Neurobiological correlates premeditated (learned) aggression: seeking new experimental approaches]

Theoretical possibility of experimental modeling of learned (premediated) aggression developing in human after experience of aggression is considered. The sensory contact technique increases aggressiveness in male mice and allows aggressive type of behavior to be formed as a result of repeated experience of victories in daily agonistic confrontations. Some behavioral domains confirm the development of learned aggression in males similar to those in humans. The features are: repeated experience of aggression reinforced by victories; elements of learned behavior after period of confrontations; intent, measured by increase of the aggressive motivation prior agonistic confrontation; decreased emotionality estimated by parameters of open field behavior. Relevant stimuli provoke demonstration of aggression. This review summarized data on the influence of positive fighting experience in daily intermale confrontations on the behavior, neurochemistry and physiology of aggressive mice (winners). This sort of experience changes many characteristics in individual and social behaviors, these having been estimated in different tests and in varied situations. Some physiological parameters are also changed in the winners. Neurochemical data confirm the activation of brain dopaminergic systems and functional inhibition of serotonergic system in winners under influence of repeated experience of aggression. The expression of the neurochemical and behavioral changes observed in winners has been found dependent on the mouse strain and on the duration of their agonistic confrontations. Similarities in mechanisms of learned aggression in humans and mice are considered.     

Effects of a short period of isolation in adulthood on the aggressive behavior of dominant and subordinate male mice

Male ddY mice were used to investigate the effect of a short period of isolation in adulthood on aggressive behavior. The relationship between the dominance status previous to isolation and the effect of isolation was investigated. The mice were kept in isolation for 3 weeks from 9 weeks of age, during which intruder tests were conducted once a week. They the went through an encounter test, in which the mice encountered dominant or subordinate mice in a neutral space. The number of the formerly-dominant isolated mice that attacked the intruder mice decreased at first and then increased. The latency to attack also lengthened at first and then shortened. Seven former-dominants continued to show aggression throughout the intruder The number of the formerly-subordinate isolated mice that attacked the intruder mice increased linearly. But 3 former-subordinates did not show aggression through the entire experiment. After 3 weeks isolation, the number of mice that showed aggression and the amount of aggression did not differ between the former-dominants and subordinatcs. Isolation housing was concluded to differentially affect the dominant and subordinate mice during the 3 weeks of isolation. It was also concluded to differentially affect the mice of absolute dominance and relative dominance differentially. The aggressive behavior of the isolated mice appears to occur independently of site.     

Sex-differences in the Agonistic Behavior of Spiny-mice (Acomys cahirinus)

Observations of 8 groups each containing three adult spiny mice (Acomys cahirinus) revealed that instances of chasing and physical displacement were quite common, while fighting and biting were rarely observed. The relationships between the most frequent behavioral categories were presented in a correlation matrix. In a second, study, ♀♀ tested in their home cages were dominant over ♂♂ In the ♂♂ home cages, however, no differences in the frequency of ♀ vs. ♂ aggression were observed. More instances of aggression were observed in the cages of the ♀♀ than in the cages of the ♂♂.     

Genotype/age interactions on aggressive behavior in gonadally intact estrogen receptor beta knockout (betaERKO) male mice

Estrogen, as an aromatized metabolite of testosterone, has a facilitatory effect on male aggressive behavior in mice. Two subtypes of estrogen receptors, alpha (ER-alpha) and beta (ER-beta), in the brain are known to bind estrogen. Previous studies revealed that the lack of ER-alpha gene severely reduced the induction of male aggressive behavior. In contrast, mice that lacked the ER-beta gene tended to be more aggressive than wild type (WT) control mice, although the behavioral effects of ER-beta gene disruption were dependent on their social experience. These findings lead us to hypothesize that estrogen may facilitate aggression via ER-alpha whereas it may inhibit aggression via ER-beta. In the present study, we further investigated the role of ER-beta in the regulation of aggressive behavior by examining developmental changes starting at the time of first onset, around the age of puberty. Aggressive behaviors of ER-beta gene knockout (betaERKO) mice were examined in three different age groups, puberty, young-adult, and adult. Each mouse was tested every other day for three times in a resident-intruder paradigm against olfactory bulbectomized intruder mice and their trunk blood was collected for measurements of serum testosterone after the completion of the study. Overall, betaERKO mice were significantly more aggressive than WT. These genotype differences were more pronounced in puberty and young adult age groups, but not apparent in the adult age group, in which betaERKO mice were less aggressive than those in two younger age groups. Serum testosterone levels of betaERKO mice were significantly higher than those of WT mice only in the pubertal age group, but not in young adult (when betaERKO mice were still significantly more aggressive than WT mice) and adult (when no genotype differences in aggression were found) age groups. These results suggest that ER-beta mediated actions of gonadal steroids may more profoundly be involved in the inhibitory regulation of aggressive behavior in pubertal and young adult mice.     

Testosterone in juvenile and adolescent male chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes): effects of dominance rank, aggression, and behavioral style

Testosterone is a steroid hormone with diverse effects on male reproductive function and behavior. The relationship between testosterone and social behavior such as mating and aggression has been investigated in a variety of primate species, but few such studies have been conducted on chimpanzees, and even fewer on primates during the juvenile and adolescent periods. This study explores the relationship between baseline urinary testosterone and behavioral variables including dominance rank, rates of aggression toward peers, and behavioral style in 16 juvenile and adolescent male chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes) living at the New Iberia Research Center in Louisiana. Behavioral observations and urine collection occurred during four research periods, each a year apart. After correcting for the positive association between testosterone and age, testosterone was positively associated with both dominance rank and rates of aggression directed at others. It was negatively associated with rates of aggression received. Individuals scoring highest in the "mellow" behavioral style component showed higher levels of testosterone than individuals scoring lowest in this component, an effect that may be partially due to the confounding effect of rank. The results of this study suggest that hormonal changes during the period preceding adulthood are not simply programmed physiological processes tied primarily to age-related change, but that important age-independent relationships with behavior also exist.     

Endocrine correlates of rank,reproduction, and female-directed aggression in male Japanese macaques (Macaca fuscata)

Fecal testosterone and cortisol levels in six wild male Japanese macaques (Macaca fuscata), three of high rank and three of low, were analyzed to investigate the hormonal correlates of rank, reproduction, and female-directed aggression. The study encompassed the 6-month mating season, from October 1999 to March 2000, during which time 251 fecal samples and approximately 550 h of behavioral data were collected. Dominant males were not found to differ from subordinate males in overall rates of aggressive or copulatory behavior. Likewise, testosterone excretion, which peaked in the early part of the mating season and declined gradually thereafter, did not differ significantly by rank. High-ranking males, however, were observed to excrete significantly higher levels of cortisol than low-ranking males, suggesting that dominance may carry costs. The two hormones were found to be inversely correlated in the two most dominant males, but independent in all others. Rate of noncontact aggression was significantly correlated with testosterone, while no significant relationships were observed between testosterone and contact aggression nor any aspect of copulatory behavior. These data further support the contention that social subordinance and stress are not inexorably linked, as well as suggest that elevated glucocorticoid concentrations in high-ranking males may reflect increased metabolic costs associated with dominant male reproductive strategy.     

Isolation effect in mice (Mus musculus): (i) Does it really induce aggression?

In previous studies, isolated mice are found to be extremely more aggressive than group-reared mice. In most of those studies, however, the pairings of the group-reared mice were randomly determined, without attention to individuals' ranks in their home cages. In this study, the effect of isolation was analyzed by comparing isolated mice with dominants of group-reared mice. In experiment 1 the group-reared mice were randomly chosen as in previous studies. Isolated mice were significantly more aggressive, but the pairings of the group-reared mice were found to be all dominant vs. subordinate. In experiment 2, the group-reared dominants encountered unfamiliar dominants in an unfamiliar place. Dominant mice were found to be less aggressive than the isolated mice. This result was inconsistent with the “territorial dominant hypothesis” on the hyperaggressiveness of the isolated mice. Sequential analysis of behavior clarified that the isolated mice had a sequential pattern quite different from the group-reared mice, and provided an illustrative figure for the “escalation hypothesis”. The lack of aggression in the group-reared mice, however, left a question about the sequence similarity of aggressive behavior in isolaed and group-reared mice.     

Aggression and fitness differences between plumage morphs in the common buzzard (Buteo buteo)

Genetic plumage polymorphism in birds is increasingly recognizedas a potentially important trait influencing birds’ lifehistories. In the common buzzard Buteo buteo, the 3 color morphsvary in lifetime reproductive success (LRS), but the proximatemechanisms leading to these differences are unknown. We firstconfirmed the stability of the fitness differences found previously,using a greatly extended LRS data set. To find potential causesfor these differences, we experimentally studied variation inaggressive behavior of the morphs, both against an interspecificpredator and intraspecific competitors. The morphs showed substantialvariation in aggressive behavior. Light-colored males were mostaggressive toward an interspecific predator, followed by intermediateand dark males. In females, this pattern was reversed, resultingin sex-related differences of aggression in 2 morphs. When defendingtheir territory against intraspecific competitors, no absolutedifference in aggression was found, but the morphs reacted strongesttoward intruders of a morph similar to their own. This suggeststhat aggression differs both between and within morphs, leadingto a complex pattern on the population level. Coupled with thestrong fitness differences, our results suggest that the geneticbasis of the polymorphism has far-reaching behavioral consequences.     

Social dominance in male vasopressin 1b receptor knockout mice

We have previously reported that mice with a targeted disruption of their vasopressin 1b receptor gene, Avpr1b, have mild impairments in social recognition and reduced aggression. The reductions in aggression are limited to social forms of aggression, i.e., maternal and inter-male aggression, while predatory aggression remains unaffected. To further clarify the role of the Avpr1b in the regulation of social behavior we first examined anxiety-like and depression-like behaviors in Avpr1b knockout (Avpr1b −/−) mice. We then went on to test the ability of Avpr1b −/− mice to form dominance hierarchies. No major differences were found between Avpr1b −/− and wildtype mice in anxiety-like behaviors, as measured using an elevated plus maze and an open field test, or depression-like behaviors, as measured using a forced swim test. In the social dominance study we found that Avpr1b −/− mice are able to form dominance hierarchies, though in early hierarchy formation dominant Avpr1b −/− mice display significantly more mounting behavior on Day 1 of testing compared to wildtype controls. Further, non-socially dominant Avpr1b −/− mice spend less time engaged in attack behavior than wildtype controls. These findings suggest that while Avpr1b −/− mice may be able to form dominance hierarchies they appear to employ alternate strategies.     

Phenotypic instability between the near isogenic substrains BALB/cJ and BALB/cByJ

Closely related substrains of inbred mice often show phenotypic differences that are presumed to be caused by recent mutations. The substrains BALB/cJ and BALB/cByJ, which were separated in 1935, have been reported to show numerous highly significant behavioral and morphological differences. In an effort to identify some of the causal mutations, we phenotyped BALB/cJ and BALB/cByJ mice as well as their F1, F2, and N2 progeny for behavioral and morphological phenotypes. We also generated whole-genome sequence data for both inbred strains (~3.5× coverage) with the intention of identifying polymorphic markers to be used for linkage analysis. We observed significant differences in body weight, the weight of the heart, liver, spleen and brain, and corpus callosum length between the two substrains. We also observed that BALB/cJ animals showed greater anxiety-like behavior in the open field test, less depression-like behavior in the tail suspension test, and reduced aggression compared to BALB/cByJ mice. Some but not all of these physiological and behavioral results were inconsistent with prior publications. These inconsistencies led us to suspect that the differences were due to, or modified by, non-genetic factors. Thus, we did not perform linkage analysis. We provide a comprehensive summary of the prior literature about phenotypic differences between these substrains as well as our current findings. We conclude that many differences between these strains are unstable and therefore ill-suited to linkage analysis; the source of this instability is unclear. We discuss the broader implications of these observations for the design of future studies.     

Variation in steroid hormone levels among Caribbean Anolis lizards: Endocrine system convergence?

Variation in aggression among species can be due to a number of proximate and ultimate factors, leading to patterns of divergent and convergent evolution of behavior among even closely related species. Caribbean Anolis lizards are well known for their convergence in microhabitat use and morphology, but they also display marked convergence in social behavior and patterns of aggression. We studied 18 Anolis species across six ecomorphs on four different Caribbean islands to test four main hypotheses. We hypothesized that species differences in aggression would be due to species differences in circulating testosterone (T), a steroid hormone implicated in numerous studies across vertebrate taxa as a primary determinant of social behavior; more aggressive species were expected to have higher baseline concentrations of T and corticosterone. We further hypothesized that low-T species would increase T and corticosterone levels during a social challenge. Within three of the four island assemblages studied we found differences in T levels among species within an island that differ in aggression, but in the opposite pattern than predicted: more aggressive species had lower baseline T than the least aggressive species. The fourth island, Puerto Rico, showed the pattern of baseline T levels among species we predicted. There were no patterns of corticosterone levels among species or ecomorphs. One of the two species tested increased T in response to a social challenge, but neither species elevated corticosterone. Our results suggest that it is possible for similarities in aggression among closely related species to evolve via different proximate mechanisms.     

Issues in Bonobo (Pan paniscus) Sexual Behavior

Sexual behavior is one of the reported similarities between Pan paniscus and Homo sapiens that has stimulated recent interest in the phylogeny of the Pan and the Australopithecus/Homo genera. Similarities do exist, but an understanding of the forms and functions of Van paniscus sexual behavior is best achieved through a comparison to Pan troglodytes. Pan paniscus shows increased female receptivity, variability in copulatory position, male or female initiation of sexual behavior, differential male and female preferences for copulatory position, and association of food sharing and sexual behavior. Their sexual behavior appears to function in proximate terms as a tension-reduction mechanism. Lowered tension, in turn, facilitates multi-male, multi-female social groups. Lowered levels of aggression and increased sexual activity appear to be associated with paedomorphism, and the behavioral and anatomical/physiological characteristics of the species appear to be a consequence of a feeding ecology that promotes large groupings of the animals at preferential and comparatively rich feeding sites.     

The role of progesterone in pregnancy-induced aggression in mice

A series of six experiments was performed in order to explore the potential involvement of progesterone (P) in pregnancy-induced aggression (PIA) displayed by Rockland-Swiss mice toward adult male intruders. In Experiment 1, circulating levels of P and aggression were low on gestation Days 6 and 10 while both the behavior and the steroid reached peak levels by gestation Day 14. By gestation Day 18 (the day prior to parturition), serum P was at its lowest level yet aggressive behavior was still intense. Also, individual differences in the display of fighting behavior by pregnant females were not related to circulating P. Experiments 2 and 3 showed that supplemental P treatment to early pregnant female mice did not advance the onset of aggression. Experiment 4 showed that P treatment promoted the onset and elevated the incidence of aggression in virgin mice, but only in those females with intact ovaries. Experiment 5 showed that the aggressive behavior of P-stimulated virgin females was qualitatively and quantitatively different from that exhibited by pregnant mice in that the former exhibited fewer attacks and lunges than the latter. Finally, Experiment 6 showed that the removal of P from aggressive, P-stimulated virgins dramatically attenuated levels of the behavior. This contrasts sharply with the continued fighting behavior observed in late pregnant P-deficient mice. Thus, although P augments aggression in female mice it apparently is not a sufficient stimulus for producing pregnancy-like aggressive behavior.     

Nongenomic effects of estradiol on aggression under short day photoperiods

In several vertebrate species, the effects of estrogens on male aggressive behavior can be modulated by environmental cues. In song sparrows and rodents, estrogens modulate aggression in the nonbreeding season or winter-like short days, respectively. The behavioral effects of estrogens are rapid, which generally is considered indicative of nongenomic processes. The current study further examined the hypothesis that estradiol acts nongenomically under short days by utilizing a protein synthesis inhibitor, cycloheximide (CX). Mice were housed in either short or long day photoperiods, and treated with an aromatase inhibitor. One hour before resident–intruder testing mice were injected with either CX or saline vehicle, and 30 min later were treated orally with either cyclodextrin conjugated estradiol or vehicle. Under short days, mice treated with estradiol showed a rapid decrease in aggressive behavior, independent of CX administration. CX alone had no effect on aggression. These results show that protein synthesis is not required for the rapid effects of estradiol on aggression, strongly suggesting that these effects are mediated by nongenomic processes. We also showed that estradiol suppressed c-fos immunoreactivity in the caudal bed nucleus of the stria terminalis under short days. No effects of estradiol on behavior or c-fos expression were observed in mice housed under long days. Previously we had also demonstrated that cage bedding influenced the directional effects of estrogens on aggression. Here, we show that the phenomenon of rapid action of estradiol on aggression under short days is a robust result that generalizes to different bedding conditions.     

Adult-young interactions in island and mainland populations of the deermouse Peromyscus maniculatus

Summary The demographic and ecological characteristics of island populations of small mammals have received increasing attention in recent years, but few studies have compared the behavioral characteristics of island populations with those of mainland populations. Behavior is considered an important variable because it is believed by many to be a crucial factor affecting the population dynamics and demography of natural populations. In particular, among many species of rodents, the social behavior of adults towards juveniles is cited as an important factor influencing dispersal patterns and population regulation. The present study compares social interactions between adults and juveniles of island and mainland populations of the deermouse Peromyscus maniculatus, and attempts to relate differences in behavior to the demographic differences between the two populations. Adult mice were trapped on the mainland of British Columbia and on one of the Gulf Islands off the British Columbia coast, and allowed to breed in the laboratory. Male and female juveniles from both populations were then tested with their own parents and with unrelated male and female adults. The results demonstrate that island adults show almost no aggression towards either own or unrelated young. Mainland adults likewise show little aggression towards their own young, but a proportion of the population, consisting of both male and female adults, shows severe aggression towards unrelated juveniles of both sexes. These results suggest four major conclusions: 1) behavior may be the mechanism responsible for the demographic differences reported for these island and mainland populations; 2) female aggression may be a more important factor in deermouse population dynamics than has been previously recognized; 3) since parents show little aggression towards their own young, adult aggression may be a significant factor in juvenile mortality and emigration only after juveniles have initiated dispersal away from their natal sites; and 4) adult aggression controls the number of both male and female juveniles which are recruited into the population.     

Vasopressin and aggression in cross-fostered California mice (Peromyscus californicus) and white-footed mice (Peromyscus leucopus)

To examine how developmental experiences alter neural pathways associated with adult social behavior, we cross-fostered pups between the more aggressive and monogamous California mouse (Peromyscus californicus) and the less aggressive and polygamous white-footed mouse (P. leucopus). Cross-fostered males became more like their foster parents when tested as adults. Male white-footed mice became more aggressive only in an aggression test in a neutral arena, whereas the territorial California mice became less aggressive in resident-intruder aggression test, as measured by attack latency. Only the species that displayed a change in resident-intruder aggression showed a change in arginine vasopressin (AVP) levels: cross-fostered California mice had significantly lower levels of AVP-immunoreactive (AVP-ir) staining than controls in the bed nucleus of the stria terminalis (BNST) and the supraoptic nucleus (SON) and a nonsignificant trend toward lower levels in the medial amygdala (MA). Neither species showed changes in AVP-ir staining in a control area, the paraventricular nucleus (PVN). The changes in AVP-ir staining in the BNST and SON may not be caused by stress because cross-fostering was not associated with changes in adult plasma concentrations of two steroid hormones, corticosterone and testosterone, that have been associated with stress-related alterations in AVP pathways. These results suggest that manipulating the early parental environment can directly alter both a neurotransmitter system and species-typical patterns of social behavior, but that these effects may vary between species and under different social contexts.     

Prolyl-leucyl-glycinamide (PLG): inhibition of offensive aggression in mice

The effects on offensive aggression of the endogenous peptide-leucyl-glycinamide (PLG, MIF-1) and the exogenous opiate antagonist, naloxone, were examined in male mice. PLG (0.01-10 mg/Kg) reduced, in a dose-dependent manner, the incidence and intensity of offensive aggression in dominant resident mice. PLG was more potent than naloxone (1.0 mg/Kg). In a number of cases, PLG completely eliminated the display of offensive aggression towards intruder mice. These results raise the possibility that PLG may function as an "anti-aggressive" peptide whose actions may include antagonistic and/or modulatory influences on both opioid and non-opioid systems.     

The effect of DAGO,selective milli-opioid receptor agonist,on hostile and anxious behaviors in male mice with different experience of aggression

Effects of mu-opioid receptor agonist DAGO (2.0 mg/kg, s.c.) on anxioUs, hostile, and aggressive behaviors of male mice with repeated 3- and 20-day experience of aggression accompanied by victories (T3 and T20 winners, respectively) were stUdied. T20 winners showed lower aggression (attacking and biting) and hostile behavior and were more anxioUs (estimated by plUs-maze test) than T3 winners. In the plUs-maze test DAGO prodUced anxiogenic effects in intact males and was ineffective in T3 and T20 winners testifying to a decrease in mu-receptor sensitivity Under the inflUence of repeated aggression. In agonistic confrontation test, DAGO increased aggressive grooming in T20 winners, decreased hostile behavior (digging and throwing partner's litter) in T3 winners, and did not inflUence attacks in both groUps. It is sUggested that mu-opioid receptors are involved into forming the aggressive behavioral type in mice, and DAGO effects may be conditioned by emotional backgroUnd of these behavioral forms.     

Long‐term monitoring of social behavior in a grouping of six female tigers (Panthera tigris)

Although literature on the reproduction of captive tigers is plentiful, there is little information on other social behaviors, particularly within large social groupings. Here we report on the long‐term monitoring of social behaviors in six female tigers (Panthera tigris). Over a period of 6 years, behavioral data were collected on spraying, vocalizations, non‐contact aggression, and contact aggression during outdoor observations, as well as nearest neighbors in the morning, as a proxy measure of affiliation. Regression analyses showed that non‐contact aggression and vocalizing were increasing, whereas spraying and social proximity were decreasing over the 6 years of the study. Paired t‐tests showed no seasonal differences in aggression, but animals had higher social proximity scores during the mornings of the colder winter months. Correlations showed that spraying was positively related to contact aggression whereas social proximity was negatively correlated with non‐contact aggression. In addition to documenting levels of contact and non‐contact aggression over time, this study showed these behaviors correlated with behaviors that were more easily scored (spraying and social proximity). Behavioral monitoring has played a key role in the management and husbandry of this large social grouping of female tigers. In addition to providing keepers with the opportunity to observe their animals in regularly scheduled sessions, behavioral monitoring has provided baseline information on social relationships in this grouping over time. If future research validates the relationship between aggression and spraying/social proximity, this can be a valuable tool for long‐term monitoring of groups of tigers. Zoo Biol 27:89–99, 2008. © 2007 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Environmental enrichment for captive stumptail macaques (Macaca arctoides)

Background  The behavior of animals is modified by captivity. Environmental enrichment (EE) is a program designed to enhance the welfare of confined animals by providing them with a more stimulating background. This is carried out by the implementation of a series of activities that encourages them to present behaviors typical of their species, as well as keeps them active. The aim of this study was the evaluation of the influence of the EE in the behavioral variables in a colony of 24 stumptail macaques ( Macaca arctoides ). Our hypothesis is that the application of this program will reduce aggression, stereotypes and coprophilia behaviors and, at the same time, will increase exploration and solitary play.
Methods  The behavioral frequency previous to EE was compared with that during EE implementation.
Results  Our results showed that aggression, coprophilia stereotypic behaviors and social play were significantly reduced during EE, whereas exploration was significantly enhanced. The response of the individuals according to gender was similar for both sexes.
Conclusions  Environmental enrichment programs are indispensable for captive animals' wellbeing as they reduce aggression and stress while providing animals both physical and cognitive entertainment.