Unravelled nucleosomes,nucleosome beads and higher order structures of chromatin: Influence of non-histone components and histone H1

Effects of non-histone components and histone H1 on the morphology of nucleosomes and chromatin were studied by electron microscopy. Soluble rat liver ehromatin was depleted of non-histone components [NH]or non-histone components and H1 [NH and H1] by dissociation and subsequent fractionation in sucrose gradients in the presence of 300 to 350 mm or 500 mm-NaCl, respectively. In reconstitution experiments the depleted samples were mixed either with [NH] or with [NH and H1] or with purified H1. The morphology of the ionic strength-dependent condensation of the samples was monitored by electron microscopy using 0 mm to 100 mm-NaCl. Based on the appearance of the different types of fibres in very low salt (0 mm up to 10 mm-NaCl), namely the zigzag-shaped, the beads-on-a-string or the DNA-like filaments, it is possible to distinguish between nucleosomes, partially unravelled nucleosomes and unravelled nucleosomes, respectively. Only those fibres which were zigzag-shaped at low ionic strength condense at increasing ionic strength into higher order structures of compact fibres. We demonstrate the dependence of the appearance of nucleosomes and chromatin upon its composition and upon the ionic strength of the solvent.[NH] have no detectable influence upon the formation of higher order chromatin structures, but they can prevent the unravelling of nucleosomes at very low ionic strength, presumably by charge shielding.For the appearance of zigzag-shaped fibres and for the condensation into compact fibres with increasing ionic strength, H1 must be present in about native amounts. Partial removal of H1 (about 10%) promotes a change from fibres into tangles. This supports the model that an H1 polymer is stabilizing the higher order chromatin structures.Reconstitution experiments with purified H1 regenerated fibres containing all the features of [NH]-depleted chromatin. Reconstitution experiments with [NH and H1] promoted fibres compatible with control chromatin. Overloading of chromatin with H1 led to additional condensation. The detailed morphology of the reconstituted fibres showed local distortions. One possibility explaining these local distortions would be competition between “main” and “additional” binding sites for histone H1.     

Involvement of the globular domain of histone H1 in the higher order structures of chromatin

We have attacked H1-containing soluble chromatin by α-chymotrypsin under conditions where chromatin adopts different structures.Soluble rat liver chromatin fragments depleted of non-histone components were digested with α-chymotrypsin in NaCl concentrations between 0 mm and 500 mm. at pH 7, or at pH 10, or at pH 7 in the presence of 4 m-urea. α-Chymotrypsin cleaves purified rat liver histone H1 at a specific initial site (CT) located in the globular domain and produces an N-terminal half (CT-N) which contains most of the globular domain and the N-terminal tail, and a C-terminal half (CT-C) which contains the C-terminal tail and a small part of the globular domain. Since in sodium dodecyl sulfate/polyacrylamide-gel electrophoresis CT-C migrates between the core histones and H1, cleavage of chromatin-bound H1 by α-chymotrypsin can be easily monitored.The CT-C fragment was detected under conditions where chromatin fibers were unfolded or distorted: (1) under conditions of H1 dissociation at 400 mm and 500 mm-NaCl (pH 7 and 10); (2) at very low ionic strength where chromatin is unfolded into a filament with well-separated nucleosomes; (3) at pH 10 independent of the ionic strength where chromatin never assumes higher order structures; (4) in the presence of 4 m-urea (pH 7), again independent of the ionic strength. However, hardly any CT-C fragment was detected under conditions where fibers are observed in the electron microscope at pH 7 between 20 mm and 300 mm-NaCl. Under these conditions H1 is degraded by α-chymotrypsin into unstable fragments with a molecular weight higher than that of CT-C. Thus, the data show that there are at least two different modes of interaction of H1 in chromatin which correlate with the physical state of the chromatin.Since the condensation of chromatin into structurally organized fibers upon raising the ionic strength starts by internucleosomal contacts in the fiber axis (zig-zag-shaped fiber), where H1 appears to be localized, it is likely that in chromatin fibers the preferential cleavage site for α-chymotrypsin is protected because of H1-H1 contacts. The data suggest that the globular part of H1 is involved in these contacts close to the fiber axis. They appear to be hydrophobic and to be essential for the structural organization of the chromatin fibers. Based on the present and earlier observations we propose a model for H1 in which the globular domains eventually together with the N-terminal tails form a backbone in the fiber axis, and the nucleosomes are mainly attached to this polymer by the C-terminal tails.     

Involvement of histone H1 in the organization of the nucleosome and of the salt-dependent superstructures of chromatin

We describe the results of a systematic study, using electron microscopy, of the effects of ionic strength on the morphology of chromatin and of H1-depleted chromatin. With increasing ionic strength, chromatin folds up progressively from a filament of nucleosomes at approximately 1 mM monovalent salt through some intermediate higher- order helical structures (Thoma, F., and T. Koller, 1977, Cell 12:101- 107) with a fairly constant pitch but increasing numbers of nucleosomes per turn, until finally at 60 mM (or else in approximately 0.3 mM Mg++) a thick fiber of 250 A diameter is formed, corresponding to a structurally well-organized but not perfectly regular superhelix or solenoid of pitch approximately 110 A as described by Finch and Klug (1976, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 73:1897-1901). The numbers of nucleosomes per turn of the helical structures agree well with those which can be calculated from the light-scattering data of Campbell et al. (1978, Nucleic Acids Res. 5:1571-1580). H1-depleted chromatin also condenses with increasing ionic strength but not so densely as chromatin and not into a definite structure with a well-defined fiber direction. At very low ionic strengths, nucleosomes are present in chromatin but not in H1-depleted chromatin which has the form of an unravelled filament. At somewhat higher ionic strengths (greater than 5 mM triethanolamine chloride), nucleosomes are visible in both types of specimen but the fine details are different. In chromatin containing H1, the DNA enters and leaves the nucleosome on the same side but in chromatin depleted of H1 the entrance and exit points are much more random and more or less on opposite sides of the nucleosome. We conclude that H1 stabilizes the nucleosome and is located in the region of the exit and entry points of the DNA. This result is correlated with biochemical and x-ray crystallographic results on the internal structure of the nucleosome core to give a picture of a nucleosome in which H1 is bound to the unique region on a complete two-turn, 166 base pair particle (Fig. 15). In the formation of higher-order structures, these regions on neighboring nucleosomes come closer together so that an H1 polymer may be formed in the center of the superhelical structures.     

Nucleosome dissociation at physiological ionic strengths.

Monomer nucleosomes purified on isokinetic sucrose gradients are shown to dissociate into component DNA and histones at physiological ionic strength upon dilution to a DNA concentration below 20 microgram/ml. The starting material is 11S, contains 145-190 BP DNA, and equimolar amounts of the four core histones with slightly less H1. Dilution of monomers in the presence of 0.14 M NaCl results in the rapid conversion of 10-40% of the 3H thymidine labeled material from 11S to 5S (5S is coincident with the S value of monomer length DNA). The proportion of nucleosomes which dissociate increases with increasing NaCl concentration between 0.15 M and 0.35 M and decreases with increasing DNA concentration above 1 microgram/ml. Recycling 11S monomers, which remain after dissociation, through a second dilution in salt generates an equivalent proportion of 5S material as seen after the initial dilution. Thus, the dissociation does not result from special properties of a subset of nucleosomes. An equilibrium between intact monomer and free DNA and histones appears to be rapidly established under the conditions described and the dissociated DNA will reassociate with histones to form 11S monomers if conditions of high DNA concentration and low ionic strength are established.     

Interactions between core histones and chromatin at physiological ionic strength

Addition of core histones to chromatin or chromatin core particles at physiological ionic strength results in soluble nucleohistone complexes when polyglutamic acid is included in the sample. The interaction between nucleosomes and added core histones is strong enough to inhibit nucleosome formation on a closed circular DNA in the same solution. Complexes consisting of core particles and core histones run as discrete nucleoprotein particles on polyacrylamide gels. Consistent with the electrophoretic properties of these particles, protein cross-linking with dimethyl suberimidate indicates that added core histones are bound as excess octamers. Histones in the excess octamers do not exchange with nucleosomal core histones at an ionic strength of 0.1 M and can be selectively removed from core particles by incubating the complexes in a solution containing sufficient DNA. Under conditions where added histones are confined to the surface of chromatin, the excess histones are mobile and can migrate onto a contiguous extension of naked DNA and form nucleosomes.     

Influence of histones H1/H5 on the DNA coiling in the nucleosome — electric dichroism and birefringence study

Removal of histones H1 and H5 from chicken erythrocyte mononucleosomes results in a large increase of the negative electric birefringence and dichroism, and of the relaxation times, towards the values observed for mononucleosomal DNA. Cross-linking with dimethylsuberimidate does not yield important changes in the electro-optical properties of mononucleosomes, provided that the reaction is performed at low ionic strength. We suggest that in the absence of H1/H5 the linker DNA is flexible, and that this DNA tail is unwound at low ionic strength and responsible for most of the negative anisotropy of these particles. Bipolar pulse experiments revealed that the orientation mechanism of chromatosomes and H1/H5-depleted nucleosomes is predominantly of the induced dipole type.     

Circular dichroism as a probe of DNA structure inside reconstituted nucleohistones.

Reconstituted nucleohistones were obtained by mixing in given conditions acid extracted histones and eukaryotic DNA. The histone/DNA ratio (w/w) was in the range 0.35 - 0.95. With the four histones (H2A2B) we have been able to obtain subunits (nucleosomes or upsilon-bodies). The variation of cirsular dichroism signal with temperature at 280 nm was measured to follow structural changes of the DNA inside the complex. The true change of ellipticity (see article) of histone-bound DNA regions, is similar for reconstituted nucleohistone and H1-depleted chromatin, and is therefore a physical probe of the presence of nucleosomes.     

Comparative study of nucleosome particles in chromatin from normal and tumor cells. II. Reconstitution, compaction and association induced by ionic strength of a solution

The method of circular dichroism (CD) has been used to investigate the reconstitution of mononucleosomes from C3HA mice liver and ascitic hepatoma 22A cells chromatin. It has been revealed that the more unfolding state of DNA in ascitic nucleosomes (discovered earlier) is determined by the peculiarities of the interactions between DNA and the dimers H2A-H2B, as well as by the linker histones of the H1 group. The investigation of the DNA folding in the oligonucleosome chains with increasing ionic strength has shown complete invariability of the DNA compactness in the ascitic chromatin up to 100 mM NaCl, while in liver nucleosomes an additional folding of the linker portion of the DNA was observed within the range of 20-40 mM NaCl. Oligonucleosomes from ascitic chromatin are less inclined to association upon increasing ionic strength, as compared with those from liver chromatin.     

Electron microscope evidence for the presence of globular structures in different sperm chromatins

Dispersion of nuclear fibers of the spermatozoa of dogfish, man, and bull is made possible after treatment with a reducing and alkylating reagent coupled with an anionic detergent; the same detergent used at a low ionic strength dissociates the nuclear content of the rainbow trout sperm. Electron microscopy of such dispersed nuclear fibers has shown a beads-on-a-string configuration for these four types of sperm chromatin. These structures are morphologically similar to those described in somatic cell nuclei as nucleosomes, although in sperm chromatin the basic proteins associated with DNA were significantly different from histones.     

The condensation of chromatin and histone H1-depleted chromatin by spermine

At low ionic strength, spermine induces aggregation of native and H1-depleted chromatin at spermine/phosphate (Sp/P) ratios of 0.15 and 0.3, respectively. Physico-chemical methods (electric dichroism, circular dichroism and thermal denaturation) show that spermine, at Sp/P less than 0.15, does not appreciably alter the conformation of native chromatin and interacts unspecifically with all parts of chromatin DNA (linker as well as regions slightly or tightly bound to histones). In chromatin, the role of spermine could be more important in the stabilization of higher-order structure than in the condensation of the 30 nm solenoid. The addition of spermine to H1-depleted chromatin revealed two important features: (i) spermine can partially mimic the role of histone H1 in the condensation of chromatin; (ii) the core histone octamer does not appear to play any role in the aggregation process by spermine as DNA and H1-depleted chromatin aggregate at the same Sp/P ratio.     

Accessibility and structural role of histone domains in chromatin. biophysical and immunochemical studies of progressive digestion with immobilized proteases

The accessibility and role of histone regions in chromatin fibres were investigated using limited proteolysis with enzymes covalently bound to collagen membranes. The changes in chromatin conformation and condensation monitored by various biophysical methods, were correlated to the degradation of the histone proteins revealed by antibodies specific for histones and histone peptides. Upon digestion with trypsin and subtilisin, chromatin undergoes successive structural transitions. The cleavage of the C-terminal domains of H1, H2A and H2B, and of the N-terminal tail of H3 led to a decondensation of chromatin fibres, indicated by increases in electric birefringence and orientational relaxation times. It corresponds to a 15% increase in linear dimensions. The degradation of the other terminal regions of histones H3, H2A and H2B resulted in the appearance of hinge points between nucleosomes without alteration of the overall orientation of polynucleosome chains. Despite the loss of all the basic domains of H1, H3, H2A and H2B, no significant change in DNA-protein interactions occurred, suggesting that most of these protease-accessible regions interact weakly, if at all, with DNA in chromatin. Further proteolysis led to H4 degradation and other additional cleavages of H1, H2B and H3. This caused the relaxation of no more than 8% of the total DNA but resulted in changes in the ability of chromatin to condense at high ionic strength. More extensive digestion resulted in a total unravelling of nucleosomal chains which acquired properties similar to those of H1-depleted chromatin, although the globular part of H1 was still present. The data suggest that histone-histone interactions between H1 and core histone domains play a central role in stabilizing the chromatin fibres, and cuts in H3, H2A and H2B as well as H1, seem necessary for chromatin expansion. On the contrary, H4 might be involved in the stabilization of nucleosomes only.     

Thermal stability of nucleosomes studied in situ by flow cytometry: effect of ionic strength and n-butyrate

Heating of cells permeabilized with ethanol and resuspended in aqueous media increases accessibility of DNA to intercalating dyes such as acridine orange (AO). The curves, representing increase in binding of AO as a function of rise in temperature, indicate that the transitions are cooperative. The transitions are sensitive to ionic strength and occur at lower temperatures when cells are suspended in media of increasing ionic strength. Extraction of histones raises accessibility of DNA to intercalators at room temperature, and heating has little effect on additional binding. The results are interpreted as indicating thermal destruction of nucleosomal structure in nuclear chromatin; dissociation of DNA from core histones results in its increasing ability to intercalate AO, most likely due to increased topological freedom to undergo unwinding and elongation following binding of the intercalator. Preincubation of cells with n-butyrate, known to induce histone hyperacetylation, lowers the heat stability of nucleosomes by about 5 degrees C. On the other hand, no differences are observed between chromatin of mitotic vs interphase cells tested over a wide range of ionic strengths (0.1-0.7 N NaCl). The method appears to be useful as a probe of chromatin structure at the nucleosomal level.     

Stability of nucleosomes in native and reconstituted chromatins.

The stability of nucleosomes of SV40 minichromosomes extracted from infected cells or reconstituted by association of SV40 DNA and the four histones H2A, H2B, H3 and H4 was studied as a function of the ionic strength. As a measure of the stability of the nucleosome, we followed the disappearance of the nucleosomes from the original chromatin and their appearance on a "competing" DNA. We show here that the DNA and the histone components of the nucleosomes do not apprecially dissociate below 800 mM NaCl. At 800 mM and above, the histone moiety of the nucleosomes can dissociate from the DNA and efficiently participate to the formation of nucleosomes on a "competing" DNA.     

Effect of salt on the binding of the linker histone H1 to DNA and nucleosomes

The linker histones are involved in the salt-dependent folding of the nucleosomes into higher-order chromatin structures. To better understand the mechanism of action of these histones in chromatin, we studied the interactions of the linker histone H1 with DNA at various histone/DNA ratios and at different ionic strengths. In direct competition experiments, we have confirmed the binding of H1 to superhelical DNA in preference to linear or nicked circular DNA forms. We show that the electrophoretic mobility of the H1/supercoiled DNA complex decreases with increasing H1 concentrations and increases with ionic strengths. These results indicate that the interaction of the linker histone H1 with supercoiled DNA results in a soluble binding of H1 with DNA at low H1 or salt concentrations and aggregation at higher H1 concentrations. Moreover, we show that H1 dissociates from the DNA or nucleosomes at high salt concentrations. By the immobilized template pull-down assay, we confirm these data using the physiologically relevant nucleosome array template.     

Formation and characterization of soluble complexes of histone H1 with supercoiled DNA

We have analyzed the interaction of rat liver histone H1 with superhelical DNA. Depending on the ratio of H1 to DNA and the concentration of salt, two different types of complexes were found. Above a critical ratio of H1 to DNA, called the aggregation point, large aggregates are formed, which have a cable-like appearance in the electron microscope. Below the aggregation point, individual soluble complexes are formed, which are the subject of this study. With increasing ionic strength, the aggregation point is shifted towards lower ratios of H1 to DNA. In the soluble complexes, H1 appears to bind along superhelically intertwined DNA strands, forming a polymer. Partial digestion of the complexes with protease suggests protection of the N-terminal tail and the globular domain of H1. Similar soluble complexes were observed with various H1 fragments but not with the core histones. In the soluble complexes, similar regions of the H1 molecule are considered to be protected from cleavage by protease, as in chromatin. Therefore, these complexes appear to be a valuable model for the interaction of H1 in chromatin fibers.     

DNA wrapping in nucleosomes. The linking number problem re-examined.

Chromatin was assembled in vitro from relaxed closed circular DNA (SV40) and core histones at histone to DNA ratios of 0.2 to 0.3 (g/g) and incubated with topoisomerase I to relax supercoils in DNA regions not constrained by protein. Addition of histones H1 + H5 to the chromatin at an ionic strength of 0.1 M, in the presence of the solubilizing agent, polyglutamic acid, and topoisomerase I, increased the magnitude of the DNA linking number change, relative to protein-free DNA. No change in the linking number distribution occurred for relaxed protein-free DNA under these conditions. Control experiments indicated that the increase in the absolute value of the DNA linking number change in the chromatin could not be attributed to an increase in the number of nucleosomes per DNA molecule. These data suggest a solution to the linking number problem associated with models of chromatin structure.     

Disruption of the nucleosomes at the replication fork.

The fate of parental nucleosomes during chromatin replication was studied in vitro using in vitro assembled chromatin containing the whole SV40 genome as well as salt-treated and native SV40 minichromosomes. In vitro assembled minichromosomes were able to replicate efficiently in vitro, when the DNA was preincubated with T-antigen, a cytosolic S100 extract and three deoxynucleoside triphosphates prior to chromatin assembly, indicating that the origin has to be free of nucleosomes for replication initiation. The chromatin structure of the newly synthesized daughter strands in replicating molecules was analysed by psoralen cross-linking of the DNA and by micrococcal nuclease digestion. A 5- and 10-fold excess of protein-free competitor DNA present during minichromosome replication traps the segregating histones. In opposition to published data this suggests that the parental histones remain only loosely or not attached to the DNA in the region of the replication fork. Replication in the putative absence of free histones shows that a subnucleosomal particle is randomly assembled on the daughter strands. The data are compatible with the formation of a H3/H4 tetramer complex under these conditions, supporting the notion that under physiological conditions nucleosome core assembly on the newly synthesized daughter strands occurs by the binding of H2A/H2B dimers to a H3/H4 tetramer complex.     

Nuclease digestion promotes structural rearrangements in H1-depleted chromatin.

Digestion of H1-depleted chromatin with micrococcal nuclease at an ionic strength of 0.35M gives rise to structural rearrangements indicating nucleosomal sliding. The ionic strength necessary to reveal this effect is significantly lower than that required in the absence of an accompanying digestion. As an explanation, a model is presented in which the progressing terminal degradation of oligomeric nucleosomes is made responsible for promoting structural rearrangements.     

Remodeling of sperm chromatin after fertilization involves nucleosomes formed by sperm histones H2A and H2B and two CS histone variants

The composition of nucleosomes at an intermediate stage of male pronucleus formation was determined in sea urchins. Nucleosomes were isolated from zygotes harvested 10 min post-insemination, whole nucleoprotein particles were obtained from nucleus by nuclease digestion, and nucleosomes were subsequently purified by a sucrose gradient fractionation. The nucleosomes derived from male pronucleus were separated from those derived from female pronucleus by immunoadsorption to antibodies against sperm specific histones (anti-SpH) covalently bound to Sepharose 4B (anti-SpH-Sepharose). The immunoadsorbed nucleosomes were eluted, and the histones were analyzed by Western blots. Sperm histones (SpH) or alternatively, the histones from unfertilized eggs (CS histone variants), were identified with antibodies directed against each set of histones. It was found that these nucleosomes are organized by a core formed by sperm histones H2A and H2B combined with two major CS histone variants. Such a hybrid histone core interacts with DNA fragments of approximately 100 bp. It was also found that these atypical nucleosome cores are subsequently organized in a chromatin fiber that exhibits periodic nuclease hypersensitive sites determined by DNA fragments of 500 bp of DNA. It was found that these nucleoprotein particles were organized primarily by the hybrid nucleosomes described above. We postulate that this unique chromatin organization defines an intermediate stage of male chromatin remodeling after fertilization.