the sequences on either side of the 5'-boundary appear to lie in separate domains in which CpG methylation is independently controlled. These separate methylation domains are lost in all prostate cancer where GSTP1 expression is silenced and methylation extends throughout the island and spans across both the 5'- and 3'-boundary regions.     

Characterization of differentially methylated regions in 3 bovine imprinted genes: a model for studying human germ-cell and embryo development

Correct imprinting is crucial for normal fetal and placental development in mammals. Experimental evidence in animal models and epidemiological studies in humans suggest that assisted reproductive technologies (ARTs) can interfere with imprinted gene regulation in gametogenesis and early embryogenesis. Bos taurus is an agriculturally important species in which ARTs are commonly employed. Because this species exhibits a similar preimplantation development and gestation length as humans, it is increasingly being used as a model for human germ-cell and embryo development. However, in contrast to humans and mice, there is relatively little information on bovine imprinted genes. Here, we characterized the bovine intergenic IGF2-H19 imprinting control region (ICR) spanning approximately 3 kb. We identified a 300-bp differentially methylated region (DMR) approximately 6 kb upstream of the H19 promoter, containing a CpG island with CTCF-binding site and high sequence similarity with the human intergenic ICR. Additional differentially methylated CpG islands lie -6 kb to -3 kb upstream of the promoter, however these are less conserved. Both classical bisulfite sequencing and bisulfite pyrosequencing demonstrated complete methylation of the IGF2-H19 ICR in sperm, complete demethylation in parthenogenetic embryos having only the female genome, and differential methylation in placental and somatic tissues. In addition, we established pyrosequencing assays for the previously reported bovine SNRPN and PEG3 DMRs. The observed methylation patterns were consistent with genomic imprinting in all analyzed tissues/cell types. The identified IGF2-H19 ICR and the developed quantitative methylation assays may prove useful for further studies on the relationship between ARTs and imprinting defects in the bovine model.     

小鼠骨髓细胞中p16和Ralb基因启动区CpG岛的甲基化位点分析

抑癌基因p16和白血病致癌因子Ralb与白血病的发生密切相关,其启动子区CpG岛的甲基化对基因表达具有重要作用.本文旨在分析p16、Ralb基因启动子区CpG岛甲基化位点信息,并比较这两个基因在小鼠骨髓细胞和原代培养的骨髓细胞中甲基化状态的差异.运用"MethPrimer"软件预测p16、Ralb基因启动子区的CpG岛,设计甲基化特异性引物.利用重亚硫酸盐测序法(BSP)检测甲基化位点信息.结果显示,p16有1个CpG岛,岛上21个CpG位点全部未发生甲基化;Ralb有2个CpG岛,CpG岛1上的5个CpG位点全部呈甲基化状态,而CpG岛2上的17个CpG位点全部呈非甲基化状态,且小鼠骨髓细胞和体外原代培养的骨髓细胞中两基因的甲基化状态一致.表明p16、Ralb基因甲基化状态未受外界培养条件的影响而改变,提示在与两基因甲基化相关的研究中体外试验可替代体内试验.     

Densely methylated sequences that are preferentially localized at telomere-proximal regions of human chromosomes

We have constructed a library of densely methylated DNA sequences from human blood DNA by selecting fragments with a high affinity for a methyl-CpG binding domain (MBD) column. PCR analysis of the library confirmed the presence of known densely methylated CpG island sequences. Analysis of random clones, however, showed that the library was dominated by sequences whose G+C content and CpG frequency were intermediate between those of bulk genomic DNA and bona fide CpG islands. When human chromosomes were probed with the library by fluorescent in situ hybridisation (FISH), the predominant sites of labelling were at terminal regions of many chromosomes, approximately corresponding to T-bands. Analysis of the methylation status of random clones indicated that all were heavily methylated at CpGs in blood DNA, but many were under-methylated in sperm DNA. Lack of methylation in germ cells may reduce CpG depletion at some sub-terminal sequences and result in a high density of methyl-CpG when these regions become methylated in somatic cells.