Silver-enhanced colloidal gold probes as markers for scanning electron microscopy

Summary Silver enlargement of small colloidal gold particles has been extensively used for the light microscopical visualization of gold probes. Very recently, a few investigators have employed physical developers in electron microscopy (both pre-embedding and on-grid staining methods). We now demonstrate that physical development of small colloidal gold particles advantageously can be exploited for labelling biological surfaces in scanning electron microscopy. This novel application of silver enhancement of colloidal gold particles is characterized by a high detection efficiency. Thus, specimens are labelled with small gold probes affording high immunocytochemical efficiency but being impossible to detect with the present scanning microscopes. These particles are subsequently scanning electronmicro-scopically visualized by silver enhancement.Presented in part at the International Symposium on Biological Regulation of Cell Proliferation, 9th International Chalone Conference, Milano, Italy, March 3–6, 1986     

Silver enhancement of protein A-gold probes on resin-embedded ultrathin sections. An electron microscopic localization of mouse mammary tumor virus (MMTV) antigens

A simple method is described allowing the enhancement of the visibility of small gold probes for the electron microscopy. This method, which allows the silver intensification of gold directly on epon-embedded ultrathin sections, was used for the electron microscopic localization of Mouse Mammary Tumor Virus (MMTV) antigens in cultured cells derived from GR and BALB/cfRIII mouse mammary tumors. After the immunostaining with the preembedding protein A-gold technique, the ultrathin sections, placed on 200 mesh copper grids, were rehydrated and exposed to a photographic developer containing silver nitrate. During this physical development gold particles are incapsulated in growing shells of metallic silver, which gradually become more and more visible. We were able to obtain a heavy labelling of the viral particles, well visible even at low magnification, with a negligeable background staining. The present technique can be useful whenever it is necessary to use the smallest gold probes today available.     

Silver enhancement of lectin-gold and enzyme-gold cytochemical labelling of eggs of the nematode Onchocerca gibsoni

Summary Wheat germ agglutinin—gold and chitinase—gold complexes were used to demonstrate the presence of chitin on the surfaces of eggs of the animal parasitic nematodeOnchocerca gibsoni. The gold complexes were enhanced by silver intensification and examined by light microscopy (LM), transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and scanning electron microscopy (SEM). Distinctive labelling of the egg surfaces was obtained with both probes in all three microscope modes. The results indicate that the small colloidal gold markers (3–10 nm) commonly used for high resolution TEM studies may be silver enhanced and also used for sensitive LM and SEM studies.     

Silver enhancement of protein A-gold probes on resin-embedded ultrathin sections

Summary A simple method is described allowing the enhancement of the visibility of small gold probes for the electron microscopy.This method, which allows the silver intensification of gold directly on epon-embedded ultrathin sections, was used for the electron microscopic localization of Mouse Mammary Tumor Virus (MMTV) antigens in cultured cells derived from GR and BALB/cfRIII mouse mammary tumors. After the immunostaining with the preembedding protein A-gold technique, the ultrathin sections, placed on 200 mesh copper grids, were rehydrated and exposed to a photographic developer containing silver nitrate. During this physical development gold particles are incapsulated in growing shells of metallic silver, which gradually become more and more visible. We were able to obtain a heavy labelling of the viral particles, well visible even at low magmfication, with a negligeable background staining.The present technique can be useful whenever it is necessary to use the smallest gold probes today available.Supported by contract No. 85.02038.44 from the National Research Council, Rome, Progetto Finalizzato Oncologia     

Investigation of immunogold-silver staining by electron microscopy

Deposition of metallic silver on colloidal gold immunoreagents has been shown to be a very sensitive immunostaining technique capable of detecting low levels of immunoreactivity in tissue sections. Using electron microscopy we have shown that immunolabelling is highest with small sizes of gold which can penetrate sections better and achieve higher densities of particles in the section than larger particles. Chemical permeabilisation of the embedding medium aids the penetration of colloidal gold. The silver enhancement step in immunogold-silver staining was shown to be progressive, allowing optimisation of staining and the selection of the final size of silver deposits required. Some poorly understood features of the technique are rationalised and the additional knowledge gained will aid the wider application of this method.     

Investigation of immunogold-silver staining by electron microscopy

Summary Deposition of metallic silver on colloidal gold immunoreagents has been shown to be a very sensitive immunostaining technique capable of detecting low levels of immunoreactivity in tissue sections. Using electron microscopy we have shown that immunolabelling is highest with small sizes of gold which can penetrate sections better and achieve higher densities of particles in the section than larger particles. Chemical permeabilisation of the embedding medium aids the penetration of colloidal gold. The silver enhancement step in immunogold-silver staining was shown to be progressive, allowing optimisation of staining and the selection of the final size of silver deposits required. Some poorly understood features of the technique are rationalised and the additional knowledge gained will aid the wider application of this method.     

Immunogold-silver staining method for light and electron microscopic detection of lymphocyte cell surface antigens with monoclonal antibodies

We used the immunogold-silver staining method (IGSS) for detection of lymphocyte cell surface antigens with monoclonal antibodies in light and electron microscopy and compared this procedure with the immunogold staining method. Two different sizes of colloidal gold particles (5 nm and 15 nm) were used in this study. Immunolabeling on cell surfaces was visualized as fine granules only by IGSS in light microscopy. The labeling density (silver-gold complexes/cell) and diameters of silver-enhanced gold particles on cell surfaces were examined by electron microscopy. Labeling density was influenced not by the enhancement time of the physical developer but by the size of the gold particles. However, the development of shells of silver-enhanced gold particles correlated with the enhancement time of the physical developer rather than the size of the colloidal gold particles. Five-nm gold particles enhanced with the physical developer for 3 min were considered optimal for this IGSS method because of reduced background staining and high specific staining in the cell suspensions in sheep lymph. Moreover, this method may make it possible to show the ultrastructure of identical positive cells detected in 1-micron sections counterstained with toluidine blue by electron microscopy, in addition to the percentage of positive cells by light microscopy.     

Mapping gold-labeled IgE receptors on mast cells by scanning electron microscopy: receptor distributions revealed by silver enhancement, backscattered electron imaging, and digital image analysis

Immunogold labeling and silver enhancement techniques are widely used to determine density and distribution of cell membrane receptors by light and transmission electron microscopy. However, these techniques have not been widely used for receptor detection by scanning electron microscopy. We used antigen- or protein A-conjugated colloidal gold particles, together with silver enhancement, sequential secondary and back-scattered electron imaging (SEI and BEI), and digital image processing, to explore cell surface distribution of IgE-receptor complexes on RBL-2H3 cells, a rat leukemia line that provides a model for the study of mucosal mast cells. Cells were first incubated with a monoclonal antidinitrophenol IgE (anti-DNP-IgE) that binds with high affinity to cell surface IgE receptors. The resulting IgE-receptor complexes were cross-linked either with the multivalent antigen, DNP-BSA-gold, or with a polyclonal anti-IgE antibody. Antibody-treated cells were labeled after fixation with protein A-gold. Fixed, gold-labeled cell monolayers were silver enhanced (or not), dehydrated, critical point-dried, and coated with gold-palladium (for SEI analysis) or carbon (for combined SEI/BEI analysis). They were observed in an Hitachi S800 SEM equipped with a field emission tip and a Robinson backscattered electron detector. An image processor (MegaVision 1024XM) digitized images directly from the S800 microscope at 500-1000 line resolution. Silver enhancement significantly improves detection of gold particles in both SEI and BEI modes of SEM. On gold-palladium-coated samples, 20-nm particles are resolved by SEI after enhancement. BEI resolves 15-nm particles without enhancement and 5- or 10-nm particles are resolved by BEI on silver-enhanced, carbon-coated samples. Neither BEI nor SEI alone can yield high resolution topographical maps of receptor distribution (BEI forms images on the basis of atomic number contrast which reveals gold but not surface features). Image analysis techniques were therefore introduced to digitize, enhance, and process BEI and SEI images of the same field of view. The resulting high-contrast, high-resolution images were superimposed, yielding well-resolved maps of the distribution of antigen-IgE-receptor complexes on the surface of RBL-2H3 mast cells. The maps are stored in digital form, as required for computer-based quantitative morphometric analyses. These techniques of silver enhancement, combined BEI/SEI imaging, and digital image analysis can be applied to analyze density and distribution of any gold-labeled ligand on its target cell.     

Light microscopic localization of silver-enhanced liposome-entrapped colloidal gold in mouse tissues

Silver-enhanced liposome-entrapped colloidal gold was developed for light microscopic localization of liposomes. Preparation of colloidal gold entrapped in liposomes was achieved by a modified method of Hong, et al. (1983) Biochim. Biophys. Acta 732, 320-323). In this report, a gold chloride/citrate solution of low pH (3.4) was used to inhibit the formation of gold granules during the liposome preparation. The diameter of most liposomes ranged from 80 to 100 nm. Following liposome preparation, the pH was adjusted to 6, and the temperature increased to 55 degrees C. The majority of the liposomes contained one to three gold particles. Liposomes were injected into mice via tail vein; 24 h later, tissues were collected. Sections were processed for silver enhancement of the gold particles and examined by light microscopy. Silver-enhanced gold particles were clearly observed in both liver and implanted tumor. Localization was confirmed by electron and fluorescence microscopy. Thus, we have shown that silver enhancement of colloidal gold liposomes is a direct and sensitive method for tracing the fate of liposomes in vivo, providing minimal background interference and a good definition of various cell types.     

Optimizing parameters for correlative immunogold localization by video-enhanced light microscopy, high-voltage transmission electron microscopy, and field emission scanning electron microscopy

Correlative video-enhanced light microscopy, high-voltage transmission electron microscopy, and low-voltage high resolution scanning electron microscopy were used to examine the binding of colloidal gold-labeled fibrinogen to platelet surfaces. Optimal conditions for the detection of large (18 nm) and small (3 nm) gold particles are described.     

ENHANCEMENT OF IMMUNOGOLD-LABELLED FOCAL ADHESION SITES IN FIBROBLASTS CULTURED ON METAL SUBSTRATES: PROBLEMS AND SOLUTIONS

Visualisation of cell adhesion patterns by scanning electron microscopy requires special preparation and labelling. The membranes and cytoplasm must be removed, without damaging the antigen, to facilitate antibody access to vinculin in the focal adhesions. Low beam energy imaging is used to visualise the cell undersurface (embedded in resin after staining with osmium tetroxide) and immunogold-labelled adhesion sites. The gold probe, must be large enough (>40 nm) for detection, while viewing the whole cell, but large gold markers increase steric hindrance and decrease labelling efficiency. This problem can be overcome by using small gold probes (1-5 nm) followed by enlargement with silver enhancement, but osmium tetroxide stain etches the silver. We demonstrated that metal substrates increased this etching. Reducing the concentration of osmium tetroxide and incubation time reduced the amount of etching. We have demonstrated that gold enhancement was not etched by osmium tetroxide, irrespective of the substrate. Therefore, comparative studies of cell adhesion to different biomaterial substrates can be performed using immunogold-labelling with gold enhancement.     

Silver-enhanced colloidal gold as a cell surface marker for photoelectron microscopy

Colloidal gold labeling in conjunction with silver enhancement was investigated as a labeling technique for photoelectron microscopy (PEM). PEM uses UV-stimulated electron emission to image uncoated cell surfaces, and markers for cell surfaces need to be sufficiently photoemissive to be clearly visible against this background. Label contrast provided by 6 nm or 20 nm colloidal gold markers alone was compared to that provided by 6 nm markers after silver enhancement, using both direct and indirect labeling methods for fibronectin on human fibroblast cell surfaces. In all cases, details of the fibrillar fibronectin labeling distribution which were barely discernible before silver enhancement became highly visible against the cellular surface features. Two factors evidently contribute to the pronounced increase in label contrast with silver enhancement: (1) Increased particle size, which was documented by transmission electron microscopy, and (2) increased photoemission resulting from a silver coating on the enhanced gold markers, compared with the protein coating on the unenhanced gold markers. These data demonstrate that silver enhancement of colloidal gold labeling patterns in PEM images is a highly effective method for localization of specific sites on cell surfaces.     

Localization of immunoreactive tyrosine hydroxylase in the goldfish retina with pre-embedding immunolabeling with one-nanometer colloidal gold particles and gold toning.

The goal of this study was to develop an alternative to silver intensification for visualizing small colloidal gold particles by light and electron microscopy. The isolated goldfish retina was labeled with rabbit antiserum to tyrosine hydroxylase and 1-nm colloidal gold-conjugated goat anti-rabbit IgG. The gold particles were enlarged by toning with gold chloride, followed by reduction in oxalic acid. Dopaminergic interplexiform cells were clearly visible by light microscopy and, in lightly-fixed material treated with detergent, they were labeled in their entirety. Labeling was qualitatively similar, although less extensive, in material fixed and processed for electron microscopy. The labeled processes were apparent in ultra-thin sections viewed at low magnification, but the gold-toned particles were not so large that they obscured subcellular structures. The procedure apparently had no deleterious effects on the tissue, since the ultrastructural preservation was comparable to that seen with other pre-embedding immunolabeling methods. The technique was simple, reliable and, since the gold solutions were so dilute, relatively inexpensive.     

Colloidal gold probes in immunocytochemistry. An optimization of their application in light microscopy by use of silver intensification procedures

Colloidal gold particles are the markers of choice for ultrastructural localization of antigens. By reducing gold chloride with tannic acid and trisodium citrate, a broad range of narrowly determined particle sizes can be obtained. Such particles can easily be coupled to a number of proteins and the resulting conjugates are conveniently purified on a gel-chromatography column. Their application in light microscopy requires an amplification step with a silver physical developer. Silver-intensified colloidal gold probes can advantageously be used for immunostaining of cryostat, paraffin and plastic sections. Moreover, permeabilized cultured cells and whole-mount preparations can also be stained with gold-silver techniques. Silver intensification does not affect reactivity of a number of tissue antigens, thus permitting double staining combinations with immunoperoxidase or immunofluorescence methods.     

Fluorescence in situ hybridisation coupled to ultra small immunogold detection to identify prokaryotic cells using transmission and scanning electron microscopy

We describe a method based on fluorescence in situ hybridisation (FISH) that allows the identification of individual cells by electron microscopy. We hybridised universal and specific fluorescein-labelled oligonucleotide probes to the ribosomal RNA of prokaryotic microorganisms in heterogeneous cell mixtures. We then used antibodies against fluorescein coupled to sub-nanometer gold particles to label the hybridised probes in the ribosome. After increasing the diameter of the metal particles by silver enhancement, the specific gold-silver signal was visualised by optical microscopy, transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and scanning electron microscopy (SEM). It is the first time that SEM is applied to the detection of gold nanoparticles hybridised to an intracellular target, such as the ribosome. The possibility to couple phylogenetic identification by FISH to cell surface and ultrastructure observation at electron microscopy resolution has promising potential applications in microbial ecology.     

Binding and internalization of gold-labeled IFN-gamma by human Raji cells

Binding and internalization of gold-labeled IFN-gamma (IFN-gamma/Au) by human Raji cells was examined by scanning and transmission electron microscopy. For SEM, visualization of gold particles was enhanced by the silver enhancement technique and by backscattered electron imaging. Binding studies revealed distinct labeling of microvilli-bearing cells after incubation with at least 10 U/ml IFN-gamma/Au, whereas cells with a smooth surface showed substantially lower labeling. After application of higher IFN-gamma (greater than 200 U/ml) concentrations, labeling intensity remained constant, which is consistent with the concentration of radiolabeled IFN-gamma required for saturating receptors on Raji cells. The specificity of IFN-gamma/Au binding was demonstrated by complete displacement with unlabeled IFN-gamma and by partial inhibition of labeling with a monoclonal anti-IFN-gamma R antibody. Thus, colloidal gold represents a valuable tag for visualizing the interaction of IFN-gamma with its receptor. Internalization of IFN-gamma/Au was initiated by accumulation of gold particles in coated pits which occurred within 10 min after warming of Raji cells. Additional incubation at 37 degrees C (up to 2 h) led to the appearance of gold particles in endocytic vesicles and lysosomes. Thus, our studies indicate that IFN-gamma/Au enters the Raji cells via the typical endocytotic pathway.     

Retrograde tracing of neural pathways with a protein gold complex. II. Electron microscopic demonstration of projections and collaterals

This paper describes a sensitive method for tracing neural connections at the electron microscopic (EM) level using a new compound produced through the coupling of colloidal gold particles to a wheat germ agglutinin horseradish peroxidase conjugate (the WGA*HRP-gold complex). Visualization of retrogradely labeled cells at the EM level was achieved either directly by gold particles scanning or after silver enhancement. By using different sizes of gold particles individually coupled to WGA*HRP and injected in different brain areas EM detection of multiple retrograde labeling was possible. Thus retrogradely labeled cells were first identified at the light microscopic level through HRP histochemistry with tetramethylbenzidine as a chromogen and then examined under the electron microscope after osmication and embedding. Gold particles were readily identified as electron dense, round dots in spherical grey vesicles. Identification of different sizes of gold particles often localized in the same vesicle established that the protein-gold complex can be used to study collateralisation of parental axons.     

The silver anniversary of gold: 25 years of the colloidal gold marker system for immunocytochemistry and histochemistry

Since 1971, when W.P. Faulk and G.M. Taylor published “An immunocolloid method for the electron microscope”, colloidal gold has become a very widely used marker in microscopy. It has been used to detect a huge range of cellular and extracellular constituents by in situ hybridization, immunogold, lectin-gold, and enzyme-gold labeling. Besides its use in light microscopic immunogold and lectin-gold silver staining, colloidal gold remains the label of choice for transmission electron microscopy studying thin sections, freeze-etch, and surface replicas, as well as for scanning electron microscopy. The year 1996 is the 25th anniversary of the introduction of colloidal gold as a marker in immunoelectron microscopy and this overview outlines some of the major milestones in the development of the colloidal gold marker system.     

Pitfalls of immunogold labeling: analysis by light microscopy, transmission electron microscopy, and photoelectron microscopy

The immunogold method is widely used to localize, identify, and distinguish cellular antigens. There are, however, some pitfalls that can lead to nonspecific binding, particularly in cytoskeletal studies with gold probes prepared from small gold particles. We present a list of suggestions for minimizing nonspecific binding, with particular attention to two problems identified in this study. First, we find that the method used to prepare the colloidal gold particles affects the degree of nonspecific binding. Second, the standard BSA-stabilized small gold probes evidently possess exposed regions that bind to the proteins of cytoskeletal preparations. This was investigated in whole-mount cytoskeletal preparations of cultured cells by use of light microscopy, transmission electron microscopy, and photoelectron microscopy of silver-enhanced specimens. Gold probes were made from approximately 5-nm particles generated by reduction of HAuCl4 with three different reducing agents: white phosphorus, sodium borohydride, and citrate-tannic acid. All three preparations stabilized in the conventional way showed significant levels of nonspecific binding, which was highest with citrate-tannic acid. This problem was largely solved with all three types of probes by including fish gelatin in the probe buffer, by substituting fish gelatin for the BSA stabilizer used to prepare the probes, or by pre-adsorption methods. Application of these techniques resulted in clear immunogold labeling patterns with minimal nonspecific background.     

A review of the potential and versatility of colloidal gold cytochemical labeling for molecular morphology.

In the present article we review several postembedding cytochemical techniques using the colloidal gold marker. Owing to the high atomic number of gold, the colloidal gold particles are electron dense. They are spherical in shape and can be prepared in sizes from 1 to 25 nm, which renders this marker among the best for electron microscopy. In addition, because it can be bound to several molecules, this marker has the advantage of being extremely versatile. Combined to immunoglobulins or immunoglobulin-binding proteins (protein A), it has been applied successfully in immunocytochemistry. Colloidal gold particles 5-15 nm in size are excellent for postembedding cytochemistry. Particles of smaller size, such as 1 nm, must be silver enhanced to be visualized by transmission electron microscopy. We have elected to review the superiority of indirect immunocytochemical approaches using IgG-gold or protein A-gold (protein G-gold and protein AG-gold). Lectins or enzymes can be tagged with colloidal gold particles, and the corresponding lectin-gold and enzyme-gold techniques have specific advantages and great potential. Using an indirect digoxigenin-tagged nucleotide and an antidigoxigenin probe, colloidal gold technology can also be used for in situ hybridization at the electron microscope level. Affinity characteristics lie behind all cytochemical techniques and several molecules displaying high affinity properties can also be beneficial for colloidal gold electron microscopy cytochemistry. All of these techniques can be combined in various ways to produce multiple labelings of several binding sites on the same tissue section. Colloidal gold is particulate and can easily be counted; thus the cytochemical signal can be evaluated quantitatively, introducing further advantages to the use of the colloidal gold marker. Finally, several combinations and multiple step procedures have been designed to amplify the final signal which renders the techniques more sensitive. The approaches reviewed here have been applied successfully in different fields of cell and molecular biology, cell pathology, plant biology and pathology, microbiology and virology. The potential of the approaches is emphasized in addition to different ways to assess specificity, sensitivity and accuracy of results.