Evolution of an interloop disulfide bond in high-affinity antibody mimics based on fibronectin type III domain and selected by yeast surface display: molecular convergence with single-domain camelid and shark antibodies

The 10th human fibronectin type III domain ((10)Fn3) is one of several protein scaffolds used to design and select families of proteins that bind with high affinity and specificity to macromolecular targets. To date, the highest affinity (10)Fn3 variants have been selected by mRNA display of libraries generated by randomizing all three complementarity-determining region -like loops of the (10)Fn3 scaffold. The sub-nanomolar affinities of such antibody mimics have been attributed to the extremely large size of the library accessible by mRNA display (10(12) unique sequences). Here we describe the selection and affinity maturation of (10)Fn3-based antibody mimics with dissociation constants as low as 350 pM selected from significantly smaller libraries (10(7)-10(9) different sequences), which were constructed by randomizing only 14 (10)Fn3 residues. The finding that two adjacent loops in human (10)Fn3 provide a large enough variable surface area to select high-affinity antibody mimics is significant because a smaller deviation from wild-type (10)Fn3 sequence is associated with a higher stability of selected antibody mimics. Our results also demonstrate the utility of an affinity-maturation strategy that led to a 340-fold improvement in affinity by maximizing sampling of sequence space close to the original selected antibody mimic. A striking feature of the highest affinity antibody mimics selected against lysozyme is a pair of cysteines on adjacent loops, in positions 28 and 77, which are critical for the affinity of the (10)Fn3 variant for its target and are close enough to form a disulfide bond. The selection of this cysteine pair is structurally analogous to the natural evolution of disulfide bonds found in new antigen receptors of cartilaginous fish and in camelid heavy-chain variable domains. We propose that future library designs incorporating such an interloop disulfide will further facilitate the selection of high-affinity, highly stable antibody mimics from libraries accessible to phage and yeast surface display methods.     

Selection of genomic sequences that bind tightly to Ff gene 5 protein: primer-free genomic SELEX

Single-stranded DNA or RNA libraries used in SELEX experiments usually include primer-annealing sequences for PCR amplification. In genomic SELEX, these fixed sequences may form base pairs with the central genomic fragments and interfere with the binding of target molecules to the genomic sequences. In this study, a method has been developed to circumvent these artificial effects. Primer-annealing sequences are removed from the genomic library before selection with the target protein and are then regenerated to allow amplification of the selected genomic fragments. A key step in the regeneration of primer-annealing sequences is to employ thermal cycles of hybridization-extension, using the sequences from unselected pools as templates. The genomic library was derived from the bacteriophage fd, and the gene 5 protein (g5p) from the phage was used as a target protein. After four rounds of primer-free genomic SELEX, most cloned sequences overlapped at a segment within gene 6 of the viral genome. This sequence segment was pyrimidine-rich and contained no stable secondary structures. Compared with a neighboring genomic fragment, a representative sequence from the family of selected sequences had about 23-fold higher g5p-binding affinity. Results from primer-free genomic SELEX were compared with the results from two other genomic SELEX protocols.     

Construction of high-complexity combinatorial phage display peptide libraries

Random peptide libraries displayed on the surface of filamentous bacteriophage are widely used as tools for the discovery of ligands for biologically relevant macromolecules, including antibodies, enzymes, and cell surface receptors. Phage display results in linkage of an affinity-selectable function (the displayed peptide) to the DNA encoding that function, allowing selection of individual binding clones by iterative cycles of in vitro panning and in vivo amplification. Critical to the success of a panning experiment is the complexity of the library: the greater the diversity of clones within the library, the more likely the library contains sequences that will bind a given target with useful affinity. A method for construction of high-complexity (> or = 10(9) independent clones) random peptide libraries is presented. The key steps are highly efficient binary ligation under conditions where the vector is relatively dilute, with only a modest molar excess of insert, followed by efficient electrotransformation into Escherichia coli. Library design strategies and a protocol for rapid sequence characterization are also presented.     

Ligand-mediated protection against phage lysis as a positive selection strategy for the enrichment of epitopes displayed on the surface of E. coli cells

We present a novel strategy, termed CISTEM, which allows direct in vivo screening of polypeptides displayed on the surface of E. coli cells by a combination of ligand-mediated protection and phage-mediated selection. The effectiveness of this new approach was demonstrated by displaying the T7.tag on the surface of E. coli as a fusion with the outer membrane protein A, the receptor for bacteriophage K3. A monoclonal T7.tag antibody was used as protective ligand for T7.tag-displaying cells and phage K3 for the elimination of unprotected cells. When populations of bacteria, containing between 6 to 10,000 cells displaying the T7.tag and approximately 10(8) cells displaying an unrelated OmpA fusion protein, were infected with phage K3, specific and antibody-dependent survival of T7.tag displaying cells was observed, yielding an enrichment factor of up to 10(7)-fold. The CISTEM technology was used to select sequences from a T7.tag-based, randomised library and the results were compared to those obtained from selection by MACS with the same library. Together, these results reveal a novel in vivo screening strategy in which an E. coli phage receptor is used as display plafform and selection is performed in suspension upon addition of a protective ligand and a bacteriophage. Extentions and modifications of the basic strategy should lead to novel applications for the identification of protein-ligand interactions.     

Effective Optimization of Antibody Affinity by Phage Display Integrated with High-Throughput DNA Synthesis and Sequencing Technologies

Phage display technology has been widely used for antibody affinity maturation for decades. The limited library sequence diversity together with excessive redundancy and labour-consuming procedure for candidate identification are two major obstacles to widespread adoption of this technology. We hereby describe a novel library generation and screening approach to address the problems. The approach started with the targeted diversification of multiple complementarity determining regions (CDRs) of a humanized anti-ErbB2 antibody, HuA21, with a small perturbation mutagenesis strategy. A combination of three degenerate codons, NWG, NWC, and NSG, were chosen for amino acid saturation mutagenesis without introducing cysteine and stop residues. In total, 7,749 degenerate oligonucleotides were synthesized on two microchips and released to construct five single-chain antibody fragment (scFv) gene libraries with 4 x 10⁶ DNA sequences. Deep sequencing of the unselected and selected phage libraries using the Illumina platform allowed for an in-depth evaluation of the enrichment landscapes in CDR sequences and amino acid substitutions. Potent candidates were identified according to their high frequencies using NGS analysis, by-passing the need for the primary screening of target-binding clones. Furthermore, a subsequent library by recombination of the 10 most abundant variants from four CDRs was constructed and screened, and a mutant with 158-fold increased affinity (K_d = 25.5 pM) was obtained. These results suggest the potential application of the developed methodology for optimizing the binding properties of other antibodies and biomolecules.     

A multipurpose vector system for the screening of libraries in bacteria, insect and mammalian cells and expression in vivo

We have constructed a novel tetra-promoter vector (pBVboostFG) system that enables screening of gene/cDNA libraries for functional genomic studies. The vector enables an all-in-one strategy for gene expression in mammalian, bacterial and insect cells and is also suitable for direct use in vivo. Virus preparation is based on an improved mini Tn7 transpositional system allowing easy and fast production of recombinant baculoviruses with high diversity and negligible background. Cloning of the desired DNA fragments or libraries is based on the recombination system of bacteriophage lambda. As an example of the utility of the vector, genes or cDNAs of 18 different proteins were cloned into pBVboostFG and expressed in different hosts. As a proof-of-principle of using the vector for library screening, a chromophoric Thr⁶⁵-Tyr-Gly⁶⁷-stretch of enhanced green fluorescent protein was destroyed and subsequently restored by novel PCR strategy and library screening. The pBVboostFG enables screening of genome-wide libraries, thus making it an efficient new platform technology for functional genomics.     

Phage-Displayed Libraries for the Selection of Optimal Affinity Peptides for Protein Purification Using Ni-Nitrilotriacetic Acid Chromatography

A random hexapeptide library, cloned in bacteriophage, was used to select affinity peptides using nickel-nitrilotriacetic acid (Ni-NTA) columns. The screening protocol was successful by isolating peptides sharing common features and, in most cases, common amino acid sequences were isolated (e.g. WHHHPH, AQHHHH). Ni-NTA chromatography of the fusion phage of the selected peptides exhibited a more homogeneous elution behavior (i.e. elution in one peak) than the most commonly used His₆peptide (elution in multiple peaks).     

Spatially addressed combinatorial protein libraries for recombinant antibody discovery and optimization

Antibody discovery typically uses hybridoma- or display-based selection approaches, which lack the advantages of directly screening spatially addressed compound libraries as in small-molecule discovery. Here we apply the latter strategy to antibody discovery, using a library of ～10,000 human germline antibody Fabs created by de novo DNA synthesis and automated protein expression and purification. In multiplexed screening assays, we obtained specific hits against seven of nine antigens. Using sequence-activity relationships and iterative mutagenesis, we optimized the binding affinities of two hits to the low nanomolar range. The matured Fabs showed full and partial antagonism activities in cell-based assays. Thus, protein drug leads can be discovered using surprisingly small libraries of proteins with known sequences, questioning the requirement for billions of members in an antibody discovery library. This methodology also provides sequence, expression and specificity information at the first step of the discovery process, and could enable novel antibody discovery in functional screens.     

Recombinant rabbit Fab with binding activity to type-1 plasminogen activator inhibitor derived from a phage-display library against human α-granules

The display of panels of antibody (Ab) fragments on the surface of filamentous bacteriophage offers a way of making Ab with defined binding specificities. Because rabbit Ab are routinely utilized as immunologic probes in a variety of biological techniques, the aim of this study was to design and utilize primers for the amplification of mRNAs encoding rabbit κ light and λ heavy chains for the construction of an Ab library from this species. Using the polymerase chain reaction, a diverse Ab library with a repertoire of 2 × 10⁷ clones was derived from the spleen and bone marrow of a rabbit that had been immunized with purified human platelet α-granules. From this library, specific clones were isolated after three rounds of affinity selection with binding activity to type-1 plasminogen activator inhibitor, a trace protein contained in platelet α-granules. These data indicate that recombinant phage-displayed Ab libraries obtained after immunization with complex biological antigens can be employed for the isolation of rabbit monoclonal Fab against specific antigens contained in the biological sample.     

Studies on locus expansion, library representation, and chromosome walking using an efficient method to screen cosmid libraries

We have developed an efficient screening method to search for clones in cosmid libraries prepared from human genomic DNA. Genomic, cDNA, and cosmid probes have been used to isolate homologous cosmids from human chromosomes 7, 10, 16, 17 and X as part of a search for polymorphic nucleotide sequences. This method has been successfully applied to chromosome walking experiments at the interstitial retinol-binding protein locus on chromosome 10, and may be a useful tool for investigating representation of cloned sequences in cosmid libraries. Our library was prepared in the vector c2RB (Bates and Swift, 1983), but the method is applicable to any cosmid cloning system in which the inserted DNA can be separated from the vector by restriction enzyme digestion. A cosmid library containing five human genome equivalents can be rapidly screened using three to four Southern hybridization filters. This results in substantial labor saving, particularly when screening genomes of high complexity with many different probes. Another advantage of the system is that it allows for the long-term storage of the cosmids so that they can be screened whenever necessary. As a consequence, cosmid screening can be made a routine laboratory procedure.     

High-affinity human antibodies from phage-displayed synthetic Fab libraries with a single framework scaffold

Phage-displayed synthetic antibody libraries were built on a single human framework by introducing synthetic diversity at solvent-exposed positions within the heavy chain complementarity-determining regions (CDRs). The design strategy of mimicking natural diversity using tailored codons had been validated previously with scFv libraries, which produced antibodies that bound to antigen, murine vascular endothelial growth factor (mVEGF), with affinities in the 100nM range. To improve library performance, we constructed monovalent and bivalent antigen-binding fragment (Fab) libraries, and explored different CDR-H3 diversities by varying the amino acid composition and CDR length. A Fab with sub-nanomolar affinity for mVEGF was obtained from a library with CDR-H3 diversity designed to contain all 20 naturally occurring amino acids. We then expanded the library by increasing the variability of CDR-H3 length and using tailored codons that mimicked the amino acid composition of natural CDR-H3 sequences. The library was tested against a panel of 13 protein antigens and high-affinity Fabs were obtained for most antigens. Furthermore, the heavy chain of an anti-mVEGF clone was recombined with a library of light chain CDRs, and the affinity was improved from low nanomolar to low picomolar. The results demonstrated that high-affinity human antibodies can be generated from libraries with completely synthetic CDRs displayed on a single scaffold.     

Affinity chromatographic screening of soluble combinatorial peptide libraries.

Affinity chromatography using immobilized S-protein was used for the screening of affinity peptide ligands from two soluble peptide libraries. Peptide library I consisted of octamers with glycine (G) at both termini of each peptide, i.e. GXXXXXXG. The six center positions were constructed using random sequences of six L-amino acids (Y, N, F, E, V, and L). Peptide library II also consisted of octamers but with glycine and valine (V) at both termini of each peptide (GVZZZZVG). The four variable center positions of peptide library II were random sequences of 18 L-amino acids. Peptides that were retained specifically on the immobilized S-protein column were eluted by 2% acetic acid. The peptides in the acid eluate were further separated using reversed-phase HPLC. Each separated peptide fraction was collected and the peptide sequences deconvoluted by mass spectrometry (MS/MS). The screenings of peptide libraries I and II resulted in 12 and 7 affinity peptides, respectively. Eight out of the twelve peptides from peptide library I contained the clear consensus sequence NFEV. Peptide library II resulted in affinity peptides with the sequences GVNFEVVG, GVNFTVVG and GVFFEL(I)VG. The advantages and limitations of affinity chromatography in peptide library screening are discussed.     

A direct selection strategy for shotgun cloning and sequencing in the bacteriophage M13.

A new cloning strategy is described which utilizes direct selection of recombinants for shotgun sequencing in the filamentous bacteriophage M13. Direct selection is accomplished by insertional inactivation of the M13 gene X protein, a powerful inhibitor of phage-specific DNA synthesis when overproduced. An extra copy of gene X was inserted into the intergenic region of M13 and placed under the control of the bacteriophage T7 gene 10 promoter and RBS. Random fragments are cloned into the EcoRV cloning site of the new gene X cistron and recombinants are selected in an E. coli male strain producing T7 RNA polymerase. Cloning efficiencies obtained with M13-100 or phosphatase-treated M13mp19 vector are comparable. The direct selection capability of M13-100 was demonstrated to have the following advantages: (a) consistently achieved high ratios of recombinants to religated vector in the libraries, averaging about 500:1 (0.2% background), and (b) the elimination of the need for phosphatase treatment of the vector to reduce background. The direct selection strategy significantly improves the efficiency of shotgun library construction in M13, and should therefore facilitate the cloning aspects of large scale sequencing projects.     

Random peptide bacteriophage display as a probe for urokinase receptor ligands

The urokinase receptor is a multi-functional protein that plays a central role in cell surface plasminogen activation, cell migration, and cell adhesion. We previously demonstrated that high affinity peptide ligands for the urokinase receptor, which are urokinase competitors, can be obtained from a 15mer peptide library (Goodson et al., 1994). In order to probe for additional urokinase receptor binding sites we affinity selected the same bacteriophage library on complexes of soluble urokinase receptor (suPAR) and the receptor binding domain of urokinase, residues 1-48 (uPA1-48). Bacteriophage were isolated which bound to suPAR and suPAR:uPA1-48 complexes with high yield. The peptide sequences encoded by these bacteriophage were distinct from those obtained previously on urokinase receptor expressing cells, and comprise two groups based upon effects on su-PAR:1-anilino-8-napthalene sulfonate (ANS) fluorescence, and vitronectin binding competition. Alanine scanning mutagensis of the soluble peptides was used to define minimal regions and key residues for suPAR binding by competition with the parent bacteriophage. A comparison of these results with sequences of domains of both vitronectin and integrin alpha-chains, which have been reported to be important for urokinase receptor binding, suggests that the homology with the peptide sequences selected is functionally significant.     

Peptide epitope identification by affinity selection on bacteriophage MS2 virus-like particles

Filamentous phages are now the most widely used vehicles for phage display and provide efficient means for epitope identification. However, the peptides they display are not very immunogenic because they normally fail to present foreign epitopes at the very high densities required for efficient B-cell activation. Meanwhile, systems based on virus-like particles (VLPs) permit the engineered high-density display of specific epitopes but are incapable of peptide library display and affinity selection. We developed a new peptide display platform based on VLPs of the RNA bacteriophage MS2. It combines the high immunogenicity of MS2 VLPs with the affinity selection capabilities of other phage display systems. Here, we describe plasmid vectors that facilitate the construction of high-complexity random sequence peptide libraries on MS2 VLPs and that allow control of the stringency of affinity selection through the manipulation of display valency. We used the system to identify epitopes for several previously characterized monoclonal antibody targets and showed that the VLPs thus obtained elicit antibodies in mice whose activities mimic those of the selecting antibodies.     

High-Throughput Ligand Discovery Reveals a Sitewise Gradient of Diversity in Broadly Evolved Hydrophilic Fibronectin Domains

Discovering new binding function via a combinatorial library in small protein scaffolds requires balance between appropriate mutations to introduce favorable intermolecular interactions while maintaining intramolecular integrity. Sitewise constraints exist in a non-spatial gradient from diverse to conserved in evolved antibody repertoires; yet non-antibody scaffolds generally do not implement this strategy in combinatorial libraries. Despite the fact that biased amino acid distributions, typically elevated in tyrosine, serine, and glycine, have gained wider use in synthetic scaffolds, these distributions are still predominantly applied uniformly to diversified sites. While select sites in fibronectin domains and DARPins have shown benefit from sitewise designs, they have not been deeply evaluated. Inspired by this disparity between diversity distributions in natural libraries and synthetic scaffold libraries, we hypothesized that binders resulting from discovery and evolution would exhibit a non-spatial, sitewise gradient of amino acid diversity. To identify sitewise diversities consistent with efficient evolution in the context of a hydrophilic fibronectin domain, >10⁵ binders to six targets were evolved and sequenced. Evolutionarily favorable amino acid distributions at 25 sites reveal Shannon entropies (range: 0.3–3.9; median: 2.1; standard deviation: 1.1) supporting the diversity gradient hypothesis. Sitewise constraints in evolved sequences are consistent with complementarity, stability, and consensus biases. Implementation of sitewise constrained diversity enables direct selection of nanomolar affinity binders validating an efficient strategy to balance inter- and intra-molecular interaction demands at each site.     

Chicken microsatellite markers isolated from libraries enriched for simple tandem repeats

The total number of microsatellite loci is considered to be at least 10-fold lower in avian species than in mammalian species. Therefore, efficient large-scale cloning of chicken microsatellites, as required for the construction of a high-resolution linkage map, is facilitated by the construction of libraries using an enrichment strategy. In this study, a plasmid library enriched for tandem repeats was constructed from chicken genomic DNA by hybridization selection. Using this technique the proportion of recombinant clones that cross-hybridized to probes containing simple tandem repeats was raised to 16%, compared with < 0·1% in a non-enriched library. Primers were designed from 121 different sequences. Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) analysis of two chicken reference pedigrees enabled 72 loci to be localized within the collaborative chicken genetic map, and at least 30 of the remaining loci have been shown to be informative in these or other crosses.     

mRNA-display-based selections for proteins with desired functions: a protease-substrate case study

mRNA-display is an amplification-based, iterative rounds of in vitro protein selection technique that circumvents a number of difficulties associated with yeast two-hybrid and phage display. Because of the covalent linkage between the genotype and the phenotype, mRNA-display provides a powerful means for reading and amplifying a peptide or protein sequence after it has been selected from a library with a diversity in the range of 10(12)-10(13). In this paper, we briefly review the recent progress in using mRNA-display to identify affinity reagents, binding partners, and enzyme substrates from synthetic peptide or natural proteome libraries. To facilitate the use of mRNA-display in research laboratories without previous experience, we provide a detailed analysis of the critical steps of an mRNA-display-based selection in a case study for the identification of the natural substrates of caspases, including the generation of an mRNA-displayed proteome library, removal of abundant sequences, and selection of proteins with desired functions. The advantages and technical limitations of mRNA-display as a general peptide or protein selection tool are also addressed.     

Isolation and characterization of an IgNAR variable domain specific for the human mitochondrial translocase receptor Tom70.

The new antigen receptor (IgNAR) from sharks is a disulphide bonded dimer of two protein chains, each containing one variable and five constant domains, and functions as an antibody. In order to assess the antigen-binding capabilities of isolated IgNAR variable domains (VNAR), we have constructed an in vitro library incorporating synthetic CDR3 regions of 15-18 residues in length. Screening of this library against the 60 kDa cytosolic domain of the 70 kDa outer membrane translocase receptor from human mitochondria (Tom70) resulted in one dominant antigen-specific clone (VNAR 12F-11) after four rounds of in vitro selection. VNAR 12F-11 was expressed into the Escherichia coli periplasm and purified by anti-FLAG affinity chromatography at yields of 3 mg x L(-1). Purified protein eluted from gel filtration columns as a single monomeric protein and CD spectrum analysis indicated correct folding into the expected beta-sheet conformation. Specific binding to Tom70 was demonstrated by ELISA and BIAcore (Kd = 2.2 +/- 0.31 x 10(-9) m-1) indicating that these VNAR domains can be efficiently displayed as bacteriophage libraries, and selected against target antigens with an affinity and stability equivalent to that obtained for other single domain antibodies. As an initial step in producing 'intrabody' variants of 12F-11, the impact of modifying or removing the conserved immunoglobulin intradomain disulphide bond was assessed. High affinity binding was only retained in the wild-type protein, which combined with our inability to affinity mature 12F-11, suggests that this particular VNAR is critically dependent upon precise CDR loop conformations for its binding affinity.     

An in vivo library-versus-library selection of optimized protein-protein interactions.

We describe a rapid and efficient in vivo library-versus-library screening strategy for identifying optimally interacting pairs of heterodimerizing polypeptides. Two leucine zipper libraries, semi-randomized at the positions adjacent to the hydrophobic core, were genetically fused to either one of two designed fragments of the enzyme murine dihydrofolate reductase (mDHFR), and cotransformed into Escherichia coli. Interaction between the library polypeptides reconstituted enzymatic activity of mDHFR, allowing bacterial growth. Analysis of the resulting colonies revealed important biases in the zipper sequences relative to the original libraries, which are consistent with selection for stable, heterodimerizing pairs. Using more weakly associating mDHFR fragments, we increased the stringency of selection. We enriched the best-performing leucine zipper pairs by multiple passaging of the pooled, selected colonies in liquid culture, as the best pairs allowed for better bacterial propagation. This competitive growth allowed small differences among the pairs to be amplified, and different sequence positions were enriched at different rates. We applied these selection processes to a library-versus-library sample of 2.0 x 10(6) combinations and selected a novel leucine zipper pair that may be appropriate for use in further in vivo heterodimerization strategies.