Stability of drug-induced tubulin rings by fluorescence correlation spectroscopy

Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) was applied to investigate the stability of tubulin rings that result from the interaction of alpha beta-tubulin dimers with three vinca domain-binding peptides--cryptophycin 1, hemiasterlin, and dolastatin 10. These peptides inhibit tubulin polymerization into microtubules and, instead, induce the formation of single-walled tubulin rings of 23.8 nm mean diameter for cryptophycin and 44.6 nm mean diameter for hemiasterlin and dolastatin, as revealed by electron microscopy on micromolar drug-tubulin samples. However, the hydrodynamic diameter and the apparent number of fluorescent particles, determined from analysis of FCS measurements obtained from nanomolar drug-tubulin samples, indicate variation in the stability of the rings depending on the drug and the tubulin concentration. Cryptophycin-tubulin rings appear to be the most stable even with tubulin concentration as low as 1 nM, whereas hemiasterlin-tubulin rings are the least, depolymerizing even at relatively high concentrations (100 nM). In contrast, the dolastatin-tubulin rings demonstrate an intermediate level of stability, depolymerizing significantly only at tubulin concentrations below 10 nM. We also compare the stability results with those of cytotoxicity measurements taken on several cell lines and note a rough correlation between the cytotoxicity of the drugs in cell cultures and the stability of the corresponding drug-induced rings.     

Reversible dimer dissociation of tubulin S and tubulin detected by fluorescence anisotropy.

Concentration-dependent dissociation of dimers of goat brain tubulin S and tubulin was studied by fluorescence anisotropy. Upon dilution, assembly-competent fluorescein 5'-maleimide labeled dimers of tubulin S and tubulin show a progressive decrease in fluorescence anisotropy. That this lowering of anisotropy results from the dissociation of tubulin S dimers into monomers was shown by dilution experiments with unlabeled homologous and heterologous proteins. A nonlinear least-squares fit of the data gave a dissociation constant of 7.1 x 10(-8) M for tubulin S compared to 7.2 x 10(-7) M for tubulin at 25 degrees C in 0.1 M PEM buffer, pH 7.0. van't Hoff plots of dimer-monomer dissociation of tubulin S and tubulin also show considerable differences in delta H and delta S. Effects of ionic strength and colchicine on the equilibrium constants are also substantially different for tubulin and tubulin S. The implications of these observations on the influence of C-terminal tails on tubulin structure are discussed.     

Hydrophobic surfaces of tubulin probed by time-resolved and steady-state fluorescence of nile red

Binding of Nile Red to tubulin enhances and blue-shifts fluorescence emission to about 623 nm with a "shoulder" around 665 nm. Binding is reversible and saturable with an apparent Kd of approximately 0.6 microM. Nile Red does not alter tubulin polymerization, and polymerization in 2-(N-morpholino)ethanesulfonic acid (Mes) buffer does not alter the spectrum of the Nile Red-tubulin complex. In contrast, polymerization in glutamate buffer results in a red shift, reduction of intensity, and a decrease in lifetime, suggesting an increase in "polarity" of the binding environment. Lifetimes of 4.5 and 0.6 ns fluorescence in Mes buffer are associated with the 623-nm peak and the 665-nm shoulder, respectively. Indirect excitation spectra for these components are distinct and the 4.5-ns component exhibits tryptophan to Nile Red energy transfer. Acrylamide quenching yields linear Stern-Volmer plots with unchanged lifetimes, indicating static quenching. Apparent quenching constants are wavelength-dependent; global analysis reveals a quenchable component corresponding to the 4.5 ns component and an "unquenchable" component superposing the 0.6-ns spectrum. Analysis of anisotropy decay required an "associative" model which yielded rotational correlation times of greater than 50 ns for the 4.5-ns lifetime and 0.3 ns for the 0.6-ns lifetime. Dilution of tubulin in Mes results in an apparent red shift of emission without lifetime changes, due only to loss of the 623-nm component. These data are reconciled in terms of a model with two binding sites on the tubulin dimer. The more "nonpolar" site is located in a region of subunit-subunit contact which accounts for the fluorescence changes upon dilution; this permits estimation of a subunit dissociation constant of 1 microM.     

Taxol allosterically alters the dynamics of the tubulin dimer and increases the flexibility of microtubules

Taxol is a commonly used antitumor agent that hyperstabilizes microtubules and prevents cell division. The interaction of Taxol with tubulin and the microtubule has been studied through a wide array of experimental techniques; however, the exact molecular mechanism by which Taxol stabilizes microtubules has remained elusive. In this study, through the use of large-scale molecular simulations, we show that Taxol affects the interactions between the M and H1-S2 loops of adjacent tubulin dimers leading to more stable interprotofilament interactions. More importantly, we demonstrate that Taxol binding leads to a significant increase in the dynamics and flexibility of the portion of β-tubulin that surrounds the bound nucleotide and makes contact with the α-monomer of the next dimer in the protofilament. We conclude that this increase in flexibility allows the microtubule to counteract the conformational changes induced by nucleotide hydrolysis and keeps the protofilaments in a straight conformation, resulting in a stable microtubule.     

Quantitative characterization of the binding of fluorescently labeled colchicine to tubulin in vitro using fluorescence correlation spectroscopy

Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) is a new technique that allows the determination of the diffusion constant of a fluorescent molecule in solution. Also, the binding of the fluorescent molecule to a target can be analyzed, if the difference in the diffusion coefficients of the free and bound ligand is sufficiently large. With FCS, the interaction between fluorescein-colchicine (FC) and tubulin has been studied in vitro. A fast and reversible binding is observed with an association constant at room temperature of (3.9 +/- 0.1) x 10(4) M-1. No competition with colchicine is seen, indicating that FCS reveals the existence of a new binding site on tubulin. FCS is not able to show the binding of FC to the original colchicine binding site, even though it exists, because the fluorescence of FC is strongly quenched upon binding to this site. This quenching is evident in spectrofluorometry experiments, revealing a slow binding of FC to tubulin that is subject to competition with colchicine. FCS allows the determination of the diffusion coefficients of both free and bound fluorescent colchicine which were found to be (2.6 +/- 0.2) x 10(-)10 and (2.0 +/- 0.2) x 10(-)11 m2 s-1, respectively. It can be concluded that fluorescent labeling, especially of small molecules, can interfere considerably with the binding behavior that is being studied. Although general qualitative effects in vivo are similar for colchicine and its fluorescein derivative, this quantitative study of the binding to tubulin presents a nuanced view, and the existence of a second binding site for FC can even explain some conflicting indications in the literature.     

Secondary structure analysis of tubulin and microtubules with Raman spectroscopy

Raman spectroscopy is used to study the secondary structure of tubulin in the assembled and the dissociated states from the analysis of the amide-I band. Essentially two states are recognized: the GTP- and the GDP-bound state, differing in alpha-helix and antiparallel beta-sheet content. Microtubules give a spectrum which is very similar to the GDP-bound state. MAPs and temperature have minor effects, while increasing the pH up to 8 causes a reduction in alpha-helix content and a increase in antiparallel beta-sheet. The binding of demecolcine also induces structural changes which are similar to the GDP-bound state.     

RNA dimerization monitored by fluorescence correlation spectroscopy

Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) provides a versatile tool to investigate molecular interaction under native conditions, approximating infinite dilution. One precondition for its application is a sufficient difference between the molecular weights of the fluorescence-labelled unbound and bound ligand. In previous studies, an 8-fold difference in molecular weights or correspondingly a 1.6-fold difference in diffusion coefficients was required to accurately distinguish between two diffusion species by FCS. In the presented work, the hybridization of two complementary equally sized RNA single strands was investigated at an excellent signal-to-noise ratio enabled by the highly photostable fluorophore Atto647N. The fractions of ssRNA and dsRNA were quantified by applying multicomponent model analysis of single autocorrelation functions and globally fitting several autocorrelation functions. By introducing a priori knowledge into the fitting procedure, 1.3- to 1.4-fold differences in diffusion coefficients of single- and double-stranded RNA of 26, 41, and 54 nucleotides could be accurately resolved. Global fits of autocorrelation functions of all titration steps enabled a highly accurate quantification of diffusion species fractions and mobilities. At a high signal-to-noise ratio, the median of individually fitted autocorrelation functions allowed a robust representation of heterogeneous data. These findings point out the possibility of studying molecular interaction of equally sized molecules based on their diffusional behavior, which significantly broadens the application spectrum of FCS.     

Structure of the tubulin dimer

Microtubules are formed from a 110,000-dalton dimeric subunit called tubulin. Two forms of 55,000-dalton monomer, alpha and beta, are found in all microtubule preparations. The dimers could thus theoretically be either heterodimers (alphabeta) or homodimers (alphaalpha and betabeta). This problem was investigated by stigated by chemical cross-linking using several bifunctional reagents, of which one, dimethyl-3,3-(tetrame thylenedioxy) dipropionimidate dihydrochloride (DTDI), was able to make intradimer bonds in tubulin. When soluble chick brain tubulin was cross-linked with DTDI and analyzed by electrophoresis in an acrylamide gel system capable of resolving alphaalpha, alphabeta, and betabeta, 60 to 90% of the cross-linked dimer was alphabeta. If tubulin was incubated at 24 degrees prior to cross-linking with DTDI the total yield of cross-linked dimer increased with time, indicating that tubulin was forming loose aggregates. The relative amounts of cross-linked dimer alphaalpha and betabeta also increase with time, indicating that soluble tubulin is largely alphabeta, and suggesting that cross-linked alphaalpha and betabeta arise from nonspecific aggregation during tubulin purification. The aggregation observed by cross-linking with DTDI was strongly influenced by colchicine and Vinca alkaloids in a pattern similar to the effects of these drugs on tubulin polymerization.     

Accessing molecular dynamics in cells by fluorescence correlation spectroscopy

Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) analyzes spontaneous fluctuations in the fluorescence emission of small molecular ensembles, thus providing information about a multitude of parameters, such as concentrations, molecular mobility and dynamics of fluorescently labeled molecules. Performed within diffraction-limited confocal volume elements, FCS provides an attractive alternative to photobleaching recovery methods for determining intracellular mobility parameters of very low quantities of fluorophores. Due to its high sensitivity sufficient for single molecule detection, the method is subject to certain artifact hazards that must be carefully controlled, such as photobleaching and intramolecular dynamics, which introduce fluorescence flickering. Furthermore, if molecular mobility is to be probed, nonspecific interactions of the labeling dye with cellular structures can introduce systematic errors. In cytosolic measurements, lipophilic dyes, such as certain rhodamines that bind to intracellular membranes, should be avoided. To study free diffusion, genetically encoded fluorescent labels such as green fluorescent protein (GFP) or DsRed are preferable since they are less likely to nonspecifically interact with cellular substructures.     

Measuring diffusion in cell membranes by fluorescence correlation spectroscopy

Fluorescence Correlation Spectroscopy (FCS) can measure diffusion on the cell surface with unparalleled sensitivity. In appropriate situations, this can be the most sensitive and accurate method for measuring receptor interaction and oligomerization. Here we attempt to describe FCS in sufficient detail so that the reader is able to judge when there is a compelling reason to choose this technique, understand the basic theory behind it, construct a FCS spectrometer in the laboratory, and analyze the data to obtain a meaningful estimate of the physical parameters.     

Viral DNA packaging studied by fluorescence correlation spectroscopy

The DNA packaging machinery of bacteriophage T4 was studied in vitro using fluorescence correlation spectroscopy. The ATP-dependent translocation kinetics of labeled DNA from the bulk solution, to the phage interior, was measured by monitoring the accompanied decrease in DNA diffusibility. It was found that multiple short DNA fragments (100 basepairs) can be sequentially packaged by an individual phage prohead. Fluorescence resonance energy transfer between green fluorescent protein donors within the phage interior and acceptor-labeled DNA was used to confirm DNA packaging. Without ATP, no packaging was observed, and there was no evidence of substrate association with the prohead.     

On the statistics of fluorescence correlation spectroscopy

I present a detailed statistical analysis of fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) which is a natural extension of an early work. This analysis more realistically takes account of the following issues. (1) A spatial Gaussian laser excitation of fluorescence, (2) the effect of a small number of fluorescent molecules in the observation volume, (3) the shot noise effect due to random emission of fluorescent photons, and (4) a hyperbolic form for the fluorescence autocorrelation function obtained in the case of diffusion. Based on these assumptions, the results differ from the earlier work in several respects, in particular, the dependence of the signal-to-noise ratio on sample concentration and the understanding of shot noise in fluorescence fluctuation moments.     

Proteolysis of tubulin and the substructure of the tubulin dimer

The alpha and beta subunits of tubulin each have a single highly reactive site for a variety of proteases that divides each subunit into two unequal regions. The position of cleavage is not the same for alpha and beta, since alpha is consistently cleaved into about 38- and 14-kDa pieces, while beta is cleaved into about 34- and 21-kDa pieces. The larger fragment is amino-terminal in both subunits as shown: by size reduction of the smaller fragment by subtilisin (which cleaves at the extreme carboxyl-terminal end), but no change in size of the larger fragment; by the charge/mass ratios of the proteolytic fragments; and by sequence analysis which locates trypsin cleavage after residue 339 (alpha) and chymotrypsin cleavage after residue 281 (beta). Since this cleavage pattern of the alpha and beta subunits is found for very different proteases, we suggest that it is determined by structural features of the tubulin molecule. The two pieces of each subunit remain associated following cleavage. While both cleavage sites are exposed in the free dimer, assembly of dimers into microtubules or sheets protects the internal site against cleavage. By contrast, the carboxyl-terminal subtilisin-sensitive sites remain exposed. Based on these results we propose a model for the substructure of the tubulin dimer that accommodates internal cleavage in the dimer but not the polymer, access to the COOH termini in both forms, and the orientation of the dimer in the polymer.     

Correct diffusion coefficients of proteins in fluorescence correlation spectroscopy. Application to tubulin oligomers induced by Mg2+ and Paclitaxel

In view of recent warnings for artifacts in fluorescence correlation spectroscopy, the diffusion coefficient of a series of labeled proteins in a wide range of molecular mass (43-670 kD) was determined and shown to be correct with respect to published values and the theory. Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy was then applied to the study of fluorescently labeled tubulin and its oligomerization in vitro induced by Mg2+ ions, paclitaxel, and a fluorescent derivative of paclitaxel (Flutax2). By applying relations derived from the theory of Oosawa, we were able to determine the association constant of the oligomers induced by Mg2+. With Flutax2 our experiments show that at nanomolar concentration, the fluorescent derivative is able to recruit tubulin dimers and to form oligomers of defined size. Flutax2 does not bind to microtubules preformed with paclitaxel, but it becomes preferentially incorporated into microtubules when Flutax2 oligomers are preformed, and microtubule formation is induced by paclitaxel addition. This shows that their incorporation into microtubules is faster than the displacement of the prebound drug. Experiments using fluorescently labeled tubulin and (unlabeled) paclitaxel confirm the induction of tubulin oligomers at limiting paclitaxel concentrations.     

Hindered diffusion in polymeric solutions studied by fluorescence correlation spectroscopy

Diffusion of molecules in the crowded and charged interior of the cell has long been of interest for understanding cellular processes. Here, we introduce a model system of hindered diffusion that includes both crowding and binding. In particular, we obtained the diffusivity of the positively charged protein, ribonuclease A (RNase), in solutions of dextrans of various charges (binding) and concentrations (crowding), as well as combinations of both, in a buffer of physiological ionic strength. Using fluorescence correlation spectroscopy, we observed that the diffusivity of RNase was unaffected by the presence of positively charged or neutral dextrans in the dilute regime but was affected by crowding at higher polymer concentrations. Conversely, protein diffusivity was significantly reduced by negatively charged dextrans, even at 0.4 μM (0.02% w/v) dextran. The diffusivity of RNase decreased with increasing concentrations of negative dextran, and the amount of bound RNase increased until it reached a plateau of ∼80% bound RNase. High salt concentrations were used to establish the electrostatic nature of the binding. Binding of RNase to the negatively charged dextrans was further confirmed by ultrafiltration.     

Lipid diffusion in planar membranes investigated by fluorescence correlation spectroscopy

Investigation of lipid lateral mobility in biological membranes and their artificial models provides information on membrane dynamics and structure; methods based on optical microscopy are very convenient for such investigations. We focus on fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS), explain its principles and review its state of the art versions such as 2-focus, Z-scan or scanning FCS, which overcome most artefacts of standard FCS (especially those resulting from the need for an external calibration) making it a reliable and versatile method. FCS is also compared to single particle tracking and fluorescence photobleaching recovery and the applicability and the limitations of the methods are briefly reviewed. We discuss several key questions of lateral mobility investigation in planar lipid membranes, namely the influence which membrane and aqueous phase composition (ionic strength and sugar content), choice of a fluorescent tracer molecule, frictional coupling between the two membrane leaflets and between membrane and solid support (in the case of supported membranes) or presence of membrane inhomogeneities has on the lateral mobility of lipids. The recent FCS studies addressing those questions are reviewed and possible explanations of eventual discrepancies are mentioned.     

The standard deviation in fluorescence correlation spectroscopy

The standard deviation (SD) in fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) has been mostly neglected in applications. However, the knowledge of the correct SD is necessary for an accurate data evaluation, especially when fitting theoretical models to experimental data. In this work, an algorithm is presented that considers the essential features of FCS. It allows prediction of the performance of FCS measurements in various cases, which is important for finding optimal experimental conditions. The program calculates the SD of the experimental autocorrelation function online. This procedure leads to improved parameter estimation, compared to currently used theoretical approximations for the SD. Three methods for the calculation of the SD are presented and compared to earlier analytical solutions (D. E. Koppel. 1974. Phys. Rev. A. 10:1938-1945.), calculation directly from fluorescence intensity values, by averaging several FCS measurements, or by dividing one measurement into a set of shorter data packages. Although the averaging over several measurements yields accurate estimates for the SD, the other two methods are considerably less time consuming, can be run online, and yield comparable results.     

Probing receptor-translocator interactions in the oligopeptide ABC transporter by fluorescence correlation spectroscopy

The oligopeptide transporter Opp is a five-component ABC uptake system. The extracytoplasmic lipid-anchored substrate-binding protein (or receptor) OppA delivers peptides to an integral membrane complex OppBCDF (or translocator), where, on ATP binding and hydrolysis, translocation across the membrane takes place. OppA and OppBCDF were labeled with fluorescent probes, reconstituted into giant unilamellar vesicles, and the receptor-translocator interactions were investigated by fluorescence correlation spectroscopy. Lateral mobility of OppA was reduced on incorporation of OppBCDF into giant unilamellar vesicles, and decreased even further on the addition of peptide. Fluorescence cross-correlation measurements revealed that OppBCDF distinguished liganded from unliganded OppA, binding only the former. Addition of ATP or its nonhydrolyzable analog AMP-PNP resulted in release of OppA from OppBCDF. In vanadate-trapped “transition state” conditions, OppA also was not bound by OppBCDF. A model is presented in which ATP-binding to OppDF results in donation of peptide to OppBC and simultaneous release of OppA. ATP-hydrolysis would complete the peptide translocation and reset the transporter for another catalytic cycle. Implications in terms of a general transport mechanism for ABC importers and exporters are discussed.     

Detection of polyglutamine protein oligomers in cells by fluorescence correlation spectroscopy

Abnormal aggregation of misfolded proteins and their deposition as inclusion bodies in the brain have been implicated as a common molecular pathogenesis of neurodegenerative diseases including Alzheimer, Parkinson, and the polyglutamine (poly(Q)) diseases, which are collectively called the conformational diseases. The poly(Q) diseases, including Huntington disease and various types of spinocerebellar ataxia, are caused by abnormal expansions of the poly(Q) stretch within disease-causing proteins, which triggers the disease-causing proteins to aggregate into insoluble beta-sheet-rich amyloid fibrils. Although oligomeric structures formed in vitro are believed to be more toxic than mature amyloid fibrils in these diseases, the existence of oligomers in vivo has remained controversial. To explore oligomer formation in cells, we employed fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS), which is a highly sensitive technique for investigating the dynamics of fluorescent molecules in solution. Here we demonstrate direct evidence for oligomer formation of poly(Q)-green fluorescent protein (GFP) fusion proteins expressed in cultured cells, by showing a time-dependent increase in their diffusion time and particle size by FCS. We show that the poly(Q)-binding peptide QBP1 inhibits poly(Q)-GFP oligomer formation, whereas Congo red only inhibits the growth of oligomers, but not the initial formation of the poly(Q)-GFP oligomers, suggesting that FCS is capable of identifying poly(Q) oligomer inhibitors. We therefore conclude that FCS is a useful technique to monitor the oligomerization of disease-causing proteins in cells as well as its inhibition in the conformational diseases.