The Arabidopsis CLV3-like (CLE) genes are expressed in diverse tissues and encode secreted proteins

Members of the receptor-like kinase gene family play crucial regulatory roles in many aspects of plant development, but the ligands to which they bind are largely unknown. In Arabidopsis, the receptor kinase CLAVATA1 (CLV1) binds to the small secreted polypeptide CLV3, and three proteins act as key elements of a signal transduction pathway that regulates shoot apical meristem maintenance. To better understand the signal transduction mechanisms involving small polypeptides, we are studying 25 Arabidopsis CLV3/ESR (CLE) proteins that share a conserved C-terminal domain with CLV3 and three maize ESR proteins. Members of the CLE gene family were identified in database searches and only a few are known to be expressed. We have identified an additional member of the CLE gene family in Arabidopsis, which is more similar in gene structure to CLV3 than the other CLE genes. Phylogenetic analysis reveals that few of the putative CLE gene products are closely related, suggesting there may be little functional overlap between them. We show that 24 of the 25 Arabidopsis CLE genes are transcribed in one or more tissues during development, indicating that they do encode functional products. Many are widely expressed, but others are restricted to one or a few tissue types. We have also determined the sub-cellular localization of several CLE proteins, and find that they are exported to the plasma membrane or extracellular space. Our results suggest that the Arabidopsis CLE proteins, like CLV3, may function as secreted signaling molecules that act in diverse pathways during growth and development.     

Enhanced resistance to soybean cyst nematode Heterodera glycines in transgenic soybean by silencing putative CLE receptors

CLE peptides are small extracellular proteins important in regulating plant meristematic activity through the CLE‐receptor kinase‐WOX signalling module. Stem cell pools in the SAM (shoot apical meristem), RAM (root apical meristem) and vascular cambium are controlled by CLE signalling pathways. Interestingly, plant‐parasitic cyst nematodes secrete CLE‐like effector proteins, which act as ligand mimics of plant CLE peptides and are required for successful parasitism. Recently, we demonstrated that Arabidopsis CLE receptors CLAVATA1 (CLV1), the CLAVATA2 (CLV2)/CORYNE (CRN) heterodimer receptor complex and RECEPTOR‐LIKE PROTEIN KINASE 2 (RPK2), which transmit the CLV3 signal in the SAM, are required for perception of beet cyst nematode Heterodera schachtii CLEs. Reduction in nematode infection was observed in clv1, clv2, crn, rpk2 and combined double and triple mutants. In an effort to develop nematode resistance in an agriculturally important crop, orthologues of Arabidopsis receptors including CLV1, CLV2, CRN and RPK2 were identified from soybean, a host for the soybean cyst nematode Heterodera glycines. For each of the receptors, there are at least two paralogues in the soybean genome. Localization studies showed that most receptors are expressed in the root, but vary in their level of expression and spatial expression patterns. Expression in nematode‐induced feeding cells was also confirmed. In vitro direct binding of the soybean receptors with the HgCLE peptide was analysed. Knock‐down of the receptors in soybean hairy roots showed enhanced resistance to SCN. Our findings suggest that targeted disruption of nematode CLE signalling may be a potential means to engineer nematode resistance in crop plants.     

CLE14/CLE20 peptides may interact with CLAVATA2/CORYNE receptor-like kinases to irreversibly inhibit cell division in the root meristem of Arabidopsis

Towards an understanding of the interacting nature of the CLAVATA (CLV) complex, we predicted the 3D structures of CLV3/ESR-related (CLE) peptides and the ectodomain of their potential receptor proteins/kinases, and docking models of these molecules. The results show that the ectodomain of CLV1 can form homodimers and that the 12-/13-amino-acid CLV3 peptide fits into the binding clefts of the CLV1 dimers. Our results also demonstrate that the receptor domain of CORYNE (CRN), a recently identified receptor-like kinase, binds tightly to the ectodomain of CLV2, and this likely leads to an increased possibility for docking with CLV1. Furthermore, our docking models reveal that two CRN-CLV2 ectodomain heterodimers are able to form a tetramer receptor complex. Peptides of CLV3, CLE14, CLE19, and CLE20 are also able to bind a potential CLV2-CRN heterodimer or heterotetramer complex. Using a cell-division reporter line, we found that synthetic 12-amino-acid CLE14 and CLE20 peptides inhibit, irreversibly, root growth by reducing cell division rates in the root apical meristem, resulting in a short-root phenotype. Intriguingly, we observed that exogenous application of cytokinin can partially rescue the short-root phenotype induced by over-expression of either CLE14 or CLE20 in planta. However, cytokinin treatment does not rescue the short-root phenotype caused by exogenous application of the synthetic CLE14/CLE20 peptides, suggesting a requirement for a condition provided only in living plants. These results therefore imply that the CLE14/CLE20 peptides may act through the CLV2-CRN receptor kinase, and that their availabilities and/or abundances may be affected by cytokinin activity in planta.     

CLE genes may act in a variety of tissues/cells and involve other signaling cascades in addition to CLV3-WUS-like pathways

CLE, which is the term for the CLV3/ESR-related gene family, is thought to participate in CLAVATA3-WUSCHEL (CLV3-WUS) and CLV3-WUS-like signaling pathways to regulate meristem activity in plant. Although some CLE genes are expressed in meristems, many CLE genes appear to express in a variety of tissues/cells. Here we report that CLE14 and CLE20 express in various specific tissues/cells outside the shoot/root apical meristem (SAM/RAM), including in highly differentiated cells, and at different developmental stages. Overexpressing CLE14 or CLE20 also causes multiple phenotypes, which is consistent with its expression pattern in Arabidopsis. These results suggest that CLE genes may play multiple roles and involve other signaling cascades in addition to the CLV3-WUS and CLV3-WUS-like pathways.Key words: CLE, CLAVATA3-WUSCHEL, cell signaling and development, root apical meristem, arabidopsisIntercellular communication and coordination between adjacent cell populations are critical for cell-fate specification, as well as for meristem organization and maintenance. In the shoot apical meristem (SAM), local signaling, which involves the CLAVATA3-WUSCHEL (CLV3-WUS) negative feedback loop, controls stem cell homeostasis and SAM activity.¹ As well, it has been suggested that a CLV3-WUS-like negative feedback pathway operates to control root apical meristem (RAM) activity. This view is supported by the facts that a WUS-related homeobox gene, WOX5, is expressed in cells of the quiescent center (QC) in the RAM, and that loss-of-function of WOX5 in the QC leads to the differentiation of the adjacent root cap initials (RCI), whereas gain-of-function blocks the differentiation of derivatives of the RCI in the root.² Additional support for the function in the RAM of a CLV3-WUS-like pathway, comes from observations that CLE genes (collectively referred to as the CLV3/ESR-relate gene family) are not only expressed in the RAM,^3,4 but also, that overexpression of some CLE genes triggers premature termination of the RAM.⁵ In this regard it has been recently reported that CLE40, which expresses in the differentiating daughter cells of the distal root stem cells, restricts WOX5 expression and promotes differentiation of stem cells in the RAM.⁶ Taken together these data suggest a CLV3-WUS-like feedback loop acts to negatively regulate RAM activity in plants.Our previous results have shown that CLE14 and CLE20 express in specific cells of roots, and that overexpression of CLE14 or CLE20 in Arabidopsis triggers early termination of the RAM in a CLAVATA1 (CLV1)-independent, but CLAVATA2 (CLV2)-dependent manner.^7,8 We also showed that both CLE14 and CLE20 peptides inhibit, irreversibly, root growth by reducing cell division rates in the RAM.⁷ CLV2 and CRN (a receptor-like protein kinase, also known as SOL2, isolated as a suppressor of root-specific overexpression of CLE19) are required for CLE14 and CLE20 peptide functions in vitro.^9,10 Using computational modeling approaches we further demonstrated that 12-amino-acid CLE14 and CLE20 peptides may function through a potential heterodimer/heterotetramer CLV2-CRN complex.⁷CLV3 expresses exclusively in the stem cells of the SAM, and it has been consistently shown that the CLV3 peptide is required for homeostasis of the stem cells and for the maintenance of the SAM.¹ Although some CLE genes are found to express in meristems, many CLE genes appear to express in an array of tissues and cells, including highly differentiated tissues/cells.^3,4 In this report we show that CLE14 and CLE20 express in specific tissues outside the RAM and SAM of Arabidopsis, including highly differentiated cells, and at different developmental stages. Overexpressing CLE14 or CLE20 also causes multiple phenotypes, which is consistent with its expression pattern in Arabidopsis. These results suggest that CLE genes may play multiple roles in regulating the developmental fate of cells, which includes, but is not limited to, stem cells, and also may be involved in other signaling cascades in addition to the CLV3-WUS pathway.     

CLE25 peptide regulates phloem initiation in Arabidopsis through a CLERK‐CLV2 receptor complex

The phloem, located within the vascular system, is critical for delivery of nutrients and signaling molecules throughout the plant body. Although the morphological process and several factors regulating phloem differentiation have been reported, the molecular mechanism underlying its initiation remains largely unknown. Here, we report that the small peptide‐coding gene, CLAVATA 3 (CLV3)/EMBEYO SURROUNDING REGION 25 (CLE25), the expression of which begins in provascular initial cells of 64‐cell‐staged embryos, and continues in sieve element‐procambium stem cells and phloem lineage cells, during post‐embryonic root development, facilitates phloem initiation in Arabidopsis. Knockout of CLE25 led to delayed protophloem formation, and in situ expression of an antagonistic CLE25_G6T peptide compromised the fate‐determining periclinal division of the sieve element precursor cell and the continuity of the phloem in roots. In stems of CLE25_G6T plants the phloem formation was also compromised, and procambial cells were over‐accumulated. Genetic and biochemical analyses indicated that a complex, consisting of the CLE‐RESISTANT RECEPTOR KINASE (CLERK) leucine‐rich repeat (LRR) receptor kinase and the CLV2 LRR receptor‐like protein, is involved in perceiving the CLE25 peptide. Similar to CLE25, CLERK was also expressed during early embryogenesis. Taken together, our findings suggest that CLE25 regulates phloem initiation in Arabidopsis through a CLERK‐CLV2 receptor complex.     

The Cysteine Pairs in CLV2 are Not Necessary for Sensing the CLV3 Peptide in Shoot and Root Meristems

Receptor-like proteins (RLPs) are involved in both plant defense and developmental processes. Previous genetic and biochemical studies show that the leucine-rich repeat (LRR) receptor-like protein CLAVATA2 (CLV2) functions together with CLAVATA1 (CLV1) and CORYNE (CRN) in Arabidopsis to limit the stem cell number in shoot apical meristem, while in root it acts with CRN to trigger a premature differentiation of the stem cells after sensing the exogenously applied peptides of CLV3p, CLE19p or CLE40p. It has been proposed that disulfide bonds might be formed through two cysteine pairs in the extracellular LRR domains of CLV1 and CLV2 to stabilize the receptor complex. Here we tested the hypothesis by replacing these cysteines with alanines and showed that depletions of one or both of the cysteine pairs do not hamper the function of CLV2 in SAM maintenance. In vitro peptide assay also showed that removal of the cysteine pairs did not affect the perception of CLV3 peptides in roots. These observations allow us to conclude that the formation of disulfide bonds is not needed for the function of CLV2.     

The 14-amino acid CLV3, CLE19, and CLE40 peptides trigger consumption of the root meristem in Arabidopsis through a CLAVATA2-dependent pathway

CLAVATA3 (CLV3), CLV3/ESR19 (CLE19), and CLE40 belong to a family of 26 genes in Arabidopsis thaliana that encode putative peptide ligands with unknown identity. It has been shown previously that ectopic expression of any of these three genes leads to a consumption of the root meristem. Here, we show that in vitro application of synthetic 14-amino acid peptides, CLV3p, CLE19p, and CLE40p, corresponding to the conserved CLE motif, mimics the overexpression phenotype. The same result was observed when CLE19 protein was applied externally. Interestingly, clv2 failed to respond to the peptide treatment, suggesting that CLV2 is involved in the CLE peptide signaling. Crossing of the CLE19 overexpression line with clv mutants confirms the involvement of CLV2. Analyses using tissue-specific marker lines revealed that the peptide treatments led to a premature differentiation of the ground tissue daughter cells and misspecification of cell identity in the pericycle and endodermis layers. We propose that these 14-amino acid peptides represent the major active domain of the corresponding CLE proteins, which interact with or saturate an unknown cell identity-maintaining CLV2 receptor complex in roots, leading to consumption of the root meristem.     

Triarabinosylation is required for nodulation‐suppressive CLE peptides to systemically inhibit nodulation in Pisum sativum

Legumes form root nodules to house beneficial nitrogen‐fixing rhizobia bacteria. However, nodulation is resource demanding; hence, legumes evolved a systemic signalling mechanism called autoregulation of nodulation (AON) to control nodule numbers. AON begins with the production of CLE peptides in the root, which are predicted to be glycosylated, transported to the shoot, and perceived. We synthesized variants of nodulation‐suppressing CLE peptides to test their activity using petiole feeding to introduce CLE peptides into the shoot. Hydroxylated, monoarabinosylated, and triarabinosylated variants of soybean GmRIC1a and GmRIC2a were chemically synthesized and fed into recipient Pisum sativum (pea) plants, which were used due to the availability of key AON pathway mutants unavailable in soybean. Triarabinosylated GmRIC1a and GmRIC2a suppressed nodulation of wild‐type pea, whereas no other peptide variant tested had this ability. Suppression also occurred in the supernodulating hydroxyproline O‐arabinosyltransferase mutant, Psnod3, but not in the supernodulating receptor mutants, Pssym29, and to some extent, Pssym28. During our study, bioinformatic resources for pea became available and our analyses identified 40 CLE peptide‐encoding genes, including orthologues of nodulation‐suppressive CLE peptides. Collectively, we demonstrated that soybean nodulation‐suppressive CLE peptides can function interspecifically in the AON pathway of pea and require arabinosylation for their activity.     

Perception of root‐active CLE peptides requires CORYNE function in the phloem vasculature

Arabidopsis root development is orchestrated by signaling pathways that consist of different CLAVATA3/EMBRYO SURROUNDING REGION (CLE) peptide ligands and their cognate CLAVATA (CLV) and BARELY ANY MERISTEM (BAM) receptors. How and where different CLE peptides trigger specific morphological or physiological changes in the root is poorly understood. Here, we report that the receptor‐like protein CLAVATA 2 (CLV2) and the pseudokinase CORYNE (CRN) are necessary to fully sense root‐active CLE peptides. We uncover BAM3 as the CLE45 receptor in the root and biochemically map its peptide binding surface. In contrast to other plant peptide receptors, we found no evidence that SOMATIC EMBRYOGENESIS RECEPTOR KINASE (SERK) proteins act as co‐receptor kinases in CLE45 perception. CRN stabilizes BAM3 expression and thus is required for BAM3‐mediated CLE45 signaling. Moreover, protophloem‐specific CRN expression complements resistance of the crn mutant to root‐active CLE peptides, suggesting that protophloem is their principal site of action. Our work defines a genetic framework for dissecting CLE peptide signaling and CLV/BAM receptor activation in the root.     

Identification and comprehensive analysis of the CLV3/ESR‐related (CLE) gene family in Brassica napus L.

• The CLE (CLAVATA3/ESR) gene family, encoding a group of small secretory peptides, plays important roles in cell‐to‐cell communication, thereby controlling a broad spectrum of development processes. The CLE family has been systematically characterized in some plants, but not in Brassica napus.
• In the present study, 116 BnCLE genes were identified in the B. napus genome, including seven unannotated, six incorrectly predicted and five multi‐CLE domain‐encoding genes. These BnCLE members were separated into seven distinct groups based on phylogenetic analysis, which might facilitate the functional characterization of the peptides.
• Further characterization of CLE pre‐propeptides revealed 31 unique CLE peptides from 45 BnCLE genes, which may give rise to distinct roles of BnCLE and expansion of the gene family. The biological activity of these unique CLE dodecamer peptides was tested further through in vitro peptide assays. Variations in several important residues were identified as key contributors to the functional differentiation of BnCLE and expansion of the gene family in B. napus. Expression profile analysis helped to characterize possible functional redundancy and sub‐functionalization among the BnCLE members.
• This study presents a comprehensive overview of the CLE gene family in B. napus and provides a foundation for future evolutionary and functional studies.

     

The receptor-like kinase SOL2 mediates CLE signaling in Arabidopsis

Arabidopsis sol2 mutants showed CLV3 peptide resistance. Twenty-six synthetic CLE peptides were examined in the clv1, clv2 and sol2 mutants. sol2 showed different levels of resistance to the various peptides, and the spectrum of peptide resistance was quite similar to that of clv2. SOL2 encoded a receptor-like kinase protein which is identical to CORYNE (CRN). GeneChip analysis revealed that the expression of several genes was altered in the sol2 root tip. Here, we suggest that SOL2, together with CLV2, plays an important role in the regulation of root meristem development through the CLE signaling pathway.     

Antagonistic Peptide Technology for Functional Dissection of CLV3/ESR Genes in Arabidopsis

In recent years, peptide hormones have been recognized as important signal molecules in plants. Genetic characterization of such peptides is challenging since they are usually encoded by small genes. As a proof of concept, we used the well-characterized stem cell-restricting CLAVATA3 (CLV3) to develop an antagonistic peptide technology by transformations of wild-type Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) with constructs carrying the full-length CLV3 with every residue in the peptide-coding region replaced, one at a time, by alanine. Analyses of transgenic plants allowed us to identify one line exhibiting a dominant-negative clv3-like phenotype, with enlarged shoot apical meristems and increased numbers of floral organs. We then performed second dimensional amino acid substitutions to replace the glycine residue individually with the other 18 possible proteinaceous amino acids. Examination of transgenic plants showed that a glycine-to-threonine substitution gave the strongest antagonistic effect in the wild type, in which over 70% of transgenic lines showed the clv3-like phenotype. Among these substitutions, a negative correlation was observed between the antagonistic effects in the wild type and the complementation efficiencies in clv3. We also demonstrated that such an antagonistic peptide technology is applicable to other CLV3/EMBRYO SURROUNDING REGION (CLE) genes, CLE8 and CLE22, as well as in vitro treatments. We believe this technology provides a powerful tool for functional dissection of widely occurring CLE genes in plants.In animals, small peptides are important signal molecules in neural and endocrinal systems (Feld and Hirschberg, 1996; Edlund and Jessell, 1999). In recent years, over a dozen different types of peptide hormones have been identified in plants, regulating both developmental and adaptive responses, usually through interacting with Leu-rich repeat receptor kinases localized in plasma membranes of neighboring cells (Boller and Felix, 2009; De Smet et al., 2009; Katsir et al., 2011). These peptides are often produced from genes with small open reading frames, after posttranslational processing (Matsubayashi, 2011). In addition, peptide hormones, such as CLAVATA3/EMBRYO SURROUNDING REGION (CLV3/ESR [CLE]), systemin, PHYTOSULFOKINE, AtPEP1, and EPIDERMAL PATTERNING FACTOR1 (EPF1), often have paralogs in genomes (Cock and McCormick, 2001; Yang et al., 2001; Pearce and Ryan, 2003; Huffaker et al., 2007; Hara et al., 2007). Bioinformatics analyses revealed that the Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) genome contains 33,809 small open reading frames (Lease and Walker, 2006).CLV3 acts as a secreted 12- or 13-amino acid glycosylated peptide (Kondo et al., 2006; Ohyama et al., 2009) to restrict the number of stem cells in shoot apical meristems (SAMs), through a CLV1-CLV2-SOL2 (for SUPPRESSOR OF LLP1 2, also called CORYNE)-RECEPTOR-LIKE PROTEIN KINASE2 (RPK2) receptor kinase-mediated pathway (Clark et al., 1993; Jeong et al., 1999; Miwa et al., 2008; Müller et al., 2008; Kinoshita et al., 2010; Zhu et al., 2010). All CLE family members, of which there are 83 in Arabidopsis and 89 in rice (Oryza sativa), carry a putative signal peptide and share a conserved 12-amino acid core CLE motif (Oelkers et al., 2008). Overexpression of CLE genes often shows a common dwarf and short-root phenotype (Strabala et al., 2006; Jun et al., 2010), which may not reflect their endogenous functions. Due to redundancies and difficulties in identifying mutants of these small genes, studies of CLE members are challenging. Only a few CLE genes have been genetically characterized, in particular, CLV3, CLE8, CLE40, and CLE41 in Arabidopsis and FLORAL ORGAN NUMBER4 (FON4), FON2-LIKE CLE PROTEIN1 (FCP1), and FON2 SPARE1 in rice (Fletcher et al., 1999; Hobe et al., 2003; Chu et al., 2006; Suzaki et al., 2008, 2009; Etchells and Turner, 2010; Fiume and Fletcher, 2012), while functions of other CLE members remain unknown.As a proof of concept, we used the well-characterized CLV3 gene to develop an antagonistic peptide technology for functionally dissecting CLE family members in Arabidopsis. A series of constructs carrying Ala substitutions in every amino acid residue in the core CLE motif of CLV3, expressed under the endogenous CLV3 regulatory elements, were made and introduced to wild-type Arabidopsis by transformation. This allowed us to identify the conserved Gly residue in the middle of the CLE motif was vulnerable for generating the dominant-negative clv3-like phenotype. We then performed second dimensional amino acid substitutions to replace the Gly with all other 18 possible proteinaceous amino acids, one at a time, and observed that the substitution of the Gly residue by Thr generated the strongest dominant-negative clv3-like phenotype. Further experiments showed that this technology can potentially be applied to in vitro-synthesized peptides and for functional characterization of other CLE members.     

CLAVATA2 forms a distinct CLE‐binding receptor complex regulating Arabidopsis stem cell specification

CLAVATA1 (CLV1), CLV2, CLV3, CORYNE (CRN), BAM1 and BAM2 are key regulators that function at the shoot apical meristem (SAM) of plants to promote differentiation by limiting the size of the organizing center that maintains stem cell identity in neighboring cells. Previous results have indicated that the extracellular domain of the receptor kinase CLV1 binds to the CLV3‐derived CLE ligand. The biochemical role of the receptor‐like protein CLV2 has remained largely unknown. Although genetic analysis suggested that CLV2, together with the membrane kinase CRN, acts in parallel with CLV1, recent studies using transient expression indicated that CLV2 and CRN from a complex with CLV1. Here, we report detection of distinct CLV2‐CRN heteromultimeric and CLV1‐BAM multimeric complexes in transient expression in tobacco and in Arabidopsis meristems. Weaker interactions between the two complexes were detectable in transient expression. We also find that CLV2 alone generates a membrane‐localized CLE binding activity independent of CLV1. CLV2, CLV1 and the CLV1 homologs BAM1 and BAM2 all bind to the CLV3‐derived CLE peptide with similar kinetics, but BAM receptors show a broader range of interactions with different CLE peptides. Finally, we show that BAM and CLV1 overexpression can compensate for the loss of CLV2 function in vivo. These results suggest two parallel ligand‐binding receptor complexes controlling stem cell specification in Arabidopsis.