Interdomain cooperativity of calmodulin bound to melittin preferentially increases calcium affinity of sites I and II

Calmodulin (CaM) is the primary transducer of calcium fluxes in eukaryotic cells. Its two domains allosterically regulate myriad target proteins through calcium-linked association and conformational change. Many of these proteins have a basic amphipathic alpha-helix (BAA) motif that binds one or both CaM domains. Previously, we demonstrated domain-specific binding of melittin, a model BAA peptide, to Paramecium CaM (PCaM): C-domain mutations altered the interaction with melittin, whereas N-domain mutations had no discernable effect. Here, we report on the use of fluorescence and NMR spectroscopy to measure the domain-specific association of melittin with calcium-saturated ((Ca(2+))(4)-PCaM) or calcium-depleted (apo) PCaM, which has enabled us to determine the free energies of calcium binding to the PCaM-melittin complex, and to estimate interdomain cooperativity. Under apo conditions, melittin associated with each PCaM domain fragment (PCaM(1-80) and PCaM(76-148)), as well as with the C-domain of full-length PCaM (PCaM(1-148)). In the presence of calcium, all of these interactions were again observed, in addition to which an association with the N-domain of (Ca(2+))(4)-PCaM(1-148) occurred. This new association was made possible by the fact that melittin changed the calcium-binding preferences for the domains from sequential (C > N) to concomitant, decreasing the median ligand activity of calcium toward the N-domain 10-fold more than that observed for the C-domain. This selectivity may be explained by a free energy of cooperativity of -3 kcal/mol between the N- and C-domains. This study demonstrates multiple domain-selective differences in the interactions between melittin and PCaM. Our findings support a model that may apply more generally to ion channels that associate with the C-domain of CaM under low (resting) calcium conditions, but rearrange when calcium binding triggers an association of the N- domain with the channel.     

Paramecium calmodulin mutants defective in ion channel regulation associate with melittin in the absence of calcium but require it for tertiary collapse

Calmodulin (CaM) is a small acidic protein essential to calcium-mediated signal transduction. Conformational change driven by calcium binding controls its selective activation of myriad target proteins. In most well characterized cases, both homologous domains of CaM interact with a target protein. However, physiologically separable roles for the two domains were demonstrated by mutants of Paramecium tetraurelia [Kung, C. et al. (1992) Cell Calcium 13, 413], some of which have altered calcium affinities [Jaren, O. R. et al. (2000) Biochemistry 39, 6881]. To determine whether these mutants can associate with canonical targets in a calcium-dependent manner, their ability to bind melittin was assessed using analytical gel permeation chromatography, analytical ultracentrifugation, and fluorescence spectroscopy. The Stokes radius of wild-type PCaM and 11 of the mutants decreased dramatically upon binding melittin in the presence of calcium. Fluorescence spectra and sedimentation velocity studies showed that melittin bound to wild-type PCaM and mutants in a calcium-independent manner. However, there were domain-specific perturbations. Mutations in the N-domain of PCaM did not affect the spectrum of melittin (residue W19) under apo or calcium-saturated conditions, whereas most of the mutations in the C-domain did. These data are consistent with a calcium-dependent model of sequential target association whereby melittin (i) binds to the C-domain of PCaM in the absence of calcium, (ii) remains associated with the C-domain upon calcium binding to sites III and IV, and (iii) subsequently binds to the N-domain upon calcium binding to sites I and II of CaM, causing tertiary collapse.     

Calcium binding to calmodulin mutants having domain-specific effects on the regulation of ion channels

Calmodulin (CaM) is an essential, eukaryotic protein comprised of two highly homologous domains (N and C). CaM binds four calcium ions cooperatively, regulating a wide array of target proteins. A genetic screen of Paramecia by Kung [Kung, C. et al. (1992) Cell Calcium 13, 413-425] demonstrated that the domains of CaM have separable physiological roles: "under-reactive" mutations affecting calcium-dependent sodium currents mapped to the N-domain, while "over-reactive" mutations affecting calcium-dependent potassium currents localized to the C-domain of CaM. To determine whether and how these mutations affected intrinsic calcium-binding properties of CaM domains, phenylalanine fluorescence was used to monitor calcium binding to sites I and II (N-domain) and tyrosine fluorescence was used to monitor sites III and IV (C-domain). To explore interdomain interactions, binding properties of each full-length mutant were compared to those of its corresponding domain fragments. The calcium-binding properties of six under-reactive mutants (V35I/D50N, G40E, G40E/D50N, D50G, E54K, and G59S) and one over-reactive mutant (M145V) were indistinguishable from those of wild-type CaM, despite their deleterious physiological effects on ion-channel regulation. Four over-reactive mutants (D95G, S101F, E104K, and H135R) significantly decreased the calcium affinity of the C-domain. Of these, one (E104K) also increased the calcium affinity of the N-domain, demonstrating that the magnitude and direction of wild-type interdomain coupling had been perturbed. This suggests that, while some of these mutations alter calcium-binding directly, others probably alter CaM-channel association or calcium-triggered conformational change in the context of a ternary complex with the affected ion channel.     

Paramecium calmodulin mutants defective in ion channel regulation can bind calcium and undergo calcium-induced conformational switching

Calmodulin (CaM) is an essential eukaryotic protein that binds calcium ions cooperatively at four EF-hand binding sites to regulate signal transduction pathways. Interactions between the apo domains of vertebrate CaM reduce the calcium affinities of sites I and II below their intrinsic values, allowing sequential opening of the two hydrophobic clefts in CaM. Viable domain-specific mutants of Parameciumcalmodulin (PCaM) differentially affect ion channels and provide a unique opportunity to dissect the roles of the two highly homologous half-molecule domains. Calcium binding induced an increase in the level of ordered secondary structure and a decrease in Stokes radius in these mutants; such changes were identical in direction to those of wild type CaM, but the magnitude depended on the mutation. Calcium titrations monitored by changes in the intrinsic fluorescence of Y138 in site IV showed that the affinities of sites III and IV of wild type PCaM were (i) higher than those of the same sites in rat CaM, (ii) equivalent to those of the same sites in PCaM mutants altered between sites I and II, and (iii) higher than those of PCaM mutants modified in sites III and IV. Thus, calcium saturation drove all mutants to undergo conformational switching in the same direction but not to the same extent as wild type PCaM. The disruption of the allosteric mechanism that is manifest as faulty channel regulation may be explained by altered properties of switching among the 14 possible partially saturated species of PCaM rather than by an inability to adopt two end-state conformations or target interactions similar to those of the wild type protein.     

Basic interdomain boundary residues in calmodulin decrease calcium affinity of sites I and II by stabilizing helix-helix interactions

Calmodulin is an EF-hand calcium-binding protein (148 a.a.) essential in intracellular signal transduction. Its homologous N- and C-terminal domains are separated by a linker that appears disordered in NMR studies. In a study of an N-domain fragment of Paramecium CaM (PCaM1-75), the addition of linker residues 76 to 80 (MKEQD) raised the Tm by 9 degrees C and lowered calcium binding by 0.54 kcal/mol (Sorensen et al., [Biochemistry 2002;41:15-20]), showing that these tether residues affect energetics as well as being a barrier to diffusion. To determine the individual contributions of residues 74 through 80 (RKMKEQD) to stability and calcium affinity, we compared a nested series of 7 fragments (PCaM1-74 to PCaM1-80). For the first 4, PCaM1-74 through PCaM1-77, single amino acid additions at the C-terminus corresponded to stepwise increases in thermostability and decreases in calcium affinity with a net change of 13.5 degrees C in Tm and 0.55 kcal/mol in free energy. The thermodynamic properties of fragments PCaM1-77 through PCaM1-80 were nearly identical. We concluded that the 3 basic residues in the sequence from 74 to 77 (RKMK) are critical to the increased stability and decreased calcium affinity of the longer N-domain fragments. Comparisons of NMR (HSQC) spectra of 15N-PCaM1-74 and 15N-PCaM1-80 and analysis of high-resolution structural models suggest these residues are latched to amino acids in helix A of CaM. The addition of residues E78, Q79, and D80 had a minimal effect on sites I and II, but they may contribute to the mechanism of energetic communication between the domains.     

Calcium binding to calmodulin mutants monitored by domain-specific intrinsic phenylalanine and tyrosine fluorescence

Cooperative calcium binding to the two homologous domains of calmodulin (CaM) induces conformational changes that regulate its association with and activation of numerous cellular target proteins. Calcium binding to the pair of high-affinity sites (III and IV in the C-domain) can be monitored by observing calcium-dependent changes in intrinsic tyrosine fluorescence intensity (lambda(ex)/lambda(em) of 277/320 nm). However, calcium binding to the low-affinity sites (I and II in the N-domain) is more difficult to measure with optical spectroscopy because that domain of CaM does not contain tryptophan or tyrosine. We recently demonstrated that calcium-dependent changes in intrinsic phenylalanine fluorescence (lambda(ex)/lambda(em) of 250/280 nm) of an N-domain fragment of CaM reflect occupancy of sites I and II (VanScyoc, W. S., and M. A. Shea, 2001, Protein Sci. 10:1758-1768). Using steady-state and time-resolved fluorescence methods, we now show that these excitation and emission wavelength pairs for phenylalanine and tyrosine fluorescence can be used to monitor equilibrium calcium titrations of the individual domains in full-length CaM. Calcium-dependent changes in phenylalanine fluorescence specifically indicate ion occupancy of sites I and II in the N-domain because phenylalanine residues in the C-domain are nonemissive. Tyrosine emission from the C-domain does not interfere with phenylalanine fluorescence signals from the N-domain. This is the first demonstration that intrinsic fluorescence may be used to monitor calcium binding to each domain of CaM. In this way, we also evaluated how mutations of two residues (Arg74 and Arg90) located between sites II and III can alter the calcium-binding properties of each of the domains. The mutation R74A caused an increase in the calcium affinity of sites I and II in the N-domain. The mutation R90A caused an increase in calcium affinity of sites III and IV in the C-domain whereas R90G caused an increase in calcium affinity of sites in both domains. This approach holds promise for exploring the linked energetics of calcium binding and target recognition.     

The neuronal voltage-dependent sodium channel type II IQ motif lowers the calcium affinity of the C-domain of calmodulin

Calmodulin (CaM) is the primary calcium sensor in eukaryotes. Calcium binds cooperatively to pairs of EF-hand motifs in each domain (N and C). This allows CaM to regulate cellular processes via calcium-dependent interactions with a variety of proteins, including ion channels. One neuronal target is NaV1.2, voltage-dependent sodium channel type II, to which CaM binds via an IQ motif within the NaV1.2 C-terminal tail (residues 1901-1938) [Mori, M., et al. (2000) Biochemistry 39, 1316-1323]. Here we report on the use of circular dichroism, fluorescein emission, and fluorescence anisotropy to study the interaction between CaM and NaV1.2 at varying calcium concentrations. At 1 mM MgCl2, both full-length CaM (CaM1-148) and a C-domain fragment (CaM76-148) exhibit tight (nanomolar) calcium-independent binding to the NaV1.2 IQ motif, whereas an N-domain fragment of CaM (CaM1-80) binds weakly, regardless of calcium concentration. Equilibrium calcium titrations of CaM at several concentrations of the NaV1.2 IQ peptide showed that the peptide reduced the calcium affinity of the CaM C-domain sites (III and IV) without affecting the N-domain sites (I and II) significantly. This leads us to propose that the CaM C-domain mediates constitutive binding to the NaV1.2 peptide, but that interaction then distorts calcium-binding sites III and IV, thereby reducing their affinity for calcium. This contrasts with the CaM-binding domains of voltage-dependent Ca2+ channels, kinases, and phosphatases, which increase the calcium binding affinity of the C-domain of CaM.     

Calcium occupancy of N-terminal sites within calmodulin induces inhibition of the ryanodine receptor calcium release channel

Calmodulin (CaM) regulates calcium release from intracellular stores in skeletal muscle through its association with the ryanodine receptor (RyR1) calcium release channel, where CaM association enhances channel opening at resting calcium levels and its closing at micromolar calcium levels associated with muscle contraction. A high-affinity CaM-binding sequence (RyRp) has been identified in RyR1, which corresponds to a 30-residue sequence (i.e., K3614-N3643) located within the central portion of the primary sequence. However, it is presently unclear whether the identified CaM-binding sequence in association with CaM (a) senses calcium over the physiological range of calcium concentrations associated with RyR1 regulation or alternatively, (b) plays a structural role unrelated to the calcium-dependent modulation of RyR1 function. Therefore, we have measured the calcium-dependent activation of the individual domains of CaM in association with RyRp and their relationship to the CaM-dependent regulation of RyR1. These measurements utilize an engineered CaM, permitting the site-specific incorporation of N-(1-pyrene)maleimide at either T34C (PyN-CaM) or T110C (PyC-CaM) in the N- and C-domains, respectively. Consistent with prior measurements, we observe a high-affinity association of both apo-CaM and calcium-activated CaM with RyRp. Upon association with RyRp, fluorescence changes in PyN-CaM or PyC-CaM permit the measurement of the calcium-dependent activation of these individual domains. Fluorescence changes upon calcium activation of PyC-CaM in association with RyRp are indicative of high-affinity calcium-dependent activation of the C-terminal domain of CaM at resting calcium levels; at calcium levels associated with muscle contraction, activation of the N-terminal domain occurs with concomitant increases in the fluorescence intensity of PyC-CaM that is associated with structural changes within the CaM-binding sequence of RyR1. Occupancy of calcium-binding sites in the N-domain of CaM mirrors the calcium dependence of RyR1 inhibition observed at activating calcium levels, where [Ca]1/2 = 4.3 +/- 0.4 microM, suggesting a direct regulation of RyR1 function upon the calcium-dependent activation of CaM. These results indicate that occupancy of the N-terminal domain calcium binding sites in CaM bound to the identified CaM-binding sequence K3614-N3643 induces conformational rearrangements within the complex between CaM and RyR1 responsible for the CaM-dependent modulation of the RyR1 calcium release channel.     

Conformational and metal-binding properties of androcam, a testis-specific, calmodulin-related protein from Drosophila

Androcam is a testis-specific protein of Drosophila melanogaster, with 67% sequence identity to calmodulin and four potential EF-hand calcium-binding sites. Spectroscopic monitoring of the thermal unfolding of recombinant calcium-free androcam shows a biphasic process characteristic of a two-domain protein, with the apo-N-domain less stable than the apo-C-domain. The two EF hands of the C-domain of androcam bind calcium cooperatively with 40-fold higher average affinity than the corresponding calmodulin sites. Magnesium competes with calcium binding [Ka(Mg) approximately 3 x 10(3) M(-1)]. Weak calcium binding is also detected at one or more N-domain sites. Compared to apo-calmodulin, apo-androcam has a smaller conformational response to calcium and a lower alpha-helical content over a range of experimental conditions. Unlike calmodulin, a tryptic cleavage site in the N-domain of apo-androcam remains trypsin sensitive in the presence of calcium, suggesting an altered calcium-dependent conformational change in this domain. The affinity of model target peptides for androcam is 10(3)-10(5) times lower than for calmodulin, and interaction of the N-domain of androcam with these peptides is significantly reduced. Thus, androcam shows calcium-induced conformational responses typical of a calcium sensor, but its properties indicate calcium sensitivity and target interactions significantly different from those of calmodulin. From the sequence differences and the altered calcium-binding properties it is likely that androcam differs from calmodulin in the conformation of residues in the second calcium-binding loop. Molecular modeling supports the deduction that there are significant conformational differences in the N-domain of androcam compared to calmodulin, and that these could affect the surface, conferring a different specificity on androcam in target interactions related to testis-specific calcium signaling functions.     

Solution structures of the N-terminal domain of yeast calmodulin: Ca2+-dependent conformational change and its functional implication

We have determined solution structures of the N-terminal half domain (N-domain) of yeast calmodulin (YCM0-N, residues 1-77) in the apo and Ca(2+)-saturated forms by NMR spectroscopy. The Ca(2+)-binding sites of YCM0-N consist of a pair of helix-loop-helix motifs (EF-hands), in which the loops are linked by a short beta-sheet. The binding of two Ca(2+) causes large rearrangement of the four alpha-helices and exposes the hydrophobic surface as observed for vertebrate calmodulin (CaM). Within the observed overall conformational similarity in the peptide backbone, several significant conformational differences were observed between the two proteins, which originated from the 38% disagreement in amino acid sequences. The beta-sheet in apo YCM0-N is strongly twisted compared with that in the N-domain of CaM, while it turns to the normal more stable conformation on Ca(2+) binding. YCM0-N shows higher cooperativity in Ca(2+) binding than the N-domain of CaM, and the observed conformational change of the beta-sheet is a possible cause of the highly cooperative Ca(2+) binding. The hydrophobic surface on Ca(2+)-saturated YCM0-N appears less flexible due to the replacements of Met51, Met71, and Val55 in the hydrophobic surface of CaM with Leu51, Leu71, and Ile55, which is thought to be one of reasons for the poor activation of target enzymes by yeast CaM.     

Disruption of interdomain interactions via partial calcium occupancy of calmodulin

Binding of calcium to CaM exposes clefts in both N- and C-domains to promote their cooperative association with a diverse array of target proteins, functioning to relay the calcium signal regulating cellular metabolism. To clarify relationships between the calcium-dependent activation of individual domains and interdomain structural transitions associated with productive binding to target proteins, we have utilized three engineered CaM mutants that were covalently labeled with N-(1-pyrene) maleimide at introduced cysteines in the C- and N-domains, i.e., T110C (PyC-CaM), T34C (PyN-CaM), and T34C/T110C (Py2-CaM). These sites were designed to detect known conformers of CaM such that upon association with classical CaM-binding sequences, the pyrenes in Py2-CaM are brought close together, resulting in excimer formation. Complementary measurements of calcium-dependent enhancements of monomer fluorescence of PyC-CaM and PyN-CaM permit a determination of the calcium-dependent activation of individual domains and indicate the sequential calcium occupancy of the C- and N-terminal domains, with full saturation at 7.0 and 300 microM calcium, respectively. Substantial amounts of excimer formation are observed for apo-CaM prior to peptide association, indicating that interdomain interactions occur in solution. Calcium binding results in a large and highly cooperative reduction in the level of excimer formation; its calcium dependence coincides with the occupancy of C-terminal sites. These results indicate that interdomain interactions between the opposing domains of CaM occur in solution and that the occupancy of C-terminal calcium binding sites is necessary for the structural coupling between the opposing domains associated with the stabilization of the interdomain linker to enhance target protein binding.     

Use of engineered proteins with internal tryptophan reporter groups and pertubation techniques to probe the mechanism of ligand-protein interactions: investigation of the mechanism of calcium binding to calmodulin.

Stopped-flow kinetic and fluorescence spectroscopic analyses, including solvent and temperature perturbations, of five isofunctional structural mutants of calmodulin indicate that calcium binding to calmodulin follows the order site III, site IV, site I, site II, with dissociation occurring in the reverse order. Each of the isofunctional structural mutants contains a single tryptophan residue, introduced by site-specific mutagenesis, as an internal spectroscopic reporter group that was used as a probe of local conformational change. Calcium binding was studied by using flow dialysis or by using fluorescence spectroscopy and monitoring the change in the single tryptophan residue in each calcium-binding site. Calcium removal was examined by using EDTA and monitoring tryptophan fluorescence or by using Quin 2 and monitoring the change in the chromophoric chelator. Computational analysis of the data suggests a rate-limiting step for dissociation between calcium removal from sites I/II and sites III/IV. Unexpected results with the site IV isofunctional mutant (Q135W-CaM) indicated cross-talk between the amino and carboxyl terminal halves of CaM during the calcium-binding mechanism. Studies with ethylene glycol provided empirical data that suggest the functional importance of the electrostatic potential of CaM, or the molarity of water, in the calcium-binding process. Altogether, the data allowed a kinetic extension of the sequential, cooperative model for calcium binding to calmodulin and provided values for additional parameters in the model of calcium binding to CaM, a prototypical member of the family of proteins required for calcium signal transduction in eukaryotic cells.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

A flagellum-specific calcium sensor

The flagellar calcium-binding protein (FCaBP) of the flagellated protozoan Trypanosoma cruzi associates with the flagellar membrane via its N-terminal myristate and palmitate moieties in a calcium-modulated, conformation-dependent manner. This mechanism of localization is similar to that described for neuronal calcium sensors, which undergo calcium-dependent changes in conformation, which modulate the availability of the acyl groups for membrane interaction and partner association. To test whether FCaBP undergoes a calcium-dependent conformational change and to explore the role of such a change in flagellar targeting, we first introduced point mutations into each of the two EF-hand calcium-binding sites of FCaBP to define their affinities. Analysis of recombinant EF-3 mutant (E151Q), EF-4 mutant (E188Q), and double mutant proteins showed EF-3 to be the high affinity site (Kd approximately 9 microM) and EF-4 the low affinity site (Kd approximately 120 microM). These assignments also correlated with partial (E188Q), nearly complete (E151Q), and complete (E151Q,E188Q) disruption of calcium-induced conformational changes determined by NMR spectrometry. We next expressed the FCaBP E151Q mutant and the double mutant in T. cruzi epimastigotes. These transproteins localized to the flagellum, suggesting the existence of a calcium-dependent interaction of FCaBP that is independent of its intrinsic calcium binding capacity. Several proteins were identified by FCaBP affinity chromatography that interact with FCaBP in a calcium-dependent manner, but with differential dependence on calcium-binding by FCaBP. These findings may have broader implications for the calcium acyl switch mechanism of protein regulation.     

Allosteric effects of the antipsychotic drug trifluoperazine on the energetics of calcium binding by calmodulin

Trifluoperazine (TFP; Stelazine?) is an antagonist of calmodulin (CaM), an essential regulator of calcium‐dependent signal transduction. Reports differ regarding whether, or where, TFP binds to apo CaM. Three crystallographic structures (1CTR, 1A29, and 1LIN) show TFP bound to (Ca²⁺)₄‐CaM in ratios of 1, 2, or 4 TFP per CaM. In all of these, CaM domains adopt the “open” conformation seen in CaM‐kinase complexes having increased calcium affinity. Most reports suggest TFP also increases calcium affinity of CaM. To compare TFP binding to apo CaM and (Ca²⁺)₄‐CaM and explore differential effects on the N‐ and C‐domains of CaM, stoichiometric TFP titrations of CaM were monitored by ¹⁵N‐HSQC NMR. Two TFP bound to apo CaM, whereas four bound to (Ca²⁺)₄‐CaM. In both cases, the preferred site was in the C‐domain. During the titrations, biphasic responses for some resonances suggested intersite interactions. TFP‐binding sites in apo CaM appeared distinct from those in (Ca²⁺)₄‐CaM. In equilibrium calcium titrations at defined ratios of TFP:CaM, TFP reduced calcium affinity at most levels tested; this is similar to the effect of many IQ‐motifs on CaM. However, at the highest level tested, TFP raised the calcium affinity of the N‐domain of CaM. A model of conformational switching is proposed to explain how TFP can exert opposing allosteric effects on calcium affinity by binding to different sites in the “closed,” “semi‐open,” and “open” domains of CaM. In physiological processes, apo CaM, as well as (Ca²⁺)₄‐CaM, needs to be considered a potential target of drug action. Proteins 2010. © 2010 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Sequential binding of calcium leads to dimerization in neural cadherin

Neural cadherin (N-cadherin) is a calcium-dependent homophilic cell-adhesive molecule and critical for synaptogenesis and synapse maintenance. The extracellular region plays an important role in cadherin-mediated cell adhesion and has five tandemly repeated ectodomains (EC1-EC5) with three calcium-binding sites situated between each of these domains. Adhesive dimer formation is significantly dependent on binding of calcium such that mutations in the calcium-binding sites adversely affect cell adhesion. To investigate the relative significance of the calcium-binding sites at the EC1-EC2 interface in calcium-induced dimerization, we mutated three important amino acids, D134, D136, and D103, in NCAD12, a construct containing EC1 and EC2. Spectroscopic and chromatographic experiments showed that all three mutations affected calcium binding and dimerization. Mutation of D134, a bidentate chelator in site 3, severely impaired the binding of calcium to all three sites. These findings confirm that binding to site 3 is required for binding to occur at site 2 and site 1. Interestingly, while the D103A mutation diminished only the affinity for calcium, it completely eliminated dimerization. Equilibrium dialysis experiments showed a stoichiometry of 3 at 2 mM calcium for D103A, but no dimerization was apparent even at 10 mM calcium. These results indicate that calcium binding alone is not sufficient for dimerization but requires cooperativity between calcium-binding sites. In summary, our findings confirm that the calcium-binding sites are occupied sequentially in the order of site 3, then site 2 and site 1, and that cooperativity between site 2 and site 1 is essential for formation of adhesive dimers by N-cadherin.     

Protein conformational changes studied by diffusion NMR spectroscopy: application to helix-loop-helix calcium binding proteins

Pulsed-field gradient (PFG) diffusion NMR spectroscopy studies were conducted with several helix-loop-helix regulatory Ca(2+)-binding proteins to characterize the conformational changes associated with Ca(2+)-saturation and/or binding targets. The calmodulin (CaM) system was used as a basis for evaluation, with similar hydrodynamic radii (R(h)) obtained for apo- and Ca(2+)-CaM, consistent with previously reported R(h) data. In addition, conformational changes associated with CaM binding to target peptides from myosin light chain kinase (MLCK), phosphodiesterase (PDE), and simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV) were accurately determined compared with small-angle X-ray scattering results. Both sets of data demonstrate the well-established collapse of the extended Ca(2+)-CaM molecule into a globular complex upon peptide binding. The R(h) of CaM complexes with target peptides from CaM-dependent protein kinase I (CaMKI) and an N-terminal portion of the SIV peptide (SIV-N), as well as the anticancer drug cisplatin were also determined. The CaMKI complex demonstrates a collapse analogous to that observed for MLCK, PDE, and SIV, while the SIV-N shows only a partial collapse. Interestingly, the covalent CaM-cisplatin complex shows a near complete collapse, not expected from previous studies. The method was extended to related calcium binding proteins to show that the R(h) of calcium and integrin binding protein (CIB), calbrain, and the calcium-binding region from soybean calcium-dependent protein kinase (CDPK) decrease on Ca(2+)-binding to various extents. Heteronuclear NMR spectroscopy suggests that for CIB and calbrain this is likely because of shifting the equilibrium from unfolded to folded conformations, with calbrain forming a dimer structure. These results demonstrate the utility of PFG-diffusion NMR to rapidly and accurately screen for molecular size changes on protein-ligand and protein-protein interactions for this class of proteins.     

Calcium-induced conformational switching of Paramecium calmodulin provides evidence for domain coupling

Calmodulin (CaM) is an intracellular calcium-binding protein essential for many pathways in eukaryotic signal transduction. Although a structure of Ca(2+)-saturated Paramecium CaM at 1.0 A resolution (1EXR.pdb) provides the highest level of detail about side-chain orientations in CaM, information about an end state alone cannot explain driving forces for the transitions that occur during Ca(2+)-induced conformational switching and why the two domains of CaM are saturated sequentially rather than simultaneously. Recent studies focus attention on the contributions of interdomain linker residues. Electron paramagnetic resonance showed that Ca(2+)-induced structural stabilization of residues 76-81 modulates domain coupling [Qin and Squier (2001) Biophys. J. 81, 2908-2918]. Studies of N-domain fragments of Paramecium CaM showed that residues 76-80 increased thermostability of the N-domain but lowered the Ca(2+) affinity of sites I and II [Sorensen et al. (2002) Biochemistry 41, 15-20]. To probe domain coupling during Ca(2+) binding, we have used (1)H-(15)N HSQC NMR to monitor more than 40 residues in Paramecium CaM. The titrations demonstrated that residues Glu78 to Glu84 (in the linker and cap of helix E) underwent sequential phases of conformational change. Initially, they changed in volume (slow exchange) as sites III and IV titrated, and subsequently, they changed in frequency (fast exchange) as sites I and II titrated. These studies provide evidence for Ca(2+)-dependent communication between the domains, demonstrating that spatially distant residues respond to Ca(2+) binding at sites I and II in the N-domain of CaM.     

Activation of the edema factor of Bacillus anthracis by calmodulin: evidence of an interplay between the EF-calmodulin interaction and calcium binding

Calmodulin (CaM) is a remarkably flexible protein which can bind multiple targets in response to changes in intracellular calcium concentration. It contains four calcium-binding sites, arranged in two globular domains. The calcium affinity of CaM N-terminal domain (N-CaM) is dramatically reduced when the complex with the edema factor (EF) of Bacillus anthracis is formed. Here, an atomic explanation for this reduced affinity is proposed through molecular dynamics simulations and free energy perturbation calculations of the EF-CaM complex starting from different crystallographic models. The simulations show that electrostatic interactions between CaM and EF disfavor the opening of N-CaM domains usually induced by calcium binding. Relative calcium affinities of the N-CaM binding sites are probed by free energy perturbation, and dissociation probabilities are evaluated with locally enhanced sampling simulations. We show that EF impairs calcium binding on N-CaM through a direct conformational restraint on Site 1, by an indirect destabilization of Site 2, and by reducing the cooperativity between the two sites.     

Retention of Conformational Entropy upon Calmodulin Binding to Target Peptides Is Driven by Transient Salt Bridges

Calmodulin (CaM) is a highly flexible calcium-binding protein that mediates signal transduction through an ability to differentially bind to highly variable binding sequences in target proteins. To identify how binding affects CaM motions, and its relationship to conformational entropy and target peptide sequence, we have employed fully atomistic, explicit solvent molecular dynamics simulations of unbound CaM and CaM bound to five different target peptides. The calculated CaM conformational binding entropies correlate with experimentally derived conformational entropies with a correlation coefficient R² of 0.95. Selected side-chain interactions with target peptides restrain interhelical loop motions, acting to tune the conformational entropy of the bound complex via widely distributed CaM motions. In the complex with the most conformational entropy retention (CaM in complex with the neuronal nitric oxide synthase binding sequence), Lys-148 at the C-terminus of CaM forms transient salt bridges alternating between Glu side chains in the N-domain, the central linker, and the binding target. Additional analyses of CaM structures, fluctuations, and CaM-target interactions illuminate the interplay between electrostatic, side chain, and backbone properties in the ability of CaM to recognize and discriminate against targets by tuning its conformational entropy, and suggest a need to consider conformational dynamics in optimizing binding affinities.     

Helix A stabilization precedes amino-terminal lobe activation upon calcium binding to calmodulin

The structural coupling between opposing domains of CaM was investigated using the conformationally sensitive biarsenical probe 4,5-bis(1,3,2-dithioarsolan-2-yl)resorufin (ReAsH), which upon binding to an engineered tetracysteine motif near the end of helix A (Thr-5 to Phe-19) becomes highly fluorescent. Changes in conformation and dynamics are reflective of the native CaM structure, as there is no change in the (1)H- (15)N HSQC NMR spectrum in comparison to wild-type CaM. We find evidence of a conformational intermediate associated with CaM activation, where calcium occupancy of sites in the amino-terminal and carboxyl-terminal lobes of CaM differentially affect the fluorescence intensity of bound ReAsH. Insight into the structure of the conformational intermediate is possible from a consideration of calcium-dependent changes in rates of ReAsH binding and helix A mobility, which respectively distinguish secondary structural changes associated with helix A stabilization from the tertiary structural reorganization of the amino-terminal lobe of CaM necessary for high-affinity binding to target proteins. Helix A stabilization is associated with calcium occupancy of sites in the carboxyl-terminal lobe ( K d = 0.36 +/- 0.04 microM), which results in a reduction in the rate of ReAsH binding from 4900 M (-1) s (-1) to 370 M (-1) s (-1). In comparison, tertiary structural changes involving helix A and other structural elements in the amino-terminal lobe require calcium occupancy of amino-terminal sites (K d = 18 +/- 3 microM). Observed secondary and tertiary structural changes involving helix A in response to the sequential calcium occupancy of carboxyl- and amino-terminal lobe calcium binding sites suggest an important involvement of helix A in mediating the structural coupling between the opposing domains of CaM. These results are discussed in terms of a model in which carboxyl-terminal lobe calcium activation induces secondary structural changes within the interdomain linker that release helix A, thereby facilitating the formation of calcium binding sites in the amino-terminal lobe and linked tertiary structural rearrangements to form a high-affinity binding cleft that can associate with target proteins.