Freezing avoidance mechanism of primordial shoots of conifer buds

Excised winter buds of very hardy fir supercooled to —30or — 35?C, though primordial shoots excised from thesewinter buds (freezing point: about —5.5?C) supercooledonly to —12 to — 14?C. Also, excised primordialshoots did not tolerate freezing, but were rather resistantto desiccation. Differential thermal analysis (DTA) of primordialshoots revealed that the capability of supercooling increasedwith decreasing water content and that no exotherm could bedetected in the primordial shoots with a water content belowabout 20%. When excised whole buds were cooled very slowly,the exotherm temperature shifted markedly to a lower value andthe exotherm became much smaller. Also, masses of needle icewere observed, mainly beneath the crown of the primordial shoot.From these results, it may be concluded that most of the waterin primordial shoots gradually migrates out through the crownand freezes as the temperature decreases (extraorgan freezing),which enables primordial shoots to survive at very low temperatures.Winter buds of Abies balsamea held at — 20?C for 30 daysand then slowly cooled down to —50 or —60?C remainedalive. Thus, there seems to be no low temperature limit to thisfrost avoidance mechanism, if the primordial shoots can resistintensive freeze-dehydration. Low temperature exotherms wereobserved in all genera which belong to Abietoideae and Laricoideaeof Pinaceae, all of which have a crown in the primordial shoots,but not in other conifers. ¹ Contribution No. 2037 from the Institute of Low TemperatureScience. (Received June 25, 1979; )     

Visualization of Freezing Behaviors in Leaf and Flower Buds of Full-Moon Maple by Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Microscopy

1H-Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) microscopy was used to study the freezing behavior of wintering buds of full-moon maple (Acer japonicum Thunb.). The images obtained predominantly reflected the density of mobile (i.e. non-ice) protons from unfrozen water. A comparison of NMR images taken at different subfreezing temperatures revealed which tissues produced high- and low-temperature exotherms in differential thermal analyses. In leaf and lower buds of A. japonicum, the scales and stem bark tissues were already frozen by -7[deg]C, but the primordial inflorescence and terminal primordial shoots remained supercooled at -14[deg]C, and the lateral primordial shoots were unfrozen even at -21[deg]C. The freezing of these supercooled tissues was associated with their loss of viability. The size of the supercooled primordial shoots and inflorescences was gradually reduced with decreasing temperature, indicating extraorgan freezing in these tissues. During this process the formation of dark regions beneath the primordia and subsequent gradual darkening in the basal part of supercooled primordia were visible. As the lateral shoot primordia were cooled, the unfrozen area was considerably reduced. Since the lateral primordia remained viable down to -40[deg]C, with no detectable low-temperature exotherms, they probably underwent type I extraorgan freezing. Deep supercooling in the xylem was clearly imaged. NMR microscopy is a powerful tool for noninvasively visualizing harmonized freezing behaviors in complex plant organs.     

Low temperature exotherms of winter buds of hardy conifers

Differential thermal analysis (DTA) of winter buds and the excisedprimordial shoots of sub-alpine or sub-cold firs revealed thatthese buds had all low temperature exotherms around –30?C.However, no low temperature exotherm below –15?C was detectedin the spring buds. In the winter bud of Abies firma, a temperatefir native to Japan, a low temperature exotherm was detectedaround –20?C, which is higher by 10?C than that of sub-alpineor sub-cold firs. The low temperature exotherms of these firsoccurred at nearly the same temperatures that result in thedeath of these primordial shoots. On the other hand, littleor no low temperature exotherm was detected in the winter budsof sub-cold spruces. In larch winter buds, numerous small exothermswere observed, which are probably due to the many leaf primordiain the buds. Unlike many temperate deciduous broad-leaved trees,no low temperature exotherm was detected below –15?C inwinter twig xylem of conifers such as Abies, Picea, Pinus, Larixand Pseudotsuga. Thus, very hardy coniferous twigs can tolerateextracellular freezing to –70?C. ¹ Contribution No. 1907 from the Institute of Low TemperatureScience. (Received June 8, 1978; )     

Freezing Avoidance Mechanisms by Supercooling in Some Rhododendron flower Buds with Reference to Water Relations

Excised florets of some hardy Rhododendron species did not toleratefreezing at –5°C when ice-inoculated due to intracellularfreezing. Florets in intact December buds, however, could besupercooled to about –30°C. When flower buds of R.japonicum were slowly cooled with daily decrements of 5°Cto temperatures ranging from 0 to –20°C, the exothermtemperatures of the florets drastically decreased. This wasaccompanied by a decrease in water content of florets and peduncleand an increase in that of scales. The water in florets andthe peduncle is thought to migrate to scales and other tissuesduring the early stages of freezing; the dehydrated floret hasa lower freezing point which enhances its supercooling abilityand the dehydrated peduncle helps to maintain the supercooledstate of the florets. This hypothesis would explain the dependenceon the cooling rate of supercooling in Rhododendron flower buds.Water migration within flower buds was observed in other hardyRhododendron species with some variation in ice formation siteand the quantity of migrated water. The exotherm temperatureof excised florets was inversely proportional to their watercontent. Dehydration of flower buds by wind at 0°C alsoenhanced their supercooling ability. Mechanisms of freezingavoidance by supercooling in Rhododendron flower buds and therelationship of supercooling to freezing tolerance are discussed. ¹ Contribution No. 2254 from the Institute of Low TemperatureScience ² This is a revised form of the master's thesis of the seniorauthor (M.I.) which is cited in the present and previous papers(Sakai 1979a, b, etc.). (Received August 11, 1980; Accepted June 1, 1981)     

Supercooling ability of Rhododendron flower buds in relation to cooling rate and cold hardiness

The freezing process and supercooling ability in flower budsof 11 native Rhododendron species were examined with referenceto the cooling rate and cold hardiness by differential thermalanalysis. The freezing patterns of the excised whole buds variedwith the season: in autumn, buds froze as whole units, whilein winter, freezing was initiated in the scales and propagatedto each floret. The supercooling ability of florets was enhancedduring winter. The freezing patterns in winter buds were stronglyinfluenced by the cooling rate (1 to 30°C/hr). Althoughthe first exotherm in scales occurred at –5 to –10°Gand was rate-independent, the occurrence of several floret exothermsshifted considerably to lower subzero temperatures at slowerrates. The most reliable cooling rate for testing maximum supercoolingability was l°C/hr. The exotherm in florets of hardier speciesoccurred at –20 to –25°C and at –7 to–20°C for less hardy ones, and were well correlatedwith their killing temperatures. Water relations within budtissues in response to freezing are briefly discussed. (Received June 26, 1980; )     

Supercooling ability of Rhododendron flower buds in relation to cooling rate and cold hardiness

The freezing process and supercooling ability in flower budsof 11 native Rhododendron species were examined with referenceto the cooling rate and cold hardiness by differential thermalanalysis. The freezing patterns of the excised whole buds variedwith the season: in autumn, buds froze as whole units, whilein winter, freezing was initiated in the scales and propagatedto each floret. The supercooling ability of florets was enhancedduring winter. The freezing patterns in winter buds were stronglyinfluenced by the cooling rate (1 to 30°C/hr). Althoughthe first exotherm in scales occurred at –5 to –10°Gand was rate-independent, the occurrence of several floret exothermsshifted considerably to lower subzero temperatures at slowerrates. The most reliable cooling rate for testing maximum supercoolingability was l°C/hr. The exotherm in florets of hardier speciesoccurred at –20 to –25°C and at –7 to–20°C for less hardy ones, and were well correlatedwith their killing temperatures. Water relations within budtissues in response to freezing are briefly discussed. (Received June 26, 1980; )     

Supercooling in overwintering azalea flower buds

Differential thermal analysis and nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy experiments on whole flower buds and excised floral primordia of azalea (Rhododendron kosterianum, Schneid.) proved that supercooling is the mode of freezing resistance (avoidance) of azalea flower primordia. Increase in the linewidth of nuclear magnetic resonance spectra for water upon thawing supports the view that injury to the primordia occurs at the moment of freezing. Nonliving primordia freeze at the same temperatures as living primordia, indicating that morphological features of primordial tissues are a key factor in freezing avoidance of dormant azalea flower primordia. Differential thermal analyses was used to study the relationship of cooling rate to the freezing points of floral primordia in whole flower buds. At a cooling rate of 8.5 C per hour, primordia in whole buds froze at about the same subfreezing temperatures as did excised primordia cooled at 37 C per hour. At more rapid cooling rates primordia in intact buds froze at higher temperatures.     

Freezing of water in red-osier dogwood stems in relation to cold hardiness

Studies of stem water in red-osier dogwood (Cornus stolonifera Michx.) using nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy indicated that most freezing occurs at temperatures above −30 C in cold-hardy and tender stems. Hardy and tender stems had about the same amount of unfrozen water at −40 C (0.28 gram of water per gram dry weight). When hardy stems were slowly cooled below −20 C, the temperature below which little additional freezing occurs, they survived direct immersion in liquid N₂ (−196 C). Fully hardy samples not slowly precooled to at least −15 C did not survive direct immersion in liquid N₂. The results support the hypothesis that cooling rate is an unimportant factor in tissue survival at and below temperatures where there is little freezable water.     

Disruption of an Ice-nucleation Barrier in Cold Hardy Azalea Buds by Sublethal Heat Stress

Ice nucleating barriers of undetermined composition are knownto occur in floral buds of several cold hardy species, includingAzalea. Fluorescence microscopy indicated the presence of phenolic-nchareas within hardy Azalea flower buds, which could be ice barriers.Hardy buds were subjected to a sublethal heat stress of 45 °Cfor 2 h to disrupt barrier integrity. Two hours after treatmentthe low temperature exotherms (LTEs) of flowers were observedusing differential thermal analysis (DTA). The LTEs of budsexposed to heat stress were either fewer in number and/or occurredat higher temperatures than in controls. Visual assay of theflowers following DTA confirmed that heat-stressed flowers werekilled at higher temperatures than control flowers. Heat-stressedbuds also have lower resultant hardiness compared to controlsas demonstrated by controlled freezing experiments. Acclimation, phenolics, resistance, stress     

Cryo-scanning electron microscopic study on freezing behaviors of tissue cells in dormant buds of larch (Larix kaempferi)

The freezing behavior of dormant buds in larch, especially at the cellular level, was examined by a Cryo-SEM. The dormant buds exhibited typical extraorgan freezing. Extracellular ice crystals accumulated only in basal areas of scales and beneath crown tissues, areas in which only these living cells had thick walls unlike other tissue cells. By slow cooling (5 °C/day) of dormant buds to −50 °C, all living cells in bud tissues exhibited distinct shrinkage without intracellular ice formation detectable by Cryo-SEM. However, the recrystallization experiment of these slowly cooled tissue cells, which was done by further freezing of slowly cooled buds with LN and then rewarming to −20 °C, confirmed that some of the cells in the leaf primordia, shoot primordia and apical meristem, areas in which cells had thin walls and in which no extracellular ice accumulated, lost freezable water with slow cooling to −30 °C, indicating ability of these cells to adapt by extracellular freezing, whereas other cells in these tissues retained freezable water with slow cooling even to −50 °C, indicating adaptation of these cells by deep supercooling. On the other hand, all cells in crown tissues and in basal areas of scales, areas in which cells had thick walls and in which large masses of ice accumulated, had the ability to adapt by extracellular freezing. It is thought that the presence of two types of cells exhibiting different freezing adaptation abilities within a bud tissue is quite unique and may reflect sophisticated freezing adaptation mechanisms in dormant buds.     

Characteristics of winter hardiness in extremely hardy twigs of woody plants

Lethal intracellular freezing rarely occurs in extremely hardytwigs, such as white birch, poplar and willow, especially whenthey are prefrozen to –15 or –20?C. These prefrozentwigs survive subsequent rapid cooling in air at – 150?C,and immersion in liquid nitrogen. The winter hardiness of thesetwigs remains stable throughout winter. Negligible changes inhardiness occur with environmental temperature fluctuations.In these twigs and in most of the hardy twig cortex, water iseasily frozen out extracellularly at temperatures as high as–15 to – 30?C. Below this range the intensity ofcold and the cooling rate does not seem to cause injury to thesetwigs. The general applicability of hypotheses proposed by Russianworkers and by Weiser on hardening and injury below –30?Cis discussed. ¹Contribution No. 1199 from The Institute of Low TemperatureScience. (Received July 17, 1972; )     

Complex bud architecture and cell‐specific chemical patterns enable supercooling of Picea abies bud primordia

Bud primordia of Picea abies, despite a frozen shoot, stay ice free down to ?50 °C by a mechanism termed supercooling whose biophysical and biochemical requirements are poorly understood. Bud architecture was assessed by 3D—reconstruction, supercooling and freezing patterns by infrared video thermography, freeze dehydration and extraorgan freezing by water potential measurements, and cell‐specific chemical patterns by Raman microscopy and mass spectrometry imaging. A bowl‐like ice barrier tissue insulates primordia from entrance by intrinsic ice. Water repellent and densely packed bud scales prevent extrinsic ice penetration. At ?18 °C, break‐down of supercooling was triggered by intrinsic ice nucleators whereas the ice barrier remained active. Temperature‐dependent freeze dehydration (?0.1 MPa K^?1) caused accumulation of extraorgan ice masses that by rupture of the shoot, pith tissue are accommodated in large voids. The barrier tissue has exceptionally pectin‐rich cell walls and intercellular spaces, and the cell lumina were lined or filled with proteins, especially near the primordium. Primordial cells close to the barrier accumulate di, tri and tetrasaccharides. Bud architecture efficiently prevents ice penetration, but ice nucleators become active inside the primordium below a temperature threshold. Biochemical patterns indicate a complex cellular interplay enabling supercooling and the necessity for cell‐specific biochemical analysis.     

Reproductive Anatomy of the Grape-vine (Vitis vinifera L.): Origin and Development of the Anlage and its Derivatives

The origin and development of anlagen (undifferentiated primordia),inflorescences, tendrils and flowers in the grape cv. Shirazhas been investigated by scanning electron microscopy. Anlagenarise terminally by bisection of the apex of the so-called latentbud. The axis of the latent bud is continued by the originalapex and anlagen are displaced laterally. Micrographs presentedhere favour the interpretation of the grape-vine shoot as amonopodium. Anlagen formed distal to the 10th node of container grown vinesformed inflorescence primordia when plants were grown at hightemperatures (33°C day-28°C night). At lower temperatures(21°C day, 16°C night or 18°Cday, 13°C night)anlagen formed distal to the 10th node grew into tendril primordia.At basal nodes anlagen gave rise to shoot primordia. Each branchof the highly-divided inflorescence primordium of Shiraz formsfive flower primordia. Flower development is discussed.     

Survival of carnation (Dianthus caryophyllus L.) shoot apices frozen to the temperature of liquid nitrogen

Effects of cooling and rewarming rates on the survival of carnationshoot apices frozen to the temperature of liquid nitrogen wereinvestigated. Ten percent dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO), alone orin combination with 5% glucose, sucrose or sorbitol was mosteffective as a cryoprotectant for carnation shoot apices. Theshoot apices survived slow freezing at about –70?C inthe presence of 10% DMSO. About 80% of the shoot apices survivedfreezing at the temperature of liquid nitrogen after prefreezingat –50?C or below, regardless of the rewarming rates.Shoot apices in the presence of 10% DMSO were cooled at differentrates then rewarmed rapidly. The survival rate gradually decreasedto zero as the cooling rate increased from about 0.5?C/min to50?C/min. At cooling rates higher than 50?C/min, no survivalwas observed even at 5?10⁴?C/min. However, in apices prefrozenat –15?C or below then cooled ultrarapidly at 10⁴?C/min,all remained alive with subsequent rapid rewarming. These apicesdeveloped normal young plants. This ultrarapid cooling methodcombined with prefreezing seems to be useful for the cryopreservationof shoot apices from various plants. ¹Contribution No. 2207 from the Institute of Low TemperatureScience, Hokkaido University. This work was supported in partby a Grant-in-Aid (No. 434035) for Scientific Research fromthe Ministry of Education, Science and Culture. (Received November 13, 1979; )     

Supercooling Ability, Water Content and Hardiness of Rhododendron Flower Buds during Cold Acclimation and Deacclimation

The relationship between supercooling ability and water contentand killing temperature of flower buds during cold acclimationand deacclimation were studied using R. kiusianum and R. x akebono.The occurrence of multiple floret exotherms and their shiftto a narrow range at lower subzero temperatures, as well asthe marked decrease of florets water content, were observedas the symptoms of cold acclimation occuring in flower budsfrom fall to winter, and vice versa in spring buds during deacclimation.In R. kiusianum, the fully acclimated period was from Novemberto March and two months longer than that of R. x akebono. Thesupercooling ability of the former was about –25°Cand about –20°C in the latter. Although the watermigration within bud tissues during the freezing process wasdetermined in the acclimated and deacclimated buds for R. xakebono, no significant water changes could be observed, evenin the acclimated buds. Thus, it is conceivable that deep supercoolingin florets may result not necessarily from water migration fromflorets and bud axes to scales in response to freezing, butfrom low water content in situ of cold-acclimated or artificiallydehydrated flower buds. (Received July 29, 1981; Accepted October 12, 1981)     

The Freezing Response of an Arctic Cushion Plant, Saxifraga caespitosa L.: Acclimation, Freezing Tolerance and Ice Nucleation

Cold hardiness in actively growing plants of Saxifraga caespitosaL., an arctic and subarctic cushion plant, was examined. Plantscollected from subarctic and arctic sites were cultivated ina phytotron at temperatures of 3, 9, 12 and 21 °C undera 24-h photoperiod, and examined for freezing tolerance usingcontrolled freezing at a cooling rate of 3–4 °C eitherin air or in moist sand. Post-freezing injury was assessed byvisual inspection and with chlorophyll fluorescence, which appearedto be well suited for the evaluation of injury in Saxifragaleaves. Freezing of excised leaves in moist sand distinguishedwell among the various treatments, but the differences werepartly masked by significant supercooling when the tissue wasfrozen in air. Excised leaves, meristems, stem tissue and flowerssupercooled to –9 to –15 °C, but in rosettesand in intact plants ice nucleation was initiated at –4to –7 °C. The arctic plants tended to be more coldhardy than the subarctic plants, but in plants from both locationscold hardiness increased significantly with decreasing growthtemperature. Plants grown at 12 °C or less developed resistanceto freezing, and excised leaves of arctic Saxifraga grown at3 °C survived temperatures down to about –20 °C.Exposure to –3 °C temperature for up to 5 d did notsignificantly enhance the hardiness obtained at 3 °C. Whenwhole plants of arctic Saxifraga were frozen, with roots protectedfrom freezing, they survived –15 °C and –25°C when cultivated at 12 and 3 °C, respectively, althougha high percentage of the leaves were killed. The basal levelof freezing tolerance maintained in these plants throughoutperiods of active growth may have adaptive significance in subarcticand arctic environments. Saxifraga caespitosa L., arctic, chlorophyll fluorescence, cold acclimation, cushion plant, freezing stress, freezing tolerance, ice nucleation, supercooling     

The Potential for Newly-Germinated Cabbage Seed Survival and Storage at Sub-Zero Temperatures

The moisture content of newly germinated cabbage seed (radicles1 05 mm long) was reduced to 14% of f.wt without loss of viability.As the moisture content was reduced below 45%, the temperatureat which the germinated seeds froze, and therefore died, decreasedprogressively to a minimum of –34 C at 19% moisture content.No freezing exotherms were recorded in seeds with moisture contentsbelow 19%. Seeds with a moisture content between 14 and 16%maintained viability for at least 1 week when cooled at 26C.min^–1to –20 C and held at this temperature, indicating thepotential for prolonged storage of these low-moisture-contentgerminated (LMCG) seeds. Brassica oleracea, cabbage, germinated seed, seed storage, fluid drilling, freezing exotherm, thermal analysis     

Freezing tolerance, protein composition, and abscisic acid localization and content of pea epicotyl, shoot, and root tissue 3

The freezing tolerance of many plants, such as pea (Pisum sativum),is increased by exposure to low temperature or abscisic acidtreatment, although the physiological basis of this phenomenonis poorly understood. The freezing tolerance of pea shoot tips,root tips, and epicotyl tissue was tested after cold acclimationat 2C, dehydration/rehydration, applications of 10^–4M abscisic acid (ABA), and deacclimation at 25C. Tests wereconducted using the cultivar ‘Alaska’, an ABA-deficientmutant ‘wil’, and its ‘wildtype’. Freezinginjury was determined graphically as the temperature that caused50% injury (T₅₀) from electrical conductivity. Endogenous ABAwas measured using an indirect enzyme-linked immunosorbant assay,and novel proteins were detected using 2-dimensional polyacrylamidegel electrophoresis. The maximum decrease in T₅₀ for root tissuewas 1C for all genotypes, regardless of treatment. For ‘Alaska’shoot tips and epicotyl tissue, exogenous ABA increased thefreezing tolerance by –1.5 to –4.0C, while coldtreatment increased the freezing tolerance by –7.5 to–14.8C. Cold treatment increased the freezing toleranceof shoot tips by –9 and –15C for ‘wil’and ‘wild-type’, respectively. Cold acclimationincreased endogenous ABA concentrations in ‘Alaska’shoot tips and epicotyls 3- to 4-fold. Immunogold labeling increasednoticeably in the nucleus and cytoplasm of the epicotyl after7 d at 2C and was greatest after 30 d at the time of maximumfreezing tolerance and soluble ABA concentration. Cold treatmentinduced the production of seven, three, and two proteins inshoot, epicotyl, and root tissue of ‘Alaska’, respectively.In ‘Alaska’ shoot tissue, five out of seven novelproteins accumulated in response to both ABA and cold treatment.However, only a 24 kDa protein was produced in ‘wil’and ‘wild-type’ shoot and epicotyl tissues aftercold treatment. Abscisic acid and cold treatment additivelyincreased the freezing tolerance of pea epicotyl and shoot tissuesthrough apparently independent mechanisms that both resultedin the production of a 24 kDa protein. Key words: Pisum sativum, cold acclimation, immuno-localization     

Freeze Desiccation: a Second Mechanism for the Survival of Hydrated Lettuce (Lactuca sativa L.) Seed at Sub-zero Temperatures

Differential Thermal Analysis of hydrated lettuce cv. GreatLakes achenes using a rapid cooling rate (20 °C h^–1)produced two exotherms per achene. Both exotherms representedthe freezing of supercooled water. The high temperature exothermoccurred at –93 °C and was produced by freezing ofwater inside the pericarp but exterior to the endosperm. Thetemperature at which it occurred could be altered by the additionof nucleating agents. The low temperature exotherm produced by freezing of the embryooccurred at –162 °C and marked the death of the seed.Its temperature was not changed by the addition of nucleatingagents but its occurrence required the structural integrityof the endosperm. At low cooling rates (1 and 2 °C h^–1)low temperature exotherms were not recorded and samples removedat –25 °C had high viability. Slow cooling causeda redistribution of water within the seed whereby ice formingoutside the endosperm caused desiccation of the embryo and preventedits freezing. A mechanism is proposed, in terms of established supercoolingand nucleation theory, to explain the observed results and thevalue of freeze tolerance to the species in its natural habitatis discussed. Cooling rate, differential thermal analysis, freezing avoidance, Lactuca sativa L., lettuce, seed, supercooling, water migration     

Freezing Events within Overwintering Buds of Blackcurrant (Ribes nigrum L.)

Overwintering buds of blackcurrant cultivars 'Ben Lomond' and'Ben More' were examined by differential thermal analysis (DTA).Photographic evidence relates the first (primary) exotherm tothe freezing of water in the basal pith and bud scales. Thenumber of secondary exotherms either matched, or was fewer than,the number of floral racemes within the bud. There is evidencein the structure of the secondary exotherms that the freezingof individual primordia was being recorded.Copyright 1993, 1999Academic Press Differential thermal analysis, freezing injury, buds, Ribes nigrum, blackcurrant