Why Have Small Multidrug Resistance Proteins Not Evolved into Fused,Internally Duplicated Structures?

The increasing number of solved membrane protein structures has led to the recognition of a common feature in a large fraction of the small-molecule transporters: inverted repeat structures, formed by two fused homologous membrane domains with opposite orientation in the membrane. An evolutionary pathway in which the ancestral state is a single gene encoding a dual-topology membrane protein capable of forming antiparallel homodimers has been posited. A gene duplication event enables the evolution of two oppositely orientated proteins that form antiparallel heterodimers. Finally, fusion of the two genes generates an internally duplicated transporter with two oppositely orientated membrane domains. Strikingly, however, in the small multidrug resistance (SMR) family of transporters, no fused, internally duplicated proteins have been found to date. Here, we have analyzed fused versions of the dual-topology transporter EmrE, a member of the SMR family, by blue-native PAGE and in vivo activity measurements. We find that fused constructs give rise to both intramolecular inverted repeat structures and competing intermolecular dimers of varying activity. The formation of several intramolecularly and intermolecularly paired species indicates that a gene fusion event may lower the overall amount of active protein, possibly explaining the apparent absence of fused SMR proteins in nature.     

Antiparallel dimers of the small multidrug resistance protein EmrE are more stable than parallel dimers

The bacterial multidrug transporter EmrE is a dual-topology membrane protein and as such is able to insert into the membrane in two opposite orientations. The functional form of EmrE is a homodimer; however, the relative orientation of the subunits in the dimer is under debate. Using EmrE variants with fixed, opposite orientations in the membrane, we now show that, although the proteins are able to form parallel dimers, an antiparallel organization of the subunits in the dimer is preferred. Blue-native PAGE analyses of intact oligomers and disulfide cross-linking demonstrate that in membranes, the proteins form parallel dimers only if no oppositely orientated partner is present. Co-expression of oppositely orientated proteins almost exclusively yields antiparallel dimers. Finally, parallel dimers can be disrupted and converted into antiparallel dimers by heating of detergent-solubilized protein. Importantly, in vivo function is correlated clearly to the presence of antiparallel dimers. Our results suggest that an antiparallel arrangement of the subunits in the dimer is more stable than a parallel organization and likely corresponds to the functional form of the protein.     

The projection structure of EmrE, a proton-linked multidrug transporter from Escherichia coli, at 7 A resolution

EmrE belongs to a family of eubacterial multidrug transporters that confer resistance to a wide variety of toxins by coupling the influx of protons to toxin extrusion. EmrE was purified and crystallized in two dimensions by reconstitution with dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine into lipid bilayers. Images of frozen hydrated crystals were collected by cryo-electron microscopy and a projection structure of EmrE was calculated to 7 A resolution. The projection map shows an asymmetric EmrE dimer with overall dimensions approximately 31 x 40 A, comprising an arc of highly tilted helices separating two helices nearly perpendicular to the membrane from another two helices, one tilted and the other nearly perpendicular. There is no obvious 2-fold symmetry axis perpendicular to the membrane within the dimer, suggesting that the monomers may have different structures in the functional unit.     

Spectroscopic analysis of small multidrug resistance protein EmrE in the presence of various quaternary cation compounds

Escherichia coli EmrE protein is the archetypical member of the small multidrug resistance protein family in bacteria and confers host resistance to a wide assortment of toxic quaternary cation compounds by secondary active efflux. This protein can form a variety of multimers under various membrane mimetic conditions, and the consensus of most biochemical and biophysical studies indicate that the active form is a dimer. The purpose of this study is to characterize the conformation of organically extracted detergent solubilized EmrE protein known to predominate as monomer yet demonstrates ligand binding ability. Active site EmrE-E14 replacements were also examined as functionally inactive controls for this study. EmrE was solubilized in detergents, sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) and dodecyl maltoside (DDM), and protein conformation was examined in the presence of four known quaternary cation compound (QCC) substrates, tetraphenyl phosphonium (TPP), methyl viologen, cetylpyridinium, and ethidium. SDS-Tricine PAGE analysis of both detergent solubilized proteins revealed that DDM-EmrE preparations enhanced the formation of dimer (and in some cases trimer) forms in the presence of all four QCC above 25 QCC:1 EmrE molar ratios. Examination of EmrE and its active site variant tertiary structures in DDM by circular dichroism spectropolarimetry, intrinsic Trp fluorescence quenching and second order derivative ultraviolet absorbance revealed that the variant fails to bind TPP but interacts with all other compounds. The results of this study show that monomeric detergent solubilized EmrE is capable of forming multimeric complexes that are enhanced by chemically diverse QCCs.     

Common occurrence of internal repeat symmetry in membrane proteins

Symmetry plays significant roles in protein structure and function. Particularly, symmetric interfaces are known to act as switches for two-state conformational change. Membrane proteins often undergo two-state conformational change during the transport process of ion channels or the active/inactive transitions in receptors. Here, we provide the first comprehensive analyses of internal repeat symmetry in membrane proteins. We examined the known membrane protein structures and found that, remarkably, nearly half of them have internal repeat symmetry. Moreover, we found that the conserved cores of these internal repeats are positioned at the interface of symmetric units when they are mapped on structures. Because of the large sequence divergence that occurs between internal repeats, the inherent symmetry present in protein sequences often has only been detected after structure determination. We therefore developed a sensitive procedure to predict the internal repeat symmetry from sequence information and identified 4653 proteins that are likely to have internal repeat symmetry.     

The membrane topology of EmrE - a small multidrug transporter from Escherichia coli

EmrE is a multidrug transporter from Escherichia coli that belongs to the Smr family of small multidrug transporters. The secondary structure of EmrE consists of a four helical bundle, as judged by different techniques. EmrE has been extensively characterized; nevertheless, the membrane topology of EmrE has not been determined yet. Previous work with a homologous Smr protein provided partial information of the membrane topology, however the location of the carboxy-terminus remained inconclusive. In this work we probed the membrane topology of EmrE, focusing on the carboxy-terminus of the protein, using two independent approaches. Our results support a secondary structure where the carboxy-terminus faces the cytoplasm, while the first loop faces the periplasm.     

Structure,Dynamics, and Substrate-induced Conformational Changes of the Multidrug Transporter EmrE in Liposomes

EmrE, a member of the small multidrug transporters superfamily, extrudes positively charged hydrophobic compounds out of Escherichia coli cytoplasm in exchange for inward movement of protons down their electrochemical gradient. Although its transport mechanism has been thoroughly characterized, the structural basis of energy coupling and the conformational cycle mediating transport have yet to be elucidated. In this study, EmrE structure in liposomes and the substrate-induced conformational changes were investigated by systematic spin labeling and EPR analysis. Spin label mobilities and accessibilities describe a highly dynamic ligand-free (apo) conformation. Dipolar coupling between spin labels across the dimer reveals at least two spin label populations arising from different packing interfaces of the EmrE dimer. One population is consistent with antiparallel arrangement of the monomers, although the EPR parameters suggest deviations from the crystal structure of substrate-bound EmrE. Resolving these discrepancies requires an unusual disposition of TM3 relative to the membrane-water interface and a kink in its backbone that enables bending of its C-terminal part. Binding of the substrate tetraphenylphosphonium changes the environment of spin labels and their proximity in three transmembrane helices. The underlying conformational transition involves repacking of TM1, tilting of TM2, and changes in the backbone configurations of TM3 and the adjacent loop connecting it to TM4. A dynamic apo conformation is necessary for the polyspecificity of EmrE allowing the binding of structurally diverse substrates. The flexibility of TM3 may play a critical role in movement of substrates across the membrane.     

Precious things come in little packages

The 110-amino acid multidrug transporter from E. coli, EmrE, is a member of the family of MiniTexan or Smr drug transporters. EmrE can transport acriflavine, ethidium bromide, tetraphenylphosphonium (TPP+), benzalkonium and several other drugs with relatively high affinities. EmrE is an H+/drug antiporter, utilizing the proton electrochemical gradient generated across the bacterial cytoplasmic membrane by exchanging two protons with one substrate molecule. The EmrE multidrug transporter is unique in its small size and hydrophobic nature. Hydropathic analysis of the EmrE sequence predicts four alpha-helical transmembrane segments. This model is experimentally supported by FTIR studies that confirm the high alpha-helicity of the protein and by high-resolution heteronuclear NMR analysis of the protein structure. The TMS of EmrE are tightly packed in the membrane without any continuous aqueous domain, as was shown by Cysteine scanning experiments. These results suggest the existence of a hydrophobic pathway through which the substrates are translocated. EmrE is functional as a homo-oligomer as suggested by several lines of evidence, including co-reconstitution experiments of wild-type protein with inactive mutants in which negative dominance has been observed. EmrE has only one membrane embedded charged residue, Glu-14, that is conserved in more than fifty homologous proteins and it is a simple model system to study the role of carboxylic residues in ion-coupled transporters. We have used mutagenesis and chemical modification to show that Glu-14 is part of the substrate-binding site. Its role in proton binding and translocation was shown by a study of the effect of pH on ligand binding, uptake, efflux and exchange reactions. We conclude that Glu-14 is an essential part of a binding site, common to substrates and protons. The occupancy of this site is mutually exclusive and provides the basis of the simplest coupling of two fluxes. Because of some of its properties and its size, EmrE provides a unique system to understand mechanisms of substrate recognition and translocation.     

Determination of structural models of the complex between the cytoplasmic domain of erythrocyte band 3 and ankyrin-R repeats 13-24

The adaptor protein ankyrin-R interacts via its membrane binding domain with the cytoplasmic domain of the anion exchange protein (AE1) and via its spectrin binding domain with the spectrin-based membrane skeleton in human erythrocytes. This set of interactions provides a bridge between the lipid bilayer and the membrane skeleton, thereby stabilizing the membrane. Crystal structures for the dimeric cytoplasmic domain of AE1 (cdb3) and for a 12-ankyrin repeat segment (repeats 13-24) from the membrane binding domain of ankyrin-R (AnkD34) have been reported. However, structural data on how these proteins assemble to form a stable complex have not been reported. In the current studies, site-directed spin labeling, in combination with electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) and double electron-electron resonance, has been utilized to map the binding interfaces of the two proteins in the complex and to obtain inter-protein distance constraints. These data have been utilized to construct a family of structural models that are consistent with the full range of experimental data. These models indicate that an extensive area on the peripheral domain of cdb3 binds to ankyrin repeats 18-20 on the top loop surface of AnkD34 primarily through hydrophobic interactions. This is a previously uncharacterized surface for binding of cdb3 to AnkD34. Because a second dimer of cdb3 is known to bind to ankyrin repeats 7-12 of the membrane binding domain of ankyrin-R, the current models have significant implications regarding the structural nature of a tetrameric form of AE1 that is hypothesized to be involved in binding to full-length ankyrin-R in the erythrocyte membrane.     

Quasi-symmetry in the cryo-EM structure of EmrE provides the key to modeling its transmembrane domain

Small multidrug resistance (SMR) transporters contribute to bacterial resistance by coupling the efflux of a wide range of toxic aromatic cations, some of which are commonly used as antibiotics and antiseptics, to proton influx. EmrE is a prototypical small multidrug resistance transporter comprising four transmembrane segments (M1-M4) that forms dimers. It was suggested recently that EmrE molecules in the dimer have different topologies, i.e. monomers have opposite orientations with respect to the membrane plane. A 3-D structure of EmrE acquired by electron cryo-microscopy (cryo-EM) at 7.5 Angstroms resolution in the membrane plane showed that parts of the structure are related by quasi-symmetry. We used this symmetry relationship, combined with sequence conservation data, to assign the transmembrane segments in EmrE to the densities seen in the cryo-EM structure. A C alpha model of the transmembrane region was constructed by considering the evolutionary conservation pattern of each helix. The model is validated by much of the biochemical data on EmrE with most of the positions that were identified as affecting substrate translocation being located around the substrate-binding cavity. A suggested mechanism for proton-coupled substrate translocation in small multidrug resistance antiporters provides a mechanistic rationale to the experimentally observed inverted topology.     

The Influenza Hemagglutinin Fusion Domain Is an Amphipathic Helical Hairpin That Functions by Inducing Membrane Curvature

The highly conserved N-terminal 23 residues of the hemagglutinin glycoprotein, known as the fusion peptide domain (HAfp23), is vital to the membrane fusion and infection mechanism of the influenza virus. HAfp23 has a helical hairpin structure consisting of two tightly packed amphiphilic helices that rest on the membrane surface. We demonstrate that HAfp23 is a new class of amphipathic helix that functions by leveraging the negative curvature induced by two tightly packed helices on membranes. The helical hairpin structure has an inverted wedge shape characteristic of negative curvature lipids, with a bulky hydrophobic region and a relatively small hydrophilic head region. The F3G mutation reduces this inverted wedge shape by reducing the volume of its hydrophobic base. We show that despite maintaining identical backbone structures and dynamics as the wild type HAfp23, the F3G mutant has an attenuated fusion activity that is correlated to its reduced ability to induce negative membrane curvature. The inverted wedge shape of HAfp23 is likely to play a crucial role in the initial stages of membrane fusion by stabilizing negative curvature in the fusion stalk.     

Comparison of three structures of the multidrug transporter EmrE

The small multidrug resistance proteins constitute a family of bacterial antiporters that confer multidrug resistance by H(+)-linked drug efflux across the bacterial cytoplasmic membrane. The structure of EmrE, the family archetype, has been determined by electron crystallography and shows that EmrE in the membrane is an asymmetric homodimer composed of a tightly packed bundle of eight alpha helices, six of which form the substrate-binding site, which has a single molecule of tetraphenylphosphonium at its centre. Two X-ray structures of EmrE have been determined; the first structure was of a non-native conformation of EmrE that formed a crystallographic tetramer, whereas EmrE in the second structure was an asymmetric dimer containing a single molecule of bound tetraphenylphosphonium. This recent EmrE structure bears a superficial resemblance to the electron crystallographic structure and the differences were ascribed to conformational changes. However, the biological relevance of these conformational differences is questionable.     

The mitochondrial genomes of spontaneous orir petite mutants of yeast have rearranged repeat units organized as inverted tandem dimers

We have investigated the structure and organization of the mitochondrial genomes of two related orir (ori-rearranged) spontaneous petite mutants of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. In these mutant genomes every repeat unit contains an inverted terminal duplication harboring a second (inverted) ori sequence, and tandem pairs of repeat units alternate with tandem pairs in inverted orientation. We have shown that orir genomes are organized as the genomes with inverted repeat units of ethidium bromide (EtBr)-induced petites, and we have clarified the mechanism by which such mutant mitochondrial genomes arise.     

Organic solvent extracted EmrE solubilized in dodecyl maltoside is monomeric and binds drug ligand

Ethidium multidrug resistance protein (EmrE) is a member of the small multidrug resistance family of proteins and is responsible for resistance to a diverse group of lipophilic cations. To examine the multimeric state(s), size-exclusion HPLC and sedimentation velocity experiments were performed with EmrE solubilized in N-dodecyl-beta-d-maltopyranoside (DM) detergent. EmrE was purified from Escherichia coli membranes using organic extraction with a 3:1 chloroform:methanol solvent followed by LH-20 chromatography and the recovered pure protein was re-solubilized in a buffer containing 2% DM. The purified protein was analyzed by SEC-HPLC to estimate the monodispersity and to determine the amount of bound detergent. The results show that EmrE is homogeneous in DM with a Stokes radius of 3.6nm compatible with that of a monomer. Sedimentation velocity experiments indicated that the EmrE preparation was monodisperse and supports the fact that the organic extracted protein solubilized in DM is monomeric. This monomeric form of the protein analyzed here is also shown to bind substrate in the micromolar range.     

Investigation of ligand binding to the multidrug resistance protein EmrE by isothermal titration calorimetry

Escherichia coli multidrug resistance protein E (EmrE) is an integral membrane protein spanning the inner membrane of Escherichia coli that is responsible for this organism's resistance to a variety of lipophilic cations such as quaternary ammonium compounds (QACs) and interchelating dyes. EmrE is a 12-kDa protein of four transmembrane helices considered to be functional as a multimer. It is an efflux transporter that can bind and transport cytoplasmic QACs into the periplasm using the energy of the proton gradient across the inner membrane. Isothermal titration calorimetry provides information about the stoichiometry and thermodynamic properties of protein-ligand interactions, and can be used to monitor the binding of QACs to EmrE in different membrane mimetic environments. In this study the ligand binding to EmrE solubilized in dodecyl maltoside, sodium dodecyl sulfate and reconstituted into small unilamellar vesicles is examined by isothermal titration calorimetry. The binding stoichiometry of EmrE to drug was found to be 1:1, demonstrating that oligomerization of EmrE is not necessary for binding to drug. The binding of EmrE to drug was observed with the dissociation constant (K(D)) in the micromolar range for each of the drugs in any of the membrane mimetic environments. Thermodynamic properties demonstrated this interaction to be enthalpy-driven with similar enthalpies of 8-12 kcal/mol for each of the drugs in any of the membrane mimetics.     

When biochemistry meets structural biology: the cautionary tale of EmrE

When biochemistry meets structural biology a more complete understanding of the mechanism of biological macromolecules is usually achieved. Several high-resolution structures of ion-coupled transporters have enriched the understanding of mechanisms of substrate recognition, translocation and coupling of substrate fluxes. However, two X-ray structures of EmrE, the smallest ion-coupled multi-drug transporter, raised questions over the veracity of the structural model and represented a cautionary tale about the difficulty of determining the 3D structures of membrane proteins and the dangers of ignoring biochemical results. The 3D structures of EmrE have since been retracted because of faulty software, but the suggestion that the protomers in the dimer are in an antiparallel topological orientation sparked controversy that is still ongoing.     

Blocking Dynamics of the SMR Transporter EmrE Impairs Efflux Activity

EmrE is a small multidrug resistance transporter that has been well studied as a model for secondary active transport. Because transport requires the protein to convert between at least two states open to opposite sides of the membrane, it is expected that blocking these conformational transitions will prevent transport activity. We have previously shown that NMR can quantitatively measure the transition between the open-in and open-out states of EmrE in bicelles. Now, we have used the antiparallel EmrE crystal structure to design a cross-link to inhibit this conformational exchange process. We probed the structural, dynamic, and functional effects of this cross-link with NMR and in vivo efflux assays. Our NMR results show that our antiparallel cross-link performs as predicted: dramatically reducing conformational exchange while minimally perturbing the overall structure of EmrE and essentially trapping EmrE in a single state. The same cross-link also impairs ethidium efflux activity by EmrE in Escherichia coli. This confirms the hypothesis that transport can be inhibited simply by blocking conformational transitions in a properly folded transporter. The success of our cross-linker design also provides further evidence that the antiparallel crystal structure provides a good model for functional EmrE.     

Blocking Dynamics of the SMR Transporter EmrE Impairs Efflux Activity

EmrE is a small multidrug resistance transporter that has been well studied as a model for secondary active transport. Because transport requires the protein to convert between at least two states open to opposite sides of the membrane, it is expected that blocking these conformational transitions will prevent transport activity. We have previously shown that NMR can quantitatively measure the transition between the open-in and open-out states of EmrE in bicelles. Now, we have used the antiparallel EmrE crystal structure to design a cross-link to inhibit this conformational exchange process. We probed the structural, dynamic, and functional effects of this cross-link with NMR and in vivo efflux assays. Our NMR results show that our antiparallel cross-link performs as predicted: dramatically reducing conformational exchange while minimally perturbing the overall structure of EmrE and essentially trapping EmrE in a single state. The same cross-link also impairs ethidium efflux activity by EmrE in Escherichia coli. This confirms the hypothesis that transport can be inhibited simply by blocking conformational transitions in a properly folded transporter. The success of our cross-linker design also provides further evidence that the antiparallel crystal structure provides a good model for functional EmrE.     

Examination of EmrE conformational differences in various membrane mimetic environments.

Ethidium multidrug resistance protein (EmrE) is a member of the small multidrug resistance family of proteins and is responsible for resistance in Escherichia coli to a diverse group of lipophilic cations. Research is beginning to elucidate structural information as well as substrate binding and extrusion mechanisms for this protein. However, the choice of membrane mimetic environment to perform structural studies needs to be made. In this study EmrE was solubilized in different membrane mimetic environments to investigate the influence of environment on the structure and dynamics of the protein by comparing the fluorescence properties of emission maxima, peak shifts, relative intensities, acrylamide quenching constants, and polarization. Taken together, the different fluorescence observations on EmrE in the various membrane mimetic systems tested suggest that the tryptophan residues in EmrE are present in the most flexible and exposed state when solubilized in methanol, followed by sodium dodecyl sulfate and urea. The two detergents N-dodecyl-beta-D-maltoside (DM) and polyoxyethylene(8)dodecyl ether, for the most part, only display subtle differences between the spectral properties with DM best representing the lipid environment. The conformation of EmrE is clearly more open and dynamic in detergent relative to being reconstituted in small unilamellar vesicles. The fluorescence observations of EmrE solubilized in trifluoroethanol shows an environment that is similar to that of EmrE solubilized in detergents. Additionally, secondary structure was monitored by circular dichroism (CD). The CD spectra were similar among the different solubilizing conditions, suggesting little difference in alpha-helical content. This work establishes groundwork for the choice of solubilizing conditions for future structural, folding, and ligand binding studies.     

Transported Substrate Determines Exchange Rate in the Multidrug Resistance Transporter EmrE

EmrE, a small multidrug resistance transporter, serves as an ideal model to study coupling between multidrug recognition and protein function. EmrE has a single small binding pocket that must accommodate the full range of diverse substrates recognized by this transporter. We have studied a series of tetrahedral compounds, as well as several planar substrates, to examine multidrug recognition and transport by EmrE. Here we show that even within this limited series, the rate of interconversion between the inward- and outward-facing states of EmrE varies over 3 orders of magnitude. Thus, the identity of the bound substrate controls the rate of this critical step in the transport process. The binding affinity also varies over a similar range and is correlated with substrate hydrophobicity within the tetrahedral substrate series. Substrate identity influences both the ground-state and transition-state energies for the conformational exchange process, highlighting the coupling between substrate binding and transport required for alternating access antiport.