Evidence for a Third Uptake Hydrogenase Phenotype among the Soybean Bradyrhizobia

The existence of a hydrogen uptake host-regulated (Hup-hr) phenotype was established among the soybean bradyrhizobia. The Hup-hr phenotype is characterized by the expression of uptake hydrogenase activity in symbiosis with cowpea but not soybean. Uptake hydrogenase induction is not possible under free-living cultural conditions by using techniques developed for uptake hydrogenase-positive (Hup⁺) Bradyrhizobium japonicum. Hydrogen oxidation by Hup-hr phenotype USDA 61 in cowpea symbioses was significant because hydrogen evolution from nitrogen-fixing nodules was not detected. An examination for uptake hydrogenase activity in soybean and cowpea with 123 strains diverse in origin and serology identified 16 Hup⁺ and 28 Hup-hr phenotype strains; the remainder appeared to be Hup⁻. The Hup-hr phenotype was associated with serogroups 31, 76, and 94, while strains belonging to serogroups 6, 31, 110, 122, 123, and 38/115 were Hup⁺. Hup⁺ strains of the 123 serogroup typed positive with USDA 129-specific antiserum. The presence of the uptake hydrogenase protein in cowpea bacteroids of Hup⁺ strains was demonstrated with immunoblot analyses by using antibodies against the 65-kDa subunit of uptake hydrogenase purified from strain SR470. However, the hydrogenase protein of Hup-hr strains was not detected. Results of Southern hybridization analyses with pHU1 showed the region of DNA with hydrogenase genes among Hup⁺ strains to be similar. Hybridization was also obtained with Hup-hr strains by using a variety of cloned DNA as probes including hydrogenase structural genes. Both hydrogenase structural genes also hybridized with the DNA of four Hup⁻ strains.     

Determination of the Hydrogenase Status of Individual Legume Nodules by a Methylene Blue Reduction Assay

We adapted a method for the rapid screening of colonies of free-living Rhizobium japonicum for hydrogenase activity to determine the hydrogenase status of individual soybean nodules. Crude bacteroid suspensions from nodules containing strains known to be hydrogen uptake positive (Hup⁺) caused a localized decolorization of filter paper disks, whereas suspensions from nodules arising from inoculation with hydrogen uptake-negative (Hup⁻) mutants or strains did not decolorize the disks. The reliability of the method was demonstrated by its successful application to 29 slow-growing rhizobia. The Hup phenotype on methylene blue filters agreed with that determined amperometrically with either methylene blue or oxygen as the electron acceptor.     

Transposon Tn5-Generated Bradyrhizobium japonicum Mutants Unable To Grow Chemoautotrophically with H2

Twelve Tn5-induced mutants of Bradyrhizobium japonicum unable to grow chemoautotrophically with CO₂ and H₂ (Aut⁻) were isolated. Five Aut⁻ mutants lacked hydrogen uptake activity (Hup⁻). The other seven Aut⁻ mutants possessed wild-type levels of hydrogen uptake activity (Hup⁺), both in free-living culture and symbiotically. Three of the Hup⁻ mutants lacked hydrogenase activity both in free-living culture and as nodule bacteroids. The other two mutants were Hup⁻ only in free-living culture. The latter two mutants appeared to be hypersensitive to repression by oxygen, since Hup activity could be derepressed under 0.4% O₂. All five Hup⁻ mutants expressed both ex planta and symbiotic nitrogenase activities. Two of the seven Aut⁻ Hup⁺ mutants expressed no free-living nitrogenase activity, but they did express it symbiotically. These two strains, plus one other Aut⁻ Hup⁺ mutant, had CO₂ fixation activities 20 to 32% of the wild-type level. The cosmid pSH22, which was shown previously to contain hydrogenase-related genes of B. japonicum, was conjugated into each Aut⁻ mutant. The Aut⁻ Hup⁻ mutants that were Hup⁻ both in free-living culture and symbiotically were complemented by the cosmid. None of the other mutants was complemented by pSH22. Individual subcloned fragments of pSH22 were used to complement two of the Hup⁻ mutants.     

Influence of the Bradyrhizobium japonicum Hydrogenase on the Growth of Glycine and Vigna Species

The effect of the Bradyrhizobium japonicum hydrogenase on nitrogen fixation was evaluated by comparing the growth of Vigna and Glycine species inoculated with a Hup mutant and its Hup⁺ revertant. In all experiments, the growth of plants inoculated with the strain without hydrogenase was at least equal to the growth of the strain with hydrogenase. For Glycine usuriensis and Glycine max cv. Hodgson in liquid culture, the growth was higher with the Hup⁻ strain. It is possible that reduced rates of nitrogen fixation in the presence of hydrogenase are due to O₂ depletion caused by the hydrogen oxidizing, since the oxygen pressure in the air appears to be a limiting factor of symbiotic nitrogen fixation in the soybean.     

Rhizobium japonicum Serogroup and Hydrogenase Phenotype Distribution in 12 States

A survey was conducted in 1980 on 972 isolates of Rhizobium japonicum obtained from 65 soybean field locations in 12 states. Isolates were examined for the hydrogenase (Hup) phenotype and somatic serogroup identity. Only 20% of the isolates were Hup⁺, with a majority of Hup⁻ isolates occurring in 10 of the 12 states. The most predominant serogroup was 31 (21.5%), followed by 123 (13.6%). Although most serogroups contained a majority of Hup⁻ isolates, marked differences occurred. None of the isolates in serogroup 135 were Hup⁺, but 93% of the isolates in serogroup 122 were Hup⁺. The serogroups with relatively high frequencies of Hup⁺ isolates (122 and 110) constitute only a small part (<5% each) of the R. japonicum field population in the 12 states.     

Symbiotic efficiency of Hup+ and Hup− strains ofRhizobium japonicum

Summary Relative efficiency of Hup⁺ and Hup^– R. japonicum strains with Pusa 16 cultivar of soybean was studied. Inoculation with the Hup⁺ strain (A 1014) reduced the protein content in grain as compared to uninoculated control.     

The Relationship between H(2) Evolution and Acetylene Reduction in Pisum sativum-Rhizobium leguminosarum Symbioses Differing in Uptake Hydrogenase Activity

Peas (Pisum sativum L.) were inoculated with strains of Rhizobium leguminosarum having different levels of uptake hydrogenase (Hup) activity and were grown in sterile Leonard jars under controlled conditions. Rates of H₂ evolution and acetylene reduction were determined for intact nodulated roots at intervals after the onset of darkness or after removal of the shoots. Hup activity was estimated using treatment plants or equivalent plants from the growth chamber, by measuring the uptake of H₂ or ³H₂ in the presence of acetylene. In all cases, the rate of H₂ evolution was a continuous function of the rate of acetylene reduction. In symbioses with no demonstrable Hup activity, H₂ evolution increased in direct proportion to acetylene reduction and the slopes were similar with the Hup⁻ strains NA502 and 128C79. Hup activity was similar in strains 128C30 and 128C52 but significantly lower in strain 128C54. With these strains, the slopes of the H₂ evolution versus acetylene reduction curves initially increased with acetylene reduction, but became constant and similar to those for the Hup⁻ strains at high rates of acetylene reduction. On these parallel portions of the curves, the decreases in H₂ evolution by Hup⁺ strains were similar in magnitude to their H₂-saturated rates of Hup activity. The curvilinear relationship between H₂ evolution and acetylene reduction for a representative Hup⁺ strain (128C52) was the same, regardless of the experimental conditions used to vary the nitrogenase activity.     

Conserved Plasmid Hydrogen-Uptake (hup)-Specific Sequences within Hup+Rhizobium leguminosarum Strains

Thirteen Rhizobium leguminosarum strains previously reported as H₂-uptake hydrogenase positive (Hup⁺) or negative (Hup⁻) were analyzed for the presence and conservation of DNA sequences homologous to cloned Bradyrhizobium japonicum hup-specific DNA from cosmid pHU1 (M. A. Cantrell, R. A. Haugland, and H. J. Evans, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 80:181-185, 1983). The Hup phenotype of these strains was reexamined by determining hydrogenase activity induced in bacteroids from pea nodules. Five strains, including H₂ oxidation-ATP synthesis-coupled and -uncoupled strains, induced significant rates of H₂-uptake hydrogenase activity and contained DNA sequences homologous to three probe DNA fragments (5.9-kilobase [kb] HindIII, 2.9-kb EcoRI, and 5.0-kb EcoRI) from pHU1. The pattern of genomic DNA HindIII and EcoRI fragments with significant homology to each of the three probes was identical in all five strains regardless of the H₂-dependent ATP generation trait. The restriction fragments containing the homology totalled about 22 kb of DNA common to the five strains. In all instances the putative hup sequences were located on a plasmid that also contained nif genes. The molecular sizes of the identified hup-sym plasmids ranged between 184 and 212 megadaltons. No common DNA sequences homologous to B. japonicum hup DNA were found in genomic DNA from any of the eight remaining strains showing no significant hydrogenase activity in pea bacteroids. These results suggest that the identified DNA region contains genes essential for hydrogenase activity in R. leguminosarum and that its organization is highly conserved within Hup⁺ strains in this symbiotic species.     

Development and Partial Characterization of Nearly Isogenic Pea Lines (Pisum sativum L.) that Alter Uptake Hydrogenase Activity in Symbiotic Rhizobium

Some Rhizobium bacteria have H₂-uptake (Hup) systems that oxidize H₂ evolved from nitrogenase in leguminous root nodules. Pea (Pisum sativum L.) cultivars `JI1205' and `Alaska' produce high Hup (Hup⁺⁺) and moderate Hup (Hup⁺) phenotypes, respectively, in Rhizobium leguminosarum 128C53. The physiological significance and biochemical basis of this host plant genetic effect are unknown. The purpose of this investigation was to advance basic Hup studies by developing nearly isogenic lines of peas that alter Hup phenotypes in R. leguminosarum strains containing hup genes. Eight pairs of nearly isogenic pea lines that produce Hup⁺⁺ and Hup⁺ phenotypes in R. leguminosarum 128C53 were identified in 173 F₂-derived F₆ families produced from crosses between JI1205 and Alaska. Tests with the pea isolines and three strains of hup-containing R. leguminosarum showed that the isolines altered Hup activity significantly (P ≤ 0.05) in 19 of 24 symbiotic combinations. Analyses of Hup phenotypes in F₆ families, the F₁ population, and two backcrosses suggested involvement of a single genetic locus. Three of the eight pairs of isolines were identified as being suitable for physiological studies, because the two lines in each pair showed similar growth, N assimilation, and flowering traits under nonsymbiotic conditions. Tests of those lines under N₂-dependent conditions with isogenic Hup⁺ and negligible Hup (Hup⁻) mutants of R. leguminosarum 128C53 showed that, in symbioses with Hup⁺ rhizobia, two out of three Hup⁺⁺ pea lines decreased N₂ fixation relative to Hup⁺ peas. In one of those cases, however, the Hup⁺⁺ plant line also decreased fixation by Hup⁻ rhizobia. When results were averaged across all rhizobia tested, Hup⁺ pea isolines had 8.2% higher dry weight (P ≤ 0.05) and fixed 12.6% more N₂ (P ≤ 0.05) than Hup⁺⁺ isolines. Pea lines described here may help identify host plant factors that influence rhizobial Hup activity and should assist in clarifying how Hup systems influence other physiological processes.     

Uptake Hydrogenase (Hup) in Common Bean (Phaseolus vulgaris) Symbioses

Strains of Rhizobium forming nitrogen-fixing symbioses with common bean were systematically examined for the presence of the uptake hydrogenase (hup) structural genes and expression of uptake hydrogenase (Hup) activity. DNA with homology to the hup structural genes of Bradyrhizobium japonicum was present in 100 of 248 strains examined. EcoRI fragments with molecular sizes of approximately 20.0 and 2.2 kb hybridized with an internal SacI fragment, which contains part of both bradyrhizobial hup structural genes. The DNA with homology to the hup genes was located on pSym of one of the bean rhizobia. Hup activity was observed in bean symbioses with 13 of 30 strains containing DNA homologous with the hup structural genes. However, the Hup activity was not sufficient to eliminate hydrogen evolution from the nodules. Varying the host plant with two of the Hup⁺ strains indicated that expression of Hup activity was host regulated, as has been reported with soybean, pea, and cowpea strains.     

Enrichment for Hydrogen-Oxidizing Acinetobacter spp. in the Rhizosphere of Hydrogen-Evolving Soybean Root Nodules

Field soybean plants were inoculated with Hup⁺ wild-type or H₂ uptake-negative (Hup⁻) mutants of Bradyrhizobium japonicum. For two consecutive summers we found an enrichment for acinetobacters associated with the surfaces of the H₂-evolving nodules. Soybean root nodules that evolved H₂ had up to 12 times more Acinetobacter spp. bacteria associated with their surfaces than did nodules incapable of evolving H₂. All of the newly isolated strains identified as Acinetobacter obtained from the surfaces of root nodules, as well as known established Acinetobacter strains, were capable of oxidizing H₂, a property not previously described for this alkane-degrading soil bacterium.     

H2-Recycling system in mungbean Rhizobium in relation to N2-fixation

Thirty isolates of mungbean Rhizobium were tested for the presence of H₂-recycling system. All the isolates were preliminary screened for detecting H₂-recycling system in free culture using triphenyltetrazolium chloride reduction as screening procedure. The isolates which reduced the dye rapidly at early stages of growth were found to recycle hydrogen both in vivo as well as in vitro. Nitrogen fixing efficiency of hydrogenase positive, hydrogenase negative isolates and Hup^– mutants was compared by green house experiments. There was 13–56% increase in dry matter and 21–46% increase in total nitrogen of the plants inoculated with H₂-recycling isolates over the plants inoculated with non-recycling isolates. There was reduction in dry matter and total nitrogen content of the plants inoculated with Hup^– mutants as compared to plants inoculated with wild type strain. The per cent decrease due to inoculation with Hup^– mutants over wild type strain was 19–22 and 20–26 of dry weight and total nitrogen in plants, respectively.Abbreviations TTC triphenyltetrazolium chloride     

A Comparative Study of the Physiology of Symbioses Formed by Rhizobium japonicum with Glycine max, Vigna unguiculata, and Macroptilium atropurpurem

Although Rhizobium japonicum nodulates Vigna unguiculata and Macroptilium atropurpurem, little is known about the physiology of these symbioses. In this study, strains of R. japonicum of varying effectiveness on soybean were examined. The nonhomologous hosts were nodulated by all the strains tested, but effectiveness was not related to that of the homologous host. On siratro, compared to soybean, many strains reversed their relative effectiveness ranking. Both siratro and cowpea produced more dry matter with standard cowpea rhizobia CB756 and 176A22 than with the strains of R. japonicum. Strains USDA33 and USDA74 were more effective with siratro and cowpea than with soybean. The strain USDA122 expressed high rates of hydrogenase activity in symbiosis with the cowpea as well as the soybean host. The strains USDA61 and USDA74 expressed low levels of hydrogenase activity in symbiosis with cowpea, but no activity was found with soybean. Our results indicate host influence for the expression of hydrogenase activity, and suggest the possibility of host influence of nitrogenase for the allocation of electrons to N₂ and H⁺.     

Symbiotic Expression of Cosmid-Borne Bradyrhizobium japonicum Hydrogenase Genes

The expression of cosmid-borne Bradyrhizobium japonicum hydrogenase genes in alfalfa, clover, and soybean nodules harboring Rhizobium transconjugants was studied. Cosmid pHU52 conferred hydrogen uptake (Hup) activity in both free-living bacteria and in nodules on the different plant hosts, although in nodules the instability of the cosmid resulted in low levels of Hup activity. In contrast, cosmid pHU1, which does not confer Hup activity on free-living bacteria, gave a Hup⁺ phenotype in nodules on alfalfa and soybean. Nodules formed by B. japonicum USDA 123Spc(pHU1) recycled about 90% of nitrogenase-mediated hydrogen evolution. Both subunits of hydrogenase (30- and 60-kilodalton polypeptides) were detected in enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays of bacteroid preparations from nodules harboring B. japonicum strains with pHU1 or pHU52. Neither pHU53 nor pLAFR1 conferred detectable Hup activity in either nodules or free-living bacteria. Based on the physical maps of pHU1 and pHU52, it is suggested that a 5.5-kilobase EcoRI fragment unique to pHU52 contains a gene or part of a gene required for Hup activity in free-living bacteria but not in nodules. This conclusion is supported by the observation that two Tn5 insertions in the chromosome of B. japonicum USDA 122DES obtained by marker exchange with Tn5-mutagenized pHU1 abolished Hup activity in free-living bacteria but not in nodules.     

Nitrate inhibition of legume nodule growth and activity : I. Long term studies with a continuous supply of nitrate

The synthesis and accumulation of nitrite has been suggested as a causative factor in the inhibition of legume nodules supplied with nitrate. Plants were grown in sand culture with a moderate level of nitrate (2.1 to 6.4 millimolar) supplied continuously from seed germination to 30 to 50 days after planting. In a comparison of nitrate treatments, a highly significant negative correlation between nitrite concentration in soybean (Glycine max [L.] Merr.) nodules and nodule fresh weight per shoot dry weight was found even when bacteroids lacked nitrate reductase (NR). However, in a comparison of two Rhizobium japonicum strains, there was only 12% as much nitrite in nodules formed by NR⁻R. japonicum as in nodules formed by NR⁺R. japonicum, and growth and acetylene reduction activity of both types of nodules was about equally inhibited. In a comparison of eight other NR⁺ and NR⁻R. japonicum strains, and a comparison of G. max, Phaseolus vulgaris, and Pisum sativum, the concentration of nitrite in nodules was unrelated to nodule weight per plant or to specific acetylene reduction activity. The very small concentration of nitrite found in P. vulgaris nodules (0.05 micrograms NO₂⁻-N per gram fresh weight) was probably below that required for the inhibition of nitrogenase based on published in vitro experiments, and yet the specific acetylene reduction activity was inhibited 83% by nitrate. The overall results do not support the idea that nitrite plays a role in the inhibition of nodule growth and nitrogenase activity by nitrate.     

Host Plant Cultivar Effects on Hydrogen Evolution by Rhizobium leguminosarum

The effect of host plant cultivar on H₂ evolution by root nodules was examined in symbioses between Pisum sativum L. and selected strains of Rhizobium leguminosarum. Hydrogen evolution from root nodules containing Rhizobium represents the sum of H₂ produced by the nitrogenase enzyme complex and H₂ oxidized by any uptake hydrogenase present in those bacterial cells. Relative efficiency (RE) calculated as RE = 1 − (H₂ evolved in air/C₂ H₂ reduced) did not vary significantly among `Feltham First,' `Alaska,' and `JI1205' peas inoculated with R. leguminosarum strain 300, which lacks uptake hydrogenase activity (Hup⁻). That observation suggests that the three host cultivars had no effect on H₂ production by nitrogenase. However, RE of strain 128C53 was significantly (P ≤ 0.05) greater in symbiosis with cultivar JI1205 than in root nodules of Feltham First. At a similar rate of C₂H₂ reduction on a whole-plant basis, nearly 24 times more H₂ was evolved from the Feltham First/128C53 symbiosis than from the JI1205/128C53 association. Root nodules from the Alaska/128C53 symbiosis had an intermediate RE over the entire study period, which extended from 21 to 36 days after planting. Direct assays of uptake hydrogenase by two methods showed significant (P ≤ 0.05) host cultivar effects on H₂ uptake capacity of both strain 128C53 and the genetically related strain 3960. The ³H₂ incorporation assay showed that strains 128C53 and 3960 in symbiosis with Feltham First had about 10% of the uptake hydrogenase activity measured in root nodules of Alaska or JI1205. These data are the first demonstration of significant host plant effects on rhizobial uptake hydrogenase in a single plant species.     

Occurrence of H(2)-Uptake Hydrogenases in Bradyrhizobium sp. (Lupinus) and Their Expression in Nodules of Lupinus spp. and Ornithopus compressus

Fifty-four strains of Bradyrhizobium sp. (Lupinus) from worldwide collections were screened by a colony hybridization method for the presence of DNA sequences homologous to the structural genes of the Bradyrhizobium japonicum hydrogenase. Twelve strains exhibited strong colony hybridization signals, and subsequent Southern blot hybridization experiments showed that they fell into two different groups on the basis of the pattern of EcoRI fragments containing the homology to the hup probe. All strains in the first group (UPM860, UPM861, and 750) expressed uptake hydrogenase activity in symbiosis with Lupinus albus, Lupinus angustifolius, Lupinus luteus, and Ornithopus compressus, but both the rate of H₂ uptake by bacteroids and the relative efficiency of N₂ fixation (RE = 1 - [H₂ evolved in air/acetylene reduced]) by nodules were markedly affected by the legume host. L. angustifolius was the less permissive host for hydrogenase expression in symbiosis with the three strains (average RE = 0.76), and O. compressus was the more permissive (average RE = 1.0). None of the strains in the second group expressed hydrogenase activity in lupine nodules, and only one exhibited low H₂-uptake activity in symbiosis with O. compressus. The inability of these putative Hup⁺ strains to induce hydrogenase activity in lupine nodules is discussed on the basis of the legume host effect. Among the 42 strains showing no homology to the B. japonicum hup-specific probe in the colony hybridization assay, 10 were examined in symbiosis with L. angustifolius. The average RE for these strains was 0.51. However, one strain, IM43B, exhibited high RE values (higher than 0.80) and high levels of hydrogenase activity in symbiosis with L. angustifolius, L. albus, and L. luteus. In Southern blot hybridization experiments, no homology was detected between the B. japonicum hup-specific DNA probe and total DNA from vegetative cells or bacteroids from strain IM43B even under low stringency hybridization conditions. We conclude from these results that strain IM43B contains hup DNA sequences different from those in B. japonicum and in other lupine rhizobia strains.     

Genetic and physical mapping of an hydrogenase gene cluster from Rhodobacter capsulatus

Summary An hydrogenase-deficient (Hup^–) mutant of Rhodobacter capsulatus was obtained by adventitious insertion of IS21 DNA into an hydrogenase structural gene (hup) of the wild-type strain 1310. The resulting Hup^– mutant, strain JP91, selected by its inability to grow autotrophically (Aut^– phenotype) together with other Hup^– mutant strains obtained by classical ethyl methane sulphonate mutagenesis were used in R plasmid-mediated conjugation experiments to map the hup/aut loci on the chromosome of R. capsulatus. The hup genes tested in this study were found to cluster on the chromosome in the proximity of the his-1 marker. A cluster of hup genes comprising the structural genes was isolated from a gene bank constructed in the cosmid vector pHC79 with 40 kb insert DNA. The clustered hup genes, characterized by hybridization studies and complementation analyses of the R. capsulatus Hup^– mutants, span 15–20 kb of DNA.     

Ecology of Hup+ Rhizobium strains of cow pea miscellany: native frequency and competence

Rhizobium strains nodulating summer legumes cow pea [Vigna unguiculata (L.)], green gram [V. radiata (L.) (Wilczek)], black gram [V. mungo (L.) (Hepper)] and cluster bean [Cyamopsis tetragonoloba (L.) (Taub)] and a winter legume chick pea [Cicer arietinum (L.)] were surveyed in the Northern Plains of India and screened for hydrogenase activity to determine distribution of Hup character in the native ecosystem. It was observed that 56% of the Rhizobium strains of summer legumes were Hup⁺ whereas that of the winter legume, chick pea, were all Hup^-. Ex planta acetylene reduction activity was observed in most of the Hup⁺ but not in the Hup^- strains of any of the host species. In summer legume, mixed inoculation of Hup⁺ and Hup^- strains, under sterilized as well as unsterilized soil conditions, showed that the host species were predominantly nodulated with Hup⁺ strain.