Role of the chicken homeobox-containing genes GHox-4.6 and GHox-8 in the specification of positional identities during the development of normal and polydactylous chick limb buds.

During early stages of normal chick limb development, the homeobox-containing (HOX) gene GHox-4.6 is expressed throughout the posterior mesoderm of the wing bud from which most of the skeletal elements including the digits will develop, whereas GHox-8 is expressed in the anterior limb bud mesoderm which will not give rise to skeletal elements. In the present study, we have examined the expression of GHox-4.6 and GHox-8 in the wing buds of two polydactylous mutant chick embryos, diplopodia-5 and talpid2, from which supernumerary digits develop from anterior limb mesoderm, and have also examined the expression of these genes in response to polarizing zone grafts and retinoic acid-coated bead implants which induce the formation of supernumerary digits from anterior limb mesoderm. We have found that the formation of supernumerary digits from the anterior mesoderm in mutant and experimentally induced polydactylous limb buds is preceded by the ectopic expression of GHox-4.6 in the anterior mesoderm and the coincident suppression of GHox-8 expression in the anterior mesoderm. These observations suggest that the anterior mesoderm of the polydactylous limb buds is "posteriorized" and support the suggestion that GHox-8 and GHox-4.6, respectively, are involved in specifying the anterior non-skeletal and posterior digit-forming regions of the limb bud. Although the anterior mesodermal domain of GHox-8 expression is severely impaired in the mutant and experimentally induced polydactylous limb buds, this gene is expressed by the prolonged, thickened apical ectodermal ridges of the polydactylous limb buds that extend along the distal anterior as well as the distal posterior mesoderm.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Studies on the mechanism of retinoid-induced pattern duplications in the early chick limb bud: temporal and spatial aspects

All-trans-retinoic acid causes striking digit pattern changes when it is continuously released from a bead implanted in the anterior margin of an early chick wing bud. In addition to the normal set of digits (234), extra digits form in a mirror-symmetrical arrangement, creating digit patterns such as a 432234. These retinoic acid-induced pattern duplications closely mimic those found after grafts of polarizing region cells to the same positions with regard to dose-response, timing, and positional effects. To elucidate the mechanism by which retinoic acid induces these pattern duplications, we have studied the temporal and spatial distribution of all-trans-retinoic acid and its potent analogue TTNPB in these limb buds. We find that the induction process is biphasic: there is an 8-h lag phase followed by a 6-h duplication phase, during which additional digits are irreversibly specified in the sequence digit 2, digit 3, digit 4. On average, formation of each digit seems to require between 1 and 2 h. The tissue concentrations, metabolic pattern, and spatial distribution of all- trans-retinoic acid and TTNPB in the limb rapidly reach a steady state, in which the continuous release of the retinoid is balanced by loss from metabolism and blood circulation. Pulse-chase experiments reveal that the half-time of clearance from the bud is 20 min for all-trans- retinoic acid and 80 min for TTNPB. Manipulations that change the experimentally induced steep concentration gradient of TTNPB suggest that a graded distribution of retinoid concentrations across the limb is required during the duplication phase to induce changes in the digit pattern. The extensive similarities between results obtained with retinoids and with polarizing region grafts raise the possibility that retinoic acid serves as a natural "morphogen" in the limb.     

Retinoic acid induces a pattern of digits in anterior half wing buds that lack the zone of polarizing activity

Wing buds whose posterior half is excised, develop into wings lacking distal structures. However, such experimentally generated preaxial half wing buds can be rescued by implanting a retinoic-acid-releasing bead at their anterior margin. The polarity of the pattern that originates from preaxial half wing buds is reversed. For example, instead of a 234 digit pattern typical for normal wings, the order of digits is 432. This result implies that retinoic acid has the capacity to reprogram anterior limb bud tissue, and that the resulting change in cell fate does not depend on the presence of posterior tissue regions such as the zone of polarizing activity (ZPA).     

Posterior apical ectodermal ridge removal in the chick wing bud triggers a series of events resulting in defective anterior pattern formation

The ability of the anterior apical ectodermal ridge to promote outgrowth in the chick wing bud when disconnected from posterior apical ridge was examined by rotating the posterior portion of the stage-19/20 to stage-21 wing bud around its anteroposterior axis. This permitted contact between the anterior and posterior mesoderm, without removing wing bud tissue. In a small but significant number of cases (10/54), anterior structures (digit 2) formed spatially isolated from posterior structures (digits 3 and 4). Thus, continuity with posterior ridge is not a prerequisite for anterior-ridge function in the wing bud. Nevertheless, posterior-ridge removal does result in anterior limb truncation. To investigate events leading to anterior truncation, we examined cell death patterns in the wing bud following posterior-ridge removal. We observed an abnormal area of necrosis along the posterior border of the wing bud at 6-12 h following posterior-ridge removal. This was followed by necrosis in the distal, anterior mesoderm at 48 h postoperatively and subsequent anterior truncation. Clearly, healthy posterior limb bud mesoderm is needed for anterior limb bud survival and development. We propose that anterior truncation is the direct result of anterior mesodermal cell death and that this may not be related to positional specification of anterior cells. In our view, cell death of anterior mesoderm, after posterior mesoderm removal, should not be used as evidence for a role in position specification by the polarizing zone during the limb bud stages of development. We suggest that the posterior mesoderm that maintains the anterior mesoderm need not be restricted to the mapped polarizing zone, but is more extensively distributed in the limb bud.     

The role of the polarizing zone in the pattern of experimental chondrogenesis in the chick embryo interdigital space

We have previously shown that removal of the apical ectodermal ridge of the third interdigital space of the chick leg bud at stages 28 and 29 is followed by the appearance of ectopic cartilage, which in the course of development gives rise to extra digits. These in vivo studies suggest that the pattern of skeletal morphogenesis in the limb depends on the inhibitory effect of the ectoderm. In the present study we tested whether zone polarizing activity (ZPA) exerted an effect on the pattern of experimental chondrogenesis in the interdigital space of the leg bud in stage 29 HH chick embryos. A small fragment of tissue from the ZPA in chick embryos in which ZPA activity was most intense was grafted onto the interdigital space in which chondrogenesis had previously been experimentally induced. No significant changes were observed in the course of differentiation of the recipient interdigital spaces with ZPA grafts, leading us to conclude that the graft failed to modify the morphogenetic fate of interdigital tissue.     

Does anterior (non-polarizing region) tissue signal in the developing chick limb?

The morphogenetic properties of embryonic chick limb bud tissue from anterior positions and from the posterior (polarizing) region are compared. Quail grafts, which possess the distinctive nucleolar cell marker, and γ-irradiation are used. Supernumerary limb structures induced by anterior tissue wedge grafts are found to be nearly exclusively graft, donor tissue derived. This contrasts with the duplicate limb structures formed in response to posterior (polarizing region) tissue grafts in which host cells predominate. Distinction between anterior and posterior tissue properties was also demonstrated using doses of radiation (～ 12 Gy = 1200 rad) which inhibit cell proliferation, but have negligible effects on avian polarizing activity. These doses, however, are found to completely abolish morphogenetic activity by chick or quail anterior tissue grafts. The results of anterior (nonpolarizing) region tissue grafts are best interpreted as graft self-differentiation under the influence of a posterior signalling region, whose properties in the limb bud are demonstrably unique.     

"Fingering" the vertebrate limb

A detailed and precise picture is being pieced together about how the pattern of digits develops in vertebrate limbs. What is particularly exciting is that it will soon be possible to trace the process all the way from establishment of a signalling centre in a small bud of undifferentiated cells right through to final limb anatomy. The development of the vertebrate limb is a traditional model in which to explore mechanisms involved in pattern formation, and there is accelerating knowledge about the genes involved. One reason why the limb is holding its place in the post-genomic age is that it is rich in pre-genomic embryology. Here, we will focus on recent findings about the aspect of vertebrate limb development concerned with digit pattern across the anteroposterior axis of the limb. This process is controlled by a signalling region in the early limb bud known as the polarizing region. Interactions between polarizing region cells and other cells in the limb bud ensure that a thumb develops at one edge of the hand (anterior) and a little finger at the other (posterior).     

Cellular contribution to symmetrical forelimbs from triploid-marked "polarizing region" in the embryo of axolotl, Ambystoma mexicanum

Grafts of posterior tissue placed anterior to the limb bud in the salamander embryo exert a polarizing influence. To explain this result, the idea that the anteroposterior axis of the developing forelimb is polarized by a diffusible morphogen has been proposed. An alternative hypothesis, and the working hypothesis of the present study, is that the polarization of the developing salamander forelimb is accomplished by short-range cellular interactions resulting in intercalation rather than by the more global influence of a diffusible morphogen. One prediction of this intercalation hypothesis is that cells will be contributed to the limb from the "polarizing tissue." To test this idea, grafts of triploid marked polarizing tissue were implanted anterior to the limb bud in 82 diploid axolotl embryos at stages 32-34 of development. A total of 27 (33%) of the limbs that resulted were symmetrical and ranged in complexity from one to seven digits. Histological analysis of a subgroup of the original symmetrical limbs revealed that mesodermally derived tissues in the anterior side of these limbs (the side which formed as a duplication in response to the influence of the graft) contained high percentages of trinucleolate cells (muscle, 12.1%; connective tissue tissue, 12.5%; and cartilage, 13.4%) when compared to similar tissues in the posterior side of the same symmetrical limbs (muscle, 1.8%; connective tissue , 0.7%; and cartilage, 0.6%). When symmetrical limbs were amputated, 73% regenerated symmetrical limbs. When these regenerated limbs were again amputated, 63% formed symmetrical secondary regenerates. Histological analysis of the first generation of regenerated limbs revealed that the pattern of distribution of trinucleolate cells in each regenerate was similar to the pattern seen in the original symmetrical limb. These results indicate that there is considerable cellular contribution to the anterior side of the symmetrical forelimb from the mesoderm of grafted "polarizing tissue." This result supports the idea that short-range cellular interaction are sufficient for formation of symmetrical forelimbs in salamander embryos.     

Limb development in a "nonmodel" vertebrate, the direct-developing frog Eleutherodactylus coqui.

Mechanisms that mediate limb development are regarded as highly conserved among vertebrates, especially tetrapods. Yet, this assumption is based on the study of relatively few species, and virtually none of those that display any of a large number of specialized life-history or reproductive modes, which might be expected to affect developmental pattern or process. Direct development is an alternative life history found in many anuran amphibians. Many adult features that form after hatching in metamorphic frogs, such as limbs, appear during embryogenesis in direct-developing species. Limb development in the direct-developing frog Eleutherodactylus coqui presents a mosaic of apparently conserved and novel features. The former include the basic sequence and pattern of limb chondrogenesis, which are typical of anurans generally and appear largely unaffected by the gross shift in developmental timing; expression of Distal-less protein (Dlx) in the distal ectoderm; expression of the gene Sonic hedgehog (Shh) in the zone of polarizing activity (ZPA); and the ability of the ZPA to induce supernumerary digits when transplanted to the anterior region of an early host limb bud. Novel features include the absence of a morphologically distinct apical ectodermal ridge, the ability of the limb to continue distal outgrowth and differentiation following removal of the distal ectoderm, and earlier cessation of the inductive ability of the ZPA. Attempts to represent tetrapod limb development as a developmental "module" must allow for this kind of evolutionary variation among species.     

Feather buds exert a polarizing activity when transplanted to chick limb buds

Homeoproteins have been shown to be expressed in a position-specific manner along the anterior-posterior axis in the developing chick feather bud, as seen also in the developing limb bud. These facts raise the possibility that there may be common mechanistic features in the establishment of the anterior-posterior polarity between both organs. In order to investigate this possibility, feather bud tissues were transplanted into the anterior region of limb buds to determine whether feather bud tissues possess properties such as the zone of polarizing activity of the limb bud. The manipulated limb bud formed a mirror image duplication of the skeletal elements, mainly (2)2234 digit pattern or sometimes 3(2)234. Both the anterior and posterior halves of feather bud tissue exhibited almost equal activity in inducing ectopic skeletal elements. Hox d-12 and Hox a-13 were expressed coordinately around the transplanted site of the operated limb bud. This secondary axis-inducing activity of the feather bud was enhanced when grafts were pretreated with trypsin. In contrast, the presumptive feather bud tissue and inter-feather bud tissue did not induce a secondary axis of the limb bud. These results suggest that the feather bud contains a region that exerts polarizing activity and that this region may play key roles in the formation of the anterior-posterior and, if it exists, proximal-distal axis of the feather bud, possibly via the regulation of region specific expression of Hox genes.     

Inhibitory effect on limb morphogenesis by cells of the polarizing zone coaggregated with pre- or postaxial wing bud mesoderm.

The influence of cells of the polarizing zone mesoderm on the morphogenesis of recombinant chick limbs was studied. The recombinant buds were composed of leg bud ectoderm and different regions of the wing bud mesoderm, which had been dissociated and reaggregated. In any case where the polarizing zone mesoderm was coaggregated with the wing mesoderm the morphogenetic capabilities of the recombinant were reduced. This was the case with postaxial mesoderm, preaxial mesoderm plus polarizing tissue, and postaxial mesoderm from which a piece of the nonpolarizing mesoderm (comparable in size to the polarizing zone) had been removed. All of these gave outgrowths with digits in only a very low percentage of cases. In contrast, those recombinants without polarizing mesoderm developed outgrowths with digits in a high percentage of cases, indicating good morphogenesis. Finally, if the polarizing zone were removed prior to dissociation, the recombinant limb, composed of the total remaining wing bud mesoderm plus leg bud ectoderm, exhibited a higher percentage of complete morphogenesis than if the polarizing zone had been part of the recombinant.It is clear that cells of the polarizing zone, when dissociated, and coaggregated with wing mesoderm, are inhibitory to the morphogenetic performance of that mesoderm in the recombinant limb situation.     

The control of the anteroposterior and dorsoventral axes in embryonic chick limbs constructed of dissociated and reaggregated limb-bud mesoderm

In the 3- to 4-day embryonic avian limb bud, a unique zone of mesodermal tissue is located posteriorly at the junction of bud and body wall. Appropriately grafted to a host limb bud, it induces the formation of a supernumerary limb outgrowth from preaxial tissue and determines that its posterior side will face the graft. It is called the zone of polarizing activity (ZPA).When limb-bud mesoderm is isolated, dissociated, reaggregated centrifugally, jacketed in the mesoderm-free hull of another limb bud, and grown as a graft on a host embryo, the recombinant frequently forms a limb-like structure terminating in digits that fail to show differentiation with respect to the anteroposterior axis. When, however, a bit of ZPA tissue is implanted in the recombinant subjacent to the anterior or posterior margin of the ectoderm, the resulting outgrowth shows a characteristic anteroposterior order of digits that corresponds to the placement of the implant, regardless of its relationship with the anteroposterior axis of the ectoderm or of the host embryo.Dorsoventral differentials have been recognized only in limbs formed from reaggregated leg-bud mesoderm. The direction of the dorsoventral axis always corresponds to the original axis of the ectodermal jacket regardless of the orientation of the recombinant on the host.     

Modification of the zone of polarizing activity signal by trypsin

Patterning of the developing vertebrate limb along the anterior‐posterior axis is controlled by the zone of polarizing activity (ZPA) via the expression of Sonic hedgehog (Shh) and along the proximal‐distal axis by the apical ectodermal ridge (AER) through the production of fibroblast growth factors (FGFs). ZPA grafting, as well as ectopic application of SHH to the anterior chick limb bud, demonstrate that digit patterning is largely influenced by these secreted factors. Although signal transduction pathways have been well characterized for SHH and for FGFs, little is known of how these signals are regulated extracellularly in the limb. The present study shows that alteration of the extracellular environment through trypsin treatment can have profound effects on digit patterning. These effects appear to be mediated by the induction of Shh in host tissues and by ectopic AER formation, implicating the extracellular matrix in regulating the signaling activities of key patterning genes in the limb.     

Expression of a homeobox gene in the chick wing bud following application of retinoic acid and grafts of polarizing region tissue.

Homeobox gene XlHbox 1 is expressed in a mesodermal gradient in vertebrate forelimbs with maximal expression anteriorly and proximally and may encode positional values. In chick wing buds, anterior cells can be reprogrammed to form posterior structures by grafts of polarizing region tissue and by beads soaked in retinoic acid (RA), which is a good candidate for an endogenous morphogen. Applications of RA anteriorly or at the bud apex, treatments which produce duplicated digits or truncations respectively, substantially increase the extent of mesodermal XlHbox 1 expression. Polarizing region grafts that also produce additional digits lead to a moderate increase. The effects of RA application and the behaviour of transplanted tissue show that only anterior cells are competent to express XlHbox 1 and that expression is cell autonomous. Ectodermal expression in wing buds is enhanced by RA but not by polarizing region grafts and ectoderm/mesoderm recombinations show that the mesoderm is irreversibly affected. The changes in mesodermal expression do not fit the predictions of the simple model that XlHbox 1 encodes anterior positional values but are correlated with a series of novel malformations of the shoulder girdle which, in normal wing buds, is derived from cells expressing XlHbox 1.     

Intercalation and the cellular origin of supernumerary limbs in Xenopus

The hypothesis that a specialized polarizing zone controls the pattern of the anterior-posterior axis during limb development in Xenopus has been tested by analysing the cellular contribution to supernumerary limbs. Supernumerary limbs were generated by grafting hindlimb buds contralaterally between X. borealis and X. laevis to appose anterior and posterior limb tissues. Cells derived from these two species of Xenopus are readily identified by staining with quinacrine. The analysis of cellular contribution showed that supernumerary limbs consist of approximately half anterior-derived (57%) and half posterior-derived (43%) cells. These data are not consistent with the polarizing zone theory but are consistent with the hypothesis that both supernumerary limbs and normally developing limbs arise from intercalary interactions between limb bud cells with different positional values.     

Residual morphogenetic competence in the proximal core region of stage 25 chick limbs: Zwilling's hypothesis revisited

Morphogenetic competence (MC) exists in embryonic limb tissue once thought to have lost this property as a consequence of cytodifferentiation. By stage 25 of chick embryonic development, cells in the proximal core of the limb have committed to the cartilage phenotype and are producing their characteristic extracellular matrix. Recombinant limb-bud grafts constructed using isolated fragments of this tissue produce outgrowths with a limb-like skeletal pattern. Inclusion of proximal peripheral tissue in the grafts (with or without the polarizing tissue) inhibits outgrowth and skeletal morphogenesis, explaining the failure of earlier studies to reveal the MC of the proximal core (chondrogenic) cells. Since definitive chondroblasts express MC in more permissive surroundings, it appears that Zwilling's assertion, that the onset of cytodifferentiation causes the loss of MC, is an oversimplification and that complex tissue interactions are probably involved.     

Compatible limb patterning mechanisms in urodeles and anurans

We have experimentally tested the similarity of limb pattern-forming mechanisms in urodeles and anurans. To determine whether the mechanisms of limb outgrowth are equivalent, we compared the results of two kinds of reciprocal limb bud grafts between Xenopus and axolotls: contralateral grafts to confront anterior and posterior positions of graft and host, and ipsilateral grafts to align equivalent circumferential positions. Axolotl limb buds grafted to Xenopus hosts are immunologically rejected at a relatively early stage. Prior to rejection, however, experimental (but not control) grafts form supernumerary digits. Xenopus limb buds grafted to axolotl hosts are not rejected within the time frame of the experiment and therefore can be used to test the ability of frog cells to elicit responses from axolotl tissue that are similar to those that are elicited by axolotl tissue itself. When Xenopus buds were grafted to axolotl limb stumps so as to align circumferential positions, the majority of limbs did not form any supernumerary digits. However, in experimental grafts, where anterior and posterior of host and graft were misaligned, supernumerary digits formed at positional discontinuities. These results suggest that Xenopus/axolotl cell interactions result in responses that are similar to axolotl/axolotl cell interactions. Furthermore, axolotl and Xenopus cells can cooperate to build recognizable skeletal elements, despite large differences in cell size and growth rate between the two species. We infer from these results that urodeles and anurans share the same limb pattern-forming mechanisms, including compatible positional signals that allow appropriate localized cellular interactions between the two species. Our results suggest an approach for understanding homology of the tetrapod limb based on experimental cellular interactions.     

Cooperative Activation of HoxD Homeobox Genes by Factors from the Polarizing Region and the Apical Ridge in Chick Limb Morphogenesis

When a mouse zone of polarizing activity (ZPA) at the posterior margin of the limb bud was grafted into the anterior margin of the chick limb bud, the expressions of the chick homeobox genes HoxD12 and D13 were induced prior to the formation of chick extra digits. This induction was observed in a restricted domain close to both the grafted mouse ZPA and the chick apical ectodermal ridge (AER). When the posterior half of the AER was removed, the normal expression was diminished in the distaloposterior region. Thus, it is likely that at least two distinct factors, one from the ZPA and the other from the AER, act cooperatively to provide positional information to induce the sequential expression of the HoxD genes.