Combined staining procedures for cytophotometry of protein and DNA Feulgen-Naphthol Yellow S and dinitrofluorobenzene-Feulgen

A comparison has been made between dinitrofluorobenzene (DNFB) and Naphthol Yellow S (NYS) as protein stains in combination with the pararosaniline-SO2 Feulgen procedure. Chicken erythrocytes were used as test cells. Cytophotometric measurements were made using a Zeiss scanning stage cytophotometer coupled to a PDP 11/10 minicomputer using the BICOSCAN program to obtain values for protein per cell, protein per "nuclear area' and DNA per nucleus. With 5N HCl as the Feulgen hydrolysis agent, DNFB staining, applied before the Feulgen procedure, was found to be unaffected by hydrolysis conditions required to give optimum Feulgen staining and showed only small losses after longer hydrolysis times. On the other hand measurements of NYS staining, of necessity applied after the Feulgen procedure, seem to be susceptible to the duration of Feulgen hydrolysis. This susceptibility is probably due to the interaction of the DNA phosphates with the basic amino acid residues, potential binding sites for NYS. Since the degree of this interaction may be variable, it is argued that NYS binding will measure the available basicity of proteins at the time of staining but no specific protein fraction. DNFB binding is unaffected by DNA-protein interactions and therefore can give a more reliable measure of "nuclear' protein, particularly in conjunction with Feulgen-DNA measurements.     

Quantification of nuclear non-histone proteins by Feulgen-Naphthol Yellow S cytophotometry

Summary Owing to the accumulation of nuclear non-histone protein (NHP) (a) in cells entering the cell cycle from the quiescent state and (b) in continuously cycling cells during G₁ phase, a simultaneous determination of DNA and nuclear NHP is of high potential utility in cell kinetic studies. This paper provides guidelines for a Feulgen-Naphthol Yellow S staining technique for this purpose. It discusses details of the preparation and quantification procedures, and reviews the evidence for a quantitative relationship between nuclear Naphthol Yellow S binding and nuclear NHP.     

Feulgen-Naphthol Yellow S cytophotometry of liver cells. The effect of formaldehyde induced shrinkage on nuclear Naphthol Yellow S binding.

1. In isolated liver cells, fixed in 4 per cent formaldehyde (NFS) for Feulgen-Naphthol Yellow S (F-NYS) staining of DNA and protein, nuclear shrinkage increases the nuclear concentration of solids to 46 per cent (w/v) before the start of the NYS staining. 2. When a fixative mixture of methanol:acetic acid:formalin (85:5:10 by volume; MAF) is used, the concentration of nuclear solids during NYS staining remain at a physiological level of 19 per cent. 3. By exposing liver cells to NFS for 10 to 120 seconds before fixation in MAF, increasing nuclear shrinkage can be induced with increasing pretreatment in NFS. Nuclear NYS binding decreases in parallel with the decreasing nuclear volume in cells thus treated. As the shrinkage induced reduction in NYS binding may vary with the net charge of nuclear non-histone proteins, MAF fixation must be preferred for quantitative determinations of nuclear non-histone protein in F-NYS stained, isolated cells. 4. Fixation in MAF offers the same advantages as NFS fixation as regards the small loss of proteins during the Feulgen staining procedure and the excellent reproducibility of the F-NYS staining. Storage of MAF fixed cells in the fixative for a few days does not alter their F-NYS staining properties. 5. In MAF fixed, F-NYS stained cells there is no NYS binding to histone basic amino acid residues.     

Quantitative cytochemical aspects of a combined Feulgen-Naphthol Yellow S staining procedure for the simultaneous determination of nuclear and cytoplasmic proteins and DNA in mammalian cells

The simultaneous cytophotometric determination of nuclear and cytoplasmic proteins and DNA by means of a combined Feulgen-Naphthol Yellow S (NYS) staining procedure was investigated. According to this procedure Feulgen staining is performed prior to NYS staining. The following main results were obtained:

1. 1. After NYS staining alone, the amount of NYS bound to the cell was found to be closely correlated to the cellular dry mass. The correlation coefficient was 0.99 in ethanol-acetone fixed cells and 0.95 in formaldehyde-fixed cells. This close correlation was not significantly altered by the Feulgen staining procedure and was 0.92 in ethanol-acetone and 0.94 in formaldehyde-fixed cells. However, the absolute amount of NYS bound per unit dry mass was affected by the method of fixation and type of Feulgen hydrolysis.

2. 2. The cells lose material during the Feulgen procedure, particularly during the acid hydrolysis stage. The type of hydrolysis most suitable for the Feulgen procedure (5 N HCl, 22 °C, 60 min) resulted in a considerable loss of dry mass in ethanol-acetone fixed cells. This loss was smaller in formaldehyde-fixed cells (15%) and was in addition closely correlated (correlation coefficient 0.99) to the dry mass of the cells prior to hydrolysis. In formaldehyde-fixed cells the dry mass after the Feulgen procedure is thus a good measure of the true cellular dry mass of the fixed cells. This is further demonstrated by the close correlation between NYS binding to Feulgenstained cells and the dry mass of these cells prior to the Feulgen procedure (correlation coefficient 0.95).

3. 3. When using the combined Feulgen-NYS staining procedure under standardized conditions (formaldehyde fixation and acid hydrolysis in 5 N HCl, 22 °C, 60 min) a constant amount of NYS was found to be bound per unit dry weight to nuclear and cytoplasmic proteins in various types of mammalian cells with different proliferative activity.

4. 4. The Feulgen DNA determination was not found to be quantitatively affected by the subsequent NYS staining.

From the results of the present study it seems that, under standardized conditions, the combined Feulgen-NYS staining procedure can be used as a reliable quantitative method for the determination of nuclear and cytoplasmic proteins and DNA in mammalian cells.     

Adaptation of the Naphthol Yellow S staining for objects with high protein content.

In measuring isolated rat liver cells stained with Naphthol Yellow S (NYS) at optimal conditions of pH (2.8), the absorbances measured at the absorption peak of 430 nm appeared to be far too high locally to enable accurate cytophotometric measurements. In order to bring down these absorbances, different techniques for flattening the cells, off-peak measurement and NYS staining at non-optimal pH levels have been applied respectively. Using albumin incorporated in polyacrylamide model films, the reliability of off-peak measurements and the quantitative aspects of the modified protein staining procedures have been investigated. It was found that the NYS procedure can be used as a quantitative protein staining not only at pH 2.8, but also at pH 2.0, 3.5 and 4.0 respectively. The problem with regard to the cytophotometric measuring of isolated liver cells could only be solved, however, by combining a specially developed flattening procedure (by centrifuging small drops of suspension) with staining at non-optimal pH levels. In contrast to the model film results, off-peak measurements applied in situ appeared to give rather unreliable results. In cases of a combined Feulgen-NYS staining, the Fuelgen-DNA values were not significantly influenced by any of the modifications of the original NYS staining procedure.     

Combined study of leukemic blasts using DNA autoradiography and cytophotometry]

The 3H-thymidine incorporation capacity and DNA contents were studied in the same bone marrow blasts in 4 patients suffering from acute leucaemia. The blast populations were both proliferating and non-proliferating. Actively proliferating cells were blasts of large and medium diameters. Mitotically inactive cells were blasts of medium and small diameters. Cells that stopped dividing were established as being in period G1 of the cell cycle. A high variation in DNA contents was noted in blasts unlabeled with 3H-thymidine, a possible reason of the above phenomenon being discussed.     

Prognostic significance of DNA image cytophotometry for osteosarcoma

OBJECTIVE: To investigate the prognostic significance of DNA image cytophotometric data. STUDY DESIGN: Twenty-six osteosarcomas in patients without lung metastases were investigated for several cytophotometric data. In 24 cases, these data were correlated with the clinical course of the patients to assess the prognostic value of nuclear DNA content in osteosarcomas. RESULTS: Of all osteosarcomas, 96% showed aneuploid DNA content. Patients with tumors having a 2c deviation index (2cDI) of 12.00, DNA malignancy grade (DNA-MG) of 2.0, a mean DNA content (MDC) of 4.95 c, DNA index (DI) of 1.75 or mean nuclear area (MNA) of 130 microns 2 had a significantly lower overall survival rate as compared to those with lower values (P < .05). CONCLUSION: Image cytophotometric features, such as 2cDI, DNA-MG, MDC, DI and MNA, are of prognostic value in patients with osteosarcoma and free of lung metastases.     

DNA cytophotometry of human chromosomes.

The applicability of Feulgen-based parameters to detect variant metaphase chromosomes involved in deletions or translocations, was investigated and algorithms developed to compute such parameters. This report is focused primarily on the magnitude of the errors involved during the prerequisite procedures of photography, measurement and computation. Measurements were performed by stage-scanning of photographic negatives of Feulgen-stained metaphases. In the scanned images the initial chromosome boundaries were obtained by thresholding, while definite chromosomal areas and local background values were obtained by expansion of the initial boundaries. The integrated density profiles and the relative DNA content were computed for the individual chromosomes (straight as well as bent). Total DNA content, DNA arm ratio, as well as length and centromere index can be obtained from the profile. It was shown that under such conditions the experimental errors associated with the measurements are small compared to biologic variations (e.g., differences between homologues) and that the procedures applied allow to detect polymorphisms. In addition to this, mean and standard deviations of both DNA and length parameters are given for metaphases of five subjects. Comparison of the applicability of DNA and length parameters is realized by a classification experiment.     

Simplified method for DNA and protein staining of human hematopoietic cell samples

A rapid reproducible method yielding high resolution analysis of DNA and protein in human hematopoietic cell samples has been developed by modification of the propidium iodide and fluorescein isothiocyanate procedure. Cell staining involves sequential addition of each reagent (RNase, fluorescein isothiocyanate and propidium iodide) to ethanol-fixed cells and requires no centrifugation steps. Stained cells are analyzed in the reagent solutions. Analysis of bone marrow samples from multiple myeloma patients showed mixed normal and aneuploid populations with a major portion of the aneuploid cells having a significantly higher protein content. This approach permitted differential cell cycle analysis of normal and the aneuploid populations.     

Extraction of cells from paraffin-embedded tissue sections for single-cell DNA cytophotometry

A simple technique is presented for the isolation of cells from paraffin-embedded tissues for Feulgen DNA cytophotometric investigations. Tissue fragments from paraffin blocks were deparaffinized in xylene, rehydrated and refixed in a formalin solution and incubated in a solution of 0.5 pepsin in 0.25% hydrochloric acid. After filtration through a 70 micron mesh and centrifugation, the cells were smeared upon a glass slide. Comparison between the results obtained with freshly prepared imprints and with pepsin-extracted cells of the same tumor showed that the extraction technique does not influence the Feulgen reaction or the DNA distribution pattern. Investigations carried out on bladder and embryonal carcinomas have demonstrated that the method permits an analysis of histologically or histochemically identified tumor cells within individual tissue areas.     

Combined beta-galactosidase and immunogold/silver staining for immunohistochemistry and DNA in situ hybridization.

A combination of beta-galactosidase enzyme and the immunogold/silver staining method was studied for evaluation of double-staining experiments. Applications are shown for immunohistochemical double staining using two monoclonal antibodies and for combined immunohistochemistry and DNA in situ hybridization in one tissue section. The following advantages for the present double-staining method were evaluated: superior sensitivity of the immunogold/silver staining method for at least one epitope, which also allows detection of biotinylated DNA probes. The structure of the indolyl precipitate after revelation of beta-galactosidase activity did not show a concealing effect during a sequential double-staining method, as compared with the visualization of peroxidase with diaminobenzidine. These factors, and the sharply contrasting colored reaction products of beta-galactosidase (blue-green) and the immunogold/silver staining method including silver enhancement (brown-black), allow clear distinction of mixed-stained cell constituents.     

Remarks on the usefulness of toluidine blue staining for RNA cytophotometry in plastic embedded tissues.

The study demonstrates the usefulness of water-soluble plastic resins for the cytological quantification of RNA contents after toluidine blue staining. In this way shrinkage artefacts in delicate tissues are avoided and more exact cytophotometrical results can be obtained from embryological material.     

Adaptation of the naphthol yellow S staining for objects with high protein content

Summary In measuring isolated rat liver cells stained with Naphthol Yellow S (NYS) at optimal conditions of pH (2.8), the absorbances measured at the absorption peak of 430 nm appeared to be far too high locally to enable accurate cytophotometric measurements. In order to bring down these absorbances, different techniques for flattening the cells, off-peak measurement and NYS staining at non-optimal pH levels have been applied respectively. Using albumin incorporated in polyacrylamide model films, the reliability of off-peak measurements and the quantitative aspects of the modified protein staining procedures have been investigated. It was found that the NYS procedure can be used as a quantitative protein staining not only at pH 2.8, but also at pH 2.0, 3.5 and 4.0 respectively. The problem with regard to the cytophotometric measuring of isolated liver cells could only be solved, however, by combining a specially developed flattening procedure (by centrifuging small drops of suspension) with staining at non-optimal pH levels. In contrast to the model film results, off-peak measurements applied in situ appeared to give rather unreliable results. In cases of a combined Feulgen-NYS staining, the Feulgen-DNA values were not significantly influenced by any of the modifications of the original NYS staining procedure.     

Combined staining of protein-bound sulphydryl groups and DNA in polyacrylamide model systems.

A model system of polyacrylamide films containing protein and DNA has been used to examine the feasibility of combining the dihydroxydinaphthyldisulphide (DDD)-diazonium salt procedure for localizing protein-bound sulphydryl groups with the Feulgen technique for DNA to make possible the direct measurement of both these parameters simultaneously. Optimun conditions for the sulphydryl group reaction require reduction of the protein-containing films in 10% aqueous ammonium sulphide for 3 hr at 50 degree C followed by treatment with a DDD solution at 50 degree C for 4 hr. The final coloured product was developed in a solution of the diazonium salt, Fast Red TR, for 15 min. The azo compound thus produced was completely resistant to hydrochloric acid hydrolysis in the manner of the Feulgen reaction. Calculation of protein-bound sulphydryl groups and DNA from measurements made on doubly-stained films showed excellent agreement between the measured and the expected values.     

Quantitative cytochemistry of nuclear and cytoplasmic proteins using the Naphthol Yellow S and dinitrofluorobenzene staining methods

Summary The total protein staining of biological specimens with the electrostatically binding Naphthol Yellow S or the covalently binding dinitrofluorobenzene must be interpreted as methods which yield data on the specific amino acid pool of the proteins concerned. Both dyes bind to certain free amino-acid side-chains, giving different dye-protein ratios for various proteins. In the presence of DNA, dinitrofluorobenzene stains all proteins present in cell nuclei, whereas Naphthol Yellow S only stains the majority of the non-histone proteins. When protein staining methods are combined with the Feulgen-Pararosaniline (SO₂) procedure for DNA, decreased Feulgen-DNA contents were measured in dinitrofluorobenzene-stained isolated nuclei and lymphocytes.     

Feulgen DNA cytophotometry in histologic sections of mammary neoplasms

Because of a lack of suitable archival material, it is rarely possible to make retrospective studies of the correlation between the prognosis for a patient with mammary carcinoma and the distribution of nuclear DNA in the cells of the neoplasm. An investigation of the possibility of using sections cut from paraffin-embedded specimens showed that such sections are not suitable for use in retrospective studies of breast carcinoma. Because of such factors as the heterogeneity in size and shape of the nuclei from neoplastic cells and their tendency to mold around each other, determinations of DNA content of cells in sections were extremely difficult; in this particular carcinoma it was found that the distribution of nuclear DNA as obtained from a Feulgen-stained histologic section was not the same as that obtained from a Feulgen-stained imprint smear, and some polyploid tumors were erroneously classified as aneuploid.