Modification of the alkaline comet assay with human mesenchymal stem cells

MSCs (mesenchymal stem cells) are planned foruse in regenerative medicine to offset age-dependent alterations. However, MSCs are affected by replicative senescence associated with decreasing proliferation potential, telomere shortening and DNA damage during in vitro propagation. To monitor in vitro senescence, we have assessed the integrity of DNA by the alkaline comet assay. For optimization of the comet assay we have enhanced the stability of comet slides in liquid and minimized the background noise of the method by improving adhesion of agarose gels on the comet slides and concentrating cells on a defined small area on the slides. The modifications of the slide preparation increase the overall efficiency and reproducibility of the comet assay and minimize the image capture and storage. DNA damage of human MSCs during in vitro cultivation increased with time, as assessed by the comet assay, which therefore offers a fast and easy screening tool in future efforts to minimize replicative senescence of MSCs in vitro.     

Preservation of comet assay slides: comparison with fresh slides.

The single cell gel electrophoresis assay (comet assay) is an inexpensive, rapid and highly sensitive method for the determination of DNA damage, crosslinks, and alkaline-labile lesions in individual cells. A limitation of the procedure is that the microelectrophoretic gels must be scored rapidly as the comet configuration deteriorates on storage due to dehydration of the agarose and diffusion of DNA. The objectives of this study were firstly to evaluate drying regimes as rapid and simple methods of preservation of the microgels as close to their original fresh state as possible, and secondly to examine the effects of storage of the slides. Human hepatoma (HepG2) cells challenged for 30 min with hydrogen peroxide (H(2)O(2)) were used in the study. Microgel slides were prepared and evaluated immediately, or after drying with or without a methanol fixation step. Microgels that were dried at a variety of temperatures (22-50 degrees C) and re-hydrated did not differ in the values obtained for H(2)O(2)-induced DNA damage when compared to fresh samples. Samples could also be continually dried and re-hydrated over a period of up to 3 months with no obvious loss of information. In conclusion, drying of microgels represents a simple and inexpensive method of preserving comet assay slides.     

Induction of DNA damage in mammalian cells by hydrogen peroxide generated by glucose oxidase immobilized in agarose slides

A new model system has been developed to study the influence of reactive oxygen species on isolated mammalian cells in conjunction with the comet assay. The glucose-glucose oxidase system was used as a hydrogen peroxide generating source. The level of DNA damage was assessed in the splenocytes and the cells of bone marrow of mouse and in human leukocytes both in untreated cells and in cells treated with hydrogen peroxide generated by glucose oxidase using the alkaline comet assay in vitro. Various options for the location of the enzyme in the slides have been studied: in the layer with the cells, in the layer above the cells, or in solution on the surface of the slides. The option where glucose oxidase was in the upper layer of 0.5% agarose over the layer of the cells was optimal. It provided separation of the enzyme from the cells and avoided obstruction to the hydrogen peroxide exposure. For the whole blood study, the content of endogenous glucose must be taken into account. This approach can be used to study the level of DNA damage induced in vitro and for the detection of DNA repair, thereby expanding the possibilities of the method, while the experiments are conducted under controlled conditions.     

The comet assay: a method to measure DNA damage in individual cells

We present a procedure for the comet assay, a gel electrophoresis-based method that can be used to measure DNA damage in individual eukaryotic cells. It is versatile, relatively simple to perform and sensitive. Although most investigations make use of its ability to measure DNA single-strand breaks, modifications to the method allow detection of DNA double-strand breaks, cross-links, base damage and apoptotic nuclei. The limit of sensitivity is approximately 50 strand breaks per diploid mammalian cell. DNA damage and its repair in single-cell suspensions prepared from yeast, protozoa, plants, invertebrates and mammals can also be studied using this assay. Originally developed to measure variation in DNA damage and repair capacity within a population of mammalian cells, applications of the comet assay now range from human and sentinel animal biomonitoring (e.g., DNA damage in earthworms crawling through toxic waste sites) to measurement of DNA damage in specific genomic sequences. This protocol can be completed in fewer than 24 h.     

Use of the single cell gel electrophoresis/comet assay for detecting DNA damage in aquatic (marine and freshwater) animals

The comet assay is a rapid, sensitive and inexpensive method for measuring DNA strand breaks. The comet assay has advantages over other DNA damage methods, such as sister chromatid exchange, alkali elution and micronucleus assay, because of its high sensitivity and that DNA strand breaks are determined in individual cells. This review describes a number of studies that used the comet assay to determine DNA strand breaks in aquatic animals exposed to genotoxicants both in vitro and in vivo, including assessment of DNA damage in aquatic animals collected from contaminated sites. One difficulty of using the comet assay in environmental work is that of comparing results from studies that used different methods, such as empirical scoring or comet tail lengths. There seems to be a consensus in more recent studies to use both the intensity of the tail and the length of the tail, i.e. DNA tail moment, percentage of DNA in the tail. The comet assay has been used to assess DNA repair and apoptosis in aquatic animals and modifications of the comet assay have allowed the detection of specific DNA lesions. There have been some recent studies to link DNA strand breaks in aquatic animals to effects on the immune system, reproduction, growth, and population dynamics. Further work is required before the comet assay can be used as a standard bio-indicator in aquatic environments, including standardization of methods (such as ASTM method E2186-02a) and measurements.     

Ultrasensitive detection of hydrogen peroxide-mediated DNA damage after alkaline single cell gel electrophoresis using occultation microscopy and TUNEL labeling.

DNA damage at the level of individual cells can be detected using the single cell gel electrophoresis (SCGE) or 'comet' assay. In the present study, we report novel variations on the conventional comet assay that can be used to enhance the microscopic detection of DNA damage. Hydrogen peroxide-treated peripheral blood leukocytes were used as a DNA damage model system. Cells were embedded in agarose, treated, and electrophoresed according to the procedure of Singh et al. [N.P. Singh, M.T. McCoy, R.R. Tice, E.L. Schneider, A simple technique for quantitation of low levels of DNA damage in individual cells, Exp. Cell Res. 175 (1988), p. 184-191]. However, sites of strand breaks were directly labeled with the TUNEL (TdT-mediated fluorescein-dUTP nick end labeling) method. This labeling protocol revealed clumps and/or a series of stripes in the comet tail perpendicular to the direction of electrophoresis; these sites may account for the substructure seen in conventional comet assays. In a second comet variation, we passed an opaque disk into a field-conjugated plane of the microscope near the lamp, thus occluding the nucleus' image. Nuclear occultation allows the intensified charge-coupled device (ICCD) camera gain to increase to a single photon detection level thus revealing low levels of DNA damage in the tail. These methods offer a substantial improvement in sensitivity.     

Assessing the DNA methylation status of single cells with the comet assay

The comet assay (single cell gel electrophoresis) is a cost-effective, sensitive, and simple technique that is traditionally used for analyzing and quantifying DNA damage in individual cells. The aim of this study was to determine whether the comet assay could be modified to detect changes in the levels of DNA methylation in single cells. We used the difference in methylation sensitivity of the isoschizomeric restriction endonucleases HpaII and MspI to demonstrate the feasibility of the comet assay to measure the global DNA methylation level of individual cells. The results were verified with the well-established cytosine extension assay. We were able to show variations in DNA methylation after treatment of cultured cells with 5-azacytidine and succinylacetone, an accumulating metabolite in human tyrosinemia type I.     

检测DNA-蛋白质交联的新方法

将彗星实验进行改进以用于DNA-蛋白质交联作用的检测。利用甲醛对受试动物肝细胞的影响来判定此法是否适用于检测DNA-蛋白质交联。由于在实验中添加一定量的蛋白酶K, 可使单细胞在电泳时产生更大的迁移, 因此可以利用添加蛋白酶K前后的彗星尾距比来判断外来化合物对生物机体产生DNA损伤效应的时候是否有出现DNA-蛋白质交联作用。结果表明, 该方法快速、经济、灵敏度较高, 可以在单细胞水平对甲醛等强交联剂引发的不同组织的DNA-蛋白质交联效应进行检测, 希望该方法能成为指示DNA交联能力的有用工具。     

A silver staining method for single-cell gel assay.

The single-cell gel assay (comet assay) is a very useful microelectrophoretic technique for evaluation of DNA damage and repair in individual cells. Usually, the comets are visualized and evaluated with fluorescent DNA stains. This staining requires specific equipment (e.g., a high-quality fluorescence microscope), the slides must be analyzed immediately, and they cannot be stored for long periods of time. Here we describe, using human lymphocytes, some modifications of the silver staining for comets that significantly increase the sensitivity/reproducibility of the assay. This silver staining was compared with fluorescence staining and commercial silver stains. (J Histochem Cytochem 49:1183-1186, 2001)     

Comet assay: rapid processing of multiple samples

The present study describes modifications to the basic comet protocol that increase productivity and efficiency without sacrificing assay reliability. A simple technique is described for rapidly preparing up to 96 comet assay samples simultaneously. The sample preparation technique allows thin layers of agarose-embedded cells to be prepared in multiple wells attached to a flexible film of Gelbond, which improves the ease of manipulating and processing samples. To evaluate the effect of these modifications on assay sensitivity, dose-response curves are presented for DNA damage induced by exposure of TK6 cells to low concentrations of hydrogen peroxide (0-10 microM) and for exposure of human lymphocytes to X-irradiation (0-100 cGy). The limit of detection of DNA damage induced by hydrogen peroxide in TK6 cells was observed to be 1 uM for all parameters (tail ratio, tail moment, tail length and comet length) while the limit of detection of DNA damage in human lymphocytes was 10 cGy for tail and comet length parameters, but 50 cGy for tail ratio and tail moment parameters. These results are similar to those previously reported using the conventional alkaline comet assay. The application of SYBR Gold for detection of DNA damage was compared to that of propidium iodide. Measurements of matching samples for tail length and comet length were similar using both stains. However, comets stained with SYBR Gold persisted longer and were much brighter than those obtained with propidium iodide. SYBR Gold was found to be ideal for measuring tail length and comet length but, under present assay conditions, impractical for measuring tail ratio or tail moment due to saturation of staining in the head region of the comets.     

Assessment of DNA damage in peripheral blood of heavy smokers with the comet assay and the micronucleus test

The comet assay (single-cell gel electrophoresis, SCG) is being increasingly used in human biomonitoring for the detection of genotoxic exposures. Cigarette smoking is a well-documented source of a variety of potentially mutagenic and carcinogenic compounds. Therefore, smoking should represent a relevant mutagenic exposure and lead to genotoxic effects in exposed cells. However, our previous investigations as well as several other published studies on human biomonitoring failed to show an effect of smoking on DNA migration in the comet assay, while some other studies did indicate such an effect. Although many factors can contribute to the generation of discrepant results in such studies, clear effects should be obtained after high exposure. We therefore performed a comparative study with healthy male heavy smokers (>20 cigarettes per day) and non-smokers (n=12 in each group). We measured the baseline comet assay effects in fresh whole blood samples and isolated lymphocytes. In addition, the amount of 'formamidopyrimidine DNA-glycosylase (FPG)-sensitive sites' was determined by a combination of the standard comet assay with the bacterial FPG protein. Furthermore, the influence of a repair inhibitor (aphidicolin, APC) on baseline DNA damage was comparatively analysed. Duplicate slides from each sample were processed and analysed separately. In all experiments, a reference standard (untreated V79 cells) was included to correct for assay variability. Finally, to compare the comet assay results with another genetic endpoint, all blood samples were investigated in parallel by the micronucleus test (MNT). Baseline and gamma radiation-induced micronucleus frequencies were determined. None of these approaches revealed a significant difference between heavy smokers and non-smokers with regard to a genotoxic effect in peripheral blood cells.     

Analysis of chromate-induced DNA-protein crosslinks with the comet assay

Modifications of the comet assay have been introduced to measure crosslinks by determining the reduction of induced DNA migration. Our previous results indicated that the modified protocol of the alkaline comet assay is a sensitive tool for the detection of formaldehyde-induced DNA-protein crosslinks. But results for mitomycin C and cisplatin suggested that the modified protocol is not well suited for the evaluation of DNA-DNA crosslinkers. We now used the comet assay to investigate in V79 cells the effect of potassium chromate (K(2)CrO(4)), another DNA-protein crosslinker, to see whether the results obtained for formaldehyde can be generalized. However, chromate did not reduce spontaneous or radiation-induced DNA migration in the alkaline (pH 13) comet assay but led to a small but significant induction of DNA migration. A crosslinking effect of chromate could also not be detected with the alkaline comet assay after postincubation of cells in normal medium after chromate treatment to enable repair of other (migration-inducing) lesions that might mask the crosslinking effect. Exposure of slides to proteinase K further increased DNA migration of chromate-treated cells, thus indicating the presence of DNA-protein crosslinks. In contrast to the alkaline comet assay, a "neutral" version at pH 9 was suited to demonstrate reduced induction of DNA migration after gamma-irradiation of chromate-treated cells. The crosslinking effect was seen immediately at the end of the chromate treatment as well as after a 3h postincubation period. Using the "neutral" protocol in combination with proteinase K, we were able to demonstrate the presence of DNA-protein crosslinks as the probable cause for the migration-reducing effect. Further investigations will have to show whether this protocol can be recommended as a universal approach for the detection of DNA-protein crosslinks and also of DNA-DNA crosslinks with the comet assay.     

Improved alkaline comet assay protocol for adherent HaCaT keratinocytes to study UVA-induced DNA damage

The comet assay is one of the well-accepted tests to measure radiation-induced DNA damage. The most commonly used protocols require single-cell suspensions that are embedded in agarose in order to perform electrophoresis. For adherently growing cells such as human HaCaT skin keratinocytes this method bears several problems. We show that trypsinization required for maintaining single-cell suspensions is prolonged after UV radiation and thereby reduces cell viability and allows partial repair, with the consequence of reduced damage detection after irradiation. Therefore, we here introduce a modified version of the comet assay where HaCaT cells are seeded onto comet slides 24 h before the assay and overlaid with agarose immediately after irradiation. Using this modification we are now able to reproducibly measure high DNA-damage levels (13-fold increase compared with controls) following irradiation with 60 J/cm² UVA as well as a dose-dependent increase of DNA damage after 10, 20 and 60 J/cm² UVA. Thus, by maintaining the cells in their natural configuration, i.e. adherently growing, we exclude several artefacts that are likely to influence the damage responses. These include: (i) trypsinization-dependent changes in cell morphology and polarity (clear lateral, i.e. adherent, and apical side of keratinocytes) which are likely of consequence for the gene-expression pattern, (ii) trypsin- and dislodgement-induced damage reducing cell viability, and (iii) the time delay between damage induction and damage evaluation to unpredictable results due to partial repair. Since these advantages pertain to all adherently growing cells, this improved protocol is not restricted to HaCaT cells but offers great potential also with all non-haematopoietic cells for obtaining accurate results and for studying repair processes in a highly reproducible manner.     

Improved alkaline comet assay protocol for adherent HaCaT keratinocytes to study UVA-induced DNA damage

The comet assay is one of the well-accepted tests to measure radiation-induced DNA damage. The most commonly used protocols require single-cell suspensions that are embedded in agarose in order to perform electrophoresis. For adherently growing cells such as human HaCaT skin keratinocytes this method bears several problems. We show that trypsinization required for maintaining single-cell suspensions is prolonged after UV radiation and thereby reduces cell viability and allows partial repair, with the consequence of reduced damage detection after irradiation. Therefore, we here introduce a modified version of the comet assay where HaCaT cells are seeded onto comet slides 24h before the assay and overlaid with agarose immediately after irradiation. Using this modification we are now able to reproducibly measure high DNA-damage levels (13-fold increase compared with controls) following irradiation with 60J/cm(2) UVA as well as a dose-dependent increase of DNA damage after 10, 20 and 60J/cm(2) UVA. Thus, by maintaining the cells in their natural configuration, i.e. adherently growing, we exclude several artefacts that are likely to influence the damage responses. These include: (i) trypsinization-dependent changes in cell morphology and polarity (clear lateral, i.e. adherent, and apical side of keratinocytes) which are likely of consequence for the gene-expression pattern, (ii) trypsin- and dislodgement-induced damage reducing cell viability, and (iii) the time delay between damage induction and damage evaluation to unpredictable results due to partial repair. Since these advantages pertain to all adherently growing cells, this improved protocol is not restricted to HaCaT cells but offers great potential also with all non-haematopoietic cells for obtaining accurate results and for studying repair processes in a highly reproducible manner.     

Single cell gel electrophoresis assay: a new technique for human biomonitoring studies

Human biomonitoring using the single cell gel electrophoresis (SCGE) or comet assay is a novel approach for the assessment of genetic damage in exposed populations. This assay enables the detection of various forms of DNA damage in individual cells with ease and speed and is, therefore, well suited to the analysis of a large group in a population. Here, application of SCGE assay in the identification of dietary protective factors, in clinical studies and in monitoring the risk of DNA damage resulting from occupational, environmental or lifestyle exposures is reviewed. Also, the comparative sensitivity of SCGE assay and conventional cytogenetic tests to detect genetic damage is discussed. Finally, strengths and shortcomings of the SCGE assay are addressed.     

Genotoxicity of the Kishon River,Israel: the application of an in vitro cellular assay

The alkaline comet assay, a sensitive method for DNA strand breaks and alkali labile site detection in individual cells, was employed here as an ecotoxicological monitoring tool for evaluation of genotoxicity in the Kishon River, Israel. This river, the most polluted river in Israel, has recently elicited major public concern with regard to cancer incidences in people who have dived there over many years. Five water samples were collected every odd month throughout the year 2001, from four localities. The comet assay was employed on fish hepatoma cell line RTH-149. Cells were exposed for 2h, in triplicate, to Kishon water: medium (1:1) samples that were pre-adjusted for pH and salinity percentage levels. Three DNA damage parameters (comet percentages, score of damage, and cumulative tail lengths of the comet), revealed significantly higher genotoxic values in Kishon water-treated cells as compared with the controls (up to 2.4, 3.2, and 3.6-fold, respectively). Part of the sampling sites revealed higher genotoxicity than other polluted sites. The results of this study demonstrate that the comet assay with RTH-149 cells can be successfully applied to a variety of aquatic samples revealing freshwater, marine and estuary conditions. The method found to be fast, sensitive, and suitable for monitoring programs.     

Genotoxicity of three pesticides used in Costa Rican banana plantations

The in vitro genotoxicity of imazalil and thiabendazole fungicides and the insecticide chlorpyrifos, compounds used in Costa Rican banana plantations, was evaluated with the single-cell gel electrophoresis technique (comet assay). The comet assay is a simple, rapid and low cost technique for quantification of DNA damage. This assay detects DNA single-strand breaks and alkali-labile sites in individual cells. The effects were analyzed by using human lymphocytes exposed to doses of 0, 25, 50, 75 and 100 microg/ml of each pesticide for 30 min at 37 degrees C. The cells were embedded in agarose, lysed, subjected to alkaline electrophoresis (pH >13) for 20 min at 25V, neutralized and dehydrated to be stained with a fluorescent dye and later comets visualization with the epifluorescence microscope. Chlorpyrifos and imazalil induced significant DNA damage in a dose-dependent manner. Chlorpyrifos was the major inductor of DNA breaks. These results indicate that both are genotoxic compounds in vitro. Thiabendazole fungicide did not induced DNA damage using the comet assay for all concentrations tested.     

Application of Euglena gracilis cells to comet assay: evaluation of DNA damage and repair

Alkaline single-cell gel electrophoresis (comet assay) enables sensitive detection of DNA damage in eukaryotic cells induced by genotoxic agents. We performed a comet assay of unicellular green alga Euglena gracilis that was exposed to genotoxic chemicals, 1-methyl-3-nitro-1-nitrosoguanidine (MNNG), benzo[a]pyrene (BAP), mitomycin C (MMC) and actinomycin D (AMD). Tail length and tail moment in migrated DNA were measured as indications of DNA damage. MNNG and BAP were found to cause concentration-dependent increases in DNA damage. The responses were more sensitive than those of human lymphocytes under the same treatment conditions. MMC and AMD showed no positive response, as reported elsewhere. The comet assays performed at specified times after treatment revealed that the DNA damaged by MNNG and gamma-ray irradiation was repaired during the initial 1h. The results clearly show that the comet assay is useful for evaluating chemically-induced DNA damage and repair in E. gracilis. Given the ease of culturing and handling E. gracilis as well as its sensitivity, the comet assay of this alga would undoubtedly prove to be a useful tool for testing the genotoxicity of chemicals and monitoring of environmental pollution.     

Inhalation of formaldehyde does not induce genotoxic effects in broncho-alveolar lavage (BAL) cells of rats

Male Fischer-344 rats were exposed to formaldehyde (FA) by inhalation for 4 weeks (6 h/day, 5 days/week). Groups of six rats each were exposed to the target concentrations of 0, 0.5, 1, 2, 6, 10 and 15 ppm. Potential genotoxic effects in the lung were investigated as part of a comprehensive study on local and systemic toxic and genotoxic effects. Broncho-alveolar lavage (BAL) cells were obtained by lung lavage with physiological saline and counted. From one half of the cells, slides for the micronucleus test (MNT) were prepared by cytocentrifugation; with the other half, the comet assay was performed. DNA migration in the comet assay was measured both directly and after irradiation of the cells with 2 Gy gamma-radiation. The latter modification of the comet assay was included to increase its sensitivity for the detection of DNA-protein cross-links (DPX). For the comet assay, four slides were analysed from each cell sample, two without and two with irradiation. From each slide, 50 randomly selected cells were measured by image analysis and tail intensity (% tail DNA) and tail moment were evaluated. The frequency of micronucleated BAL cells was determined in acridine orange-stained slides by analysing 2000 cells per animal. FA did not induce any significant effect in any of the genotoxicity tests performed. It can be concluded that inhalation of FA in a 28 days study with FA concentrations up to 15 ppm does not lead to genotoxic effects in BAL cells of rats. Because detection of DPX by the comet assay is a very sensitive biomarker of FA exposure of cells, our results suggest that there is no genetically relevant exposure of the lung after FA inhalation. The results of our inhalation study, which was performed under GLP conditions, call into question the biological significance of previously reported genotoxic effects in the lung of rats after FA inhalation.     

In vivo DNA damage in gastric epithelial cells

A number of risk factors have been linked epidemiologically with gastric cancer, but studies of DNA damage in gastric epithelial cells are limited. The comet assay is a simple technique for determining levels of DNA damage in individual cells. In this study, we have validated the comet assay for use in epithelial cells derived directly from human gastric biopsies, determined optimal conditions for biopsy digestion and investigated the effects of oxidative stress and digestion time on DNA damage. Biopsies taken at endoscopy were digested using combinations of pronase and collagenase, ethylenediaminetetra-acetic acid (EDTA) and vigorous shaking. The resultant cell suspension was assessed for cell concentration and epithelial cell and leukocyte content. A score for DNA damage, the comet %, was derived from the cell suspension, and the effect of various digestion conditions was studied. Cells were incubated with H(2)O(2) and DNA damage was assessed. Pronase and collagenase provided optimum digestion conditions, releasing 1. 12x10(5) cells per biopsy, predominantly epithelial. Of the 23 suspensions examined, all but three had leukocyte concentrations of less than 20%. The comet assay had high inter-observer (6.1%) and inter-assay (4.5%) reproducibility. Overnight storage of the biopsy at 4 degrees C had no significant effect on DNA migration. Comet % increased from a median of 46% in untreated cells to 88% in cells incubated for 45 min in H(2)O(2) (p=0.005). Serial 25-min digestions were performed on biopsies from 13 patients to release cells from successively deeper levels in the crypt. Levels of DNA migration were significantly lower with each digestion (r=-0.94, p<0.001), suggesting that DNA damage is lower in younger cells released from low in the gastric crypt. The comet assay is a reproducible measure of DNA damage in gastric epithelial cells. Damage accumulates in older, more superficial cells, and can be induced by oxidative stress.