Osteochondral tissue engineering: Current strategies and challenges

Osteochondral defect management and repair remain a significant challenge in orthopedic surgery. Osteochondral defects contain damage to both the articular cartilage as well as the underlying subchondral bone. In order to repair an osteochondral defect the needs of the bone, cartilage and the bone-cartilage interface must be taken into account. Current clinical treatments for the repair of osteochondral defects have only been palliative, not curative. Tissue engineering has emerged as a potential alternative as it can be effectively used to regenerate bone, cartilage and the bone-cartilage interface. Several scaffold strategies, such as single phase, layered, and recently graded structures have been developed and evaluated for osteochondral defect repair. Also, as a potential cell source, tissue specific cells and progenitor cells are widely studied in cell culture models, as well with the osteochondral scaffolds in vitro and in vivo. Novel factor strategies being developed, including single factor, multi-factor, or controlled factor release in a graded fashion, not only assist bone and cartilage regeneration, but also establish osteochondral interface formation. The field of tissue engineering has made great strides, however further research needs to be carried out to make this strategy a clinical reality. In this review, we summarize current tissue engineering strategies, including scaffold design, bioreactor use, as well as cell and factor based approaches and recent developments for osteochondral defect repair. In addition, we discuss various challenges that need to be addressed in years to come.     

Development of large engineered cartilage constructs from a small population of cells

Confronted with articular cartilage's limited capacity for self‐repair, joint resurfacing techniques offer an attractive treatment for damaged or diseased tissue. Although tissue engineered cartilage constructs can be created, a substantial number of cells are required to generate sufficient quantities of tissue for the repair of large defects. As routine cell expansion methods tend to elicit negative effects on chondrocyte function, we have developed an approach to generate phenotypically stable, large‐sized engineered constructs (≥3 cm²) directly from a small amount of donor tissue or cells (as little as 20,000 cells to generate a 3 cm² tissue construct). Using rabbit donor tissue, the bioreactor‐cultivated constructs were hyaline‐like in appearance and possessed a biochemical composition similar to native articular cartilage. Longer bioreactor cultivation times resulted in increased matrix deposition and improved mechanical properties determined over a 4 week period. Additionally, as the anatomy of the joint will need to be taken in account to effectively resurface large affected areas, we have also explored the possibility of generating constructs matched to the shape and surface geometry of a defect site through the use of rapid‐prototyped defect tissue culture molds. Similar hyaline‐like tissue constructs were developed that also possessed a high degree of shape correlation to the original defect mold. Future studies will be aimed at determining the effectiveness of this approach to the repair of cartilage defects in an animal model and the creation of large‐sized osteochondral constructs. © 2012 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 2013     

Repair of injured articular and growth plate cartilage using mesenchymal stem cells and chondrogenic gene therapy

Injuries to the articular cartilage and growth plate are significant clinical problems due to their limited ability to regenerate themselves. Despite progress in orthopedic surgery and some success in development of chondrocyte transplantation treatment and in early tissue-engineering work, cartilage regeneration using a biological approach still remains a great challenge. In the last 15 years, researchers have made significant advances and tremendous progress in exploring the potentials of mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) in cartilage repair. These include (a) identifying readily available sources of and devising appropriate techniques for isolation and culture expansion of MSCs that have good chondrogenic differentiation capability, (b) discovering appropriate growth factors (such as TGF-beta, IGF-I, BMPs, and FGF-2) that promote MSC chondrogenic differentiation, (c) identifying or engineering biological or artificial matrix scaffolds as carriers for MSCs and growth factors for their transplantation and defect filling. In addition, representing another new perspective for cartilage repair is the successful demonstration of gene therapy with chondrogenic growth factors or inflammatory inhibitors (either individually or in combination), either directly to the cartilage tissue or mediated through transducing and transplanting cultured chondrocytes, MSCs or other mesenchymal cells. However, despite these rapid pre-clinical advances and some success in engineering cartilage-like tissue and in repairing articular and growth plate cartilage, challenges of their clinical translation remain. To achieve clinical effectiveness, safety, and practicality of using MSCs for cartilage repair, one critical investigation will be to examine the optimal combination of MSC sources, growth factor cocktails, and supporting carrier matrixes. As more insights are acquired into the critical factors regulating MSC migration, proliferation and chondrogenic differentiation both ex vivo and in vivo, it will be possible clinically to orchestrate desirable repair of injured articular and growth plate cartilage, either by transplanting ex vivo expanded MSCs or MSCs with genetic modifications, or by mobilising endogenous MSCs from adjacent source tissues such as synovium, bone marrow, or trabecular bone.     

Requirement of fibroblast growth factor signaling for regeneration of epiphyseal morphology in rabbit full-thickness defects of articular cartilage

The involvement of fibroblast growth factor-2 (FGF-2) during the repair process in rabbit full-thickness defects of articular cartilage was studied. Fibroblast growth factor-2 (50 pg/h) was administered for 2 weeks in a 5mm defect of articular cartilage, which is large enough not to repair spontaneously. The administration of FGF-2 resulted in the regeneration of the articular cartilage and the subchondral bone within 8 weeks. In these defects, undifferentiated mesenchymal cells initiated chondrogenic differentiation coupled with replacement by subchondral bone, resulting in the resurfacing of the defects with hyaline cartilage and the recovery of subchondral bone up to the original bone–articular cartilage junction. In rabbits, full-thickness defects are capable of regenerating articular cartilage as long as the defect size is limited to ≤3 mm in diameter. In the defects, strong immunoreactivity for FGF-2 was observed in the granulation tissue filling the defects in the early stage of repair, in association with the expression of FGF-2 mRNA shown by in situ hybridization. Once the undifferentiated mesenchymal cells had differentiated into chondrocytes, both the immunoreactivity and the in situ hybridization signal declined significantly. Upon the local administration of a monoclonal antibody against FGF-2 (bFM-1, 50ng/h), the defects were filled with fibrous tissue and no resurfacing hyaline cartilage was formed. Compared to the non-treated defects, there were marked increases in FGF-2 immunoreactivity and the overexpression of FGF-2 mRNA in the reparative tissue in the bFM-1 -treated defects. This rebound phenomenon indicates that the autocrine FGF-2 signaling is critically important for the regeneration of articular cartilage.     

Biomechanical assessment of tissue retrieved after in vivo cartilage defect repair: tensile modulus of repair tissue and integration with host cartilage

Failure to restore the mechanical properties of tissue at the repair site and its interface with host cartilage is a common problem in tissue engineering procedures to repair cartilage defects. Quantitative in vitro studies have helped elucidate mechanisms underlying processes leading to functional biomechanical changes. However, biomechanical assessment of tissue retrieved from in vivo studies of cartilage defect repair has been limited to compressive tests. Analysis of integration following in vivo repair has relied on qualitative histological methods. The objectives of this study were to develop a quantitative biomechanical method to assess (1) the tensile modulus of repair tissue and (2) its integration in vivo, as well as determine whether supplementation of transplanted chondrocytes with IGF-I affected these mechanical properties. Osteochondral blocks were obtained from a previous 8 month study on the effects of IGF-I on chondrocyte transplantation in the equine model. Tapered test specimens were prepared from osteochondral blocks containing the repair/native tissue interface and adjacently located blocks of intact native tissue. Specimens were then tested in uniaxial tension. The tensile modulus of repair tissue averaged 0.65 MPa, compared to the average of 5.2 MPa measured in intact control samples. Integration strength averaged 1.2 MPa, nearly half the failure strength of intact cartilage samples, 2.7 MPa. IGF-I treatment had no detectable effects on these mechanical properties. This represents the first quantitative biomechanical investigation of the tensile properties of repair tissue and its integration strength in an in vivo joint defect environment.     

微载体技术在软骨损伤修复中的应用与展望北大核心CSCD

软骨内部无血管结构、细胞外基质含量高的特点,使软骨组织的自我恢复能力很差。在临床治疗中,轻度的软骨缺损通常采用物理治疗或药物治疗方式,严重者需进行手术治疗。近年来,软骨组织工程技术为治疗软骨缺损提供了新的思路,与传统的手术治疗方式相比,结合软骨组织工程技术进行治疗具有创口小、恢复佳的优点。将微载体技术融入组织工程支架的设计中,可以利用微载体直径小、能够负载多种生长因子的特点,进一步扩展支架功能、促进软骨组织再生。文中首先对微载体技术进行介绍,对近年来微载体的主要制备方式和创新内容进行了概括总结,作为后续介绍的基础内容。然后对应用于软骨修复中的微载体进行了材料和功能上的划分,介绍了不同材料、不同功能微载体的属性特征和在软骨修复方面的具体应用,最后结合该领域发展历程对其今后发展趋势及方向进行展望,并基于笔者团队关于骨软骨一体化层状支架的研究,提出了通过微载体优化层状支架性能的思路,有望制备出更贴合天然软骨结构特征的仿生支架。     

Matrix-assisted Autologous Chondrocyte Transplantation for Remodeling and Repair of Chondral Defects in a Rabbit Model

Articular cartilage defects are considered a major health problem because articular cartilage has a limited capacity for self-regeneration ¹. Untreated cartilage lesions lead to ongoing pain, negatively affect the quality of life and predispose for osteoarthritis. During the last decades, several surgical techniques have been developed to treat such lesions. However, until now it was not possible to achieve a full repair in terms of covering the defect with hyaline articular cartilage or of providing satisfactory long-term recovery ^2-4. Therefore, articular cartilage injuries remain a prime target for regenerative techniques such as Tissue Engineering. In contrast to other surgical techniques, which often lead to the formation of fibrous or fibrocartilaginous tissue, Tissue Engineering aims at fully restoring the complex structure and properties of the original articular cartilage by using the chondrogenic potential of transplanted cells. Recent developments opened up promising possibilities for regenerative cartilage therapies.The first cell based approach for the treatment of full-thickness cartilage or osteochondral lesions was performed in 1994 by Lars Peterson and Mats Brittberg who pioneered clinical autologous chondrocyte implantation (ACI) ⁵. Today, the technique is clinically well-established for the treatment of large hyaline cartilage defects of the knee, maintaining good clinical results even 10 to 20 years after implantation ⁶. In recent years, the implantation of autologous chondrocytes underwent a rapid progression. The use of an artificial three-dimensional collagen-matrix on which cells are subsequently replanted became more and more popular ^7-9.MACT comprises of two surgical procedures: First, in order to collect chondrocytes, a cartilage biopsy needs to be performed from a non weight-bearing cartilage area of the knee joint. Then, chondrocytes are being extracted, purified and expanded to a sufficient cell number in vitro. Chondrocytes are then seeded onto a three-dimensional matrix and can subsequently be re-implanted. When preparing a tissue-engineered implant, proliferation rate and differentiation capacity are crucial for a successful tissue regeneration ¹⁰. The use of a three-dimensional matrix as a cell carrier is thought to support these cellular characteristics ¹¹.The following protocol will summarize and demonstrate a technique for the isolation of chondrocytes from cartilage biopsies, their proliferation in vitro and their seeding onto a 3D-matrix (Chondro-Gide, Geistlich Biomaterials, Wollhusen, Switzerland). Finally, the implantation of the cell-matrix-constructs into artificially created chondral defects of a rabbit''s knee joint will be described. This technique can be used as an experimental setting for further experiments of cartilage repair.     

The rationale for using microscopic units of a donor matrix in cartilage defect repair

The efficacy of existing articular cartilage defect repair strategies are limited. Native cartilage tissue forms via a series of exquisitely orchestrated morphogenic events spanning through gestation into early childhood. However, defect repair must be achieved in a non-ideal microenvironment over an accelerated time-frame compatible with the normal life of an adult patient. Scaffolds formed from decellularized tissues are commonly utilized to enable the rapid and accurate repair of tissues such as skin, bladder and heart valves. The intact extracellular matrix remaining following the decellularization of these relatively low-matrix-density tissues is able to rapidly and accurately guide host cell repopulation. By contrast, the extraordinary density of cartilage matrix limits both the initial decellularization of donor material as well as its subsequent repopulation. Repopulation of donor cartilage matrix is generally limited to the periphery, with repopulation of lacunae deeper within the matrix mass being highly inefficient. Herein, we review the relevant literature and discuss the trend toward the use of decellularized donor cartilage matrix of microscopic dimensions. We show that 2-μm microparticles of donor matrix are rapidly integrate with articular chondrocytes, forming a robust cartilage-like composites with enhanced chondrogenic gene expression. Strategies for the clinical application of donor matrix microparticles in cartilage defect repair are discussed.     

Local stimulation of articular cartilage repair by transplantation of encapsulated chondrocytes overexpressing human fibroblast growth factor 2 (FGF-2) in vivo

BACKGROUND: Defects of articular cartilage are an unsolved problem in orthopaedics. In the present study, we tested the hypothesis that gene transfer of human fibroblast growth factor 2 (FGF-2) via transplantation of encapsulated genetically modified articular chondrocytes stimulates chondrogenesis in cartilage defects in vivo. METHODS: Lapine articular chondrocytes overexpressing a lacZ or a human FGF-2 gene sequence were encapsulated in alginate and further characterized. The resulting lacZ or FGF-2 spheres were applied to cartilage defects in the knee joints of rabbits. In vivo, cartilage repair was assessed qualitatively and quantitatively at 3 and 14 weeks after implantation. RESULTS: In vitro, bioactive FGF-2 was secreted, leading to a significant increase in the cell numbers in FGF-2 spheres. In vivo, FGF-2 continued to be expressed for at least 3 weeks without leading to differences in FGF-2 concentrations in the synovial fluid between treatment groups. Histological analysis revealed no adverse pathologic effects on the synovial membrane at any time point. FGF-2 gene transfer enhanced type II collagen expression and individual parameters of chondrogenesis, such as the cell morphology and architecture of the new tissue. Overall articular cartilage repair was significantly improved at both time points in vivo. CONCLUSIONS: The data suggest that localized overexpression of FGF-2 enhances the repair of cartilage defects via stimulation of chondrogenesis, without adverse effects on the synovial membrane. These results may lead to the development of safe gene-based therapies for human articular cartilage defects.     

Current clinical therapies for cartilage repair, their limitation and the role of stem cells

The management of osteochondral defects of articular cartilage, whether from trauma or degenerative disease, continues to be a significant challenge for Orthopaedic surgeons. Current treatment options such as abrasion arthroplasty procedures, osteochondral transplantation and autologous chondrocyte implantation fail to produce repair tissue exhibiting the same mechanical and functional properties of native articular cartilage. This results in repair tissue that inevitably fails as it is unable to deal with the mechanical demands of articular cartilage, and does not prevent further degeneration of the native cartilage. Mesenchymal stem cells have been proposed as a potential source of cells for cell-based cartilage repair due to their ability to self-renew and undergo multi-lineage differentiation. This proposed procedure has the advantage of not requiring harvesting of cells from the joint surface, and its associated donor site morbidity, as well as having multiple possible adult donor tissues such as bone marrow, adipose tissue and synovium. Mesenchymal stem cells have multi-lineage potential, but can be stimulated to undergo chondrogenesis in the appropriate culture medium. As the majority of work with mesenchymal stem cell-derived articular cartilage repair has been carried out in vitro and in animal studies, more work still has to be done before this technique can be used for clinical purposes. This includes realizing the ideal method of harvesting mesenchymal stem cells, the culture medium to stimulate proliferation and differentiation, appropriate choice of scaffold incorporating growth factors directly or with gene therapy and integration of repair tissue with native tissue.     

The minipig model for experimental chondral and osteochondral defect repair in tissue engineering: retrospective analysis of 180 defects

Articular cartilage repair is still a challenge in orthopaedic surgery. Although many treatment options have been developed in the last decade, true regeneration of hyaline articular cartilage is yet to be accomplished. In vitro experiments are useful for evaluating cell-matrix interactions under controlled parameters. When introducing new treatment options into clinical routine, adequate animal models are capable of closing the gap between in vitro experiments and the clinical use in human beings. We developed an animal model in the G?ttingen minipig (GMP) to evaluate the healing of osteochondral or full-thickness cartilage defects. The defects were located in the middle third of the medial portion of the patellofemoral joint at both distal femurs. Chondral defects were 6.3 mm, osteochondral defects either 5.4 or 6.3 mm in diameter and 8 or 10 mm deep. In both defects the endogenous repair response showed incomplete repair tissue formation up to 12 months postoperatively. Based on its limited capability for endogenous repair of chondral and osteochondral defects, the GMP is a useful model for critical assessment of new treatment strategies in articular cartilage tissue engineering.     

Transplantation of autologous rabbit BM-derived mesenchymal stromal cells embedded in hyaluronic acid gel sponge into osteochondral defects of the knee

BACKGROUND: Mesenchymal stromal cells (MSC) have the potential to differentiate into distinct mesenchymal tissues including cartilage, suggesting that these cells are an attractive cell source for cartilage tissue engineering approaches. Various methods, such as using hyaluronan-based materials, have been employed to improve transplantation for repair. Our objective was to study the effects of autologous transplantation of rabbit MSC with hyaluronic acid gel sponges into full-thickness osteochondral defects of the knee. METHODS: Rabbit BM-derived MSC were cultured and expanded with fibroblast growth factor (FGF). Specimens were harvested at 4 and 12 weeks after implantation, examined histologically for morphologic features, and stained immunohistochemically for type II collagen and CD44. RESULTS: The regenerated area after autologous transplantation of hyaluronic acid gel sponge loaded with MSC into the osteochondral defect at 12 weeks after surgery showed well-repaired cartilage tissue, resembling the articular cartilage of the surrounding structure, of which the histologic score was significantly better than that of the untreated osteochondral defect. In the regenerated cartilage, type II collagen was found in the pericellular matrix of regenerative chondrocytes, while CD44 expression in the regenerative tissue could not be revealed. DISCUSSION: These data suggest that the autologous transplantation of MSC embedded in hyaluronan-based material may support chondrogenic differentiation and be useful for osteochondral defect repair.     

骨碎补结合组织工程软骨促进软骨再生的实验研究

目的:评估骨碎补结合组织工程软骨治疗对实验兔软骨缺陷模型软骨再生的疗效。方法:将h IGF-1基因转染MSCs,并与脱细胞真皮基质(ADM)构建组织工程软骨。24只新西兰白兔随机分为A、B、C、D四组,A、C组进行自体软骨移植,B、D组进行改建的细胞-ADM移植。C、D组用40%骨碎补汤喂养4周,150 m L/d。第12周处死实验动物,分离缺损关节软骨部位,蜡块包埋染色,通过总体形态评价软骨再生组织。采用组织学评分评估再生软骨质量。采用甲苯胺蓝染色评价缺损部位产生软骨糖胺聚糖的情况。结果:与B组比较,C组和D组的新生软骨覆盖度、新骨髓的颜色、缺损边缘和表面粗糙度均显著提高(P0.05);再生软骨的组织学评分软骨表面评分显著改善(P0.05)。C组与D组具有比其他组更好的基质、细胞分布和表面指数。并且有较厚的透明样软骨组织,具有正常的糖胺聚糖产生。表明该治疗方法可以通过再生透明样软骨且没有不良事件来减少软骨缺陷。结论:工程软骨结合骨碎补治疗可显著改善兔膝关节软骨缺损修复的质量,为临床治疗软骨病变提供重要理论依据。     

From gristle to chondrocyte transplantation: treatment of cartilage injuries

This review addresses the progress in cartilage repair technology over the decades with an emphasis on cartilage regeneration with cell therapy. The most abundant cartilage is the hyaline cartilage that covers the surface of our joints and, due to avascularity, this tissue is unable to repair itself. The cartilage degeneration seen in osteoarthritis causes patient suffering and is a huge burden to society. The surgical approach to cartilage repair was non-existing until the 1950s when new surgical techniques emerged. The use of cultured cells for cell therapy started as experimental studies in the 1970s that developed over the years to a clinical application in 1994 with the introduction of the autologous chondrocyte transplantation technique (ACT). The technology is now spread worldwide and has been further refined by combining arthroscopic techniques with cells cultured on matrix (MACI technology). The non-regenerating hypothesis of cartilage has been revisited and we are now able to demonstrate cell divisions and presence of stem-cell niches in the joint. Furthermore, cartilage derived from human embryonic stem cells and induced pluripotent stem cells could be the base for new broader cell treatments for cartilage injuries and the future technology base for prevention and cure of osteoarthritis.     

Fourier transform infrared imaging spectroscopy investigations in the pathogenesis and repair of cartilage

Significant complications in the management of osteoarthritis (OA) are the inability to identify early cartilage changes during the development of the disease, and the lack of techniques to evaluate the tissue response to therapeutic and tissue engineering interventions. In recent studies several spectroscopic parameters have been elucidated by Fourier transform infrared imaging spectroscopy (FT-IRIS) that enable evaluation of molecular and compositional changes in human cartilage with progressively severe OA, and in repair cartilage from animal models. FT-IRIS permits evaluation of early-stage matrix changes in the primary components of cartilage, collagen and proteoglycan on histological sections at a spatial resolution of approximately 6.25 microm. In osteoarthritic cartilage, the collagen integrity, monitored by the ratio of peak areas at 1338 cm(-1)/Amide II, was found to correspond to the histological Mankin grade, the gold standard scale utilized to evaluate cartilage degeneration. Apparent matrix degradation was observable in the deep zone of cartilage even in the early stages of OA. FT-IRIS studies also found that within the territorial matrix of the cartilage cells (chondrocytes), proteoglycan content increased with progression of cartilage degeneration while the collagen content remained the same, but the collagen integrity decreased. Regenerative (repair) tissue from microfracture treatment of an equine cartilage defect showed significant changes in collagen distribution and loss in proteoglycan content compared to the adjacent normal cartilage, with collagen fibrils demonstrating a random orientation in most of the repair tissue. These studies demonstrate that FT-IRIS is a powerful technique that can provide detailed ultrastructural information on heterogeneous tissues such as diseased cartilage and thus has great potential as a diagnostic modality for cartilage degradation and repair.     

骨软骨复合支架的研究进展

软骨的修复是当前医学界十分棘手的难题,人们采取若干手段均收效甚微。由于软骨缺损时,其下的软骨下骨常出现硬化、退变,而新生软骨是无法与病变的软骨下骨进行整合的,所以在修复软骨的同时,必须重视软骨下骨的修复。近十几年来,人们开始发明和利用各种骨软骨复合支架,进行同时修复软骨与软骨下骨的动物实验研究。在正常骨软骨组织中,软骨与软骨下骨被钙化层所相连,此外钙化层也将软骨与软骨下骨分隔在不同的生存环境中。根据仿生学原理,人们又设计出一种带有隔离层的新型骨软骨复合支架,并取得了较为理想的实验结果。本文就国内外骨软骨复合支架的研完进展作一综述。     

Long-term results of deep defects in articular cartilage. A scanning electron microscope study.

Core defects produced in the medial femoral condyle of the rabbit were studied by scanning electron microscopy and light microscopy over a period of 2 years. In some cases the defect was filled by hyaline articular cartilage with a fairly smooth surface, but in others the tissue was markedly fibrillated and resembled fibrous tissue and fibrocartilage. Appearances suggesting disintegration of the newly formed cartilage were seen in some cases. It would appear that a continuation of this process can lead to the exposure of subchondral bone. In one instance no repair tissue or new cartilage could be identified but the surrounding old cartilage had formed a shelf over the defect. The cartilage surrounding the defect was either normal or showed superficial fibrillation, and/or flow formation, and/or fissures.     

Serum levels of hyaluronic acid and chondroitin sulfate as a non-invasive method to evaluate healing after cartilage repair procedures

Magnetic resonance imaging remains the only non-invasive method to assess the quality of cartilage repair procedures, but ideally would be complemented by other modalities, particularly blood tests. Nganvongpanit and colleagues investigated serum levels of hyaluronic acid (HA) and chondroitin sulfate (CS) for their correlation with tissue quality after cartilage repair with autologous chondrocytes versus subchondral drilling in a dog model. They reported better tissue quality in animals treated with chondrocyte implantation. Serum levels correlated with the histological score of biopsy samples: CS showed a negative (r = -0.69) and HA a positive (r = +0.46) correlation. Many questions remain to be answered before serum markers can provide a reliable, non-invasive tool to assess tissue quality, but these data provide an important foundation for additional research.In the previous issue of Arthritis Research & Therapy, Nganvongpanit and colleagues [1], of Chiang Mai University in Thailand, investigated the potential use of serum biomarkers, such as hyaluronic acid (HA) and chondroitin sulfate (CS), to evaluate healing after cartilage repair procedures. They randomly assigned dogs to treatment with autologous chondrocyte implantation (ACI) versus subchondral drilling (SD) and followed the animals for 24 weeks post-operatively with multiple blood draws and a cartilage biopsy at final follow-up.Cartilage defects are a common diagnosis, encountered in over 60% of knee arthroscopies [2]. While the natural history and pathophysiology of cartilage defects remain controversial, a significant number of patients present with symptoms that warrant surgical intervention. These patients undergo various cartilage repair procedures to repair the damaged articular surfaces, including microfracture, osteochondral autografting, and ACI. Progress in the field of cartilage repair has been impeded in part by the relative lack of adequate instruments to evaluate the quality of the reparative tissue. While histological evaluation is desirable, researchers have found it difficult to recruit patients for a second surgical procedure to harvest a tissue biopsy solely for research purposes. Imaging techniques, especially magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), have made significant progress in recent years. Certain cartilage-specific techniques such as delayed gadolinium-enhanced MRI of cartilage (dGEMRIC) and T1-rho and T2-mapping have promise to assess tissue quality by indirectly measuring glycosaminoglycan content [3,4]. However, these techniques are associated with substantial cost and potential risk to the patient from contrast exposure; therefore, the development of alternative non-invasive techniques is desirable. In particular, blood tests, which could be repeated multiple times with minimal discomfort to the patient, would present an ideal method to investigate the maturation of repair tissue after cartilage repair. Beyond the scientific benefit of comparing the relative time courses of healing after different repair techniques, once thresholds are established, biomarkers could provide clinical guidance regarding the point when patients might return to full activities.In their article, Nganvongpanit and colleagues investigated the use of monoclonal antibodies and enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay to quantify serum levels of CS and HA, respectively, in a dog model. They followed two groups treated with either SD or autologous chondrocytes (ACs) for 24 weeks, with blood draws at baseline and every 6 weeks thereafter. Other endpoints included the gross visual evaluation of the reparative tissue as well as histologic grading. Animals treated with ACs demonstrated better visual and histological appearance than those treated with drilling. Three of the five AC biopsies were near normal, and the other two showed at least 50% fill and peripheral integration of the repair site. In the SD group, three of five samples demonstrated complete degeneration, and the other two only inconsistent fill and no peripheral integration with the surrounding articular surface. Histologically, both groups demonstrated some fibrocartilage; however, the AC group also showed hyaline cartilage compared with fibrous tissue in the SD group.Interestingly, serum levels of CS and HA demonstrated different trends at final follow-up after 24 weeks: CS had a strong negative correlation with histological scores (r = -0.69), while HA was positively correlated (r = +0.46). In the AC group, CS levels trended downward over time, a finding the authors interpret as a reflection of the normalizing proteoglycan turnover due to a successful repair with maturing tissue. In the SD group, however, levels remained high, possibly reflecting the progressive damage of the surrounding cartilage seen in these samples. Overall, HA levels also decreased from baseline, with relatively higher values in samples with better histological scores, potentially a sign of normalization of joint homeostasis.This study provided two important findings. First, it added to the mounting evidence of improved histological outcomes with cell-based therapy, such as ACI [5], over marrow-stimulation techniques, such as SD or microfracture. Second, the authors describe two potential candidate factors to follow tissue maturation and healing: HA and CS. Many questions remain to be addressed, such as the correlation of marker levels with defect size, number, and location as well as possible differences between chondral and osteochondral defects and patient gender, age, or weight. However, these preliminary results are promising and provide a foundation for future research.In conclusion, while these findings require larger, confirmatory studies (ideally in human patients), they hold promise for non-invasive monitoring after cartilage repair procedures. Reliable, reproducible, and relatively inexpensive methods to evaluate the quality and maturation of reparative tissue will substantially advance the field of cartilage repair. These tests would potentially enable investigators and industry to develop new technologies aimed at repairing articular cartilage, assist surgeons to select the appropriate procedure for any given patient, and post-operatively, allow an individualized determination of when it is safe for the patient to return to higher levels of activity.     

Mechano-regulation of stem cell differentiation and tissue regeneration in osteochondral defects

Cartilage defects that penetrate the subchondral bone can undergo spontaneous repair through the formation of a fibrous or cartilaginous tissue mediated primarily by mesenchymal stem cells from the bone marrow. This tissue is biomechanically inferior to normal articular cartilage, and is often observed to degrade over time. Whether or not biomechanical factors control the type and quality of the repair tissue, and its subsequent degradation, have yet to be elucidated. In this paper, we hypothesise a relationship between the mechanical environment of mesenchymal stem cells and their subsequent dispersal, proliferation, differentiation and death. The mechano-regulation stimulus is hypothesised to be a function of strain and fluid flow; these quantities are calculated using biphasic poroelastic finite element analysis. A finite element model of an osteochondral defect in the knee was created, and used to simulate the spontaneous repair process. The model predicts bone formation through both endochondral and direct intramembranous ossification in the base of the defect, cartilage formation in the centre of the defect and fibrous tissue formation superficially. Greater amounts of fibrous tissue formation are predicted as the size of the defect is increased. Large strains are predicted within the fibrous tissue at the articular surface, resulting in significant cell apoptosis. This result leads to the conclusion that repair tissue degradation is initiated in the fibrous tissue that forms at the articular surface. The success of the mechano-regulation model in predicting many of the cellular events that occur during osteochondral defect healing suggest that in the future it could be used as a tool for optimising scaffolds for tissue engineering.     

Influence of aspect ratios on the creep behaviour of articular cartilage in indentation

Indentation tests are commonly used to determine the mechanical behaviour of articular cartilage with varying properties, thickness, and geometry. This investigation evaluated the effect of changing geometric parameters on the properties determined from creep indentation tests. Finite element analyses simulated the indentation behaviour of two models, an excised cylindrical specimen of cartilage with either normal and repair qualities and an osteochondral defect represented as a cylindrical region of repair cartilage integrated with a surrounding layer of normal tissue. For each model, the ratios of indenter radius to cartilage height (a/h=0.5,1.5) and cartilage radius to indenter radius (r/a=2,5) were varied. The vertical displacement of the cartilage under the indenter obtained through finite element analysis was fitted to a numerical algorithm to determine the aggregate modulus, permeability, and Poisson's ratio. Indentation behaviours of cartilage specimens for either model with a/h=1.5 were not affected by r/a for values of 2 and 5. Aggregate modulus was not greatly affected by the geometric changes studied. Permeability was affected by changes in the ratio of specimen to indenter radii for a/h=0.5. These findings suggest that experimental configurations of excised cylindrical specimens, also representing osteochondral defects with no or unknown degree of integration, where the cartilage layer has a/h=0.5 should not have r/a values on the order of 2 for confidence in the mechanical properties determined. Indentation of osteochondral defects where the repair cartilage is fully integrated to the surrounding cartilage can be performed with confidence for all cases tested.