Limited left-right cell migration across the midline of the gastrulating avian embryo

During avian development the earliest phase in which the avian embryo expresses axial features of a left-right axis is at the primitive streak stage. Until the stage of definitive primitive streak (streak 4 H&H), the axis seems to possess morphological bilateral symmetry. Morphological asymmetry begins only during the next few hours of incubation, with development of overt morphological and molecular asymmetry within Hensen's node (stage 5 H&H). In this report, we present an experimental study aimed at following the pattern of cell movements during primitive streak formation and gastrulation of specific left-right regions from earlier stages of the avian embryo. To determine the origin of cells contributing to each side of the primitive streak, we applied the dye Lysinated-Rodamine-Dextran (LRD) to one half, either left or right, of the pre-streak blastoderm (stages X–XIII, EG&K). We tried to estimate the relative cell contribution to primitive streak formation, and to the three germ layers evolving during gastrulation in the context of the left-right axis. Moreover, we asked whether the midline serves as a border, that is, as a physiological barrier preventing cell passing during gastrulation. Our results demonstrate that on each side of the axis, either the right or the left, most of the cells originate from the same half of a pre-streak blastoderm, populate the same half of the PS and contribute to tissues largely confined to that particular side. However, along the primitive streak, a few cells were detected on the opposite side of the midline. Moreover, variation in the number of cells crossing the midline at specific regions along the primitive streak was found. Most crossing cells were located near the mid rostrocaudal extent of the primitive streak, from 25–85% of its length. At the posterior end of the primitive streak, fewer crossing cells were detected. At the anterior region of the PS, that is, within Hensen's node, cells do not cross the midline. These results suggest that differences occur in the process of ingression along the rostrocaudal extent of the PS. Dev. Genet. 23:175–184, 1998. © 1998 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

An ECM substratum allows mouse mesodermal cells isolated from the primitive streak to exhibit motility similar to that inside the embryo and reveals a deficiency in the T/T mutant cells

The mesodermal cell layer is created by ingression and migration of the cells from the primitive streak region in mouse embryos on day 7 of pregnancy. In order to study the mechanisms of mesodermal cell migration during development, the mesodermal cells isolated from the primitive streak were cultured on various substrata, and cell behaviour and motility were analysed with a time-lapse video system. The mesodermal cells on the surface of extracellular matrix (ECM)-coated dishes (ECM produced by bovine corneal endothelial cells) showed extensive migration at a mean rate of approx. 50 micron h-1. They also showed frequent cell division and exhibited contact paralysis of lamellipodia and contact inhibition of movement. On plastic or glass surfaces, however, the mesodermal cells became more flattened and less motile (approx. 20-30 micron h-1). Cell shape and mean rate of movement on the ECM were very similar to those in situ, as investigated in a previous study (Nakatsuji, Snow & Wylie, 1986). Therefore, this culture condition could provide a useful experimental system for analysing the cellular basis of normal and abnormal morphogenetic movements in mouse embryos. Employing such a culture system, we studied motility of the mesodermal cells from embryos homozygous for Brachyury (T) mutation, which are lethal at the midgestation stage in utero. Histological observations have suggested that anomalous morphogenesis of the T/T embryos may be brought about by defects in migration of the mesodermal cells derived from the primitive streak. When mesodermal cells from the primitive streak of the T/T mutant embryos on days 8-9 were cultured on the ECM substratum, mean rate of cell migration was significantly reduced compared to cells from normal embryos. Results support the idea of retarded migration by the mutant mesodermal cells as an important factor causing abnormalities in morphogenesis.     

Formation of the avian primitive streak from spatially restricted blastoderm: evidence for polarized cell division in the elongating streak

Gastrulation in the amniote begins with the formation of a primitive streak through which precursors of definitive mesoderm and endoderm ingress and migrate to their embryonic destinations. This organizing center for amniote gastrulation is induced by signal(s) from the posterior margin of the blastodisc. The mode of action of these inductive signal(s) remains unresolved, since various origins and developmental pathways of the primitive streak have been proposed. In the present study, the fate of chicken blastodermal cells was traced for the first time in ovo from prestreak stages XI-XII through HH stage 3, when the primitive streak is initially established and prior to the migration of mesoderm. Using replication-defective retrovirus-mediated gene transfer and vital dye labeling, precursor cells of the stage 3 primitive streak were mapped predominantly to a specific region where the embryonic midline crosses the posterior margin of the epiblast. No significant contribution to the early primitive streak was seen from the anterolateral epiblast. Instead, the precursor cells generated daughter cells that underwent a polarized cell division oriented perpendicular to the anteroposterior embryonic axis. The resulting daughter cell population was arranged in a longitudinal array extending the complete length of the primitive streak. Furthermore, expression of cVg1, a posterior margin-derived signal, at the anterior marginal zone induced adjacent epiblast cells, but not those lateral to or distant from the signal, to form an ectopic primitive streak. The cVg1-induced epiblast cells also exhibited polarized cell divisions during ectopic primitive streak formation. These results suggest that blastoderm cells located immediately anterior to the posterior marginal zone, which secretes an inductive signal, undergo spatially directed cytokineses during early primitive streak formation.     

Analysis of tissue flow patterns during primitive streak formation in the chick embryo

We have investigated the patterns of tissue flow underlying the formation of the primitive streak in the chick embryo. Analysis of time-lapse sequences of brightfield images to extract the tissue velocity field and of fluorescence images of small groups of DiI-labelled cells have shown that epiblast cells move in two large-scale counter-rotating streams, which merge at the site of streak formation. Despite the large-scale tissue flows, individual cells appear to move little relative to their neighbours. As the streak forms, it elongates in both the anterior and posterior directions. Inhibition of actin polymerisation via local application of the inhibitor latrunculin A immediately terminates anterior extension of the streak tip, but does not prevent posterior elongation. Inhibition of actin polymerisation at the base of the streak completely inhibits streak formation, implying that continuous movement of cells into the base of the forming streak is crucial for extension. Analysis of cycling cells in the early embryo shows that cell-cycle progression in the epiblast is quite uniform before the primitive streak forms then decreases in the central epiblast and incipient streak and increases at the boundary between the area pellucida and area opaca during elongation. The cell-cycle inhibitor aphidicolin, at concentrations that completely block cell-cycle progression, permits initial streak formation but arrests development during extension. Our analysis suggests that cell division maintains the cell-flow pattern that supplies the streak with cells from the lateral epiblast, which is critical for epiblast expansion in peripheral areas, but that division does not drive streak formation or the observed tissue flow.     

Spatial anisotropies and temporal fluctuations in extracellular matrix network texture during early embryogenesis

Early stages of vertebrate embryogenesis are characterized by a remarkable series of shape changes. The resulting morphological complexity is driven by molecular, cellular, and tissue-scale biophysical alterations. Operating at the cellular level, extracellular matrix (ECM) networks facilitate cell motility. At the tissue level, ECM networks provide material properties required to accommodate the large-scale deformations and forces that shape amniote embryos. In other words, the primordial biomaterial from which reptilian, avian, and mammalian embryos are molded is a dynamic composite comprised of cells and ECM. Despite its central importance during early morphogenesis we know little about the intrinsic micrometer-scale surface properties of primordial ECM networks. Here we computed, using avian embryos, five textural properties of fluorescently tagged ECM networks--(a) inertia, (b) correlation, (c) uniformity, (d) homogeneity, and (e) entropy. We analyzed fibronectin and fibrillin-2 as examples of fibrous ECM constituents. Our quantitative data demonstrated differences in the surface texture between the fibronectin and fibrillin-2 network in Day 1 (gastrulating) embryos, with the fibronectin network being relatively coarse compared to the fibrillin-2 network. Stage-specific regional anisotropy in fibronectin texture was also discovered. Relatively smooth fibronectin texture was exhibited in medial regions adjoining the primitive streak (PS) compared with the fibronectin network investing the lateral plate mesoderm (LPM), at embryonic stage 5. However, the texture differences had changed by embryonic stage 6, with the LPM fibronectin network exhibiting a relatively smooth texture compared with the medial PS-oriented network. Our data identify, and partially characterize, stage-specific regional anisotropy of fibronectin texture within tissues of a warm-blooded embryo. The data suggest that changes in ECM textural properties reflect orderly time-dependent rearrangements of a primordial biomaterial. We conclude that the ECM microenvironment changes markedly in time and space during the most important period of amniote morphogenesis--as determined by fluctuating textural properties.     

Cell fate and cell lineage in the endoderm of the presomite mouse embryo, studied with an intracellular tracer

The fate of the embryonic endoderm (generally called visceral embryonic endoderm) of midstreak to neural plate stages of the mouse embryo was studied by microinjecting horseradish peroxidase (HRP) into single axial endoderm cells in situ, and tracing the labeled descendants to early somite stages in vitro. Axial endoderm cells along the anterior fifth of the late streak/neural plate stage embryo contributed descendants either to the yolk sac endoderm or to the anterior intestinal portal. Cells of the exposed head process contributed to the trunk endoderm and notochord; neighboring endoderm cells contributed to the dorsal foregut. Contributions to the ventral foregut came from endoderm at, and anterior to, the distal tip of the younger, midstreak embryo (in which the head process was not yet exposed). Endoderm over the primitive streak contributed to the postsomite endoderm. We argue from these results and those in the literature that during gastrulation the axial embryonic endoderm is of mixed lineage: (1) an anterior population of cells is derived from primitive endoderm and contributes to the yolk sac endoderm; (2) a population at, and anterior to, the distal tip of the midstreak embryo, extending more anteriorly at late streak/neural plate stages, is presumed to emerge from primitive ectoderm at the beginning of gastrulation and contributes to the foregut and anterior intestinal portal; (3) the axial portion of the head process that begins to incorporate into the ventral surface at the late streak stage contributes to notochord and trunk endoderm. Cells or their descendants that were destined to die within 24 hr were evident at the midstreak stage. There was a linear trend in the incidence of cell death among labeled cells at the late streak/neural plate stages, ranging from 27% caudal to the node to 57% in the anterior fifth of the embryo. The surviving axial endoderm cells divided sufficiently fast to double the population in 24 hr.     

Clonal analysis of epiblast fate during germ layer formation in the mouse embryo.

The fate of cells in the epiblast at prestreak and early primitive streak stages has been studied by injecting horseradish peroxidase (HRP) into single cells in situ of 6.7-day mouse embryos and identifying the labelled descendants at midstreak to neural plate stages after one day of culture. Ectoderm was composed of descendants of epiblast progenitors that had been located in the embryonic axis anterior to the primitive streak. Embryonic mesoderm was derived from all areas of the epiblast except the distal tip and the adjacent region anterior to it: the most anterior mesoderm cells originated posteriorly, traversing the primitive streak early; labelled cells in the posterior part of the streak at the neural plate stage were derived from extreme anterior axial and paraxial epiblast progenitors; head process cells were derived from epiblast at or near the anterior end of the primitive streak. Endoderm descendants were most frequently derived from a region that included, but extended beyond, the region producing the head process: descendants of epiblast were present in endoderm by the midstreak stage, as well as at later stages. Yolk sac and amnion mesoderm developed from posterolateral and posterior epiblast. The resulting fate map is essentially the same as those of the chick and urodele and indicates that, despite geometrical differences, topological fate relationships are conserved among these vertebrates. Clonal descendants were not necessarily confined to a single germ layer or to extraembryonic mesoderm, indicating that these lineages are not separated at the beginning of gastrulation. The embryonic axis lengthened up to the neural plate stage by (1) elongation of the primitive streak through progressive incorporation of the expanding lateral and initially more anterior regions of epiblast and, (2) expansion of the region of epiblast immediately cranial to the anterior end of the primitive streak. The population doubling time of labelled cells was 7.5 h; a calculated 43% were in, or had completed, a 4th cell cycle, and no statistically significant regional differences in the number of descendants were found. This clonal analysis also showed that (1) growth in the epiblast was noncoherent and in most regions anisotropic and directed towards the primitive streak and (2) the midline did not act as a barrier to clonal spread, either in the epiblast in the anterior half of the axis or in the primitive streak. These results taken together with the fate map indicate that, while individual cells in the epiblast sheet behave independently with respect to their neighbours, morphogenetic movement during germ layer formation is coordinated in the population as a whole.     

Fate maps of the primitive streak in chick and quail embryo: ingression timing of progenitor cells of each rostro-caudal axial level of somites

Developmental fates of cells emigrating from the primitive streak were traced by a fluorescent dye Dil both in chick and in quail embryos from the fully grown streak stage to 12-somite stage, focusing on the development of mesoderm and especially on the timing of ingression of each level of somitic mesoderm. The fate maps of the chick and quail streak were alike, although the chick streak was longer at all stages examined. The anterior part of the primitive streak predominantly produced somites. The thoracic and the lumbar somites were shown to begin to ingress at the 5 somite-stage and 10 somite-stage in a chick embryo, and 6 somite-stage and 9 somite-stage in a quail embryo, respectively. The posterior part of the streak served mainly as the origin of more lateral or extra embryonic mesoderm. As development proceeded, the fate of the posterior part of the streak changed from the lateral plate mesoderm to the tail bud mesoderm and then to extra embryonic, allantois mesoderm. The fate map of the primitive streak in chick and quail embryo presented here will serve as basic data for studies on mesoderm development with embryo manipulation, especially for transplantation experiments between chick and quail embryos.     

Developmental patterning of the carbohydrate antigen FC10.2 during early embryogenesis in the chick

An oligosaccharide antigen (FC10.2), formerly described only in mammalian cells and secreted glycoproteins, has been detected and found to display striking temporal and spatial patterning in the chick during early embryonic development. This antigen is expressed on type 1 chains, which are isomers of oligosaccharides of the poly-N-acetyllactosamine series (type 2 chains). Immunoreactivities before and after neuraminidase treatment of serial sections of chick embryos during the first 17 stages of development indicate that the FC10.2 structure occurs predominantly in the sialylated form (S-FC10.2). The FC10.2 and S-FC10.2 antigens are prominent markers of the primordial germ cells, being strongly expressed by these cells from the pre-primitive streak stage onwards. S-FC10.2 is also a clear marker of the pronephric duct from its first appearance. Initially present over the entire apical surface of the ectoderm, antigenicity diminishes in an antero-posterior direction as neurulation proceeds. A unique pattern for a carbohydrate antigen is displayed by cells of the primitive streak; antigenicity is lost with de-epithelialisation and ingression, but is regained in a pericellular distribution on the mesoderm cells that emerge from the primitive streak. Thereafter, successive changes in expression and distribution of FC10.2 and S-FC10.2 are features of mesodermal tissues, particularly during somitogenesis. These antigens are prominent components of the extracellular matrix around the notochord and sclerotome cells. They are also prominent posteriorly in the subectodermal region, ceasing abruptly at the lateral limits of the embryo proper. Although no absolute correlations can yet be made, several features of the distribution of these antigens suggest that they may be integral components of, or ligands for, cell adhesion molecules.     

Cellular events associated with lung branching morphogenesis including the deposition of collagen type IV

In this study mouse lung development was examined using an in vitro model system. The culture system permitted examination of a morphogenic process that eventually led to the formation of presumptive alveoli (terminal sacs). The observations included changes in epithelial cell morphology (transition from a columnar to a spindle shape), and evidence for motile activity on the part of primitive airway epithelial cells. The importance of Type IV collagen to the cellular events associated with branching morphogenesis was investigated by immunolocalization. In addition, we assessed the similarity of normal lung development to in vitro development by comparing cultured lungs with equivalent stages of embryonic and fetal mouse lungs. The results show that cultured embryonic lung explants proceed along a morphogenic pathway that parallels normal lung development; that primitive pulmonary epithelial cells engage in motile activity and transiently acquire an extended cell shape both in vitro and in vivo; that, as suggested by others, the pattern of late branching morphogenesis is not dichotomous, but irregular; and that short wisplike fibers of Type IV collagen are present in developing embryonic and fetal lung mesenchyme. Taken together, the results show that early and late lung branching patterns differ significantly, and suggest that later stages of lung branching involve distinct epithelial cell shape transitions. The immunofluorescence data suggest that fibrous Type IV collagen may be the extracellular matrix scaffold within which early epithelial cells accomplish lung branching morphogenesis.     

Left‐right asymmetry in the chick embryo requires core planar cell polarity protein Vangl2

Consistent left‐right patterning is a fascinating and biomedically important problem. In the chick embryo, it is not known how cells determine their position (left or right) relative to the primitive streak, which is required for subsequent asymmetric gene expression cascades. We show that the subcellular localization of Vangl2, a core planar cell polarity (PCP) protein, is consistently polarized, giving cells in the blastoderm a vector pointing toward the primitive streak. Moreover, morpholino‐mediated loss‐of‐function of Vangl2 by electroporation into chicks at very early stages randomizes the normally left‐sided expression of Sonic hedgehog. Strikingly, Vangl2 morpholinos also induce a desynchronization of asymmetric gene expression within the left and right domains of Hensen's node. These data reveal the existence of polarized planar cell polarity protein localization in gastrulating chick and demonstrate that the PCP pathway is functionally required for normal asymmetry in the chick upstream of Sonic hedgehog. These data suggest a new and widely applicable class of models for the spread and coordination of left‐right patterning information in the embryonic blastoderm. genesis 47:719–728, 2009. © 2009 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Distribution of acid phosphatase in the chicken blastoderm]

The distribution of acid phosphatase in the chick blastoderm (stages 2--4 by HH) has been studied using cytochemistry. A marked increase of enzymatic activity all over the blastoderm was shown to coincide with the beginning of primitive streak formation. A part of the cells after their immigration are characterized by the fall of acid phosphatase activity. The percentage of such cells increases in the cranio-caudal direction of the definitive primitive streak. The patterns of yolk utilization upon the separation of individual embryonic rudiments are discussed.     

Fgf-4 expression during gastrulation, myogenesis, limb and tooth development in the mouse.

Fgf-4, initially isolated as a transforming gene from human tumors, is a member of the Fibroblast Growth Factor (FGF) family. It has previously been shown by northern blot hybridization analysis to be expressed in teratocarcinoma and embryonic stem cells, suggesting that it plays a role in embryonic development. We have carried out an RNA in situ hybridization analysis of Fgf-4 expression in the developing mouse embryo, from fertilization through the 14th day of gestation (E14.5). Our results show that Fgf-4 RNA is first detected at the late blastocyst stage in cells that give rise to all of the embryonic lineages (inner cell mass cells). During the early stages of gastrulation, expression becomes restricted to the primitive streak where mesoderm and definitive endoderm are formed. Expression continues in the distal (rostral) two-thirds of the streak through approx. E10, and then is detected in the tail bud, which replaces the streak as the primary source of mesoderm. Additional sites of expression are found after the three primary germ layers are established and organogenesis begins. Fgf-4 RNA is detected transiently in the branchial arch units, the somitic myotome, the apical ectodermal ridge of the developing limb bud and the tooth bud, suggesting that the gene has multiple roles during embryogenesis. These results are compared with the expression patterns of other FGF genes. Taken together, the data suggest that individual members of the gene family are expressed sequentially in developmental pathways such as mesoderm formation and myogenesis, and play a role in specific epithelial-mesenchymal interactions.     

Development of separated germ layers of rodent embryos on ectopic sites: a reappraisal.

The method of separation of germ layers of rodent embryos by treating the embryonic shields with proteolytic enzymes and by microsurgery with the subsequent transplantation to ectopic sites has helped to gain a more detailed insight into what is going on during gastrulation in mammals. The space under the kidney capsule of adult animals seems to be the most appropriate ectopic site for transplantation of early postimplantation rat embryos or separated germ layers. After transplantation the grafts develop into teratomas whose complex histological structure reflects the initial developmental capacities of the graft. At the pre-primitive streak and the early primitive streak stages the primitive ectoderm differentiates into tissue derivatives of all three definitive germ layers, often in complex organotypic combinations. This is indirect evidence that all cells of the embryonic body originate from the primitive embryonic ectoderm. Halves of the primitive ectoderm obtained by a longitudinal or transverse cut through the egg cylinder give the same result. At the head fold stage the capacity for differentiation of the ectoderm is restricted to ectodermal and mesodermal derivatives. One day before gastrulation the isolated primitive ectoderm is not able to differentiate as renal isograft. The mesoderm isolated at the head fold stage and at later stages when its segmentation occurs, differentiates almost exclusively into the brown adipose tissue. The embryonic endoderm differentiates only in combination with the mesoderm. After transplantation the embryonic ectoderm loses its epithelial organization and breaks up into a mass of mesenchyme-like cells in which epithelial structures subsequently appear and differentiate in a way reminiscent of the reaggregation of cells in mixed cell suspension in vitro.     

Otx2 is required for visceral endoderm movement and for the restriction of posterior signals in the epiblast of the mouse embryo

Genetic and embryological experiments have demonstrated an essential role for the visceral endoderm in the formation of the forebrain; however, the precise molecular and cellular mechanisms of this requirement are poorly understood. We have performed lineage tracing in combination with molecular marker studies to follow morphogenetic movements and cell fates before and during gastrulation in embryos mutant for the homeobox gene Otx2. Our results show, first, that Otx2 is not required for proliferation of the visceral endoderm, but is essential for anteriorly directed morphogenetic movement. Second, molecules that are normally expressed in the anterior visceral endoderm, such as Lefty1 and Mdkk1, are not expressed in Otx2 mutants. These secreted proteins have been reported to antagonise, respectively, the activities of Nodal and Wnt signals, which have a role in regulating primitive streak formation. The visceral endoderm defects of the Otx2 mutants are associated with abnormal expression of primitive streak markers in the epiblast, suggesting that anterior epiblast cells acquire primitive streak characteristics. Taken together, our data support a model whereby Otx2 functions in the anterior visceral endoderm to influence the ability of the adjacent epiblast cells to differentiate into anterior neurectoderm, indirectly, by preventing them from coming under the influence of posterior signals that regulate primitive streak formation.     

The orderly allocation of mesodermal cells to the extraembryonic structures and the anteroposterior axis during gastrulation of the mouse embryo.

The prospective fate of cells in the primitive streak was examined at early, mid and late stages of mouse gastrula development to determine the order of allocation of primitive streak cells to the mesoderm of the extraembryonic membranes and to the fetal tissues. At the early-streak stage, primitive streak cells contribute predominantly to tissues of the extraembryonic mesoderm as previously found. However, a surprising observation is that the erythropoietic precursors of the yolk sac emerge earlier than the bulk of the vitelline endothelium, which is formed continuously throughout gastrula development. This may suggest that the erythropoietic and the endothelial cell lineages may arise independently of one another. Furthermore, the extraembryonic mesoderm that is localized to the anterior and chorionic side of the yolk sac is recruited ahead of that destined for the posterior and amnionic side. For the mesodermal derivatives in the embryo, those destined for the rostral structures such as heart and forebrain mesoderm ingress through the primitive streak early during a narrow window of development. They are then followed by those for the rest of the cranial mesoderm and lastly the paraxial and lateral mesoderm of the trunk. Results of this study, which represent snapshots of the types of precursor cells in the primitive streak, have provided a better delineation of the timing of allocation of the various mesodermal lineages to specific compartments in the extraembryonic membranes and different locations in the embryonic anteroposterior axis.     

Primitive streak formation in mice is preceded by localized activation of Brachyury and Wnt3

The prevalent model for the generation of axial polarity in mouse embryos proposes that a radial to a linear transition in the expression of primitive streak markers precedes the formation of the primitive streak on one side of the epiblast. This model contrasts with the models of mesoderm formation in other vertebrates as it suggests that the primitive streak is initially established in a radial pattern rather than a localized region of the epiblast. Here, we examine the proposed correlation between the expression of Brachyury and Wnt3, two genes reported as expressed radially in the proximal epiblast, with the movements of proximal anterior epiblast cells at stages leading to the formation of the primitive streak. Our results reveal that neither Brachyury nor Wnt3 forms a ring of expression in the proximal epiblast as previously thought. In embryos dissected between 5.5 and 6.5 dpc, Brachyury is first expressed in the distal extra-embryonic ectoderm and subsequently on one side of the epiblast. Wnt3 expression is evident first in the posterior visceral endoderm of 5.5 dpc embryos and later in the posterior epiblast. Lineage analysis shows that the movements of the proximal epiblast do not restrict Brachyury expression to the posterior epiblast. Our data suggest a model whereby the localized expression of these genes in the posterior epiblast, and hence the formation of the primitive streak, is the result of local cell-cell interactions in the future posterior portion of the egg cylinder rather than regionalization of a radial pattern of expression in proximal epiblast cells.