Characterization of harpin<Subscript>Xoo</Subscript> induced hypersensitive responses in non host plant,tobacco

Harpin proteins encoded by hrp genes are bacterial protein elicitors that can stimulate hypersensitive response (HR) in non-host plants. HR-related pathogen resistance involves a complex form of programmed cell death (PCD). It is increasingly viewed as a key component of the hypersensitive disease response of plants. Currently, the evidence of harpin proteins-induced PCD is deficient though it exhibits phenotypic parallels with HR, and the mechanism of harpin proteins-induced PCD is not well understood. In this study, we demonstrate that harpin_Xoo protein from Xanthomonas oryzae pv. oryzae of rice bacterial blight expressed and isolated from bacterial cells acted as an agent to induce PCD in infiltrated tobacco plants. Treatment of tobacco leaves with harpin_Xoo induced typical PCD-related morphological and biochemical changes including cell shrinkage and nuclear DNA degradation. We further analyzed the expression of several genes in signal transduction pathway of PCD in tobacco plants by real-time qRT-PCR analysis using EF-1α as an endogenous control. Our results showed that the expression of NtDAD1 was down-regulated and the expression of BI-1, tpa1 and aox1 was up-regulated following the infiltration of harpin_Xoo into tobacco leaves. Our data suggest that harpin_Xoo can induce PCD with the coordination of PCD-related genes in infiltrated tobacco leaves, providing evidence to further investigate the signal transduction pathways of HR and PCD.     

Incompatible pathogen infection results in enhanced reactive oxygen and cell death responses in transgenic tobacco expressing a hyperactive mutant calmodulin

Transgenic tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L. cv. Wisconsin 38) lines expressing a mutant calmodulin (VU-3) that hyperactivates NAD kinase exhibit an enhanced elicitor-stimulated oxidative-burst reaction (S.A. Harding et al., 1997, EMBO J. 16: 1137–1144). VU-3 transgenic tobacco was used in the present study to investigate the relationship between calmodulin signalling, the production of active oxygen species and cell death in response to infection with an incompatible pathogen. Following P. syringae pv. syringae 61 infection, suspension cells derived from VU-3 transgenic plants exhibited a stronger oxidative burst (3- to 4-fold higher primary and secondary burst reactions), greater media alkalinization (3-fold) and more rapid cell death (4-fold greater mortality at 20 h post infection) than did infected control tobacco cells. Infection of leaf tissues with P. syringae pv. syringae 61 also resulted in an enhanced cell death response compared to control tobacco tissues. This cell death response of VU-3 leaf tissues, but not control leaf tissues, was further enhanced by the presence of 50 μM salicylic acid, suggesting that this transgenic line is more sensitive to the effects of this agent. Overall, the data support the model that calmodulin signalling pathways are involved in the plant oxidative burst and contribute to the regulation of cell death in infected plant tissues undergoing the hypersensitive response. Received: 6 January 1998 / Accepted: 7 March 1998     

Ectopically expressed sweet pepper ferredoxin PFLP enhances disease resistance to Pectobacterium carotovorum subsp. carotovorum affected by harpin and protease‐mediated hypersensitive response in Arabidopsis

Plant ferredoxin‐like protein (PFLP) is a photosynthesis‐type ferredoxin (Fd) found in sweet pepper. It contains an iron–sulphur cluster that receives and delivers electrons between enzymes involved in many fundamental metabolic processes. It has been demonstrated that transgenic plants overexpressing PFLP show a high resistance to many bacterial pathogens, although the mechanism remains unclear. In this investigation, the PFLP gene was transferred into Arabidopsis and its defective derivatives, such as npr1 (nonexpresser of pathogenesis‐related gene 1) and eds1 (enhanced disease susceptibility 1) mutants and NAHG‐transgenic plants. These transgenic plants were then infected with the soft‐rot bacterial pathogen Pectobacterium carotovorum subsp. carotovorum (Erwinia carotovora ssp. carotovora, ECC) to investigate the mechanism behind PFLP‐mediated resistance. The results revealed that, instead of showing soft‐rot symptoms, ECC activated hypersensitive response (HR)‐associated events, such as the accumulation of hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂), electrical conductivity leakage and expression of the HR marker genes (ATHSR2 and ATHSR3) in PFLP‐transgenic Arabidopsis. This PFLP‐mediated resistance could be abolished by inhibitors, such as diphenylene iodonium (DPI), 1‐l ‐trans‐epoxysuccinyl‐leucylamido‐(4‐guanidino)‐butane (E64) and benzyloxycarbonyl‐Val‐Ala‐Asp‐fluoromethylketone (z‐VAD‐fmk), but not by myriocin and fumonisin. The PFLP‐transgenic plants were resistant to ECC, but not to its harpin mutant strain ECCAC5082. In the npr1 mutant and NAHG‐transgenic Arabidopsis, but not in the eds1 mutant, overexpression of the PFLP gene increased resistance to ECC. Based on these results, we suggest that transgenic Arabidopsis contains high levels of ectopic PFLP; this may lead to the recognition of the harpin and to the activation of the HR and other resistance mechanisms, and is dependent on the protease‐mediated pathway.     

An improved method for monitoring cell death in cell suspension and leaf disc assays using evans blue

Cell viability or cell death is an important variable to monitor in many studies of host/pathogen interactions. However for studies that focus on events within the first few hours of the interaction, many of the viability assays currently being used are either too laborious and time consuming or measure the cell's temporary metabolic state rather than irreversible cell death. Evans blue has proven over the years to be a dependable stain for microscopic determination of cell death. We have used this stain to develop a spectrophotometric procedure that allows rapid, reproducible quantification of the stain retained by dead cells. This spectrophotometric procedure was used to compare plant/bacteria interactions involving either soybean/Pseudomonas syringae pv. glycinea or tobacco/P. syringae pv. syringae. Relative increases in cell death during these interactions in suspension cell systems were measured by both the spectrophotometric and microscopic technique and found to be similar. The spectrophotometric procedure was also adapted for leaf disc assays.Abbreviations HR hypersensitive response - SDS sodium dodecyl sulfate     

In planta measurements of oxidative bursts elicited by avirulent and virulent bacterial pathogens suggests that H2O2 is insufficient to elicit cell death in tobacco

A rapid and localized programmed cell death – the hypersensitive response (HR) – is a widely utilized plant resistance mechanism against pathogens. Studies have implicated H₂O₂ generation as a key elicitory mechanism in the HR. The causal relationship between the kinetics of the in planta oxidative burst, the HR and certain defence gene expression was examined. H₂O₂ generation following challenge with avirulent strains of Pseudomonas syringae pv. (P. s. pv.) syringae occurred in two phases. The effects of ROS generation were investigated using the H₂O₂-responsive transgene AoPR10-GUS, the dually responsive (H₂O₂ and salicylic acid) PR1a-GUS as well as measures of cell death. Co-application of catalase with P. s. pv. syringae into tobacco leaf panels suppressed AoPR10- and PR1a-GUS expression and cell death. Conversely, varying H₂O₂ generation with glucose: glucose oxidase influenced both defence gene expression and cell death. AoPR10-GUS proved to be primarily responsive to apoplastic not intracellular oxidative stress, suggesting that the apoplasm was a distinctive source of oxidative signals. A biphasic oxidative burst was also observed with virulent P. s. pv. tabaci, which, although delayed compared to that observed during HR, persisted at equivalent levels for a longer period. Taking all these data together we suggest that either (1) additional factors to the apoplastic oxidative burst are required to explain the rapid kinetics of defence signalling and cell death associated with the HR or (2) P. s. pv. tabaci successfully suppresses the effects of H₂O₂ generation by an unknown mechanism.     

Indole-3-acetic acid reverses the harpin-induced hypersensitive response and alters the expression of hypersensitive-response-related genes in tobacco

Harpin proteins stimulate hypersensitive response (HR) in plants. However, the mechanism by which HR is regulated is not clear. The role of the auxin, indole-3-acetic acid (IAA), in the control of harpin-stimulated HR was investigated. IAA was used to inhibit HR that was stimulated by purified fusion harpin_Xoo protein in tobacco. Semi-quantitative PCR and qRT-PCR were employed to detect the expression of HR related genes. IAA at 100 μM reversed harpin-induced HR which was inhibited by 500 μM 2,3,5-triiodobenzoic acid (TIBA). Semi-quantitative PCR and qRT-PCR showed the combined application of 100 μM IAA and harpin protein from Xanthomonas oryzae enhanced the expression of HR marker gene, hsr203J, but weakened the expression of the disease-defense gene, chia5. TIBA also decreased the expression of hsr203J but increased the expression of chia5. Thus, the auxin can reverse harpin_Xoo-induced HR.     

Involvement of mitochondria and metacaspase elevation in harpinPss‐induced cell death of Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Expression of a proteinaceous elicitor harpin_Pss, encoded by hrpZ of Pseudomonas syringae pv. syringae 61, under GAL1 promoter in Saccharomyces cerevisiae Y187 resulted in galactose‐inducible yeast cell death (YCD). Extracellular treatment of harpin did not affect the growth of yeast. The observed YCD was independent of the stage of cell cycle. “Petite” mutant of S. cerevisiae Y187 pYEUT‐hrpZ was insensitive to cell death indicating the involvement of mitochondria in this YCD. Loss in mitochondrial potential, but no leakage of Cytochrome c from mitochondria into the cytosol, were notable features in harpin_Pss‐induced YCD. Cyclosporin A had no effect on hrpZ expressing yeast cells, further confirmed that there was no release of Cytochrome c. Elevation of caspase activity has been reported for the first time in this form of cell death induced by harpin expression. Release of reactive oxygen species and clear loss of membrane integrity were evident with the absence of nuclear fragmentation and chromosomal condensation, while annexin V and propidium iodide staining showed features typical of necrosis. J. Cell. Biochem. 107: 1150–1159, 2009. © 2009 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Different responses of two tobacco cultivars and their cell suspension cultures to quercinin,a novel elicitin from Phytophthora quercina

In this study we describe the response of two tobacco cultivars (Nicotiana tabacum L. cv. Bel B and Bel W3) and their cell suspension cultures to quercinin, a novel elicitin produced by the oak pathogen Phytophthora quercina. N-terminal sequencing of the purified protein proved that it belongs to the basic β-elicitins with threonine on position 13. Both tobacco leaves and cells of the cultivar Bel W3 showed hypersensitive cell death after quercinin treatment. Leaves of Bel B also developed quercinin-induced necrosis but higher concentrations of quercinin were necessary as compared to Bel W3. Also Bel B cells showed cell death induction only at the highest quercinin concentration (20 nM). In cell suspension experiments we also measured the quercinin-induced oxidative burst, which occurred in both cultivars. H₂O₂ production in Bel B increased with increasing quercinin concentration and was inhibited only at the highest elicitin concentration (20 nM) whereas the oxidative burst in Bel W3 was completely abolished by 5 nM quercinin. Furthermore we demonstrated that neither H₂O₂ nor superoxide were responsible for cell death induction since neither the inhibitor diphenyleneiodonium (DPI) nor the enzymes catalase (CAT) and superoxide dismutase (SOD) influenced the hypersensitive reaction (HR) in Bel W3 cells. Due to the different response of Bel W3 and Bel B towards the P. quercina elicitin, our system represents an interesting tool to elucidate signaling pathways in tobacco leading to hypersensitive cell death.     

Pepper pathogenesis‐related protein 4c is a plasma membrane‐localized cysteine protease inhibitor that is required for plant cell death and defense signaling

Xanthomonas campestris pv. vesicatoria (Xcv) type III effector AvrBsT triggers programmed cell death (PCD) and activates the hypersensitive response (HR) in plants. Here, we isolated and identified the plasma membrane localized pathogenesis‐related (PR) protein 4c gene (CaPR4c) from pepper (Capsicum annuum) leaves undergoing AvrBsT‐triggered HR cell death. CaPR4c encodes a protein with a signal peptide and a Barwin domain. Recombinant CaPR4c protein expressed in Escherichia coli exhibited cysteine protease‐inhibitor activity and ribonuclease (RNase) activity. Subcellular localization analyses revealed that CaPR4c localized to the plasma membrane in plant cells. CaPR4c expression was rapidly and specifically induced by avirulent Xcv (avrBsT) infection. Transient expression of CaPR4c caused HR cell death in pepper leaves, which was accompanied by enhanced accumulation of H₂O₂ and significant induction of some defense‐response genes. Deletion of the signal peptide from CaPR4c abolished the induction of HR cell death, indicating a requirement for plasma membrane localization of CaPR4c for HR cell death. CaPR4c silencing in pepper disrupted both basal and AvrBsT‐triggered resistance responses, and enabled Xcv proliferation in infected leaves. H₂O₂ accumulation, cell‐death induction, and defense‐response gene expression were distinctly reduced in CaPR4c‐silenced pepper. CaPR4c overexpression in transgenic Arabidopsis plants conferred greater resistance against infection by Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato and Hyaloperonospora arabidopsidis. These results collectively suggest that CaPR4c plays an important role in plant cell death and defense signaling.     

Comparative analysis of induction pattern of programmed cell death and defense-related responses during hypersensitive cell death and development of bacterial necrotic leaf spots in eggplant

Pseudomonas cichorii causes necrotic leaf spots (NLS), while Pseudomonas syringae pv. tabaci induces a hypersensitive response (HR) in eggplant. P. cichorii induced cell death at 9 h after inoculation (HAI), reaching a maximum of around 24–30 HAI. On the other hand, cell death was induced 6 HAI with P. syringae pv. tabaci, reaching a maximum of around 12–18 HAI. Superoxide generation was observed in eggplant inoculated with both bacteria. DNA fragmentation, cytochrome c release into the cytosol and expression of defense-related genes such as PR-1 and hsr203J was also induced by inoculation with both bacteria, but these plant reactions were more rapidly induced in eggplant inoculated with P. syringae pv. tabaci rather than those with P. cichorii. Lipid peroxidation and induction of lipoxygenase (LOX) was drastically induced in eggplant inoculated with P. syringae pv. tabaci compared to P. cichorii-inoculated eggplant. Pharmacological studies showed that induction of the cell death, and the NLS or the HR in response to both bacteria was commonly associated with de novo protein synthesis, reactive oxygen species and caspase III-like protease. Interestingly, involvement of lipid peroxidation, LOX, serine protease, and DNase differed between induction of NLS and HR. These results suggest that programmed cell death might be closely associated not only with the HR but also NLS. However, there may be differences not only in the induction kinetics and level of plant responses but also in the infection-related responses between HR and NLS.     

Defence gene expression in soybean is linked to the status of the cell death program

Soybean cell cultures (cv. Williams 82) respond to Pseudomonas syringae bacteria expressing the avirulence gene AvrA with a hypersensitive reaction, a programmed cell death (PCD) of plant cells to pathogen attack. This PCD is under control of salicylic acid (SA) via an unknown mechanism. In the presence of low concentrations of SA, the cells undergo a very rapid cell death, which needs only half of the time required for the normal hypersensitive reaction (HR). Northern blot studies for defence-related genes show that the expression of many of these genes is tightly linked to the status of the cell death program rather than to pathogen-derived elicitors. Thus the expression is much faster in the SA-accelerated PCD than in the normal hypersensitive reaction. In contrast, other pathogen-responsive genes are induced independently of the speed of PCD, indicating a divergent signalling mechanism. The production of reactive oxygen species during the oxidative burst of bacteria-inoculated soybean cells is slightly enhanced in the presence of SA but occurs at the same time as in untreated cells, suggesting that SA exhibits the control of the PCD downstream of the oxidative burst. Consistent with these findings a HR-specific marker gene is neither directly induced by H₂O₂ or SA. However, this gene shows a high expression in the regular HR and is induced much faster in the SA-accelerated PCD.     

Distinct Pseudomonas type‐III effectors use a cleavable transit peptide to target chloroplasts

The pathogen Pseudomonas syringae requires a type‐III protein secretion system and the effector proteins it injects into plant cells for pathogenesis. The primary role for P. syringae type‐III effectors is the suppression of plant immunity. The P. syringae pv. tomato DC3000 HopK1 type‐III effector was known to suppress the hypersensitive response (HR), a programmed cell death response associated with effector‐triggered immunity. Here we show that DC3000 hopK1 mutants are reduced in their ability to grow in Arabidopsis, and produce reduced disease symptoms. Arabidopsis transgenically expressing HopK1 are reduced in PAMP‐triggered immune responses compared with wild‐type plants. An N‐terminal region of HopK1 shares similarity with the corresponding region in the well‐studied type‐III effector AvrRps4; however, their C‐terminal regions are dissimilar, indicating that they have different effector activities. HopK1 is processed in planta at the same processing site found in AvrRps4. The processed forms of HopK1 and AvrRps4 are chloroplast localized, indicating that the shared N‐terminal regions of these type‐III effectors represent a chloroplast transit peptide. The HopK1 contribution to virulence and the ability of HopK1 and AvrRps4 to suppress immunity required their respective transit peptides, but the AvrRps4‐induced HR did not. Our results suggest that a primary virulence target of these type‐III effectors resides in chloroplasts, and that the recognition of AvrRps4 by the plant immune system occurs elsewhere. Moreover, our results reveal that distinct type‐III effectors use a cleavable transit peptide to localize to chloroplasts, and that targets within this organelle are important for immunity.     

Effects of Singlet Oxygen Quenchers and pH on the Bacterially Induced Hypersensitive Reaction in Tobacco Suspension Cell Cultures

Suspension cell cultures of Nicotiana tabacum L. inoculated with the incompatible pathogen Pseudomonas syringae pv pisi undergo a hypersensitive reaction. Addition of the singlet oxygen quencher bixin to cell suspensions had no effect on hypersensitive cell death. Addition of the singlet oxygen quencher 1,4-diazabicyclo octane (DABCO) increased the medium pH and delayed the onset of cell death. This delay was eliminated when cell suspensions were buffered, and could also be induced by increasing medium pH with KOH. Bixin and DABCO also did not suppress the hypersensitive reaction in tobacco leaves. These data do not support a role for singlet oxygen in the hypersensitive reaction. Medium pH, however, appears to be a critical factor in cell suspension cultures.     

Glucocorticoid‐inducible expression of a bacterial avirulence gene in transgenic Arabidopsis induces hypersensitive cell death

Pathogenic strains of Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato carrying the avrRpt2 avirulence gene specifically induce a hypersensitive cell death response in Arabidopsis plants that contain the complementary RPS2 disease resistance gene. Transient expression of avrRpt2 in Arabidopsis plants having the RPS2 gene has been shown to induce hypersensitive cell death. In order to analyze the effects of conditional expression of avrRpt2 in Arabidopsis plants, transgenic lines were constructed that contained the avrRpt2 gene under the control of a tightly regulated, glucocorticoid-inducible promoter. Dexamethasone-induced expression of avrRpt2 in transgenic lines having the RPS2 gene resulted in a specific hypersensitive cell death response that resembled a Pseudomonas syringae-induced hypersensitive response and also induced the expression of a pathogenesis-related gene (PR1). Interestingly, high level expression of avrRpt2 in a mutant rps2–101C background resulted in plant stress and ultimately cell death, suggesting a possible role for avrRpt2 in Pseudomonas syringae virulence. Transgenic RPS2 and rps2 plants that contain the glucocorticoid-inducible avrRpt2 gene will provide a powerful new tool for the genetic, physiological, biochemical, and molecular dissection of an avirulence gene-specified cell death response in both resistant and susceptible plants.     

Assessment of inheritance pattern and agronomic performance of transgenic rapeseed having harpin<Subscript>Xooc</Subscript>-encoding <Emphasis Type="Italic">hrf2</Emphasis> Gene

hrf2 gene is a member of the harpin-encoding gene family of rice-pathogenic bacterium Xanthomonas oryzae pv. oryzicola. In our previous studies, we observed that harpin_Xooc could elicit hypersensitive cell death in non-host plants, induce disease and insect resistance in plants, and enhance plant growth. In this study, the rapeseed cultivar, Yangyou 4, was genetically engineered via Agrobacterium-mediated transformation to express the hrf2 gene. Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and southern blot analyses of T₁ generation of transgenic rapeseed revealed stable integration and expression of the inserted gene hrf2. In addition, the resistance to Sclerotinia sclerotiorum was greatly enhanced. A comparison between agronomic characters of transgenic and control lines displayed significant differences in terms of plant height, stem width, number of pods per plant, number of seeds per pod, 1,000-seed weight, and seed yield per plant. Among lines with resistance to S. sclerotiorum, T₁1 had improved agronomic traits compared with controls with a 22.7% seed yield increase. These results suggest that the introduction of the hrf2 gene into rapeseed can be an effective strategy for enhancing resistance to S. sclerotiorum.     

Cloning of soybean genes induced during hypersensitive cell death caused by syringolide elicitor

Syringolide elicitors produced by bacteria expressing Pseudomonas syringae pv. glycinea avirulence gene D (avrD) induce hypersensitive cell death (HCD) only in soybean (Glycine max [L.] Merr.) plants carrying the Rpg4 disease resistance gene. Employing a differential display method, we isolated 13 gene fragments induced in cultured cells of a soybean cultivar Harosoy (Rpg4) treated with syringolides. Several genes for isolated fragments were induced by syringolides in an rpg4 cultivar Acme as well as in Harosoy; however, the genes for seven fragments designated as SIH (for syringolide-induced/HCD associated) were induced exclusively or strongly in Harosoy. cDNA clones for SIH genes were obtained from a cDNA library of Harosoy treated with syringolide. Several sequences are homologous to proteins associated with plant defense responses. The SIH genes did not respond to a non-specific -glucan elicitor, which induces phytoalexin accumulation but not HCD, suggesting that the induction of the SIH genes is specific for the syringolide–Harosoy interaction. HCD and the induction of SIH genes by syringolides were independent of H₂O₂. On the other hand, Ca²⁺ was required for HCD and the induction of some SIH genes. These results suggest that the induction of SIH genes by syringolides could be activated through the syringolide-specific signaling pathway and the SIH gene products may play an important role(s) in the processes of HCD induced by syringolides.Abbreviations AOS active oxygen species - CHS chalcone synthase - DPI diphenylene iodonium - HCD hypersensitive cell death - HR hypersensitive response - PAL phenylalanine ammonia lyase - SID syringolide-induced/defense associated - SIG syringolide-induced/general - SIH for syringolide-induced/HCD associated - XET xyloglucan endotransglycosylase     

Early Detection of Bacterium-induced Basal Resistance in Tobacco Leaves with Diaminobenzidine and Dichlorofluorescein Diacetate

The present study demonstrate that in tobacco leaves the diaminobenzidine (DAB) and 2′,7′‐dichlorofluorescein diacetate (DCFH‐DA) staining is a useful indicator of the basal (also known as general or innate) defence‐associated reactions, especially of the early developing form of basal resistance (EBR). DAB and DCFH‐DA, in the presence of H₂O₂ and peroxidase converts to a brown polymer and fluorescent DCF respectively. In the present study, the hypersensitive response (HR)‐inducing avirulent Pseudomonas syringae pv. syringae 61, its HR‐negative hrp/hrc mutants and even non‐pathogenic bacteria such as P. fluorescens and Escherichia coli caused DAB and DCFH‐DA staining, if the dyes were injected 3–4 h after bacterial inoculation into tobacco leaves. The conditions that enable the staining of plant leaves infiltrated with HR‐negative bacteria were persisted for 1 to several days depending on the physiological state of the plant, and plant activity was required to the development of the staining. The live virulent P. syringae pv. tabaci was able to suppress the development of the staining reaction. Bacteria that induced more intensive staining reaction triggered stronger local resistance response, which was verified by its ability to inhibit the HR by challenging avirulent bacteria and by expression analysis of genes that are activated during the basal defence response. The peroxidase enzyme activity increased in bacterially treated tobacco tissue, and inhibition of peroxidase activity blocked the development of the staining. The results showed that in tobacco leaves the staining reactions were associated with the general recognition and basal defence reaction of tobacco plant and can be used as markers in tobacco leaves for testing the occurrence of this type of defence.     

Deficient plastidic fatty acid synthesis triggers cell death by modulating mitochondrial reactive oxygen species

Programmed cell death (PCD) is of fundamental importance to development and defense in animals and plants. In plants, a well-recognized form of PCD is hypersensitive response (HR) triggered by pathogens, which involves the generation of reactive oxygen species (ROS) and other signaling molecules. While the mitochondrion is a master regulator of PCD in animals, the chloroplast is known to regulate PCD in plants. Arabidopsis Mosaic Death 1 (MOD1), an enoyl-acyl carrier protein (ACP) reductase essential for fatty acid biosynthesis in chloroplasts, negatively regulates PCD in Arabidopsis. Here we report that PCD in mod1 results from accumulated ROS and can be suppressed by mutations in mitochondrial complex I components, and that the suppression is confirmed by pharmaceutical inhibition of the complex I-generated ROS. We further show that intact mitochondria are required for full HR and optimum disease resistance to the Pseudomonas syringae bacteria. These findings strongly indicate that the ROS generated in the electron transport chain in mitochondria plays a key role in triggering plant PCD and highlight an important role of the communication between chloroplast and mitochondrion in the control of PCD in plants.