Truncation of class IV chitinases from Arabidopsis by secreted fungal proteases

Plant class IV chitinases have a small amino‐terminal chitin‐binding domain and a larger chitinase domain, and are involved in plant defence against fungal infection. Our previous work on the chitinases ChitA and ChitB from the model monocotyledon Zea mays showed that the chitin‐binding domain is removed by secreted fungal proteases called fungalysins. In this article, we extend this work to dicotyledons. The effects of fungalysin‐like proteases on four class IV chitinases from the model dicotyledon Arabidopsis thaliana were analysed. Four Arabidopsis chitinases were heterologously expressed in Pichia pastoris, purified and shown to have chitinase activity against a chitohexaose (dp6) substrate. The incubation of these four chitinases with Fv‐cmp, a fungalysin protease secreted by Fusarium verticillioides, resulted in the truncation of AtchitIV3 and AtchitIV5. Moreover, incubation with secreted proteins from Alternaria brassicae, a pathogen of A. thaliana and brassica crops, also led to a similar truncation of AtchitIV3 and AtchitIV4. Our finding that class IV chitinases from both dicotyledons (A. thaliana) and monocotyledons (Z. mays) are truncated by proteases secreted by specialized pathogens of each plant suggests that this may be a general mechanism of plant–fungal pathogenicity.     

Crystallographic structure of ChitA,a glycoside hydrolase family 19, plant class IV chitinase from Zea mays

Maize ChitA chitinase is composed of a small, hevein‐like domain attached to a carboxy‐terminal chitinase domain. During fungal ear rot, the hevein‐like domain is cleaved by secreted fungal proteases to produce truncated forms of ChitA. Here, we report a structural and biochemical characterization of truncated ChitA (ChitA ΔN), which lacks the hevein‐like domain. ChitA ΔN and a mutant form (ChitA ΔN‐EQ) were expressed and purified; enzyme assays showed that ChitA ΔN activity was comparable to the full‐length enzyme. Mutation of Glu62 to Gln (ChitA ΔN‐EQ) abolished chitinase activity without disrupting substrate binding, demonstrating that Glu62 is directly involved in catalysis. A crystal structure of ChitA ΔN‐EQ provided strong support for key roles for Glu62, Arg177, and Glu165 in hydrolysis, and for Ser103 and Tyr106 in substrate binding. These findings demonstrate that the hevein‐like domain is not needed for enzyme activity. Moreover, comparison of the crystal structure of this plant class IV chitinase with structures from larger class I and II enzymes suggest that class IV chitinases have evolved to accommodate shorter substrates.     

Modification of recombinant maize ChitA chitinase by fungal chitinase-modifying proteins

In commercial maize, there are at least two different alleles of the chiA gene that encode alloforms of ChitA chitinase, a protein that is abundant in developing seed. Both known alloforms are modified by Bz-cmp, a chitinase-modifying protein (cmp) secreted by the fungal pathogen Bipolaris zeicola. One alloform (ChitA-B73) is also modified by Stm-cmp, a protein secreted by the fungal pathogen Stenocarpella maydis, whereas the other (ChitA-LH82) is resistant. The two ChitA alloforms possess six differences or polymorphisms (P1-P6). To determine whether the P2 polymorphism in the chitin-binding domain is responsible for resistance or susceptibility to modification by Stm-cmp, and to determine whether Stm-cmp and Bz-cmp are proteases, heterologous expression strains of the yeast Pichia pastoris that produce recombinant maize ChitA (rChitA) alloforms and mutant rChitAs were created. rChitA alloforms and mutant rChitAs were purified from yeast cultures and used as substrates in assays with Stm-cmp and Bz-cmp. As with native protein, Bz-cmp modified both rChitA-LH82 and rChitA-B73, whereas Stm-cmp modified rChitA-B73 only. Mutant rChitAs, in which the P2 amino acids were changed to those of the other alloform, resulted in a significant exchange in Stm-cmp susceptibility. Amino-terminal sequencing of unmodified and modified rChitA-B73 demonstrated that Stm-cmp cleaves the peptide bond on the amino-terminal side of the P2 alanine, whereas Bz-cmp cleaves in the poly-glycine hinge region, the site of P3. The results demonstrate that Stm-cmp and Bz-cmp are proteases that truncate ChitA chitinase at the amino terminus, but at different sites. Both sites correspond to polymorphisms in the two alloforms, suggesting that the sequence diversity at P2 and P3 is the result of selective pressure to prevent truncation by fungal proteases.     

Recognition of corn defense chitinases by fungal polyglycine hydrolases

Polyglycine hydrolases (PGH)s are secreted fungal endoproteases that cleave peptide bonds in the polyglycine interdomain linker of ChitA chitinase, an antifungal protein from domesticated corn (Zea mays ssp. mays). These target‐specific endoproteases are unusual because they do not cut a specific peptide bond but select one of many Gly‐Gly bonds within the polyglycine region. Some Gly‐Gly bonds are cleaved frequently while others are never cleaved. Moreover, we have previously shown that PGHs from different fungal pathogens prefer to cleave different Gly‐Gly peptide bonds. It is not understood how PGHs selectively cleave the ChitA linker, especially because its polyglycine structure lacks peptide sidechains. To gain insights into this process we synthesized several peptide analogs of ChitA to evaluate them as potential substrates and inhibitors of Es‐cmp, a PGH from the plant pathogenic fungus Epicoccum sorghi. Our results showed that part of the PGH recognition site for substrate chitinases is adjacent to the polyglycine linker on the carboxy side. More specifically, four amino acid residues were implicated, each spaced four residues apart on an alpha helix. Moreover, analogous peptides with selective Gly‐>sarcosine (N‐methylglycine) mutations or a specific Ser‐>Thr mutation retained inhibitor activity but were no longer cleaved by PGH. Additonally, our findings suggest that peptide analogs of ChitA that inhibit PGH activity could be used to strengthen plant defenses.     

Polyglycine hydrolases: Fungal β‐lactamase‐like endoproteases that cleave polyglycine regions within plant class IV chitinases

Polyglycine hydrolases are secreted fungal proteases that cleave glycine–glycine peptide bonds in the inter‐domain linker region of specific plant defense chitinases. Previously, we reported the catalytic activity of polyglycine hydrolases from the phytopathogens Epicoccum sorghi (Es‐cmp) and Cochliobolus carbonum (Bz‐cmp). Here we report the identity of their encoding genes and the primary amino acid sequences of the proteins responsible for these activities. Peptides from a tryptic digest of Es‐cmp were analyzed by LC‐MS/MS and the spectra obtained were matched to a draft genome sequence of E. sorghi. From this analysis, a 642 amino acid protein containing a predicted β‐lactamase catalytic region of 280 amino acids was identified. Heterologous strains of the yeast Pichia pastoris were created to express this protein and its homolog from C. carbonum from their cDNAs. Both strains produced recombinant proteins with polyglycine hydrolase activity as shown by SDS‐PAGE and MALDI‐MS based assays. Site directed mutagenesis was used to mutate the predicted catalytic serine of Es‐cmp to glycine, resulting in loss of catalytic activity. BLAST searching of publicly available fungal genomes identified full‐length homologous proteins in 11 other fungi of the class Dothideomycetes, and in three fungi of the related class Sordariomycetes while significant BLAST hits extended into the phylum Basidiomycota. Multiple sequence alignment led to the identification of a network of seven conserved tryptophans that surround the β‐lactamase‐like region. This is the first report of a predicted β‐lactamase that is an endoprotease.     

Cleavage of the Carboxyl-Terminus of LEACS2, a Tomato 1-Aminocycl opropane-1-Carboxylic Acid Synthase Isomer, by a 64-kDa Tomato Metalloprotease Produces a Truncated but Active Enzyme

l-Aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC) synthase (ACS) is the principal enzyme in phytohormone ethylene biosynthesis. Previous studies have shown that the hypervariable C-terminus of ACS is proteolytically processed in vivo. However, the protease responsible for this has not yet been identified. In the present study, we investigated the processing of the 55-kDa full-length tomato ACS (LeACS2) into 52-, 50- and 49-kDa truncated isoforms in ripening tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill. cv.Cooperation 903) fruit using the sodium dodecyl sulfate-boiling method. Meanwhile, an LeACS2-processing protease was purified via multi-step column chromatography from tomato fruit. Subsequent biochemical analysis of the 64-kDa purified protease revealed that it is a metalloprotease active at multiple cleavage sites within the hypervariable C-terminus of LeACS2. N-terminal sequencing and matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight analysis indicated that the LeACS2-processing metalloprotease cleaves at the C-terminal sites Lys438, Glu447, Lys448, Asn456, Ser460, Ser462, Lys463, and Leu474, but does not cleave the Nterminus of LeACS2. Four C-terminus-deleted (26-50 amino acids) LeACS2 fusion proteins were overproduced and subjected to proteolysis by this metalloprotease to identify the multiple cleavage sites located on the N-terminal side of the phosphorylation site Ser460. The results indisputably confirmed the presence of cleavage sites within the region between the α-helix domain (H14) and Ser460 for this metalloprotease.Furhermore, the resulting C-terminally truncated LeACS2 isoforms were active enzymatically. Because this protease could produce LeACS2 isoforms in vitro similar to those detected in vivo, it is proposed that this metalloprotease may be involved in the proteolysis of LeACS2 in vivo.     

<Emphasis Type="Italic">Aeromonas caviae</Emphasis> CB101 Contains Four Chitinases Encoded by a Single Gene <Emphasis Type="Italic">chi1</Emphasis>

Aeromonas caviae CB101 secretes four chitinases (around 92, 82, 70, and 55 kDa) into the culture supernatant. A chitinase gene chi1 (92 kDa) was previously studied. To identify the genes encoding the remaining three chitinases, a cosmid library of CB101 was constructed to screen for putative chitinase genes. Nine cosmid clones were shown to contain a chitinase gene on chitin plates. Surprisingly, all the positive clones contained chi1. In parallel, we purified the 55-kDa chitinase (Chi55) from the CB101 culture supernatant by continuous DEAE-Sepharose and Mono-Q anion exchange chromatography. The N-terminal amino acid sequence of the purified chitinase exactly matched the N-terminal sequence of mature Chi1, indicating that the purified chitinase (Chi55) is a truncated form of Chi1. The N- and C-terminal domains of chi1 were cloned, expressed, and purified, separately. Western blots using anti-sera to the N- and C-terminal domains of chi1 on the chitinases of CB101 showed that the four chitinases in the culture supernatant are either chi1 or C-terminal truncations of Chi1. In addition, the CB101 chi1 null mutant showed no chitinolytic activity, while CB101 chi1 null mutant complemented by pUC19chi1 containing chi1 showed all four chitinases in gel activity assay. These data indicated that all four chitinases secreted by CB101 in the culture supernatant are the product of one chitinase gene chi1.     

Purification and characterization of a new fungalysin-like metallopeptidase from the culture filtrate of a plant worm,Nomuraea atypicola

A new protease was purified from the culture filtrate of a plant worm, Nomuraea atypicola. The activity of the protease was suppressed by metalloprotease inhibitors such as EDTA and 1,10-phenanthroline, suggesting that it might be a metalloprotease. Its molecular mass was estimated to be 48 kDa by SDS-PAGE, and its optimal pH and temperature were pH 8.5–9.0 and 40 °C, respectively. The N-terminal amino acid sequence of the metalloprotease was similar to those of fungalysin metallopeptidases of the M36 family from fungi such as Coccidioides posadasii, Pyrenophora tritici-repentis, and Arthroderma gypseum, supporting the idea that it is a fungalysin-like metallopeptidase.     

Caulobacter crescentus synthesizes an S-layer-editing metalloprotease possessing a domain sharing sequence similarity with its paracrystalline S-layer protein

Strains of Caulobacter crescentus elaborate an S-layer, a two-dimensional protein latticework which covers the cell surface. The S-layer protein (RsaA) is secreted by a type I mechanism (relying on a C-terminal signal) and is unusual among type I secreted proteins because high levels of protein are produced continuously. In efforts to adapt the S-layer for display of foreign peptides and proteins, we noted a proteolytic activity that affected S-layer monomers with foreign inserts. The cleavage was precise, resulting in fragments with an unambiguous N-terminal sequence. We developed an assay to screen for loss of this activity (i.e., presentation of foreign peptides without degradation), using transposon and traditional mutagenesis. A metalloprotease gene designated sap (S-layer-associated protease) was identified which could complement the protease-negative mutants. The N-terminal half of Sap possessed significant similarity to other type I secreted proteases (e.g., alkaline protease of Pseudomonas aeruginosa), including the characteristic RTX repeat sequences, but the C-terminal half which normally includes the type I secretion signal exhibited no such similarity. Instead, there was a region of significant similarity to the N-terminal region of RsaA. We hypothesize that Sap evolved by combining the catalytic portion of a type I secreted protease with an S-layer-like protein, perhaps to associate with nascent S-layer monomers to "scan" for modifications.     

豇豆几丁质酶N端序列测定及与其它植物的比较

通过自动 Edman降解程序 ,测定了经诱导、纯化的豇豆几丁质酶 N端 1 0个氨基酸的序列 ,并将该序列与其它植物几丁质酶 N端相应部分的氨基酸序列进行了比较分析。结果表明 ,该豇豆 ( Vigna sesquipedalis)几丁质酶 N端 1 0个氨基酸的序列为 EQCGSQAGGA,与 类几丁质酶同一部分同感序列同源性高达 1 0 0 % ;而与 、 及 类几丁质酶的相应序列均无同源性。结合考虑此酶的等电点 ( 8.3)及分子量 ( 33k D) ,可推测该豇豆几丁质酶属于 类几丁质酶。其 N端序列的高度保守性提示 ,该段序列可作为 类几丁质酶的一段主要特征序列 ,并可据其合成核酸探针 ,以分离、克隆其它 类几丁质酶编码基因。     

Only Specific Tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum) Chitinases and [beta]-1,3-Glucanases Exhibit Antifungal Activity

Different isoforms of chitinases and [beta]-1,3-glucanases of tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum cv Samsun NN) were tested for their antifungal activities. The class I, vacuolar chitinase and [beta]-1,3-glucanase isoforms were the most active against Fusarium solani germlings, resulting in lysis of the hyphal tips and in growth inhibition. In additon, we observed that the class I chitinase and [beta]-1,3-glucanase acted synergistically. The class II isoforms of the two hydrolases exhibited no antifungal activity. However, the class II chitinases showed limited growth inhibitory activity in combination with higher amounts of class I [beta]-1,3-glucanase. The class II [beta]-1,3-glucanases showed no inhibitory activity in any combination. In transgenic tobacco plants producing modified forms of either a class I chitinase or a class I [beta]-1,3-glucanase, or both, these proteins were targeted extracellularly. Both modified proteins lack their C-terminal propeptide, which functions as a vacuolar targeting signal. Extracellular targeting had no effect on the specific activities of the chitinase and [beta]-1,3-glucanase enzymes. Furthermore, the extracellular washing fluid (EF) from leaves of transgenic plants expressing either of the secreted class I enzymes exhibited antifungal activity on F. solani germlings in vitro comparable to that of the purified vacuolar class I proteins. Mixing EF fractions from these plants revealed synergism in inhibitory activity against F. solani; the mixed fractions exhibited inhibitory activity similar to that of EF from plants expressing both secreted enzymes.     

Incomplete process of recombinant human platelet-derived growth factor produced in yeast and its effect on the biological activity.

Partially purified recombinant human Platelet-derived Growth Factor BB homodimer isolated from yeast culture media contains variable amounts of unprocessed PDGF-BB. This unprocessed PDGF-BB is found as a result of incomplete cleavage of the precursor to form the mature protein. Although the signal peptide is efficiently removed, a fraction of the PDGF secreted has an extended sequence corresponding to the truncated yeast alpha-factor leader. The data suggest that it is the amino acid chain from the truncated a-factor leader and not the sugar moiety attached to it that is responsible for the higher mitogenic activity found in this unprocessed molecule compared to highly purified PDGF-BB.     

Protease secretion by Erwinia chrysanthemi. Proteases B and C are synthesized and secreted as zymogens without a signal peptide

The gene encoding the secreted 53-kDa metalloprotease (protease B) and the 5' end of the gene encoding the secreted 55-kDa metalloprotease (protease C) of the Gram-negative bacterium Erwinia chrysanthemi have been sequenced. The predicted sequences of the two proteases do not have typical signal sequences at their NH2 termini. Both proteases are synthesized as inactive higher molecular weight precursors (zymogens proB and proC) which are secreted into the external medium where divalent cation-mediated activation occurs. The activation of proB occurs with a t1/2 of less than 5 min at 37 degrees C in Luria broth medium, whereas that of proC occurs with a t1/2 of about 150 min. The NH2 termini of purified proteases B, proB, and C were sequenced. ProB starts at the initiator methionine whereas B and C start, respectively, at residues +16 and +18 of the sequence deduced from the nucleotide sequence. A short NH2-terminal extension is therefore removed during the activation process, most likely by an autocatalytic mechanism. Protease B shows a high degree of sequence homology with the secreted 50-kDa metalloprotease of Serratia marcescens, which also lacks a signal peptide and for which an inactive higher molecular weight form has been reported.     

Purification and characterization of a serine protease and chitinases from Paecilomyces lilacinus and detection of chitinase activity on 2D gels

The filamentous fungus Paecilomyces lilacinus is currently developed as a biocontrol agent against plant parasitic nematodes. Nematode eggs and cuticles are the infection sites for biocontrol agents that penetrate by the production of lytic enzymes. P. lilacinus was cultured in liquid media and proteases and chitinases were induced by the introduction of egg yolk and chitin, respectively. A serine protease was purified from a culture medium using Sepharose-bacitracin affinity column. The protease occurred in three forms, two of which were C-terminally truncated. Chitinase activity was also observed in the culture supernatant, and after separation by isoelectric focusing six proteins were detected that showed activity. Chitinase activity was further confirmed on non-denaturing one-dimensional (1D) and two-dimensional (2D) gels using a sandwich assay with glycol chitin as a substrate. Two of the proteins had similarities with endochitinases as shown by their N-terminal amino acid sequences.     

Isolation and characterization of a novel extracellular metalloprotease from Bacillus subtilis.

We have isolated and characterized two minor extracellular proteases from culture supernatants of a strain of Bacillus subtilis containing deletion mutations of the genes for the extracellular proteases subtilisin (apr) and neutral protease (npr) and a minor extracellular protease (epr) as well as intracellular serine protease-I (isp-1). Characterization studies have revealed that one of these enzymes is the previously described protease bacillopeptidase F. The second enzyme, the subject of this report, is a novel metalloprotease, which we designate Mpr. Mpr is a unique metalloprotease that has been purified to apparent homogeneity by using both conventional and high-performance liquid chromatography procedures. Mpr has a molecular mass of approximately 28 kilodaltons on sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and a basic isoelectric point of 8.7. The enzyme showed maximal activity against azocoll at pH 7.5 and 50 degrees C. Mpr was inhibited by dithiothreitol and a combination of beta-mercaptoethanol and EDTA. Activity was moderately inhibited by beta-mercaptoethanol and EDTA alone as well as by cysteine and citrate and only marginally by phosphoramidon 1,10-phenanthroline and N-[N-(L-3-trans-carboxyoxiran-2-carbonyl)-L-leucyl]-agmatine. Mpr was not inhibited by phenylmethylsulfonyl fluoride. In addition, Mpr showed esterolytic but not collagenolytic activities. Our studies suggest that Mpr is a secreted metalloprotease containing cysteine residues that are required for maximal activity.     

ADAMTS1 cleaves aggrecan at multiple sites and is differentially inhibited by metalloproteinase inhibitors

ADAMTS1 is a secreted protein that belongs to the recently described ADAMTS (a disintegrin and metalloprotease with thrombospondin repeats) family of proteases. Evaluation of ADAMTS1 catalytic activity on a panel of extracellular matrix proteins showed a restrictive substrate specificity which includes some proteoglycans. Our results demonstrated that human ADAMTS1 cleaves aggrecan at a previously shown site by its mouse homolog, but we have also identified additional cleavage sites that ultimately confirm the classification of this protease as an 'aggrecanase'. Specificity of ADAMTS1 activity was further verified when a point mutation in the zinc-binding domain abolished its catalytic effects, and latency conferred by the prodomain was also demonstrated using a furin cleavage site mutant. Suppression of ADAMTS1 activity was accomplished with a specific monoclonal antibody and some metalloprotease inhibitors, including tissue inhibitor of metalloproteinases 2 and 3. Finally, we developed an activity assay using an artificial peptide substrate based on the interglobular domain cleavage site (E(373)-A) of rat aggrecan.     

Apoplastic extracts from a transgenic wheat line exhibiting lesion-mimic phenotype have multiple pathogenesis-related proteins that are antifungal

A transgenic wheat line constitutively expressing genes encoding a class IV acidic chitinase and an acidic beta-1,3-glucanase, showed significant delay in spread of Fusarium head blight (scab) disease under greenhouse conditions. In an earlier work, we observed a lesion-mimic phenotype in this transgenic line when homozygous for transgene loci. Apoplastic fluid (AF) extracted from the lesion-mimic plants had pathogenesis-related (PR) proteins belonging to families of beta-1,3-glucanases, chitinases, and thaumatin-like proteins (TLPs). AF had growth inhibitory activity against certain fungal pathogens, including Fusarium graminearum and Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici. Through a two-step ion-exchange chromatography protocol, we recovered many PR proteins and a few uncharacterized proteins. Three individual protein bands corresponding to a TLP (molecular mass, 16 kDa) and two beta-1,3-glucanases (molecular mass, 32 kDa each) were purified and identified by tandem mass spectrometry. We measured the in vitro antifungal activity of the three purified enzymes and a barley class II chitinase (purified earlier in our laboratory) in microtiter plate assays with macroconidia or conidiophores of F. graminearum and Pyrenophora tritici-repentis. Mixtures of proteins revealed synergistic or additive inhibitory activity against F. graminearum and P. tritici-repentis hyphae. The concentrations of PR proteins at which these effects were observed are likely to be those reached in AF of cells exhibiting a hypersensitive response. Our results suggest that apoplastic PR proteins are antifungal and their antimicrobial potency is dependent on concentrations and combinations that are effectively reached in plants following microbial attack.     

Properties of Manduca sexta chitinase and its C-terminal deletions

Manduca sexta (tobacco hornworm) chitinase is a molting enzyme that contains several domains including a catalytic domain, a serine/threonine-rich region, and a C-terminal cysteine-rich domain. Previously we showed that this chitinase acts as a biopesticide in transgenic plants where it disrupts gut physiology. To delineate the role of these domains further and to identify and characterize some of the multiple forms produced in molting fluid and in transgenic plants, three different forms with variable lengths of C-terminal deletions were generated. Appropriately truncated forms of the M. sexta chitinase cDNA were generated, introduced into a baculovirus vector, and expressed in insect cells. Two of the truncated chitinases (Chi 1-407 and Chi 1-477) were secreted into the medium, whereas the one with the longest deletion (Chi 1-376) was retained inside the insect cells. The two larger truncated chitinases and the full-length enzyme (Chi 1-535) were purified and their properties were compared. Differences in carbohydrate compositions, pH–activity profiles, and kinetic constants were observed among the different forms of chitinases. All three of these chitinases had some affinity for chitin, and they also exhibited differences in their ability to hydrolyze colloidal chitin. The results support the hypothesis that multiple forms of this enzyme occur in vivo due to proteolytic processing at the C-terminal end and differential glycosylation.     

Characterzation of chitinases able to rescue somatic embryos of the temperature-sensitive carrot variantts11

To characterize the acidic endochitinase EP3, able to rescue somatic embryos of the carrot cell linets11, the enzyme was purified from the medium of wild-type suspension cultures. Peptide sequences, deduced amino acid sequences of corresponding PCR-generated cDNA clones, serological relation and biochemical properties showed that there were at least five closely related chitinases, four of which could be identified as class IV EP3 chitinases with an apparent size of 30 kDa. Two other proteins were identified as a serologically related class I acidic chitinase (DcChitI) of 34 kDa, and a serologically unrelated 29 kDa class II acidic chitinase (DcChitII), respectively. Additional cDNA sequences, Western and Southern analysis showed the presence of a least two, but possibly more, highly homologous class IV EP3 genes in the carrot genome. Two class IV EP3 chitinases were tested and found to be able to increase the number ofts11 globular embryos formed under non-permissive conditions. One of the class IV EP3 chitinases as well as the class I chitinase DcChitI promoted the transition from globular to heart-stagets11 embryos. The class II endochitinase and a heterologous class IV chitinase from sugar-beet were not active onts11. This suggests that there are differences in the specificity of chitinases in terms of their effect on plant somatic embryos.