Deprotonation stimulates productive folding in allosteric TRAP hammerhead ribozymes

Hammerhead ribozymes in crystals change conformation in response to deprotonation of the nucleophilic 2' OH, thereby aligning the hydroxyl for in-line displacement at the scissile phosphate. Published data do not address whether deprotonation affects folding in solution. Allosteric hammerhead "TRAPs," when activated by the appropriate oligonucleotide, show the expected log-linear relation between initial cleavage rate and pH. In contrast, attenuated TRAPs shows biphasic kinetics in which a rapid burst is followed by slow cleavage that is nearly independent of pH. Attenuated ribozymes are stimulated by urea at both low and high pH, confirming that rearrangement of secondary structure is rate-limiting for the attenuated ribozymes once they have folded. Plots of burst magnitude versus pH in the absence of urea show a sharp transition around pH 8.3, which is near the kinetic pKa for the cleavage reaction in Mg2+. Raising the pH after folding at pH 7.5 did not activate attenuated ribozymes even when the RNA was incubated at the elevated pH for extended periods prior to addition of Mg2+. In contrast, lowering the pH after folding at pH 9.5 rapidly re-established attenuation. Deprotonation of the ribozyme-substrate complex thus appears to alter the folding landscape such that a metastable "pre-activated" complex forms before the thermodynamically more stable attenuated state can be attained. From the initial partition into active and inactive conformers, we estimate that this deprotonation contributes approximately 1.2 kcal/mol toward stabilization of the active fold at a crucial step during folding of the TRAP. Assuming that the nucleophilic 2' OH is the relevant acid, its deprotonation would thus serve a dual role of favoring productive fold and enhancing the nucleophilicity of this oxygen.     

RNA folding: models and perspectives

Intrinsic events during RNA folding include conformational search and metal ion binding. Several experimentally testable models have been proposed to explain how large ribozymes accomplish folding. Future challenges include the validation of these models, and the correlation of experimental results and theoretical simulations.     

RNA molecules with conserved catalytic cores but variable peripheries fold along unique energetically optimized pathways

Functional and kinetic constraints must be efficiently balanced during the folding process of all biopolymers. To understand how homologous RNA molecules with different global architectures fold into a common core structure we determined, under identical conditions, the folding mechanisms of three phylogenetically divergent group I intron ribozymes. These ribozymes share a conserved functional core defined by topologically equivalent tertiary motifs but differ in their primary sequence, size, and structural complexity. Time-resolved hydroxyl radical probing of the backbone solvent accessible surface and catalytic activity measurements integrated with structural-kinetic modeling reveal that each ribozyme adopts a unique strategy to attain the conserved functional fold. The folding rates are not dictated by the size or the overall structural complexity, but rather by the strength of the constituent tertiary motifs which, in turn, govern the structure, stability, and lifetime of the folding intermediates. A fundamental general principle of RNA folding emerges from this study: The dominant folding flux always proceeds through an optimally structured kinetic intermediate that has sufficient stability to act as a nucleating scaffold while retaining enough conformational freedom to avoid kinetic trapping. Our results also suggest a potential role of naturally selected peripheral A-minor interactions in balancing RNA structural stability with folding efficiency.     

Fast formation of the P3-P7 pseudoknot: a strategy for efficient folding of the catalytically active ribozyme

Formation of the P3-P7 pseudoknot structure, the core of group I ribozymes, requires long-range base pairing. Study of the Tetrahymena ribozyme appreciates the hierarchical folding of the large, multidomain RNA, in which the P3-P7 core folds significantly slower than do the other domains. Here we explored the formation of the P3-P7 pseudoknot of the Candida ribozyme that has been reported to concertedly fold to the catalytically active structure with a rate constant of 2 min(-1). We demonstrate that pseudoknot formation occurs during the rapid ribozyme compaction, coincident with formation of many tertiary interactions of the ribozyme. A low physiological concentration of magnesium (1.5 mM) is sufficient to fully support the pseudoknot formation. The presence of nonnative intermediates containing an unfolded P3-P7 region is evident. However, catalysis-based analysis shows these nonnative intermediates are stable and fail to convert to the catalytically active structure, suggesting that rapid pseudoknot formation is essential for folding of the active ribozyme. Interestingly, RNAstructure predicts no stable Alt P3 structure for the Candida ribozyme, but two stable Alt P3s for the Tetrahymena ribozyme, explaining the dramatic difference in folding of the P3-P7 core of these two ribozymes. We propose that rapid formation of the P3-P7 pseudoknot represents a folding strategy ensuring efficient production of the catalytically active structure of group I ribozymes, which sheds new light on the mechanism of effective ribozyme folding in vivo.     

Mapping nucleic acid structure by hydroxyl radical cleavage

Hydroxyl radical footprinting is a widely used method for following the folding of RNA molecules in solution. This method has the unique ability to provide experimental information on the solvent accessibility of each nucleotide in an RNA molecule, so that the folding of all domains of the RNA species can be followed simultaneously at single-nucleotide resolution. In recent work, hydroxyl radical footprinting has been used, often in combination with other global measures of structure, to work out detailed folding pathways and three-dimensional structures for increasingly large and complicated RNA molecules. These include synthetic ribozymes, and group I and group II ribozymes, from yeast, the Azoarcus cyanobacterium and Tetrahymena thermophila. Advances have been made in methods for analysis of hydroxyl radical data, so that the large datasets that result from kinetic folding experiments can be analyzed in a semi-automated and quantitative manner.     

Iterative annealing mechanism explains the functions of the GroEL and RNA chaperones

Molecular chaperones are ATP‐consuming machines, which facilitate the folding of proteins and RNA molecules that are kinetically trapped in misfolded states. Unassisted folding occurs by the kinetic partitioning mechanism according to which folding to the native state, with low probability as well as misfolding to one of the many metastable states, with high probability, occur rapidly. GroEL is an all‐purpose stochastic machine that assists misfolded substrate proteins to fold. The RNA chaperones such as CYT‐19, which are ATP‐consuming enzymes, help the folding of ribozymes that get trapped in metastable states for long times. GroEL does not interact with the folded proteins but CYT‐19 disrupts both the folded and misfolded ribozymes. The structures of GroEL and RNA chaperones are strikingly different. Despite these differences, the iterative annealing mechanism (IAM) quantitatively explains all the available experimental data for assisted folding of proteins and ribozymes. Driven by ATP binding and hydrolysis and GroES binding, GroEL undergoes a catalytic cycle during which it samples three allosteric states, T (apo), R (ATP bound), and R^″ (ADP bound). Analyses of the experimental data show that the efficiency of the GroEL–GroES machinery and mutants is determined by the resetting rate k _{R ″ → T} , which is largest for the wild‐type (WT) GroEL. Generalized IAM accurately predicts the folding kinetics of Tetrahymena ribozyme and its variants. Chaperones maximize the product of the folding rate and the steady‐state native state fold by driving the substrates out of equilibrium. Neither the absolute yield nor the folding rate is optimized.     

A general strategy for effector-mediated control of RNA-cleaving ribozymes and DNA enzymes

A novel and general approach is described for generating versions of RNA-cleaving ribozymes (RNA enzymes) and DNAzymes (DNA enzymes), whose catalytic activity can be controlled by the binding of activator molecules. Variants of the RNA-cleaving 10-23 DNAzyme and 8-17 DNAzyme were created, whose catalysis was activated by up to approximately 35-fold by the binding of the effector adenosine. The design of such variants was possible even though the tertiary folding of the two DNAzymes is not known. Variants of the hammerhead ribozyme were constructed, to respond to the effectors ATP and flavin mononucleotide. Whereas in conventional allosteric ribozymes, effector-binding modulates the chemical step of catalysis, here, effectors exercise their effect upon the substrate-binding step, by stabilizing the enzyme-substrate complex. Because such an approach for controlling the activity of DNAzymes/ribozymes requires no prior knowledge of the enzyme's secondary or tertiary folding, this regulatory strategy should be generally applicable to any RNA-cleaving ribozyme or DNAzyme, natural or in vitro selected, provided substrate-recognition is achieved by Watson-Crick base-pairing.     

Protein-Facilitated Folding of Group II Intron Ribozymes

Multiple studies hypothesize that DEAD-box proteins facilitate folding of the ai5γ group II intron. However, these conclusions are generally inferred from splicing kinetics, and not from direct monitoring of DEAD-box protein-facilitated folding of the intron. Using native gel electrophoresis and dimethyl sulfate structural probing, we monitored Mss-116-facilitated folding of ai5γ intron ribozymes and a catalytically active self-splicing RNA containing full-length intron and short exons. We found that the protein directly stimulates folding of these RNAs by accelerating formation of the compact near-native state. This process occurs in an ATP-independent manner, although ATP is required for the protein turnover. As Mss 116 binds RNA nonspecifically, most binding events do not result in the formation of the compact state, and ATP is required for the protein to dissociate from such nonproductive complexes and rebind the unfolded RNA. Results obtained from experiments at different concentrations of magnesium ions suggest that Mss 116 stimulates folding of ai5γ ribozymes by promoting the formation of unstable folding intermediates, which is then followed by a cascade of folding events resulting in the formation of the compact near-native state. Dimethyl sulfate probing results suggest that the compact state formed in the presence of the protein is identical to the near-native state formed more slowly in its absence. Our results also indicate that Mss 116 does not stabilize the native state of the ribozyme, but that such stabilization results from binding of attached exons.     

Oligoribonucleotide circularization by 'template-mediated' ligation with T4 RNA ligase: synthesis of circular hammerhead ribozymes.

Circular hammerhead ribozymes were synthesized from linear oligoribonucleotides using T4 RNA ligase. Some of the precursors could not be efficiently circularized under standard conditions. For these molecules, the use of a DNA template allowed their efficient circularization. The template was designed to prevent the precursor from folding into an unsuitable structure. The template allowed circular ribozymes as small as 15 nucleotides in length to be efficiently synthesized at concentrations as high as 50 microM in the ligation reaction. The circular products retained their biological activity.     

Freely diffusing single hairpin ribozymes provide insights into the role of secondary structure and partially folded states in RNA folding

Single-molecule fluorescence resonance energy transfer studies of freely diffusing hairpin ribozymes with different combinations of helical junction and loop elements reveal striking differences in their folding behavior. We examined a series of six different ribozymes consisting of two-, three- and four-way junction variants, as well as corresponding constructs with one of the two loops removed. Our results highlight the varying contributions of preformed secondary structure elements to tertiary folding of the hairpin ribozyme. Of the three helical junction variants studied, the four-way junction strongly favored folding to a docked conformation of the two loops, required for catalytic activity. Moreover, the four-way junction was uniquely able to fold to a similar compact structure even in the absence of specific loop-loop docking interactions. A key feature of the data is the observation of broadening/tailing in the fluorescence resonance energy transfer histogram peak for a single-loop mutant of the four-way junction at higher Mg(2+) concentrations, not observed for any of the other single-loop variants. This feature is consistent with interconversion between compact and extended structures, which we estimate takes place on the 100-micros timescale using a simple model for the peak shape. This unique ability of the four-way junction ribozyme to populate an undocked conformation with native-like structure (a quasi-docked state) likely contributes to its greater tertiary structure stability, with the quasi-docked state acting as an intermediate and facilitating the subsequent formation of the specific hydrogen bonding network during docking of the two loops. The inability of two- and three-way junction ribozymes to fully populate a docked conformation reveals the importance of correct helical junction geometry as well as loop elements for effective ribozyme folding.     

The kinetics and magnesium requirements for the folding of antigenomic delta ribozymes

Using an oligonucleotide hybridization assay to gain insight into the folding of delta ribozymes, we demonstrate a correlation between their folding and catalytic behavior. Together with recent structural information on the crystal structure of self-cleaved genomic delta ribozyme, in which the L3 loop interacts with J1/4 to form the newly proposed stem P1.1, we conclude that it is likely that the P1.1 stem forms only in the presence of Mg(2+). This stem can be detected in both the self-cleaved and trans-acting delta ribozymes. When the trans-acting version of antigenomic delta ribozyme was studied, it is demonstrated that its L3 loop requires magnesium and, apparently, formation of the P1 stem for the subsequently formation of the P1.1 stem. Most importantly, the kinetics were monitored, and provide a significant addition to our understanding of ribozyme tertiary structure formation prior to the chemical cleavage step. Using previous kinetic data and our new findings, we discuss the rate-limiting characteristics of delta ribozyme folding.     

Folding of a universal ribozyme: the ribonuclease P RNA

Ribonuclease P is among the first ribozymes discovered, and is the only ubiquitously occurring ribozyme besides the ribosome. The bacterial RNase P RNA is catalytically active without its protein subunit and has been studied for over two decades as a model system for RNA catalysis, structure and folding. This review focuses on the thermodynamic, kinetic and structural frameworks derived from the folding studies of bacterial RNase P RNA.     

Metal ion binding to catalytic RNA molecules

Cations play critical roles in ribozyme structure and catalysis. Unraveling the contributions of cations as catalytic cofactors is a complex process, due to their role in inducing RNA folding and their potential ability to influence chemical reactions. Recent studies have made progress in separating these roles by directly comparing ion-induced folding with ribozyme activity. In addition, spectroscopic studies have allowed some ribozyme metal sites to be directly observed in solution, providing binding affinities and ligand information. The emerging picture suggests that important cation sites can be classified according to their affinities and properties, and can be located within the ribozyme structure. At moderate ionic strengths, a common theme is emerging for some ribozymes of structural sites that have relatively high metal ion affinities and a second type of metal site with weaker affinity that is responsible for catalysis or structural fine-tuning. In the larger ribozymes, apparent clusters of metal-sensitive positions are observed.     

A versatile communication module for controlling RNA folding and catalysis

To exert control over RNA folding and catalysis, both molecular engineering strategies and in vitro selection techniques have been applied toward the development of allosteric ribozymes whose activities are regulated by the binding of specific effector molecules or ligands. We now describe the isolation and characterization of a new and considerably versatile RNA element that functions as a communication module to render disparate RNA folding domains interdependent. In contrast to some existing communication modules, the novel 9-nt RNA element is demonstrated to function similarly between a variety of catalysts that include the hepatitis delta virus, hammerhead, X motif and Tetrahymena group I ribozymes, and various ligand-binding domains. The data support a mechanistic model of RNA folding in which the element is comprised of both canonical and non-canonical base pairs and an unpaired nucleotide in the active, effector-bound conformation. Aside from enabling effector-controlled RNA function through rational design, the element can be utilized to identify sites in large RNAs that are susceptible to effector regulation.     

Pseudoknots: a new motif in the RNA game.

In the last few years a novel RNA folding principle called pseudoknotting has emerged. Originally discovered in noncoding regions of plant viral RNAs, pseudoknots now appear to be a widespread structural motif in a number of functionally different RNAs. These structural elements are part of tRNA-like structures and are involved in folding catalytic sites of ribozymes. They increase the efficiency of ribosomal frameshifting or can serve as specific binding sites for regulatory proteins.     

Formation of RNA spatial structures

The review considers different experimental and theoretical approaches to the investigation of RNA folding and identification of nucleotides that critically affect the folding of molecules, such as tRNA, and several classes of ribozymes. For instance, it has been shown that nucleotides of the D- and T-loop regions are the last to be involved in the tRNA structure, or, rather, they are not included in the tRNA folding nucleus. A specially developed SHAPE method was used to show that the long-recognized hierarchical folding model does not hold true for tRNA folding. In the second part of the review, algorithms and programs used for the prediction of RNA secondary structures, as well as for modeling RNA folding, are considered.     

Expressing active ribozymes in cells

Artificially engineered ribozymes can be used to specifically regulate expression of target genes. Such ribozymes can be synthesized chemically and delivered into the cell exogeneously. Alternatively, ribozymes can be produced by the cell endogenously, after introduction of the artificial gene into the cellular genome. In the latter case, the design of the artificial gene defines the ribozyme properties, such as: expression level, intracellular localization, folding and association with proteins. Generally speaking, design of the expression vector is critical to obtain active ribozyme molecules. This paper first describes factors that are known or predicted to affect ribozyme activity in the cell, then reviews various expression systems that have been specifically developed for ribozymes. Lastly, a recently developed ribozyme system termed snorbozymes (small nucleolar RNA:ribozyme hybrids) will be discussed. This powerful test system has generated several important observations that are likely to affect the future development of ribozyme technology.     

Engineering high-speed allosteric hammerhead ribozymes

Full-length hammerhead ribozymes were subjected to in vitro selection to identify variants that are allosterically regulated by theophylline in the presence of a physiologically relevant concentration of Mg(2+). The population of allosteric ribozymes resulting from 15 rounds of in vitro selection yielded variants with observed rate constants (k (obs)) as high as 8 min(-1) in the presence of theophylline and maximal k (obs) increases of up to 285-fold compared to rate constants measured in the absence of effector. The selected ribozymes have kinetic characteristics that are predicted to be sufficient for cellular gene control applications, but do not exhibit any activity in reporter gene assays. The inability of the engineered RNAs to control gene expression suggests that the in vitro and in vivo folding pathways of the RNAs are different. These results provide several key pieces of information that will aid in future efforts to engineer allosteric ribozymes for gene control applications.     

Formation of spatial structure of RNA molecules

In this review we consider several experimental and theoretical approaches for investigation of RNA folding and determination of nucleotides that play an important role upon folding of such molecules as tRNA and several classes of ribozymes. It has been shown that nucleotides in the D- and T-loop regions are the last to be involved in tRNA structure or they are not included in the folding nucleus of tRNA. Using the specially elaborated method SHAPE it has been demonstrated that the model of hierarchical folding which was recognized for a long time is not correct for tRNA folding. In the second part of the given review the algorithms and programs used for the prediction of secondary structures of RNA as well as for modeling of RNA folding are considered.