Did protein kinase regulatory mechanisms evolve through elaboration of a simple structural component?

Statistical analysis of the functional constraints acting on eukaryotic protein kinases (EPKs) and on distantly related kinases suggests that EPK regulatory mechanisms evolved around an ancient structural component whose most distinctive features include the HxD-motif adjoining the catalytic loop, the F-helix, an F-helix aspartate, and the DFG-motif adjoined to the activation loop. The HxD-histidine constitutes a convergence point for signal integration, as conserved interactions link it to key catalytic residues, to the F-helix aspartate, and to both ends of the DFG-motif. These and other conserved features appear to be associated with DFG conformational changes and with coordinated movements possibly associated with phosphate transfer and ADP release. The EPKs have acquired structural features that link this core component to likely substrate-interacting regions at either end of the F-helix (most notably involving an F-helix tryptophan) and to three regions undergoing conformational changes upon kinase activation: the activation segment, the C-helix, and the nucleotide-binding pocket.     

Different conformational changes within the F-helix occur during serpin folding, polymerization, and proteinase inhibition

The intrinsic metastability of the serpin native state is the thermodynamic driving force for both proteinase inhibition and the formation of inactive polymers. A number of mechanisms has been proposed to explain how both these conformational changes are achieved. However, one aspect that has received little attention is the movement of the F-helix, which physically impedes both these events. We have applied a protein engineering approach to investigate the conformational changes of this helix during proteinase inhibition, serpin folding, and polymerization. We systematically mutated two highly conserved hydrophobic residues on the F-helix, V161 and I157, and in addition, removed a hydrogen bond between D149 and the first turn of the helix. Our data demonstrate that while all three interactions are important for the stability and folding of the molecule, their contribution during inhibition and polymerization differ. The presence of I157 is crucial to all conformational changes as its loss results in inactivation of the serpin and rapid polymerization. The replacement of D149 does not affect activity but significantly increases the polymerization rate. The interactions formed by V161 play an important role only in maintaining the native conformation. Taken together, these data suggest that the F-helix undergoes a reversible conformational change in both its N- and C-termini during proteinase inhibition only the C-terminus undergoes changes during polymerization, but there is a global change required for folding.     

Evolution of the eukaryotic protein kinases as dynamic molecular switches

Protein kinases have evolved in eukaryotes to be highly dynamic molecular switches that regulate a plethora of biological processes. Two motifs, a dynamic activation segment and a GHI helical subdomain, distinguish the eukaryotic protein kinases (EPKs) from the more primitive eukaryotic-like kinases. The EPKs are themselves highly regulated, typically by phosphorylation, and this allows them to be rapidly turned on and off. The EPKs have a novel hydrophobic architecture that is typically regulated by the dynamic assembly of two hydrophobic spines that is usually mediated by the phosphorylation of an activation loop phosphate. Cyclic AMP-dependent protein kinase (protein kinase A (PKA)) is used as a prototype to exemplify these features of the PKA superfamily. Specificity in PKA signalling is achieved in large part by packaging the enzyme as inactive tetrameric holoenzymes with regulatory subunits that then are localized to macromolecular complexes in close proximity to dedicated substrates by targeting scaffold proteins. In this way, the cell creates discrete foci that most likely represent the physiological environment for cyclic AMP-mediated signalling.     

Defining the conserved internal architecture of a protein kinase

Protein kinases constitute a large protein family of important regulators in all eukaryotic cells. All of the protein kinases have a similar bilobal fold, and their key structural features have been well studied. However, the recent discovery of non-contiguous hydrophobic ensembles inside the protein kinase core shed new light on the internal organization of these molecules. Two hydrophobic “spines” traverse both lobes of the protein kinase molecule, providing a firm but flexible connection between its key elements. The spine model introduces a useful framework for analysis of intramolecular communications, molecular dynamics, and drug design.     

Probing the role of the F-helix in serpin stability through a single tryptophan substitution

Serpins form loop-sheet polymers through the formation of a partially folded intermediate. Through mutagenesis and biophysical analysis, we have probed the conformational stability of the F-helix, demonstrating that it is almost completely unfolded in the intermediate state. The replacement of Tyr160 on the F-helix of alpha1-antitrypsin to alanine results in the loss of a conserved hydrogen bond that dramatically reduces the stability of the protein to both heat and solvent denaturation, indicating the importance of Tyr160 in the stability of the molecule. The mutation of Tyr160 to a tryptophan residue, within a fluorescently silent variant of alpha1-antitrypsin, results in a fully active, stable serpin. Fluorescence analysis of the equilibrium unfolding behavior of this variant indicates that the F-helix is highly disrupted in the intermediate conformation. Iodide quenching experiments demonstrate that the tryptophan residue is exposed to a similar extent in both the intermediate and unfolded states. Cumulatively, these data indicate that the F-helix plays an important role in controlling the early conformational changes involved in alpha1-antitrypsin unfolding. The implications of these data on both alpha1-antitrypsin function and misfolding are discussed.     

Proteomic analysis of kinase inhibitor selectivity and function

Small molecule inhibitors of protein kinases have become highly popular tools in signal transduction research, despite the fact that rather limited data about their respective selectivities have been available. We established an efficient chemical proteomics method to characterize the cellular targets of the widely used inhibitor SB 203580, which was deemed to be rather specific for p38 kinase. Our results revealed several protein kinases as high affinity targets of SB 203580 and therefore imply a far more complicated cellular mode of action of this inhibitor than previously assumed. This raises the important question whether a lack of selectivity is inherent to many other "specific" inhibitors of protein kinases and warrants their evaluation employing experimental approaches adapted from our described proteomic technique.     

A 3-phosphoinositide-dependent protein kinase-1 (PDK1) docking site is required for the phosphorylation of protein kinase Czeta (PKCzeta ) and PKC-related kinase 2 by PDK1

Members of the AGC subfamily of protein kinases including protein kinase B, p70 S6 kinase, and protein kinase C (PKC) isoforms are activated and/or stabilized by phosphorylation of two residues, one that resides in the T-loop of the kinase domain and the other that is located C-terminal to the kinase domain in a region known as the hydrophobic motif. Atypical PKC isoforms, such as PKCzeta, and the PKC-related kinases, like PRK2, are also activated by phosphorylation of their T-loop site but, instead of possessing a phosphorylatable Ser/Thr in their hydrophobic motif, contain an acidic residue. The 3-phosphoinositide-dependent protein kinase (PDK1) activates many members of the AGC subfamily of kinases in vitro, including PKCzeta and PRK2 by phosphorylating the T-loop residue. In the present study we demonstrate that the hydrophobic motifs of PKCzeta and PKCiota, as well as PRK1 and PRK2, interact with the kinase domain of PDK1. Mutation of the conserved residues of the hydrophobic motif of full-length PKCzeta, full-length PRK2, or PRK2 lacking its N-terminal regulatory domain abolishes or significantly reduces the ability of these kinases to interact with PDK1 and to become phosphorylated at their T-loop sites in vivo. Furthermore, overexpression of the hydrophobic motif of PRK2 in cells prevents the T-loop phosphorylation and thus inhibits the activation of PRK2 and PKCzeta. These findings indicate that the hydrophobic motif of PRK2 and PKCzeta acts as a "docking site" enabling the recruitment of PDK1 to these substrates. This is essential for their phosphorylation by PDK1 in cells.     

Computational modeling of allosteric communication reveals organizing principles of mutation-induced signaling in ABL and EGFR kinases

The emerging structural information about allosteric kinase complexes and the growing number of allosteric inhibitors call for a systematic strategy to delineate and classify mechanisms of allosteric regulation and long-range communication that control kinase activity. In this work, we have investigated mechanistic aspects of long-range communications in ABL and EGFR kinases based on the results of multiscale simulations of regulatory complexes and computational modeling of signal propagation in proteins. These approaches have been systematically employed to elucidate organizing molecular principles of allosteric signaling in the ABL and EGFR multi-domain regulatory complexes and analyze allosteric signatures of the gate-keeper cancer mutations. We have presented evidence that mechanisms of allosteric activation may have universally evolved in the ABL and EGFR regulatory complexes as a product of a functional cross-talk between the organizing αF-helix and conformationally adaptive αI-helix and αC-helix. These structural elements form a dynamic network of efficiently communicated clusters that may control the long-range interdomain coupling and allosteric activation. The results of this study have unveiled a unifying effect of the gate-keeper cancer mutations as catalysts of kinase activation, leading to the enhanced long-range communication among allosterically coupled segments and stabilization of the active kinase form. The results of this study can reconcile recent experimental studies of allosteric inhibition and long-range cooperativity between binding sites in protein kinases. The presented study offers a novel molecular insight into mechanistic aspects of allosteric kinase signaling and provides a quantitative picture of activation mechanisms in protein kinases at the atomic level.     

Conserved spatial patterns across the protein kinase family

Protein kinases are a large family of enzymes heavily involved in signal transduction, regulation of metabolism, and control of cell growth and differentiation. These functions require precise recognition of widely diverse signals and substrates, and very detailed control of protein kinase activity. Large molecules interact primarily through recognition of surface features. Comparison of surfaces is complicated by both sequence diversity and conformational variability, including multiple possible rotameric states of side chains. We used a recently developed method of protein surface comparison to compare different serine/threonine and tyrosine kinases. As we have shown, two hydrophobic cores inside a protein kinase molecule are connected by a unique formation, called the "spine". It exists only in the active conformation of protein kinases and is dynamically disassembled during the inactivation process. Detection of such structures by any other method was not possible as the residues which comprise the spine do not form any sequence or 3D motifs in a traditional sense.     

Structure of apo-phosphatidylinositol transfer protein alpha provides insight into membrane association

Phosphatidylinositol transfer protein alpha (PITP alpha) is a ubiquitous and highly conserved protein in multicellular eukaryotes that catalyzes the exchange of phospholipids between membranes in vitro and participates in cellular phospholipid metabolism, signal transduction and vesicular trafficking in vivo. Here we report the three-dimensional crystal structure of a phospholipid-free mouse PITP alpha at 2.0 A resolution. The structure reveals an open conformation characterized by a channel running through the protein. The channel is created by opening the phospholipid-binding cavity on one side by displacement of the C-terminal region and a hydrophobic lipid exchange loop, and on the other side by flattening of the central beta-sheet. The relaxed conformation is stabilized at the proposed membrane association site by hydrophobic interactions with a crystallographically related molecule, creating an intimate dimer. The observed open conformer is consistent with a membrane-bound state of PITP and suggests a mechanism for membrane anchoring and the presentation of phosphatidylinositol to kinases and phospholipases after its extraction from the membrane. Coordinates have been deposited in the Protein Data Bank (accession No. 1KCM).     

Structural characterization of the N-terminal kinase-interacting domain of an Hsp90-cochaperone Cdc37 by CD and solution NMR spectroscopy

Cdc37 is a protein kinase-targeting molecular chaperone, which cooperates with Hsp90 to assist the folding, assembly and maturation of various signaling kinases. It consists of three distinct domains: the N-terminal, middle, and C-terminal domain. While the middle domain is an Hsp90-binding domain, the N-terminal domain is recognized as a kinase-interacting domain. The N-terminal domain contains a well-conserved Ser residue at position 13, and the phosphorylation at this site has been shown to be a prerequisite for the interaction between Cdc37 and signaling kinases. Although the phosphorylation of Ser13 might induce some conformational change in Cdc37 molecule, little is known about the structure of the N-terminal domain of Cdc37. We examined the structural and dynamic properties of several fragment proteins corresponding to the N-terminal region of Cdc37 by circular dichroism and solution NMR spectroscopy. We found that the N-terminal domain of Cdc37 exhibits highly dynamic structure, and it exists in the equilibrium between α-helical and more disordered structures. We also found that phosphorylation at Ser13 did not significantly change the overall structure of N-terminal fragment protein of Cdc37. The results suggested that more complicated mechanisms might be necessary to explain the phosphorylation-activated interaction of Cdc37 with various kinases.     

An Experimentally Based Computer Search Identifies Unstructured Membrane-binding Sites in Proteins: APPLICATION TO CLASS I MYOSINS, PAKS, AND CARMIL

Programs exist for searching protein sequences for potential membrane-penetrating segments (hydrophobic regions) and for lipid-binding sites with highly defined tertiary structures, such as PH, FERM, C2, ENTH, and other domains. However, a rapidly growing number of membrane-associated proteins (including cytoskeletal proteins, kinases, GTP-binding proteins, and their effectors) bind lipids through less structured regions. Here, we describe the development and testing of a simple computer search program that identifies unstructured potential membrane-binding sites. Initially, we found that both basic and hydrophobic amino acids, irrespective of sequence, contribute to the binding to acidic phospholipid vesicles of synthetic peptides that correspond to the putative membrane-binding domains of Acanthamoeba class I myosins. Based on these results, we modified a hydrophobicity scale giving Arg- and Lys-positive, rather than negative, values. Using this basic and hydrophobic scale with a standard search algorithm, we successfully identified previously determined unstructured membrane-binding sites in all 16 proteins tested. Importantly, basic and hydrophobic searches identified previously unknown potential membrane-binding sites in class I myosins, PAKs and CARMIL (capping protein, Arp2/3, myosin I linker; a membrane-associated cytoskeletal scaffold protein), and synthetic peptides and protein domains containing these newly identified sites bound to acidic phospholipids in vitro.     

PKA: Lessons learned after twenty years

The first protein kinase structure, solved in 1991, revealed the fold that is shared by all members of the eukaryotic protein kinase superfamily and showed how the conserved sequence motifs cluster mostly around the active site. This structure of the PKA catalytic (C) subunit showed also how a single phosphate integrated the entire molecule. Since then the EPKs have become a major drug target, second only to the G-protein coupled receptors. Although PKA provided a mechanistic understanding of catalysis that continues to serve as a prototype for the family, by comparing many active and inactive kinases we subsequently discovered a hydrophobic spine architecture that is a characteristic feature of all active kinases. The ways in which the regulatory spine is dynamically assembled is the defining feature of each protein kinase. Protein kinases have thus evolved to be molecular switches, like the G-proteins, and unlike metabolic enzymes which have evolved to be efficient catalysis. PKA also shows how the dynamic tails surround the core and serve as essential regulatory elements. The phosphorylation sites in PKA, introduced both co- and post-translationally, are very stable. The resulting C-subunit is then packaged as an inhibited holoenzyme with cAMP-binding regulatory (R) subunits so that PKA activity is regulated exclusively by cAMP, not by the dynamic turnover of an activation loop phosphate. We could not understand activation and inhibition without seeing structures of R:C complexes; however, to appreciate the structural uniqueness of each R₂:C₂ holoenzyme required solving structures of tetrameric holoenzymes. It is these tetrameric holoenzymes that are localized to discrete sites in the cell, typically by A Kinase Anchoring Proteins where they create discrete foci for PKA signaling. Understanding these dynamic macromolecular complexes is the challenge that we now face. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Inhibitors of Protein Kinases (2012).     

Transient movement of helix F revealed by photo-induced inactivation by reaction of a bulky SH-reagent to cysteine-introduced pharaonis phoborhodopsin (sensory rhodopsin II).

Pharaonis phoborhodopsin (ppR) is a photosensor of negative phototaxis in Natronomonas (Natronobacterium) pharaonis, an alkalophilic halophile. This protein has seven transmembrane helices into which a chromophore, all-trans retinal, binds to a specific lysine residue (located in helix G)via a protonated Schiff base. Various mutants were engineered to have a single cysteine in the F-helix. In the presence of a bulky fluorescent SH-reagent, MIANS, (2-(4'-maleimidylanilino)naphthalene-6-sulfonic acid, illumination decreased the photoreactivity or flash-yield (absorbance deflection immediately after the flash) of the L163C ppR mutant (in which Leu-163 was replaced with Cys) without changing the photocycling rate. The fluorescence of the isolated protein increased with increasing illumination. These observations suggest that during photocycling, the space around Cys-163 in the F-helix might open, permitting reaction with the relatively large molecule. This reaction occurred only at the M-state and not at the O-state. The implications are discussed.     

Unique MAP Kinase binding sites

Map kinases are drug targets for autoimmune disease, cancer, and apoptosis-related diseases. Drug discovery efforts have developed MAP kinase inhibitors directed toward the ATP binding site and neighboring "DFG-out" site, both of which are targets for inhibitors of other protein kinases. On the other hand, MAP kinases have unique substrate and small molecule binding sites that could serve as inhibition sites. The substrate and processing enzyme D-motif binding site is present in all MAP kinases, and has many features of a good small molecule binding site. Further, the MAP kinase p38alpha has a binding site near its C-terminus discovered in crystallographic studies. Finally, the MAP kinases ERK2 and p38alpha have a second substrate binding site, the FXFP binding site that is exposed in active ERK2 and the D-motif peptide induced conformation of MAP kinases. Crystallographic evidence of these latter two binding sites is presented.     

Analysis of micronuclear, macronuclear and cDNA sequences encoding the regulatory subunit of cAMP-dependent protein kinase of Euplotes octocarinatus: evidence for a ribosomal frameshift

We have isolated and characterized the micronuclear gene encoding the regulatory subunit of cAMP-dependent protein kinase of the ciliated protozoan Euplotes octocarinatus, as well as its macronuclear version and the corresponding cDNA. Analyses of the sequences revealed that the micronuclear gene contains one small 69-bp internal eliminated sequence (IES) that is removed during macronuclear development. The IES is located in the 5'-noncoding region of the micronuclear gene and is flanked by a pair of tetranucleotide 5'-TACA-3' direct repeats. The macronuclear DNA molecule carrying this gene is approximately 1400 bp long and is amplified to about 2000 copies per macronucleus. Sequence analysis suggests that the expression of this gene requires a +1 ribosomal frameshift. The deduced protein shares 31% identity with the cAMP-dependent protein kinase type I regulatory subunit of Homo sapiens, and 53% identity with the regulatory subunit R44 of one of the two cAMP-dependent protein kinases of Paramecium. In addition, it contains two highly conserved cAMP binding sites in the C-terminal domain. The putative autophosphorylation site ARTSV of the regulatory subunit of E. octocarinatus is similar to that of the regulatory subunit R44 of Paramecium but distinct from the consensus motif RRXSZ of other eukaryotic regulatory subunits of cAMP-dependent protein kinases.     

Kinases and Pseudokinases: Lessons from RAF

Protein kinases are thought to mediate their biological effects through their catalytic activity. The large number of pseudokinases in the kinome and an increasing appreciation that they have critical roles in signaling pathways, however, suggest that catalyzing protein phosphorylation may not be the only function of protein kinases. Using the principle of hydrophobic spine assembly, we interpret how kinases are capable of performing a dual function in signaling. Its first role is that of a signaling enzyme (classical kinases; canonical), while its second role is that of an allosteric activator of other kinases or as a scaffold protein for signaling in a manner that is independent of phosphoryl transfer (classical pseudokinases; noncanonical). As the hydrophobic spines are a conserved feature of the kinase domain itself, all kinases carry an inherent potential to play both roles in signaling. This review focuses on the recent lessons from the RAF kinases that effectively toggle between these roles and can be “frozen” by introducing mutations at their hydrophobic spines.     

High affinity targets of protein kinase inhibitors have similar residues at the positions energetically important for binding

Inhibition of protein kinase activity is a focus of intense drug discovery efforts in several therapeutic areas. Major challenges facing the field include understanding of the factors determining the selectivity of kinase inhibitors and the development of compounds with the desired selectivity profile. Here, we report the analysis of sequence variability among high and low affinity targets of eight different small molecule kinase inhibitors (BIRB796, Tarceva, NU6102, Gleevec, SB203580, balanol, H89, PP1). It is observed that all high affinity targets of each inhibitor are found among a relatively small number of kinases, which have similar residues at the specific positions important for binding. The findings are highly statistically significant, and allow one to exclude the majority of kinases in a genome from a list of likely targets for an inhibitor. The findings have implications for the design of novel inhibitors with a desired selectivity profile (e.g. targeted at multiple kinases), the discovery of new targets for kinase inhibitor drugs, comparative analysis of different in vivo models, and the design of "a-la-carte" chemical libraries tailored for individual kinases.     

A role for phosphorylation in the dynamics of keratin intermediate filaments

Keratins undergo highly dynamic events in the epithelial cells that express them. These dynamic changes have been associated with important cell processes. We have studied the possible role of keratin phosphorylation-dephosphorylation processes in the control of these dynamic events. Drugs that affect the protein phosphorylation metabolism (activators or inhibitors of protein kinases or protein phosphatases) have been used in two different dynamic experimental systems. First, the behaviour of keratins after the formation of cell heterokaryons, and second, the assembly of a newly synthesised keratin after transfection into the pre-existing keratin cytoskeleton. The main difference between these two systems stems on the alteration of the amount of keratin polypeptides present in the cells, since in heterokaryons this amount was unaltered whilst in transfection experiments there is an increase due to the presence of the transfected protein. We observed in both systems that the inhibition of protein kinases led to a delayed dynamic behaviour of the keratin polypeptides. On the contrary, the inhibition of protein phosphatases by okadaic acid or the activation of protein kinases by phorbol esters promoted a substantial increase in the kinetics of these processes. Biochemical studies demonstrate that this behavioural changes can be correlated with changes in the phosphorylation state of the keratin polypeptides. As a whole, present results indicate that the highly dynamic properties of the keratin polypeptides can be modulated by phosphorylation.     

Estimation of the maximum change in stability of globular proteins upon mutation of a hydrophobic residue to another of smaller size.

Although the hydrophobic effect is generally considered to be one of the most important forces in stabilizing the folded structure of a globular protein molecule, there is a lack of consensus on the precise magnitude of this effect. The magnitude of the hydrophobic effect is most directly measured by observing the change in stability of a protein molecule when an internal hydrophobic residue is mutated to another of smaller size. Results of such measurements have, however, been confusing because they vary greatly and are generally considerably larger than expected from the transfer free energies of corresponding small molecules. In this article, a thermodynamic argument is presented to show (1) that the variation is mainly due to that in the flexibility of the protein molecule at the site of mutation, (2) that the maximum destabilization occurs when the protein at the site of mutation is rigid, in which case the value of the destabilization is approximately given by the work of cavity formation in water, and (3) that the transfer free energy approximately gives the minimum of the range of variations. The best numerical agreements between the small molecule and the protein systems are obtained when the data from the small molecule system are expressed as the molarity-based standard free energies without other corrections.