Fetal breathing movements and other tests of fetal wellbeing: a comparative evaluation.

Sixty pregnant women whose fetuses were considered to be at high risk were intensively studied with fetal and placental function tests. Fetal breathing movements were studied with real-time ultrasound and the amount of time spent breathing and the variability of the breath-to-breath interval were measured. A reduction in the amount of time the fetus spent making breathing movements and decreased variability were indicative of fetal compromise. When these results were compared with those of other tests of fetal wellbeing measurement of fetal breathing movements and ultrasound assessment of growth were more sensitive tests of fetal wellbeing than the biochemical measures (urinary oestrogen, human placental lactogen, pregnancy-specific beta-1-glycoprotein, and unconjugated oestriol concentrations) or fetal heart rate. The predictive value was highest with serum unconjugated oestriol but the results of other tests were similar. Study of fetal breathing movements or an ultrasonic assessment of growth may provide a better screening test for fetal compromise than biochemical estimations.     

Nutritional control of respiratory and other muscular activities in relation to plasma prostaglandin E in the fetal sheep

The effects of nutrient availability on fetal plasma prostaglandin E (PGE) concentrations, on fetal breathing movements and electromyographic (EMG) activities of fetal nuchal and forelimb muscles were investigated in pregnant ewes by varying dietary intake and by manipulation of fetal plasma glucose concentration. The incidence of fetal breathing movements (06.00-10.00 h) decreased with increasing gestational age while fetal arterial concentrations of plasma PGE increased significantly over the same period of gestation. Maternal fasting for 48 h reduced the incidence of fetal breathing movements and the amount of nuchal EMG activity (06.00-10.00 h) in animals older than 130 days but had no effect earlier in gestation. No changes in forelimb EMG activity were observed during fasting at any gestational age. Plasma PGE levels increased significantly during fasts begun both before and after 130 days of gestation. When data from fed and fasted states were combined for all fetuses, irrespective of gestational age, there was a significant inverse correlation between fetal breathing movements incidence and plasma PGE concentration in utero. This relationship was even more pronounced when the fetuses were considered individually. Insulin infusions induced hypoglycaemia, an increase in fetal plasma PGE concentration and a significant reduction in the incidence of fetal breathing movements at all ages. Glucose infusions of fetal breathing movements only after 130 days and had no effect on plasma PGE levels in utero at any gestational age. Neither insulin nor glucose infusions altered the EMG activities of the nuchal and forelimb muscles. The results show that glucose availability is an important factor in determining the incidence of fetal breathing movements in utero and indicate that nutritionally induced changes in fetal breathing movements are mediated in part by PGE. They also suggest that PGE is a physiological regulator of fetal breathing movements in the sheep during late gestation.     

Fetal breathing movements and lung maturation in the congenitally abnormal human fetus

Fetal breathing movements have been studied in conjunction with features of anatomical and biochemical development of the lung at birth in fetuses with congenital abnormalities affecting the respiratory system. Total absence of fetal breathing movements or abnormal fetal breathing movements were associated with lung hypoplasia and failure of normal surfactant release into saline extracts of lung fluid. Surfactant synthesis was demonstrated regardless of the presence or absence of fetal breathing movements. The study supports the hypothesis that normal fetal breathing movements are important for fetal lung development and suggests that surfactant synthesis and its release are independent. The latter process may be dependent upon fetal breathing movements while the former is not.     

The relationship between fetal breathing movements and prostaglandin E2 during ACTH-induced labour in sheep

We measured fetal breathing movements and fetal carotid arterial prostaglandin E concentrations during adrenocorticotrophin-induced labour in 6 pregnant sheep and in 6 control animals starting at day 127. The 6 ACTH-treated animals went into labour on average 97 h after the onset of infusion and the incidence of fetal breathing movements diminished during the last 12h before the onset of labour. There was a significant negative relationship between the incidence of fetal breathing movements and fetal carotid arterial prostaglandin E concentrations (r = -0.88; P less than 0.001) in ACTH treated animals. These data suggest a role for prostaglandin E in the diminution of fetal breathing movements prior to the onset of labour.     

Increased oxygen consumption associated with breathing activity in fetal lambs

To examine the relationship between fetal O2 consumption and fetal breathing movements, we measured O2 consumption, umbilical blood flow, and cardiovascular and blood gas data before, during, and after fetal breathing movements in conscious chronically catheterized fetal lambs. During fetal breathing movements, O2 consumption increased by 30% from a control value of 7.7 +/- 0.7 (SE) ml X min-1 X kg-1. Umbilical blood flow was 210 +/- 21 ml X min-1 X kg-1 before fetal breathing movements; in 9 of 16 samples it increased by 52 +/- 12 ml X min-1 X kg-1, while in the other 7 it decreased by 23 +/- 9 ml X min-1 X kg-1. Umbilical arterial and venous O2 partial pressures and pH fell during fetal breathing movements, and the fall was greater when umbilical blood flow was decreased. Partial CO2 pressure rose in both vessels, and again the increase was greatest when umbilical blood flow fell during fetal breathing movements. Also associated with a fall in umbilical blood flow was the transition from low-amplitude irregular to large-amplitude regular fetal breathing movements. It is concluded that fetal breathing movements increase fetal O2 demands and are associated with a transient deterioration in fetal blood gas status, which is most severe during large-amplitude breathing movements.     

Indomethacin reversal of ethanol-induced suppression of ovine fetal breathing movements and relationship to prostaglandin E2

The effects of indomethacin on the ethanol-induced suppression of fetal breathing movements and fetal arterial plasma and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) PGE2 concentrations and maternal arterial plasma PGE2 concentration were determined in the near-term fetal lamb. Eight conscious instrumented pregnant ewes (between 130 and 133 days of gestation; term, 147 days) received 1-h maternal intravenous infusion of 1 g ethanol/kg total body weight, and the fetus received 6-h intravenous infusion of indomethacin (1 mg/h per kg fetal body weight) commencing 30 min later. Serial fetal and maternal arterial blood samples (n = 8) and fetal CSF samples (n = 5) were collected at selected times throughout the 12-h study for the determination of PGE2 concentration. Fetal breathing movements were monitored continuously throughout the experimental period. Maternal ethanol infusion resulted in initial suppression (P less than 0.05) of fetal breathing movements for 2 h below pretreatment value, followed by a rapid increase in the incidence of fetal breathing movements after the onset of fetal indomethacin treatment. Fetal and maternal plasma PGE2 concentrations and fetal CSF PGE2 concentration were increased (P less than 0.05) above the pre-infusion value during the administration of ethanol and 1 h thereafter. Fetal indomethacin treatment suppressed (P less than 0.05) to undetectable levels fetal plasma and CSF PGE2 concentrations, which then became similar (P greater than 0.05) to pretreatment by 12 h. There was a positive correlation between fetal plasma and CSF PGE2 concentrations. There was an inverse correlation between the incidence of fetal breathing movements and fetal CSF PGE2 concentration.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Stimulation of breathing movements in fetal sheep by inhibitors of prostaglandin synthesis

We studied the effects of inhibitors of prostaglandin synthesis on fetal breathing movements on 17 occasions in 11 lambs (gestational age 125-141 days). We gave 12 h infusions of sodium mechlofenamate (8.6-22.2 mg.kg-1) in 13 studies and indomethacin (21.8-38.8 mg.kg-1) in four studies. Results were similar with both agents and did not correlate with drug dosage. There were no changes in fetal arterial blood pressure, pH or blood gas tensions. We assessed fetal breathing movements by measurements of tracheal pressure for a control period of 224 h prior to and 208 h during the infusion of inhibitors of prostaglandin synthesis; their administration caused a marked stimulation of fetal breathing movements judged from the following four variables: (1) incidence of fetal breathing movements increased from 38.4 to 69.2% of the time (P < 0.001); (2) average amplitude of change in tracheal pressure during fetal breathing movements increased from 4.1 to 6.0 torr (P < 0.01); (3) maximal amplitude of change in tracheal pressure during fetal breathing movements increased from 8.8 to 13.4 torr (P < 0.01); and (4) the duration of the longest continuous episode of fetal breathing movements increased from 37 to 229 min (P < 0.05). Two fetuses had electrocorticogram (ECoG) recordings. In control periods, fetal breathing movements occurred only during low voltage, high frequency ECoG activity; however, during infusions of inhibitors of prostaglandin synthesis, fetal breathing movements occurred also during high voltage, low frequency ECoG activity. We conclude that inhibitors of prostaglandin synthesis stimulate fetal breathing movement in fetal sheep. These results suggest that a component of the prostaglandin system is a factor which inhibits breathing movements during fetal life.     

Fetal and neonatal breathing movements in man after betamethasone.

Nineteen women in the last trimester of pregnancy were treated with betamethasone 12 mg daily for three consecutive days. The fetal breathing movements were monitored by an ultrasonic method before and after the treatment and the patterns of movements were compared to those in controls. In seven treated cases the recording of breathing was performed also in the neonatal period. Betamethasone in the given dose, which causes pronounced alterations in the fetal corticosteroid balance, does not influence the pattern of breathing movements in the fetus and newborn. Although corticosteroids are known to affect several functions of CNS, the maturation of mechanisms regulating breathing movements in the perinatal period is apparently not accelerated by betamethasone.     

Effects of alcohol (ethanol) on the fetus

Alcohol (ethanol) use during pregnancy can produce a wide spectrum of effects in the developing embryo/fetus that are dependent on the maternal drinking pattern. The effects of chronic ethanol exposure on the developing conceptus are reviewed with primary focus on ethanol teratogenesis, manifesting in the human as the fetal alcohol syndrome or fetal alcohol effects. The effects of acute ethanol exposure on the near-term fetus are described, including suppressed fetal breathing movements, electrocorticographic (ECoG) activity and electrooculographic (EOG) activity. The ethanol-induced suppression of fetal breathing movements is a very sensitive index of acute exposure of the near-term fetus to ethanol, and appears to involve a direct mechanism of action rather than an indirect mechanism involving suppression of electrocortical activity. The disposition of ethanol and its pharmacologically active proximate metabolite, acetaldehyde, and the activity of alcohol dehydrogenase and aldehyde dehydrogenase in the near-term maternal-fetal unit are described, and a pharmacokinetic model is proposed. The effects of short-term ethanol exposure on the near-term fetus include the development of tolerance to the ethanol-induced suppression of fetal breathing movements, low-voltage ECoG activity and EOG activity. The development of tolerance occurs more rapidly to the latter two fetal biophysical activities. The mechanism of tolerance development appears to be pharmacodynamic (functional) in nature, as there is no increase in the rate of ethanol elimination from the maternal-fetal unit. The role of prostaglandins (PGs) in the mechanism of the ethanol-induced suppression of fetal breathing movements is described. In the near-term fetus, there is a direct relationship between fetal blood ethanol concentration and fetal plasma PGE2 concentration, and an inverse relationship between the incidence of fetal breathing movements and each of fetal plasma and fetal cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) PGE2 concentrations. Indomethacin, a PG synthetase inhibitor, selectively blocks and reverses the ethanol-induced suppression of fetal breathing movements. These data support the postulates that the ethanol-induced suppression of fetal breathing movements is mediated by increased PGE2 concentration in the near-term fetus and that the ability of indomethacin to antagonize the ethanol-induced suppression of fetal breathing movements is due to its biochemical action to decrease fetal PGE2 concentration.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Effects of naloxone on breathing movements during hypercapnia in the fetal lamb

To determine whether endogenous opioids influence the fetal breathing response to CO2 we have investigated the effect of the opiate antagonist, naloxone on the incidence, rate, and amplitude of breathing movements during hypercapnia in fetal lambs in utero. In 20 experiments in six pregnant sheep (130-145 days gestation) hypercapnia was induced by giving the ewe 4-6% CO2-18% O2 in N2 to breathe for 60 min. After 30 min of hypercapnia either naloxone (13 experiments) or saline (7 experiments) was infused intravenously for the remaining 30 min. During hypercapnia breath amplitude increased from 5.8 +/- 0.5 to 9.1 +/- 1.2 mmHg (P less than 0.001), and infusion of naloxone was associated with a further significant increase to 15.7 +/- 1.2 mmHg (P less than 0.001). Naloxone had no effect on the incidence or rate of breathing movements during hypercapnia. After hypercapnia there was a significant decrease in the incidence of fetal breathing movements in the naloxone group (14.7 +/- 3.2%). Infusion of saline during hypercapnia had no effect on incidence, rate, or amplitude of fetal breathing movements. These results suggest that endogenous opioids act to suppress or limit breath amplitude during hypercapnia but do not affect rate or incidence of breathing movements.     

Maternal perception of fetal motor activity.

A technique using real-time ultrasound for comprehensive recording of fetal motor activity was used in 20 subjects in the third trimester of pregnancy. Maternal awareness of fetal movement correlated with the number of fetal parts contributing to the movement but not with maternal parity or obesity, gestational age, placental site, or duration of the fetal movement. Some subjects recorded fetal breathing, passive fetal displacement, and Braxton Hicks''s contractions as fetal movement. Most of our subjects were consistent and accurate in their perception of major fetal movements, but a few were inconsistent and one was completely unaware of major fetal movements. These results suggest that kick counts kept by most mothers will be accurate. Low counts of fetal movement should be an indication for fetal monitoring by other means and not, unconfirmed, for intervention.     

A new technique for the identification of respiratory sinus arrhythmia in utero

Fetal heart rate (FHR) monitoring forms the basis of routine fetal assessment, particularly short-term variability in the interbeat interval which can be difficult to interpret. Respiratory sinus arrhythmia (RSA), the change in heart rate in response to breathing, contributes to short-term variability, and the presence of RSA in utero may reflect the functional integrity of the central nervous system. This paper describes the use of Doppler ultrasound to derive the required measures of fetal heart rate and fetal breathing movements and spectral analysis to identify RSA. Cases are presented to illustrate the results obtained both in the presence and absence of RSA.     

Fetal breathing and development of control of breathing

Technical advances during the last several decades have greatly facilitated research into fetal physiology and behavior, specifically fetal breathing (FB). Breathing movements have been demonstrated in the fetuses of every mammalian species investigated and appear to be part of normal fetal development. In this review we focus on the methods of measuring FB and on some of the problems associated with these measurements and their interpretation. We also review fetal behavior, the role of the peripheral and central chemoreceptors in spontaneous FB, the fetal respiratory response to hypercapnia and hypoxia, and the transition to continuous breathing at birth. It is clear that in many ways the control of breathing movements in utero differs from that after birth. In particular, inhibitory influences are much more prominent before than after birth. Possibly this is due to the unique fetal situation, in which conservation of energy may be more important than any advantage breathing activity imparts to the fetus.     

Effects of hyperthermia on fetal breathing movements

High environmental temperature is known to impair fetal growth and development. We now report long lasting changes in fetal breathing activity following the exposure of pregnant ewes to an ambient temperature of 43 degrees C for 8 h. In 16 trials in 10 ewes (119-138 days gestation) heat exposure increased maternal and fetal core temperatures 1.5-2.0 degrees C, and the hyperventilation by the ewe produced a fall in fetal PaCO2 from 53.5 +/- 1.3 to 34.8 +/- 5.3 mmHg (P less than 0.05). Fetal breathing movements decreased in incidence during the hyperthermia but remained episodic (present during low-voltage electrocortical activity) with occasional brief episodes of breathing at high rates (greater than 4 breaths/s). However, 1-2 h after the end of heating, when maternal and fetal core temperature and PaCO2 had returned to normal, fetal breathing movements became continuous, and were augmented 30-100% in amplitude. Fetal breathing movements occurred during both low- and high-voltage electrocortical activity. The results show that a heat load similar to that experienced by sheep in sub-tropical regions in the summer months cause prolonged changes in the central regulation of fetal breathing.     

Effects of prostaglandins on fetal breathing do not involve peripheral chemoreceptors

In sheep, prostaglandin (PG) E2 inhibits fetal breathing movements and meclofenamate, a PG synthetase inhibitor, causes a marked stimulation of fetal breathing movements; the site of action of these agents is not known. To determine whether these effects are mediated through the peripheral chemoreceptors, we studied 13 fetal sheep at gestational ages of 127 to 138 days. Seven fetuses had bilateral section of the carotid sinus and vagus nerves (denervated); six had sham operations. Beginning at least 6 days after the operation, we infused PGE2 (0.6 microgram X kg-1 X min-1) into five denervated and five sham-operated fetuses and meclofenamate (0.4 mg X kg-1 X h-1) into six denervated and four sham-operated fetuses. Infusions averaged 20 h in duration. During preinfusion control periods, the incidence of fetal breathing movements (% of time) was lower in denervated than in sham-operated fetuses (18.9% vs. 31.5%; P less than 0.005). In both groups, the incidence of fetal breathing movements was decreased by PGE2 and was increased by meclofenamate; when expressed as absolute values, the magnitude of the changes with both agents was greater in sham-operated fetuses than denervated fetuses. However, the effects were similar in both groups when the changes were expressed as a percent of the respective control values. The incidence of fetal breathing movements (% of control) was decreased by PGE2 to 25.4% in denervated and to 28.2% in sham-operated fetuses and was increased by meclofenamate to 297.3% in denervated and to 304.0% in sham-operated fetuses.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

The effects of raising intracranial pressure on breathing movements, eye movements and electrocortical activity in fetal sheep

Extra-dural or cerebroventricular intracranial pressure was measured in 7 unanaesthetized fetal sheep (123-137 days gestation). Basal intracranial pressure was 6.7 +/- 1.7 mmHg, but there were many transient increases of pressure in association with spontaneous changes of amniotic pressure, fetal intrathoracic pressure, and particularly when the fetal nuchal muscles were active. These spontaneous increases of intracranial pressure were often associated with cessation of breathing movements and change of the electrocorticogram from low to high voltage activity. To test whether increased intracranial pressure influenced breathing movements and electrocortical activity, intracranial pressure was raised either by occluding the superior vena cava for 1 min with an implanted extravascular cuff, or by extra-dural injection of 0.3-1.0 ml of 0.9% NaCl. Increasing the intracranial pressure 5-15 mmHg by either method during low voltage electrocortical activity caused cessation of breathing movements, electro-ocular activity, and change of the electrocorticogram from low to high voltage in a significant proportion of trials. We propose that natural fluctuations of intracranial pressure caused by compression of the fetal body or skull, by body movements or by uterine activity, may cause changes in electrocortical activity and breathing movements.     

Almitrine inhibits breathing movements in fetal sheep in utero

Whilst hypoxia stimulates fetal peripheral chemoreceptors, fetal breathing movements do not increase as hypoxia also has central effects. We wondered whether specific stimulation of the arterial chemoreceptors by almitrine would produce a stimulation of fetal breathing movements. When almitrine was given to 5 intact and 3 peripherally-chemodenervated fetal sheep in utero, fetal breathing movements rapidly ceased for 1-12 h. There was also a decrease in the amount of time spent in low voltage electrocortical activity. The effects of almitrine are therefore similar to those of hypoxia, and are independent of the peripheral chemoreceptors. Thus it may be a valuable tool in the study of the control of fetal breathing.     

Indomethacin antagonizes the ethanol-induced suppression of breathing activity but not the suppression of brain activity in the near-term fetal sheep

The effect of indomethacin on the ethanol-induced suppression of fetal breathing movements, low-voltage electrocortical (ECoG) activity, and electro-ocular (EOG) activity was studied in the near-term fetal sheep. Ten conscious instrumented pregnant ewes (between 129 and 131 days of gestation; term, 147 days) received 1-h maternal intravenous infusion of 1 g ethanol/kg total body weight and simultaneous fetal treatment with either indomethacin (2 mg/kg fetal body weight/h) (n = 5) or an equivalent volume of phosphate buffer (n = 5) intravenously for 9 h. Fetal ECoG activity, EOG activity, and fetal breathing movements were monitored continuously over the experimental periods. In animals treated with ethanol and buffer (n = 5), fetal breathing movements were suppressed for 8 h and low-voltage ECoG and EOG activity was suppressed for 2 h below preinfusion levels. In animals treated with ethanol and indomethacin (n = 5), fetal breathing movements were elevated for 13 h but low-voltage ECoG and EOG activity remained suppressed for 3 h below preinfusion levels. The data suggests that indomethacin can antagonize the ethanol-induced suppression of fetal breathing movements, but does not alter the ethanol-induced suppression of ECoG or EOG activity.     

Effect of hyperoxia (PaO2 50-90 mmHg) on fetal breathing movements in the unanaesthetized fetal sheep

Hypoxia inhibits fetal breathing movements but after birth it stimulates breathing. These differences have long been thought to involve central nervous inhibitory mechanisms. Such mechanisms might exert a tonic inhibition of fetal breathing movements at normal fetal PaO2 and the rise in PaO2 at birth might lift this inhibitory effect. To test this hypothesis 7 fetal sheep were chronically instrumented at 125-130 days for recording electrocortical activity (ECoG), and the electromyograph (EMG) activity of the diaphragm and neck muscles. Catheters were placed in a fetal carotid and a brachial artery and in the fetal trachea. For an extracorporeal membrane oxygenation system a 12 F gauge silastic catheter was placed in the right atrium for draining fetal blood and a 9.6 F gauge catheter was placed in a carotid artery to return oxygenated blood. Three days after operation the fetuses were connected to the extracorporeal membrane oxygenation system and fetal PaO2 was raised to 65.2 +/- 4.4 mmHg (SEM) for 6 to 19 h without changing pH or PaCO2. Neither the incidence of high voltage ECoG (48.5 +/- SEM 2.0% vs 52.8 +/- 3.3%) nor of fetal breathing movements (37.3 +/- 2.6% vs 23.8 +/- 5.9%) changed during the periods of hyperoxia. Since fetal breathing movements did not become continuous, we conclude that the lower PaO2 in the fetus compared to the neonate does not exert a tonic inhibitory influence on fetal breathing movements.     

Denervation of peripheral chemoreceptors decreases breathing movements in fetal sheep

The role of the peripheral chemoreceptors in the control of fetal breathing movements has not been fully defined. To determine whether denervation of the peripheral chemoreceptors affects fetal breathing movements, we studied 14 chronically catheterized fetal sheep from 120 to 138 days of gestation. In seven fetuses the chemoreceptors were denervated by bilateral section of the vagus and carotid sinus nerves; in seven others, sham operations were performed. We compared several variables during two study periods: 0-5 and 6-13 days after operation. In the denervated fetuses there were significant decreases in the incidence and amplitude of fetal breathing movements during both study periods. There were no differences between the two groups in incidence of low-voltage electrocortical activity, arterial pH and blood gas tensions, fetal heart rate, mean arterial blood pressure, or duration of survival after operation or birth weight. We conclude that denervation of the peripheral chemoreceptors decreases fetal breathing movements. These results indicate that the peripheral chemoreceptors are active during fetal life and participate in the control of fetal breathing movements.