Modular construction for function of a ribonucleoprotein enzyme: the catalytic domain of Bacillus subtilis RNase P complexed with B. subtilis RNase P protein

The bacterial RNase P holoenzyme catalyzes the formation of the mature 5′-end of tRNAs and is composed of an RNA and a protein subunit. Among the two folding domains of the RNase P RNA, the catalytic domain (C-domain) contains the active site of this ribozyme. We investigated specific binding of the Bacillus subtilis C-domain with the B.subtilis RNase P protein and examined the catalytic activity of this C-domain–P protein complex. The C-domain forms a specific complex with the P protein with a binding constant of ~0.1 µM. The C-domain–P protein complex and the holoenzyme are equally efficient in cleaving single-stranded RNA (~0.9 min^–1 at pH 7.8) and substrates with a hairpin–loop 3′ to the cleavage site (~40 min^–1). The holoenzyme reaction is much more efficient with a pre-tRNA substrate, binding at least 100-fold better and cleaving 10–500 times more efficiently. These results demonstrate that the RNase P holoenzyme is functionally constructed in three parts. The catalytic domain alone contains the active site, but has little specificity and affinity for most substrates. The specificity and affinity for the substrate is generated by either the specificity domain of RNase P RNA binding to a T stem–loop-like hairpin or RNase P protein binding to a single-stranded RNA. This modular construction may be exploited to obtain RNase P-based ribonucleoprotein complexes with altered substrate specificity.     

Molecular modeling of the three-dimensional structure of the bacterial RNase P holoenzyme

Bacterial ribonuclease P (RNase P), an enzyme involved in tRNA maturation, consists of a catalytic RNA subunit and a protein cofactor. Comparative phylogenetic analysis and molecular modeling have been employed to derive secondary and tertiary structure models of the RNA subunits from Escherichia coli (type A) and Bacillus subtilis (type B) RNase P. The tertiary structure of the protein subunit of B.subtilis and Staphylococcus aureus RNase P has recently been determined. However, an understanding of the structure of the RNase P holoenzyme (i.e. the ribonucleoprotein complex) is lacking. We have now used an EDTA-Fe-based footprinting approach to generate information about RNA-protein contact sites in E.coli RNase P. The footprinting data, together with results from other biochemical and biophysical studies, have furnished distance constraints, which in turn have enabled us to build three-dimensional models of both type A and B versions of the bacterial RNase P holoenzyme in the absence and presence of its precursor tRNA substrate. These models are consistent with results from previous studies and provide both structural and mechanistic insights into the functioning of this unique catalytic RNP complex.     

Interaction of the Bacillus subtilis RNase P with the 30S ribosomal subunit

Ribonuclease P (RNase P) is a ribozyme required for the 5' maturation of all tRNA. RNase P and the ribosome are the only known ribozymes conserved in all organisms. We set out to determine whether this ribonucleoprotein enzyme interacts with other cellular components, which may imply other functions for this conserved ribozyme. Incubation of the Bacillus subtilis RNase P holoenzyme with fractionated B. subtilis cellular extracts and purified ribosomal subunits results in the formation of a gel-shifted complex with the 30S ribosomal subunit at a binding affinity of approximately 40 nM in 0.1 M NH(4)Cl and 10 mM MgCl(2). The complex does not form with the RNase P RNA alone and is disrupted by a mRNA mimic polyuridine, but is stable in the presence of high concentrations of mature tRNA. Endogenous RNase P can also be detected in the 30S ribosomal fraction. Cleavage of a pre-tRNA substrate by the RNase P holoenzyme remains the same in the presence of the 30S ribosome, but the cleavage of an artificial non-tRNA substrate is inhibited eightfold. Hydroxyl radical protection and chemical modification identify several protected residues located in a highly conserved region in the RNase P RNA. A single mutation within this region significantly reduces binding, providing strong support on the specificity of the RNase P-30S ribosome complex. Our results also suggest that the dimeric form of the RNase P is primarily involved in 30S ribosome binding. We discuss several models on a potential function of the RNase P-30S ribosome complex.     

Protein activation of a ribozyme: the role of bacterial RNase P protein

Bacterial ribonuclease P (RNase P) belongs to a class of enzymes that utilize both RNAs and proteins to perform essential cellular functions. The bacterial RNase P protein is required to activate bacterial RNase P RNA in vivo, but previous studies have yielded contradictory conclusions regarding its specific functions. Here, we use biochemical and biophysical techniques to examine all of the proposed functions of the protein in both Escherichia coli and Bacillus subtilis RNase P. We demonstrate that the E. coli protein, but not the B. subtilis protein, stabilizes the global structure of RNase P RNA, although both proteins influence holoenzyme dimer formation and precursor tRNA recognition to different extents. By comparing each protein in complex with its cognate and noncognate RNA, we show that differences between the two types of holoenzymes reside primarily in the RNA and not the protein components of each. Our results reconcile previous contradictory conclusions regarding the role of the protein and support a model where the protein activates local RNA structures that manifest multiple holoenzyme properties.     

Analysis of substrate recognition by the ribonucleoprotein endonuclease RNase P

Ribonuclease P (RNase P), is a ribonucleoprotein complex that catalyzes the site-specific cleavage of pre-tRNA and a wide variety of other substrates. Although RNase P RNA is the catalytic subunit of the holoenzyme, the protein subunit plays a critical role in substrate binding. Thus, RNase P is an excellent model system for studying ribonucleoprotein function. In this review we describe methods applied to the in vitro study of substrate recognition by bacterial RNase P, covering general considerations of reaction conditions, quantitative measurement of substrate binding equilibria, enzymatic and chemical protection, cross-linking, modification interference, and analysis of site-specific substitutions. We describe application of these methods to substrate binding by RNase P RNA alone and experimental considerations for examining the holoenzyme. The combined use of these approaches has shown that the RNA and protein subunits cooperate to bind different portions of the substrate structure, with the RNA subunit predominantly interacting with the mature domain of tRNA and the protein interacting with the 5(') leader sequence. However, important questions concerning the interface between the two subunits and the coordination of RNA and protein subunits in binding and catalysis remain.     

Probing the architecture of the B. subtilis RNase P holoenzyme active site by cross-linking and affinity cleavage

Bacterial ribonuclease P (RNase P) is a ribonucleoprotein complex composed of one catalytic RNA (PRNA) and one protein subunit (P protein) that together catalyze the 5' maturation of precursor tRNA. High-resolution X-ray crystal structures of the individual P protein and PRNA components from several species have been determined, and structural models of the RNase P holoenzyme have been proposed. However, holoenzyme models have been limited by a lack of distance constraints between P protein and PRNA in the holoenzyme-substrate complex. Here, we report the results of extensive cross-linking and affinity cleavage experiments using single-cysteine P protein variants derivatized with either azidophenacyl bromide or 5-iodoacetamido-1,10-o-phenanthroline to determine distance constraints and to model the Bacillus subtilis holoenzyme-substrate complex. These data indicate that the evolutionarily conserved RNR motif of P protein is located near (<15 Angstroms) the pre-tRNA cleavage site, the base of the pre-tRNA acceptor stem and helix P4 of PRNA, the putative active site of the enzyme. In addition, the metal binding loop and N-terminal region of the P protein are proximal to the P3 stem-loop of PRNA. Studies using heterologous holoenzymes composed of covalently modified B. subtilis P protein and Escherichia coli M1 RNA indicate that P protein binds similarly to both RNAs. Together, these data indicate that P protein is positioned close to the RNase P active site and may play a role in organizing the RNase P active site.     

Ion dependence of the Bacillus subtilis RNase P reaction

The properties of the Bacillus subtilis RNase P are characterized with regard to the types and concentrations of monovalent and divalent ions required to potentiate precursor tRNA cleavage by the protein-RNA holoenzyme and the catalytic RNA alone. The ionic dependence of the RNase P RNA-catalyzed reaction in part seems due to a requirement for ion shielding between substrate and catalytic RNAs. The RNase P protein, which binds to RNA nonspecifically and tightly, likely serves, in part, as a cation screen. However, the character of the ion dependence of the RNA catalysis, the inhibition by high SO2-4 concentration, and potentiation by solvents suggest that RNA conformational transition may be involved in the reaction. It is proposed that the reason for catalysis by RNA in the RNase P reaction may be a requirement for fluidity in the structure of the catalyst, so that it can accommodate many tRNA substrates, which vary in their structural details.     

Pre-tRNA turnover catalyzed by the yeast nuclear RNase P holoenzyme is limited by product release

Ribonuclease P (RNase P) is a ribonucleoprotein that catalyzes the 5′ maturation of precursor transfer RNA in the presence of magnesium ions. The bacterial RNase P holoenzyme consists of one catalytically active RNA component and a single essential but catalytically inactive protein. In contrast, yeast nuclear RNase P is more complex with one RNA subunit and nine protein subunits. We have devised an affinity purification protocol to gently and rapidly purify intact yeast nuclear RNase P holoenzyme for transient kinetic studies. In pre-steady-state kinetic studies under saturating substrate concentrations, we observed an initial burst of tRNA formation followed by a slower, linear, steady-state turnover, with the burst amplitude equal to the concentration of the holoenzyme used in the reaction. These data indicate that the rate-limiting step in turnover occurs after pre-tRNA cleavage, such as mature tRNA release. Additionally, the steady-state rate constants demonstrate a large dependence on temperature that results in nonlinear Arrhenius plots, suggesting that a kinetically important conformational change occurs during catalysis. Finally, deletion of the 3′ trailer in pre-tRNA has little or no effect on the steady-state kinetic rate constants. These data suggest that, despite marked differences in subunit composition, the minimal kinetic mechanism for cleavage of pre-tRNA catalyzed by yeast nuclear RNase P holoenzyme is similar to that of the bacterial RNase P holoenzyme.     

The 5' leader of precursor tRNAAsp bound to the Bacillus subtilis RNase P holoenzyme has an extended conformation

RNase P catalyzes the 5' maturation of transfer RNA (tRNA). RNase P from Bacillus subtilis comprises a large RNA component (130 kDa, P RNA) and a small protein subunit (14 kDa, P protein). Although P RNA alone can efficiently catalyze the maturation reaction in vitro, P protein is strictly required under physiological conditions. We have used time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer on a series of donor-labeled substrates and two acceptor-labeled P proteins to determine the conformation of the pre-tRNA 5' leader relative to the protein in the holoenzyme-pre-tRNA complex. The resulting distance distribution measurements indicate that the leader binds to the holoenzyme in an extended conformation between nucleotides 3 and 7. The conformational mobility of nucleotides 5-8 in the leader is reduced, providing further evidence that these nucleotides interact with the holoenzyme. The increased fluorescence intensity and lifetime of the 5'-fluorescein label of these leaders indicate a more hydrophobic environment, consistent with the notion that such interactions occur with the central cleft of the P protein. Taken together, our data support a model where the P protein binds to the 5' leader between the fourth and seventh nucleotides upstream of the cleavage site, extending the leader and decreasing its structural dynamics. Thus, P protein acts as a wedge to separate the 5' from the 3' terminus of the pre-tRNA and to position the cleavage site in the catalytic core. These results reveal a structural basis for the P protein dependent discrimination between precursor and mature tRNAs.     

Effects of 5' leader and 3' trailer structures on pre-tRNA processing by nuclear RNase P

Eukaryotic transfer RNA precursors (pre-tRNAs) contain a 5' leader preceding the aminoacyl acceptor stem and a 3' trailer extending beyond this stem. An early step in pre-tRNA maturation is removal of the 5' leader by the endoribonuclease, RNase P. Extensive pairing between leader and trailer sequences has previously been demonstrated to block RNase P cleavage, suggesting that the 5' leader and 3' trailer sequences might need to be separated for the substrate to be recognized by the eukaryotic holoenzyme. To address whether the nuclear RNase P holoenzyme recognizes the 5' leader and 3' trailer sequences independently, interactions of RNase P with pre-tRNA(Tyr) containing either the 5' leader, the 3' trailer, or both were examined. Kinetic analysis revealed little effect of the 3' trailer or a long 5' leader on the catalytic rate (k(cat)) for cleavage using the various pre-tRNA derivatives. However, the presence of a 3' trailer that pairs with the 5' leader increases the K(m) of pre-tRNA slightly, in agreement with previous results. Similarly, competition studies demonstrate that removal of a complementary 3' trailer lowers the apparent K(I), consistent with the structure between these two sequences interfering with their interaction with the enzyme. Deletion of both the 5' and 3' extensions to give mature termini resulted in the least effective competitor. Further studies showed that the nuclear holoenzyme, but not the B. subtilis holoenzyme, had a high affinity for single-stranded RNA in the absence of attached tRNA structure. The data suggest that yeast nuclear RNase P contains a minimum of two binding sites involved in substrate recognition, one that interacts with tRNA and one that interacts with the 3' trailer. Furthermore, base pairing between the 5' leader and 3' trailer hinders recognition.     

Function of heterologous and truncated RNase P proteins in Bacillus subtilis

Bacterial RNase P is composed of an RNA subunit and a single protein (encoded by the rnpB and rnpA genes respectively). The Bacillus subtilis rnpA knockdown strain d7 was used to screen for functional conservation among bacterial RNase P proteins from a representative spectrum of bacterial subphyla. We demonstrate conserved function of bacterial RNase P (RnpA) proteins despite low sequence conservation. Even rnpA genes from psychrophilic and thermophilic bacteria rescued growth of B. subtilis d7 bacteria; likewise, terminal extensions and insertions between beta strands 2 and 3, in the so-called metal binding loop, were compatible with RnpA function in B. subtilis. A deletion analysis of B. subtilis RnpA defined the structural elements essential for bacterial RNase P function in vivo. We further extended our complementation analysis in B. subtilis strain d7 to the four individual RNase P protein subunits from three different Archaea, as well as to human Rpp21 and Rpp29 as representatives of eukaryal RNase P. None of these non-bacterial RNase P proteins showed any evidence of being able to replace the B. subtilis RNase P protein in vivo, supporting the notion that archaeal/eukaryal RNase P proteins are evolutionary unrelated to the bacterial RnpA protein.     

Bacterial RNase P: a new view of an ancient enzyme

Ribonuclease P (RNase P) is a ubiquitous endonuclease that catalyses the maturation of the 5' end of transfer RNA (tRNA). Although it carries out a biochemically simple reaction, RNase P is a complex ribonucleoprotein particle composed of a single large RNA and at least one protein component. In bacteria and some archaea, the RNA component of RNase P can catalyse tRNA maturation in vitro in the absence of proteins. The discovery of the catalytic activity of the bacterial RNase P RNA triggered numerous mechanistic and biochemical studies of the reactions catalysed by the RNA alone and by the holoenzyme and, in recent years, structures of individual components of the RNase P holoenzyme have been determined. The goal of the present review is to summarize what is known about the bacterial RNase P, and to bring together the recent structural results with extensive earlier biochemical and phylogenetic findings.     

Solution structure of RNase P RNA

The ribonucleoprotein enzyme ribonuclease P (RNase P) processes tRNAs by cleavage of precursor-tRNAs. RNase P is a ribozyme: The RNA component catalyzes tRNA maturation in vitro without proteins. Remarkable features of RNase P include multiple turnovers in vivo and ability to process diverse substrates. Structures of the bacterial RNase P, including full-length RNAs and a ternary complex with substrate, have been determined by X-ray crystallography. However, crystal structures of free RNA are significantly different from the ternary complex, and the solution structure of the RNA is unknown. Here, we report solution structures of three phylogenetically distinct bacterial RNase P RNAs from Escherichia coli, Agrobacterium tumefaciens, and Bacillus stearothermophilus, determined using small angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) and selective 2'-hydroxyl acylation analyzed by primer extension (SHAPE) analysis. A combination of homology modeling, normal mode analysis, and molecular dynamics was used to refine the structural models against the empirical data of these RNAs in solution under the high ionic strength required for catalytic activity.     

RNA-dependent folding and stabilization of C5 protein during assembly of the E. coli RNase P holoenzyme

The pre-tRNA processing enzyme ribonuclease P is a ribonucleoprotein. In Escherichia coli assembly of the holoenzyme involves binding of the small (119 amino acid residue) C5 protein to the much larger (377 nucleotide) P RNA subunit. The RNA subunit makes the majority of contacts to the pre-tRNA substrate and contains the active site; however, binding of C5 stabilizes P RNA folding and contributes to high affinity substrate binding. Here, we show that RNase P ribonucleoprotein assembly also influences the folding of C5 protein. Thermal melting studies demonstrate that the free protein population is a mixture of folded and unfolded conformations under conditions where it assembles quantitatively with the RNA subunit. Changes in the intrinsic fluorescence of a unique tryptophan residue located in the folded core of C5 provide further evidence for an RNA-dependent conformational change during RNase P assembly. Comparisons of the CD spectra of the free RNA and protein subunits with that of the holoenzyme provide evidence for changes in P RNA structure in the presence of C5 as indicated by previous studies. Importantly, monitoring the temperature dependence of the CD signal in regions of the holoenzyme spectra that are dominated by protein or RNA structure permitted analysis of the thermal melting of the individual subunits within the ribonucleoprotein. These analyses reveal a significantly higher Tm for C5 when bound to P RNA and show that unfolding of the protein and RNA are coupled. These data provide evidence for a general mechanism in which the favorable free energy for formation of the RNA-protein complex offsets the unfavorable free energy of structural rearrangements in the RNA and protein subunits.     

Evidence that substrate-specific effects of C5 protein lead to uniformity in binding and catalysis by RNase P

The ribonucleoprotein enzyme RNase P processes all pre-tRNAs, yet some substrates apparently lack consensus elements for recognition. Here, we compare binding affinities and cleavage rates of Escherichia coli pre-tRNAs that exhibit the largest variation from consensus recognition sequences. These results reveal that the affinities of both consensus and nonconsensus substrates for the RNase P holoenzyme are essentially uniform. Comparative analyses of pre-tRNA and tRNA binding to the RNase P holoenzyme and P RNA alone reveal differential contributions of the protein subunit to 5' leader and tRNA affinity. Additionally, these studies reveal that uniform binding results from variations in the energetic contribution of the 5' leader, which serve to compensate for weaker tRNA interactions. Furthermore, kinetic analyses reveal uniformity in the rates of substrate cleavage that result from dramatic (> 900-fold) contributions of the protein subunit to catalysis for some nonconsensus pre-tRNAs. Together, these data suggest that an important biological function of RNase P protein is to offset differences in pre-tRNA structure such that binding and catalysis are uniform.     

RNase P RNA mediated cleavage: substrate recognition and catalysis

The universally conserved endoribonuclease P consists of one RNA subunit and, depending on its origin, a variable number of protein subunits. RNase P is involved in the processing of a large variety of substrates in the cell, the preferred substrate being tRNA precursors. Cleavage activity does not require the presence of the protein subunit(s) in vitro. This is true for both prokaryotic and eukaryotic RNase P RNA suggesting that the RNA based catalytic activity has been preserved during evolution. Progress has been made in our understanding of the contribution of residues and chemical groups both in the substrate as well as in RNase P RNA to substrate binding and catalysis. Moreover, we have access to two crystal structures of bacterial RNase P RNA but we still lack the structure of RNase P RNA in complex with its substrate and/or the protein subunit. Nevertheless, these recent advancements put us in a new position to study the way and nature of interactions between in particular RNase P RNA and its substrate. In this review I will discuss various aspects of the RNA component of RNase P with an emphasis on our current understanding of the interaction between RNase P RNA and its substrate.     

Binding and cleavage of unstructured RNA by nuclear RNase P

Ribonuclease P (RNase P) is an essential endoribonuclease for which the best-characterized function is processing the 5' leader of pre-tRNAs. Compared to bacterial RNase P, which contains a single small protein subunit and a large catalytic RNA subunit, eukaryotic nuclear RNase P is more complex, containing nine proteins and an RNA subunit in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Consistent with this, nuclear RNase P has been shown to possess unique RNA binding capabilities. To understand the unique molecular recognition of nuclear RNase P, the interaction of S. cerevisiae RNase P with single-stranded RNA was characterized. Unstructured, single-stranded RNA inhibits RNase P in a size-dependent manner, suggesting that multiple interactions are required for high affinity binding. Mixed-sequence RNAs from protein-coding regions also bind strongly to the RNase P holoenzyme. However, in contrast to poly(U) homopolymer RNA that is not cleaved, a variety of mixed-sequence RNAs have multiple preferential cleavage sites that do not correspond to identifiable consensus structures or sequences. In addition, pre-tRNA(Tyr), poly(U)(50) RNA, and mixed-sequence RNA cross-link with purified RNase P in the RNA subunit Rpr1 near the active site in "Conserved Region I," although the exact positions vary. Additional contacts between poly(U)(50) and the RNase P proteins Rpr2p and Pop4p were identified. We conclude that unstructured RNAs interact with multiple protein and RNA contacts near the RNase P RNA active site, but that cleavage depends on the nature of interaction with the active site.