Assay for doubled haploid sunflower (Helianthus annuus) plant production by androgenesis: fact or artifact? Part 1. In vitro anther culture

Sunflower anthers placed on solid medium developed calli and embryos after 12 days. Embryogenesis was improved by the addition of 0.1% polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP) that alleviated anther and medium browning. As in other species, genotypic variability was an important parameter in the anther response and a medium genotype interaction was suggested with a different PVP effect depending on the genotype. Embryo germination was largely increased by the successive use of germination media with decreasing sucrose concentrations (10%6%3%). Histological examination of the anthers during the first ten days of culture showed that, under our conditions, the embryos were of somatic origin, arising directly from the anther wall on the outside or inside of the anther loculus, or indirectly from proliferating anther wall- or connective tissue-derived callus. Finally, the ploidy status of 78 embryo-derived plants was determined by Feulgen stain or flow cytometry: all plants were diploid (2n=34).Abbreviations PVP polyvinylpyrrolidone     

Haploid plant regeneration via embryogenesis from anther cultures of Hepatica nobilis

An anther culture technique for the production of haploid plants was developed in Hepatica nobilis. Embryos with bipolar meristem regions were induced from microspores within the cultured anthers. Embryo formation was promoted by first culturing anthers on NN medium (Nitsch and Nitsch, 1969) supplemented with 1% activated charcoal (AC) at 5 or 35°C for a few days and by then incubating them in the dark at 25°C. Pre-culturing anthers at 35°C for 4days (thermal-shock treatment) led to the best embryo formation (45 embryos/Petri dish with 30 anthers). Plant regeneration was achieved by culturing the anther-derived embryos on NN medium without AC at 15°C. Flow cytometric analysis of anther-derived embryos and chromosome counts in regenerated plants showed that they were haploid plants.     

Propagation of Lirlodendron hybrids via somatic embryogenesis

Propagation of hybrids between the Chinese tuliptree (Liriodendron chinense) and the North American yellow-poplar (Liriodendron tulipiferea) could be greatly accelerated with a highly productive somatic embryogenesis system. Flowers were collected from a single Chinese tuliptree and the anthers used for controlled pollinations of 4 yellow-poplar mother trees. Aggregates of samaras resulting from the pollinations were harvested 8 weeks post-pollination. Following surface disinfestation, samaras were dissected and embryos and endosperm were cultured together on a semisolid induction medium containing 9.0 M 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid and 1.1 M benzyladenine. Following 2–3 months on induction medium, an average of 15.6 percent of the explants produced either somatic embryos or proembryogenic masses. Compared to pure yellow-poplar embryogenic cultures, putative hybrid cultures tended not to maintain growth as proembryogenic masses while exposed to auxin, instead proliferating via repetitive embryogenesis as globular-stage embryos. Four to six weeks following transfer of globular embryos to basal medium, mature embryos were produced from the putative hybrid lines. Mature embryos germinated following transfer to basal medium lacking casein hydrolysate. Plantlets survived transfer to potting mix and acclimatization to greenhouse conditions. Verification of the hybrid nature of the embryogenic lines and somatic embryo-derived plantlets was accomplished by Southern hybridization analysis with a species-specific DNA marker.Abbreviations BA benzyladenine - 2,4-d 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid - PEM proembryogenic mass - CH casein hydrolysate - RFLP restricted fragment length polymorphism - CTAB hexadecyltrimethylammonium bromide - TBE Tris-borate-EDTA - SDS sodium dodecylsufate - SSC sodium citrate/chloride     

Selection of embryogenic pollen from cold-treated buds ofNicotiana tabacum var. badischer burley and their development into embryos in cultures

Summary By using density gradient centrifugation, employing 55% percoll and 4% sucrose as suspension medium, it is possible to select embryogenic pollen from buds after cold treatment at 10 °C for 8 or more days. These buds at the uninucleate stage of pollen were collected from plants grown in 8 hours photocycles at 18 °C and supplied with mineral salts. The embryogenic pollen are small, starch-free with a clear cytoplasm whereas large starch-filled ones are nonembryogenic. The embryogenic pollen regularly form embryos at a frequency of 2% on a mineral medium supplemented with glutamine, asparagine and sucrose at pH 6.5.These results demonstrate, for the first time, that it is possible to have embryos in appreciable frequencies in ab initio pollen cultures raised from cold treated anthers.On leave from University of Delhi.     

Interaction of environment and ABA and GA treatments on the maize anther culture response

Treatments designed to influence abscisic acid (ABA) or gibberellin (GA) concentrations were applied to developing tassels of maize (Zea mays L.) plants in different environments or to anthers in culture to determine the effect on formation of embryo-like structures (ELS). Production of ELS was significantly affected in certain environments when ABA, GA₃, ancymidol, or fluridone solutions were pipetted into whorls of field-grown plants approximately 3 days before tassel harvest. In 1996 anthers from 10 M ancymidol-treated plants were most responsive, producing 35 ELS/100 anthers and 50 M GA₃-treated plants were least responsive, producing 12 ELS/100 anthers. In 1997 under hotter, drier conditions, anthers from 50 M GA₃-treated plants were most responsive, producing 20 ELS/100 anthers and those from 50 M ABA-treated plants were least responsive, producing 2.4 ELS/100 anthers. Anthers from growth chamber plants were significantly more responsive when grown in a 16-h than a 12-h photoperiod. With the 16-h photoperiod the response was significantly greater with a 250 M ABA whorl treatment. With the 12-h photoperiod there was no significant effect from whorl treatments. Modification of the culture medium with added ABA, GA₃, ancymidol, or fluridone was generally ineffective, except in 1997 when the response was significantly higher with 1 M ABA added to the culture medium. The results suggest that the maize anther culture response may be influenced by environmental conditions that interact with ABA and GA treatments to donor plants during tassel development.     

Improved plant regeneration from wheat anther and barley microspore culture using phenylacetic acid (PAA)

Summary The effect of the auxin phenylacetic acid (PAA) on wheat anther and on barley anther/microspore culture was investigated. With PAA the induction response was not usually significantly different from controls but a significantly higher number of green plants were produced in wheat anther and barley microspore culture. For wheat anther culture 100 mg/L PAA was beneficial. For barley microspore culture the optimum levels were from 1 to 100 mg/L, depending on genotype. In barley anther culture there were no improvements using PAA. In wheat anther culture, 145 green plants/100 anthers were obtained with cultivar VeeryS, while the average response from twelve F₁ hybrids in the breeding program was 332 green plants/100 anthers. At least 1000 green plants were obtained using isolated microspores from 100 anthers in barley cv. Igri. With cv. Bruce, regeneration occurred only when 100 mg/L PAA was used. The influence of PAA appears at the embryogenic phase of the culture system. The possible mechanisms by which PAA may improve regeneration are discussed.     

Effect of thidiazuron on vegetative tissue-derived somatic embryogenesis and flowering of bamboo Bambusa edulis

Current research on somatic embryogenesis of bamboo uses reproductive tissue as explants. However, it was hard to obtain the explant. Shoots of a local accession (3–4 m high) were used for multiple shoot production. In order to obtain embryogenic callus, nodal and internodal tissues from in vitro plantlets were placed on Murashige and Skoog (MS) medium supplemented with 9.2 M kinetin (KN), 13.6 M 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D), 0.1% (v/v) coconut milk, and 6% (w/v) sucrose. We studied the effects of sucrose and thidiazuron (TDZ) on callus proliferation. Optimal additives to the MS medium for embryogenic callus proliferation were 0.046 M TDZ, 13.6 M 2,4-D and 3% (w/v) sucrose. TDZ also promoted the germination of bamboo somatic embryos. The germination rate of the somatic embryos exceeded 80% on MS-based medium supplemented with 0.455M TDZ. Naphthaleneacetic acid (NAA) reduced germination. Well-developed plantlets were successfully transferred to soil. There was no albino mutant in subsequent culture. In vitro regenerants and potted plants flowered, but no seeds were produced.     

Sex determination in the dioecious Melandrium

Summary Melandrium album (2n=24), a dioecious species with heteromorphic sex chromosomes (XY, males and XX, females), has a strong genetic commitment for sex determination. We report here a procedure for obtaining haploid plants from cultured anthers and show that genotype, pollen stage, cold treatment and certain culture media components are essential for a reproducible yield of embryos. Our procedure increased the number of responsive anthers and not the number of responsive microspores per anther. Most likely, our experimental system allows the recovery of competent microspores, and this on a medium containing either an auxin or a cytokinin. All of the 36 anther-derived plants tested expressed a female phenotypic sex instead of the theoretical one male one female ratio. When analysed cytologically, the plants exhibited the corresponding female genetic sex (one or two X chromosomes).     

Segregation of genetic markers among plants regenerated from cultured anthers of broccoli (Brassica oleracea var. ‘italica’)

Summary An experiment was conducted to determine critical factors in the recovery of embryos from cultured anthers of broccoli (Brassica oleracea var. italica) and to unambiguously distinguish whether embryos were of gametophytic origin. Among factors tested, genotype, genotype x anther developmental stage, and method of anther culture had a distinct impact on embryo recovery, whereas length of anther exposure to the culture medium did not. However, extreme heterogeneity of embryo emergence within and among replications precluded statistical contrasts. Among 762 plants derived from embryos of four independent cultivars, only one was determined to be of sporophytic origin by use of heterozygous codominant isozyme markers. Two of the cultivars tested were heterozygous at two or more loci. While segregation among loci was consistent with previously published linkage data, segregation of alleles was consistently non-random. In all of seven separate cases involving four cultivars, a significant over-representation of the fast-migrating class was observed. It appears, therefore, that populations of plants derived from microspores within cultured anthers of broccoli do not necessarily represent a random gametic array, and that care must be exercised in breeding and genetic applications.     

Variation for improved protein and yield from rice anther culture

Summary The anther culture technique is useful for the recovery of haploids which when doubled provide homozygosity. Additionally, beneficial as well as deleterious genetic and epigenetic changes are promoted by the in vitro procedures. The majority of plants recovered from anther calli of the cultivar Calrose 76 were similar to the starting cultivar but plants regenerated from microspore calli had a wider range of responses than controls for several characteristics. Plants with larger seeds, higher levels of seed protein, shorter stature and more highly tillered than the starting cultivar were obtained from selfed anther-derived plants. The data also support the concept that in vitro procedures including anther culture of specific cultivars of rice promoted the recovery of phenotypes with increased seed storage proteins.Contribution from the U.S. Department of Agriculture, Science and Education, Agricultural Research Service, Plant Physiology Institute, Tissue Culture and Molecular Genetics Laboratory, Room 116, Building 011-A, BARC-West, Beltsville, Maryland 20705, USA     

Plant regeneration through culture of isolated microspores of Triticum aestivum L.

Wheat microspores mechanically isolated from the anthers before culture and isolated from the anthers during the hole culture period in a chemically defined medium resulted in proembryos, embryos and finally plants. Of the four genotypes included, all responded with proembryos, and the two spring wheats Ciano and Walter gave rise to macroscopic embryos and plants. The frequency of embryo regeneration and the frequency of albino plants in both Ciano and Walter was in accordance with previously obtained results with anther culture derived material.Abbreviations 2,4-d 2,4-dichlorophenoxy acetic acid - NAA 1-naphthaleneacetic acid     

Osmotic potential of media affecting green plant percentage in wheat anther culture

The percentage of green plants in anther culture is known to be controlled by the genetics of anther donor materials. The objective of this study was to determine whether components in the culture media also would have a significant influence on the percentage of green plants from wheat anther culture. Anthers of a spring wheat cultivar, Pavon 76, were cultured on potato 4 (P4) induction media with various modifications. Addition of 200 g/l ficoll to the liquid P4 medium significantly increased the percentage of green plants even though the final yield of green plants per 100 anthers was lower than the liquid medium. A higher concentration of maltose (135 g/l) produced significantly higher percentage of green plants than the medium containing 90 g/l maltose or sucrose. These results demonstrate culture medium effects on albinism, indicating that the percentage of green plants in wheat anther culture can be increased by optimizing medium osmotic potential.     

Microspore cultures as donor tissue for the initiation of embryogenic cell suspensions in barley

We have initiated embryogenic cell suspension cultures of barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) Igri from isolated microspore cultures. Data were obtained on the time required for establishment, frequency of establishment, i.e. number of calluses out of the total number of initiations giving rise to suspensions, and embryogenic capacity of the suspension cultures. For comparison, establishment of embryogenic cell suspensions from callus derived from immature zygotic embryos of Igri, Dissa and Golden Promise was also carried out. The results revealed that embryogenic suspension cultures were established in half the time and with a seven-fold higher frequency from microspore cultures than from zygotic embryo-derived calluses. The suspension cultures were still capable of embryo formation after two years. However, only albino plantlets were regenerated. For comparison, long term callus cultures derived from microspores, anthers and zygotic embryos were established. From the anther and zygotic embryo-derived callus cultures green plants were continuously regenerated, whereas the microspore-derived callus cultures lost this ability after the second subculture.     

Initiation and maintenance of long term somatic embryogenesis from anthers and ovaries of Vitis longii ‘Microsperma’

Anthers and ovaries of Vitis longii Microsperma produced embryogenic callus when cultured on solidified Murashige and Skoog medium with 5M 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D) and 1M benzyladenine (BA). The initial callus was short-lived. However, long-term embryogenesis from callus was maintained through serial transfers by careful selection of clustered embryos with subtending callus. Alternatively, long term culture maintenance was through secondary embryogenesis which occurred directly from previously formed embryos on medium lacking growth regulators. Somatic embryos were white, exhibited frequent pluricotyly and tended to be larger than zygotic embryos. Histology of embryogenic callus demonstrated the presence of lipid-like substances and abundant starch. Somatic embryos were attached to callus by narrow to wide suspensor-like structures and possessed typical epidermal, cortical, and vascular tissue. Embryo cells contained abundant lipid-like accumulations but no starch. Embryos germinated when placed on medium containing 1M BA and produced plants of normal appearance.     

Scale-up of somatic embryogenesis in alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.) I subculture and indirect secondary somatic embryogenisis

Three methods of increasing the productivity of somatic embryogenesis in Medicago sativa L. were investigated. In the basic procedure, somatic embryos were initiated from young petioles and carried through several phases: callus formation, suspension culture, selection of the embryogenic fraction by sieving, development, maturation, desiccation and storage. The suspensions were normally separated into three fractions by sieving. Fraction I (<200 m) containing nonembryogenic cells or cell clusters was discarded. Fraction II (200–500 m) consisting of embryogenic cell clusters was collected for embryo development and maturation. Fraction III (over 500 M) containing the mixture of petiole residues with large pieces of calli and globular somatic embryos was usually discarded. Several methods to scale-up the suspension phase were unsuccessful. Direct subculture of the entire suspension by the addition of fresh liquid medium resulted in the loss of embryogenic capacity by the third subculture. Subculture of fraction II decreased embryogenic cell mass, and hence reduced total productivity. The recycling of fraction III back to fresh B₅g liquid medium resulted in high productivity in the first culture but further subculture of this fraction resulted in a rapid decline in the embryogenic capacity.As an alternative, somatic embryos from the first tissue culture cycle were also used as explants for the initiation of secondary embryogenic callus. The embryogenic capacity of these somatic embryo explants declined rapidly as they matured. More than 100 secondary somatic embryos could be induced from embryo explants removed from development medium at 10 days after sieving the suspension, but only 40 somatic embryos were produced from each mature somatic embryo explant, and 13 from desiccated embryos. The secondary somatic embryos were comparable to the primary embryos in quality according to germination tests. The implications of the results to the efficiency of somatic embryo production of Medicago are discussed.Abbreviations ABA abscisic acid - 2,4-d 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid - DAS days after sieving - PPF photosynthetic photon flux density - SE somatic embryo     

Establishment of oil palm cell suspensions and plant regeneration

Primary globular callus from immature zygotic embryos and friable embryogenic tissue derived from mature zygotic embryos were used to establish suspension cultures. Callus cultures were established either on modified Y3 or MS medium containing 475–500 M 2,4-D or 250 M picloram and 0.3% (w/v) activated charcoal. Suspension cultures of both cell lines were established in modified Y3 medium containing 10 M 2,4-D. The establishment of cell suspensions from friable embryogenic tissue took only 2 months, in contrast with suspensions from primary globular callus which took 3–5 months to establish. Embryo differentiation was observed only in cell suspensions derived from the friable embryogenic tissue after plating aliquots on regeneration medium. Germinated embryos were recovered and plantlets were successfully established under greenhouse conditions.Abbreviations CET compact embryogenic tissue - FET friable embryogenic tissue - CIM callus induction medium - PGC primary globular callus - 2,3-D 2,4-dichlorphenoxyacetic acid Y3-Eeuwens' medium - MS Murashige & Skoog medium - PVP-40 polyvinylpyrrolidone - KM Kao & Michayluk vitamins - ABA abscisic acid     

Non-zygotic embryos of Brassica napus L. contain embryo-specific storage proteins

The storage-protein content of non-zygotic and zygotic embryos of B. napus was compared, using antibodies to guantitate 12S storage protein in extracts by rocket immunoelectrophoresis. Non-zygotic embryos were induced from microspores in anther culture and on the hypocotyls of zygotic embryos in culture. All embryo-like structures were found to contain 12S storage protein, whereas preculture anthers, anthers from which embryos had been removed, and regenerated shoots did not have detectable 12S storage protein. In zygotic embryos, 12S storage protein was first detected at the cotyledon stage, but microsporic embryos contained storage protein at the globular and heart stages. Storage protein levels in microsporic and hypocotyl embryos were low relative to those in zygotic embryos. The largest microsporic embryo had a storage protein concentration of 13 g mg^-1 fresh weight, almost 10 times lower than a mature zygotic embryo. Thus, although storage proteins are present in both zygotic and non-zygotic embryos, the timing and extent of accumulation differ.     

A novel type of somatic embryogenesis in Coffea arabica

A novel type of somatic embryogenesis characterized by an efficient and highly synchronized embryo formation was observed in embryogenic callus of Coffea arabica initiated on Murashige and Skoog medium containing kinetin (4 mg/l) and 2,4-D (1 mg/l). It occurs in suspension and goes along with the suppression of High Frequency Somatic Embryo Induction (HFSE). This is achieved by favoring during cultivation senescence-or necrosis-like processes which apparently do not impair the competence for embryogenesis. Since the resulting embryos germinate at a rate of 94.5 % without the need of a maturation step, we propose the term Self-Controlled Somatic Embryogenesis (SCSE).In addition, HFSE was optimized using half-strength liquid medium with 0.1 mg/l kinetin and 0.25 mg/l 2,4-D for proliferation of embryonic tissue, and 2.6 mg/l ABA for maturation of embryos. Yields as well as germination rates of HFSE embryos were markedly lower as compared to SCSE.Abbreviations ABA abscisic acid - BAP 6-benzylaminopurine - 2,4-D 2,4-dichlorophenoxy-acetic acid - NAA 1-naphthaleneacetic acid - HFSE high frequency somatic embryo induction - LFSE low frequency somatic embryo induction - SCSE self-controlled somatic embryogenesis     

Somatic embryogenesis from immature zygotic embryos of oil palm

Immature zygotic embryos at different developmental stages were used for callus induction and regeneration studies. Immature embryos excised from fruits 77, 91, 100, 114, 128, 140 and 193 days after pollination and mature embryos were cultured on modified Y3 medium containing 500 mgl^–1 cysteine, 0.5% (w/v) PVP-40, 500 M 2,4-d and 0.3% (w/v) charcoal. Compact embryogenic tissue began differentiating directly from embryo explants after 2 weeks of culture. The percentage of embryos forming compact embryogenic tissue ranged from 28.6% for 91-day-old embryos to 0% for 140-day-old and older embryos. Friable embryogenic tissue was observed in callus cultures derived from 100-day-old embryos. Although both compact and friable embryogenic tissues were successfully isolated, normal embryo and plantlet development was observed only from friable embryogenic tissue.Abbreviations ABA abscisic acid - 2,4-d 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid - NAA naphthaleneacetic acid - PVP polyvinylpyrollidone     

Morphogenesis from cultured leaf tissue ofSorghum bicolor—The morphogenetic pathways

Summary Immature leaf explants ofSorghum bicolor (L.) Moench can be stimulatedin vitro to form roots, shoots or embryos. When the cultures were maintained with the high 2,4-D level which was essential for optimal culture initiation, the organs or embryos proliferated as suppressed primordia, but they could always be identified by simple histological means. Perivascular cells of comparatively old but still immature leaf sheath regions appeared to be strongly determined to form adventitious roots or root-type callus cultures. We have evidence that the embryogenic tissue, and ultimately the embryos, are of multicellular origin. This ontogeny of the embryos appears to be contradictory to the often stated view that somatic embryos generally arise from single committed cells. The implications of these findings for basic and applied research on cereal tissue culture are discussed.Abbreviations 2,4-D 2,4-Dichlorophenoxyacetic acid - Kinetin 6-Furfurylaminopurine - 6-BAP 6-Benzylaminopurine - MS Murashige and Skoog Emrys Thomas died in England in May 1981.