Repressor titration: a novel system for selection and stable maintenance of recombinant plasmids.

The propagation of recombinant plasmids in bacterial hosts, particularly in Escherichia coli, is essential for the amplification and manipulation of cloned DNA and the production of recombinant proteins. The isolation of bacterial transformants and subsequent stable plasmid maintenance have traditionally been accomplished using plasmid-borne selectable marker genes. Here we describe a novel system that employs plasmid-mediated repressor titration to activate a chromosomal selectable marker, removing the requirement for a plasmid-borne marker gene. A modified E.coli host strain containing a conditionally essential chromosomal gene (kan) under the control of the lac operator/promoter, lac O/P, has been constructed. In the absence of an inducer (allolactose or IPTG) this strain, DH1 lackan , cannot grow on kanamycin-containing media due to the repression of kan expression by LacI protein binding to lac O/P. Transformation with a high copy-number plasmid containing the lac operator, lac O, effectively induces kan expression by titrating LacI from the operator. This strain thus allows the selection of plasmids without antibiotic resistance genes (they need only contain lac O and an origin of replication) which have clear advantages for use as gene therapy vectors. Regulation in the same way of an essential, endogenous bacterial gene will allow the production of recombinant therapeutics devoid of residual antibiotic contamination.     

Escherichia coli strains that allow antibiotic-free plasmid selection and maintenance by repressor titration

We report the construction of two novel Escherichia coli strains (DH1lacdapD and DH1lacP2dapD) that facilitate the antibiotic-free selection and stable maintenance of recombinant plasmids in complex media. They contain the essential chromosomal gene, dapD, under the control of the lac operator/promoter. Unless supplemented with IPTG (which induces expression of dapD) or DAP, these cells lyse. However, when the strains are transformed with a multicopy plasmid containing the lac operator, the operator competitively titrates the LacI repressor and allows expression of dapD from the lac promoter. Thus transformants can be isolated and propagated simply by their ability to grow on any medium by repressor titration selection. No antibiotic resistance genes or other protein expressing sequences are required on the plasmid, and antibiotics are not necessary for plasmid selection, making these strains a valuable tool for therapeutic DNA and recombinant protein production. We describe the construction of these strains and demonstrate plasmid selection and maintenance by repressor titration, using the new pORT plasmid vectors designed to facilitate recombinant DNA exploitation.     

Effects of recombinant plasmid content on growth properties and cloned gene product formation in Escherichia coli

Plasmid-host cell interactions have been investigated experimentally using Escherichia coli HB101, plasmid RSF1050 which contains the origin of replication of pMB1, and four other closely related copy number mutant plasmids. Growth characteristics of these recombinant strains and beta-lactamase activity expressed from a plasmid gene were investigated in Luria broth (LB) and in minimal medium (M9) containing in some cases casamino acids or different concentrations of alpha-methylglucoside, a competitive inhibitor of glucose transport. Maximum specific growth rates in LB and minimal media were reduced for increasing plasmid content per cell. Plasmid copy number increased when specific growth rate was reduced by changing medium composition. Growth rates of high copy number strains were less sensitive to alpha-methylglucoside than lower copy number strains and the plasmidfree host. The overall efficiency of plasmid gene expression, measured as the ratio of beta-lactamase specific activity to plasmid content, decreased significantly with increasing plasmid content in LB medium.     

Absolute and relative QPCR quantification of plasmid copy number in Escherichia coli

Real-time QPCR based methods for determination of plasmid copy number in recombinant Escherichia coli cultures are presented. Two compatible methods based on absolute and relative analyses were tested with recombinant E. coli DH5alpha harboring pBR322, which is a common bacterial cloning vector. The separate detection of the plasmid and the host chromosomal DNA was achieved using two separate primer sets, specific for the plasmid beta-lactamase gene (bla) and for the chromosomal d-1-deoxyxylulose 5-phosphate synthase gene (dxs), respectively. Since both bla and dxs are single-copy genes of pBR322 and E. coli chromosomal DNA, respectively, the plasmid copy number can be determined as the copy ratio of bla to dxs. These methods were successfully applied to determine the plasmid copy number of pBR322 of E. coli host cells. The results of the absolute and relative analyses were identical and highly reproducible with coefficient of variation (CV) values of 2.8-3.9% and 4.7-5.4%, respectively. The results corresponded to the previously reported values of pBR322 copy number within E. coli host cells, 15-20. The methods introduced in this study are convenient to perform and cost-effective compared to the traditionally used Southern blot method. The primer sets designed in this study can be used to determine plasmid copy number of any recombinant E. coli with a plasmid vector having bla gene.     

Analysis of a recessive plasmid copy number mutant: evidence for negative control of Col E1 replication.

The Col E1-derivative copy number mutant plasmid pOP1Δ6 has been used to investigate the control of plasmid replication. pOP1Δ6 normally exists at about 200 copies per chromosome, while the wild-type plasmid from which it was derived (pBGP120) exists at about 15 copies per chromosome. We have observed that in E. coli containing both pOP1Δ6 and pBGP120, the copy number of pOP1Δ6 is lowered to 4–6 copies per chromosome. Thus the mutation in pOP1Δ6 is recessive. The association between the two plasmids is stable in E. coli, indicating that incompatibility properties as well as replication control characteristics have been altered in pOP1Δ6. Co-residence of the unrelated plasmid pSC101 with pOP1Δ6 has no detectable effect on pOP1Δ6 copy number. These results suggest that a plasmid-specific, diffusible repressor may act negatively to control plasmid copy number, and that pOP1Δ6 produces a defective repressor or is altered in repressor synthesis. We have constructed in vitro a plasmid which is identical in size to pQP1Δ6 but contains a replication origin region derived from pBGP120. Since this plasmid, pNOP1, exists stably (like pBGP120) at 10–15 copies per chromosome, the high copy number of pOP1Δ6 is not related to its reduced size relative to pBGP120. To localize the mutation in pOP1Δ6 responsible for DNA overproduction, we have cloned fragments of pBGP120 into pOP1Δ6 and selected for plasmids with wild-type copy number. We find that a 2.0 kb region of pBGP120 DNA surrounding the origin of plasmid DNA replication is capable of suppressing the DNA overproducer phenotype of pOP1Δ6. The 2.0 kb fragment is capable of independent self-replication or can integrate into pOP1Δ6 in vivo to form a composite plasmid with two origins of replication. The overproducer phenotype of pOP1Δ6 is suppressed in either configuration.     

A mathematical model for lambda dv plasmid replication: analysis of copy number mutants

A mathematical model based on the molecular control mechanisms for lambda dv plasmid replication in a single Escherichia coli cell has been applied to simulate replication of mutant lambda dv plasmids. Model simulations of changes in repressor level and copy number resulting from mutations in the promoter-operator PROR region are consistent with experimental data. Calculated effects on lambda dv plasmid copy number of oligomer formation and of alternations in termination efficiency at tR1 also agree with experiment. The model has been employed to simulate the influence of cro mutants and of cro and tR1 double mutants on copy number and stable maintenance of lambda dv plasmid copy number. The genetic structure included in formulation of the replicon model provides a framework for relating changes in specific genetic loci on the plasmid with resulting alterations in host-plasmid system function.     

Retrovirus-mediated insertional mutagenesis: phagemid rescue of flanking DNA by selecting plasmid ori

A method for screening recombinant lambda libraries was devised to select phage containing genomic regions containing provirus insertions of retroviruses that carry the kanamycin and G418 resistance factor neo and the origin of replication derived from pBR322 (oripBR). Such recombinants are phagemids, able to replicate as bacteriophages or as plasmids under lambda repressor control. lambda repressor was cloned into a plasmid derived from pSC101 that is compatible with pBR322-derived phagemids. A strain carrying this plasmid may be used to select phagemids derived from a single proviral insertion with 100% efficiency from complex recombinant libraries. Homologous recombination between proviral long terminal repeats was observed at a rate of 10(-4)/plaque-forming unit in recABC+ strains. Despite this frequency, intact phagemids are easily recovered as phage after temperature shift to 42 degrees C. Since oripBR itself is a selectable marker in this system, the method could be applied to recover any sequence carrying the ori sequence from pBR322.     

Lambda phagemids and their transducing properties

Two recombinant lambda DNAs, lambda gt::pMB9 and lambda NM::pBR322, containing, respectively, the pMB9 and pBR322 replicon were constructed and characterized. Both constructs (phagemid DNAs) transfect Escherichia coli cells, producing mature infectious phage progenies. Alternatively, drug-resistant colonies of transductants can be selected upon infection with these phages (phagemid particles) that maintain phagemid DNA in the cell in the form of covalently closed circular plasmids. The efficiency of transduction for nonlysogenic E. coli strains with lambda gt::pMB9 phage producing lambda repressor cIts ranges from 10(-7) to 10(-2) transductant colonies per input phage, depending on the temperature and strain used, while lambda NM::pBR322 phage carrying imm21 transduces with a frequency of up to 1. This means that each lambda NM::pBR322 phagemid particle is capable of establishing itself in the cell as a nonlethal plasmid, permitting formation of a resistant bacterial colony. The maximal level of transduction with lambda gt::pMB9 was obtained when E. coli cells lysogenic for lambda were used. Thus, we believe that the efficiency of transduction is determined by the turn-on of the phage repressor in the transductant. In addition, we have found that all lambda gt::pMB9-containing transductants under certain conditions harbor precisely excised pMB9; excision of pBR322 from lambda NM::pBR322 has not been observed.     

The admid system: generation of recombinant adenoviruses by Tn7-mediated transposition in E. coli

A new system has been developed for generating recombinant adenoviruses by Tn7-mediated transposition in E. coli. Low copy number E. coli plasmids containing a full-length adenoviral genome with lacZattTn7 replacing E1 have been constructed. The adenovirus plasmid or admid, as well as high copy number progenitors, were stably maintained in E. coli strain DH10B. Several transfer vectors containing a mammalian expression cassette flanked by Tn7R and Tn7L were used as donors to transpose the mini-Tn7 into the E1 region of the adenoviral genome. Transposed recombinant admids are readily identified by their beta-galactosidase phenotype. Transfection of admid DNA into producer cells resulted in the efficient production of infectious adenovirus. This easy-to-use, efficient system generates pure, clonal stocks of recombinant adenovirus without successive rounds of plaque purification.     

Cloning vectors, derived from a naturally occurring plasmid of Pseudomonas savastanoi, specifically tailored for genetic manipulations in Pseudomonas

A minimal replicon of 1.8 kb isolated from a 10-kb plasmid of Pseudomonas savastanoi, pPS10, has been used to obtain a collection of small vectors specific for Pseudomonas (P. savastanoi, P. aeruginosa and P.putida). In addition, shuttle vectors that can be established both in Pseudomonas and Escherichia coli have been constructed by adding a pMB9 replicon. The vectors permit cloning of DNA fragments generated by a variety of restriction enzymes using different antibiotic resistance markers for selection and offer the possibility to screen recombinants by insertional inactivation. This cloning system can be used to establish recombinant plasmids in Pseudomonas either at low or high copy number. pPS10 derivatives are compatible with other Pseudomonas vectors derived from broad-host-range replicons of the incompatibility groups P1, P4/Q and W. Introduction and expression of the iaaMH operon in a P. savastanoi mutant deficient in the production of indoleacetic acid has been achieved using one of these vectors.     

The minimal replicon of a Streptomycete plasmid produces an ultrahigh level of plasmid DNA

A functional map of Streptomyces coelicolor plasmid SCP2* was deduced from derivatives constructed by in vitro deletions. Functions were analyzed on bifunctional shuttle plasmids that contained pBR322 for selection and replication in Escherichia coli and fragments of SCP2* for replication in Streptomyces griseofuscus C581 and strains of Streptomyces lividans. The aph gene for neomycin resistance from Streptomyces fradiae and the tsr gene for thiostrepton resistance from Streptomyces azureus were incorporated as selectable antibiotic resistance markers in streptomycetes. An 11.8-kb sequence bounded by EcoRI and KpnI restriction sites contains the information for self-transfer and normal replication of the plasmid. A 5.9-kb EcoRI-SalI fragment contains all of the information for normal replication. Partial digestion generated a 2.2-kb Sau3A fragment that is sufficient for replication but it produces ten times higher plasmid copy number than the basic replicon. pHJL400 and PHJL401 are useful shuttle vectors containing the moderate-copy-number streptomycete plasmid combined with the E. coli plasmid pUC19. A 1.4-kb BclI-Sau3A fragment with an additional internal BclI site contains the minimal replicon but it produces 1000 times higher plasmid copy number than the basic replicon. pHJL302 is a useful shuttle vector containing the ultrahigh-copy-number streptomycete plasmid combined with the E. coli plasmid pUC19.     

Sequence analysis and characterization of plasmid pSFD10 from Salmonella choleraesuis

The nucleotide sequence of a small plasmid, designated pSFD10, is isolated from the vaccine strain Salmonella choleraesuis C500 in China, has been determined. This plasmid is 4091 bp long with a total G+C content of 51.4%, which is in the range of Salmonella genomic DNA. Analysis of the complete nucleotide sequence reveals that pSFD10 has a high degree of similarity to ColE1-type plasmid, having the possible cer and rom genes, and a putative mobilization origin of ColE1-type. Plasmid pSFD10 possesses six main open reading frames (ORFs), five of which have a very high degree of amino acid identity to ColE1-type plasmid gene products involved in mobilization and copy number control. The other ORF (ORF6) encodes a putative protein, which has 49% homology to the invasion plasmid antigen J protein (IpaJ) secreted by the type III secretion apparatus of Shigella flexneri. In addition, pSFD10 belongs to a different incompatibility group than ColE1-type and pMB1-type to which it is related. Plasmid pSFD10 can be mobilized by the plasmid RP4 in E. coli.     

Effects of genes exerting growth inhibition and plasmid stability on plasmid maintenance.

Plasmid stabilization mediated by the parA+ and parB+ genes of the R1 plasmid and the ccd+ and sop+ genes of the F plasmid was tested on a mini-R1 plasmid and a pBR322 plasmid derivative. The mini-R1 plasmid is thought to be unstably inherited owing to a low copy number and to random segregation of the plasmid at cell division, whereas cells harboring the pBR322 derivative used in this work are lost through competition with plasmid-free cells, mainly as a result of the shorter generation time of cells without plasmids. The pBR322 derivative carries a fusion between part of the atp operon of Escherichia coli and the bacteriophage lambda pR promoter, and the cI857 repressor gene. The insertion of sop+ from the F plasmid or parB+ from the R1 plasmid reduced the loss frequency by a factor of 10(3) for the pBR322 derivative and by at least a factor of 10(2) for the mini-R1 plasmid. Insertion of parA+ from the R1 plasmid decreased the loss frequency of the pBR322 derivative by a factor of 10 and that of the mini-R1 plasmid by a factor of 50. When ccd+ from the F plasmid was inserted, the loss frequency of the pBR322 derivative was decreased by a factor of 10, but it had only a marginal effect on the stability of the mini-R1 plasmid. In no case was any significant structural instability of the plasmids observed.     

Investigation of the instability of plasmids directing the expression of Met-prochymosin in Escherichia coli

The causes of the instability of a multicopy plasmid, pCT70, which directs the expression of calf prochymosin in Escherichia coli, were investigated. Plasmid pAT153 and its derivative, pCT54, were stable for more than 90 generations in continuous culture with glucose limitation. The multicopy plasmid pCT66, which expressed very low levels of prochymosin due to poor translational efficiency, and low copy number plasmids which efficiently expressed the prochymosin gene, were also stable. These results indicated that high level translation of the recombinant gene was the cause of the instability of pCT70. The maximum specific growth rate of E. coli(pCT70) was reduced by 30% compared with E. coli(pCT66). To fulfil the requirements of a production system, a dual origin plasmid with controllable copy number was developed. Both this plasmid (pMG165) and a derivative which contained the prochymosin gene (pMG168) were stable when maintained at low copy number. When the copy number of plasmid pMG168 was increased by putting replication under the control of the lambda PR promoter and the cI857 temperature sensitive repressor, expression of prochymosin was achieved. This strategy enables large-scale production of prochymosin without the need for antibiotic selection or other methods of preventing plasmid loss.     

A mathematical model for prediction of plasmid copy number and genetic stability in Escherichia coli

The design of bioreactors for genetically modified bacterial cultures would benefit from predictive models. Of particular importance is the interaction of the external environment, cell physiology, and control of plasmid copy number. We have recently developed a model based on the molecular mechanisms for control of replication of Co1E1 type plasmids. The inclusion of the plasmid model into a single-cell E. coli model allows the explicit prediction of the interaction of cell physiology and plasmid-encoded functions. The model predictions of the copy number of plasmids with the Co1E1 origin of replication carrying a variety of regulatory mutations is very close to that observed experimentally.All of the model parameters for plasmid replication control can be obtained independently and no adjustable parameters are needed for the plasmid model. In this article we discuss the model's use in predicting the effect of operating conditions on production of a protein from a plasmid encoded gene and the stability of the recombinant cells in a continuous culture.     

Exonucleases I, III, and V are required for stability of ColE1-related plasmids in Escherichia coli.

The stability of two ColE1-related plasmids (pRSF2124 and pMB9) was examined in strains of Escherichia coli multiply deficient in exonucleases I (sbcB), III (xthA), or V (recB recC). Any combination of exonuclease I, III, and V deficiency resulted in dramatically decreased stability of both pRSF2124 and pMB9. Inactivation of the RecF pathway by introducing either recF or recJ mutations to the recB recC subcB background resulted in nearly wild-type levels of stability for both plasmids. In contrast, the introduction of uvrD3 uvr-257, uvrE100, or recL152 into the recB21 recC22 sbcB15 strain did not affect plasmid stability. Furthermore, the amount of plasmid DNA recovered from pRSF2124 or pMB9 transformants of a xthA1 sbcB15 strain was strikingly reduced relative to that of a wild-type control. Taken together, these results suggest that some aspect of DNA repair is required for stable maintenance of ColE1-related plasmids in E. coli.     

Plasmid-mediated lethality and plasmid multimer formation in an Escherichia coli recBC sbcBC mutant. Involvement of RecF recombination pathway genes

Apparent plasmid instability, i.e. progressive plasmid loss in a bacterial culture growing in the absence of selection for the plasmid, in an Escherichia coli recBC sbcBC mutant was investigated with two different ColE1 derivatives (pMB9 and pBR322) and a mini-F plasmid. The instability was most striking for pMB9 and much less, but still significant, for pBR322 and the mini-F. It was also dependent upon a subset of the genes involved in the RecF recombination pathway: in addition to the previously reported recA, recF and recJ mutations, a recO and a recQ mutation showed a total and a partial suppression, respectively, of the instability. Other recF-family mutations, recN and ruv, were without such an effect. Population analyses of the recBC sbcBC strain carrying pMB9 or the mini-F, as carried out by plating and Coulter counting, revealed marked loss of viability in plasmid-carrying cells, strongly implicating plasmid-mediated cell death in the apparent defect in plasmid maintenance. Analysis of intracellular plasmid DNA by pulsed-field gel electrophoresis combined with the in-agarose cell lysis technique showed that the instability was associated with the formation of plasmid multimers, with a good correlation between the degree of the instability and the amount of the multimers. The multimer formation was also dependent on the same subset of the RecF pathway genes as in the instability phenomenon. These results strongly suggest that the lethality is somehow caused by the multimer formation. Various DNase treatments of cell lysates showed that such multimers of pMB9 DNA comprised molecules of exonuclease-sensitive and exonuclease-resistant types. It was inferred that the former class, which showed electrophoretic mobilities corresponding to plain linear duplexes of approximately 200 x 10(3) to 2200 x 10(3) base-pairs, represented linear multimers possibly carrying circular structures at one end. The latter class, which remained in the origin, was thought to consist of circular multimers and/or linear multimers protected by circular structures at both ends against exonucleolytic attack.     

Evidence for positive regulation of plasmid prophage P1 replication: integrative suppression by copy mutants.

Like low-copy-number plasmids including P1 wild type, multicopy P1 mutants (P1 cop, maintained at five to eight copies per chromosome) can suppress the thermosensitive phenotype of an Escherichia coli dnaA host by forming a cointegrate. At 40 degrees C in a dnaA host suppressed by P1 cop, the only copy of P1 is the one in the host chromosome. Trivial explanations of the lack of extrachromosomal copies of P1 cop have been eliminated: (i) during integrative suppression, the P1 cop plasmid does not revert to cop+; (ii) the dnaA+ function of the host is not required to maintain P1 cop at a high copy number; and (iii) integrative recombination does not occur within the region of the plasmid involved in regulation of copy number. Since there are no more copies of the chromosomal origin (now located within the integrated P1 plasmid) than in a P1 cop+-suppressed strain, the extra initiation potential of the P1 cop is not used to provide multiple initiations of the chromosome. When a P1 cop-suppressed dnaA strain was grown at 30 degrees C so that replication could initiate from the chromosomal origin as well as from the P1 origin, multicopy supercoiled P1 DNA was found in the cells. This plasmid DNA was lost again when the temperature was shifted back to 40 degrees C.