A phylogenetic analysis of indel dynamics in the cotton genus

Genome size evolution is a dynamic process involving counterbalancing mechanisms whose actions vary across lineages and over time. Whereas the primary mechanism of expansion, transposable element (TE) amplification, has been widely documented, the evolutionary dynamics of genome contraction have been less thoroughly explored. To evaluate the relative impact and evolutionary stability of the mechanisms that affect genome size, we conducted a phylogenetic analysis of indel rates for 2 genomic regions in 4 Gossypium genomes: the 2 coresident genomes (A(T) and D(T)) of tetraploid cotton and its model diploid progenitors, Gossypium arboreum (A) and Gossypium raimondii (D). We determined the rates of sequence gain or loss along each branch, partitioned by mechanism, and how these changed during species divergence. In general, there has been a propensity toward growth of the diploid genomes and contraction in the polyploid. Most of the size difference between the diploid species occurred prior to polyploid divergence and was largely attributable to TE amplification in the A/A(T) genome. After separating from the true parents of the polyploid genomes, both diploid genomes experienced slower sequence gain than in the ancestor, due to fewer TE insertions in the A genome and a combination of increased deletions and decreased TE insertions in the D genome. Both genomes of the polyploid displayed increased rates of deletion and decreased rates of insertion, leading to a rate of near stasis in D(T) and overall contraction in A(T) resulting in polyploid genome contraction. As expected, TE insertions contributed significantly to the genome size differences; however, intrastrand homologous recombination, although rare, had the most significant impact on the rate of deletion. Small indel data for the diploids suggest the possibility of a bias as the smaller genomes add less or delete more sequence through small indels than do the larger genomes, whereas data for the polyploid suggest increased sequence turnover in general (both as small deletions and small insertions). Illegitimate recombination, although not demonstrated to be a dominant mechanism of genome size change, was biased in the polyploid toward deletions, which may provide a partial explanation of polyploid genomic downsizing.     

Mutational equilibrium model of genome size evolution

The paper describes a mutational equilibrium model of genome size evolution. This model is different from both adaptive and junk DNA models of genome size evolution in that it does not assume that genome size is maintained either by positive or stabilizing selection for the optimum genome size (as in adaptive theories) or by purifying selection against too much junk DNA (as in junk DNA theories). Instead the genome size is suggested to evolve until the loss of DNA through more frequent small deletions is equal to the rate of DNA gain through more frequent long insertions. The empirical basis for this theory is the finding of a strong correlation and of a clear power-function relationship between the rate of mutational DNA loss (per bp) through small deletions and genome size in animals. Genome size scales as a negative 1.3 power function of the deletion rate per nucleotide. Such a relationship is not predicted by either adaptive or junk DNA theories. However, if genome size is maintained at equilibrium by the balance of mutational forces, this empirilical relationship can be readily accommodated. Within this framework, this finding would imply that the rate of DNA gain through large insertions scales up a quarter-power function of genome size. On this view, as genome size grows, the rate of growth through large insertions is increasing as a quarter power function of genome size and the rate of DNA loss through small deletions increases linearly, until eventually, at the stable equilibrium genome size value, rates of growth and loss equal each other. The current data also suggest that the long-term variation is genome size in animals is brought about to a significant extent by changes in the intrinsic rates of DNA loss through small deletions. Both the origin of mutational biases and the adaptive consequences of such a mode of evolution of genome size are discussed.     

The correlation between intron length and recombination in drosophila. Dynamic equilibrium between mutational and selective forces

Intron length is negatively correlated with recombination in both Drosophila melanogaster and humans. This correlation is not likely to be the result of mutational processes alone: evolutionary analysis of intron length polymorphism in D. melanogaster reveals equivalent ratios of deletion to insertion in regions of high and low recombination. The polymorphism data do reveal, however, an excess of deletions relative to insertions (i.e., a deletion bias), with an overall deletion-to-insertion events ratio of 1.35. We propose two types of selection favoring longer intron lengths. First, the natural mutational bias toward deletion must be opposed by strong selection in very short introns to maintain the minimum intron length needed for the intron splicing reaction. Second, selection will favor insertions in introns that increase recombination between mutations under the influence of selection in adjacent exons. Mutations that increase recombination, even slightly, will be selectively favored because they reduce interference among selected mutations. Interference selection acting on intron length mutations must be very weak, as indicated by frequency spectrum analysis of Drosophila intron length polymorphism, making the equilibrium for intron length sensitive to changes in the recombinational environment and population size. One consequence of this sensitivity is that the advantage of longer introns is expected to decrease inversely with the rate of recombination, thus leading to a negative correlation between intron length and recombination rate. Also in accord with this model, intron length differs between closely related Drosophila species, with the longest variant present more often in D. melanogaster than in D. simulans. We suggest that the study of the proposed dynamic model, taking into account interference among selected sites, might shed light on many aspects of the comparative biology of genome sizes including the C value paradox.     

Insertion/deletion and nucleotide polymorphism data reveal constraints in Drosophila melanogaster introns and intergenic regions

Our study of nucleotide sequence and insertion/deletion polymorphism in Drosophila melanogaster noncoding DNA provides evidence for selective pressures in both intergenic regions and introns (of the large size class). Intronic and intergenic sequences show a similar polymorphic deletion bias. Insertions have smaller sizes and higher frequencies than deletions, supporting the hypothesis that insertions are selected to compensate for the loss of DNA caused by deletion bias. Analysis of a simple model of selective constraints suggests that the blocks of functional elements located in intergenic sequences are on average larger than those in introns, while the length distribution of relatively unconstrained sequences interspaced between these blocks is similar in intronic and intergenic regions.     

SHORT INDELS ARE SUBJECT TO INSERTION‐BIASED GENE CONVERSION

Recombination between homologous loci is accompanied by formation of heteroduplexes. Repairing mismatches in heteroduplexes often leads to single nucleotide substitutions in a process known as gene conversion. Gene conversion was shown to be GC‐biased in different organisms; that is, a W(A or T)→S(G or C) substitution is more likely in this process than a S→W substitution. Here, we show that the insertion/deletion ratio for short noncoding indels that reach fixation between species is positively correlated with the recombination rate in Drosophila melanogaster, Homo sapiens, and Saccharomyces cerevisiae. This correlation is both due to an increase of the fixation rate of insertions and decrease of the fixation rate of deletions in regions of high recombination. Whole‐genome data on indel polymorphism and divergence in D. melanogaster rule out mutation biases and selection as the cause of this trend, pointing to insertion‐biased gene conversion as the most likely explanation. The bias toward insertions is the strongest for single‐nucleotide indels, and decreases with indel length. In regions of high recombination rate this bias leads to an up to ～5‐fold excess of fixed short insertions over deletions, and substantially affects the evolution of DNA segments.     

High rate of DNA loss in the Drosophila melanogaster and Drosophila virilis species groups

We recently proposed that patterns of evolution of non-LTR retrotransposable elements can be used to study patterns of spontaneous mutation. Transposition of non-LTR retrotransposable elements commonly results in creation of 5' truncated, "dead-on-arrival" copies. These inactive copies are effectively pseudogenes and, according to the neutral theory, their molecular evolution ought to reflect rates and patterns of spontaneous mutation. Maximum parsimony can be used to separate the evolution of active lineages of a non-LTR element from the fate of the "dead-on-arrival" insertions and to directly assess the relative frequencies of different types of spontaneous mutations. We applied this approach using a non-LTR element, Helena, in the Drosophila virilis group and have demonstrated a surprisingly high incidence of large deletions and the virtual absence of insertions. Based on these results, we suggested that Drosophila in general may exhibit a high rate of spontaneous large deletions and have hypothesized that such a high rate of DNA loss may help to explain the puzzling dearth of bona fide pseudogenes in Drosophila. We also speculated that variation in the rate of spontaneous deletion may contribute to the divergence of genome size in different taxa by affecting the amount of superfluous "junk" DNA such as, for example, pseudogenes or long introns. In this paper, we extend our analysis to the D. melanogaster subgroup, which last shared a common ancestor with the D. virilis group approximately 40 MYA. In a different region of the same transposable element, Helena, we demonstrate that inactive copies accumulate deletions in species of the D. melanogaster subgroup at a rate very similar to that of the D. virilis group. These results strongly suggest that the high rate of DNA loss is a general feature of Drosophila and not a peculiar property of a particular stretch of DNA in a particular species group.      

A Model for Genome Size Evolution

We present a model for genome size evolution that takes into account both local mutations such as small insertions and small deletions, and large chromosomal rearrangements such as duplications and large deletions. We introduce the possibility of undergoing several mutations within one generation. The model, albeit minimalist, reveals a non-trivial spontaneous dynamics of genome size: in the absence of selection, an arbitrary large part of genomes remains beneath a finite size, even for a duplication rate 2.6-fold higher than the rate of large deletions, and even if there is also a systematic bias toward small insertions compared to small deletions. Specifically, we show that the condition of existence of an asymptotic stationary distribution for genome size non-trivially depends on the rates and mean sizes of the different mutation types. We also give upper bounds for the median and other quantiles of the genome size distribution, and argue that these bounds cannot be overcome by selection. Taken together, our results show that the spontaneous dynamics of genome size naturally prevents it from growing infinitely, even in cases where intuition would suggest an infinite growth. Using quantitative numerical examples, we show that, in practice, a shrinkage bias appears very quickly in genomes undergoing mutation accumulation, even though DNA gains and losses appear to be perfectly symmetrical at first sight. We discuss this spontaneous dynamics in the light of the other evolutionary forces proposed in the literature and argue that it provides them a stability-related size limit below which they can act.     

Transposons but not retrotransposons are located preferentially in regions of high recombination rate in Caenorhabditis elegans

We analyzed the distribution of transposable elements (TEs: transposons, LTR retrotransposons, and non-LTR retrotransposons) in the chromosomes of the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans. The density of transposons (DNA-based elements) along the chromosomes was found to be positively correlated with recombination rate, but this relationship was not observed for LTR or non-LTR retrotransposons (RNA-based elements). Gene (coding region) density is higher in regions of low recombination rate. However, the lower TE density in these regions is not due to the counterselection of TE insertions within exons since the same positive correlation between TE density and recombination rate was found in noncoding regions (both in introns and intergenic DNA). These data are not compatible with a global model of selection acting against TE insertions, for which an accumulation of elements in regions of reduced recombination is expected. We also found no evidence for a stronger selection against TE insertions on the X chromosome compared to the autosomes. The difference in distribution of the DNA and RNA-based elements along the chromosomes in relation to recombination rate can be explained by differences in the transposition processes.     

The sunflower (Helianthus annuus L.) genome reflects a recent history of biased accumulation of transposable elements

Aside from polyploidy, transposable elements are the major drivers of genome size increases in plants. Thus, understanding the diversity and evolutionary dynamics of transposable elements in sunflower (Helianthus annuus L.), especially given its large genome size (～3.5 Gb) and the well‐documented cases of amplification of certain transposons within the genus, is of considerable importance for understanding the evolutionary history of this emerging model species. By analyzing approximately 25% of the sunflower genome from random sequence reads and assembled bacterial artificial chromosome (BAC) clones, we show that it is composed of over 81% transposable elements, 77% of which are long terminal repeat (LTR) retrotransposons. Moreover, the LTR retrotransposon fraction in BAC clones harboring genes is disproportionately composed of chromodomain‐containing Gypsy LTR retrotransposons (‘chromoviruses’), and the majority of the intact chromoviruses contain tandem chromodomain duplications. We show that there is a bias in the efficacy of homologous recombination in removing LTR retrotransposon DNA, thereby providing insight into the mechanisms associated with transposable element (TE) composition in the sunflower genome. We also show that the vast majority of observed LTR retrotransposon insertions have likely occurred since the origin of this species, providing further evidence that biased LTR retrotransposon activity has played a major role in shaping the chromatin and DNA landscape of the sunflower genome. Although our findings on LTR retrotransposon age and structure could be influenced by the selection of the BAC clones analyzed, a global analysis of random sequence reads indicates that the evolutionary patterns described herein apply to the sunflower genome as a whole.     

Insertion sequence-caused large-scale rearrangements in the genome of Escherichia coli

A majority of large-scale bacterial genome rearrangements involve mobile genetic elements such as insertion sequence (IS) elements. Here we report novel insertions and excisions of IS elements and recombination between homologous IS elements identified in a large collection of Escherichia coli mutation accumulation lines by analysis of whole genome shotgun sequencing data. Based on 857 identified events (758 IS insertions, 98 recombinations and 1 excision), we estimate that the rate of IS insertion is 3.5 × 10⁻⁴ insertions per genome per generation and the rate of IS homologous recombination is 4.5 × 10⁻⁵ recombinations per genome per generation. These events are mostly contributed by the IS elements IS1, IS2, IS5 and IS186. Spatial analysis of new insertions suggest that transposition is biased to proximal insertions, and the length spectrum of IS-caused deletions is largely explained by local hopping. For any of the ISs studied there is no region of the circular genome that is favored or disfavored for new insertions but there are notable hotspots for deletions. Some elements have preferences for non-coding sequence or for the beginning and end of coding regions, largely explained by target site motifs. Interestingly, transposition and deletion rates remain constant across the wild-type and 12 mutant E. coli lines, each deficient in a distinct DNA repair pathway. Finally, we characterized the target sites of four IS families, confirming previous results and characterizing a highly specific pattern at IS186 target-sites, 5′-GGGG(N6/N7)CCCC-3′. We also detected 48 long deletions not involving IS elements.     

植物基因组大小进化的研究进展

不同的真核生物之间基因组大小差异很大, 并与生物体复杂性不相关, 在基因组中存在大量的非编码DNA序列是造成这种差异的主要原因, 特别是转座子序列。文章综述了植物基因组大小差异以及引起这种差异的主要进化动力的最新研究进展。植物基因组多倍化和转座子积累是导致基因组增大的主要动力, 而同源不平等重组和非正规重组则是驱动基因组DNA丢失的潜在动力, 以制约基因组无限制地增大。文中还讨论了植物基因组大小进化方向, 即总体趋势是朝着增大的方向进化, 某些删除机制主要是削弱这种增大作用但不能逆转。     

Biased distributions and decay of long interspersed nuclear elements in the chicken genome

The genomes of birds are much smaller than mammalian genomes, and transposable elements (TEs) make up only 10% of the chicken genome, compared with the 45% of the human genome. To study the mechanisms that constrain the copy numbers of TEs, and as a consequence the genome size of birds, we analyzed the distributions of LINEs (CR1's) and SINEs (MIRs) on the chicken autosomes and Z chromosome. We show that (1) CR1 repeats are longest on the Z chromosome and their length is negatively correlated with the local GC content; (2) the decay of CR1 elements is highly biased, and the 5'-ends of the insertions are lost much faster than their 3'-ends; (3) the GC distribution of CR1 repeats shows a bimodal pattern with repeats enriched in both AT-rich and GC-rich regions of the genome, but the CR1 families show large differences in their GC distribution; and (4) the few MIRs in the chicken are most abundant in regions with intermediate GC content. Our results indicate that the primary mechanism that removes repeats from the chicken genome is ectopic exchange and that the low abundance of repeats in avian genomes is likely to be the consequence of their high recombination rates.     

A detailed look at 7 million years of genome evolution in a 439 kb contiguous sequence at the barley Hv-eIF4E locus: recombination, rearrangements and repeats

Six overlapping BAC clones covering the Hv-eIF4E gene region in barley were sequenced in their entire length, resulting in a 439.7 kb contiguous sequence. The contig contains only two genes, Hv-eIF4E and Hv-MLL, which are located in a small gene island and more than 88% of the sequence is composed of transposable elements. A detailed analysis of the repetitive component revealed that this chromosomal region was affected by multiple major duplication and deletion events as well as the insertion of numerous transposable elements, resulting in a complete reshuffling of genomic DNA. Resolving this highly complex pattern resulted in a model unraveling evolutionary events that shaped this region over an estimated 7 million years. Duplications and deletions caused by illegitimate recombination and unequal crossing over were major driving forces in the evolution of the Hv-eIF4E region, equaling or exceeding the effects of transposable element activities. In addition to a dramatic reshuffling of the repetitive portion of the sequence, we also found evidence for important contributions of illegitimate recombination and transposable elements to the sequence organization of the gene island containing Hv-eIF4E and Hv-MLL.     

Mechanisms and rates of genome expansion and contraction in flowering plants

Plant genomes are exceptional for their great variation in genome size, an outcome derived primarily from their frequent polyploid origins and from the amplification of retrotransposons. Although most studies of plant genome size variation have focused on developmental or physiological effects of nuclear DNA content that might influence plant fitness, more recent studies have begun to investigate possible mechanisms for plant genome expansion and contraction. Analyses of relatively neutral genome components, like transposable elements, have been particularly fruitful, largely due to the enormous growth in genomic sequence information from many different plant species. Current data suggest that unequal recombination can slow the growth in genome size caused by retrotransposon amplification, but that illegitimate recombination and other deletion processes may be primarily responsible for the removal of non-essential DNA from small genome plants.     

A strong deletion bias in nonallelic gene conversion

Gene conversion is the unidirectional transfer of genetic information between orthologous (allelic) or paralogous (nonallelic) genomic segments. Though a number of studies have examined nucleotide replacements, little is known about length difference mutations produced by gene conversion. Here, we investigate insertions and deletions produced by nonallelic gene conversion in 338 Drosophila and 10,149 primate paralogs. Using a direct phylogenetic approach, we identify 179 insertions and 614 deletions in Drosophila paralogs, and 132 insertions and 455 deletions in primate paralogs. Thus, nonallelic gene conversion is strongly deletion-biased in both lineages, with almost 3.5 times as many conversion-induced deletions as insertions. In primates, the deletion bias is considerably stronger for long indels and, in both lineages, the per-site rate of gene conversion is orders of magnitudes higher than that of ordinary mutation. Due to this high rate, deletion-biased nonallelic gene conversion plays a key role in genome size evolution, leading to the cooperative shrinkage and eventual disappearance of selectively neutral paralogs.     

Prospects of applying a combination of DNA transposition and site-specific recombination in plants: a strategy for gene identification and cloning

The concept of gene identification and cloning using insertional mutagenesis is well established. Many genes have been isolated using T-DNA transformation or transposable elements. Maize transposable elements have been introduced into heterologous plant species for tagging experiments. The behaviour of these elements in heterologous hosts shows many similarities with transposon behaviour in Zea mays. Site-specific recombination systems from lower organisms have also been shown to function efficiently in plant cells. Combining transposon and site-specific recombination systems in plants would create the possibility to induce chromosomal deletions. This transposition-deletion system could allow the screening of large segments of the genome for interesting genes and may also permit the cloning of the DNA corresponding to the deleted material by the same site-specific recombination reaction in vitro. This methodology may provide a unique means to construct libraries of large DNA clones derived from defined parts of the genome, the phenotypic contribution of which is displayed by the mutant carrying the deletion.     

Repeated big bangs and the expanding universe: Directionality in plant genome size evolution

The lack of correlation between genome size and organismal complexity has long been a topic of great interest. Over the last decade it has become clear that transposable elements play a dominant role in genome size growth, and that most of the observed genome size variation in plants can be ascribed to differential accumulation of transposable elements, particularly long terminal repeat retrotransposons, which often massively proliferate over exceptionally short evolutionary time-scales. In the absence of one or more counterbalancing forces, Bennetzen and Kellogg previously suggested that growth via transposable element accumulation would create a “one-way ticket to genomic obesity”. Phylogenetic evidence, however, indicates that lineages may experience genomic downsizing, notwithstanding the relative paucity of experimental evidence on mechanisms capable of eliminating massive amounts of DNA. Thus, genome size evolution in plants may involve both feast and famine. Here we review recent insights into the molecular mechanisms and evolutionary dynamics of genome size evolution in plants. These include mechanisms that contribute to genome size expansion, i.e. polyploidy and transposable element proliferation, in addition to the counteracting forces that act to remove DNA, particularly intra-strand homologous recombination and illegitimate recombination. We argue that extant genome sizes reflect myriad competing forces of genomic expansion and contraction, but that current evidence pertaining to rates and amounts of DNA loss prove insufficient to overcome transposable element proliferation in most lineages. Accordingly, the directionality of plant genome size evolution in most cases is biased toward growth, with mechanisms of DNA loss acting to attenuate (but not reverse) the march toward obesity.     

Molecular basis of evolutionary events that shaped the hardness locus in diploid and polyploid wheat species (Triticum and Aegilops)

The Hardness (Ha) locus controls grain hardness in hexaploid wheat (Triticum aestivum) and its relatives (Triticum and Aegilops species) and represents a classical example of a trait whose variation arose from gene loss after polyploidization. In this study, we investigated the molecular basis of the evolutionary events observed at this locus by comparing corresponding sequences of diploid, tertraploid, and hexaploid wheat species (Triticum and Aegilops). Genomic rearrangements, such as transposable element insertions, genomic deletions, duplications, and inversions, were shown to constitute the major differences when the same genomes (i.e., the A, B, or D genomes) were compared between species of different ploidy levels. The comparative analysis allowed us to determine the extent and sequences of the rearranged regions as well as rearrangement breakpoints and sequence motifs at their boundaries, which suggest rearrangement by illegitimate recombination. Among these genomic rearrangements, the previously reported Pina and Pinb genes loss from the Ha locus of polyploid wheat species was caused by a large genomic deletion that probably occurred independently in the A and B genomes. Moreover, the Ha locus in the D genome of hexaploid wheat (T. aestivum) is 29 kb smaller than in the D genome of its diploid progenitor Ae. tauschii, principally because of transposable element insertions and two large deletions caused by illegitimate recombination. Our data suggest that illegitimate DNA recombination, leading to various genomic rearrangements, constitutes one of the major evolutionary mechanisms in wheat species.