Linear-quadratic analysis of radiosensitization by halogenated pyrimidines. II. Radiosensitization of human colon cancer cells by bromodeoxyuridine.

As a continuation of the studies in Part I (Miller, Fowler, and Kinsella, Radiat. Res. 131, 000-000, 1992), which examined the radiosensitizing effects of iododeoxyuridine (IdU), similar experiments with bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) were conducted concurrently to characterize its effects on the shape of the radiation survival curves of cells of two human colon cancer cell lines, HT 29 and HCT 116. The efficiency of radiosensitization by BrdU, expressed as a function of percentage thymidine replacement, was lower when compared to IdU in both cell lines. However, the major radiosensitizing effect of BrdU was manifest as an increase in the initial slope (alpha), just as observed for IdU. However, with BrdU, in contrast to IdU, an increase in curvature (repairable damage) was also evident. Cells of the more radiosensitive line, HCT 116, showed less sensitization by either BrdU or IdU than cells of the more radioresistant line, HT 29. These results were consistent with the proposed mechanism of radiosensitization being an increase in the single-hit character of low-LET radiation. It follows that the radiosensitizing effects of both analogs were largest in the low-dose region of the survival curve.     

Comments on "The Grand Objectives" by Thomas E. Graedel

In "The Grand Objectives: A Framework for Prioritized Grouping of Environmental Concerns in Life-Cycle Assessment". Thomas Graedel (1997) proposed an elegant schema for prioritizing environmental concerns. It operates at three levels: grand objectives, environmental concerns, and targeted activities. I argue that consensus is most likely on the first and third levels, but that the middle level, environmental concerns, is more problematic. Even among individuals who agree on general societal directions, strong differences of views can occur regarding specific technologies. I illustrate by applying Graedel's system to his "radionuclide" category, under his first grand objective (human species extinction). I use the example of nuclear waste to illustrate how values are inextricably involved at the "environmental concerns" level. My analysis suggests ways to enhance the utility of Graedel's useful system.     

Mechanism of radiosensitization by halogenated pyrimidines: bromodeoxyuridine and beta-arabinofuranosyladenine affect similar subsets of radiation-induced potentially lethal lesions in plateau-phase Chinese hamster ovary cells

Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells were grown to plateau phase in the presence of various amounts of bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) and treated after irradiation with beta-arabinofuranosyladenine (ara-A), an inhibitor of DNA and potentially lethal damage (PLD) repair, in order to investigate the importance of repair reactions in general and of PLD repair, in particular, on the mechanism of radiosensitization by halogenated pyrimidines. The degree of BrdU-mediated radiosensitization observed in ara-A-treated cells was compared to that of cells incubated after irradiation in the absence of ara-A. A substantial reduction in BrdU-mediated radiosensitization was observed in cells treated with ara-A at concentrations that, when given alone, produced maximum potentiation in cell killing (500-1500 microM). The residual BrdU-mediated radiosensitization observed at high levels of thymidine replacement could be explained by a BrdU-mediated increase in DNA and chromosome damage induction per gray. These findings are similar to those reported previously for a repair-deficient mutant of CHO cells, the xrs-5 cell line, and consistent with the hypothesis that BrdU-mediated radiosensitization has two distinct components, one that derives from an increase in damage induction per gray, and a second one that derives from an effect of BrdU on the repair of radiation-induced damage. It is proposed that the reduction in BrdU-mediated radiosensitization observed in ara-A-treated cells is the result of ara-A-mediated expression of radiation damage, the repair of which would have been otherwise modulated by BrdU. Since ara-A is known to act by fixing a form of radiation-induced PLD (alpha-PLD), we further propose that BrdU acts by fixing alpha-PLD. A synergistic effect in the potentiation of cell killing was observed between ara-A and BrdU when ara-A was given at concentrations below 100 microM. This result suggests that a benefit may be expected in the clinic from the combined application of halogenated pyrimidines with repair inhibitors, if administered at a carefully screened range of concentrations.     

Bacterial radiosensitization by 8-methoxypsoralen.

8-Methoxypsoralen has been shown to act as a radiosensitizer of hypoxic bacterial cells with uvrA, recA and uvrB and/or lexA mutations. No effect of the drug on the radiosensitivity of oxic bacteria with these mutations was observed. This drug differs from O2 and electron-affinic radiosensitizers in that its effect is not purely dose-modifying and can exceed the oxygen effect in certain mutants.