Suppressive subtractive hybridization as a tool for identifying genetic diversity in an environmental metagenome: the rumen as a model

Molecular techniques previously used for genome comparisons of closely related bacterial species could prove extremely valuable for comparisons of complex microbial communities, or metagenomes. Our study aimed to determine the breadth and value of suppressive subtractive hybridization (SSH) in a pilot-scale analysis of metagenomic DNA from communities of microorganisms in the rumen. Suppressive subtractive hybridization was performed using total genomic DNA isolated from rumen fluid samples of two hay-fed steers, arbitrarily designated as tester or driver. Ninety-six subtraction DNA fragments from the tester metagenome were amplified, cloned and the DNA sequences were determined. Verification of the isolation of DNA fragments unique to the tester metagenome was accomplished through dot blot and Southern blot hybridizations. Tester-specific SSH fragments were found in 95 of 96 randomly selected clones. DNA sequences of subtraction fragments were analysed by computer assisted DNA and amino acid comparisons. Putative translations of 26 (32.1%) subtractive hybridization fragments exhibited significant similarity to Bacterial proteins, whereas 15 (18.5%) distinctive subtracted fragments had significant similarity to proteins from Archaea. The remainder of the subtractive hybridization fragments displayed no similarity to GenBank sequences. This metagenomic approach has exposed an unexpectedly large difference in Archaeal community structure between the rumen microbial populations of two steers fed identical diets and housed together. 16S rRNA dot blot hybridizations revealed similar proportions of Bacteria and Archaea in both rumen samples and suggest that the differences uncovered by SSH are the result of varying community structural composition. Our study demonstrates a novel approach to comparative analyses of environmental microbial communities through the use of SSH.     

Differential expression of immune-related genes and transposable elements in black tiger shrimp (Penaeus monodon) exposed to a range of environmental stressors

The health of aquatic species is dependent on interactions between the environment, pathogens and the host. Under intensive shrimp aquaculture, environmental conditions can degrade, causing significant stress to the cultured organisms. To investigate the effect of environmental stress on shrimp hemocyte gene expression profiles, we applied suppression subtractive hybridization (SSH) in juvenile Penaeus monodon exposed to hyperthermal, hypoxic or hyposmotic conditions. Random sequencing of 258 clones from the SSH revealed 176 distinct sequences of which 58 shared high similarity to sequences in the public databases. The three most common groups of identifiable unique sequences in the SSH libraries were the POL region of non-LTR retrotransposons (31%), genes with immune or potential immune functions (30%), and genes involved in protein synthesis and processing (18%). Stress-regulated differential expression was further verified by quantitative qRT-PCR, with seven out of eight randomly selected genes showing qRT-PCR profiles that conformed to the patterns predicted by SSH. Hence this work provides a list of genes which appear to be up- or down-regulated in response to stress, providing a basis for studying the genetic response of shrimp to environmental stress.     

低温对鲤鱼的5个基因在不同组织中表达量的影响

本研究应用实时荧光定量 PCR技术对抑制性消减杂交所得到的鲤鱼不同温度下差异表达的5个基因做进一步的研究.结果表明: 水温由16℃降至4℃(骤降点)的过程中,在鲤鱼的肝、肠组织中,LKE-25基因的表达量呈下降趋势,而LKE-62基因则呈上升趋势;在肾脏组织中,LKE-48-1、 LKE-48-2和LKE-59基因的表达量呈上升趋势,且随着4℃维持时间的延长,其表达量逐渐下降.LKE-25和LKE-59基因在4℃同一尾鱼的心脏、脑、肝、脾、肾、肠组织中的表达量上有很大差异,其中LKE-25基因在心、LKE-59基因在肾组织中的表达量最高 .本实验所研究的5个基因在不同温度、不同组织表达量的显著差异,证明了这些基因与水温相关且有组织特异性 [动物学报 54(3):460-466,2008].     

Valuation for usefulness of selected chromosomal markers for Bacillus anthracis identification. II. Valuation for markers SSH and rpoB

The article presents results of valuation for B. anthracis-specificity and usefulness for its identification obtained for different chromosomal markers. In the second part of the study markers SSH241, SSH196, SSH163, SSH133 as well as a fragment of the house-keeping gene rpoB were analyzed. For the investigation MSSCP and multiplex-PCR assays were used. There were also tested different techniques of electrophoresis. The results gave an information about specificity of tested markers and their usefulness for B. anthracis identification.     

Molecular cloning of an IL-8-like CXC chemokine and tissue factor in rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) by use of suppression subtractive hybridization

Suppression subtractive hybridization (SSH) was performed to construct a Rainbow trout cDNA library enriched in sequences up-regulated in head kidney leukocytes after lipopolysaccharide (LPS) and tumour necrosis factor alpha (TNFalpha) stimulation. Random sequencing of fifty clones allowed the identification of a Rainbow trout interleukin 8 (IL-8)-related CXC chemokine, as well as the Rainbow trout tissue factor (TF) precursor. Expression of both the IL-8-like chemokine and TF is induced after LPS and TNFalpha stimulation, indicating that they are associated with inflammatory responses in fish, as has been suggested in mammals. These results confirm the potential of SSH to identify cytokines and immuno-regulatory genes in fish.     

Expression patterns in soybean resistant to Phakopsora pachyrhizi reveal the importance of peroxidases and lipoxygenases

Soybean rust caused by Phakopsora pachyrhizi Sydow is a devastating foliar disease that has spread to most soybean growing regions throughout the world, including the USA. Four independent rust resistance genes, Rpp1–Rpp4, have been identified in soybean that recognize specific isolates of P. pachyrhizi. A suppressive subtraction hybridization (SSH) complementary DNA (cDNA) library was constructed from the soybean accession PI200492, which contains Rpp1, after inoculation with two different isolates of P. pachyrhizi that result in susceptible or immune reactions. Both forward and reverse SSH were performed using cDNA from messenger RNA pooled from 1, 6, 12, 24, and 48 h post-inoculation. A total of 1,728 SSH clones were sequenced and compared to sequences in GenBank for similarity. Microarray analyses were conducted on a custom 7883 soybean-cDNA clone array encompassing all of the soybean-rust SSH clones and expressed sequence tags from four other soybean cDNA libraries. Results of the microarray revealed 558 cDNA clones differentially expressed in the immune reaction. The majority of the upregulated cDNA clones fell into the functional category of defense. In particular, cDNA clones with similarity to peroxidases and lipoxygenases were prevalent. Downregulated cDNA clones included those with similarity to cell-wall-associated protein, such as extensins, proline-rich proteins, and xyloglucan endotransglycosylases. Electronic supplementary material  The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

Genome comparison of Bifidobacterium longum strains NCC2705 and CRC-002 using suppression subtractive hybridization

Because probiotic effects are strain dependent, genomic explanations of these differences will contribute to understanding their mechanisms of action. The genomic sequence of the Bifidobacterium longum probiotic strain NCC2705 was determined, but little is known about the genetic diversity between strains of this species. Suppression subtractive hybridization (SSH) is a powerful method for generating a set of DNA fragments differing between two closely related bacterial strains. The purpose of this study was to identify genetic differences between genomes of B. longum strains NCC2705 and CRC-002 using PCR-based SSH. Strain CRC-002 produces exopolysaccharides whereas NCC2705 is not known for reliable exopolysaccharide production. Thirty-five and 30 different sequences were obtained from the SSH libraries of strains CRC-002 and NCC2705, respectively. Specific CRC-002 genes found were predicted to be involved in the biosynthesis of exopolysaccharides and metabolism of other carbohydrates, and these genes were not present in the genome of strain NCC2705. The identification of an endo-1,4-beta-xylanase gene in the CRC-002 SSH library is an important difference because xylanase genes have previously been proposed as a defining characteristic of the NCC2705 strain. The results demonstrate that the SSH technique was useful to highlight potential genes involved in complex sugar metabolism that differ between the two probiotic strains.     

Prokaryotic Suppression Subtractive Hybridization PCR cDNA Subtraction, a Targeted Method To Identify Differentially Expressed Genes

Molecular biology tools can be used to monitor and optimize biological treatment systems, but the application of nucleic acid-based tools has been hindered by the lack of available sequences for environmentally relevant biodegradation genes. The objective of our work was to extend an existing molecular method for eukaryotes to prokaryotes, allowing us to rapidly identify differentially expressed genes for subsequent sequencing. Suppression subtractive hybridization (SSH) PCR cDNA subtraction is a technique that can be used to identify genes that are expressed under specific conditions (e.g., growth on a given pollutant). While excellent methods for eukaryotic SSH PCR cDNA subtraction are available, to our knowledge, no methods previously existed for prokaryotes. This work describes our methodology for prokaryotic SSH PCR cDNA subtraction, which we validated using a model system: Pseudomonas putida mt-2 degrading toluene. cDNA from P. putida mt-2 grown on toluene (model pollutant) or acetate (control substrate) was subjected to our prokaryotic SSH PCR cDNA subtraction protocol to generate subtraction clone libraries. Over 90% of the sequenced clones contained gene fragments encoding toluene-related enzymes, and 20 distinct toluene-related genes from three key operons were sequenced. Based on these results, prokaryotic SSH PCR cDNA subtraction shows promise as a targeted method for gene identification.     

Stolbur phytoplasma genome survey achieved using a suppression subtractive hybridization approach with high specificity

Phytoplasmas are unculturable bacterial plant pathogens transmitted by phloem-feeding hemipteran insects. DNA of phytoplasmas is difficult to purify because of their exclusive phloem location and low abundance in plants. To overcome this constraint, suppression subtractive hybridization (SSH) was modified and used to selectively amplify DNA of the stolbur phytoplasma infecting a periwinkle plant. Plasmid libraries were constructed, and the origins of the DNA inserts were verified by hybridization and PCR screenings. After a single round of SSH, there was still a significant level of contamination with plant DNA (around 50%). However, the modified SSH, which included a second round of subtraction (double SSH), resulted in an increased phytoplasma DNA purity (97%). Results validated double SSH as an efficient way to produce a genome survey for microbial agents unavailable in culture. Assembly of 266 insert sequences revealed 181 phytoplasma genetic loci which were annotated. Comparative analysis of 113 kbp indicated that among 217 protein coding sequences, 83% were homologous to "Candidatus Phytoplasma asteris" (OY-M strain) genes, with hits widely distributed along the chromosome. Most of the stolbur-specific SSH sequences were orphan genes, with the exception of two partial coding sequences encoding proteins homologous to a mycoplasma surface protein and riboflavin kinase.     

小麦抗病基因表达谱中的文库构建与筛选方法研究

以抗白粉病品系“百农 32 17×Mardler”BC5F4为材料 ,构建了白粉病菌诱导的普通cDNA文库和抑制消减杂交(SSH)cDNA文库。分别对两文库进行了一定规模的测序 ,获得普通cDNA文库不重复ESTs 387条和SSHcDNA文库ESTs 76 0条。将获得的ESTs与GenBank序列进行了BLASTn、BLASTx同源性分析。结果表明 :在普通文库中 ,一些参与光合作用与核糖体构成等的基因出现频率较高 ,而获得的抗病相关基因则较少。消减文库在构建方法、抗病相关基因的富集等方面具有明显的优越性 ,是目前抗病基因表达谱研究中的较好方法。利用高密度点阵膜杂交技术对两文库的筛选结果表明 ,该方法具有相对简便易操作、杂交膜可反复使用等优点 ;但也存在mRNA及同位素用量大等问题。经筛选 ,消减文库中有 5 4 1%的功能已知ESTs为抗病相关基因 ,被证明参与了小麦抗白粉病反应     

Stolbur Phytoplasma Genome Survey Achieved Using a Suppression Subtractive Hybridization Approach with High Specificity

Phytoplasmas are unculturable bacterial plant pathogens transmitted by phloem-feeding hemipteran insects. DNA of phytoplasmas is difficult to purify because of their exclusive phloem location and low abundance in plants. To overcome this constraint, suppression subtractive hybridization (SSH) was modified and used to selectively amplify DNA of the stolbur phytoplasma infecting a periwinkle plant. Plasmid libraries were constructed, and the origins of the DNA inserts were verified by hybridization and PCR screenings. After a single round of SSH, there was still a significant level of contamination with plant DNA (around 50%). However, the modified SSH, which included a second round of subtraction (double SSH), resulted in an increased phytoplasma DNA purity (97%). Results validated double SSH as an efficient way to produce a genome survey for microbial agents unavailable in culture. Assembly of 266 insert sequences revealed 181 phytoplasma genetic loci which were annotated. Comparative analysis of 113 kbp indicated that among 217 protein coding sequences, 83% were homologous to “Candidatus Phytoplasma asteris” (OY-M strain) genes, with hits widely distributed along the chromosome. Most of the stolbur-specific SSH sequences were orphan genes, with the exception of two partial coding sequences encoding proteins homologous to a mycoplasma surface protein and riboflavin kinase.     

茶树肌动蛋白基因（CsActin1）全长cDNA克隆与生物信息学分析

以茶树（Camellia sinensis）萌动芽为材料,根据茶树萌动芽芽抑制消减杂交文库中分离得到的肌动蛋白（actin）基因的5′-片段设计引物,利用3′-RACE技术克隆了其cDNA全长序列,该基因cDNA全长1 470 bp,命名为CsActin1（GenBank登录号HQ235647）。序列分析表明,CsActin1开放阅读框长1 134 bp,编码377个氨基酸,5′非编码区100 bp,3′非编码区236 bp。推测的蛋白质分子量为41.70 kD,等电点约为5.31,具有肌动蛋白家族的特征信号序列（YVGDEAQs.KRG和WIAKaEYDE）和肌动蛋白相关蛋白的特征信号序列（LLTEApLNPkaNR）。CsActin1与GenBank中注册的其它植物肌动蛋白核苷酸序列的相似性在80%以上,氨基酸序列相似性在95%以上。与其它植物肌动蛋白的进化树分析结果表明,茶树肌动蛋白与杨树的两个肌动蛋白间的亲缘关系最为密切。并对推导的蛋白结构进行了分析。     

Combining SSH and cDNA microarrays for rapid identification of differentially expressed genes

Comparing patterns of gene expression in cell lines and tissues has important applications in a variety of biological systems. In this study we have examined whether the emerging technology of cDNA microarrays will allow a high throughput analysis of expression of cDNA clones generated by suppression subtractive hybridization (SSH). A set of cDNA clones including 332 SSH inserts amplified by PCR was arrayed using robotic printing. The cDNA arrays were hybridized with fluorescent labeled probes prepared from RNA from ER-positive (MCF7 and T47D) and ER-negative (MDA-MB-231 and HBL-100) breast cancer cell lines. Ten clones were identified that were over-expressed by at least a factor of five in the ER-positive cell lines. Northern blot analysis confirmed over-expression of these 10 cDNAs. Sequence analysis identified four of these clones as cytokeratin 19, GATA-3, CD24 and glutathione-S-transferase mu-3. Of the remaining six cDNA clones, four clones matched EST sequences from two different genes and two clones were novel sequences. Flow cytometry and immunofluorescence confirmed that CD24 protein was over-expressed in the ER-positive cell lines. We conclude that SSH and microarray technology can be successfully applied to identify differentially expressed genes. This approach allowed the identification of differentially expressed genes without the need to obtain previously cloned cDNAs.     

A comparison of algorithms for the identification of specimens using DNA barcodes: examples from gymnosperms

In order to use DNA sequences for specimen identification (e.g., barcoding, fingerprinting) an algorithm to compare query sequences with a reference database is needed. Precision and accuracy of query sequence identification was estimated for hierarchical clustering (parsimony and neighbor joining), similarity methods (BLAST, BLAT and megaBLAST), combined clustering/similarity methods (BLAST/parsimony and BLAST/neighbor joining), diagnostic methods (DNA–BAR and DOME ID), and a new method (ATIM). We offer two novel alignment‐free algorithmic solutions (DOME ID and ATIM) to identify query sequences for the purposes of DNA barcoding. Publicly available gymnosperm nrITS 2 and plastid matK sequences were used as test data sets. On the test data sets, almost all of the methods were able to accurately identify sequences to genus; however, no method was able to accurately identify query sequences to species at a frequency that would be considered useful for routine specimen identification (42–71% unambiguously correct). Clustering methods performed the worst (perhaps due to alignment issues). Similarity methods, ATIM, DNA–BAR, and DOME ID all performed at approximately the same level. Given the relative precision of the algorithms (median = 67% unambiguous), the low accuracy of species‐level identification observed could be ascribed to the lack of correspondence between patterns of allelic similarity and species delimitations. Application of DNA barcoding to sequences of CITES listed cycads (Cycadopsida) provides an example of the potential application of DNA barcoding to enforcement of conservation laws. © The Willi Hennig Society 2006.     

Role of Normalization in the Elimination of Abundant Myelin Sequences in Spinal Cord cDNA Libraries Produced by Suppression Subtractive Hybridization

Spinal cord libraries subtracted against visual cortex using suppression subtractive hybridization SSH are dominated by abundant gene sequences derived from myelin elements. We compared our subtracted library results of three of these abundant sequences to published expressed sequence tag libraries that are not normalized and not subtracted and presumed representatives of murine spinal cord mRNA abundance. We show that: all three abundant sequences, myelin basic protein (Mbp), proteolipid protein (Plp1) and Ferretin heavy chain (Fth1) are highly expressed in spinal cord when this structure is compared to visual cortex; myelin basic protein is represented in our subtracted libraries but at a low frequency, whereas Plp1 and Fth1 represent nearly one-third of all sequences in these libraries; mirror orientation selection, a procedure designed to reduce background sequences, generates libraries very similar in abundance to SSH; proteolipid protein can be reduced in these libraries by adding Plp1 sequences to the driver in the SSH procedure and also by subtracting Plp1 directly from tester and driver. We conclude that adequate normalization is essential to reduce the presence of abundant sequences in SSH libraries.     

Identification of Genes Differentially Expressed by <Emphasis Type="Italic">Metarhizium anisopliae</Emphasis> Growing on <Emphasis Type="Italic">Locusta migratoria</Emphasis> Wings Using Suppression Subtractive Hybridization

Insect-pathogenic fungi penetrate their hosts directly through the cuticle. To better understand this process, we identified genes that were up-regulated by Metarhizium anisopliae germinating and differentiating on Locusta migratoria wings using suppression subtractive hybridization (SSH). A total of 78 unique expressed sequence tags (ESTs) up-regulated more than twofold during fungal growth on locust wings were identified. Among these 78 ESTs, 30 (38.5%) shared significant similarity with NCBI annotated hypothetical proteins, 16 (20.5%) shared low similarity to known or predicted genes, might represent novel genes, and 32 (41.0%) shared significant similarity with known proteins that are involved in various cell and molecular processes such as cell metabolism, protein metabolism, stress response and defense, and cell structure and function. Semi-quantitative RT-PCR analysis of six randomly selected genes confirmed the SSH results, verifying the fidelity of the SSH data. The results of this study provide novel information on genes expressed during early stages of infection with M. anisopliae, and improve current understanding of fungal pathogenesis.     

抑制差减杂交筛选禽致病性大肠杆菌基因组差异片段及其分析

采用抑制差减杂交技术(Suppression subtractive hybridization,SSH)对禽致病性大肠杆菌E037株(血清型O78)与非致病菌株K-12MG1655以及同一O2血清型高致病菌株E058与低致病菌株E526进行基因组差异片段克隆与分析。从E037株中共检出17个特异性差异片段,E058株中共检出32个特异性差异片段。经同源分析,这些序列可分为4类:质粒相关序列、噬菌体相关序列、已知功能序列、未知功能序列。这些差异片段包含许多重要的大肠杆菌毒力相关基因,如大肠杆菌素、气杆菌素受体、铁基因簇等。49个片段中,14个片段与其它微生物基因组同源性较高。结果表明,大肠杆菌高致病株与低致病菌株或非致病菌株基因组间存在较多差异基因,其中包括毒力、毒力相关基因、代谢以及噬菌体等基因成分。