Asynchrony and Commitment to Die during Apoptosis

Time lapse video microscopy is used to study the chronology of morphological changes and commitment to die in individual PC12 cells after induction of apoptosis. Cell death is highly asynchronous occurring over a 2- to 3-day period following serum removal; however, all cells go through three characteristic morphological phases irrespective of the time they die following serum removal. During phase 1, which lasts from 2 to 44 h, cells maintain normal morphology. Phase 2 is characterized by plasma membrane bubbling which lasts from 10 min to 40 h. Phase 3 represents the active or execution phase of apoptosis and involves dynamic whole cell body blebbing. Phase 3/execution phase has a restricted duration, lasting 96 ± 5 min. At the end of the execution phase of apoptosis, cells die. The inherently asynchronous nature of cell death is still present in cells that are synchronized following mitosis. Daughter cells enter phase 2 synchronously but remain in phase 2 for varying periods and die at different times. Addition of serum 24–48 h after initiating apoptosis blocks death of 89% of cells in phase 1, 79% in phase 2, and 0% in phase 3. Serum rescue experiments are consistent with cells committing to die about 2–3 h prior to the onset of phase 3 (execution phase of apoptosis). These studies indicate that although apoptosis is an asynchronous process it can be defined in terms of reproducible morphological changes that can be used to place other events, such as the commitment to die, in a temporal sequence.     

Induction of programmed cell death in a dorsal root ganglia × neuroblastoma cell line

Growth factor-dependent neurons die when they are deproved of their specific growth factor. This “programmed” cell death (PCD) requires macromolecular synthesis and is distinct from necrotic cell death. To investigate the mechanisms involved in neuronal PCD, we have studied the sequence of events that occur when a neuronal cell line (F-11: Mouse neuroblastoma X rat dorsal root ganglia) is deprived of serum in a manner analogous to growth factor deprivation from neurons. Protein synthesis was inhibited within the first 8 h of serum deprivation, while DNA cleavage into nucleosome ladders was prominent by 24 h. The DNA cleavage could be inhibited by cycloheximide, consistent with a requirement for protein synthesis. In contrast, mitochondrial function was not compromised by serum deprivation. Rather, the cells appeared to be metabolically activated after serum removal as shown by an increased reduction of MTT by mitochondrial dehydrogenases and an increase in cellular autofluorescence, which is thought to be due to elevated levels of NADH and flavoproteins. Assessment of cell viability by propidium iodide staining showed no indication of cell death within 24 h. After 48 h of serum deprivation, cells decreased in size and increased propidium iodide uptake. Thus, serum deprivation activates PCD in F-11 cells and may be a useful model to study the intracellular events responsible for PCD. © 1993 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Searching the point of no return in Helicobacter pylori life: necrosis and/or programmed death?

AIMS: Ultrastructural and molecular studies to support the hypothesis of programmed cell death in Helicobacter pylori were conducted. METHODS AND RESULTS: Evidence of programmed death in H. pylori is provided through electron microscopic detection and cytochemical labelling of electrondense bodies (EDB), containing packaged DNA in coccoid cells, resembling micronuclei of apoptotic eukaryotic cells. This morphological evidence is also supported by DNA cleavage in homogeneous fragments of about 100 base pairs. Programmed cell death was observed in H. pylori cultures at 37 degrees C, with a maximum of 37.5% of EDB coccoid cells after 7 days. The non-permissive temperature of 4 degrees C anticipated this process, with 40% of EDB coccoid forms within 3 days, and it remained substantially unaffected during the observation time of 14 days. CONCLUSION: In these experiments, deprivation of nutrients and a non-permissive temperature acted as a powerful trigger for programmed cell death. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: Helicobacter pylori bacterial populations, under stressing stimuli, can respond with programmed cell suicide as a means of species preservation.     

Extracellular ATP as a trigger for apoptosis or programmed cell death

Extracellular ATP is shown here to induce programmed cell death (or apoptosis) in thymocytes and certain tumor cell lines. EM studies indicate that the ATP-induced death of thymocytes and susceptible tumor cells follows morphological changes usually associated with glucocorticoid-induced apoptosis of thymocytes. These changes include condensation of chromatin, blebbing of the cell surface, and breakdown of the nucleus. Cytotoxicity assays using double-labeled cells show that ATP-mediated cell lysis is accompanied by fragmentation of the target cell DNA. DNA fragmentation can be set off by ATP but not the nonhydrolysable analogue ATP gamma S nor other nucleoside-5'-triphosphates. ATP-induced DNA fragmentation but not ATP-induced 51Cr release can be blocked in cells pretreated with inhibitors of protein or RNA synthesis or the endonuclease inhibitor, zinc; whereas pretreatment with calmidazolium, a potent calmodulin antagonist, blocks both DNA fragmentation and 51Cr release. The biochemical and morphological changes caused by ATP are preceded by a rapid increase in the cytoplasmic calcium of the susceptible cell. Calcium fluxes by themselves, however, are not sufficient to cause apoptosis, as the pore-forming protein, perforin, causes cell lysis without DNA fragmentation or the morphological changes associated with apoptosis. Taken together, these results indicate that ATP can cause cell death through two independent mechanisms, one of which, requiring an active participation on the part of the cell, takes place through apoptosis.     

Autophagy and Cancer Therapy

Autophagy is a dynamic process of protein degradation which is typically observed during nutrient deprivation. Recently, interest in autophagy has been renewed among oncologists, because different types of cancer cells undergo autophagy after various anticancer therapies. This type of non-apoptotic cell death has been documented mainly by observing morphological changes, e.g., numerous autophagic vacuoles in the cytoplasm of dying cells. Thus, autophagic cell death is considered programmed cell death type II, whereas apoptosis is programmed cell death type I. These two types of cell death are predominantly distinctive, but many studies demonstrate cross-talk between them. Whether autophagy in cancer cells causes death or protects cells is controversial. In multiple studies, autophagy has been inhibited pharmacologically or genetically, resulting in contrasting outcomes—survival or death—depending on the specific context. Interestingly, the regulatory pathways of autophagy share several molecules with the oncogenic pathways activated by tyrosine kinase receptors. Tumor suppressors such as Beclin 1, PTEN, and p53 also play an important role in autophagy induction. Taken together, these accumulating data may lead to development of new cancer therapies that manipulate autophagy.     

Autophagy and cancer therapy

Autophagy is a dynamic process of protein degradation, which is typically observed during nutrient deprivation. Recently, interest in autophagy has been renewed among oncologists, because different types of cancer cells undergo autophagy after various anticancer therapies. This type of nonapoptotic cell death has been documented mainly by observing morphological changes, e.g., numerous autophagic vacuoles in the cytoplasm of dying cells. Thus, autophagic cell death is considered programmed cell death type II, whereas apoptosis is programmed cell death type I. These two types of cell death are predominantly distinctive, but many studies demonstrate cross-talk between them. Whether autophagy in cancer cells causes death or protects cells is controversial. In multiple studies, autophagy has been inhibited pharmacologically or genetically, resulting in contrasting outcomes--survival or death--depending on the specific context. Interestingly, the regulatory pathways of autophagy share several molecules with the oncogenic pathways activated by tyrosine kinase receptors. Tumor suppressors such as Beclin 1, PTEN and p53 also play an important role in autophagy induction. Taken together, these accumulating data may lead to development of new cancer therapies that manipulate autophagy.     

How apoptotic cells aid in the removal of their own cold dead bodies

Apoptotic cell clearance facilitates the removal of aged, damaged, infected or dangerous cells although minimizing perturbation of surrounding tissues, and is a vital process in the development and homeostasis of multicellular organisms. Importantly, failure to correctly execute programmed cell death and subsequent corpse clearance is broadly associated with chronic inflammatory and/or autoimmune diseases such as systemic lupus erythematosus. Apoptotic cells develop dramatic morphological changes including contraction, membrane blebbing and apoptotic body formation, which were among the first and most readily identifiable features of cellular suicide. However, understanding the purpose of apoptotic cell morphological changes has proven to be elusive, and recent studies have made somewhat surprising, and occasionally opposing, conclusions about the contribution of blebbing to phagocytic clearance and prevention of inflammatory/autoimmune disease. We review the evidence indicating how apoptotic blebs actively promote corpse recognition, uptake, and generation of auto-reactive antibodies.     

Induction of an oligodendroglial enzyme in C-6 glioma cells maintained at high density or in serum-free medium.

The relationship between cell density and the activity of 2':3'-cyclic nucleotide 3'-phosphohydrolase (CNP), an enzyme believed to be specific to oligodendroglial cells and myelin in the brain, has been studied in cultured C-6 glioma cells. Over a 12-day period, the specific activity of CNP underwent a 4-fold increase in conjunction with an increase in the cell density (total protein/flask) and a decline in the growth rate of the cultures. In contrast, the specific activity of Na+,K+-ATPase was not influenced by cell density. Experiments with cultures seeded at different initial densities indicated that the increase in CNP activity coincided with the attainment of a specific cell density rather than with the length of time that the cells were maintained in culture. Arrest of cell proliferation in non-confluent C-6 cells by means of thymidine blockade was not sufficient to cause an increase in the activity of CNP; however, removal of serum from the culture medium resulted in a 3-fold induction of the enzyme in the absence of a high degree of cell contact. The induction of CNP in cells maintained in serum-free medium paralleled the development of a series of distinct morphological changes reminiscent of glial differentiation, which occurred within 48 hours after removal of the serum. Inhibition of protein synthesis by cycloheximide prevented the induction of CNP in serum-free cultures. The demonstration that an enhancement of an oligodendroglial characteristic in C-6 glioma cells can be obtained by growing the cells to high density or by removing serum from the medium, provides further support for the suggestion that these cells may be analogous to the glial stem cells present in the developing brain.     

DNA fragmentation induced in macrophages by gliotoxin does not require protein synthesis and is preceded by raised inositol triphosphate levels.

We have shown that the immunomodulating agent gliotoxin induces DNA fragmentation in macrophages characteristic of programmed cell death or apoptosis (Waring, P., Eichner, R. D., Mullbacher, A., and Sjaarda, A. (1988) J. Biol. Chem, 263, 18493-18499). In addition, morphological changes and DNA fragmentation characteristic of apoptosis are induced in 48 h concanavalin A-stimulated T blasts by gliotoxin and these changes are inhibited by Zn2+ (Waring, P., Egan, M., Braithwaite, A., Mullbacher, A., and Sjaarda, A. (1990) Int. J. Immunopharmacol., in press). We have studied the effects of actinomycin D and the protein synthesis inhibitor cycloheximide on apoptosis induced by gliotoxin in these cells, and these studies demonstrate no effect on apoptosis induced by gliotoxin. Cycloheximide and actinomycin D alone induce DNA fragmentation in these cells. Gliotoxin itself proved to be a potent inhibitor of protein synthesis. The fragmentation caused by cycloheximide correlated with the extent of protein synthesis inhibition. The toxin ricin also induced DNA fragmentation in T blasts characteristic of apoptosis. These results indicate that protein synthesis is not required for induction of apoptosis in macrophages or T blasts by gliotoxin. Gliotoxin caused elevated levels of inositol triphosphate in treated macrophages which may be related to mobilization of Ca2+ levels during apoptosis.     

Regulation of programmed death in erythroid progenitor cells by erythropoietin: effects of calcium and of protein and RNA syntheses.

Erythropoietin (EPO) retards DNA breakdown characteristic of programmed cell death (apoptosis) and promotes survival in erythroid progenitor cells. The mechanism by which EPO inhibits programmed death is unknown. In the well-characterized model of glucocorticoid-treated thymocytes, activation of a Ca2+/Mg(2+)-sensitive endonuclease and new protein and RNA syntheses have been found necessary for apoptosis. We examined the effects of EPO on the free intracellular calcium ion concentration ([Ca2+]i), and the roles of Ca2+ and RNA and protein syntheses on DNA cleavage in erythroid progenitor cells. The murine model of erythroid differentiation using Friend leukemia virus-infected proerythroblasts (FVA cells) was used. EPO did not affect the [Ca2+]i in FVA cells. Decreasing [Ca2+]i by extracellular Ca2+ chelation with EGTA facilitated DNA breakdown. Increasing [Ca2+]i with the calcium ionophore 4-bromo-A23187 increased DNA cleavage; however, DNA fragments generated by high [Ca2+]i were much larger than those seen in the absence of EPO or presence of EGTA. Increased [Ca2+]i also inhibited DNA breakdown to small oligonucleosomal fragments characteristic of cells cultured without EPO. However, no concentration of ionophore protected the high molecular weight DNA as did EPO. Cycloheximide inhibited DNA breakdown in a dose dependent manner in cultures lacking EPO, but two other protein synthesis inhibitors, pactamycin and puromycin, did not prevent DNA breakdown. Inhibition of RNA synthesis with actinomycin D did not prevent DNA breakdown. Cells with morphological characteristics similar to those reported in other cells undergoing programmed death accumulated in EPO-derived cultures. These studies demonstrate that although DNA cleavage and morphological changes are common to apoptotic cells, the roles for Ca2+ and protein and RNA syntheses are not universal and suggest that apoptosis can be regulated by different biochemical mechanisms in different cell types.     

Developmental Block and Programmed Cell Death in Bos indicus Embryos: Effects of Protein Supplementation Source and Developmental Kinetics

The aims of this study were to determine if the protein source of the medium influences zebu embryo development and if developmental kinetics, developmental block and programmed cell death are related. The culture medium was supplemented with either fetal calf serum or bovine serum albumin. The embryos were classified as Fast (n = 1,235) or Slow (n = 485) based on the time required to reach the fourth cell cycle (48 h and 90 h post insemination - hpi -, respectively). The Slow group was further separated into two groups: those presenting exactly 4 cells at 48 hpi (Slow/4 cells) and those that reached the fourth cell cycle at 90 hpi (Slow). Blastocyst quality, DNA fragmentation, mitochondrial membrane potential and signs of apoptosis or necrosis were evaluated. The Slow group had higher incidence of developmental block than the Fast group. The embryos supplemented with fetal calf serum had lower quality. DNA fragmentation and mitochondrial membrane potential were absent in embryos at 48 hpi but present at 90 hpi. Early signs of apoptosis were more frequent in the Slow and Slow/4 cell groups than in the Fast group. We concluded that fetal calf serum reduces blastocyst development and quality, but the mechanism appears to be independent of DNA fragmentation. The apoptotic cells detected at 48 hpi reveal a possible mechanism of programmed cell death activation prior to genome activation. The apoptotic cells observed in the slow-developing embryos suggested a relationship between programmed cell death and embryonic developmental kinetics in zebu in vitro-produced embryos.     

Cyclosporin A, an Immunosuppressive Drug, Induces Programmed Cell Death in Rat C6 Glioma Cells by a Mechanism that Involves the AP-1 Transcription Factor

Abstract: Cyclosporin A (CsA) is a clinically important immunosuppressive drug widely used to prevent graft rejection following organ or bone marrow transplantation. Although there are reports of serious neurologic alterations associated with the use of the drug, the precise mechanism of its action on the CNS still remains unknown. We studied the effects of CsA on the growth of C6 glioma cells. We found that CsA inhibits the growth of C6 glioma cells in a dose-dependent manner and induces morphological changes such as shrinkage of the cell body and loss of extensions followed by cell death. The analysis of DNA from CsA-treated cells revealed a ladder-like pattern of fragmented DNA. Acridine orange staining showed the occurrence of apoptotic changes in nuclear morphology. Apoptotic morphological alterations were prevented by the treatment with cycloheximide. Altogether, our findings suggest that the CsA-induced cell death of C6 glioma cells bears all the features characteristic of programmed cell death. We also observed a significant increase in the DNA-binding activity of AP-1 during CsA-induced apoptosis. The AP-1 induction preceded the appearance of apoptotic, morphological changes and was accounted for by an increase in the expression of c-Jun protein. The occurrence of increased levels of AP-1 complex and c-Jun protein during CsA-induced programmed cell death suggests its involvement in the induction of apoptosis.     

Eggs to die for: cell death during Drosophila oogenesis

Extensive programmed cell death occurs in the female germline of many species ranging from C. elegans to humans. One purpose for germline apoptosis is to remove defective cells unable to develop into fertile eggs. In addition, recent work suggests that the death of specific germline cells may also play a vital role by providing essential nutrients to the surviving oocytes. In Drosophila, the genetic control of germline apoptosis and the proteins that carry out the death sentences are beginning to emerge from studies of female sterile mutations. These studies suggest that the morphological changes that occur during the late stages of Drosophila oogenesis may be initiated and driven by a modified form of programmed cell death.     

Protein synthesis,DNA degradation,and morphological changes during programmed cell death in labial glands of Manduca sexta

Labial glands of the tobacco hornworm Manduca sexta (Lepidoptera: Sphingiidae), homologues of Drosophila salivary glands, undergo programmed cell death (PCD) in a 4-day period during larva-to-pupa metamorphosis. The programmed death of the labial gland was examined by electron microscopy and measurement of protein synthesis as well as measurement of DNA synthesis, end-labeling of single strand breaks, and pulsed-field gel electrophoresis. One of the earliest changes observed is a sharp drop in synthesis of most proteins, coupled with synthesis of a glycine-rich protein, reminiscent of silk-like proteins. From a morphological standpoint, during the earliest phases the most prominent changes are the formation of small autophagic vacuoles containing ribosomes and an apparent focal dissolution of the membranes of the endoplasmic reticulum, whereas later changes include differing destruction at the lumenal and basal surfaces of the cell and erosion of the basement membrane. By the fourth day of metamorphosis, individual cells become rapidly vacuolated in a cell-independent manner. In the vacuolated cells on day 3, chromatin begins to coalesce. It is at this period that unequivocal nucleosomal ladders are seen and end-labeling in situ or electrophoretic techniques document single or double-strand breaks, respectively. DNA synthesis ceases shortly after the molt to the fifth instar, as detected by incorporation of tritiated thymidine and weak TUNEL labeling. Large size fragments of DNA are seen shortly after DNA synthesis ceases and thence throughout the instar, raising the possibility of potential limitations built into the cells before their final collapse. Dev. Genet. 21:249–257, 1997. © 1997 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

In situ localization of heat-shock and histone proteins in honey-bee (Apis mellifera l.) larvae infected with Paenibacillus larvae

The immunohistochemical localization of the heat shock proteins (Hsp70 and Hsp90) and histone protein in healthy and Paenibacillus larvae infected honeybee (Apis mellifera L.) larvae has been studied. Hsp70 was found in the nuclei and the cytoplasm of infected midgut, salivary gland cells and haemocytes, but not in uninfected larvae. Hsp90 was localized in both infected and uninfected cells. Exposed histone proteins were localized in the nuclei of dying uninfected cells undergoing programmed cell death. The distribution of histone protein in uninfected cells of midgut, salivary gland, and other tissues was nuclear and indicative of normal programmed cell death at levels between 1 and 5%.After applying histone protein antibodies to P. larvae infected honeybee larvae, the DAB based reaction product was located in the nuclei or immediate surroundings of all larval cells. The Hsp70, Hsp90 and histone protein distribution patterns are discussed in relation to the morphological, cytochemical and immunocytochemical characteristics of programmed cell death and pathological necrosis. Results produced by methyl green-pyronin staining confirm an elevation of RNA levels in normal programmed cell death and a reduced staining for RNA in necrotic infected cells.     

Inhibition of apoptosis in human tumour cells by okadaic acid.

Gamma-radiation, tetrandrine, bistratene A, and cisplatin were all found to induce pronounced morphological changes characteristic of apoptosis and extensive DNA fragmentation in the human BM13674 cell line 8 h after treatment. Apoptosis induced in BM13674 cells by these diverse agents was markedly inhibited by 1 microM okadaic acid, a tumour promoter that inhibits protein phosphatases 1 and 2A. This compound also inhibited the appearance of apoptosis in fresh human leukaemia cells that had been exposed to gamma-radiation. The inhibition of apoptosis was confirmed using fluorescence microscopy and DNA gel electrophoresis. Dephosphorylation of a limited number of proteins was shown to be associated with apoptosis and okadaic acid prevented these dephosphorylations. Previous studies on the BM13674 cell line showed that an inhibitor of protein synthesis failed to prevent apoptosis in these cells. The present data provides further support that posttranslational modification of proteins, in particular, phosphorylation/dephosphorylation status, plays an important role in inhibition/activation of programmed cell death in different human cells after exposure to several cytotoxic agents.     

Cyclical generation and degeneration of organs in a colonial urochordate involves crosstalk between old and new: a model for development and regeneration

Botryllus schlosseri is a colonial marine urochordate in which all adult organisms (called zooids) in a colony die synchronously by apoptosis (programmed cell death) in cyclical fashion. During this death phase called takeover, cell corpses within the dying organism are engulfed by circulating phagocytic cells. The "old" zooids and their organs are resorbed within 24-36 h (programmed cell removal). This process coincides temporally with the growth of asexually derived primary buds, that harbor a small number of undifferentiated cells, into mature zooids containing functional organs and tissues with the same body plan as adult zooids from which they budded. Within these colonies, all zooids share a ramifying network of extracorporeal blood vessels embedded in a gelatinous tunic. The underlying mechanisms regulating programmed cell death and programmed cell removal in this organism are unknown. In this study, we extirpated buds or zooids from B. schlosseri colonies in order to investigate the interplay that exists between buds, zooids, and the vascular system during takeover. Our findings indicate that, in the complete absence of buds (budectomy), organs from adult zooids underwent programmed cell death but were markedly impaired in their ability to be resorbed despite engulfment of zooid-derived cell corpses by phagocytes. However, when buds were removed from only half of the flower-shaped systems of zooids in a colony (hemibudectomy), the budectomized zooids were completely resorbed within 36-48 h following onset of programmed cell death. Furthermore, if hemibudectomies were carried out by using small colonies, leaving only a single functional bud, zooids from the old generation were also resorbed, albeit delayed to 48-60 h following onset of programmed cell death. This bud eventually reached functional maturity, but grew significantly larger in size than any control zooid, and exhibited hyperplasia. This finding strongly suggested that components of the dying zooid viscera could be reutilized by the developing buds, possibly as part of a colony-wide recycling mechanism. In order to test this hypothesis, zooids were surgically removed (zooidectomy) at the onset of takeover, and bud growth was quantitatively determined. In these zooidectomized colonies, bud growth was severely curtailed. In most solitary, long-lived animals, organs and tissues are maintained by processes of continual death and removal of aging cells counterbalanced by regeneration with stem and progenitor cells. In the colonial tunicate B. schlosseri, the same kinds of processes ensure the longevity of the colony (an animal) by cycles of death and regeneration of its constituent zooids (also animals).     

Programmed cell death in Bradysia hygida (Diptera, Sciaridae) salivary glands presents apoptotic features

In this work, we present biochemical and morphological evidence that the final steps of programmed cell death (PCD) in the salivary glands of the inferior Diptera, Bradysia hygida, present apoptotic characteristics. In B. hygida, elimination of salivary glands is preceded by the establishment of a typical pattern of protein synthesis; increase in caspase activity; decrease in cell volume; nuclear pyknosis; nuclear DNA breakage; changes in the actin cytoskeleton; and most importantly, destruction of giant cells via formation of apoptotic bodies containing broken DNA or cytoplasm remains. Thus, elimination of B. hygida salivary glands by this process suggests that such mode of PCD is also involved in the destruction of entire organs in insects and, therefore, adds more complexity to the regulation of tissue elimination during development.