Developmental Genetics of Fishes: Isozymic Analyses of Differential Gene Expression

SYNOPSIS. The fundamental evolutionary position of the fishesand the plasticity of their gene expression render them wellsuited for developmental genetic analyses. Isozymes, encodedin related loci, have proven to be effective probes of differentialgene expression in the fishes. The advanced bony fishes exhibita higher temporal and spatial specificity of isozyme locus expressionthan the primitive fishes. Some isozyme loci are limited intheir expression to specific developmental periods such as hatching.The more phylogenetically recently derived loci have a morerestricted tissue expression, and tend to be expressed laterin development than more ancient loci exhibiting a more generalizedtissue expression. More closely related isozyme loci tend tooverlap more in their cellular expressions than do more distantlyrelated loci. The role of gene and genome relatedness in regulatinggene expression also has been studied by the investigation ofpreferential allele expression in interspecific hybrids. Theschedules of gene expression are often perturbed in interspecificfish hybrids. A progressive increase in the severity of developmentalabnormalities, at the morphological and enzymatic levels, occursduring embryogenesis of hybrids formed from progressively moredistantly related species. In most instances of allelic repression,the paternal allele is preferentially inhibited but occasionallythe maternal allele is selectively repressed. A non-reciprocaldevelopmental success is often observed for hybrid embryos derivedfrom reciprocal crosses. These aberrant nucleocytoplasmic interactionshave been related to models of gene regulation and the evolutionarydivergence of gene regulatory mechanisms.     

Evolution of isozyme loci and their differential tissue expression

Summary The phylogeny of the creatine kinase (CK, EC 2.7.3.2) isozyme loci and their differential tissue expressions were determined for representatives of 65 families of vertebrates, with emphasis on the fishes. The transition from the single creatine kinase locus, characteristic of certain echinoderms, to the two creatine kinase loci which are orthologous to those present in all vertebrates, occurred early in the chordate line. The majority of pre-teleostean fishes possesses only these two CK loci (A and C). These loci are relatively generalized in their tissue expressions which are variable among species of primitive fishes. The third and fourth creatine kinase loci (B and D) arose separately in the ancestors of the bony fishes and appear to be the result of regional genome duplications. Concomitant with the increase in the number of isozyme loci has been an increase in the specificity of their tissue expression. In the advanced teleost fishes the four CK loci are differentially expressed in a characteristic manner. The A₂ isozyme predominates in skeletal muscle, the B₂ isozyme in eye and brain, the C₂ isozyme in stomach muscle, and the D₂ isozyme is found exclusively in testis. We propose a phylogeny of the creatine kinase genes in the lower chordates based on the time of appearance of new CK loci, the sequence in which the loci achieve a tissue restricted expression, and the immunochemical relatedness of the orthologous and paralogous gene products.     

Conservation and divergence of Bmp2a, Bmp2b, and Bmp4 expression patterns within and between dentitions of teleost fishes

The diversity of tooth location in teleost fishes provides an excellent system for comparing genetic divergence between teeth in different species (phylogenetic homologs) with divergence between teeth within one species (iterative homologs). We have chosen to examine the expression of three members of the bone morphogenetic protein (Bmp) family because they are known to play multiple roles in tooth development and evolution in tetrapod vertebrates. We characterized expression of Bmp2a, Bmp2b, and Bmp4 during the development of oral and pharyngeal dentitions in three species of teleost fishes, the zebrafish (Danio rerio), Mexican tetra (Astyanax mexicanus), and Japanese medaka (Oryzias latipes). We found that expression in teleosts is generally highly conserved, with minor differences found among both iteratively homologous and phylogenetically homologous teeth. Expression of orthologous genes differs in several ways between the teeth of teleost fishes and those of the mouse, but between these vertebrate groups the summed expression pattern of Bmp genes is highly conserved. Significantly, the toothless oral region of the zebrafish lacks Bmp expression domains found in teleosts with oral teeth, implicating these genes in evolutionary tooth loss. We conclude that Bmp expression has been largely conserved in vertebrate tooth development over evolutionary time, and that loss of Bmp expression is correlated with region-specific loss of the dentition in a major group of fishes.     

Relaxin gene family in teleosts: phylogeny, syntenic mapping, selective constraint, andexpression analysis

Background  

In recent years, the relaxin family of signaling molecules has been shown to play diverse roles in mammalian physiology, but little is known about its diversity or physiology in teleosts, an infraclass of the bony fishes comprising ~ 50% of all extant vertebrates. In this paper, 32 relaxin family sequences were obtained by searching genomic and cDNA databases from eight teleost species; phylogenetic, molecular evolutionary, and syntenic data analyses were conducted to understand the relationship and differential patterns of evolution of relaxin family genes in teleosts compared with mammals. Additionally, real-time quantitative PCR was used to confirm and assess the tissues of expression of five relaxin family genes in Danio rerio and in situ hybridization used to assess the site-specific expression of the insulin 3-like gene in D. rerio testis.     

Adaptative features of enzymes from family Sciaenidae--III. Studies on lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) of fishes from the south coast of Uruguay

1. Electrophoretic analyses of lactate dehydrogenase isozyme patterns of three species of temperate fish belonging to family Sciaenidae (order Perciformes) indicates that at least three LDH loci--Ldh-A, Ldh-B and Ldh-C are active. 2. The subunits encoded by these loci occurred at different levels in the different tissues and organs analyzed. 3. The products of these loci show different response to changes in temperature. The results were obtained by electrophoretic analyses. 4. Thermostability of skeletal muscle, heart and eye lactate dehydrogenase incubated at 60 degrees C for different periods of time were examined. 5. Relative activities of LDH isozymes were compared by Klebe's method to determine pattern of divergence of duplicated gene expression in the three species studied.     

Evidence for a period of directional selection following gene duplication in a neurally expressed locus of triosephosphate isomerase

A striking correlation between neural expression and high net negative charge in some teleost isozymes led to the interesting, yet untested, suggestion that negative charge represents an adaptation (via natural selection) to the neural environment. We examine the evolution of the triosephosphate isomerase (TPI) gene family in fishes for periods of positive selection. Teleost fish express two TPI proteins, including a generally expressed, neutrally charged isozyme and a neurally expressed, negatively charged isozyme; more primitive fish express only a single, generally expressed TPI isozyme. The TPI gene phylogeny constructed from sequences isolated from two teleosts, a single acipenseriform, and other TPI sequences from the databases, supports a single gene duplication event early in the evolution of bony fishes. Comparisons between inferred ancestral TPI sequences indicate that the neural TPI isozyme evolved through a period of positive selection resulting in the biased accumulation of negatively charged amino acids. Further, the number of nucleotide changes required for the observed amino acid substitutions suggests that selection acted on the overall charge of the protein and not on specific key amino acids.     

Adaptive evolution of the uncoupling protein 1 gene contributed to the acquisition of novel nonshivering thermogenesis in ancestral eutherian mammals

Homeotherms possess various physiological mechanisms to maintain their body temperature, thus allowing them to adapt to various environments. Under cold conditions, most eutherian mammals upregulate heat production in brown adipose tissue (BAT), and uncoupling protein (UCP) 1 is an essential factor in BAT thermogenesis. The evolutionary origin of UCP1 was believed to have been a specific event occurring in eutherian lineages. Recently, however, the UCP1 ortholog was found in fishes, which uncovers a more ancient origin of this gene than previously believed. Here we investigate the evolutionary process of UCP1 by comparative genomic approach. We found that UCP1 evolved rapidly by positive Darwinian selection in the common ancestor of eutherians, although this gene arose in the ancestral vertebrate, since the orthologous genes were shared among most of the vertebrate species. Adaptive evolution occurred after the divergence between eutherians and marsupials, which is consistent with the fact that BAT has been found only in eutherians. Our findings indicate that positive Darwinian selection acted on UCP1 contributed to the acquisition of an efficient mechanism for body temperature regulation in primitive eutherians. Phylogenetic reconstruction of UCP1 with two paralogs (UCP2 and UCP3) among vertebrate species revealed that the gene duplication events which produced these three genes occurred in the common ancestor of vertebrates much earlier than the emergence of eutherians. Thus, our data demonstrate that novel gene function can evolve without de novo gene duplication event.     

Evolution of the differential regulation of duplicate genes after polyploidization

Summary In the 50 million years since the polyploidization event that gave rise to the catostomid family of fishes the duplicate genes encoding isozymes have undergone different fates. Ample opportunity has been available for regulatory evolution of these duplicate genes. Approximately half the duplicate genes have lost their expressions during this time. Of the duplicate genes remaining, the majority have diverged to different extents in their expression within and among adult tissues. The pattern of divergence of duplicate gene expression is consistent with the accumulation of mutations at regulatory genes. The absence of a correlation of extent of divergence of gene expression with the level of genetic variability for isozymes at these loci is consistent with the view that the rates of regulatory gene and structural gene evolution are uncoupled. The magnitude of divergence of duplicate gene expressions varies among tissues, enzymes, and species. Little correlation was found with the extent of divergence of duplicate gene expression within a species and its degree of morphological conservatism, although species pairs which are increasingly taxonomically distant are less likely to share specific patterns of differential gene expression. Probable phylogenetic times of origin of several patterns of differential gene expression have been proposed. Some patterns of differential gene expression have evolved in recent evolutionary times and are specific to one or a few species, whereas at least one pattern of differential gene expression is present in nearly all species and probably arose soon after the polyploidization event. Multilocus isozymes, formed by polyploidization, provide a useful model system for studying the forces responsible for the maintenance of duplicate genes and the evolution of these once identical genes to new spatially and temporally specific patterns of regulation.     

Unusual intraindividual variation of the nuclear 18S rRNA gene is widespread within the Acipenseridae

Significant intraindividual variation in the sequence of the 18S rRNA gene is unusual in animal genomes. In a previous study, multiple 18S rRNA gene sequences were observed within individuals of eight species of sturgeon from North America but not in the North American paddlefish, Polyodon spathula, in two species of Polypterus (Polypterus delhezi and Polypterus senegalus), in other primitive fishes (Erpetoichthys calabaricus, Lepisosteus osseus, Amia calva) or in a lungfish (Protopterus sp.). These observations led to the hypothesis that this unusual genetic characteristic arose within the Acipenseriformes after the presumed divergence of the sturgeon and paddlefish families. In the present study, a survey of nearly all Eurasian acipenseriform species was conducted to examine 18S rDNA variation. Intraindividual variation was not found in the polyodontid species, the Chinese paddlefish, Psephurus gladius, but variation was detected in all Eurasian acipenserid species. The comparison of sequences from two major segments of the 18S rRNA gene and identification of sites where insertion/deletion events have occurred are placed in the context of evolutionary relationships within the Acipenseriformes and the evolution of rDNA variation in this group.     

Variation within and among species in gene expression: raw material for evolution

Heritable variation in regulatory or coding regions is the raw material for evolutionary processes. The advent of microarrays has recently promoted examination of the extent of variation in gene expression within and among taxa and examination of the evolutionary processes affecting variation. This review examines these issues. We find: (i) microarray-based measures of gene expression are precise given appropriate experimental design; (ii) there is large inter-individual variation, which is composed of a minor nongenetic component and a large heritable component; (iii) variation among populations and species appears to be affected primarily by neutral drift and stabilizing selection, and to a lesser degree by directional selection; and (iv) neutral evolutionary divergence in gene expression becomes nonlinear with greater divergence times due to functional constraint. Evolutionary analyses of gene expression reviewed here provide unique insights into partitioning of regulatory variation in nature. However, common limitations of these studies include the tendency to assume a linear relationship between expression divergence and species divergence, and failure to test explicit hypotheses that involve the ecological context of evolutionary divergence.     

Some aspects of isozymes of lactate dehydrogenase, malate dehydrogenase and glucosephosphate isomerase in fish

1. The present paper reports some aspects of the isozymes of LDH, MDH and GPI in fish. 2. In Petromyzontiformes LDH is encoded by a single Ldh-A gene locus. In Myxiniformes and in most vertebrates LDH is encoded by two gene loci, A and B. A third Ldh-C locus is characteristic of the bony fishes Actinopterygii. 3. In fish the MDH isozymes are generally encoded by three gene loci Mdh-M, Mdh-A and Mdh-B. 4. In most diploid bony fish the GPI is controlled by two independent gene loci Gpi-A and Gpi-B. 5. The relationships of isozymes with evolution of vertebrates, tissual specificity, ontogenetic changes, with physiological and metabolic roles are discussed.     

Evolution of trace amine associated receptor (TAAR) gene family in vertebrates: lineage-specific expansions and degradations of a second class of vertebrate chemosensory receptors expressed in the olfactory epithelium

The trace amine-associated receptors (TAARs) form a specific family of G protein-coupled receptors in vertebrates. TAARs were initially considered neurotransmitter receptors, but recent study showed that mouse TAARs function as chemosensory receptors in the olfactory epithelium. To clarify the evolutionary dynamics of the TAAR gene family in vertebrates, near-complete repertoires of TAAR genes and pseudogenes were identified from the genomic assemblies of 4 teleost fishes (zebrafish, fugu, stickleback, and medaka), western clawed frogs, chickens, 3 mammals (humans, mice, and opossum), and sea lampreys. Database searches revealed that fishes had many putatively functional TAAR genes (13-109 genes), whereas relatively small numbers of TAAR genes (3-22 genes) were identified in tetrapods. Phylogenetic analysis of these genes indicated that the TAAR gene family was subdivided into 5 subfamilies that diverged before the divergence of ray-finned fishes and tetrapods. In tetrapods, virtually all TAAR genes were located in 1 specific region of their genomes as a gene cluster; however, in fishes, TAAR genes were scattered throughout more than 2 genomic locations. This possibly reflects a whole-genome duplication that occurred in the common ancestor of ray-finned fishes. Expression analysis of zebrafish and stickleback TAAR genes revealed that many TAARs in these fishes were expressed in the olfactory organ, suggesting the relatively high importance of TAARs as chemosensory receptors in fishes. A possible evolutionary history of the vertebrate TAAR gene family was inferred from the phylogenetic and comparative genomic analyses.     

Structural organization, mapping, characterization and evolutionary relationships of CDKN2 gene family members in Xiphophorus fishes

Xiphophorus fishes and their hybrids are used as models for the study of melanoma and other diseases. The cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor gene family in humans is comprised of four members, including CDKN2A (P16), and dysregulation of this gene is implicated in numerous neoplasms including melanomas. We have investigated the status of the gene family in the southern platyfish X. maculatus. Xiphophorus harbors at least two such loci, which we now term CDKN2A/B and CDKN2D. Both loci map to Xiphophorus linkage group 5, a genomic area that has long been known to harbor the DIFF tumor suppressor locus. Within this report, we report on the complete cloning, genomic exon/intron boundary delineation, linkage mapping and expressional characteristics of Xiphophorus CDKN2D. We also compare and contrast this expression to that of the previously isolated CDKN2AB locus in normal and neoplastic tissues derived from non-hybrid and hybrid fishes. The hypothetical evolutionary relationships of gene family members and their involvement in melanoma is evaluated. In comparison to CDKN2A/B, the RNA expression of Xiphophorus CDKN2D differs in normal tissues and is not associated with melanotic/pathologic tissues, confirming functional divergence between obvious homologues.     

Codon usage in histone gene families of higher eukaryotes reflects functional rather than phylogenetic relationships

Summary The nucleic acid sequences coding for 23 H3 histone genes from a variety of species have been analyzed using a computer assisted alignment and analysis program. Although these histones are highly conserved within and between highly divergent species, they represent various classes of histones whose patterns of expression are distinctively regulated. Surprisingly, in dendrograms derived from these comparisons, H3 sequences cluster according to their modes of regulation rather than phylogenetically. These clusters are generated from highly distinctive patterns of codon usage within the functional gene classes. We suggest that one factor involved in specifying the differing codon usage patterns between functional classes is a difference in requirements for rapid translation of mRNA. In addition, the data presented here, together with structural and sequence information, suggest a heterodox evolutionary model in which genes related to the intron-bearing, basally expressed H3.3 vertebrate genes are the ancestors of the intronless H3. 1 class of genes of higher eukaryotes. The H3. 1 class must have arisen, therefore, following duplication of a primitive H3.3 gene, but prior to the plant-animal divergence. Implications of the data presented are discussed with regard to functional and evolutionary relationships.     

Evolution of yellow gene regulation and pigmentation in Drosophila

BACKGROUND: Changes in developmental gene expression are central to phenotypic evolution, but the genetic mechanisms underlying these changes are not well understood. Interspecific differences in gene expression can arise from evolutionary changes in cis-regulatory DNA and/or in the expression of trans-acting regulatory proteins, but few case studies have distinguished between these mechanisms. Here, we compare the regulation of the yellow gene, which is required for melanization, among distantly related Drosophila species with different pigment patterns and determine the phenotypic effects of divergent Yellow expression. RESULTS: Yellow expression has diverged among D. melanogaster, D. subobscura, and D. virilis and, in all cases, correlates with the distribution of black melanin. Species-specific Yellow expression patterns were retained in D. melanogaster transformants carrying the D. subobscura and D. virilis yellow genes, indicating that sequence evolution within the yellow gene underlies the divergence of Yellow expression. Evolutionary changes in the activity of orthologous cis-regulatory elements are responsible for differences in abdominal Yellow expression; however, cis-regulatory element evolution is not the sole cause of divergent Yellow expression patterns. Transformation of the D. melanogaster yellow gene into D. virilis altered its expression pattern, indicating that trans-acting factors that regulate the D. melanogaster yellow gene have also diverged between these two species. Finally, we found that the phenotypic effects of evolutionary changes in Yellow expression depend on epistatic interactions with other genes. CONCLUSIONS: Evolutionary changes in Yellow expression correlate with divergent melanin patterns and are a result of evolution in both cis- and trans-regulation. These changes were likely necessary for the divergence of pigmentation, but evolutionary changes in other genes were also required.     

Evolutionary mechanisms: Modularity,morphogenetic fields of gene expression,genetic regulation

Modern concepts heterochrony mechanisms, taking into account the data on modularity of ontogenetic and evolutionary processes, morphogenetic fields of gene expression are considered. In the context of evolutionary changes, features of genetic regulation of heterochronies, and also suppression of gene activity by epigenetic regulation are analyzed. Features of the origin of evolutionary novelties due to heterochronies, macromutations, and divergence of duplicated genes, which result in the formation of new genes and gene families, are discussed.     

Comparative morphometry and phenetics of the genera of esocoid fishes (Salmoniformes)

Using shape data derived from the externa] body morphometry of esocoid fishes in which the effects of size were standardized, a close relationship of Umbra and Novumbra is supported. Dallia is provisionally associated with these but some data contradicted this. Esox is distantly associated with all of these. Thus the appropriate systematic classification for this group is: suborder Esocoidei; family Esocidae (five species in one genus— Esox ), family Umbridae (four species in two genera— Umbra and Novumbra ), and, incertae sedis Dallia (one or perhaps two species).     

Functional divergence of a syntenic invertase gene family in tomato,potato, and Arabidopsis

Comparative analysis of complex developmental pathways depends on our ability to resolve the function of members of gene families across taxonomic groups. LIN5, which belongs to a small gene family of apoplastic invertases in tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum), is a quantitative trait locus that modifies fruit sugar composition. We have compared the genomic organization and expression of this gene family in the two distantly related species: tomato and Arabidopsis. Invertase family members reside on segmental duplications in the near-colinear genomes of tomato and potato (Solanum tuberosum). These chromosomal segments are syntenically duplicated in the model plant Arabidopsis. On the basis of phylogenetic analysis of genes in the microsyntenic region, we conclude that these segmental duplications arose independently after the separation of the tomato/potato clade from Arabidopsis. Rapid regulatory divergence is characteristic of the invertase family. Interestingly, although the processes of gene duplication and specialization of expression occurred separately in the two species, synteny-based orthologs from both clades acquired similar organ-specific expression. This similar expression pattern of the genes is evidence of comparable evolutionary constraints (parallel evolution) rather than of functional orthology. The observation that functional orthology cannot be identified through analysis of expression similarity highlights the caution that needs to be exercised in extrapolating developmental networks from a model organism.