High-resolution electron diffraction of reconstituted PhoE porin

PhoE porin has been reconstituted with phospholipid, forming large membrane patches. Electron diffraction shows that the reconstituted PhoE porin forms highly coherent crystalline arrays, giving structural information to a resolution of 3.4 A. The crystal form is of the orthorhombic space group P2(1)2(1)2, with unit cell dimensions a = 150 A and b = 129 A. Images of negatively stained PhoE crystalline patches show that there are four PhoE porin trimers in a unit cell.     

Molecular design of PhoE porin and its functional consequences

The three-dimensional structure of PhoE porin from Escherichia coli, negatively stained with uranyl acetate, has been determined by electron crystallographic techniques to a resolution of about 18 A. The structure shows that PhoE porin consists of trimeric stain-filled channels as the basic unit. The trimeric channels converge as they transverse the membrane but they do not merge. Our three-dimensional structure of PhoE porin indicates that there is a short, narrower segment of channel, which extends beyond the visible strain-filled portion of the channel. The map of glucose-embedded PhoE porin in projection normal to the membrane has also been determined to a resolution of 6.5 A. The projected map shows trimeric ring-like structures, which are presumably cylindrical domains of beta-sheet. At the 3-fold symmetry axis of the trimer, there is a low density region, which is suggested to be a site of lipopolysaccharide that is required for channel and bacteriophage receptor activities. The structural model of the PhoE monomer consists of a flattened cylinder with a large water-filled vestibule about 35 A long with an elliptically shaped opening that is 27 A along the major axis and 18 A along the minor axis. The vestibule has a narrower extension about 10 A long with an average diameter of about 10 A. The vestibule wall is formed by beta-sheet, which may have a large fraction of the beta-strands oriented normal to membrane. Our structural model provides a clue as to how the surface charges on the outer membrane may regulate the permeation of ionic solutes through the channel.     

Three-dimensional electron diffraction of PhoE porin to 2.8 A resolution

A three-dimensional set of electron diffraction intensities of PhoE porin embedded in trehalose extending to 2.8 A resolution has been collected and analyzed. The strongest high-resolution intensities are distributed as a figure of revolution about the z*-axis and are located primarily in a resolution range of 4.5 A to 5.0 A. Within this region, centered near 4.8 A resolution the brightest intensities are clustered about inclination angles of 35 degrees and 0 degrees from the a*, b* plane. This distribution of intensities indicates that the beta-sheet in PhoE porin is arranged to form a cylinder-like structure that contains major populations of beta-sheet strands tilted an average of 35 degrees and 0 degrees with respect to the membrane plane normal. This cylindrical structure has been seen previously in the high-resolution projection map of PhoE as an elliptical ring of high density.     

Osmotic regulation of PhoE porin synthesis in Escherichia coli.

In Escherichia coli, adaptation to hyperosmotic conditions alters the expression of the outer membrane porins OmpF and OmpC. The amount of PhoE porin, which is normally induced by phosphate deprivation, was greatly reduced in cells adapted to high-osmolarity conditions. Osmoregulation of PhoE operated independently of the activity of the PhoR phosphate sensor and did not involve cross-talk from the homologous osmosensor EnvZ. PhoE synthesis was partially restored by additional copies of the positive regulator phoB+ and by the osmoprotectant glycine betaine.     

Structure of PhoE porin in projection at 3.5 A resolution.

The structure of PhoE porin in projection normal to the membrane plane has been determined to a resolution of about 3.5 A by electron crystallographic techniques. The purified protein was reconstituted with lipid to form two-dimensional crystals. High resolution images and electron diffraction patterns of these specimens embedded in trehalose were recorded to obtain respectively the structure factor phase information and the more accurate values of the amplitude. The projection map shows interesting features that are not seen in the earlier map at 6.5 A. Details of the trimeric ring-like structures in our earlier map are now resolved. Each ring-like structure consists of "beads" with interbead spacings of about 4-6 A. These beads are interpreted as the projections of beta-strands along the strands' axes. At the center of the trimeric structure, there is a low density region that we proposed previously to be the location of lipopolysaccharide. Within each ring-like structure, there are complicated features which may play an important role in the size, selectivity, and stability of the channel.     

On the targeting and membrane assembly of the Escherichia coli outer membrane porin, PhoE

Abstract Within gram-negative bacteria such as Escherichia coli , the outer membrane porins provide a relatively non-specific uptake route which is utilised by a wide range of solutes including many antibiotics. Understanding the targeting and membrane assembly of these proteins is therefore of importance and this mini review aims to discuss this process in light of present knowledge.     

E.coli PhoE porin has an opposite voltage-dependence to the homologous OmpF.

We used patch clamp analysis to compare the electrophysiological behavior of two related porins from Escherichia coli, the anion-specific PhoE and the cation-selective OmpF. Outer membrane fractions were obtained from strains expressing just one of these porin types, and the channels were reconstituted into liposomes without prior purification. We show that the orientation of the reconstituted channels is not random and is the same for both PhoE and OmpF. Like cation-selective porins, PhoE shows fast and slow gating to closed levels of various amplitudes, testifying that the channels visit multiple functional states and behave as cooperative entities. The voltage-dependence of PhoE closure is asymmetric, but strikingly, occurs at voltages of inverse polarity from those promoting closures of OmpC and OmpF. Both slow kinetics and inverse voltage-dependence are removed when 70 amino acids from the N-terminal of OmpF are introduced into the homologous region of PhoE. This novel observation regarding the voltage-dependence of the two channel types, along with published results on PhoE and OmpF mutants, allows us to propose a molecular mechanism for voltage sensing and sensor charge movements in bacterial porins. It also offers new cues on the possible physiological relevance in bacteria of this common form of channel modulation.     

Chemical modification of the anion selectivity of the PhoE porin from the Escherichia coli outer membrane

The PhoE porin of Escherichia coli is induced by phosphate deprivation and when purified, forms moderately anion-selective channels in lipid bilayer membranes. To further investigate the basis of anion selectivity, PhoE was chemically acetylated with acetic anhydride. Acetylation modified the mobility and staining characteristics of the PhoE porin on SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis but the acetylated protein was still found in its normal trimeric state after solubilization in SDS at low temperatures. Furthermore, the acetylated PhoE porin retained its ability to reconstitute into lipid bilayer membranes and the single channel conductance in 1 M KCl was unaltered. Zero-current potential measurements demonstrated that whereas the native PhoE porin was anion-selective, a 30-40-fold increase in preference for cations upon acetylation resulted in the acetylated PhoE porin being cation-selective. Increasing the pH of KCl solutions bathing lipid bilayer membranes from pH 3 to pH 6 caused symmetrical 4-fold increases in the selectivity of both the native and acetylated PhoE proteins for cations. In contrast, increasing the pH from 7 to 9 caused a 2.5-fold increase in selectivity only for the native PhoE porin. These results suggest that the basis of anion selectivity in the native PhoE porin is fixed protonated amino groups (possibly on lysines) in or near the channel, and furthermore indicate that deprotonated carboxyl groups have a strong influence on ion selectivity.     

Demonstration of a folded monomeric form of porin PhoE of Escherichia coli in vivo.

The porins in the outer membranes of gram-negative bacteria are trimeric proteins. A folded monomeric form of the Escherichia coli porin PhoE, with a higher electrophoretic mobility than that of the denatured protein, has recently been detected in in vitro folding studies. To investigate the possible biological significance of the folded monomer, we attempted to detect this form in vivo. After pulse-labeling, folded monomers could be detected by immunoprecipitation. Furthermore, folded monomers were detected in a preparation of mutant PhoE porins, in which the subunit interactions were weakened by a E-66-->R substitution. Together, these results show that the folded monomer is not an in vitro folding artifact but an integral part of the native trimer.     

Induction of the PhoE porin by NaCI as the basis for salt-induced acid sensitivity in Escherichia coli

Z. LAZIM, T.J. HUMPHREY AND R.J. ROWBURY. 1996. Organisms grown in low salt broth (LSB) are acid resistant but become sensitive on growth for 30-60 min with 300 mmol 1⁻¹ added NaCl. Salt-induced acid sensitivity only occurs in relA⁺ strains and sensitization is abolished by glucose, this catabolite repression effect being reversed by cAMP. The finding that sensitization did not occur in a phoE strain but did occur in a phoE⁺ derivative of it suggested that the response might result from PhoE induction, since PhoE acts as the major outer membrane (OM) proton pore under most conditions. In agreement with this, low-salt broth (LSB)-grown cells of a chromosomally lac⁻ strain carrying pJP102 ( phoE-lacZ ) produced low levels of β-galactosidase but growth with added NaCl led to rapid and appreciable induction. Also, a phoA mutant carrying a phoE-phoA fusion produced little alkaline phosphatase after growth in LSB but much more in LSB with added NaCl. Increased β-galactosidase synthesis (in phoE-lacZ strains) in the presence of NaCl was abolished by glucose, this effect being reversible by cAMP, and there was more NaCl-induced synthesis of this enzyme in relA⁺ strains.
Accordingly, it appears that addition of NaCl to LSB leads to acid sensitivity because it induces synthesis of the OM proton pore PhoE.     

Prediction of the general structure of OmpF and PhoE from the sequence and structure of porin from Rhodobacter capsulatus. Orientation of porin in the membrane.

By comparing the hydrophilicity profiles and sequences of porin from Rhodobacter capsulatus with those of OmpF and PhoE from Escherichia coli, a set of insertions and deletions for alignment of the sequences has been deduced. With this alignment a similar folding of OmpF and PhoE has been predicted as found by X-ray structure analysis of porin from Rhodobacter capsulates. Furthermore, the orientation of the porin trimer in the outer membrane was inferred from topological data on PhoE. According to this result a single channel of approx. 30 A diameter starts at the outer surface. Near the middle of the outer membrane bilayer this channel branches out into three separate channels, each running within a single porin monomer to the periplasmic surface.     

Topology of the anion-selective porin Omp32 from Comamonas acidovorans.

Limited proteolysis experiments were performed with outer membranes from Comamonas acidovorans to probe the topology of its major protein component, the anion-selective porin Omp32. Proteinase K treatment above a critical temperature of 42 degrees C cleaved the surface-exposed regions of the porin, yielding membrane-embedded fragments which were separated by SDS polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis or reversed phase chromatography. The identification of the proteinase K-sensitive sites was performed by microsequencing. This allowed us to determine six surface-exposed sites of the porin, all located in nonconserved primary structure regions. These results along with the previously determined amino acid sequence and in conjunction with some structural constraints applicable to porins allowed us to propose a chain-folding model of the Omp32 porin. The features of our model are compared with the structure of the Rhodobacter capsulatus porin, recently established by X-ray crystallography (Weiss et al., 1991) and they are used to elucidate the structural basis of the anion selectivity.     

Topology of the porin MspA in the outer membrane of Mycobacterium smegmatis

MspA is the major porin of Mycobacterium smegmatis mediating the exchange of hydrophilic solutes across the outer membrane (OM). It is the prototype of a new family of octameric porins with a single central channel of 9.6 nm in length and consists of two hydrophobic beta-barrels of 3.7 nm in length and a more hydrophilic, globular rim domain. The length of the hydrophobic domain of MspA does not match the thicknesses of mycobacterial OMs of 5-12 nm as derived from electron micrographs. Further, the membrane topology of MspA is unknown as it is for any other mycobacterial OM protein. We used MspA as a molecular ruler to define the boundaries of the OM of M. smegmatis by surface labeling of single cysteine mutants. Seventeen mutants covered the surface of the rim domain and were biotinylated with a membrane-impermeable reagent. The label efficiencies in vitro were remarkably similar to the predicted accessibilities of the cysteines. By contrast, six of these mutants were protected from biotinylation in M. smegmatis cells. Tryptophan 21 defines a horizontal plane that dissects the surface-exposed versus the membrane-protected residues of MspA. The 8 phenylalanines at position 99 form a ring at the periplasmic end of the hydrophobic beta-barrel domain. These results indicated that (i) the membrane boundaries of MspA are defined by aromatic girdles as in porins of Gram-negative bacteria and (ii) loops and a 3.4-nm long part of the hydrophilic rim domain are embedded into the OM of M. smegmatis. This is the first report suggesting that elements other than hydrophobic alpha-helices or beta-sheets are integrated into a lipid membrane.     

The pho-controlled outer membrane porin PhoE does not contain specific binding sites for phosphate or polyphosphates

Purified PhoE-porins were reconstituted into black lipid bilayer membranes, and the selectivity and size of the reconstituted pores were determined. Addition of polyphosphates influenced the internal charge situation of the pore resulting in a shift from anion to cation selectivity. However, the pore size as judged from single channel conductances was not influenced by the addition of polyphosphates. A strong inhibition of the pore conductance only occurred when Mg2+ was also present in the aqueous phase. The inhibition of the pore function is presumably caused by the formation of a chelate between the divalent cation and the polyphosphate. Nevertheless, neither this inhibition nor the selectivity shift are specific to phosphate, because both effects can be mimicked by other polyvalent anions such as citrate. Inhibition of the PhoE pore function by polyphosphate in in vivo experiments confirmed the results of in vitro experiments that polyphosphate is only able to affect the permeability of the outer membrane toward beta-lactam antibiotics if Mg2+ is present. The outcome of the in vivo and the in vitro experiments are consistent with the assumption that the PhoE-porins do not contain a specific binding site for phosphate or polyphosphates but are anion selective because of an excess of positively charged amino acids inside or at the surface of the pore.     

Existence and purification of porin heterotrimers of Escherichia coli K12 OmpC, OmpF, and PhoE proteins

Porin is a trimeric membrane protein that functions as a diffusion pore in the outer membrane of Escherichia coli. We report the existence and purification of porin heterotrimers between the ompC, ompF, and phoE porin gene products. Separation was achieved using a high resolution anion exchange column. The amount of each heterotrimer species present depended on the level of expression of the subunits and was consistent with random mixing of trimer subunits. A strong effect of bacterial lipopolysaccharide on the chromatography of porin was also detected. These results imply that assembly of porin trimers occurs between subunits synthesized on different polysomes and that subunit contacts between the porin subunits occur in conserved regions of the primary sequence.     

One single lysine residue is responsible for the special interaction between polyphosphate and the outer membrane porin PhoE of Escherichia coli

Site-directed mutagenesis was performed with the phosphate starvation-inducible outer membrane porin PhoE of Escherichia coli K-12 to study the molecular basis of its anion selectivity. Lysines 18, 29, 64, and 125 were replaced by glutamic acids, and the properties of the mutant porins were investigated in in vivo and in vitro experiments. Lipid bilayer experiments showed that all these mutations had no influence on the pore structure because PhoE and the mutants had the same single channel conductance in KCl solution. Selectivity measurements revealed that the mutations changed the ionic selectivity of PhoE, but the change was dependent on the location of the lysine. Replacement of Lys18 and Lys29 by glutamic acid had a relatively small influence. The effect of the Lys64 substitution was somewhat larger, and the effect of the replacement of Lys125 resulted in the most drastic change in selectivity and in the loss of the interaction of PhoE with polyphosphate, whereas the replacement of the other lysines had no effect on the polyphosphate interaction behavior. The results are consistent with the assumption that the charge spot in PhoE consists of only 1 lysine per monomer, located in position 125 of the primary sequence and probably close to the pore interior.     

The PhoE porin and transmission of the chemical stimulus for induction of acid resistance (acid habituation) in Escherichia coli

R. J. ROWBURY, M. GOODSON AND A.D. WALLACE. 1992. Escherichia coli K12 becomes resistant to killing by acid (habituates to acid) in a few minutes at pH 5.0. Habituation involves protein synthesis-dependent and -independent stages; both must occur at an habituating pH. The habituation sensor does not detect increased ΔpH (or decreased Δψ) nor an increased difference between pH_o and periplasmic pH but probably detects a fall in either external or periplasmic pH. Phosphate ions inhibit habituation, at any stage, probably by interfering with outer membrane passage of hydrogen ions. Most outer membrane components tested are not required for habituation but phoE deletion mutants habituated poorly and are acid-resistant. Strains derepressed for phoE , in contrast, showed increased acid sensitivity. These and other results suggest that habituation involves hydrogen ions or protonated carriers crossing the outer membrane preferentially via the PhoE pore, a process inhibited by phosphate and other anions. Stimulation by phosphate of the poor growth of E. coli at pH 5.0 is in accord with the above. Acetate did not enhance acid killing of pH 5.0 cells, suggesting that their resistance does not depend on maintaining pH_i near to neutrality at an acidic pH_o level.     

PhoE porin of Escherichia coli and phosphate reversal of acid damage and killing and of acid induction of the CadA gene product

The lethal effects of inorganic acid on phoE + Escherichia coli strains, grown at neutral pH₀, were enhanced by chloramphenicol, apparently because some organisms acquire acid tolerance (habituate) during challenge and chloramphenicol stops this. Phosphate (and/or polyphosphate) present during challenge prevented killing and damage by acid to outer membranes, DNA and cellular enzymes but did not prevent acid pH₀ enhancing novobiocin activity. To reverse acid effects, phosphate must interact with or cross the outer membrane but need not enter the cytoplasm; it is probable that it competes with H+ (or protonated anions) for passage through the PhoE pore. Phosphate also prevented induction of β-galactosidase in a strain with the cadA promoter fused to lacZ. Four unc mutants showed essentially normal acid sensitivity and habituation; the same was true for strains with lesions in fur, oxyR, katF, phoP, cadA and hycB. In contrast, deletion of rpoH led to slightly increased acid sensitivity for cells grown at pH₀ 7·0, although habituation was relatively normal.     

The PhoE porin and transmission of the chemical stimulus for induction of acid resistance (acid habituation) in Escherichia coli.

Escherichia coli K12 becomes resistant to killing by acid (habituates to acid) in a few minutes at pH 5.0. Habituation involves protein synthesis-dependent and -independent stages; both must occur at an habituating pH. The habituation sensor does not detect increased delta pH (or decreased delta psi) nor an increased difference between pHo and periplasmic pH but probably detects a fall in either external or periplasmic pH. Phosphate ions inhibit habituation, at any stage, probably by interfering with outer membrane passage of hydrogen ions. Most outer membrane components tested are not required for habituation but phoE deletion mutants habituated poorly and are acid-resistant. Strains derepressed for phoE, in contrast, showed increased acid sensitivity. These and other results suggest that habituation involves hydrogen ions or protonated carriers crossing the outer membrane preferentially via the PhoE pore, a process inhibited by phosphate and other anions. Stimulation by phosphate of the poor growth of E. coli at pH 5.0 is in accord with the above. Acetate did not enhance acid killing of pH 5.0 cells, suggesting that their resistance does not depend on maintaining pHi near to neutrality at an acidic pHo level.     

Outer membrane porin proteins F, P, and D1 of Pseudomonas aeruginosa and PhoE of Escherichia coli: chemical cross-linking to reveal native oligomers.

Native oligomers of three Pseudomonas aeruginosa outer membrane porin proteins and one Escherichia coli porin were demonstrated by using a chemical cross-linking technique. P. aeruginosa protein F, the major constitutive outer membrane porin, was cross-linked to dimers in outer membrane and whole-cell cross-linking experiments. Purified preparations of P. aeruginosa proteins F, D1 (glucose induced), and P (phosphate starvation induced) and E. coli protein PhoE (Ic) were also cross-linked to reveal dimers and trimers upon two-dimensional sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide electrophoretic analysis. Cross-linking of protein F was abolished by pretreatment of the protein with sodium dodecyl sulfate, indicating that the cross-linked products were due to native associations in the outer membrane.